Chapter 20 of 27

The Strategic Approach to Youth Ministry Mark H. Senter III

The Strategic Approach to Youth Ministry Mark H. Senter III

The Strategic Approach to Youth Ministry

by Mark H. Senter III

Scenario: Foster kids

No one in the reunion committee of the Launchers Adult Fellowship foresaw how disappointing the turnout would be for their 10-year youth group reunion. After all, 40 or 50 high schoolers had typically attended the weeknight youth meetings, and twice that number came on Sundays. At least that is how Sheila Wolfe remembered it, and nobody wanted to argue with her because she had been the social glue that held the youth group together.

Yet only 19 people showed up for the reunion—and that included four spouses. No one expected their old youth pastor Geoff to be there, since he was now serving a church in another state. But at least he e-mailed a greeting. Hardly anyone else bothered to do even that.

“What happened to all of that unity we experienced in Bible studies, on mission trips, at camp?” asked Sheila. “It feels like some sort of dream that never really happened.”

“Maybe it was a dream,” said Roger. Every youth group has its skeptic. Roger, who performed that function in the youth ministry, was one of the remnant who showed up for the reunion. “Not a dream like it never happened, but an illusion as to what was really happening while we were absorbed in all of our good times.”

“And what is that suppose to mean, Mr. Skeptic?” replied the ever-protective Sheila.

“Foster kids don’t go to family reunions. The youth ministry wasn’t really part of the church family. We were foster children. It was like the church fathers wanted to keep us from getting into too much trouble so they hired Pastor Geoff to create this virtual reality. He did a great job, too. For a lot of us it became a powerful spiritual experience, but the church never expected us to become a vital part until we got married, had children, and became just like them.”

“So what did you expect the church to do, make you the pastor?” Since high school days Sheila had bristled when critical comments were made about her parents and their friends who had done so much to build the ministries of their church.

“Now that’s an interesting idea…”

“You’ve got to be kidding! You haven’t even been to seminary.”

By now Roger’s mind was working at warp speed. No, he did not want to be the pastor of their church because they had so many traditions, musical styles, and bothersome customs that made their church seem like—well, a foster church. But to be a leader (or even a pastor) in a church that actively sought the contributions of youths…now that was intriguing.

“I was kidding,” confessed Roger, “but now that I’m thinking about the idea, it may not be as hare-brained as you seem to think. For example, if I were pastor, I could just about guarantee that more people would be here for the reunion. Not because of me, but because they would have a greater ownership in what the church is and what it does.”

A realistic appraisal of youth groups a decade after graduation suggests a disappointingly small number of alumni remain in either their home church or other churches. The absence of alumni from Fellowship of Christian Athletes huddle groups, Young Life, and Youth for Christ is more startling. Unless the youth leader maintains a meaningful contact with graduates and encourages them to attend church together, very few establish a lasting relationship with a local church.

Heart of the problem

At the core of the reunion problem faced by Launchers Adult Fellowship were two obstacles: marginalization of youths and discontinuity in spiritual nurture. While the church wanted young people to mature in their Christian faith, maturity was defined in terms that the older generation understood and to which the younger crowd was expected to conform. Outside of the sheltered enclave of the youth ministry, Sheila and Roger were mere spectators in a middle age church. Young people lived on the margins of the church.

Hymnology, while punctuated with occasional praise choruses, found much of its style and substance in a world far removed from urban or suburban America. Evangelization rarely influenced decisions about how money was spent. Expectations of lifestyle found its motivation more through fear than Christian love. Prayer was an activity rather than a relationship. Public communication appealed more to the mind than to the total person. In general, young people were not valued for what they brought to the church family as much as for what they would someday become.

While Sheila and Roger were apparently content to be spectators until such a time as when they could begin shaping the vision and priorities of the church (the leadership of most churches begin listening to “the young people” when they reach their mid-30s), most of their peers were not that patient. Most dropped out of church. Some would return in a few years with children in tow, determined to force-feed their children the same Christian faith they had been force-fed.

Outside of the sheltered enclave of the youth ministry, Sheila and Roger were mere spectators in a middle-aged church. Young people lived on the margins of the church.

The slate of church leaders to whom Sheila, Roger, and their friends looked for spiritual leadership changed every one to four years as they grew up in the church. The youth ministry was built upon a flawed discipleship model that was firmly rooted in modernity: based on the twin assumptions of specialization and discontinuity, the youth ministry resembled a factory model of nonformal education, which came to dominate formal education in the latter part of the 19TH century.

Factories, schools—and churches

Factories utilize an assembly line to create a product. As an automobile moves along the assembly line, workers contribute toward the finished product by inserting a part, tightening bolts, or welding a joint in place. At the end, a car rolls off of the conveyor belt ready to be sold to the public. No one person builds a car. Even a limited production car such as a Lamborghini is a product of many hands all contributing in specialized ways.

Schools follow the same model. The initial specialization is determined by the age of the child. A person may spend a lifetime teaching first graders and promoting them to the second grade specialist. Early in the process additional specialists enter the picture. The music teacher, gym coach, and art teacher bring their specializations to the education of children. As children approach adolescence, the various educational disciplines are isolated into specialty areas. Math, sciences, language skills, and history join the list of subjects being taught in different rooms by certified specialists. Discontinuity of relationships and specialization of content become the normal way of doing education.

Churches like Sheila and Roger’s adopted a schooling model of discipleship. Sunday school divided youths from adults. Age-graded classes further sorted students into chronological ghettoes. Discontinuity and specialization expanded with the introduction of the youth group and eventually the youth minister. Even church architecture reflected the changes. Educational wings followed the model of public schools. Eventually gymnasiums became a normal part of church building programs. Discontinuity and specialization were set in stone. Any change in approach to discipleship through the church became extremely difficult. The church became a factory.

Specialization in the discipleship ministries of the church initiated a holistic ministry to youths. Very quickly, however, it was discovered that one rather large component of discipleship ministry was absent from youth ministry in the church: the evangelization of youths was less and less a normal part of church youth ministry. To put it bluntly, it simply was not happening.

Once again specialization and discontinuity entered the picture. As has happened throughout the history of the church, special orders formed outside the church by spiritually minded Christian people. Their purpose was to fill a gap created by the church’s inattention to a value found in Scripture. Thus the concern for the evangelization of youths brought into being a series of parachurch youth ministries. They saw themselves as being alongside the church, as being the evangelistic arm extending from the church out into the youth culture.

Specialists gifted in youth evangelization championed the Young Life, Youth for Christ, and Fellowship of Christian Athletes movements. Hosts of similar youth evangelization agencies followed, including some associated with denominations. Their profound desire was to disciple youths into local churches. Yet discontinuity and specialization produced such a gap that few adolescent converts found their way into fellowship with believers in local churches.

British youth ministry specialist Pete Ward finds a similar concern in his country, where church attendance now tallies less than ten percent of the population. He comments, “This trend is extremely alarming. In the past parachurch ministries could assume that young people would somehow connect up with a suitable church. This is less likely to be the case, however, because of the decline in church-going among the youth’s parents and immediate family. Wider changes in contemporary culture also make long term allegiances to institutions much less acceptable.”1

Churches that have grown out of parachurch agencies often begin as discipleship efforts before becoming worship services and then local churches. Other churches result from youth pastors who use the leadership developed in their youth ministries to start new churches.

In time, local churches like Willow Creek Community Church brought the parachurch strategy into the church. That church, for example, used team competition much like campus clubs to feed students into Student Impact, their weeknight “supplemental witness”—which was followed by the Student Insight meetings for worship on Sunday nights. Willow Creek brought Youth for Christ’s club-rally small group strategy under the roof of the church. Yet even with church buildings housing specialized youth ministries, young converts rarely assimilated into the larger church family.2

Definition of Strategic Approach

How then should youth ministry relate to the local church so that young people both shape and are shaped by the faith community throughout their lives? The church must view youth ministry not so much as a means of turning out models of Christian living in order to perpetuate existing church ministries, but as the best opportunity to launch a vital Christian witness to shape the faith community for the next generation. We call it the Strategic approach to youth ministry.

The Strategic approach creates a community of leaders and youthful Christians that enables a parachurch or church-based youth ministry to establish a new church to maintain a theological continuity while expressing faith in a community relevant to both Christ and culture. Why do we call this the Strategic approach to youth ministry? Primarily because it calls upon the youth ministry to be and become a holistic intergenerational church that is relevant to the world in which it lives.

Description of the Strategic Approach to Youth Ministry

Strategic approaches might be a better way to describe the way in which churches grow out of youth ministries. Some ethnic groups—especially Chinese and Korean congregations—use an English-speaking youth service as a means of creating an American-style service within the same church. Some Gen-X worship services follow the same model. Churches that have grown out of parachurch agencies frequently begin as discipleship efforts before becoming worship services and then local churches. Other churches result from youth pastors who use the leadership developed in their youth ministries to start new churches.

Yet the basic approach remains constant:

1. Solid youth ministry

The ministry includes a blend of evangelism, discipleship, and worship that attracts both students and adult leaders. Through the ministry a faith community is built that delights in serving God. Instead of forcing people to leave the community as they graduate from high school, ways are sought to maintain continuity in discipleship relationships.

2. Vision for continuity

With the blessing of church leaders, the youth minister begins painting a vision of a new church that would allow the fruit of the youth ministry to be extended over a number of years, as adult and student leaders buy into the vision and begin shaping a strategy.

3. Leadership team

The team the youth minister has assembled to reach and disciple youths needs to commit themselves to the strategic vision. While some will choose to remain with the youth ministry in the mother church, a significantly large group of gifted youths and adults will need to leave their comfort zone to begin a multigenerational church.

4. A critical mass

In most of the youth ministry genesis churches that have formed in recent days, there has been an initial group of people committed to the idea that number close to 200 people or more. These are people who have been touched by the youth ministry and believe in the faith community that is being created.

5. Relevant ministry style

A ministry style grounded in scripture and appropriate to the rising generation of Christians begins in the youth ministry and then develops into an intergenerational ministry where worship, nurture, and ministries of evangelism and mercy build up the body of Christ and glorify God. Worship (leitourgia) is shaped in a holy tension between biblical concepts of preaching (kerugma) and holistic forms of communication and reflection. Nurture shepherds the flock with a balanced blend of fellowship (koinonia) and teaching (didache), while ministries of evangelism and mercy facilitate relevant witness (marturia) and pastoral care (paraklesis).

6. Time and support

Even in the best of circumstances, church planting takes time. During that time the youth ministry continues in the home church or parachurch club while the new ministry is taking shape. This means the mother church or parachurch agency may have double expenses as a new youth minister is groomed and the new ministry with all its expenditures begins. The start-up period may be as short as a year but may extend over three to five years.

7. Location

Some youth ministry genesis churches meet initially in the building of the mother church, others choose to gather in school buildings, theaters or shopping malls. In the initial stages this proves satisfactory, but eventually most new church choose to purchase property and create a place of worship appropriate to their vision. If the support base is not adequate to secure a permanent location, the new church may languish or fail. The mother churches may have to remain supportive through this stage of the ministry.

Justification for the Strategic Approach

Complexity and the youth culture

While some would call for a return to the simplicity of the old days, this option simply is not available to youth ministry in the 21st century. It would be much like returning to the one-room schoolhouse in public education. While a much more solid community might be built through returning to a 19th-century intergenerational approach to learning, the explosion and breadth of knowledge necessary to prepare young people for the challenge of sharing the planet with six billion people makes the possibility impractical.3

The complexity of the world is complicated by a distinct youth culture that gnaws on the fiber of all value systems, including the Christian worldview. The 1955 movie Rebel Without a Cause was a watershed for adolescence in America and proved to be the birth announcement of a youth culture. Rock and roll, movies targeted at the baby boomers, the anti-Vietnam war movement and accompanying experimentation with drugs, MTV, and the Internet have brought about such complexity in the world of young people that parents find their culture difficult to comprehend and more challenging to respond to.

A youth culture appears to be spreading across the developed world. While underlying cultural values separate youth cultures in Seoul or Beijing from those in Los Angeles or London, the need for generational differentiation fed by a popular culture depicted in the mass media make traditional ideas of community virtually impossible to obtain.

The influence of the youth culture’s aggressive presence on radio, television, CDs, magazines, novels, and the Internet leave a return to simplicity in youth ministry a practical impossibility. Though some families provide safe places through homeschooling and some churches build loving networks of adult mentors in hopes of building a distinctly Christian counterculture, the task is overwhelming. Apart from a spiritual revival on the order of the Great Awakenings, a position of Christ against culture appears hopeless as the central thrust of youth ministry.

Confused by the cultural complexity faced by Christian young people and the desire of Christian adults to be a redemptive force in the lives of the rising generation, youth ministers stepped in to fill the gap. Before James Dean’s Rebel Without a Cause there were fewer than 500 professional youth ministers (church and parachurch) in the United States and Canada.4 By the end of the 20th century, the National Network of Youth Ministries in the United States alone had a membership of over 3,000 professional youth ministers. In 1998, Young Life reported 994 full-time field ministry staff.5 For the same year, Fellowship of Christian Athletes reported 422 field staff, while Youth for Christ identified over 800 full-time employees, the vast majority of whom are field staff. Sonlife Ministries recounts training 49,420 youth leaders (lay and professional) in their Strategy Seminars since 1980.6,7,8 In addition, youth ministry boasts thousands of local church and parachurch professionals not associated with these more visible groups.

The church as a community

In the rush to fill the spiritual vacuum that was created as the youth culture exploded, two essential questions hardly attracted any attention: “What is the church (faith community) and what should the church do to shape the values and spiritual journey of young people?”

Youth workers’ glib but seldom spoken answer to the first question was, “We are.” After all, most youth ministers (church and parachurch) attended church with some degree of regularity and thus assumed that since they were part of the invisible church (true believers), their ministry was synonymous with that of the church. Little thought was given to questions of spiritual development before or after youth ministry.

The second question received similarly slick but seldom stated responses ranging from, “Trust me. I will figure something out,” to “I’ll do my best to show them the attractiveness of Jesus, and after that let’s hope they will want to return to the rather boring things Christian adults do.” So the function of the church in the lives of adolescents had been reduced to individualism in the person of the youth minister. For the most part youth pastors are relational and purposeful, most are biblical and accountable to spiritual leaders. But youth ministry based on individualism, no matter how qualified the individual, is individualism just the same. Any person, no matter how relationally skilled, can maintain a spiritually sensitive contact with only a limited number of young people, either right now or over a period of years.

The influence of the youth culture’s aggressive presence on radio, television, CDs, magazines, novels, and the Internet leave a return to simplicity in youth ministry a practical impossibility.

Satisfaction with these responses ranges widely. Parents of adolescents, as well as senior pastors and church leaders, agreed that they needed help if the church was to be a redemptive force in the lives of youths. But how?

The spiritual formation of youths has always found its primary influence in the nurturing relationships of the family and community of faithful believers. Kings, priests, prophets, and pastor-teachers each played a role in passing the faith from generation to generation, but the primary responsibility for nurturing youths remained with the family. The family, in turn, drew from the larger faith community a shared understanding of what it meant to be the kingdom of God. A continuity of relationships with parents and godly people from another generation appears to be the dominant means of spiritual formation in scripture. Lawrence O. Richards comments, “When we look at the ideal community sketched in Exodus, Leviticus and Deuteronomy, we find little explicit instruction on child rearing. But we do find a clear expression of the social context that God designed for the nurture of faith. That context can be simply defined. Children are intended to be brought up as participants in a loving, holy community.”9

What does it mean for young people in the 21st century to be participants in a loving, holy community? Jimmy Long, writing 15 years after Richards, asserts, “[C]ommunity, not self (in other words individualism), is the basic relational foundation…for creating small group communities, which in most situations need to be the basic framework for ministry with Xers in a postmodern environment.”10

The church as continuity

Scripture is filled with metaphors for the church. Perhaps the biblical writers found it easier to describe what the faith community was like than to provide a precise definition. Major analogies for the church share one characteristic—continuity. All require a continued relationship over an extended period of time. Family images (Matthew 12:49; 2 Corinthians 6:18; 1 Timothy 5:1–2; 1 John 3:14–15), farming images (Matthew 13:1–30; John 4:34–38; 15:5; Romans 11:17–24; 1 Corinthians 3:6–9), the body of Christ analogy (1 Corinthians 12:12–14; Ephesians 1:22–23; 4:15–16; Colossians 2:19) and even the “living stones” metaphor (1 Peter 2:5) convey the idea of life and growth in a healthy organism over time.

Families grow and develop over the lifetimes of the family members. Crops spend at least a season maturing before harvest starts the process all over again. Vines and trees grow for many years and are made more productive through a pruning process. The organs and limbs of a body are organically connected for the cycle of life. While scriptural analogies are not intended to be detailed prescriptions for doctrinal matters, the persistence of the continuity image in the metaphors for the church does not appear to be random.

Perhaps the most vulnerable point in youth ministry is continuity in discipleship relationships. Three years in junior high school with some changes in personnel each year, give way to four years in high school with more turnover among youth leaders. College or a ministry to young adults follows with even greater changes in spiritually mentoring relationships. This disruption of continuity in relationships is exaggerated even more by the mobility of families and the likelihood that the family will move beyond the sphere of influence of the church family.

The spiritual formation of youths has always been found primarily in the nurturing relationships of the family—which in turn drew from the larger faith community a shared understanding of what it meant to be the kingdom of God.

Maturity in Christian growth provides another glimpse of what should be happening in the church. While the maturing process is the responsibility of each individual believer and is often associated with personal difficulties (James 1:2–8), maturity is seldom achieved in isolation. Perhaps the clearest picture of the relationship between the faith community and the spiritual maturity of each believer is found in Ephesians 4:7–13, where the apostle Paul links the gifts given to the church with all believers becoming “mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ.”

One of the strong features of youth ministry in the last decade of the 20th century has been the determination of Christian youth leaders to identify the outcomes they feel God desires from ministry to high school students. Drawing a profile for a discipled student has helped focus many high school ministries. Gone are many of the activities designed merely to entertain youths. In their place are purpose driven activities. Discipleship is a professed value of most serious youth ministry.

Yet spiritual maturity is not something that takes place in a four-year span, especially during the high school years. The process began in childhood, even before the child learned to speak. The nurture of mother and father (or lack thereof), social exchanges with siblings (positive and negative), informal and formal communication of biblical content, and models of spirituality in the faith community (good and bad), all play a role in the spiritual maturation process both before and after youth ministry.

Even Jesus’ own disciples, after three years of following our Lord, showed very few of the characteristics that should distinguish fully devoted followers of our Lord. Only after the trauma of the crucifixion, the euphoria of the resurrection, and the ecstasy of the Spirit’s filling did the disciples suddenly show signs of maturity. Immediate persecution from their fellow Jews brought about a new continuity among the apostles (Acts 8:1–2), while other believers were scattered first throughout Judea and Samaria, and then—through the vision of the church at Antioch—throughout the Roman world (Acts 17:6).

The greatest passage on continuity in discipling relationships, however, is found following the second reading of the Law. Preparing the Israelites to enter the land they had been promised, Moses tells parents that the way to ensure that their children would remain true to Jehovah would be to talk about what Jehovah did for the Israelites throughout the normal flow of family life (Deuteronomy 6:4–9). A look at the context suggests this was to be a long-term strategy reinforced by a cycle of festivals celebrated by the nation of Israel.

While Scripture places responsibility on the individual to respond to God’s call and to the Holy Spirit’s work of sanctification, the whole purpose of Scripture is to provide instruction whereby the faith community nurtures and supports people in that process. As the African proverb declares, “It takes a village to raise a child.”

The discontinuity fallacy

At the heart of the problem faced by a youth ministry that is shaped by modernity is the fallacy of discontinuity. Adults earn the right to nurture young people and then, somewhat artificially, attempt to hand their young friends to another discipler three or four years later. The dominant philosophy of church and parachurch alike has been that the mission of student movements has been to establish or retain the Christian faith and lifestyle of a particular age group—primarily high school and college-aged people, but recently middle school students have been included in the mix as well.

Even where the primary focus of a ministry has been evangelism and discipleship (especially effective in parachurch ministries), there has been a structural restriction on continuity of relationships. Meaningful contact beyond high school was a rare exception. The span of a ministry limited the discipleship process to four years or less. Converts in campus-based ministries were expected to leave the persons most influential in their initial spiritual growth to be nurtured through existing churches.

Training union concepts of traditional youth societies were age-group specific. The approach of African-American churches has been healthier, yet limiting, in that they seek to prepare a new generation to take on leadership roles in the parent church when the young people come of age. Even the current innovative generation of youth ministry specialists find themselves restricted by the expectation that the term of their ministry will normally be four years before they hand off their students to another pastor, or cut them loose to find niches in a church that had its primary growth spurt during another generation. Organizational expectations lock them out of continuity in discipling relationships.

The net result is that the church has created an entire profession that has no choice but to ghettoize both youths and youth ministers. Expectations are more akin to baby-sitting than missiology. Youth ministers are frustrated by constant resistance to theological reflection and strategic thinking about students’ roles in the local church at the very time in life when adolescents should be adopting kingdom priorities.

Church leadership has treated youth ministers as novice adults rather than permanent parts of the church’s strategy of discipleship and world evangelization. It’s as if the church of middle-class America has been willing to pay “big kids” to play with its children. Consequently the expectation has developed that these big kids will grow up and move away, leaving behind another class of graduates who have weathered adolescence, grown in their faith, and brought a few people into the kingdom. Continuity in the nurturing process is a foreign concept.

Youth ministry as church-birthing

Perhaps the answer to the problems created by discontinuities in discipling relationships lies in a new vision of youth ministries: Youth pastors should become spiritual midwives and assist in birthing new churches. They would begin as age group specialists (they would still need some of these skills throughout their ministries) but would be chosen to work with a group of students from the time the young people entered high school until they reached their mid-20s. The primary objective would be to develop a team of spiritually mature young adults and start a new church.

Every activity of the youth group would be evaluated by its short-term impact upon students and its long-term effectiveness in preparing the volunteer staff, students, and their families to become a new church. Evangelism would be their responsibility or the infant church would not be born. Disciplines of discipleship, stewardship, eldership, prayer, social concern, and worship would rest on the shoulders of the youth pastor and emerging church leaders.

At the appropriate time the mother church would make a decision: The new church could become either a church within the mother church or a freestanding church apart from it. If the new church remains within the existing church, the youth pastor would turn over the youth ministry to another person and assume pastoral responsibility for the adult flock he has been shepherding. The test of the former youth pastor’s ministry will be in the effectiveness with which the values that were emphasized during the high school ministry years are sustained and enhanced in the church-within-the-church setting.

If the mother church elects to establish a freestanding church, then it will fund the project as a mission endeavor; and a new church would be strategically hived off. While the new church may begin by meeting in the mother church (for example on Saturday night or Sunday afternoon), within a relatively short time the new congregation would commence worship services in rented facilities in a target location. Initially the mother church would have to share the expense of the rented facility and pastor’s salary, but the church plant should rapidly move to an autonomous status. The long-term success of the venture may be tied to the securing of real estate in the new community. In most cases the mother church will have to make this commitment early in the process.

In both cases youth staff and students evangelized and discipled through the youth ministry would become the nucleus of the new church. The families of the students and former students under the youth minister’s care would be encouraged to participate with their children in the project. Though the idea has some inherent weaknesses, most of them could be minimized by careful selection of the youth minister, along with a mentoring relationship with the senior pastor. The concept would require a paradigm shift both on the part of church and within the youth ministry fraternity.

Parachurch high school and college ministries are in unique positions to become birthing midwives. The whole argument about parachurch (literally, alongside the church) versus church ministries could easily be laid to rest if the parachurch ministries targeted their efforts toward the unchurched, pioneering strategies for turning these collections of believers into socially relevant and biblically based churches. Parachurch staff members would gradually leave the campus and begin ministering to a body of believers, including a core of mature believers who served as volunteer leaders, high school converts who left for college or the workplace, and parents of those converted or discipled through the ministry.

Post-high-school fragmentation

Post-high-school fragmentation of the youth ministry will be a fatal flaw to the church-birthing process if not addressed from the very beginning. Early ownership of the project by the young people and volunteer staff will determine the long-term success. A nucleus of parents and other adults need to be early adopters of the idea. Students could be encouraged to select their college or employment based on their involvement in this ministry. For those who attend school out of the area but wish to maintain committed to the church-birthing process, the youth minister or pastor will sustain a mentoring or shepherding relationship. Some will not return; but the choice will be made consciously, not by default based exclusively on career considerations.

While it can be shown that college ministries have been relatively successful in channeling their new believers into existing churches, many times the kingdom momentum that is established during the college years dissipates as eager young believers have to accommodate themselves to the social systems and political realities of established churches. Staffers from high school ministries, by contrast, have lamented for years that students who establish a vital relationship with Jesus Christ through their ministries frequently are lost in either a local church or campus-based college ministry. When the spiritual bond between the initial discipler and the adolescent severs because the parachurch person must concentrate on a new batch of freshmen, an ecclesiological vacuum is created and spiritual accountability frequently is lost.

Even the today’s innovative generation of youth ministry specialists find themselves restricted by the expectation that the term of their ministry will normally be four years before they hand off their students to another pastor, or cut them loose to find niches in a church that had its primary growth spurt during another generation.

Many youth ministers are prepared to accept the challenge. It is time for many youth specialists to stop thinking of youth ministry as a lifetime commitment and begin viewing their youth ministry as giving birth to a biblically and culturally relevant church that will, in time, give birth to additional churches in response to the needs of future generations. Viewing themselves as strategically placed ministers of the gospel of Jesus Christ, they must re-examine the presuppositions of their callings.

Youth groups into churches: it’s been done

Though it sounds idealistic, the idea of youth groups becoming full-fledged churches has worked with startling success all over the world. From Marseille, France, to Mt. Prospect, Illinois, the strategy has established churches in postmodern cultures. In the Hindu kingdom of Nepal, a similar concept is associated with the explosive church growth that has more than tripled the size of the Nepali Christian church during the last decade of the 20th century.

Situations in Chicago, Ontario, and Brazil deserve special attention. A look at these settings might give a clue to the possible success of such strategic thinking. (It is worth pointing out, however, that only one of these youth-group-derived churches was initiated by a mother church, and none of them selected the minister of youth with this strategy in mind.)

  • Willow Creek Community Church (South Barrington, Illinois). More than two decades ago, South Park Church in Park Ridge, Illinois, hired David Hulmbo and Bill Hybels as youth pastors, who built the youth ministry to over 1,000 high schoolers. Willow Creek Community Church was launched from this youth group—perhaps the most emulated church in America during the 1990s.

    After 25 years of dynamic growth, the church is now attended by over 15,000 people on a weekly basis. Over 300 ministry staff members provide leadership for a bewildering array of ministries. The Willow Creek Association, a spinoff ministry of the church, now services 2,000 churches that share a passion for seeker-driven ministries.

  • Lawndale Community Church (Chicago). The Lawndale neighborhood on Chicago’s West Side was ravaged by rioting following the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr., and with the riots began two decades of poverty and crime. Wayne Gordon, by merely providing a weight machine for the football players at Farragut High School, gained a foothold for his ministry through Fellowship of christian Athletes. Using his contact with high school leaders, he began a Bible study that eventually became Lawndale Community Church—assisted, sadly, by the reputation of Lawndale churches, which were considered irrelevant by the community’s young people.

    Today Lawndale Community Church is a model of a holistic urban ministry. Worship services and youth ministries are complemented by a medical and dental clinic, counseling services, food and clothing resale shops, housing rehabilitation, and job referral ministries. Students from nearby Christian colleges still work with children in the community, but the church has grown far beyond its youth ministry roots.

  • Ginger Creek Community Church (Glen Ellyn, Illinois). When his Campus Life club strategy began to falter in the mid-1980s, John Henderson began Son City (now known as Student Impact), an evangelistic program modeled after the Willow Creek high school ministry. They replaced clubs with teams, led by student leaders from the area high schools. The ministry soon attracted hundreds of students.

    But the first wave of graduating seniors left a vacuum in the ministry. After failing to convince Campus Life’s leadership to drop its long-standing prohibition of CL staffers starting churches (even though at this time the president of the national organization was a preaching pastor for a church only a few miles away from Glen Ellyn), Henderson left to found Ginger Creek Community Church. Today the church is attended by close to 700 worshipers on a Sunday morning.

  • Arlington Heights (Illinois) Evangelical Free Church. In this instance of youth-group-become-church, a mother church did some strategic planning, recognizing that its own growth potential was limited. John Sheaffer, their minister to youth, was asked to create a new church. So he led a church-planting seminar as one of the normal Sunday evening training sessions. Task force leaders were then chosen, and the resulting groups used the church’s facilities. Among the core leadership of the new church were students, leaders, and friends Sheaffer had influenced during his five-year tenure in ministry to high school students. Out of this deliberate planning and ground preparation was born Grace Community Church, in September 1992.
  • Hamilton, Ontario, Canada. Early in 1992 six Baptist pastors here began discussing how they could cooperate in ministry to youth in the area. The largest of the churches was 150 in attendance; most ranged between 60 and 80. David Overholt was asked to create a cooperative outreach ministry, and the plan was to disciple new believers into the churches. In its first year the Hamilton Mountain Youth Mission grew to around 70 kids—large by Canadian standards. By the fall of 1994 over 500 young people were attending the Sunday night gatherings. When they realized that the new believers were not interested in attending unfamiliar churches. Overholt got the blessing of the supporting churches to begin a worship gathering called The Alternative that met one Sunday evening a month.

    Next came the inevitable suggestion: Why not expand the Youth Mission into a church? Overholt, the six pastors, 12 couples, and some of the students spent a year praying about this possibility. In January 1997 another youth ministry genesis church was launched, with over 500 people attending the worship-evangelism service.

  • Brazil. Young Life in this South American country experienced a similar phenomenon. Hal Merwold, now director of Young Life Canada, reports that after he resigned from a similar post in Brazil, the decision was made to create communities of former Young Lifers who would meet together on a regular basis. Though technically they were like alumni Campaigner Clubs, in effect these were churches—led by people who had no formal theological training, but who had been developed by the informal training process of the parachurch organization. These communities are thriving today. Peru vian Young Life and the Navigator ministry in Brazil have followed a similar strategy, with corresponding success. In effect, the Brazilian strategy is a systematic approach to youth ministry genesis churches.
  • It is time to stop thinking of youth ministry as a lifetime commitment, and begin viewing youth ministry as giving birth to a biblically and culturally relevant church that will, in time, give birth to additional churches in response to the needs of future generations.

    Compatible with Scripture?

    The fact that churches have spawned from youth groups does not mean that the strategy is necessarily a biblical idea or pattern that can be duplicated by other Christian leaders. Though it is tempting to conclude that Christ’s disciples were the first youth group and the apostles were the first church planters, youth ministry is a phenomenon that is a product of the late 18th and 19th centuries. Like the Sunday school, faith missions, and church choirs, youth ministry is a response to changes in culture that must be judged by its compatibility with Scripture, rather than by its specific mandate from the pages of holy writ.

    Leaders who match the qualifications of elders (1 Timothy 3; Titus 2) and are empowered by appropriate spiritual gifts (1 Corinthians 12–14; Ephesians 4) should be the first consideration of the church-birthing youth ministry concept. If the church plans for the youth minister to become a pastor, the selection of that youth pastor will have to be done with an added degree of seriousness. To have a person with a superficial knowledge of the Bible and a great rapport with young people can no longer be an adequate standard for the selection of youth pastor. It should never have been appropriate in the first place.

    To this point, most of the youth ministry genesis pastors are self-taught individuals who have become lifelong learners of God’s Word. They read widely and are close to people who have formal theological training. Willow Creek Community Church has even gone so far as to link with some of the leading evangelical seminaries in an attempt to combine the entrepreneurial instincts and theological insights for many of their training events for an emerging generation of pastors.

    Intentional, in-ministry theological training for youth pastors will become a key to the long-term effectiveness of youth ministry genesis pastors. One of the benefits of seminary training is the accountability students have for mastering a broad curriculum that provides rootedness in biblical and theological perspectives. If the emerging pastor does not have the benefit of that training, the mother church or campus ministry has the responsibility to provide the opportunity and hold the young pastor accountable for developing the ability to think and act Christianly.

    A second concern is the generational issue. Israel in both the Old Testament and the New Testament church gave great honor to the wisdom of elders (1 Kings 12:6–14; 1 Timothy 5:19). The danger of the youth group genesis church is that it may be limited to people who are the about the same age as the youth pastor and younger. A commitment to eldership may be defined as mentoring functions that take place when a person mellowed by age in his walk with God offers insight and accountability to the creativity of youths.

    Like Sunday school, faith missions, and church choirs, youth ministry is a response to changes in culture that must be judged by its compatibility with Scripture, rather than by its specific mandate from the pages of holy writ.

    While Willow Creek’s Bill Hybels had his mentor in Dr. Bilezikian, John Sheaffer was accountable to the board of Arlington Heights Evangelical Free Church as the new church was being formed. David Overholt’s church in Ontario began with nearly 20 percent of the congregation aged 26 and older, and many of these were in their 40s. Clearly, the youth-group-genesis-church vision needs the exchange of ideas between generations, in order to accurately determine the leading of God.

    The youth pastor must choose people of different ages to work as youth sponsors and seek the counsel of spiritually mature parents as he goes about the early stages of ministry so that when the new church emerges, generational diversity will be an established component. When combined with accountability to the leadership of the mother church, the generational factor will become a nonissue.

    Strategic thinking

    Why create new churches? After all, isn’t the future of the church found in larger, full-service churches rather than in a host of smaller ones? Or could the metachurch be the answer to church growth at the beginning of the 21st century? Still more radical is the call for area-wide networks of cell churches that take responsibility for multiplying every six months.

    While none of these ideas are necessarily in conflict with the youth-group-genesis-church idea, there is one factor that should provide perspective on church growth. Most of the creativity and dynamic growth of a new movement takes place in the first 15 to 20 years of its existence. This is followed by 20 to 25 years of less spectacular growth while the movement changes leadership or solidifies the model under which it operates before entering a period of redefinition and even decline.

    A look at such movements as the Student Volunteer Movement, Society for Christian Endeavor, InterVarsity Christian Fellowship, Campus Crusade for Christ, Young Life, and Youth for Christ suggests this same general pattern in the United States. At the same time, it would appear that new church movements such as Calvary Chapel, Vineyard Fellowship, and possibly Willow Creek Community Church may conform to a similar pattern.

    Church growth specialists track an initial eight-year burst of growth for new churches before the growth curve flattens out. If the original growth does not catapult the church past the 250 attendance mark, the church may spend a majority of its lifetime flirting with the same attendance barrier.

    Where a new church comes into existence with momentum generated by several years of evangelism and discipleship under a respected leader, the prospects of continued growth and impact are greatly enhanced. Youth pastors who view their youth ministries as strategic opportunities for long-term kingdom influence have the potential for shaping a new generation of culturally relevant and theologically significant churches.

    The strategy for the youth group genesis church may be one of the best disciplines for a local church to retain a commitment to local evangelism and church growth from generation to generation. While the philosophy of growth may cause some difficulties for the mother church as groups are periodically hived off, the circumstances under which the church split takes place should create a healthy climate in which numbers will be regenerated.

    Objections to Youth Ministry as Church Planting

    The very concept of youth ministry as church planting is not without its detractors. Objections frequently assist the discussion to a more realistic and biblically sound set of conclusions. While other reservations might be raised, the following four provide useful clarifications.

    Edifice argument/Club argument

    If we siphon off the future leadership of our church, who will be around to maintain the edifice or club? While the argument is in part a case for continuity in the local church, it comes laden with subbiblical assumptions.

    The faith community in the New Testament was never identified as a physical building or edifice. Christians are described as the building. Cathedrals, while majestic places to worship, were never the “church.” Today most serve more as museums than organisms that Scripture calls the church. Protestant church buildings followed in the tradition of the cathedral, shifting the focus of most people to the permanence of architecture rather than on the flexibility of believers. In some ways the Old Testament tabernacle is a better metaphor for the church. It was as mobile as the Bedouin Israelite nation.

    The argument could be made that the Lord allowed persecution to befall the first-century church (Acts 8:1) in order to break the church in Jerusalem out of its close identification with the land (in other words her edifice or club mentality). The fellowship (koinonia) of the Holy Spirit, by contrast, characterized the clusters of believers as they scattered throughout the world (2 Corinthians 13:14). The Jerusalem club had to be fractured for the Good News to spread.

    Another subbiblical assumption presumes a sociological basis for church growth. A successful youth ministry will attract new families to attend church and maintain current members. To lose a generation of emerging leaders is to strike the death knell of the church. Unfortunately, much of their expected church increase finds its base in biological or transfer growth. Evangelism that brings new believers of all ages into the fellowship is not factored into the expectations of the local church.

    Parachurch argument

    If we begin planting churches, other churches will see us competition and our support base will dry up. Though functioning outside of an ecclesiological structure, paraparochial ministries see themselves as being alongside the local church, and their financial support is drawn from local churches and Christian families.

    Most youth ministries aim to bond youths to a local church after winning them to Christ—a goal that churches applaud, though it’s more often missed than hit. Yet if a youth ministry wanted to increase their odds of success by themselves spawning a church, some churches would cry foul and financial support for the youth ministry would likely dry up. One wonders if such short-sighted churches would rather have the paraparochial agency fail in their mission of grounding new converts in the faith community than allow what they see as competition with their church’s ministry.

    Caught in this no-win situation, parachurch ministries have usually taken the path of least resistance. Church partnerships in some communities help complete their mission. For the most part, however, they continue an effective ministry as youth culture specialists and only occasionally attempt to ensure that new converts are adopted by local church families.

    Profession argument

    By the time youth ministers get to the point where they can be effective professionals, they will begin pulling out of youth ministry and heading into a senior pastor role. It is a new version of the old stepping-stone-to-the-ministry philosophy.

    The Strategic approach to youth ministry is a far cry from the stepping-stone approach. Strategic youth pastors are passionate about ministering to youths—so passionate that they want to extend the ministry far beyond adolescence. The youth minister who uses the stepping-stone approach, by contrast, has little passion for young people and merely puts in time with youths until a “real ministry” becomes available.

    Statistics gathered from a variety of sources suggest that few youth ministry professionals exceed the proposed amount of time in a local church that is required in this church-birthing proposal. In fact, in many cases a strategic vision might motivate youth ministers who are on the verge of leaving the field to remain in their position with passion and effectiveness for a longer period of time.

    The proposal, if commonly adopted, would redefine the youth ministry profession. Colleges and seminaries would need to rethink the career path of youth workers. While there are enough second-and third-decade youth ministers in primary youth ministry to validate the specialization, the vast majority of people who trained as youth ministers have left local church or parachurch club ministry in favor of some other form of livelihood. The absence of a career path in youth ministry leaves many gifted people outside the field at the very time they should be reaching the peak of their effectiveness in their mid-30s. The idea of youth ministry being a church-birthing process provides a career path and may even attract a new type of gifted person to a youth ministry career.

    Gender argument

    If youth ministry is for people who anticipate becoming preaching pastors, the playing field may be significantly altered for women, particularly in evangelical churches and denominations. It is a subtle way of further restricting the ministry of women in the church.

    In churches where the pulpit is a forbidden domain for women, it is true: the church-birthing philosophy will further restrict the availability of youth ministry positions to women. The reality of the situation in those churches is that youth ministry is already out of bounds for women, no matter how gifted they are.

    The church-birthing proposal should open more doors for pastoral leadership to women in churches where pastoral polity is less restrictive. In churches where a woman is a youth minister, she has the opportunity to shape a new church with an egalitarian philosophy of ministry. The church leadership of the mother church, by calling her to the role of youth minister, has authorized her to become a church planter and thus shape the ministry in a fashion that honors spiritual giftedness in both men and women.

    Women in parachurch ministries have an even greater opportunity. They are already doing the work of an evangelist. Most are already providing the primary spiritual nurture for new converts. From there it is but a small step to become the pastor of an ongoing fellowship of believers. Because many of her parishioners have not been exposed to churches that limit the leadership of women, the traditional bias may not be present.

    The idea of youth ministry being a church-birthing process provides a career path for professional youth ministers, and may even attract a new type of gifted person to a youth ministry career.

    Implications for the youth program

    A fear that many youth ministers face as they consider the implications of treating youth ministry as a strategy for church planting is the possibility that youth ministry will become boring, predictable, and tradition bound. Worse still, youth ministry might lose its relevance to the young people. The possibility of creativity, flexibility, innovation, and cultural relevance attracts many of the brightest young leaders to the field of youth ministry.

    To put it another way, if the church planting idea means conforming youth ministry to the expectations of another generation of church leaders, most of the brightest and best youth leaders would reject the idea immediately. Frankly, that is exactly what they should do. The church planting strategy is not about making youth ministry boring but about making a new church as relevant and vibrant as current approaches to youth ministry.

    When Dann Spader gave birth to Sonlife Ministries, he envisioned hundreds of model youth ministries as training centers across the nation. By the end of the first decade of training seminars, Spader discovered that there was a lid on his dream. The vast majority of the churches he was dealing with were not healthy. Their spiritual vital signs of the churches were nowhere as healthy as the youth ministries they promoted.

    Growing a Healthy Church was Spader’s initial response to what he considered to be unhealthy patterns of church life.11 By 1998, seminars based on the book attracted 11,000 church leaders. Spader’s intent was not to dumb to down the youth ministry, but to refocus the energies of Christian churches.

    The brief history of youth ministry-based church planting draws the same conclusions as Spader. Churches can only be birthed from youth ministries when youth ministries show intense relevance to the needs of local youths and a profound conviction that the answer is found in the Christian gospel, as communicated through the redemptive story line in the Bible. Cutting edge relevance to the spiritual needs experienced by people of all ages provides the basis for an ecclesiology upon which a new church can be built.

    Four elements central to youth ministry establish a framework for youth-ministry-genesis-church planting. Before a new church can be birthed, these must be a normal part of a youth ministry.12

  • Contact. Youth ministry begins when a Christian adult finds a comfortable way to enter a student’s world.13 Healthy youth ministries find creative ways to reach beyond the children of the church and establish meaningful relationships with spiritually sensitive youths in their high schools and communities. Youth leaders and students develop a Great Commission mindset. For a church to be planted and thrive as those cited above, the youth minister and the discipled leadership will bring these gifts and resulting skills into the emerging church.
  • Attract. While the right to be heard by a young person is based on a relationship, time and energy limits even the best of youth ministers from building significant relationships with more than about 30 young people. Some type of ministry activity must be created that appeals to wider circles of young people and within which other Christian connectedness might be built. Some call this a ministry strategy; others call it a purpose driven program. Either way the ministry vehicle is used to attract and sustain relationships with spiritually seeking youths.

    As a church is birthed from youth ministry, attractiveness to spiritually open adults becomes a key to bringing about conversion growth and not just biological or transfer growth. Public services may be the attraction to seekers. What is more likely in a postmodern age, however, is that people will be attracted to spiritually sensitive people they encounter in settings designed to meet their felt needs.

  • As a church is birthed from youth ministry, attractiveness to spiritually open adults becomes a key to bringing about conversion growth and not just biological or transfer growth.

  • Confront. There may have been a time when young people knew that the love exhibited by youth leaders was the love of Jesus Christ. The general framework of the gospel of Jesus Christ was fairly well known. Yet even then someone needed to explain the four spiritual laws or Romans Road before a repentance and conversion changed the eternal destiny of a young person. Youth ministries that merely attract young people but fail to confront them with the Christian gospel are not candidates for establishing churches. At the heart of most youth ministry genesis churches is a clear pattern of evangelization. Young people have been so steeped in introducing peers and family members to the gospel that the new church merely provides an intergenerational opportunity to do what they are already accustomed to doing.
  • Retain/Train. The final element essential to youth ministry and required for church planting is a conscious system of shepherding and educating people who have been brought into the ministry. Shepherding is a conscious system of making sure each young person is present or accounted for. When a ministry consists of fewer than 30 students, the shepherding process happens nearly spontaneously. Someone in the group knows when a person is missing. The larger a ministry becomes, the easier it is for a person to slip through the slats without being missed. Youth ministries have learned the value of planned accountability.

    The training aspect of the discipleship process is equally vital. No longer can it be assumed that young people have gained a knowledge of the Bible in their homes. In fact, it is not even a safe assumption that young people have gained much of a grasp of the Christian story line from creation to the final triumph of Christ in their Sunday schools or church education programs. Youth ministries that are potential church plants develop ways of assisting students to grasp the profound implications of the gospel.

  • Based on successful patterns of discipleship (shepherding and training), youth ministry genesis churches build patterns of spiritual nurture into the philosophy and strategy of the newly formed church. Without such a framework in youth ministry, the newly formed church has every possibility of reverting to older models of discipleship, which may have worked when the community shared a Christian consensus, but fails to have the same impact on a culture in which the Christian gospel is but a distorted memory.

    Changes Required in the Church

    Church leaders in the 20th century have viewed youth ministry as much for its problems as for its potential. Frank Otis Erb, writing in 1917, cites criticism of youth ministry that saw Christian Endeavor and its denominational counterparts as being “without scriptural authority and usurping the place of the church, which alone had divine authority.”

    It was greatly feared that [youth work] would divide the church on the basis of age, and supplant the church in the affection of the young. It was declared by many that it interfered seriously with other church meetings, particularly the Sunday evening preaching service, usually evangelistic, and the midweek prayer-meeting. Many feared that [Christian Endeavor] would divert the young people’s money from denominational channels, and would lead to haphazard giving and a lack of interest in the causes to which the church and denomination were pledged.14

    More visionary pastors viewed youth ministry as mere preparation for future leadership. “In other words, the real tasks of the church [were] being performed by deacons, elders, and such persons, but young people up to, say, 30, [were] engaged in a sort of play by which they [would] be fitted for genuine work later on…[T]he only churches and pastors who have regarded the young people as fit for a great task here and now are those that make much of evangelistic effort.”15

    If there was any changing that needed to be done for young people to be full participants in local churches, it would be the young people who would have to change. Youth societies became holding tanks where youthful zeal could be channeled into harmless activities. Developing skills in churchmanship overshadowed the professed desires of pastors for evangelism, character development, and Christian service. The explosive power of youthful Christian idealism wasted away in a series of youth society meetings and related committee assignments. Churches, both liberal and conservative, settled into an uneasy slide toward religion more defined by a social agenda than by the power of God.16

    Little changed in the attitude of church leaders during the remainder of the 20th century. While youth societies became youth ministries and evangelism leading to discipleship became the norm for many church-based youth ministries, adults in the church continued to pursue their privatized twin quest of personal peace and affluence.17 Youth ministry, in many churches, leads the way in attempting to live in harmony with a theological agenda while the adult congregants resist the call of such prophetic voices as C. S. Lewis and Charles Colson to “please God more than the culture and community in which we spend these few, short years.”18

    A premise of the Strategic approach to youth ministry is that the best manner to renew the church is through systematically establishing new churches based in an evangelistic vision, a profound submission to the Word of God, and the power of God’s Spirit in the contemporary world. When carefully nurtured and led, youth ministry has the greatest potential for becoming the seed bed for a strategy of church planting.

    If the Strategic approach to youth ministry is to be embraced by a local church, it is adult congregants who must change far more than purpose-driven youth ministries wherever they may be found.19 Four specific changes in adult leadership perspectives are essential.

  • Young people must be seen as people who are shaping the church and being shaped by it. Change in worship forms will reflect the tastes of all ages in healthy tension. Fel low-ship activities will promote both collective and age group exclusive experiences but neither to the detriment of the other. Issues shaped by compassion and a sacrificial lifestyle will drive the agenda of the entire faith community. The spiritual gifts of young people will be used whenever and wherever appropriate.
  • Youth pastors must be viewed as pastors. Selection and development of youth pastors will be based on spiritual leadership skills and gifts, rather than personality. Knowledge of biblical and theological content will be expected from youth pastors as they address the issues of the day. A rigorous process leading to licensure or ordination will be expected of youth pastors designated to strategically establish new churches.
  • Young people must lead in mission efforts. Both local and cross-cultural efforts will find young people in the forefront of vision casting and personal witness. The biblical idealism of youths will be honored as church priorities shape church budgets. Risks will be taken by parents of youths that will ensure that the church reaches beyond its safety zone into the full diversity of communities in which they live.
  • Adult congregations, like parents, must prefer to sacrifice their own lives so that the next generation might live and grow. The spiritual growth, development, and multiplication of the faith community will take precedence over maintenance of facilities and traditions. Biblical values will balance the needs of the parent church with the autonomy of daughter churches. Strategic decisions, driven by evangelism and Christian discipleship, will govern the priorities of the worshiping community.
  • Conclusion

    Perhaps Roger was right in his conversation with Sheila. When he claimed that more people would remain active if they started a new church (because they would have a greater ownership in what the church is and what it does), he may have identified a central challenge for the faith community. Who owns the church?

    The Scripture makes clear that Jesus Christ is the head of the church. Ownership flows from him. The Strategic approach to youth ministry attempts to balance the sense of ownership that flows from the Head to include the church of the future as it emerges today. Rather than fragmenting the church into age group enclaves of koinonia, and passing students along to spiritual leaders with whom they have little affinity or relationship, the church should “make every effort to keep the unity of the Spirit through the bond of peace” (Ephesians 4:3). This time, it may be the youths of the church who become the instruments of God, “speaking the truth in love [so that] we will grow up into him who is the Head, that is, Christ. From him the whole body, joined and held together by every supporting ligament grows and builds itself up in love, as each part does its work” (Ephesians 4:15–16).

    Notes

    1. Pete Ward, God at the Mall (Peabody, Massachusetts: Hendrickson, 1999), 137.

    2. For this and other reasons, Willow Creek Community Church discontinued the competition-based strategy in the fall of 1998.

    3. The community-building benefits of a one-room schoolhouse type of education might be available if the teacher could guide students in utilizing an online curriculum, while older students mentored younger students in a form of mastery learning.

    4. This includes only people who had contact with a specific group of adolescents throughout the year. It excludes people employed in such worthy ministries as Christian camping, who by all rights are doing youth ministry.

    5. Young Life Field Ministry Staff Statistics, September 30, 1998.

    6. Fellowship of Christian Athletes, Data 1992-Present, December 10, 1998.

    7. Youth for Christ Web site (www.gospelcom.net/yfc), October 16, 1999.

    8. 1998: The Year in Review, Sonlife Board of Directors Annual Report.

    9. Lawrence O. Richards, A Theology of Children’s Ministry (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1983), 18. See also Charles R. Foster, “The Faith Community as a Guiding Image for Christian Education,” Contemporary Approaches to Christian Education (Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1982), 53–71.

    10. Jimmy Long, Generating Hope (Downers Grove: InterVarsity Press, 1997), 133.

    11. Dann Spader and Gary Mayes, Growing a Healthy Church (Chicago: Moody Press, 1991).

    12. These are developed more fully in my article, “Emerging Patterns of Youth Ministry at the End of the Twentieth Century,” in Relational Youthwork (1995): 107–131. See also Richard R. Dunn and Mark H. Senter III, eds., Reaching a Generation for Christ (Chicago: Moody Press, 1997), 105–117.

    13. Richard R. Dunn and Mark H. Senter III, eds., Reaching a Generation for Christ (Chicago: Moody Press, 1997), 123. David R. Veerman, Youth Evangelism (Wheaton: Victor, 1988), 61–74. Barry St. Clair and Keith Naylor, Penetrating the Campus (Wheaton: Victor, 1993), 101–116.

    14. Frank Otis Erb, The Development of the Young People’s Movement (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1917), 59.

    15. Erb, 107–108.

    16. Mark H. Senter III, “Where We’ve Come From (and Where We Need to Go),” Youthworker (January/February 2000), 48–52.

    17. Francis Schaeffer, How Should We Then Live? (Grand Rapids: Revell, 1976), 205.

    18. Charles Colson, The Body (Nashville: Word, 1992), 37. See also C. S. Lewis, The Screwtape Letters (New York: Macmillan, 1943), 15–19.

    19. “Purpose-driven” is used to include all youth ministries that share an evangelism/discipleship agenda as opposed to an entertainment/program format.

    References

    Colson, Charles. The Body. Nashville: Word, 1992.

    Dunn, Richard, and Mark Senter, eds. “Looking Ahead to the Next Millennium,” in Reaching a Generation for Christ. Chicago: Moody Press, 1997.

    Grudem, Wayne. Systematic Theology. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1994.

    Rice, Wayne, and others. New Directions for Youth Ministry. Loveland, Colorado: Group Publishing, 1998.

    Schaeffer, Francis. The Church at the End of the Twentieth Century. Downers Grove, Illinois: InterVarsity Press, 1970.

    Senter, Mark H., III. “In Consideration of Youth Churches,” Youthworker (September/October 1997):28–33.

    image. “Where We’ve Come From (and Where We Need to Go),” Youthworker (January/February 2000): 48–52.

    Spader, Dann and Gary Mayes. Growing a Healthy Church. Chicago: Moody Press, 1991.

    Sweet, Leonard. Aqua Church: Essential Leadership Arts for Piloting Your Church in Today’s Fluid Culture. Loveland, Colorado: Group Publishing, 1999.

    Ward, Pete, ed. The Church and Youth Ministry. Lynx, 1995.

    Ward, Pete. God at the Mall. Peabody, Massachusetts: Hendrickson, 1999.

    image. Relational Youthwork. Lynx, 1995.

    Zoba, Wendy Murray. “The Class of ‘00.” Christianity Today (3 February 1997), 18.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑