Chapter 7 of 27

Response from a Strategic perspective Mark H. Senter III

Response from a Strategic perspective Mark H. Senter III

Response to the Inclusive Congregational Approach from a Strategic Perspective

by Mark H. Senter III

I appreciate how you dealt holistically, biblically, and theologically with the issues related to youth ministry, Malan. In the youth ministry fraternity we have a tendency to cluster ourselves around the pragmatic questions that grow out of developmental psychology (What is his level of moral reasoning?), sociology (What influence does the peer group have upon her daily decisions?), communication theory (What impact does MTV have upon their understanding of my message?), and even cultural anthropology (How can I understand the youth culture?). As important as these questions are to youth ministry, they are really secondary questions that arise from theological disciplines—which is where your argument was rooted, I was pleased to see.

God approaches people

You have placed the entire discussion of youth ministry and the church in the context of God approaching people. What an insightful way to frame youth ministry—so obvious from a theological perspective, but so absent in most of the youth ministry literature, music, conferences, and even seminary training. Seldom do we take that necessary step backwards to see the big picture of how God comes to young people. You are correct when you write that “youth ministry is not a separate or additional mode of God’s coming to the youths.” It is part of something profoundly larger. Suddenly, I don’t feel as alone in youth ministry. God is relentlessly coming to young people just as he always has—through the church and through his Word.

Seldom do we take that necessary step backwards to see the big picture of how God comes to young people, relentlessly, just as he always has: through the church and through his Word.

In your definition of the Inclusive Congregational approach, I hear you in effect saying, “Do not marginalize youths. Do not rob them of the full richness of God’s coming by segregating them either physically or through a failure to pay equal attention to the language in which God’s coming is communicated.” You lift a tremendous load off the shoulders of youth ministers and place it squarely where it belongs—on the broad shoulders of the church leadership and entire congregations.

And even from the beginning of your chapter, you certainly do not downplay the consequences of adopting an Inclusive Congregational approach. It’s as if you say, “If you don’t want this, read no further.” If only these consequences were a normal part of the everyday community life of the church. There would be no second-class citizens in the faith community. The church would honor the contribution of every child and adolescent, realizing that the congregation is impoverished without what young people bring to fellowship.

Malan, your approach turns youth ministry on its ear, at least in this way: years ago the counseling profession began moving from an individualized intervention towards a family-systems approach to therapy, in the belief that most problems faced by children and adolescents were best solved by dealing with the dynamic web of family relationships, which had often fallen into disrepair. Your theological perspectives introduce a similar perspective to youth ministry and the church. (I wonder if you consider the church to be dysfunctional and in need of healing. If so, how can the church and its youths find that healing?)

The problem is not that theology is irrelevant to youth ministry, but that 19th-century theological categories are inadequate for addressing either modern youths in the 20th century (your point) or postmodern youths in the 21st century.

Historian’s perspective

As a historian I appreciate your use of the historical development of both theology and youth ministry to advance your case. The impact of Abraham Kuyper on the categorization of theology, for example, with the resulting loss of youths from churches, does suggest a closer tie between theology and youth ministry than most people might imagine. In fact, many in youth ministry might argue for a greater distance between formal theology and youth ministry for the sake of saving those you describe as “lost to the church.”

The problem, as I see it, is not that theology is irrelevant to youth ministry, but that 19th century theological categories are inadequate for addressing either modern youths in the 20th century (your point) or postmodern youths in the 21st century. Like you, I feel a theological understanding of the church must drive the church’s ministry to youths. Your chapter suggests a framework that, if applied to almost any other approach, would dramatically weave youth ministry back into the fabric of the church tapestry.

I agree that most of the critical theological issues that face youth ministry are related to ecclesiology. The recent attempts to address a theology of youth ministry by Dean Borgman and Rick Dunn have found their focus elsewhere. The last person in this field that I can remember addressing the ecclesiologal aspects of youth ministry is Larry Richards in the 1970s.1

The pragmatic question

I took an early draft of your chapter to a focus group at my school. Their predominant response was “It won’t happen.” This may be more an indictment of the church than of your chapter, but it is nevertheless a bleak assessment. The greatest problem may be that churches think they are doing what you have proposed, but never ask the youths—the customers—for their perspective. One of my students volunteered that the reason she, and eventually her family, left their church for another was precisely because the church practiced an Inclusive Congregational youth ministry.

I would suggest it is far easier to talk Inclusive Congregational than to live it. This approach cannot be a passive or laissez-faire approach to youth ministry, but must be highly active and intentional. Even the example of your own church (Critical changes required) is not highly encouraging: the inclusive steps were the outgrowth of the youth committee, not the church leadership. And maybe this is where all youth ministries will have to start, given the current structure of contemporary churches—but it seems to violate the inclusive principles you are describing.

Also less than encouraging in this same example from your own church is the small number of modes of God’s coming that I detected: kerugma (preaching) and leitourgia (worship) are there, but the didache (teaching) apparently turned into another worship service, while paraklesis (pastoral care), diakonia (service), and kubernesis (administration) are all but missing. Koinonia (mutuality) seems to be a byproduct of other activities, while marturia (witness) was a part of the fabric of the church from earlier times. If this is a best-case scenario, it doesn’t bring much hope.

Is “differentiated and focused” actually a segregated experience?

Just when I thought you were making a radical statement that in effect eliminated youth ministry as we know it and reintegrated young people into every aspect of the church, you seemed to make a switch. Introducing the modes of God’s coming seemed to create a parallel track—as you put it, “Youth ministry preaching is still preaching, but it is focused on and directed at the youths.” Your illustration suggests integration into the larger church family, but this statement sounds like separate tracks—youth and adult.

If you concede there must be youth ministry preaching, which of the other modes also deserve differentiated approaches? Differentiated worship and differentiated teaching, to name two, sound like a youth church to me, not an inclusive congregation. (I realize you mentioned only differentiated preaching, Malan, but you seemed to imply the others were appropriate.) In fact, your illustration of the Sunday school class that became a vibrant worship service in the evening appears to be parallel worship, not inclusive congregational worship.

If you are arguing that youth ministry must include the eight modes of God’s coming to adolescents but would allow for meetings that are for the most part segregated, then even though some adults might attend, the Inclusive Congregational approach could be placed within either the Preparatory or Strategic approaches. The only difference might be that more attention would be paid to some of the modes of God’s coming, modes that have been short-changed by current youth ministry models.

Involved youths eventually graduate

In my opinion youth ministry is too often a spectator sport, with adults doing the ministering and young people passively watching. Are you advocating that young people do the preaching, worship leading, teaching, pastoral care, and administrating, while facilitating mutuality, service, and witness? If so, the Inclusive Congregational approach brings a distinctive approach to the current structures of youth ministry. (It also facilitates the Strategic approach I have proposed later in this book.)

But this raises a problem for me, Malan. As youths become effective in leading the eight modes of ministry, what happens when they graduate from high school? In the past, many churches have treated high school graduates as novice adults, in effect placing them into a holding pen until they marry and have at least their first child. Only then are they allowed to assume minor roles in church leadership. By this time years have often elapsed, and much of their passion for facilitating God’s coming to his people has evaporated. Whatever integration had taken place is lost, thanks to this forced hiatus from ministry.

On the other hand, we do not want to kick out the older leaders of the church just to make room for recent high school graduates. So what should we do?

Two ideas come to mind. The one closest to my heart is to use these young Christian leaders to start a new church at the rate of about one every 10 years. New beginnings provide the greatest possibility for making the eightfold coming of God a brilliant reality in the lives of young people. This should be done, however, with the full blessing of the church leadership.

The other option might be to promote 35-to-40-year-old church leaders to a council of elders and ask them to assume the role of wise counselors, though without organizational authority over younger leaders. The implications of the idea for youth ministry seem wonderfully refreshing: younger Christians would have incentive to remain involved in the church and further shape their expression among their generation.

Large or small church?

One question that repeatedly comes to my mind: To what extent is the Inclusive Congregational approach to youth ministry possible in larger churches? For churches with a weekly attendance of 250 or less, the approach might be an option because churches of this size still tend to operate like extended families. In fact, for the church to be an effective ministry, youths just about have to be active participants.

As churches get larger, however, and move toward a full-service orientation with staff-led or staff-supervised ministries that respond to a wide range of human needs, the inclusive nature of your approach becomes difficult and perhaps even impossible. In effect, young people become customers to be served, rather than brothers or sisters to be embraced. Still, large churches are powerful influences in presenting a Christian presence to most cultures. I would be uncomfortable writing them off because they cannot readily include young people in the fabric of their congregational tapestry.

Two practical tests

Apart from these theoretical applications (although good theory is essential to good practice, as we all know), I would suggest that youth workers who read your chapter ask themselves one question: How effectively has my church allowed God to come to the youths through the eight modes described by Malan? Would this be an appropriate starting place for rethinking the relationship of youth ministry and the church?

Finally, it would be useful to those contemplating the Inclusive Congregational approach for their own ministries to contact churches with experience in this approach. Then the approach would appear to be a more viable option where the rest of us are ministering.

If you concede there must be youth ministry preaching, which of the other modes also deserve differentiated approaches? Differentiated worship and differentiated teaching, to name two, sound like a youth church to me, not an inclusive congregation.

Notes

1. Dean Borgman, When Kumbaya Is Not Enough (Peabody, Massachusetts: Hendrickson, 1997); Rick Dunn, Reaching a Generation for Christ (Chicago: Moody Press, 1997); and Larry Richards, Youth Ministry and a New Face for the Church.

↑ Back to top

↑