Response from a Preparatory perspective Wesley Black
Response to the Missional Approach from a Preparatory Perspective
Church as private club
I have to say first that I appreciate your insights into the critique of the church and its lack of emphasis on mission. We have too quickly relied on programs rather than an urgency in mission. As you say in the definition of the Mission approach, we need to reach out to “both churched and non-churched young people.” And again, “The theologically driven missional mandate of youth ministry is to bring the gospel and the kingdom to every adolescent.” It is far too easy to settle for the kids who come to our programs and forget about the ones outside the doors of the church.
One of the penetrating statements you made really hit home: “For those raised in the church, a youth group may not feel like a private club with its own culture, rules, and norms, but to many of those on the outside that’s how it has felt for decades.” We may mistake a warm, inviting fellowship for a closed club.
I also agree that one of the stress points for modern youth ministers is how to do the job in such as way as to be true to the calling and satisfy the gatekeepers, those who pay the salary and provide the resources for ministry. I felt like standing and cheering when you wrote that “this is the paradoxical quandary of contemporary youth ministry: churches are screaming for youth ministry (an ‘excellent’ one, at that—high-powered, entertaining, and theologically and sociologically safe), but there are few pastors, parents, and even boards who are convinced that God has called them as a church to mobilize their resources in order to penetrate a distant and disruptive generation.”
This was spelled out in stark clarity with the list of expectations for youth ministers: keep the youths happy, teach the Christian worldview and political ideology, thrust them into leadership too quickly, and keep them interested and involved. This list would almost be humorous if it weren’t so true.
Part of the problem, I think, grows out of the commonly held sense that church involvement leads to spirituality. As Darrel Guder first reminds us, “They have been formed by centuries in which Western civilization considered itself formally and officially Christian…. A missional ecclesiology must clearly identify and resist all attempts to equip the church merely for its maintenance and security.” The people of God must keep their eyes focused on the world that needs a message of hope from God.
I liked how you reminded us that “youth ministry programs must continue to evaluate their missional programmatic commitments and strategies” by asking “Who are our targets? How do we best reach out to them? Where do we want these students to end up when they leave our program?” This is difficult to accomplish because, as you well stated, “Very few churches see youth ministry as their missional mandate. That’s why they hired a youth minister, after all.” But exactly how is that done? How do we reach out to youths, especially following your criticism that “any programmatic, come-to-us methodology for evangelism, Christian witness, and mission in the world will, by its very assumptions, exclude the masses”?
A gift of an earring
One discussion of yours particularly got my attention: “A missional commitment to youth ministry,” you wrote, “means that a congregation sees adolescents—regardless of their current involvement—as deserving love, focus, and care…. This means that the only true measure of success in a youth ministry program is the ability and willingness of a church to fully assimilate growing adolescents into the adult fellowship.”
This reminded me of a conference I led a few years ago for volunteer youth workers. As my luck would have it, one of the small groups included an 80-year-old lady and a 19-year-old male youth leader (with an earring, of course). I was curious about how they would get along during the week. The last day the small-group members brought small gifts of remembrance for each other. The octogenarian had bought a small earring set in the gift shop, just so she could give one of them to the 19-year-old she had befriended during the week. It was a reminder of how God’s love can help us bridge the gaps between generations.
I also agree with your insight about sociological groupings and the problems with relying on peer ministry. When I read the statement, “The movement to ‘peer evangelism’ as the main thrust of a youth ministry’s missional focus is an inadequate strategy,” I was a little surprised but still intrigued. Peer evangelism is exactly what we’ve been stressing for years. Get the kids involved and you will reach more kids has been a prime organizing principle for most outreach strategies. But you added a new twist.
Your point is well made that “peer-to-peer ministry is inadequate as the primary missional thrust” because it only draws kids who, like the students, are already participating in a given program. We ask of adolescents what we hardly ask of mature Christian adults, and it can create a program-centered ministry. I will take some issue with this later, but especially with your phrase “primary missional thrust,” you give us reason to reevaluate our strategies for evangelism.
I appreciated your list of expectations for youth ministers: keep the youths happy, teach the Christian worldview and appropriate political ideology, thrust them into leadership too quickly, and keep them involved. This list would almost be humorous if it weren’t so true.
It reminds me of those who sterotypically speak of adolescents as “the typical teenager” or “the typical high school campus.” The world of teenagers is complex and multifaceted. Anyone who misses that point will have a hard time understanding the world of adolescents. So when we urge our youths to evangelize their friends at school, we often picture everyone at school as being similar to the youths in our groups at church. It just may be our blind spot.
Unnecessarily harsh on the church
I feel, however, that you have been unnecessarily harsh in your criticism of the church, although I also see in modern North American churches many of the shortcomings that you pointed out. Furthermore, I don’t see a lot of answers to the question of how to bring non-Christians into the family of God and eventually into the church. (Of course you would naturally expect me to respond to the criticism of the church, since it squarely hits the Preparatory approach.)
One statement of yours especially got my attention: “For many in youth ministry, even among the leaders of the movement, the church—that umbrella organization that sponsors youth ministry—is considered a necessary nuisance.” That’s a pretty strong statement. It almost appears cynical, as if you have written off the church as having no redeeming value.
“The fact is,” you write elsewhere, “that for large numbers of adolescents (probably the majority), youth ministries in churches (and even in parachurch organizations…) represent a world that is foreign, irrelevant, and even occasionally offensive.” Reading this is like getting a root canal—you know there’s something good for you in it, but it still hurts.
By the way, I wonder about the accuracy of this statement. Do you have any research to indicate the numbers when you say “large numbers” and “probably the majority” of adolescents? A little later you write that “in an increasingly secularized society, the gulf widened to the point where today the majority of kids would not even consider attending a church or even religious event or program.” Are these your perceptions or actual segments of the adolescent population?
I would like to raise the issue about how to move non-Christian adolescents from a secular world to the church. “As the church attempts to realize its biblical mandate of missional youth ministry,” you wrote, “the issue is to rediscover its historical and fundamental missional commitment and focus and proceed accordingly.” But I did not see a clearly stated process for proceeding to reach this goal. You mentioned some excellent ways that the church must change, mostly in attitude and acceptance; but what kind of strategies, programs, methodologies, organizations, or training should take place to reach the goals you mentioned?
Again, I appreciate your emphasis on going instead of simply making the invitation to come to programs at a church building. But this leads me to another point concerning the Missional approach. Among the needed changes you mentioned was a willingness on the part of the youth ministry leadership team to “make certain that every program, every event, and every methodology employed is centered on the end goal of full assimilation into the larger body of the church upon graduation from the youth ministry program.” And you wrote that the youth minister or youth pastor should “seek to connect students with other people and programs in the church” and “strategically commit to and plan for the goal of full assimilation into the life of the church for each student.” I am with you here completely—but how do we do that without falling into the trap of a come-to-us methodology? Sooner or later, they will have to come to us if they are to be fully assimilated into the larger body of the church.
I feel that you put excessive emphasis on reaching, and neglect teaching. Yes, the church probably reaches more than it teaches—but it takes both to be faithful to Christ’s Great Commission to us.
The Great Commission has at least two prongs—reaching all we can and teaching all we reach. I feel that you put excessive emphasis on the former and neglect the latter. Yes, the church probably reaches more than it teaches—but it takes both to be faithful to Christ’s Great Commission. In fact, churches often fall into the entertainment trap, as you said: “Thus the last 20 to 30 years have seen youth ministry move from a mission driven, outreach-oriented, culturally sensitive expression of God’s incarnational care for all people to an entertainment-based series of events, programs, options, and classes”—a potent indictment of the church. But could this also be said of many parachurch youth ministries? Both kinds of ministries stand in need of your reminders to be on mission with God.
Professionals or laypersons?
Your section about generational youth ministry approaches and parent-teen issues contains some confusing ideas.
You point out that “generationally focused ministry programming has emerged” in recent years. This is commonly accepted as a necessary process to be relevant to today’s youths. But I believe we can twist that view until it presents a false picture of the world of adolescents. You cite Dean Borgman’s statement that “communities and churches need to see youth leaders as critical bridges to youth culture”—meaning, he writes, that we function as missionaries, social workers, and finally as pastors. Yet I disagree with Borgman’s implication that the youthful generation cannot be reached by untrained laypersons, but only by professionals with advanced degrees and unique skills that enable them to relate to a culturally distant generation.
The research simply does not bear this out. The work of Search Institute and many developmental psychologists consistently show that teenagers desire to have better relationships and to communicate with other generations, including their parents. Certainly, we must be generationally and culturally relevant to those we are targeting—but does this mean that pastors should turn over all youth ministry tasks to professionals and experts? That’s the very point you were arguing against.
Finally, I was a little surprised that you did not include more about the families of adolescents. It almost sounded like this approach ignored the tremendous influence of parents on their teens. It is a common misperception that adolescents live in a world dominated by peers and isolated from adult influence, especially the influence of their parents. We all have to admit, in the end, that teens are strongly influenced by their parents and tend to be very much like them (more so than teens would ever desire to admit). If we are serious about reaching out to adolescents, we have to include strategies for reaching their families. We cannot evangelize teenagers and ignore the rest of the family.
Youth ministry must be more than simply going onto the turf of adolescents. We must also look for ways to bring them into relationship with other generations of the family of God, the body of Christ that we call church.
