Chapter 19 of 27

Rejoinder Chap Clark

Rejoinder Chap Clark

Rejoinder from the Missional Approach

by Chap Clark

Let me speak frankly: no approach but the Missional seems to take seriously the mandate to disciple all of the youth culture. Unless I missed something, the vast majority of the energy you suggest we put into youth ministry begins and ends with church people. With that off my chest, let me respond to your critiques of the Missional approach.

Malan, your insights into the distinction between bringing the gospel as verbalized explanation of the gospel and the call of the church to bring the whole gospel (Luke 8:1) was helpful. I intended to include both emphases, for I try not to delineate between the two aspects of the gospel mandate. To love and to witness to Love is part and parcel of the same communicative event. But the reminder that not everyone initially recognizes this was great.

You asked me if “this is a reason why youths reject the church?” I tend to think that the general impression of the church being filled with hypocrites is the closest I would come to saying this. I rather doubt that most postmodern adolescents reject the church based on such reflective insights as this, but rather I have sensed a systemic abandonment from Christians in general and therefore do not trust those who wear that label like a badge. I believe kids respond to an authentic, loving, passionate, compassionate follower of Jesus Christ. It is this caricatured idea of what a Christian is that is shunned.

Incarnational witness

Also, Malan, in your discussion of the distinction between friendship evangelism and service evangelism, I see the incarnational witness as being the overarching theological premise guiding both. These two concepts you mention may and often do overlap, but the men and women who represent Christ and the church are called to go—to intentionally incarnate themselves into a different world. This reflects itself in friendships and service, and therefore both are subsets under the broader umbrella of incarnational witness.

I greatly appreciate and fully endorse your insights on family and relational sensitivity when the church does somehow connect with a lost adolescent. My own mother still carries an emotional scar from how I, as a new convert, denied the seeds of faith she (and my father, and my extended family) had given me. The missionary you mention is very wise indeed, and my approach is strengthened by this reminder. Thanks.

Cautions and adjustments

Yes, Wes, much of the thrust of my focus does question and challenge many if not most of the assumptions underlying the Preparatory approach. But, as you allude, my emphasis was not to replace or throw out the Preparatory approach, but only to offer theologically and sociologically driven cautions and adjustments to the way we think about youth ministry. I honestly believe there is much to the Preparatory approach that is right and good.

My commitment to the Missional approach means that I seek to influence the “book-ends” of youth ministry—how do we care for and relate to those who do not feel safe or interested in coming to us? How do we send our adults and students into the world as representatives of Jesus, offering both the verbal gospel and the hope of the kingdom?

I understand how you were a bit put off by my critique of the church (although, as you can see, Mark felt I was too kind—oh, well, you can’t please everyone!). Yes, I did report a cynical view of the church, but from the generalized perspective of youth ministry practitioners. There are many youth ministry folks who honestly feel this way about the church. I agree that this attitude is wrong, and sad, and must be addressed by leaders in the movement, but I also know that many hold this view.

Ten percent of potential students attend a Christian youth program

Regarding specific studies or research supporting my contention that most young people see the church as “foreign, irrelevant, and even occasionally offensive,” it is true that there is not much solid research out there. But as a secularly trained social scientist who has spent my entire career studying the world of unchurched adolescents, I am convinced that it is even worse than I presented it.

An easy study would be to compare the number of students in junior and senior high in a given community with the number of students who attend a church or youth ministry program even, say, once a month. For accuracy’s sake, factor in those who go to multiple meetings (in other words Young Life and a church youth group), then add those who are home-schooled. In the informal settings where I have encouraged this type of study, students have reported back to me that not even 10 percent of potential students attend a Christian youth program on a monthly basis! This may vary greatly across regions, but I have little doubt that even the most religiously welcoming community will not be able to consistently reach even half of a town’s students with Christian programs. I contend that this is a major problem in a post-Christian society.1

Yes, I did report a cynical view of the church. But I did so from the generalized perspective of youth ministry practitioners, many of whom honestly feel this way about the church, however sad and wrong this perception is.

Called to connect people to people

As I read on I got the impression that you may be ready to concede that many if not most unchurched students have turned their collective backs on the church. The next question you raise, then is “How do we, then, do what you are saying?” My impression is you indict the Missional approach because it lacks the programmatic specifics for making transition and assimilation happen (in some ways Mark does the same thing). But that is exactly the point (although I have made it better in different articles with far more clarity): The church is not primarily called to programs and events in order to build a vital community of believers. It is, rather, called to connect people to people. I disagree that “teaching all we reach” is the goal, for example, unless you mean holistic teaching that Jesus himself implores in Matthew 28 (where the emphasis is on “obey” rather than the educational, cognitive component of historical youth ministry).

The “how” is not nearly so important as the “who” in creating a welcoming place for the person who seeks to know Christ and commit to the church. I am convinced that kids are not so much concerned about the kind of programs we offer as they are concerned that they fit, that they matter, and that they are important players in the grand scheme of life. Any number of models and programs with a missional commitment can accomplish this, and every model I know can fail miserably, too.

Your final comments were great—for, as with Malan’s and Mark’s comments, they helped me to see the holes I had left scattered about in my approach. I did not intend to communicate that we need anything other than “frail mortals” to do missional youth ministry. In fact, I teach exactly what you argue for—the best kind of youth leaders are those who are “culturally goofy” enough not to be a threat to fragile adolescent egos. When I use the notion of a “critical bridge” I mean that the one going must become a relational expression of the local church. This only means that they love God and love kids, period. You are right, Wes, and I fully agree—kids need people who love and care for them as they are.

In the context of the family system

Regarding the family, see what I wrote to Malan above. I am a published advocate for a family-based youth ministry approach (which is possibly why you expressed a sense of surprise at my article). But, Wes, I do not believe that the Missional approach negates his theological strategy. I see the church caring for all adolescents in the context of the family system. This may look differently in different programs and with different pragmatic strategies, but it is the mindset of those in youth ministry that makes or breaks this commitment. It is true that I have studied the impact of families on teenagers as much as anyone, and I know that real change generally occurs within the framework of familial systemic change.

But the flip side of this is that many unchurched adolescents break from spiritually antagonistic family systems when they respond to a Missional approach. If we wait for families to come around prior to reaching out to unchurched disinterested adolescents, we will lose far too many kids in the process. When it comes to the families of students we serve, we need to be aware, and sensitive, and smart. But we must not allow this commitment to keep us from strategically targeting the world of lost kids.

Thank you, Mark, for your perspectives on the issues raised by the Missional approach. As with Malan and Wes, in many ways we are obviously in the same chapter if not on the same page. Since you address many of the issues already covered in the above responses, I will note just a few.

A place that is safe

I must admit, your first critique struck a nerve in me (in a good way). As a result, I am going to have to take some time reflecting on the implications of the Missional approach on Christian families and churched young people. It is interesting to note that this is precisely what I struggled with in the Strategic approach! What about those dear kids who love God, want to grow, and need a place that is safe for them? You state that your approach attempts to do just this, but I found it could create just the opposite situation. Let me try and state my position on this now, with the promise that I will continue this personal reflection in the future.

I am convinced that kids are not as concerned about the kind of programs we offer as they are concerned that they fit, that they matter, that they are important players in the grand scheme of life. Any number of programs with a missional commitment can accomplish this.

I believe that most Christian kids, especially those who have grown up in the church, have been acculturated to view the church as a sort of private, “we own this” club. Although a church does not intend for this to happen, the ownership of a given sociological grouping is defined by those who have helped create and define it. The way we have learned how to “do” church—fragmentation of age groups, specializations of leadership, “church” on Sunday or Wednesday night (instead of being part of a worshiping community at all times and gathering on special days)—has caused the systems and structures which order the way we “do” church to become institutionalized. This in turn locks out others who are not acculturated. When certain students are in a school classroom, for example, it is far easier to accept and embrace one new student than five who come in with expectations for inclusion and ownership. In other words, the nature of the contemporary beast creates an instant conflict—either the church kids will lose what they thought they owned, or the converts will dominate. I have seen this happen repeatedly.

But the church does not have to be this way. Youth ministry can be a place that creates community with a purpose. The Mormons have used this strategy with great effectiveness, even while propagating a theology of works, which is not supposed to fly in a postmodern culture! I believe your concern is valid but should be addressed and dealt with head-on, without sacrificing the Missional mandate of youth ministry. For years I have seen churches criticize Youth for Christ and Young Life for failing to get kids into church, only to find these same churches unwilling to embrace these new converts. This cycle must be strategically addressed, but not at the expense of the lost.

Not a prophet

And yet, Mark, that is exactly your challenge to me. Where does the solution lie? How do we get along in the church, even before we bring in alternative subcultures who do not feel moved by a well-played organ? You invite me to “be more specific in how the church must change to make her Missional friendly.” I am a youth worker, a theologian, and a communication scholar. However, I am not a prophet, a magician, or a miracle worker. My voice is neither loud enough nor credible enough to cause sweeping change in how churches view themselves in relation to those outside. But as we all talk, teach, lead, and model what we know to be true, perhaps the Holy Spirit will wake scores of us up and cause the church to have the courage to be the church! My hope lies not in nailing my theses to the church doors so much as it does in all of us doing our part to call the church to account.

By the way, did any of you notice that we all agreed the church must change, but we all felt very little power to make it happen. That God would cause the church to have the heart of Jesus for those that he came to seek and save!

Notes

1. The exception to this is in communities where the Catholic church has a virtual cultural monopoly on the world of adolescents. I would say, however, that even where this is clearly the case—such as the Hispanic community in Los Angeles county—the vast majority of young people may report church commitment and may even attend, but they are not as personally active as their physical presence may imply.

↑ Back to top

↑