Chapter 25 of 27

Epilogue: An Open Letter to the Church Mark H. Senter III

Epilogue: An Open Letter to the Church Mark H. Senter III

Epilogue

An Open Letter to the Church

Dear church leaders in the 21st century,

May the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, the love of God, and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit be with you all. As I view our churches at the beginning of the 21st century through the lens of youth ministry, I find much in which to rejoice, but more that brings heaviness to my heart.

Rejoicing in progress

The last two decades of the 20th century witnessed more effective ministry to youths than ever before in the history of the church. Many of our local churches have been directly or indirectly on the cutting edge. Evangelism and discipleship have replaced program committees and social activities as the primary youth ministry focus for many of our churches. Movements like Challenge 2000, National Network of Youth Ministries, and First Priority, when coupled with traditional parachurch youth ministries and local church-based outreach ministries, have made possible the establishment of witnessing Christian groups on or near every one of the 56,000 U.S. high schools and middle schools early in the new century.

Admittedly, we could be doing a better job of ministering to disenfranchised youths through our church-based efforts (but at least we aren’t as self-absorbed as previous generations of youth work). Nor has discipleship translated effectively into the holiness of life or fellowship with the broader faith community sought by many youth ministers. But the progress that high school youths have made toward becoming kingdom people in their generation has been at least encouraging and in some places dramatic.

As church leaders, you must be commended for your role in enabling youth ministry to move from activity expectations to spiritually focused outcomes. You have chosen leaders gifted in discipleship and evangelism to head the high school and middle school ministries. You invested in their development as disciple-makers and defended them from tradition-bound critics. You joked with them when they failed to wear socks to worship services, coached them as they learned life-management skills, and prayed for them as they took ministry risks the rest of the congregation was not ready to assume.

Not all of our efforts are success stories. You know that as well as I. We’ve had our share of failed marriages, theological aberrations, personality conflicts, sexual abuse, and dysfunctional social systems. But by God’s grace, these have been a small minority of the total youth ministry picture.

Our churches indirectly promoted youth ministry by supporting entrepreneurial, parachurch activities in our communities to build loving relationships with young people who have not yet discovered the amazing grace of God shown in Jesus Christ. Despite the horror stories of resistance by a few overly zealous or insecure church leaders, these missional efforts to youths, disassociated from our churches, have been carried on primarily by people from our churches, both lay and professional.

A veritable army of nonprofessional adult youth workers, over 25,000 strong in the United States, touched the lives of young people outside the church. Most of these are people from our churches who are finding a niche to do youth ministry that is consistent with their God-given passions. Add to this the thousands of high schoolers and middle schoolers from our churches who lead Bible studies and prayer groups on public school campuses, and the number of nonprofessional leaders may double.

Another chord sounded in youth ministry of the 1990s: worship and spiritual journey, perhaps more than anything else, began laying to rest the entertainment orientation of previous youth ministry generations. For some observers, the pendulum may have swung too far from cognitive approaches to more contemplative expressions of worship, yet the change is a breath of fresh air, influencing many of our churches in a positive manner. At the heart of the new expressions of worship, music seeks to discover the special presence of God in a gathering of Christian believers. Its repetitive pleas to know, feel, see, and hear God express in a new genre the classic pleas of contemplative theologians.

Heaviness because of the church

The heaviness that comes to my heart as I view the church through the lens of youth ministry reminds me of the title of David Elkind’s book All Grown Up and No Place to Go. The faith community has not yet figured out what to do with young people. For the past several months Wes Black, Chap Clark, Malan Nel, and I have wrestled with the question, How does God want youth ministry to relate to our churches in our postmodern world? Each answered the question differently; yet as we did so, we discovered a shared concern. There is a distinct possibility that after youth ministry has made all the adjustments required by theologians and sociologists, church leaders and parents, pastors and youth ministry trainers, the church would remain a foreign, even unsafe place for young people to gather. No place to go. Perhaps Chap said it best as he concluded his rejoinder: “By the way, did any of you notice that we all agreed the church must change, but we all felt very little power to make it happen? That God would cause the church to have the heart of Jesus for those that he came to seek and save!”

It seems to me that adults in the West have come to understand the church to be an adult place where parents get a little help with their kids. Rather than a faith community, we have become a collection of individual adults governed by a lowest common denominator set of spiritual norms. It is quite possible that the church is no longer a “God place.” Like other human institutions, our churches have focused more on status and social norms than on our collective progress toward the Celestial City.

Please don’t misunderstand me. Young people and their leaders are not perfect. For years I have suffered under reports that youth ministry has fallen short of what it could be. Illustrations abound of the trivial youth activities that are sponsored and apparently blessed by the church. I’ve also wondered what lock-ins, “the world’s largest” events, American gladiator competitions, or killer basketball games have to do with the Christian gospel. Some of my colleagues act as if they are more interested in recapturing a squandered adolescence than in building up the church of Jesus Christ. Some stories are even worse. For this I am deeply sorry.

Many of us at some point have bowed to the pressure to entertain kids. Some gifted personalities did so on the strength of charisma and communication skills. Others used their creativity and organizational ability to generate an environment to which young people responded. Many times any kind of Christian witness was buried so deeply in the fabric of what we did that it was virtually invisible. For this I am sorry.

While there are some sour apples among us, most youth ministers have a genuine love for young people and for God. As the support systems for young people fragment around them, we are often the last adult friend they have. A cacophony of voices call out to children and youths, but the forms of communication have become so distorted, even in the church, that we want to stand up and yell, “FIRE!” just to gain someone’s attention. Then when no one seems to respond, we give up, gather in our own conventions and networks, and lick our wounds. For this retreat from you, I am sorry.

Mr. Holland’s church

A potent scene from Mr. Holland’s Opus might help you understand our dilemma. In this movie Glenn Holland teaches music at John F. Kennedy High School during the mid-1960s where he finds students apathetic toward the music curriculum. One day, in desperation, Mr. Holland scraps the curriculum and begins using rock and roll music to illustrate what classical music is all about. For the first time the students respond—and learn. Unfortunately, not everyone is as happy with the students’ newfound interest in music. Gene Walters, the uptight vice principal, reports Mr. Holland’s curricular departures to the principal, Helen Jacobs, and the music teacher is called on the carpet.

Mrs. Jacobs has a dilemma on her hands. Next week she must face the school board with the full realization that in the community there are people who are convinced that rock and roll is straight from the pit of hell. “What should I tell them?” asks the principal.

“Tell them,” says the music teacher, “I am teaching music and I will use anything from Beethoven to Billy Holiday to rock and roll if I think it will help a student to love music.”1

“That is a reasonable answer,” says Mrs. Jacobs. “I can tell them that.”

Youth ministry finds itself faced with a similar question, but in the pastor’s office instead of the principal’s.

“What should I tell the board and the parents about the methods you are using with the young people?”

For the vast majority of youth ministers, the answer rings with the spirit of Glenn Holland.

“Tell them I am teaching them to love God, and I will use anything from John Calvin to Jars of Clay to ‘The Simpsons’ if I think it will help a student to love God.”

The decision rests with the pastor. Will he respond fearfully and narrowly like VP Gene Walters, or with the visionary kindness of Helen Jacobs? The very nature of the local church lies with the leadership of the pastor. Though the board may have the right to fire the pastor and youth pastor for methods deemed inappropriate, the chances are quite good that godly leadership will create a community of faith that will take the necessary risks to become people of faith.

Church as apologetic

The Christian apologetic for young people and adults of the 21st century may be the church itself. While apologetic arguments remain appropriate in many situations, the emerging generation needs a more holistic apologetic. Narratives (individually and collectively), explanations of a Christian worldview, expressions of that worldview seen in real life (such as prayer), symbolism and ritual, and moral behavior combine to provide a compelling apologetic to postmodern youths.2 Postmoderns need to see a group of people living in a fashion prescribed by our Lord. The church must live as the church. The community of faith must exemplify integrity.

If the church is the apologetic of the 21st century, what church are we talking about? Is it your church or ours? Old or young? Anthems or worship choruses? Theology or practice? Exposition or need responsive? Liturgy or freedom of the Spirit? Evangelism or edification? Rich or poor?

To ask these questions in this manner is to do a disservice to the church. The church should never be divided into such simplistic categories. The answer to each of the questions above should be “yes.” If the church is to be a witness before a watching world, it must be your church and ours, old and young, anthems and choruses, theology and practice, exposition and need responsive, liturgy and freedom of the Spirit, evangelism and edification, rich and poor.

Weaknesses in the church

So what changes does the church have to make if youth ministry is to be fully integrated into the life of the faith community? Before suggesting changes, I would remind you of some weaknesses in local church ministry that might justify the suggestions that follow. Some may be unique to the church of the 20th and 21st centuries. Others appeared in biblical times.

The most evident deficiency in the nurture of children and youths is the dropout rate that compounds as youths move from grade school to middle school, then to high school, and finally on to college or the workplace. At the heart of the problem may be the sinful nature and the fragmenting structure of families, but the faith community must recognize its contribution to the problem. Current structures, which make continuity of spiritually mentoring relationships impossible, are totally out of step with the biblical ideals of discipleship through the extended Christian family—the church.

Adults have disregarded and resisted the spiritual leadership of children since the days of Samuel, David, the servant girl of Naaman’s wife, Daniel and his friends, Jesus’ mother Mary, Phillip’s unmarried daughters, and even the children metaphor in Matthew 18. Yet today, in most churches, the situation is much more pronounced. If the servant girl in the house of Mary (John Mark’s mother) rushed into our prayer meeting proclaiming answered prayer, as she did following the release of Peter from prison, no doubt we would conclude she was out of her mind, as did the prayer warriors of Acts 12.

Why is it that so many of the spiritual revivals and evangelistic movements begin with young people, yet the church finds so few places for them to exercise their giftedness and leadership in local assemblies of believers? This is by no means a call for young people to be the only ones overseeing the affairs of the church, nor a call for young people who are not above reproach in their lifestyles to shepherd the flock of God. It is a call for superficial age restrictions to be removed from opportunities for spiritual leadership.

What about evangelism and works of service in the broader community? Who are the people most actively emulating our Lord in this fashion? In most churches the answer is young people, coached by a handful of young adults. While adults have done a wonderful job of meeting the needs of people already associated with the church, younger people are far more likely to be the ones who venture outside the congregation and declare their faith before their peers. While middle and high school youths pray for their campuses (three million strong gather annually around the flag poles on their campuses), where is the parallel movement for adult Christians in the market place? Why is there no See You at the Copier campaign?

Changes in forms of worship, especially music, often come from young people and those in tune with them and are later embraced by local churches. In Growing Up Evangelical, Pete Ward describes the pattern in England in the chapter “Songs for each Generation.”3 The music of Youth for Christ, the Jesus Movement captured and promoted by Maranatha Music, Jesus marches and Christian festivals in England, and more recently Vineyard style worship music have their strongest supporters among young people and their greatest resistance among the church choir and Christian college conservatory crowd. By no means do I want to see worship music of one generation summarily discarded because of new tastes and styles, but I do call for a more active blending and expansion of worship styles.

Suggested changes for the church

Every worship service must be shaped for and with young people. Yet this must not exclude the other generations in the congregation. The pastor must find ways to address the spiritual needs of youths as well as adults in each message. Music should aid the spiritual journey of young people as well as their grandparents. Young people need to realize that older people may not find protracted periods of standing to sing very worshipful, while older believers will have to yield on hymnology that employs metaphors reflecting an agrarian society. Appropriate expressions of art, drama, media, and dance will take their place beside the pipe organ and anthem.

Every new person—young or old—must be bonded to people of their age group and two other generations. In many of our congregations, new attenders are fortunate to be bonded to anyone in the church. Basis assimilation has to be a starting place, but it cannot be the final goal. While young people who have started on their faith journey through a parachurch ministry must be welcomed with open arms by the youths of the church, an equally great need for these new believers is to observe models of Christian living in older and perhaps younger people. Many will have no idea what faith means to people of their parents’ age or what it means to live as a Christian parent. The church must alter its social structures (including that safe haven called youth ministry) in order to link the journeys of Christians of all ages.

Every Christian witness effort must rely upon the evangelistic giftedness in young people. The involvement must be from beginning to end. It is not a matter of setting up a witnessing program for youths and then calling upon them to participate. Relying upon gifted young people means learning from them about how evangelism might be done. For me this is very uncomfortable because I have used so many bad methods of evangelization that I prefer not to see repeated. Ironically, the uninhibited boldness of some young people may be the exact prescription the church needs for evangelism in the community. By no means does this mean that people of other ages are exempt from evangelistic efforts. In fact the leadership of youths may be the greatest catalysts for evangelism of all ages that the church has ever had.

Every service opportunity must be equally available to young people. When middle schoolers ask if they can teach Sunday school rather than go to the morning worship service, the answer will be “Of course!” When a young person demonstrates spiritual maturity, they should be given the same consideration for leadership offices as persons three times their age. In fact, the presence of a young person on a board may cause other board members to give additional attention to their conduct during discussions. At the same time, a youthful conscience contributing to the decision-making process might be extremely valuable to the church. Mature leadership must not be sacrificed for the sake of including youths in leadership positions, so the church may need to find new ways of establishing a succession of godly leaders in the church.

Every refinement in ministry vision must draw upon the insights of youths. If the church of tomorrow is to become the church of today, the vision for what we are all about must be forged and maintained together. The church is not yours or mine, it is ours—or more correctly, the Lord’s—with all of us as the beneficiaries. Vision building can be very boring work for young people, so our responsibility is to make the process unboring. The fact that young people find the slow-moving process of envisioning future ministry directions dreary is our problem, not theirs. If they do not participate, the church loses more than the young person. Though young people live in our houses and in our neighborhoods, we may not live in the same communities. Vision is only effective if it is adequate.

Every resource for spiritual growth must be accessible to youths. Biblical teaching, models of the spiritual disciplines, intentional mentoring, materials designed for a variety of learning styles, training in spiritual disciplines and ministry skills, accountability groups, coaching, and even corrective counseling must be available to people of all ages—especially youths. As leadership gifts and spiritual maturity become apparent, special funding for seminars or educational programs may be appropriate. Our pattern has been to provide “separate but equal” spiritual-growth resources, split along developmental lines. As pointed out in the earlier chapters, this may be wise. But if the developmental breakouts inhibit intergenerational nurturing, then changes must be made.

Spiritual readiness

The idea of making young people full participants in your churches may be a bit unsettling. It should be. It represents change.

In the introduction to this book, I defined spiritual readiness as passion for God. As a leader of your church, you have the responsibility to evaluate all of these ideas in light of the chief end of man—to glorify God and fully enjoy him forever. Two perspectives are necessary. To what extent will these functions of the church contribute to a passion for God within the congregation as a whole? And to what extent is a passion for God preparing the congregation to function in this manner? The two questions are inseparable.

My fear is that the young people in many of our churches may be more passionate for God than their parents were at that same age or currently. I may be wrong. I hope I am. But if I am correct, the heaviest burden for bringing about a passion for God in the congregation lies not with the youth ministry, but with the adults of the church. If properly shepherded in an environment of full participation by you and the youth ministry leaders (paid or volunteer), young people may be your greatest ally in discovering a passion for God throughout the congregation. Most young people have survived their early doubts and find comfort in God’s grace. They still take the scripture at face value. They are not surprised when prayer is answered.

To not include young people as full participants in every aspect of church life may be far more detrimental to the spiritual welfare of the entire congregation than it is to the young people themselves. They have been raised in a generation where lowering their expectations of others has become the norm. I, and many like me, still hope the church will be different—set apart, and inclusive.

What becomes of the four approaches?

The four approaches described in this book came about not because the church was healthy, but because it had failed to live up to its own mandate. If the church begins to experience wholeness and a biblical inclusiveness, will the four approaches remain valid? I suspect so. In fact because of a variety of emphases in the purposes of local churches, I feel that each of the approaches may find its niche better supported and more effectively accomplished than ever before. Each approach will be effectively integrated with the vision of the entire church. Until then, the four approaches will serve as a vehicle for assisting young people to live as Christians in a non-Christian world.

Notes

1. “Mr. Holland’s Opus” (Hollywood Pictures, 1995).

2. Dennis Hollinger, “The Church as Apologetic,” Christian Apologetics in the Postmodern World (Downers Grove, Illinois: InterVarsity Press, 1995), 188–191.

3. Pete Ward, Growing Up Evangelical (1996), 107–142.

↑ Back to top

↑