Chapter 3 of 27

Of Churches, Youth Groups, and Spiritual Readiness: The Context of the Debate Mark H. Senter III

Of Churches, Youth Groups, and Spiritual Readiness: The Context of the Debate Mark H. Senter III

Of Churches, Youth Groups, and Spiritual Readiness:

The Context of the Debate

High school football games were wonderful venues to do relational youth ministry. Half the kids there had absolutely no interest in football. “Just here to see my friends,” they often said. Even though I would have preferred to watch the game, I could hang out by the concession stand and talk to a cross section of high school students as they drifted by me. It was also a natural place to meet parents, faculty, and school administrators.

The Saturday afternoon gathering at Ost Field was a ministry opportunity made to order. Kids expected adults to show up in this part of their world. Because they were comfortable with us, introductions to their friends seemed natural. Contacts that started near the concession stand led to conversations in the halls of Palatine High School, at McDonalds, on the phone, at a Young Life club, and occasionally while standing in the narthex at Arlington Heights Evangelical Free Church.

As the stadium emptied, two youth ministers stood on the torn sod of the gridiron, reflecting on their conversations of the afternoon. Cliff Anderson, the former math teacher, had found his niche as a Young Life staffer at the high school where he used to teach. I served as youth pastor in a nearby church. Two distinctly different starting points, one common passion.

“My problem,” I confessed, “is that I cannot find enough football-game-type situations for me and my staff to establish significant relationships with non-Christian kids.”

“And my problem,” responded Cliff without missing a beat, “is that I cannot find churches where my club kids feel welcome enough to attend on a regular basis, even after they return from camp.” For my Young Life colleague, camp was frequently a spiritual watershed which should have resulted in new believers flowing into churches in their home communities.

Meanwhile back at the church

A few years later a large church in the Sun Belt asked me to serve as their minister to youth. Professionally it looked like a great opportunity. Ruth and I were treated royally when we candidated there. The ministry opportunities appeared endless. Resources were plentiful. Their tradition of youth ministry was well established.

But there was something missing.

I returned home and agonized over a decision for weeks. I could not put my finger on the missing piece, but it wasn’t fair to either my church or the Sun Belt church to drag my decision out any longer. And it was during a mile-and-a-half walk one Sunday evening, in quiet and in prayer, that the missing piece became brilliantly clear. This nationally known church did not see young people as a vital part of the church. Unless, of course, I could condition some very bright young people to sit passively and be entertained by professionally crafted worship services. What they were looking for was an in-house parachurch agency. Their invitation was based on a flawed doctrine of the church.

Youth culture and church culture

The Ost Field discourse and that Sunday night walk framed two tensions in the discussion of youth ministry and the church. Both involve a clash of cultures. How can youth ministry respond both to the youth culture and culture of the church? How can young people be vitally connected to the church both now and in the future?

For many church members the first issue revolves around lifestyle. Young believers bring with them the baggage of their prefaith lives. Language, dress, tastes in entertainment, humor, relationships between the sexes, possible use of tobacco and drugs—all these wave red flags to the godly people of the church who are convinced that the faith community must strive for biblical norms in every aspect of life.

By contrast, adolescent believers—especially recent converts—find the church culture to be a foreign land. Language, customs, rites, heritage, musical styles—even intergenerational awkwardness—create barriers that discourage all but occasional forays into the foreignness of the adult church.

Issues related to maturity and life stages define the second question. At what age should young people be considered ready for baptism? For full membership? For leadership positions? What criteria should be used to determine the readiness of a young person to teach or preach? To evangelize? To make decisions that will affect age groups other than their own?

But are the questions of the relationship between youth ministry and the church based in sociology and developmentalism? Yes, partly. Yet the issues are far more complex. Solving the sociological problem may be possible only when more complicated missiological and theological questions about the nature of the church are resolved

What is the church?

An architectural structure or a group of worshipers? A denomination or a local fellowship of Christian believers? Is its focus primarily on community, mission, or worship? Does the church require people in leadership to be ordained by prescribed formal procedures, or does it informally recognize believers whose Christian lives have been shaped in the course of ministry? Is there such a thing as a parachurch ministry or are all ministries an expression of the church? Must the church be intergenerational or could it be age-group specific?

Unlike the development of most Christian teachings, the doctrine of the church has never received the kind of attention and debate that could result in a clear definition and explanation of the nature of the church. Millard Erickson comments:

At the first assembly of the World Council of Churches in Amsterdam in 1948, Father George Florovsky claimed that the doctrine of the church had hardly passed its pre-theological phase. By contrast, Christology and the doctrine of the Trinity had been given special attention in the fourth and fifth centuries, as had the atoning work of Christ in the Middle Ages, and the doctrine of salvation in the sixteenth century. But such concerted attention has never been turned to the church.1

Youth ministry is filled with pretheological ecclesiology. From its beginning in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, youth ministry has had an inside-out and outside-in relationship to the church. Usually nonordained Christians went out to the young people in an effort to bring them to faith in Jesus Christ. The Sunday school, YMCA, Youth for Christ, and Young Life movements were all inside-out ministries, at least in their beginning stages. Where Christian faith was closely associated with church attendance, the outside-in progression was assumed, and oftentimes freshly converted adolescent believers found a home in the church. De facto sociology linked with a pretheology of the church allowed youth movements to flourish while simultaneously sowing seeds of confusion as to where mission ended and church began.

Local or universal?

One reason youth ministers find it difficult to forge an ecclesiology of youth ministry is because in the New Testament the word church is applied to situations ranging from small groups or house churches (Romans 16:5; 1 Corinthians 16:19), to all of the believers in an entire city (1 Corinthians 1:2; 1 Thessalonians 1:1), to the Christians throughout an entire region (Acts 9:31), and beyond that to the universal church, all followers of Christ from all nations and all generations (Hebrews 12:23).

This is further complicated by nonbelievers’ attendance. While Roman Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant understandings of the nature of the church differ, all would agree that not everyone who is physically present at a worship service is considered to be a true member of the church. There are sheep and there are goats (Matthew 25:31–46). There is wheat and there are weeds (Matthew 13:24–30). While the Heavenly Father knows the difference between the faith community and the world, pastors and youth ministers have a difficult time distinguishing between them and in the end they must rely on their Spirit-led perceptions as to which is which.

In some cases unbelief is found among adult participants, leaving the believing youths of the church to serve as witnesses of faith. Of course the opposite is true as well, where the adults must pass the faith to the younger generation.

What is worship?

Most church leaders will agree to a threefold to sixfold purpose of the church. For the purposes of this book, the authors have followed Wayne Grudem’s description of purposes: ministry to God, ministry to believers, and ministry to the world.2

Ultimately the church is a worshiping community. The chief end of man, says the Westminster Shorter Catechism, is to “glorify God and enjoy him forever.” While participation in church will satisfy many human needs, the ultimate purpose of the faith community is to lift people’s eyes from their human condition and fix them on the Creator-Redeemer.

In order to be a healthy part of the church, youth ministry needs to facilitate all three purposes among the adolescents of the body of Christ. Teaching and fellowship have traditionally taken precedence in church-based ministries, while evangelism and fellowship activities dominated parachurch youth ministries. In recent years, however, more time has been designated for worship in both contexts, where worship has become synonymous with praise songs and prayer. Yet the question must be raised: is this what God intended worship to be?

A century of resistance

Unfortunately, church leaders throughout the 20th century resisted allowing their young people to become full participants in accomplishing the purposes of the church. Writing in 1917, Frank Otis Erb cites criticism of the Christian Endeavor movement, stating that its denominational counterparts were “without scriptural authority and usurping the place of the church, which alone had divine authority.”

It was greatly feared that [youth work] would divide the church on the basis of age, and supplant the church in the affection of the young. It was declared by many that it interfered seriously with other church meetings, particularly the Sunday evening preaching service, usually evangelistic, and the midweek prayer meeting. Many feared that [Christian Endeavor] would divert the young people’s money from denominational channels and would lead to haphazard giving and a lack of interest in the causes to which the church and denomination were pledged.3

What fearful church leaders failed to realize was that an age-related division had already taken place in the church. Attempts by Francis Clark, founder of Christian Endeavor, and his denominational counterparts were simply a rearguard action. An 1875 Supreme Court decision to allow public tax dollars to fund high school education laid the groundwork for what would become known as the youth culture. By 1920 a third of the population between the ages of 14 and 17 gathered daily in the high schools of America.4 The church had no choice but to respond to this dramatic social change.

Churches should have seen the explosive potential that young people brought to the body of Christ. During the previous 26 years (1886–1912), college students involved in the student volunteer movement provided a dramatic corrective to the spiritual apathy of church leaders in America and the United Kingdom, sending 7,265 volunteers into foreign missionary service and profoundly influencing American church life.5

Church leaders viewed youth ministry as mere preparation for future leadership. Youth societies became holding tanks where youthful zeal could be channeled into harmless activities. Developing skills in churchmanship overshadowed the professed desires of pastors for evangelism, character development, and Christian service. The explosive power of youthful Christian idealism wasted away in a series of youth society meetings and related committee assignments. Churches, both liberal and conservative, settled into an uneasy slide toward religion defined by a social agenda rather than by the power of God. If young people were to become full participants in local churches, then the young people would have to change.

Twice during the middle of the 20th century, youths led concerted efforts to break free of the stranglehold of church polity and tradition. The Youth for Christ movement, peaking in the mid-1940s, introduced musical and preaching styles reflective of the popular culture as heard on the radio. Evangelism of youths and soon adults catalyzed many churches to embrace innovations in worship services. Yet local church youth ministries remained muted in their harmless renditions of “Christ for Me.”

The Jesus movement provided a similar effect toward the end of the 1960s. Christian music adapted from the protests of an alienated generation and forms of communication shaped by television temporarily jolted congregations out of their systems of doing church. Youthful congregations shaped new church movements, leaving the existing churches to maintain a liturgy and style of evangelism relevant only to older generations, while their youth groups sang “Kumbaya.”

Assumptions made by church leaders about the two mid-century youth ministry explosions mimicked the presumptions of church fathers at the beginning of the century. Youth ministry was a force to be contained, not an energy to be released. What God did in the lives of young people resembled a developmental stage rather than a flowing of the Spirit. Youth pastors were free to do anything they wished as long as the real church remained unaffected. Discipleship was good for young people but a bit much to expect from the older generation. Evangelism, for the most part, remained safely contained within cultural and architectural walls.

Addressing the problem

Youth workers’ frustration with the absence of spiritual vitality and ministry flexibility in the church surfaced more frequently as the century progressed. Youth ministers found themselves confronted with a problem that would seem ridiculous if it were not so universally true. The church was simply not prepared to handle young people who were committed to evangelism, discipleship, and worship—at least not in a manner that would express the diversity of the body of Christ.

Former Young Life personnel became so baffled by the inability of local churches to reach politicians and world leaders with the gospel that a group of them formed a nonchurch called “the fellowship” in order to reach and disciple people for whom identification with a local church was a barrier to becoming a follower of Jesus Christ. A former presidential aide came to faith in Christ through the incarnational witness of people associated with the fellowship. Then after years of significant ministry with Prison Fellowship, which he founded, Charles Colson wrote The Body, a book calling for the church to move people to commitment and sacrifice in the name of Jesus Christ.6 Though Colson was never in youth ministry, his book identifies many of the obstacles youth ministers face in dealing with the church.

Larry Richards and Dann Spader attacked the “church problem” from a context of youth ministry. Richards, whose Youth Ministry was a basic text for college and seminary programs in the 1970s, also wrote A New Face for the Church as a means of expressing what church should be like after one graduated from high school.7 More recently, Spader found pastors and church leaders so receptive to his Sonlife principles of youth ministry that he wrote Growing a Healthy Church and shortly thereafter began offering training that, in effect, helps churches become as biblically grounded as their youth ministries.8

In The Coming Revolution in Youth Ministry, I identified 10 megatrends of the coming revolution.9 To date, most appear to be on target. “Resistance from the church” was the one negative trend I projected; unfortunately, like the others, it is coming true, yet in a far more subtle way than I envisioned. The resistance is not to youth ministry outside of the church—in youth centers and recreation rooms, at camps, concerts, and retreats. The opposition focuses on young people who expect to bring their idealistic, faith-driven, feeling-responsive, obedience-oriented Christian walk into the homes and churches of professed followers of Jesus Christ.

Fellowship or mission?

One core issue in the discussion of youth ministry and the church is an examination of the relationship between fellowship and missiology. The relationships of community to evangelism, of intergenerational to age-group-specific ministries, and of heterogeneous to homogeneous groupings of young people all create challenges in our understanding of youth ministry and the church.

The conversation is not new. Missiologist George W. Peters framed the discussion as centrifugal versus centripetal approaches to mission. Centripetal efforts draw momentum towards a central point (in other words, the church), while centrifugal strategies spin energy toward the periphery (or the nonchurch). Traditionally, church-based youth ministry has paid attention primarily to building leaders in community (centrifugal), while parachurch youth ministry concentrated on evangelism (centripetal). Ministry models reflect “come” (centripetal) or “go” (centrifugal) postures.10

In recent years the seeker-focused, purpose-driven youth ministries of local churches have taken on a parachurch character. Driven by a desire to attract and evangelize adolescents, these youth ministries appear to have combined both “come” and “go” approaches. This has been accomplished by sending these young disciples into their respective high schools with the specific intent of bringing their peers to youth gatherings for the explicit purpose of communicating the gospel and bringing them into a community of believers.

The fact that the “go” strategy has been housed within a Willow Creek or Saddleback church has not, however, produced an effective way to integrate youths into the church. For some reason young people remain isolated in an age-specific ghetto. Before graduation, very few teens find spiritual nurturing outside the youth ministry ghetto. And after graduation, only a minority integrate into the larger body of believers. The invitation to “come” has not resulted in an intergenerational expression of the faith community, but a gathering of peers.

The fellowship versus mission issue might be plotted on a continuum that suggests a variety of responses but where a majority of youth ministries find themselves clustered at one end or the other. The continuum would look like the following:

Figure 1. Fellowship-mission continuum

Developmental issues

Another set of issues at the core of our discussion cluster around developmental issues. At what stage of a young person’s life is it possible for evidences of spiritual maturity to appear so that the young person can be a full participant in the life of the faith community? Are there theological issues that prevent adolescents from full participation in the life of the church?

Traditionally these questions have been understood as questions regarding baptism, confirmation, and church membership. In churches with a strong confessional or traditional heritage, church polity provides an answer. While people coming from Anglican, Catholic, Lutheran, Methodist, and reform (Presbyterians, Reform churches) traditions have historically defined and limited the role of youths in the faith community, in recent years these same traditions have shown an increased openness to including youths in most aspects of congregational life.

By contrast, the most recent church movements have a much more flexible response to young people in the church. Respect for the leading of the Holy Spirit in the lives of even the youngest individuals has allowed children, frequently with the encouragement of their parents, to choose baptism, church membership, and in some movements even ordination. Ironically, within traditions that place a heavy emphasis on personal experience (such as Baptist, free church, Pentecostal, and charismatic denominations), as well as in emerging church movements like Calvary Chapel, Vineyard, or Willow Creek, youthful leadership and full participation in the leadership of the church are generally viewed with suspicion.

Simply put, the question boils down to whether young people are the church of the future or of the present. Nearly all youth ministers in the West will insist that young people are the church of the present, yet the very isolation of youths within their own classrooms and activities suggest a de facto concession to church of the future assumptions.

The developmental issue might be plotted on a continuum contrasting the manner in which the senior pastor and church leadership view young people. The continuum would look like the following:

Figure 2. Developmental continuum

When we consider the fellowship/mission and developmental issues simultaneously, a pattern begins to form, which shapes the structure for this book. The following figure places the two issues in relation to each other.

FELLOWSHIP/MISSION

Figure 3. Relationship between fellowship/mission and development

From the four quarters of this grid emerge four approaches to youth ministry and the church. The lines are clearer on paper than they are in practice. Postmodern thinkers may find the following diagrams irrelevantly modern. Generation X youth ministers and millennial youths may feel discomfort with the seemingly mechanical analysis of youth ministry. Yet the lines become clearer to those who can step back and observe what is actually happening.

Four views

The four understandings of youth ministry and the church to be presented in this book are—

  • The Inclusive Congregational approach integrates youths into congregational life. Characterized by friendly relations between youths, children, and adults, this approach sees youths as full partners in every aspect of God’s coming to the faith community.
  • The Missional approach views youth ministry as a mission. Using responsible evangelism to disciple young people into established churches, youths and youth ministers are considered to be missionaries. By functioning semiautonomously as church-, school-, or community-based, their responsibility is to communicate the kerugma, or the gospel, with their generation.
  • The Preparatory approach is a specialized ministry to adolescents that prepares them to participate in the life of existing churches as leaders, disciples or evangelists. Students are viewed as disciples in training with opportunities for service both in the present and the future. Developmental dynamics suggest the youth ministry be viewed as a laboratory in which disciples are permitted to grow in a culture guided by spiritual coaches.
  • The Strategic approach prepares the youth group to become a new church (in other words, a church plant). Using continuity in discipleship between the youth minister and teens, potential leadership members are nurtured to assume responsibility for roles in evangelism and fellowship. The youth pastor then becomes the pastor, and a new church is formed with the blessing of the mother church.
  • These four approaches can best be understood as they relate to each other (see figure 4).

    FELLOWSHIP/MISSION

    Figure 4. Relationships among the four approaches to youth ministry

    As neat and clean as these approaches may seem, they are mere theory unless the young people involved are God-seekers. Programs have never produced spirituality or created churches. For that matter, neither have relationships, Bible studies, retreats, cross-cultural projects, prayer meetings or evangelistic events. Instead it is the Spirit of God working in the lives of young people that creates a hunger for discovering God through Jesus Christ.

    Spiritual readiness

    This brings into focus a third set of issues clustered around questions of spiritual readiness. In that the Spirit of God is the One who draws people to Christ, the best place to look for readiness is in the visible working of the Spirit. What evidences of the fruit of the Spirit, spiritual giftedness, fullness of the Spirit, and qualities for church leadership exist in the lives of young people and should be expected of those who lead the ministries to youth? By examining an individual’s readiness we are attempting to weave together a tapestry ranging from tight to loose compliance with the expectations of Scripture. A tight weave means abundant fruit of the Spirit, spiritual gifts being used effectively to build up the body of Christ, fullness of the Spirit shown by responsiveness to doing God’s will, and qualities of church leadership evidenced in age appropriate means. A loose weave would be weak or minimal responses in each of these areas.

    The spiritual-readiness issue is a bit harder to diagram, but for the sake of the discussion in this book we will look at the tight weave of spiritual readiness as represented by a four on a scale of one to four, while a loose weave would be represented by a one. In order to get a better picture of how spiritual readiness relates to the two prior continua that were diagrammed in figures 3 and 4, and to provide a means of connecting them, the spiritual readiness scale will be represented as follows:

    Figure 5: Spiritual-readiness scale

    Spiritual readiness, when applied to any of the understandings of youth ministry and the church, can suggest a level of effectiveness in a given situation. Another way to view spiritual readiness is as a passion for God. When young people have a passion for God, any approach to youth ministry will result in the church functioning in a biblical manner. Unfortunately, there are times when the passion of young people grows cold because they have not experienced the church in a manner that will sustain them either in the present or in the years after they leave a youth ministry.

    Figure 6: Passion-effectiveness scale

    In the chapters that follow, Wesley Black (Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary), Chap Clark (Fuller Theological Seminary), Malan Nel (Vista University, South Africa) and I (Trinity Evangelical Divinity School) will present arguments in favor of four approaches to youth ministry and the church. We will then interact regarding the other perspectives and allow each writer a rejoinder.

    While it would have been great to spend a week together in an Aspen ski lodge and discuss our ideas face to face, distance and schedules made this impossible. Consequently, our virtual gathering came by means of the Internet. You will find that while we approached our chapters in different ways, our responses and rejoinders simulate a face-to-face discussion. Our virtual fellowship has provided stimulation as we have grown to know and respect each other. Editorial changes were generally made only to create a unified writing style.

    As writers we wish to present theologically responsible views of youth ministry and the church. Because of the diversity of our church traditions and church polity, our approaches and conclusions will differ. The reader is asked not to pit one author against another, but to build a theology of youth ministry and the church based upon the collective insights gained from our discussion.

    Readers can use this book in any number of ways. Some will want to read the book straight through the four approaches. Others may want to skim the responses to an approach before reading about the approach itself (this method allows readers to flag weaknesses in the main argument before reading it). Others may want to start with the rejoinders, and work their ways backwards through the arguments. In any case, this is a book to be used more than it is a text to be read.

    Or readers may want to interact with this book in this manner: they can write down questions they think the authors should answer, then judge how well those issues are explored. For such readers, here are some sample questions to get them started:

  • What is the church to which youth ministry must relate? (Universal church? Regional church? Local church? House church? Worship service?)
  • In what way does youth ministry connect with the church? (Through the students? Through leaders? Through the building? Through their beliefs?)
  • What roles do older adults play as youth ministry connects with the church? (Authority figures/permission givers? Models of godliness? Spiritual mentors? Teachers of biblical truth?)
  • What roles do young people play as youth ministry connects with the church? (Submissive followers? Mentorees? Prophetic voices? Active workers? Partners in ministry?)
  • How do youth worship as a part of the church? (Separate from older worshipers? Learning worship forms from older people? Teaching new worship forms to older people? Experimenting with various forms of worship?)
  • How does youth ministry relate to evangelism and missions in the church? (Recruiting pool for missions? Peer evangelists? Leaders in evangelism? Innovators in evangelism?)
  • As you read Four Views of Youth Ministry and the Church, remember, the church is God’s ordained agency for accomplishing his purposes in the world. With all its flaws, the church is still the focal point for God’s work in the world.

    Notes

    1. Millard J. Erickson, Christian Theology (Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1985), 1026.

    2. Wayne Grudem, Systematic Theology (Grand Rapids: Zondervan Publishing House, 1994), 867–868.

    3. Frank Otis Erb, The Development of the Young People’s Movement (University of Chicago Press, 1917), 59.

    4. Edward A. Krug, The Shaping of the American High School (Harper & Row, 1964), 170.

    5. Erb, 94.

    6. Charles W. Colson and Ellen S. Vaughn, The Body (Word, 1994).

    7. Lawrence O. Richards, Youth Ministry: Its Renewal in the Local Church (Zondervan, 1972), and A New Face for the Church (Zondervan, 1970).

    8. Dann Spader and Gary Mayes, Growing a Healthy Church (Chicago: Moody Press, 1991).

    9. Mark H. Senter III, The Coming Revolution in Youth Ministry (Wheaton: Victor, 1992), 181.

    10. George W. Peters, A Biblical Theology of Missions (Chicago: Moody Press, 1972), 21–22; 52.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑