Response from a Missional perspective Chap Clark
Response to the Inclusive Congregational Approach from a Missional Perspective
Malan, I found your article to be an insightful critique of one of the most important aspects of parish youth ministry—the congregation’s commitment to their young.
There are several points about the Inclusive Congregational approach to youth ministry with which I agree.
Unwillingness to include youth
Your piercing appraisal of the state of youth ministry in the church—specifically, that local churches are typically unable or unwilling to include or even care about the young of the congregation—is more than justified, at least in those societies in which an adolescent subculture has developed. When you claim that young people have been treated like “foster care, not family” in the church, there is significant cause for alarm. The most recent history of youth ministry reveals that this is indeed the case in the vast majority of parish youth ministries: youths have indeed been segregated from the community of the church at large, relegated instead to a programmatic holding tank until they are ready to be included in the life of the church.
Youth ministry should not and cannot be reduced to a programmatic sideshow of a local congregation. Ministry toward and care of young people at all levels is a central responsibility of every member of a congregation. Your assertion that the youths are part of the congregation cannot be shouted too loudly, and I was grateful to hear it.
Banished to catechesis
I also share your disappointment how youth ministry has historically been banished to the narrow focus of the church’s educational program, or catechesis. Your chapter disputes the claim of those committed to a catechesic philosophy, asserting again and again that the integration of youth and adult congregation is complex, systemic, and highly relational.
Individualism as opposed to community
You touched lightly but significantly upon the tug that modern Christianity feels (at least in industrialized societies) from individualism on one hand, and community on the other. Theologically there is no question that the basic mode of experiencing biblical Christianity—including youth ministry—is within the context of the Christian community. Youth ministry that segments and divides the body, even if for the sake of winning the lost or similarly noble reasons, does a disservice to the youths it seeks to attract and disciple.
I do, however, take issue with four aspects of the Inclusive Congregational approach as you described it:
Adolescence as a transitional phase
It appears that you never do reconcile an apparent conflict between a youth ministry’s need for age-specific, programmed discipleship options (where youths “require and need to receive specific attention”)—between that and immersion in the life of the church like any adult (the church, you write, must find “a place for youths within every ministry”). You seem to favor, at least in statements like these, some sort of focused youth ministry—yet the remainder of your article appears to deny even that concession. That is, until your examples at the end, which you intended as evidence of your chapter’s premise—but which seemed to me to be instances of how most churches attempt to merely placate an uninterested adolescent population.
To what extent should youths be allowed to experience age-specific training, fellowship, and worship? Yet to what extent should that be balanced with intergenerational relationships?
Granted, this is a difficult and delicate theological balance. To what extent should youths be allowed and even encouraged to experience age-specific training, fellowship, and worship? To what extent should that be balanced with intergenerational relationships? This is not easily resolved, nor should it be, at least on a macro scale. Each church must determine for itself what is appropriate for its history, traditions, and polity in terms of deciding on programmatic responses to the needs of adolescents. Consider a church, for example, with a sizable elderly population that requires sensitivity in its style of worship—there may be other ways to connect this church’s young with the elderly than forcing them into the same worship services or mission projects. Although I fully endorse what you write about the theological bases of the Inclusive Congregational approach, the application of that theology, I believe, needs to be context specific.
Denial of the adolescent task
Your chapter seems to pass over and ignore the essence of the adolescent task. “There is no theological reason,” you write, “why what is valid for adults is not valid for youth.” This assumption pervades your article and is especially prevalent in your categories of mission and administration. The implication, at least as I read your argument, is that adolescents are herein considered to be a different kind of adult, rather than individuals who have not yet achieved the status and maturity of adulthood.
You write that the pattern for transmitting spiritual training to children is “children ask questions and parents answer.” In most places, however, this simply does not happen anymore.
By its very nature and design, adolescence is a time when one tries out different “selves,” when one is inconsistent (even in matters of faith), and when one is often more concerned about how the self emerges from a social setting or environment than about others in general. When given too much authority, too loud a voice, and too much autonomy, the adolescent stage can be more harmful than healthy for a young person. Yes, I believe that leadership options and seasons of significant responsibility are a vital component of the youth ministry task, but only when contained within the protective embrace of adults (or congregations) who watch out for the young person’s growth and development. Adolescents are not another type of adult needing to be included in every ministry of the church so much as they are trainees in life who need a congregation that is committed to their spiritual and personal development.
Young people’s world has changed
Not mentioned in your chapter is the fact that the world affecting young people has dramatically changed over the past few decades. Yet the adolescent’s world must be considered when discussing the pragmatics of youth ministry. Again, I agree with the theological assumptions of an Inclusive Congregational approach as you spell out those assumptions—what I question is the sociological and programmatic response to this theological stance.
Yes, the congregation is called to the youth ministry task. And yes, parents (and family) provide the “primary hermeneutic sphere” in the discipleship of the young. Yet the cultural gap between the young and those in power has shifted dramatically. You write, for example, that the pattern for transmitting spiritual training to children is “children ask questions and parents answer.” In most places, however, this simply does not happen anymore. Of course, in more stable societies, in which knowledge was passed to younger generations through traditional modes of education, children certainly sat with their parents and asked them questions. But for the past few decades, this kind of willingness and teachability has been all but jettisoned by adolescents.
It is generally accepted by cultural observers that we live in a society with a postmodern worldview. There is also strong evidence that young people, as a population if not as individuals, have sensed for some time that adults have generally withdrawn from their traditional nurturing role to adolescents. This has caused a sense of cultural abandonment, adding fuel to what is already smoldering. If this is correct, then your article is an important voice in calling youth ministry practitioners to strategically incorporate families and the congregation in our work with adolescents. But the answers provided here—to simply include youths at all levels of ministry without the slightest nod given to embracing the developmental needs of a disenfranchised subculture—could backfire badly. Teenagers today simply do not want, at least on the surface, what you claim they need. The church must find a way to bridge that cultural gap.
If we change, they will come
It is true, of course, that churches must be willing to adapt to a new subculture and must see the ministry to adolescents as the entire congregation’s responsibility. But I am also firmly convinced that the church’s primary function is to be a witness of salt, light, and proclamation to a world that needs to encounter the living God (as I discuss in some detail in my chapter on the Missional approach). In general, the Inclusive Congregational approach is a wonderful and appropriate first step to caring for the young of a given congregation. But this approach will have virtually no impact on the missional calling of the church to disenfranchised, uninterested, and antagonistic young people. Most of these adolescents simply will not be drawn to a church congregation, even if it is a loving, caring, and inclusive family. There is simply insufficient incentive for such youths to take that first step and explore the possibilities of involvement in (not to mention commitment to) a religious community—unless they have the assurance that the church will in turn invest in their lives.
Today’s young people are aware that adult institutions have abandoned them and left them on their own to discover life. They also know that most adults are willing to help them, but usually only if the youth show up for a program. But that is risky, especially for an unchurched adolescent. Yes, the church must be inclusive for its own—but it must be willing to reach out beyond its doors to bring the gospel to the lost, the broken, and the lonely. And as you’ve made clear in your chapter, all in the congregation are sent—adults, youth, everyone. For this is the ultimate mandate of the youth ministry task.
