Chapter 4 of 27

The Inclusive Congregational Approach to Youth Ministry Malan Nel

The Inclusive Congregational Approach to Youth Ministry Malan Nel

The Inclusive Congregational Approach to Youth Ministry

by Malan Nel

Scenario: Giving teens both roots and wings

“The problem is not our youth ministry,” Pastor Guda heard himself saying. “The problem is our church.”

Silence thick as smoke from a Dutchman’s cigar filled the boardroom. For over two hours the session had struggled with issues related to the youth ministry, and this was not the first time. On at least four other occasions during his seven-year pastorate, church leaders had wrestled with nagging questions related to the Christian commitment and involvement of the youths of the church. The answer was always the same: If we get the right people to work with the young people, they would solve the problems.

“This is not the first time we have discussed the problems we are having with our young people,” continued the pastor. “Remember when we realized that young people quit attending church services as soon as they were confirmed? What was our solution? New youth workers and better curriculum for catechesis. Did it change anything? Not really.

“Then there was the problem related to methamphetamines at the youth group retreat at Camp Hebron. It nearly split the church. What did we decide to do? Hire a youth minister and implement a drug awareness program. Did it work? Well, we haven’t had any more drug-related crises, but I’m not sure we got to the root of what our youths need to grow in their Christian faith.”

Pastor Guda was on a roll. Instead of interrupting with their standard objections, the session members appeared willing to allow their pastor to reframe their youth ministry problem.

“Then there were the complaints that came after the Family-Based Youth Ministry book circulated among the parents. So what did we do? Remember the mentors we assigned to the young people? It seemed to work for a year or so before it ran out of gas.

“And the discipleship approach that resulted in six or eight young people committing themselves to minister to unreached people groups. Remember the crises our session experienced when we realized the financial implications of the discipleship emphasis on our missionary budget and how relieved we were when several of them changed majors and career directions a couple years later?”

“Now, Pastor,” interrupted a senior member of the session, “that is a bit harsh. We all know the Lord would have provided.”

“You’re probably right, Ernie,” replied Pastor Guda. “Maybe it was my faith that was too small. But what would have happened if a half dozen young people did go into mission work every year? Would we be prepared to support them? More importantly, would the parents of the church be thrilled with a youth ministry that produced that kind of disciple? I’m not sure they would.

“So what do we want to have happen in our youth ministry? Honestly, as a church we have treated the young people like foster care, not family. They’ve become problems to deal with, rather than flesh and blood to love. We keep thinking they have to change to fit into our church family. Instead we should be adapting the family to include them, just like we all did as children were born into our own families.”

“No offense, Pastor,” objected Henri, “but our young people don’t respond like babies. They have a will of their own. They want independence.”

“Independence, yes; but isolation, no. Our youth ministry, I fear, has isolated our young people in their own little ghetto. The best families allow young people to have both roots and wings. I think that what we haven’t done well so far relates to the students’ roots. Pardon my analogy if you think I’m pushing it too far, but we have set up a little garden plot in the back of our property and asked a tenant farmer to make sure the plants have good roots. It can’t be done that way if we want them to grow and become a part of our olive tree.”

“You’re sounding rather biblical, Pastor, with the olive tree and all,” responded Henri. “But where are we going with all this? You caught our attention when you said the problem is not the youth ministry but the church. How is the church supposed to change in order for young people—to use your analogy—to grow deep roots in the church?”

Henri’s question placed the issue into clear focus. If young people are to be completely included in the life of the congregation, the church must be prepared to change. But how?

A comprehensive, inclusive approach

Although Pastor Guda and his church are fictitious, their dilemma is faced by actual churches large and small. Responding to the youth ministry needs of his church provides more than enough reasons to see youth ministry as a comprehensive, inclusive congregational ministry, with catechesis (that is, Christian education of youths) as a vital component.

Historically speaking, the church and organized youth work were typically autonomous, and often still are—probably because youth ministry did not really exist before the Industrial Revolution of the mid-19th century. In the rural context of the world, up to and during the Industrial Revolution, children and young people were perceived as part of the family.1 Yet studies of catechesis (or Christian education) have been done since the time of the New Testament and probably were the sum total of church involvement with youth for many centuries. Catechesis has been viewed as part of the church’s task without any reference to the rest of what we now know as youth ministry.

“Remember when we realized that young people quit attending church services as soon as they were confirmed?” the pastor asked. “What was our solution? New youth workers and better curriculum for catechesis. Did it change anything?”

This historical explanation for the dichotomy between catechesis and youth ministry, however, does not mean that one should accept matters as they stand.

For some time now, attempts have been made to give youth ministry a theological grounding. For over a century, theology and society have been calling for a radical change from the pattern of the autonomous church/autonomous youth ministry. The Industrial Revolution that put youth ministry on the agenda was no flash in the pan. It drew the attention of individuals and eventually the church to youths inside—but especially outside—their parental homes. This revolution continues daily.

Some societies—such as my own in South Africa—are now experiencing something of the Industrial Revolution felt by other countries in the 19th century, and something of the youth revolution felt by other countries in the 20th century. In all of society, and for varying reasons, youths are the center of attention. Sometimes it’s because of their numbers, their rebellion, their poverty, or their criminal involvement. Other times it is a result of their academic or democratic frustrations. In any case, churches are being challenged to notice the youths, to know them, to sense their needs, and to serve them.

Before I supply the necessary theological justification for this ministry, I will first explain how an inclusive congregational approach needs to be understood.

No more traditional distinction

To my mind there is no argument that holds water for the preservation of the traditional dichotomy between youth ministry as a duty of the local church and youth ministry as an organized form of working with youths separate from catechesis, or Christian education. Young people are not just partly the congregation’s responsibility, they are wholly so. The essence of God’s dealings and relationship with people—and especially with those in the community of believers—makes such a distinction indefensible.

Put simply, youth ministry is part of a comprehensive ministry of the congregation. It includes more than the organized efforts of this or that institution that, possibly in association with the congregation, organizes the youths. Youth ministry (Jugendarbeit) and youths themselves are part of the total congregational ministry and not a separate entity.2It is an integral part of the congregational whole, in that the whole is never complete without youth ministry.

Results of including youths as full participants

Even before a case for a comprehensive and inclusive approach to youth ministry is argued, a summary of the consequences of the theological justification given below is necessary here. The church must realize the implications of including youths as full participants in the church.

  • The congregation will never think of the faith life of youths separately from the faith life of adult members. People do not need to reach a certain age before God becomes interested in them and starts working with and through them. Youths are part of the congregation’s service to God because they share in God’s relationship with his people and are incorporated into the congregation.
  • Youths will not become a separate group within the congregation. Even though they are unique and have distinct characteristics, they are not apart from the rest. The relationship of God with the believers and their children, as well as the nature of the congregation as something created by God, makes this impossible. So although the youths, because of their distinct nature, require and need to receive specific attention, they should still be approached and ministered to as essential members of the congregation.
  • Youths will not be neglected or ignored. The congregation does not consist only of adults or only of youths. The youths have to be incorporated in every line of thought and received into every part of the ministry. They have to be taken into account, regardless of the type of ministry on the agenda.
  • Youths will be the congregation’s responsibility, not merely the responsibility of the “youth workers.” Children and adolescents are not simply the charge of a few people who particularly love and understand them and want to help them—however well-meaning these people might be. Youths are the responsibility of parents, Sunday school teachers, elders, deacons, the membership as such, as well as one another (in other words the youths themselves). This responsibility is inalienable and not transferable.
  • These sentiments have been stated over many years by a number of theologians—among them, Dietrich Bonhoeffer. In his eight theses on youth work, he rejected the existence of anything resembling a church youth league because its very existence discredits the cause of the church as such.3 Beyer also thinks the idea of young people and the congregation should change to young people within the congregation.4 Sara Little is of the same opinion, writing that they are a part of the ministering body of Christ now.5

    In spite of such stellar advocates, the typical congregation does not readily accept this comprehensive approach—possibly because theological faculties still teach youth ministry as a kind of supplement to catechesis (and in Anglo circles, to Christian education). As long as the whole is reduced to a part, even the part—in this case, education/catechesis—will not come into its own.

    How Should a Comprehensive

    Approach Be Understood?

    God approaches people

    A fundamental question of theology is How does God approach us? Theology’s answer is God approaches people and his creation in many ways—by means of his Spirit and of his Word, but also by means of other people. (Ultimately, of course, God can come to us in any way he pleases.) In fact, the Bible is quite clear that God approaches people by means of people—which is the essence of ministry. Our attempts to understand ministry are attempts to explain God’s coming, yet human insight and expression are severely limited trying to articulate these things.

    One such attempt is to investigate biblical accounts of how God approached people. Practical theology generally asserts that the gospel is primarily about the kingdom of God that has come and is yet to come. God comes to people by means of the gospel; furthermore, God includes the people to whom he has come and is yet to come in the very act of bringing the kingdom to us. In short, practical theology attempts to put words and descriptions to just how this coming takes place.

    Historically speaking, the church and organized youth work were typically autonomous, and often still are—probably because youth ministry did not really exist before the Industrial Revolution of the mid-19th century.

    Giving names

    In a sense, in fact, the Lord Christ himself is the first Witness of his own person and work. Then the church became the witness about Jesus Christ (and his life, work, crucifixion, resurrection, and ascent), first through the apostles and the first congregation, and primarily by means of the New Testament. Their witness about the Witness is the witness of the early church. And the church remains as the witness of Jesus. In fact, the church’s primary ministry is the witness—in Greek, the marturia—of Jesus Christ. Whatever names are given to the ways in which God comes to people, these ways of coming are a participation in the marturia of Jesus Christ.

    God’s ways of coming by means of his Word and by means of people’s service have traditionally been listed under seven headings; I have added an eighth. In all eight ministries it’s about serving God, serving one another, and serving the world—in all cases, as a community of the faithful. In this way every designated mode of God’s coming is founded on God’s communicative involvement in the church and the world.

    Figure 7. The integration and coordination of ministries in building up the local church

    Notice that there is a unique dimension to God’s coming in each kind of ministry—a dimension that asks to be distinguished. It is this unique dimension of each kind of ministry that must be discovered again and again in the context of Scripture wherever this ministry is referred to. And just as significantly, God comes in these ministries to youths as he does to the church at large (and in ways as yet undiscovered and unnamed in theology).

    Definition of the Inclusive Congregational Approach

    The Inclusive Congregational approach asserts that youth ministry is not a separate or additional mode of God’s coming to the youths—which is why there is not a ninth ministry listed in the above diagram. Youth ministry is not about finding an extra place for yet another ministry, but about finding a place for youths within every ministry and among the people that the ministries are designed to reach and serve—the people to whom God comes by means of the ministries.

    The Inclusive Congregational approach, therefore, is more about finding a place for children and adolescents than about dreaming up new modes of ministry. The modes of ministry are largely fixed, and as such they should be studied and developed as far as possible. The point is, whatever is described and discovered in these modes of ministries is relevant to the youths as well as to the adult congregation. Every ministry in the church is relevant to the youths. Every ministry contains rich potential for youth ministry.

    The task in youth ministry, as is the case in building up the local church, is not to study and describe the ministries as such. Rather, the task is twofold—to sensitize every discipline of ministry for its relevancy to the youths (as part of the whole) and to rediscover and define the place of the youths as part of the congregation. The question then becomes, How can theology and the congregation (in which theology functions) become more sensitive to and aware of the youths? How can the youths become more sensitive to and aware of theology and the congregation as a whole?

    A congregation does not consist only of adults or only of youths. The youths have to be incorporated in every line of thought and received into every part of the ministry.

    In short, how can youths find a place in their church?

    Description of Inclusive Congregational Ministry

    Comprehensive first

    There is no theological reason why what is valid for adults is not valid for the youths. The comprehensive ministry is meant for them as part of the congregation. Yes, there should be differentiation for youths—but once and for all, it is time for us to stop missing this comprehensive and inclusive perspective.

    There is quite enough proof that the traditional idea of youth work grew out of and was fed by congregations, parents, Sunday school teachers (catechists), ministers, elders, and deacons. Yet it failed in taking the youths into account in, and as part of, the congregation. Merton Strommen shows how the impersonal approach in the Lutheran church, reacting to historical events, led to a formal, impersonal, and intellectualized approach to young people by the 1860s—at about the time when many youth leagues came into being. In 1908 a youth committee wrote, “We look forward to the day when we have only the devil and not also our church fathers to fight.”6 Such an approach is counterproductive to a comprehensive, inclusive congregational ministry and its differentiation.

    The absence of such a comprehensive congregational approach has often led to a negative evaluation of the congregation by children and adolescents. In such a case the youths often seek to meet their spiritual needs and worship elsewhere—historically in the youth organizations. The matter of identification with the congregation, which is so crucial to teaching, is important here. It can be said with a great deal of confidence that traditional youth work was fed not only by the Industrial Revolution and the consequent cultural changes, but also by the inability of adult members of congregations who could not (or would not) change or adapt old traditional forms and thought patterns in order to meaningfully integrate the youths into the local church and minister to them as part of the whole. In a sense the church culture, on the one hand, was too paternalistic and legalistic to open up. On the other hand, it was also too evangelically individualistic to appreciate the whole. Some would call it the legacy of the individualistic spirituality of pietism. But it is not that simple either.

    Youth ministry is not about finding an extra place for yet another ministry, but about finding a place for youths within every ministry.

    Within reformed theology the question remains whether the traditional attitudes, which separated youth ministry from the larger life of the church, were not, at least in part, the result of the encyclopedic categorization of theology by Abraham Kuyper. In his work some functions belong to the duties of the “institute,” while others, like evangelization, are the duties of the “organism.” In any case, with or without Kuyper’s help, reformed theology contributed to this worldwide loss of the youths (especially of adolescents) in churches. All communities, countries, and denominations were affected by it, some only sooner than others. During the American youth revolution, Louis Cassels wrote, on the basis of what young people were saying, that the church was losing them because of cold worship services, lack of involvement, and phoniness.7

    In my own country, South Africa, the question is whether we are not, for the first time in our history, involved in a similar kind of revolution.8 Until 1994 cultural groups were stabilized in an artificial way under the government; still, however, the disappointment of young people in the adult section of the church seldom led to a large-scale withdrawal from catechesis. And this disappointment frequently resulted in youths who, however active they had been in youth ministry and church, became mere spectators. They did what their religious community expected of them—confirmation—and then departed. It was almost like what had occurred in Germany, where the sacrament was often referred to as being “confirmed out of the church.”

    When Christian youths have no reason to value their congregations, they often meet their spiritual needs and worship elsewhere—historically in youth organizations outside the church.

    After 1994, however, everything changed in South Africa. Disillusioned white young people find it more and more difficult to see the past through the eyes of those who shaped it. Poverty, frustration, and unrealistic expectations of youths are still serious tests for the churches. Ministry to the youths has probably just begun.

    Even well-intentioned churches, in South Africa or anywhere, can be disloyal to the nature of Christ’s congregation, and this unfaithfulness is rationalized in all kinds of ways—as in expecting children and adolescents to grow up (to an age determined by adults) before they can share in what Christ is and has done for his congregation and participate in the comprehensive ministry entrusted by Christ to his congregation.

    This kind of church, firstly, loses the youths and shoves them into the arms of any person or organization that cares and treats them like they’re important. Secondly, such a church rears a generation—even generations—of adults with whom the youths don’t want to identify or associate. And this can be fatal to the identity formation of the youths and their faith development.

    Comprehensive, but differentiated and focused

    Differentiation in youth ministry refers to at least two levels:

  • Youths need all that adults need, but there is a difference between how to feed a need in a 10-year-old and how to feed that same need in a 50-year-old. One has to differentiate within the ministry.
  • Characteristics of youths at different ages or at different development levels must be taken into account.
  • Youth ministry is not a separate or different ministry. It does, however, take into account that which is typical of a specific ministry and what is typical of the specific age group at whom the ministry is directed. For example, in youth ministry, preaching is still preaching, but it is focused on and directed at the youths. This focus is determined by the youths’ phase of life and the needs peculiar to that phase.

    In an inclusive congregational approach, then, youth ministry is at the very least the mediation of the coming of God to the youths as integral and vital parts of the congregation, through his Word and through the service of people, by means of all modes of ministry, in a differentiated and focused way.

    Modes of Youth Ministry

    Kerugma—preaching

    Through kerugma, God comes to the congregation and, in a differentiated and focused way, to the youths. The youths must be considered in the preaching ministry of a church—they must figure into the preacher’s agenda or text. Preachers who “think youth” and routinely take them into account on an everyday basis will do the same when they step into the pulpit to preach. The kerugma has to enter the here and now of the youths and proclaim the new reality that has arrived with Christ’s coming. The youths (children and adolescents) should also be summoned by the kerugma to a new existence.

    Youths must be considered in the preaching ministry of a church—they must figure into the preacher’s agenda or text.

    Of course, the better the preacher’s textbook delivery and dynamics, the more relevant the message will be for the youths. Modern insights in homiletics—insights that emphasize the dialogical character of the sermon—all these make the sermon that much more meaningful for youths. Almost by definition children and adolescents are people for dialogue, because they are relational in nature.

    Leitourgia—worship service

    The gathered congregation is the basic form of the functioning of the congregation and its ministries.9 Where people, on the basis of the leitourgia of Christ, enter into the presence of God, there is a dynamic that no one should deny the youths. They should never miss out on it. They should be an integral and a vital part of it. If this mode has stagnated as a result of unchanging liturgical agendas, the fault is not in the leitourgia mode itself; the fault should be identified and corrected in a practical theological way in the subdiscipline of liturgy.

    It is important to state here that liturgy is the corporate encounter between God and his people—including the youths. Like anywhere else in the life of the congregation, the young and the old need each other in worship, too. For worship is rich in potential for the youths. The use of symbols, for example, is no less beneficial for youths than it is for the rest of the congregation.

    A congregation’s willingness to be relevant to the youths during worship services may have more far-reaching consequences than any other mode of ministry. To be contemporary as well as traditional is no easy matter.

    Didache—teaching

    Youth ministry is about those who have just joined the (relatively) older people on the road of Yahweh. Initiation into, guidance along, and wise choices for living on the way are part of the congregational ministry to, with, and through the youths. This is the central aspect of the didache: It is about a lifelong commitment to be a disciple, or pupil, of Christ.

    Like other modes of ministry, didache seldom if ever occurs in isolation. It emphasizes that the congregational didache become part of the edification (oikodomein) and training (katartizein) of the people of God to ably represent him as his people in this world. Thus the inclusive congregational approach once again gives integrity to the differentiated focus.

    Paraklesis—pastoral care

    When it comes to children and adolescents, pastoral care may be the most neglected ministry. The youths are at a time in their lives when they especially need all the facets of pastoral care in a congregational context. They need to know that this mode says that God is with us in all circumstances and situations—in anxiety, pain, sin, doubt, error, weakness, loneliness, and success.

    God is with us to free us from the constraints of brokenness that threaten us. Paraklesis wants to lead us out of a life of imperfection and into a life of wholeness in spite of and in the midst of all the brokenness within and around us. Few other modes of ministry explain as well as paraklesis that children and adolescents need all that other believers need, only to a greater extent and in a differentiated, yet focused way.

    Koinonia—mutuality

    Closely related to paraklesis, the mode of God’s coming to people through others is built on this truth: God is with people by means of each other, because in Jesus he came to us in flesh. Through the indwelling of the Spirit, people can live and discover their humanity through one another.

    About the mode itself there is little doubt: Christians are people for one another and are the people of God in their togetherness. This mutuality should be intensely focused on the youths in the congregation. Children and adolescents need more community than that provided by one’s immediate family, as important as family is.10 Young lives can mature fully within a climate of koinonia. Much has been written on this subject; it is enough to say that the youths need koinonia as part of the whole, and in a focused way.

    Diakonia—service

    The term diakonia underwent its own development throughout history.11 Diakonia was a comprehensive term that denoted everything in which humans were involved in the name of God. In Scripture, for instance, the term is used to show that individuals find the fulfillment of their calling in service. Diakonia, therefore, is the umbrella term for all that the congregation does, for all its ministries. What we today call modes of ministry was, in the first century, simply the diakonia of the congregation. The term refers to an activity performed out of love for God for the sake of one’s fellow man—so much so that it is called a service of love. It is easy to understand how the term changed to refer mainly to the ministry of care: in acts of caring and deeds of mercy the diakonia finds special expression.

    Children and adolescents need more community than that provided by one’s immediate family, as important as family is.

    Among the youths there is a striking, characteristic selfishness that is almost antiserving—yet at the same time, there is a paradoxical readiness to serve in a way that befits their phase of life. Strommen has determined in his empirical studies, in fact, that the youths have a specific inclination to a service-oriented life.12 This mode is therefore about involving the youths, at their level of maturity for certain kinds of service, in the comprehensive service of the congregation in this world. They are, after all, part of the ministering body of Christ—even now. Congregations should therefore continually discover, cultivate, and live their identity as the serving people of God, and at the same time involve the youths in service suitable to their age. In this way the diakonia becomes the central mode of the serving ministries of the congregation—including its ministries that serve children and adolescents.

    Marturia—witness

    The church is to be understood in missionary perspective, not because it is the primary activity of the church, but because we know that God is constantly involved in bringing wholeness—that is, salvation—to his creation. The missio Dei includes the missio ecclesia. The congregation participates in and is involved in the missio Dei, and in this way: the church is not the one who sends, but rather the one who is sent.13 This sentness is therefore not one of the results of being a church, but a prerequisite. It is a characteristic of the true church. To understand that youths are an integral and a vital part of the church is to understand that they are also an integral and a vital part of the congregation’s mission. And this congregational raison d’être can only be understood as missionary in nature.

    This essential sentness of the entire church, youths included, carries many implications. Sermons cannot urge congregations to let themselves be sent; sermons must address people who are being sent. The local church should not minister as if some of their number may be called to be witnesses, but as if all are already witnesses.

    All that has to be understood is that this marturia also has to be relevant to the peculiar needs and characteristics of each age group. One witnesses to a 10-year-old differently than to an adult. Furthermore, a 10-year-old witnesses to others differently than an adult does. This mode of God’s coming to and through the congregation includes the youths and should be differentiated with an eye to their missionary involvement.

    Kubernesis—administration

    The ministry of the management and administration of the congregation is usually explained with a helmsman term, cybernesis (1 Corinthians 12:28). The early church was often contemporarily described as a ship with Christ himself as the helmsman. This cybernesis ministry is related to a strongly pastoral term for leadership, used in Romans 12. It connotes a pastoral ministry of care and empathy, which was the duty of the leading members of the early church.14 This ministry is about caring guidance in the name of the Helmsman, and implies an orderly and appropriate journey toward a destination (1 Corinthians 14). The unity and the edification of the congregation should be served in this way.

    What reason is there that a congregation’s youths should not be part of this? Granted, their interest in complicated regulations is weak, and they are typically unconcerned about dogma and administration. Still, an inclusive congregational approach asserts that youths should not, even for these reasons, be excluded from this aspect of church life. They need it for healthy growth and development as part of the whole. When administration makes sense and is handled in a pastoral manner, the youths often surprise the older generation with their abilities and insights into this ministry.

    A special focus on parents

    In the theological justification below (see Hermeneutic Perspective, page 16), the family is referred to as the basic hermeneutic lebensraum, in which God comes to the youths (both children and adolescents). Parents are primary mediators in the relationship (or covenant) between God and families, and as such are key in the roles that humans play in the coming of God to children. Not that families are exclusively important or that people outside of caring biological or custodial families are at a spiritual disadvantage. My point is only that youth ministry should be evangelically realistic and open to pivotal roles that parents can play in the lives of youths.

    Yet even families require intensive and focused attention. Where natural family ties are lacking, youth ministry once again requires intensive attention to the founding of other relationships that can facilitate growth and development. Each child that is ministered to, is ministered to with an eye to the founding of a future family. Not that procreation is the goal of youth ministry, but that reinforcing relationships is part of the goal—and for this the family remains the ideal lebensraum and structure.

    Youth ministry, therefore, is differentiated also in the way it focuses on parents. This insight, fortunately, is generally acknowledged in youth ministry.

    A theological definition

    In light of the above modes, then, the definition of youth ministry can be further refined to this: Youth ministry is a comprehensive congregational ministry in which God comes, through all forms of ministry and with especial regard to parents (or their substitutes), with a differentiated focus to youths (as an integral part of the congregation), and also with and through the youths in the congregation to the world.

    It’s as if God thinks ecclesiologically. He makes it clear that the person who belongs to him is part of his people. This principle is absolutely conclusive in youth ministry.

    Theological Justification

    The Bible, children, and other young people

    As the Bible is no manual for liturgy, it is likewise no manual for youth ministry. On the other hand, as the Bible offers direction to liturgy, so it points the way for youth ministry. My purpose in this section is not so much to prove that an Inclusive Congregational ministry is biblical (I attempt to answer that elsewhere in this chapter), but that Scripture does indeed contain theological insights about children and adolescents.

  • God is involved in a special way in the giving of children. Children are “a reward from him” (Psalm 127:3; cf. Psalm 128; Psalm 139:14–16). Children are no surprise to God—though their conception may be a surprise to their parents.
  • Not only is God involved in conception, but also with the born. He is the God of their parents, and he wants to be their God as well (cf. Genesis 17). Even the outcast’s cry is heard by him (Genesis 21:17) though the promised one has just been born (Genesis 21:2). When the poet sings about the power of God, it is part of his prayer that sons should grow high, like plants, and that daughters should stand firm and beautiful, like pillars (Psalm 144:12; Psalm 115:14–15).
  • God involves children and young people in his coming to his people. It pleases him to use children when approaching people, for they are a special part of religious ceremonies. The Passover meal and the instruction in the Deuteronomist (Deuteronomy 6), for example, are strong evidence of this. They are conversationally involved in these events and are not mere receivers of information. They are also present at the sacrifice (1 Samuel 1:4).
  • Youths are included when God deals with people outside the community of his covenant people. A young girl tells Naaman’s wife of the prophet in her own country (2 Kings 5:2–3). David is probably in his mid-teens when he becomes involved in God’s dealings with Israel, and at this age he is anointed to become king of Israel (1 Samuel 16–17). According to some, Daniel is an early adolescent when he refuses, at the table of the king himself, to eat and drink what is set before him (Daniel 1:8). There are many instances of children and young people being included by God in his dealings with people.
  • A hallmark of Jesus’ ministry on earth was how he manifested both existing and ancient views of God—and he did no less when it came to youths. God loves children, and Jesus confirmed this in his care for them. He maintained their rights over and against anyone who caused them to stumble (Matthew 18:1–14; 19:13–15). Only here and now in Christ is God’s love for children fully recognized.
  • The New Testament also emphasizes the importance of the youths in the acts of God. Young men are involved in the first tragic and disciplinary act in the early church (Acts 5). Children knelt together with their parents during a prayer meeting for a departing apostle (Acts 21:5), and unmarried daughters are said to have the gift of prophecy (Acts 21:9).
  • These examples are not mandates and directives, but merely instances of God’s dealings with and through children and other young people. Again, the Bible is not a book about youths, but about God and his dealings with people—and the youths are essentially a part of these people. What God did and still does, he also does for, with, and through the youths (as a part of his people). That is why the Bible is as rich in principles for youth ministry as it is in principles for any other ministry.

    And what are some of these principles?

    Covenantal/Relational Perspective

    It is clear from the Bible that God created humankind, binding himself forever to people as his creation. Although man often rebelled and pushed away the Creator’s hand, God remains true to his creation. According to the Bible, this relationship was seriously damaged—broken off by humans themselves, one could say. One could also say that the relationship was reinstated from God’s side. The Bible is clear about this: God was and is always a saving God, healing those with whom he deals. God is involved with creation and humankind by means of grace that repairs and restores what is broken. And this restoration can be understood only in a covenantal way, for at the root of restoration are relationships—relationships with God, with one’s fellow beings, and with creation itself.

    These things become clear in the reading of God’s dealings with Abraham. First, there is God’s initiative—he begins, he maintains, and he completes what he has started in and through Abraham. The story and its every detail is fitted into this scheme. God binds himself to a human being, to a stranger from a foreign land. It is this binding—this bond or covenant—that is so important for the theological grounding of youth ministry. God wants to make himself known to persons and their descendants, not just for their sake, but by means of them (Genesis 12:7; 22:18; Galatians 4). In this we again see God’s devotion as Creator to his creation (cf. Genesis 9).

    The most natural form of relationship is the biological or custodial family. God is indeed the God of households; in a unique way he is known within the hermeneutic sphere of the family.

    The nations—that it, those who do not (yet) know, love, and serve God—are his goal. God never discards what he has made. His plan to take creation toward its fulfillment is on the agenda. Through a human being—here, Abraham—and his descendants, God’s uniqueness as Creator-God is again acknowledged and confessed before the nations.

    All of which places youth ministry not only in a relational perspective, but also in a missional and ecological one.

    Within this relationship (or covenant, or contract) God commits himself to be a God for people, and he wants humankind to commit their humanity to him. The nature of this contract is that God has a covenantal right to humankind—but the covenant also stipulates that humankind has the right to address God.

    The biblical account of the Abrahamic covenant is not merely an intriguing pattern for youth ministry. Youth ministry is veritably rooted in these truths. God founded the relationship between Christ and humans through his Spirit—a relationship for children and young people as well as adults. To be active in youth ministry is nothing less than working with youths in the name of this God.

    After all, God has always been dealing with youths. He has kept them in mind from the very beginning. Parents and others need merely get into line with what he has been doing all along. Youth ministry is to be taken up into and involved in the covenantal dealings of God with children and young people—borne by the certain knowledge that God has covenantally attached himself to dealings with and through them.

    In a congregation both the 15-year-old and the 60-year-old observe change in each other—and both note that some changes are painful.

    Ecclesiological/Somatic Perspective

    How does God deal with his people?

    From the inception of the covenant and all that followed in its wake, it is clear that God begins with one person, but his aim is the many. From the One comes the sand of the sea and the stars of heaven. Out of the One the whole is born. When the whole is established, the one is part of the whole. The one is not absorbed by the whole, but is taken up into it. The importance of the one is related to the whole, and it does not stand detached from and independent of the whole.

    In Pauline terms the individual members of a body are what make the body function as an entity. Independent of the church and alone, however, the one loses its importance. As part of the whole, the one is irreplaceable. One could therefore say that God thinks somatically, or corporately. He takes pleasure in the wonder of the unity of his people. Their unity is a witness to his glory. In this way the restoration to wholeness attains its peak. God restores to relatedness. The covenant, relational in its essence, leads to further relatedness—relatedness to God and others.

    This corporate thinking of the Bible is striking. Families, groups, and nations all play a significant role. It’s as if God thinks ecclesiologically, thinks in terms of his gathered people, his assembly. He makes it clear that the person who belongs to him is part of his people.

    This principle is absolutely conclusive in youth ministry; furthermore, it provides the ministry with integrity. Youth ministry is often threatened by individualism—which is to say, by a lack of insight into the corporate purpose and dealings of God. Maintaining this theological principle in youth ministry is not always easy. Yet it must not be compromised. Even where the corporate character of this ministry is understood, it often leads to yet another form of individualism—denominationalism—which deprives youth ministry of a necessary ecumenical perspective and respect for the larger corpus.

    Many so-called parachurch and interdenominational youth organizations would never have been necessary if congregations had been willing to change and fulfill their calling.

    This theological departure point is admitted by more and more leaders in youth ministry. Wesley Black calls this a building block: “the church as the basic unit for ministry.”15 This is hardly new, only forgotten and neglected. In answering why youth ministry is necessary, G. E. Ludwig states twice (almost as if it were self-evident) that the congregation is important and that young people should be integrated into the life of the church.16

    There is no space here to explain why and how youth ministry evolved into something apart from or appended to the congregation. Suffice to say that there are no theological grounds for this false dichotomy. Children and adolescents are an indispensable part of the congregation. Like all other members, they are part of the congregation, and as such they are a congregational responsibility. W. R. Myers writes that the—

    …key to a church’s faithful youth ministry is the presence of faithing adults who incarnate God’s love in genuine, appropriate ways. Faithing describes the intentional and appropriate activities of those who embody God’s love…. While the presence of such individuals (the faithing individuals) is critical, no less important is…Collective Incarnation, i.e., the presence of the gathered body of Christ, the congregation, the community of the faithful.17

    Hermeneutic Perspective:

    The Family as Hermeneutic Sphere

    Within this ecclesiological sphere (lebensraum), there is a smaller unit to which God grants, in a special way, the hermeneutic function: the family. One could say that the child needs parents in order to gain understanding. The Passover meal is a unique example (cf. Exodus 12; see also the well-known reference to families and faith education in Deuteronomy 6). Children must understand who God is and how he deals with people. When the story of God’s dealings with his people comes from the people whom youths are supposed to listen to first and can trust, a story makes more sense.

    Children ask questions and parents answer—this pattern is so children can learn that “the Lord brought us out of Egypt with a mighty hand” (Deuteronomy 6:20). What today’s parents once heard as children from their parents, they recount to their own children, telling the upcoming generation of “the praiseworthy deeds of the Lord, his power and the wonders he has done” (Psalm 78:3, 4).

    Within this hermeneutic sphere of family life, one learns and gradually understands in a relatively spontaneous and natural way. Certainly, God is not restricted to a domestic context, and insight is available in countless other contexts. God is not limited to the family when he wants to enlighten someone. Yet he has offered the family as primary hermeneutic sphere, and it pleases him to grant an understanding of who he is and how he acts within the security and intimacy of a family.

    Our era requires a special sensitivity to the crisis of families. Thousands of children are born into single-parent or blended families. Thousands are born each year with scarcely any kind of family connections. Youth ministry must take these facts into account. The emphasis on the family as a hermeneutic principle should in no way be used to cause hurting people to hurt even more, nor to create the idea that one who is born into a family has a head start on grace.

    When I say that the family is a hermeneutic sphere, I mean only that God in his wisdom works in the realm of relationships (as biblical accounts of his covenantal dealings with people underscore), and the parent-child relationship is the most natural relationship. Where ties between fathers, mothers, and children are deficient for whatever reasons, God still works within primary relationships; relationships other than parent-child ones can take up the slack. In many cultures the extended family often plays this role. Many African churches often function on this basis. In industrialized societies the congregation as extended family is typically an unnoticed and underused support system; yet there are other ways of making up for the deficiency—as in daycare centers and preschools. The integrating approach to relational groups in local churches holds great promise for the development of the congregation as an extended family.

    Relationship is the password to understanding, and the most natural form of relationship is the biological or custodial family. God is indeed the God of households. In a unique way he is known within the hermeneutic sphere of the family. Here a lived and shared faith in God plays a crucial role in the understanding of him by the next generation.

    Lifestyle Perspective:

    The Congregation as the Sphere for Change

    Nobody is ever finished in the sense of being changed into perfection. Yet every adolescent is a total person and must be accepted and respected as such. The development of a person into someone who can represent God anew, as the Creator originally visualized him, is in continual process. As people in Christ, we are new creations—an irrefutable fact. We are becoming what we already are in him. God created the end in the beginning and he has already begun to realize this end for which he created everything. In fact, in a sense he starts with the end. In another sense he ends at the beginning. Perhaps it is for this reason that he has never tired of starting anew with people.

    Theology perceives change in lifestyle as a work of the Holy Spirit. And in a congregation, God has created a sphere in which change ought to be normal, where growth ought to be axiomatic. Those who don’t change, who remain the same, ought to feel uncomfortable and out of step. Conversion (in its catechetic sense, at least) ought to be a normal, daily thing for all members of a faith community. Among those who have been longer in the faith, it may be no longer a fundamental change—the change may instead be a process of increasing awareness, of insight, of choice. Myers uses the verb faithing to underline his belief that the concept is more than a noun—“more of a total lifestyle than a commodity to be possessed, more of a process than a product.”18

    Leadership and parents must return to the drawing board—this time, with the youths. Together, an Inclusive Congregational approach and its consequences must be thought through and worked out.

    The congregation motivates and facilitates growth and change. Here the 15-year-old and the 60-year-old observe change in each other—and both note that some changes are painful. People do not become who they are in Christ without a struggle. Sometimes the struggle against sin is a bloody one. Myers writes of the older members, whom he calls “guarantors,” as those who are “appropriately anchored in adulthood but who will walk with youths on their journey. Guarantors share the burden of the journey, help read the road maps and offer encouragement.” As W. H. Hebbard says: “For this the congregation and also the pastors should be willing often to confess: ‘I don’t know all the answers, but I am here to cry with you’ and…a new definition of valid, God-blessed ministry awaits.”19 The congregation is in many ways a mediating structure.

    To change, one needs others. Of course one needs God, the Complete Other, but one also needs others who have been changed by God. For one of the reasons God changed them was in order to change others through them. This is the missional aspect: the congregation grows so that, through them, others and creation can become what God meant them to be. The Holy Spirit binds the congregation to Christ so that the congregation can demonstrate a Christ-existence. In this way it becomes a change motivated by the love of Christ (cf. 2 Corinthians 5:11–21). And love is always partial: it defends the voiceless and the deprived, the sick and the poor, slaves and exiles, orphans and strangers.

    The dynamics of rapidly changing young people raise two questions for the rest of the congregation: Will the congregation also be willing to change, and will its changes be encouraged and facilitated? A changing congregation naturally invites the youths who are changing and who seek change to “[be] transformed into his likeness with ever-increasing glory, which comes from the Lord, who is in the Spirit” (2 Corinthians 3:18).

    When youth ministry takes this basic theory as a departure point, it will “create a context in which faith can be awakened, supported, and challenged.”20

    At this point, the creation of change-friendly situations within the congregation becomes crucial.

    Changes Required in the Church

    Being built as a part of the whole

    In a sentence, youth ministry is all about building Christ’s congregation to the glory of God. Those who confess that glory care for each other, and are cared for. Those who do not as yet confess faith in Christ, are cared for on behalf of God and are ministered to with a view toward becoming whole. Within the congregation each age group is incorporated into this building process. And in this multifunctioning body, youth in itself disqualifies no one from contributing to the building up of the church. The only qualification is the confession that Jesus Christ is Lord.

    The youths should therefore be built up as a part of the whole. They are in no way a group whose equipping should take place apart from the center of the congregation. A church’s youth ministry is not a mere supplement to the whole, but as much of the essence of the congregation as any other age group.

    The congregation plays a pivotal part in youth ministry. I am convinced that many so-called parachurch and interdenominational youth organizations would never have been necessary if the congregations had been willing to change and fulfill their calling. In part the congregation provides continuity for youth and provides a spiritual home in which to seek shelter.

    “The youths, time after time, have responded to genuine warmth and care evidenced by adults in the faith community.”21

    Critical changes required

    What we need in order to become fully functioning local church families again is nothing less than a change of mind and heart. This should start with a church’s leadership—ideally, with the senior pastor, for this is nothing less than ecclesiological reformation. As history has taught us, no reformation is without a price—and most reformers were considered heretics, at least for some time. The reformation I am suggesting is against the grain of individualistic Western culture, where materialism and comfort—to the point of narcissism—are inclined to determine our understanding of God’s will for his people.

    The challenge for leadership and parents is to return to the drawing board—this time, with the youths. Together, an Inclusive Congregational approach and its consequences must be thought through and worked out. Many churches are doing just this. As they listen and search together, something begins to happen.

    Though not quickly. In my own church it took a decade before the firstfruits were enjoyed. It started with the conviction of a few members of the youth committee. Many long discussions took place over several years. “We know our youths are an integral part of this local body of believers, but where are they?” we kept asking. When changes finally started, they happened fast and often simultaneously: a realization of who we are in principle (including youths as an integral part), and the empirical fact that they are obviously absent and apathetic. So our first practical step was to instill in our Sunday school teachers and parents the concept that young people are an integral part of our church. Soon, almost at the demand of the parents, a family worship service was started in the church hall—at the same time as the traditional Sunday morning service. “Why is this family worship service not in the sanctuary?” I asked. “The youths need the symbols of worship even more than the adults who are meeting in the sanctuary do.” The family worship service is now held in the sanctuary.

    Then their Sunday school classes moved to meet on Sunday afternoons, and the adolescents developed under the leadership of two of the local pastors at their own vibrant, but very traditional, worship service in the evening. And many parents attend.

    Meanwhile, the congregation at large kept thawing, too. Small groups sprouted in the church: youth groups, target groups, family clusters. The church restructured its ministry to the world. Because of a now-well-established basic philosophy to youth ministry, the youths are part of these ministries. Sometimes youths go out by themselves to visit and help the urban poor; other times they join the efforts of the whole church.

    We have a long way to go, but I can see it happen before my eyes: children and adolescents are developing a sense of belonging and awareness of being an integral part of their body of believers. Almost spontaneously, they are cared for, and they in turn care for each other. They are being respected for who they are, not how old they are.

    The inclusive congregational approach is not for the faint of heart. It takes a lot of courage and faith. After all, you will have to deal with long-established myths in the minds of many of the congregation. It is, however, a challenge of hope and of faithfulness to the gospel.

    Notes

    1. I deliberately distinguish between children, adolescents, and youths (by which term I mean both children and adolescents).

    2. It should be mentioned that several terms have been used in the course of history for this ministry. Of the most familiar are youth work, youth care, Jugendpastoral, and shaping young people. In this book I have chosen the term youth ministry, which I deem most comprehensive. It is most commonly used in the Anglo-Saxon world to describe this ministry. From time to time the English term youth work has also been used to describe what is here called youth ministry.

    3. Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Gesammelte Schriften. Vol. 3. (Munich: Kaiser, 1960), 292–293.

    4. K. Beyer, Gemeinde Jugendarbeit (Wuppertal: Brockhaus, 1978), 7.

    5. Sara Little, Youth, World, and the Church (Richmond: John Knox, 1968), 11.

    6. M. P. Strommen, Profiles of Youth (Saint Louis, Missouri: Concordia, 1963), 3.

    7. L. Cassels, Forbid Them Not (Independence, Missouri: Independence, 1973), 8–9.

    8. B. B. Haldenwang, “South African Youths in Crisis: Facing the Future,” Occasional Paper 24 (1994); F. van Z. Slabbert, Youths in the New South Africa: Towards Policy Formulation (Pretoria: HSRC, 1994).

    9. J. Firet, Dynamics in Pastoring (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1986), 82.

    10. See M. P. Strommen, Five Cries of Youth (1974, reprint. San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1979), 33. (For his “cry of psychological orphans.”)

    11. See Collins (1990).

    12. Strommen, xi.

    13. D. J. Bosch, Transforming Mission (Maryknoll: Orbis, 1991), 389ff.

    14. B. Reicke and G. W. Bromiley, trans., “Proisteimi,” Theological Dictionary of the New Testament, G. Friedrich (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1968), 6:700–703.

    15. Wesley Black, An Introduction to Youth Ministry (Nashville: Broadman, 1991), 15.

    16. G. E. Ludwig (1979:37). See also 1988:18–37.

    17. W. R. Myers (1987:xviii).

    18. Myers, xviii.

    19. D. W. Hebbard, The Complete Handbook for Family Life Ministry in the Church (Nashville: Thomas Nelson, 1995), 15.

    20. R. R. Osmer, Teaching for Faith (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1992), 15.

    21. M. Marshall, “A Rich Heritage,” Affirmation 2, no. 1 (1989), 37–48.

    REFERENCES

    Beyer, K. Gemeinde Jugendarbeit. Wuppertal: Brockhaus, 1978.

    Black, W. An Introduction to Youth Ministry. Nashville: Broadman, 1991.

    Bonhoeffer, D. Gesammelte Schriften. Dritter Band. München: Kaiser, 1960.

    Bosch, D. J. Transforming Mission. Maryknoll: Orbis, 1991.

    Brierley, P. Reaching and Keeping Teenagers. Tunbridge Wells: MARC, 1993.

    Cassels, L. Forbid Them Not. Independence, Missouri: Independence, 1973.

    De Vries, M. Family-based Youth Ministry. Downers Grove, Illinois: InterVarsity Press, 1994.

    Firet, J. Het agogisch moment in het pastoraal optreden. Kampen: Kok, 1977.

    image. Dynamics in Pastoring. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1986.

    Foley, G. Family-Centered Church. Kansas City: Sheed & Ward, 1995.

    Gilbert, W. K., ed. Confirmation and Education. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1969.

    Haldenwang, B. B. “South African Youths in Crisis: Facing the Future.” Occasional paper 24. Stellenbosch Institute for Future Research, 1994.

    Hebbard, D. W. The Complete Handbook for Family Life Ministry in the Church. Nashville: Thomas Nelson, 1995.

    Little, Sara. Youth, World, and the Church. Richmond: John Knox, 1968.

    Marshall, M. “A Rich Heritage.” Affirmation 2, no. 1 (1989): 37–48.

    Nel, M. Jeug en evangelie. Pretoria: NGKB, 1982.

    image. Die Jeugbeleid. Bloemfontein: AJK, 1983.

    image. “Kerklike bediening aan die jongmens.” Kerkjeug Antwoord, ed. M. Nel. Pretoria: NGKB, 1985.

    image. “Die kind en die Bybel 2. ‘n Benaderde oplossing.” NGTT 32, no. 4 (1991): 631–643.

    image. Gemeentebou. Halfway House: Orion, 1994.

    Osmer, R. R. Teaching for Faith. Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1992.

    Procksch, O. “The Word of God in the Old Testament.” Theological Dictionary of the New Testament,Vol. 2, 90ff, ed. G. Kittel. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1967.

    Reicke, B. and G. W. Bromiley, trans. “Proisteimi.” Theological Dictionary of the New Testament, by G. Friedrich. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1968. 6:700–703.

    Richards, L. O. Youth Ministry: Its Renewal in the Local Church. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1978.

    image. A Theology of Children’s Ministry. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1983.

    Sell, C. M. Family Ministry. Revised Edition. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1995.

    Senter III, M. H. “Axioms of Youth Ministry.” The Complete Book of Youth Ministry. W. S. Benson and M. H. Senter, III. Chicago: Moody, 1987.

    Slabbert, F. van Z. Youths in the New South Africa: Towards Policy Formulation. Pretoria: HSRC, 1994. Strommen, M. P. Profiles of Youth. Saint Louis, Missouri: Concordia, 1963.

    image. Five Cries of Youth. 1974. Reprint. San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1979.

    image and A. I. Strommen Five Cries of Parents. San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1985.

    Trimmer, E. A. Youth Ministry Handbook. Nashville: Abingdon, 1994.

    Van der Ven, J. A. and W. J. Berger. “Analysen van gesprekken met jongeren.” Graven naar geloof. Assen:Van Gorcum, 1976.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑