Chapter 13 of 27

Rejoinder Wesley Black

Rejoinder Wesley Black

Rejoinder from the Preparatory Approach

by Wesley Black

Notwithstanding your reasoned, informed, and often intriguing observations, I still believe the Preparatory approach is the best stance for effective Christian youth ministry. Perhaps a little more discussion in three areas will clarify my position.

Preparation is more than a one-way street

The very title of this approach indicates its biblical source. Ephesians 4:12–13 says that we are “to prepare God’s people for works of service, so that the body of Christ may be built up until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ.” The Preparatory approach is part of the overall mission of a church, which is to prepare (equip or perfect, as used in some translations) God’s people (including God’s younger people) to do his will in the world.

Malan, you expressed concern about the nature of preparation in two enlightening ways. You wrote that you are “concerned that people might view the Preparatory approach as just another way of reaffirming an outmoded educational paradigm.” I agree wholeheartedly. Preparation might easily be seen as simply a process whereby adults pour knowledge into passive receivers (youths) who have nothing better to do than absorb the traditions from the past. It reminds me of the old cliche in which the teacher instructs the students to “sit still while I instill.” I think we can agree that this is neither good educational practice nor good discipleship.

Mark, you also pointed to this with your comments about confirmation programs that “initiate young people out of the church.” This is a problem that many mainline denominations face regularly. You summarized it well: “The problem, in my opinion, is that the confirmation process is not designed for the whole person—just the head.” The result, as you noted, is rejection by young people of the whole process. They sense they are considered unimportant and have nothing to contribute. Therefore, they leave as quickly as possible in search of something that involves and challenges their youthful energies and commitments.

Adults do their best teaching when they walk alongside youths, providing a loving, nurturing environment in which youths see the model of adult Christians learning and growing along with them. Teaching and discipleship are more than just telling and advice-giving.

Perhaps in these churches the young people really are “viewed as problems to be solved” and the best way is to see preparation as a one-way street. After all, if the older generation has all the wisdom, insights, experience, and knowledge why, should youths be involved in the teaching or learning process other than as passive receivers? Malan, you captured this idea when you said that in your own tradition “it is the older members that would identify with the Preparatory approach…because they see it as getting back the old Sunday school they grew up with. This is probably not your intention.”

Relationships with youth

Part of the solution to this dilemma, I believe, lies in the idea of relationships with youths, as Larry Richards pointed out in Malan’s chapter on the Inclusive Congregational approach: “A ministry-facilitating relationship is one in which the adult admits and expresses his equality with youths as persons by encouraging mutual self-revelation and in which youths and adult each learn to trust the other with thoughts, feelings, and experiences, knowing that both are valued and respected.”

Discipleship is a lifelong process, not just a short body of knowledge dealing with selected topics and skills. We are all on the road of discipleship leading to “perfection”, and adults do their best when they walk alongside youths in the discipling process. This provides a loving, nurturing environment in which youths see the model of adult Christians learning and growing along with them. It makes discipleship a lifelong journey, not just something to endure as a child or youth. Teaching and discipleship are more than just telling and advice-giving.

I did emphasize that youth ministry has to be more than building relationships with youths. Perhaps I should have illustrated this more in the sense of those who see relationships as simply entertaining youths and hoping they will somehow grow closer to God in the process. This is an inadequate view of youth ministry that neither builds Christian fellowship nor discipleship. As you said, Chap, “It is even a far stretch to label this kind of thinking ‘youth ministry’.”

On the other hand, we make a mistake when we rule out the social elements of adolescence. Malan, you expressed your concern “that it is so easy to turn a church into a school, which it is not.” This would be going to the opposite extreme. I fear there are some youth ministers and pastors who sincerely want to avoid the “silly fun and games” and go to the extreme of “serious Bible study” without considering the need for balance in adolescent social needs. You stated this well in the formula, “The norm is to prepare youths for life and ministry. The form is to be contextually relevant.”

Mark, I liked your discussion about laboratories. You added to our understanding when you said, “Laboratories are designed to allow the learner to fail in a safe context and discover specific skills in the process. It is a hands-on place. Involvement is essential to learning.” Involvement in this case means we must be sensitive to adolescent levels of learning and needs, and approach them in relevant, meaningful ways.

Separating and integrating

Second, I want to reemphasize the concept of separation and integration, which I believe is a key distinction between the Inclusive Congregational and Preparatory approaches. The Preparatory approach takes seriously the need to deal with youths as adolescents. As Chap said, this approach “takes seriously the transitionary realities of the adolescent phase of the life span.” Yes, youths need to be involved in the life of the local body of Christ, but they also need focused ministry that is generationally specific. It is a balancing act between separating and integrating.

The Preparatory approach does a better job of balancing evangelism and discipleship. Any shortfall of evangelism and mission in the Preparatory approach is due to inadequate leadership, not the approach itself. The Preparatory approach calls for an equal effort in both directions.

Chap, you described adolescents well when you reminded us that they are learning how to “shift from being entirely reliant on outside forces and influences for meaning, security, help, safety, satisfaction, and purpose, to learning what it means to take personal responsibility for these things.”

Mark, you also hit on one of my current concerns, dealing with the “small group of former youth workers who now claim adolescence is not a biblical idea and therefore should not be used as a basis for ministering to people in their teenage years.” I liked your ideas of the rite of passage as seen in the life of Jesus (Luke 2:42–51) and as practiced by both ancient and modern Jews. It is both biblically and developmentally correct to deal with adolescents in a focused way.

Further, Mark, I agree with your assessment that, “youth ministry is and must be a separate program, but never divorced from the larger church culture.” Again, there must be a balance between separation and integration.

Malan, you reiterated this when you said, “Why in the world do you think we have created a gap between adults and children in this regard? Is it possible that we deem young believers unworthy of being equipped and only worthy of being kept busy?” Perhaps it is far too easy to put forth the efforts to disciple teenagers on an age-appropriate level, so we simply fall back to entertaining them separately from others and hope they will behave until they reach a magical age when they can contribute something to the kingdom of God.

Relationship between families and the church

In this separation-integration context, Malan, you brought up the issue of the relationship between families and the church. I agree that many youths (perhaps even the 80 percent you mentioned) will tend to become more like their parents as they mature. They tend to take on the life and worldview of their parents, and I think this fact alone calls for intentional efforts by pastors, youth leaders, and churches, to equip parents for their proper role as spiritual coaches for youths. This, of course, is the biblical pattern (Deuteronomy 6:4–7; Proverbs 22:6; Ephesians 6:1–4). Churches that view youth ministry as only focused on adolescents, apart from their family context, are missing an important element. Youth ministry must face the challenge of discipling both teenagers and their families if they hope to make significant life changes. This is a whole-church effort, not just something that can be done by a few youth workers.

Mark, you raised an interesting dilemma in the separation versus integration arena. You mentioned that youth leaders and young people “have little commitment to the ministry as a whole.” When we try to be generationally relevant, we sometimes mistake ministry, worship, evangelism, and stewardship to be only age-specific activities, and ignore the larger church family. Teens do need intergenerational experiences to broaden their life and worldview. This can only be accomplished with a proper balance between separation and integration.

You mentioned your concern with the three cultures: youth culture, church culture, and kingdom culture. You voiced my desire when you wrote that “actually, the youth ministry is richest when young people learn to live in all three.” I think we make a mistake, however, when we think that discipleship in the Preparatory approach is simply teaching youths how to be good church members. This falls into the trap that some confirmation and even some Sunday school approaches enter. In these contexts (the weaker ones) the task is assumed to be simply passing along the traditions of the past generation and ignoring the culture of the youths and the larger kingdom of God.

The answer has to be a youth ministry that grows out of the purposes of God for the church and his kingdom. Youth ministry that is a knee-jerk response to planning entertainment for youths, teaching outdated traditions, and keeping youths under control ignores the possibilities of developing young disciples in intentional, purposeful ways.

Initiation rites

One additional comment along these lines, Mark, has to do with your idea of the initiation rites. I like this possibility. For years I have bemoaned the fact that in contemporary life we have very few markers and initiation rites for adolescents. As David Elkind said in the title of his book, we have a generation that is all grown up and no place to go. Youth ministers, pastors, parents, and churches should develop some markers along the way to guide young people in their journey toward adulthood. This would help develop their identity and their place in the kingdom of God. You said it well: “Every activity will assist the young person to discover their ‘new name’ and how they will serve the faith community.”

Finally, this process can only be accomplished when the church sees its larger responsibility in youth ministry. Chap, you nailed this when you wrote that “youth ministry should not be delegated to the few, but rather embraced by the entire local expression of the body of Christ.” The entire congregation has to accept the marriage of youth ministry with the total mission of the church.

Balancing reaching and teaching

Finally, there is the issue of the balancing act between reaching and teaching—evangelism and discipleship. This grows out of the dual facets of the Great Commission (Matthew 28:18–20). Jesus commanded us to make disciples (reaching out) and teach them to observe all that he had commanded (teaching).

Chap, the Missional approach obviously majors on the evangelism facet. We both agree that “youth ministry must have a driving reason for being that goes beyond a baby-sitting mentality, beyond the need to keep students too busy to sin.” However, we disagree that the Preparatory approach “seems to support the ecclesiological status quo of youth ministry from the 1970s onward.”

Perhaps the answer lies in the mistaken view that the Preparatory approach equals the outdated mode of youth work with its “lack of strategic focus on the missional mandate of the church.” I would assert that the Preparatory approach does a better job of balancing both elements of the Great Commission. If there is a lack of emphasis on evangelism and mission in the Preparatory approach, then it is because of inadequate leadership, not the basic approach. The Preparatory approach calls for an equal effort in both directions.

“Kids bringing kids” approach to evangelism

Chap, you really made me rethink the “kids bringing kids” approach to evangelism. Your comment is insightful: “They usually do not bring friends; when they do, the friends they bring are almost always the kind of students already inclined to church involvement without the goad of evangelistic and strategic energy.” According to your assessment, this is the reason for stagnation in evangelism and church growth.

However, I’m not ready to give up on this strategy. It’s still an effective way to reach out to peers who may be friends in a school or community context but not a part of the Christian family. Sensitive, generationally aware adults can aid in the process by strategizing to reach out to the fringe youths, to those outside the church family, and to secular neo-pagan teenagers. It will take honest, intentional efforts for this to happen, but it can and is happening in churches that take seriously the mandate of the Great Commission.

This will take more than status quo youth ministry. It will take conscious, intentional efforts to plan youth ministry with the evangelism purpose in mind. In the best sense this involves youths as vital parts of the equation, with adult coaches who have a heart for reaching the whole world for Christ.

But then, Mark, you pointed out that many adults do not have this heart for evangelism. Resistance to change “must be tackled by the adults in the tribe/church before young people have a chance of becoming the church described in Scripture.” The reason for much of the stagnation lies in the fact that, as you put it, “Young people have very effectively absorbed these negative values and are perpetuating them into the next generation.”

I tend to agree with much of what you said. “Anything we wish for among our young people must first be true among our adults”—I still believe this is possible within the context of the Preparatory approach. God can and does bring renewal and revival among his people. We have seen this in many of the great youth movements of history. But it most often happens with the support and encouragement that adults provide to youths.

The best contemporary expressions of evangelism and spiritual renewal—True Love Waits, See You at the Pole, and the growth of campus Christian clubs—are all youth initiated and youth led. But they could not become reality without a base of adult support and encouragement. To separate youths into a baby church, even with adult oversight, tends to separate them from the ongoing coaching and support that adolescents need. I believe the Preparatory approach provides for this adult spiritual nurture in the best way.

Revival and renewal to the entire congregation

The beauty of this can also be seen in the way young people can bring revival and renewal to the entire congregation. Youthful idealism and exuberance, in the midst of a loving and nurturing congregation, can inspire adults to renew their faithfulness and commitment to the Lord’s work. In this way, God can use youths to prepare his people, “with everything good for doing his will, and may he work in us what is pleasing to him, through Jesus Christ, to whom be glory for ever and ever. Amen” (Hebrews 13:21).

↑ Back to top

↑