Response from an Inclusive Congregational perspective Malan Nel
Response to the Strategic Approach from an Inclusive Congregational Perspective
Yours is a well-articulated and thorough description of the Strategic approach and what it implies when we take this road—a logical road, when one looks at it from the perspective of specialization, as you pointed out in your reference to the situation in schools. You rightfully deduct that “discontinuity of relationships and specialization of content become the normal way of doing education.” One tends to perpetuate what one is used to.
In your description of the approach you make the point that this is “the best opportunity to launch a vital Christian witness to shape the faith community for the next generation.” In this sense the approach might be called a specific missiological strategy, like church planting in the church-growth philosophy—a valid motivation for the Strategic approach. But, I must admit, it is the only motivation I can see for it.
Your explanation of the Strategic approach leaves me with some questions and reservations.
Giving up reforming the church
Isn’t it true that this approach has become even popular in some areas because leadership in youth ministry has given up on the reformation of the congregation? I think of your important remark, which to my mind points in that direction: “While the church wanted young people to mature in their Christian faith, maturity was defined in terms that the older generation understood and to which the younger crowd was expected to conform.” When and if this is true (and I think it is), the Strategic approach is almost the only way forward. I know there are a number of leaders in my field who just no longer believe that anything good can come out of the church as we know it. The gap between the defined subject (the church as portrayed in Scripture) and the empirical subject (the local church as we meet it in any given context) is so wide that they rationalize the fact that you cannot poor new wine into old wineskins—although this approach was challenged by Aubrey Malphurs in Pouring New Wine into Old Wineskins.1
My question is whether the Strategic approach is not, at least in part, giving up on the possibility that we all can and should reform to make room for each other.
The problem seems to be the adult contingent of congregations. Spiritually speaking, one wonders whether they are that “adult,” anyway. After all, openness to change is one of the most obvious characteristics of self-reliant spiritual functioning. My question is whether the Strategic approach is not, at least in part, giving up on the possibility that we all can and should reform to make room for each other. How would you respond to my conviction that behind all of this lies a very low missionary awareness? Normally we are just not compelled by the love of God to reach out to hurting children and adolescents outside the faith community. That’s why congregations think they can afford the luxury of being so ingrown that even their own kids become strangers within the church.
Corporate nature of the people of God
My second reservation concerns the ecclesiology behind the approach. I do not think there is one right ecclesiology out there. But there are ecclesiologies that should guide us in our decisions about what is good and what is better. One of them is the corporate nature of the people of God. We all confess one holy catholic church. My growing concern is that churches seem to be taking holiness more seriously than unity. Is it possible that the Strategic approach may make it just too easy to start something new? What does this do to unity? When do we really have that freedom?
Viewing the approach as a missionary strategy puts it in a different light: this becomes not splitting congregations, but starting or planting new congregations. Given the strong and ruling youth culture, I am, however, not convinced that mission is the reason for starting new youth congregations. I therefore like your heading: “Youth Ministry as Church-Birthing.” But how do we ensure that the approach is not misused for what may be pretty selfish reasons of even a leader or two? (“I want it my way.”)
Alternative community
Another ecclesiological issue at stake is the fragmentation of community. The youth-group-genesis-church becomes yet another alternative community that draws youths away from the primary community of the congregation. Separating youths from adults, unfortunately, seems to be the norm. I believe that if we take seriously the metaphors about the church, we will hardly find any biblical reasons for arguing the need for specialization, especially to the pointing of youth churches. To name but one: the fact that we are called children of God emphasizes the fact that we belong together.
The fact that empirical realities are different almost compels us to confess that we have given in to culture rather than vigorously pursuing our alternative nature. Richard R. Osmer argues a good case for what we might call individuation and individualization of adolescents.2 We owe adolescents help to become public Christians. A congregation with its normal makeup (representing the good, the bad, and the ugly who are now in Christ) and normal struggles (victory, failure, struggle, and so on) is in a sense a laboratory, where adolescents can experiment with Christian life—the life they need to live in public.
I know there may be situations that are almost a Luther moment (“Here I stand—I do not want to go, but have no choice.”) I believe that the approach needs this controlling mechanism. Otherwise starting a youth congregation may in some cases be the fad of a leader or group. What kind of control would you suggest to prevent this from happening because it is not the intention of the approach in itself? Maybe you pointed at this when you said: “A nucleus of parents and other adults need to be early adopters of the idea.”
If we take seriously the metaphors about the church, we will hardly find any biblical reasons for arguing the need for specialization, especially to the pointing of youth churches. The fact that we are called children of God emphasizes the fact that we belong together.
Building disciples
Finally is the matter of building disciples. You wrote that “perhaps the most vulnerable point in youth ministry is continuity in discipleship relationships.” I agree with this, but fail to see how the Strategic approach will solve the problem.
We all know that the whole biblical discipleship concept comes from the Greek and Jewish world Jesus lived in. The difference was, unlike in those two cultures, the pupils (disciples) did not elect to be in Jesus’ school of disciple building. He called them. And because of their calling by him to follow him they became a unique community. A diverse group, they undoubtedly learned a lot from each other. A true example of what the church as a community of disciples is supposed to be. They were not birds of a feather who flocked together; but they stayed together because they had been called together. They met each other in Christ, not in likemindedness. Would you agree that the Strategic approach carries the tendency to create churches that are not one in Christ, but one in how they feel and on what they agree? To the contrary, don’t we need the challenge of the others who are so completely different but share with us in the difference Christ makes in all of us?
Notes
1. Aubrey Malphurs, Pouring New Wine into Old Wineskins (Baker Book, 1993).
2. Richard R. Osmer, Confirmation (Louisville: Geneva, 1996).
