Chapter 16 of 27

Response from an Inclusive Congregational perspective Malan Nel

Response from an Inclusive Congregational perspective Malan Nel

Response to the Missional Approach from an Inclusive Congregational Perspective

by Malan Nel

The understanding of the church as being missional in identity, Chap, is basic to my own theology, and I am excited about this emphasis in your chapter. In my main field of interest—namely, helping local churches understand and find their identity (what in German and in Afrikaans we call Gemeindeaufbau)—it is crucial to develop an ecclesiology that is missiological in nature. It is this golden thread that runs through your whole chapter, and of the utmost importance in any approach to youth ministry. In my comments here, I am in truth in full agreement with you. I just want to explore some of the basic issues you raise, and I’m interested in your response to the statements made below.

Your discussion of the church and the role it plays (or does not play) ties in with my basic belief that our problem is not so much youths and youth ministry, but the adult gestalt of the local church. We have allowed what you call the “club mentality.” And a club is not typically missionary in nature. This ingrown nature of churches is a major obstacle for the mission approach.

Along these lines, I’ve listed some observations that you may want to respond to:

  • The church’s lack of a missional understanding of youth ministry has to do with a misunderstanding of what it means to be a Christian. The practice of theology in local churches over many years is mainly responsible for this. Being a Christian does not mean (at least not in the first place) going to heaven. It is about being recreated back to our original purpose to serve this world. It has everything to do with the restoration of life and everything which is true of life and life eternal.
  • The “come” mentality of churches in their mission is a historical result of an informational and propositional theology of evangelism: we know the Answer, and the lost world does not. If they come, we will tell them what they do not know. If they do not come, then we claim for ourselves the sinful luxury of remaining the way we are—and then blaming the world for not coming. Who would dare come then? This approach may have worked during the so-called Christian eras, but it will not be enough in years to come.
  • I don’t know of any reference in the Bible for lost sinners to come, but the Bible is full of references to the church going or being sent. As you pointed out, “The church is missional in that its mandate is clearly focused on God sending his people into the world as light and salt.” The reference in Matthew 11:28 for people to come to Christ was not made to the world but to religious people who were so tired of their religion that they seriously needed the rest from religion and moralism, rest that Christ offers.
  • Developing a missional character as a local church includes a real conversion to what is commonly called the servanthood of the church. This dimension may need further exploration in your chapter. It seems to me that this understanding of the church in mission changes the way we do mission. The emphasis on our followership of Christ focuses on the needs of persons (youths, in our case) far more than on conversions. Serving people takes on a new meaning.
  • To be in service of the gospel is to be in service of the gospel of the kingdom (cf. Luke 8:1). To use your own words: “The theologically driven missional mandate of youth ministry is to bring the gospel and the kingdom to every adolescent. The church must step up and allow this theological axiom to shape and alter ecclesiological traditions and norms.” My fear, however, is that this may still communicate that we just bring the gospel—and when people get saved, the kingdom has come.
  • I know this is probably not your intention. My history in evangelism makes me sensitive to this possibility. The coming of the kingdom that is served by the communication of the good news is so much more. Or to state it differently, salvation is so much more. In my country salvation so often means having only one meal, having shelter for one more night, or getting a job. I remember a Sunday morning in my quiet time when I read through Isaiah 58. I was stunned once again by the concrete nature of the kingdom.

    The propositional theology of evangelism: we know the Answer, and the lost world does not. If they come, we will tell them what they do not know. If they do not come, then we can remain the way we are—and then blame the world for not coming.

  • Would you agree that it is partly because of the heavenly-mindedness of churches that youths often have no interest in the church? They just don’t expect anything real and concrete from the church. The world they live in cries out loud for concrete help, yet they see more real help coming from big businesses, government, and other institutions than from God’s agent for real kingdom help. Why then consider church (and by implication God and the gospel) as an option for life? The Germans have a saying that ministry is lebenshilfe (counseling). When youths find no help to live by, they quit seeking it from that institution.
  • This brings me to a rather subtle distinction that I would like to test out on you. You explained in a wonderful way the necessity for what is generally called “friendship evangelism.” This is a great way of doing youth evangelism. In Service Evangelism, R. S. Armstrong distinguishes between two styles of evangelism.1 May I state it this way: there are many similarities between the two styles. There is a lot of friendship in service evangelism and vice versa. But there is one obvious difference: friendship evangelism, as it is normally practiced, is not need-oriented, but conversion-oriented: You befriend in order to convert. In service evangelism, as it is normally practiced, you serve irrespective of conversion. It is an honest attempt to take after our Father: Accept, love, and care irrespective of whether or not they respond positively to that care and love. Does this makes conversion irrelevant? Not at all. It is almost modeling the love of God to whom we want people to give their lives—allowing and trusting God to draw people to himself.
  • This builds upon a very important theological issue. If we believe that faith in Christ as the Christ is ultimately a gift of God, it frees us from arguing anyone into faith. We serve in the spirit of Christ; do faith sharing, as we win the right to be heard; and when we have won that right, we leave the gift to God. He is the ultimate converter of hearts. I think Christian youths need this freedom from what is often an authoritarian go-tell approach. May I underline a very important statement you made: “…churched adults and leadership must not be allowed to deny that the church must be a place of refuge and welcome for the most desperate of the lost.” I believe it was Hebbard, in his book on family ministry, that made the same point: Nowhere should broken and hurting people (including youths) feel and be more at home and accepted than in the local body of believers.
  • Do you think it is possible that we are too middle-class in our churches? We seem to present a picture that the church is the place for those who have made it in life—successful people. Then how terribly difficult is it to help them change into helpless people who realize how broken they are, and to understand that we are but a fellowship of broken healers and healed broken ones? Kromminga referred in this regard to the local church as receiving fellowship.2

    Finally (I am not criticizing here, and I can understand the absence of the argument in your chapter) let me ask you this: should a missional approach in youth ministry take family (or what is left thereof) seriously?

    Let me explain my question by referring to a story Peters told concerning his plea for what he called “household evangelism.” A missionary in Japan led a young man to Christ one night after a rally. Knowing how difficult it would be for this young man to go through with his decision to follow Christ, given Japan’s emphasis on family, he asked the young man to wait for him. He went home with the man and met his parents, whom he told about the crucial decision their son had made. He also promised them that the church would in no way interfere with the family structure and would respect them as parents. He also invited them to come and see for themselves what new religion their son had accepted. It so happened that they did visit in a few weeks’ time and eventually came to Christ themselves.3

    If a student has a family, then helping the family find each other and Christ is crucial. History has proven that not many kids who are won for Christ made it on their own.

    My contention is that, irrespective of the age and state of family in a given case, the focus in mission is the family. If there is a family, then helping them find each other and Christ is crucial. History has proven that not many kids who are won for Christ made it on their own. The natural family (if in place) is a wonderful habitat in which to grow. But even where no family is in place, the future family of the young new believer should be our focus. Do you think this dimension can be part of the Missional approach—or even should be?

    Notes

    1. R. S. Armstrong, Service Evangelism (Philadelphia: Westminster, 1979).

    2. C. G. Kromminga, Bringing God’s News to Neighbors (Grand Rapids: Baker, 1976).

    3. G. W. Peters, Saturation Evangelism, 6th printing (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1977).

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑