Chapter 18 of 27

Response from a Strategic perspective Mark H. Senter III

Response from a Strategic perspective Mark H. Senter III

Response to the Missional Approach from a Strategic Perspective

by Mark H. Senter III

I commend you, Chap, for the manner in which you avoided the land mines laid by both sides in the church-versus-parachurch discussion. By now most thoughtful students of youth ministry recognize that the vast majority of resources (people, materials, facilities, and money) invested in youth ministry have been concentrated on less than 25 percent of the adolescent population—the bulk of whom are church kids.

Simultaneously, those same observers look at young people who come to faith through the efforts of missional activities and bemoan the fact that so few of them are assimilated into Christian churches, especially upon graduation from high school. Instead of becoming bogged down in that discussion, you framed the dialogue from the perspective of what should happen. You have leveled the playing field. A real discussion can now begin.

True measure of success

I loved your statement that “the only true measure of success in a youth ministry program is the ability and willingness of a church to fully assimilate growing adolescents into the adult fellowship.” The context of your statement is the observation that “the primary reason for having a youth ministry…[is to] create a bridge of love, trust, and support to encourage the disenfranchised adolescent to be welcomed as a member of the family of God.” The burden of this statement cannot be on the disenfranchised kid but on the church. That young person, with at least as many insecurities as experienced by the average church kid, should never be expected to worm his way into the family of God. As in the story of the prodigal son, the father should be the one who runs to the alienated son.

If anything, Chap, you could have been tougher on the church. Your comments about the role of the senior pastor to create a “systemic structure and relational community where all people are welcomed and cared for, especially in the worship services” is an excellent start. Your observation that lay leadership must maintain a “corporate ethos where adolescents know they are both accepted and taken seriously in their gifts and ministry” spreads the responsibility from the pulpit throughout all the pews. The greatest obstacle to the Missional approach is not the pagan youth of an MTV culture, or even the self-serving Christians in the youth group. The greatest obstacle is the failure of adults to build relationships and begin to love newcomers, especially young people.

Peer-to-peer youth ministry

Another point I find refreshing, Chap, is your critique of “peer-to-peer youth ministry.” The idea of clustering into social units at the early onset of mid-adolescence has a rather profound impact upon the possibility of young people successfully evangelizing their peers beyond a very limited circle of friends or their cousin clusters. What I hear you saying is that even if young people in the church successfully evangelized all of the people in their cluster and cousin clusters, none of the disenfranchised adolescents, whom you say we should be reaching, would have a possibility of being included. They are all in their own clusters.

In addition, your comment about adults doing evangelism among their peers was quite telling. It does seem counterproductive if adults are asking young people to do peer evangelism when few of them are modeling what they expect from the kids. Perhaps the same cluster factor is at work in their worlds. They may not know people outside their circle of friends, most of whom are active in the church. Young people are no dummies. They know what people do is far more important than what they tell others to do. They can tell where the values of church leadership rest.

I am not as concerned about the program-centered aspects of peer-to-peer youth ministry as you are, Chap, because every missional effort I know of has a program component. To call something “program-centered” is more a matter of perspective than a factor that hinders peer evangelism. However, your other two factors do raise major questions about the potential effectiveness of this approach to mission. The alternative that adults are the missionaries, capable of reaching across cultural lines into the world of young people, is an idea that deserves further elaboration.

Children of the church

Now before I throw my arm out of joint slapping you on the back, I must hasten to mention two issues that left me a bit puzzled. First, what happens to the church kids? Our friends with a reformed theology perspective would refer to them as “children of the covenant.” Do they become second-class citizens of the kingdom by virtue of being born into a Christian family? It would seem that we have the distinct possibility of a spiritual form of reverse discrimination here.

I recognize that young people born into Christian families have many advantages over the disenfranchised adolescent you are so rightfully concerned about, Chap. It reminds me of the apostle Paul’s question, “What advantage, then, is there in being a Jew, or what value is there in circumcision?” (Romans 3:1). I would ask the same thing about being born “Christian.” What advantage is there to being a part of a Christian family if the church is not encouraged to “take care of our own” young people?

There was a time when the family had lots of help passing the values of the Christian faith from generation to generation. The school system actively taught the importance of Christian virtues. Neighbors modeled a Christian lifestyle. Even the popular culture (primarily books and even early programming on radio and television) assisted the Christian family to raise their children in conformity with biblical standards. The church was just one of many voices assisting the Christian family to raise their children in the nurture and admonition of the Lord.

Today the only support left for the Christian family is the church. While I agree that the church should not create a Christian ghetto where Christian kids are “isolated [in a] private community,” I am not sure these are the only alternatives to your Missional approach to youth ministry. We must not get caught in an either/or mentality. Perhaps we should look at some both/and options wherein we do a better job of living a missional lifestyle and teaching Christian youths to honor what you have called the “official-yet-unwritten mandate of contemporary youth ministry”?

The world of the adolescent is, after all, a very unsafe place. So what is wrong with keeping church youths happy, interested, and safe? In fact, this safety in a loving community may become one of the most attractive features of Christian youth ministry in a postmodern world.

After all, Chap, the world of the adolescent is a very unsafe place. People like you and Dean Borgman have been very effective in reminding us of this fact. So what is wrong with keeping church youths happy, interested, and safe if this does not mean deemphasizing the missional mandate of the church as it relates to youth? In fact, the safety factor in a loving community may become one of the most attractive features of Christian youth ministry in a postmodern world.

Don’t misunderstand me. I am not saying that youth ministry has achieved this balance between being a safe place and doing the required missional work. Your emphasis on evangelism is sorely needed. Your focus on the relational aspects of being Christians in a non-Christian world is prophetic and I applaud you. What I do not see in your chapter is how we should function with youths in the faith community.

In my chapter on the Strategic approach, I have tried to build on the Missional approach, but also to give youths an intentional community in which to be safe and outreach-focused. The church-planting concept will be a miserable failure if church growth is based on people transferring from churches with less appealing worship styles or more obnoxious people. The Strategic approach is an inside-out approach to youth ministry. It is both/and.

When disenfranchised become enfranchised

The second concern I have with your chapter relates to what happens after mission. How are the disenfranchised adolescents who have been evangelized transformed into Christian worshipers? While worship may be done privately, the concept of the church requires an assembling of Christians and some corporate expressions of love for God.

You touched on the assimilation issue, and that is a very important starting place. Young people (church bred or disenfranchised) must feel the church is a safe place, a welcoming place, a relational place. But assimilation alone does not produce worshipers, it merely tears down the most obvious barrier to worship. To assume that worship will happen naturally, once a young person is enfolded by an intergenerational group of Christian believers, is to suggest theology is equivalent to sociology.

Let me frame it another way. Once the disenfranchised adolescents have become enfranchised participants in a local church, how does the church take care of them? The Missional approach, as you presented it, leaves the question wide open. Obviously, the missioner will retain some form of relationship with the new believer, but what should that be? Does the missioner become a guide to help the youthful pilgrim pick her way through the maze of church life into the presence of God? Or perhaps a mentor with whom the mentoree consults as he discovers the alternating currents of richness and barrenness of corporate worship? Or does the missioner continue as the primary shepherd of a special flock of newly enfranchised Christians and gradually move her focus of ministry from mission to pastoral care?

But assimilation into a church does not in itself produce worshipers—it merely tears down some barriers to worship. To assume that worship will happen naturally, once a young person is enfolded by an intergenerational group of Christian believers, is to equate theology with sociology.

I would assume all of these relationships would be options for the Missional approach, but what I hear you saying is that the responsibility for transforming the newly enfranchised into informed worshipers lies not with the missioner but with the church in the power of the Spirit of God. I do think the responsibility for training the church to disciple their youths, of necessity, must lie with the youth ministry specialist (in other words the missioner). This person not only understands the youth culture where the kids are coming from, but also the church culture where they now find themselves and the heavenly culture to which they aspire.

As you know, Chap, the history of enfolding new converts who are reached through missional approaches, such as you describe, is extremely weak. I recently contacted Young Life, Youth for Christ, and Fellowship of Christian Athletes and asked people in their national offices how successful their organizations have been in discipling young people into the church. Although all three claim this as part of their mission, none has ever tracked the question. They simply have no idea where most of their converts are five years after graduation. In defense of our parachurch friends, the information would be exceedingly hard to track because these organizations are not communities like churches and schools.

One would think that Willow Creek and Saddleback would have stronger records of “turning irreligious high school students into fully devoted followers of Christ.” I assume that these church-based “fully devoted followers of Christ” would remain active worshipers in the years following high school. Yet even in these church-based missional efforts, the results appear to be far less than desirable.

I would love to see advocates of the Missional approach develop stronger intentional strategies for assisting the church to become the community of faith for newly enfranchised adolescents. Yet I wonder if it can be done, except on an intermittent basis. The church has a wonderful capacity to absorb occasional refugees from foreign cultures but little success in synthesizing diverse culture into new forms of worship. When communities undergo ethnic transitions, Protestant churches have a dismal record of reinventing themselves with a blended form of discipleship and worship. Is the expectation of such a blend theologically necessary? If so, the church, not just youth ministry, has a very long way to go. I would suggest that racial reconciliation should have priority over generational reconciliation, though a healthy approach to the latter may make a major contribution to the former.

My reading of the Scripture suggests that the expectation of cultural blending is at the heart of the gospel. It is a corrective to becoming conformed to the world (spirit of the age). If the Missional approach to youth ministry could view as its other “mission” the blending of cultures within the body of Christ, the impact would be profound. As you know, Chap, this is the problem of neither church leaders (“them”) or missioners (“us”)—it is the problem of the entire body of Christ. As such we must aggressively address the problem. Our credibility as the faith community before a watching postmodern world is at stake, as is the credibility of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ.

Conclusion

To move the discussion of youth ministry and the church to the next level, Chap, I would encourage you to become even more specific in identifying how the church must change to make her missional friendly, especially as it relates to youth ministry. I think we agree that the greatest obstacle to missional youth ministry is the church—not as it should be, but as it is. Like Martin Luther, perhaps you should tack your theses to a Wittenberg door, but this time you should put them somewhere on the Internet and allow a free flow of discussion on how the church should behave in the 21st century. All of us are smarter than any one of us. Together the body of Christ should be able to resolve the problems created by the cultural blinders we bring into our attempts to worship.

↑ Back to top

↑