Rejoinder Malan Nel
Rejoinder from the Inclusive Congregational Approach
As I read your responses to my chapter, it was wonderful to sense a basic agreement of the importance of the local church as home base for youth ministry. I believe we are together in our struggle to relate youth ministry to the church. Second, it was encouraging and motivating to feel your deep love for and knowledge of the general fields of research and ministry, as well as your passion for the specific field of youth ministry.
Rather than address each of your criticisms, I will organize my response here according to the theological reasoning in the Inclusive Congregational approach itself.
Ecclesiology
My personal conviction is that our understanding of the church is vital to understanding the approach. Your general agreement with encouraged me. Allow me to put two dimensions of my own ecclesiology on the table and argue a case for the approach.
An important piece of information from my own theological journey is that I wrote my doctoral dissertation on youth evangelism. My research led me to believe that we do not have much hope to win young people back (let alone keep and prepare them for ministry) if we do not develop local churches with a heart for the lost and a heart for equipping God’s people for ministry. That whole exercise led me to research the field that the Germans, the Dutch, and we in South Africa call Gemeindeaufbau: revitalizing the local church, or equipping and preparing God’s people for ministry, or—one may say—returning the ministry to the people.
In my research in this amazing field of study and ministry, I rediscovered over and over again that the church is by definition a missionary concept. This is our God-given identity. And since then I have devoted my life to helping local churches discover who they are in order to recover who they are. A very important part of my motivation for still doing this work is to revitalize youth ministry.
A local church is seldom composed of only adults or of only youths. The faith community is inclusive. In principle we have no right whatsoever to marginalize children and adolescents. Any division here will probably result in a tragic loss for both adults and youths alike.
Missionary church
Back to the two ecclesiological remarks concerning this approach: Wherever and whenever I used the words local church or congregation in the chapter, I meant a missionary church where people—adults and youths alike—are being prepared for ministry in the world. It is part and parcel of my understanding of the church. Do local churches view themselves as such? Probably not, or at least not to the extent that they take their calling in this world seriously enough. My conviction therefore is that it is not so much the youths that need to change (which is of course also true), but the adults.
In this sense, Mark, I find your remark healing in itself: “Do you consider the church to be dysfunctional and in need of healing?” Yes I do, and I think it is worth putting a lot of energy into that. I feel like crying when I discover through congregational analyses that churches are dying because they just miss out on the understanding of their missionary nature. I cry even more when I discover leaders who are so disappointed in the local body of believers (and understandably so from time to time) that they give up on the church as the community of God to equip and to reach the world.
May I add that my understanding of mission is a very concrete and comprehensive one: Becoming involved in this world in any way the situation calls for. It is indeed a ministry of bringing help and giving hope as the people of God. We need to love, serve, and call them back. Chap, I think you are absolutely right—young people will not come just because we change. How will they ever know if we don’t show and tell them how much we care for them because we know how much God cares for us?
My second point in understanding the church, which is a given in this approach, is the biblical inclusiveness of the church. This has two dimensions to it: a local church is seldom composed of only adults or of only youths. The faith community in this sense is inclusive. In principle we have no right whatsoever to marginalize children and adolescents. Any division here will probably result in a tragic loss for both adults and youths alike. The second dimension of inclusivity has to do with the missionary nature of the church. The letter to the Ephesians is a good example of this inclusiveness.
I believe that it is really true that our theology of the church (as informed by our understanding of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit) informs our theology of youth ministry.
Comprehensive, differentiated, focused
Taking seriously the missionary nature of the church has caused me to plead for a youth ministry approach that is comprehensive, differentiated, and focused. My reason for pleading for comprehensivity is both theological and contextual—and I feel compelled to stress the contextual reason one more time: for many reasons Western society has nearly lost any deep awareness of the corporate nature of the faith community. Specialization has played into this and sometimes taken individualism to an un-Christian extreme. That being said, however, youth ministry is indeed about a differentiated and focused approach within the frame of comprehensiveness. Youth ministry can never be without it.
Chap and Wes, I really appreciate your remarks concerning the unique nature, needs, and potential of adolescents (and children). My understanding is that when we really take differentiation seriously, we will address more of the important issues you mentioned. There is, to my mind, even a strong theological argument for what is commonly called specialization and special attention to age-specifics (need as well as potential): the metaphor of us as children of God (cf. John 1:12). Although God is the Father of us all in the same way (comprehensivity), he is also the Father of every individual in a unique way (differentiation). He focuses on his family and on the individual. He made us, after all—and when we discover even in a science class how wonderfully he made us in every age and phase of life, how can any faith community ignore it?
Parents need help to keep open conversation with their children as natural as talking about baseball. The context of Deuteronomy 6 probably assumes something of this natural and spontaneous talking.
Yes, I agree with you in full. My defense? This is included and assumed in the words I used in the definition, namely differentiated focus. I take it that it applies to every single dimension of the ministry.
“Simply does not happen anymore”
In this regard, Chap, I need to respond to the important issue you raised in response to my reference to Deuteronomy 6 and how spiritual teaching is passed to the next generation (“children ask questions and parents answer”): the fact that “in most places, however, this simply does not happen anymore.” You are probably correct, in general. Yet in Christian homes where talking about God and his involvement in our lives (the issue at stake in Deuteronomy 6:4–10) is easy, parent-child dialogue probably still takes place. Thus parents need all the help in the world to keep these conversations as natural as talking about baseball. The context of Deuteronomy 6 probably assumes something of this natural and spontaneous talking.
Secondly, I take it for granted that in many societies (maybe most) the mood is very much postmodern, so much so that Deuteronomy’s asking-and-answering pattern can be interpreted only as dialogue, and often critical dialogue, on both sides. To restate my conviction: the family plays a major role in revitalizing youth ministry (as an integral congregational approach). The beauty of family (where it is still in place) is the natural, God-given, ability of parent(s) to be simultaneously comprehensive, yet differentiate.
I sincerely believe that all modes of ministry should take this principle seriously. The prerequisite is to continuously work on the inclusive understanding of the faith community. To feel accepted by the church may eventually prove to be more important than any given deed. Assuming that this is happening because it became part of the vision and mission of senior and junior leadership, differentiation is not harmful or divisive. It proves that the same faith community is serious enough to give expression to the uniqueness of the children and adolescents who are an integral part of the church as extended family. Mark, I hope that in stating this I have at least partially responded to your remark about my example of differentiation in preaching and the relevance of that for other ministries.
When they leave high school
A remark you made, Mark—and which I think is important to come back to—concerns the fact that we often lose students when they leave high school. You wrote that “whatever integration had taken place is lost by this hiatus from ministry.” My response in this case is probably very contextual, but very valid, I believe: as important as a congregational philosophy for youth ministry may be, so is a denominational philosophy. I am privileged to be part of a denomination that adopted a national policy for youth ministry way back in 1966. This was the result of almost 10 years of intensive research across the board, on what was generally understood to be youth ministry. My viewpoint in teaching future pastors has always been that understanding the first two points of the policy is critical, so much so that if you understand them the other five points are almost superfluous. Youths are an integral part of the local body of believers; furthermore, youths are the responsibility of the church from birth to adulthood. That is, youths are our responsibility from the cradle to grave.
Local churches have not taken seriously many issues of the denominational philosophy. The empirical reality is even more broken than we think. But one important fruit of the policy, after so many years, is the issue you referred to—making local churches available for youths to study in after high school, local churches that will give them even more opportunity to grow and serve (also as leaders). I could see it work as a full-time student pastor in a well-integrated local church where adults, teenagers, and university students really come into their own right while maintaining the integrated nature.
Based on the results of a national survey we did, my conviction is that this is partly because the youths who are not naturally interested in academics have never really felt accepted in their home churches—which means that during late adolescence they not only venture to “try out different ‘selves,’” (as Chap rightly puts it in his response), but also leave. Some never come back. We need a broader inclusive picture if we want to escape the present impasse.
Personally I believe that getting this approach established (initially at least) is more of an attitudinal issue than a strategic one. It can never exclude strategies, but planning alone will not save the day for youth ministry. It is the same as in what I call building up the local church: You need to help the local body of believers understand their God-given identity in order to begin living and functioning accordingly—and enjoying their identity. To say it theologically: the indicative always precedes and informs the imperative.
Establishing an Inclusive Congregational approach is more an issue of attitude than strategy. Planning alone will not save the day for youth ministry.
Three important prepositions
I will attempt to prove this point by returning to three pivotal prepositions in my definition: youth ministry is a comprehensive congregational ministry in which God comes, through all forms of ministry and with especial regard to parents (or their substitutes), with a differentiated focus to youths (as an integral part of the congregation), and also with and through the youths in the congregation to the world.
To my mind youth ministry will only change from a one-sided educational approach to an inclusive congregational approach (many-faceted and multidimensional as it may be) when the faith community begins to value children and adolescents as not only being recipients but as worthy co-workers in every sense of the Word and ministry. But this is an insight or understanding far more than it is just a strategy. In many churches I know, this asks for a new birth, a hermeneutical experience of who God is and who we are because he is who he is.
Conclusion
“Your approach is not for the faint of heart,” Wes wrote. I agree. I worked within the system for many years and know how difficult it is. Why? For many reasons, probably for this one most of all: we are being asked to challenge long-standing traditions, and often the leadership itself. What encourages me in my work as a facilitator in local churches is the attitude of parents when they realize that this is God’s plan to prepare their children as part of the faith community for their mission in the world, even to the point that planting a new church may become part of that mission.
