Chapter 10 of 27

Response from an Inclusive Congregational perspective Malan Nel

Response from an Inclusive Congregational perspective Malan Nel

Response to the Preparatory Approach from an Inclusive Congregational Perspective

by Malan Nel

When I read your chapter, Wesley, I was once again excited about the possibilities of equipping God’s people for ministry. Your chapter is very much in line with what was called catechism teaching during and after the Reformation. Being part of this tradition, I enjoyed your exploration of the approach. If I may quote one of your sentences around which I would like to build my discussion with you: “It was Ephesians 4:11–16 played out before my eyes.”

Would you agree that a sad thing that happened was the development of a false dichotomy between equipping older people and Sunday school for children, on the one hand, and integrating youths into the full life and work of the total body of believers? In a way this led to a schism between being prepared for service, and service itself—and we have ended up with an adult membership who are involved in ministry in few ways. Isn’t the intention in Ephesians 4 different? The total ministry is aimed at katartizein of the people of God “for works of service, so that the body of Christ may be built up” (Ephesians 4:12).

In your article you focus more on the discipleship metaphor, which of course explains the same truth. Whether we approach ministry from that angle or from the Pauline view-point, the fact is that we prepare people for ministry or for works of service. Why do you think we have created a gap between adults and children in this regard? Is it possible that we deem young believers unworthy of being equipped and only worthy of being kept busy?

I am concerned that people might view the Preparatory approach as just another way of reaffirming an outmoded educational paradigm—especially if this approach is paired up with a theological departure point that is authoritarian and propositional in nature.

What I point out here is not intended as a critique, but only to emphasize some points of yours that may enrich our attempt to get churches back into a comprehensive ministry of preparing children and adolescents for life and for ministry.

Old Testament moments

The background of the teaching ministry of the church lies in the Old Testament. The teaching concept involves three vital moments: initiation, guidance, and instruction in the way of wisdom.1 In Jewish thought, life is seen as a way with a destination. Education is seen as the unfolding of life, giving it direction and meaning. In this context the Torah was not really viewed as the law of a far-away lawgiver, but as the ever-present voice of the God who cares and wants to give guidance in this unfolding of life. “It points out the way, offers guidance on the road,” writes Firet. “It is the word of revelation in which God comes to a person.”2

In order to sell this important and essential approach in youth ministry, should we not go a little deeper in the discovery of what preparation for life is? I am concerned that people might view the Preparatory approach as just another way of reaffirming an outmoded educational paradigm—especially if this approach is paired up with a theological departure point that is authoritarian and propositional in nature. I believe you would agree that what we want is to revitalize the ministry of katartizein, as explained to us in Ephesians 4 and through the metaphor of discipleship. In my own tradition, it is the older members that would identify with the Preparatory approach as you describe it, because they see it as getting back the old Sunday school they grew up with. This is probably not your intention. The norm is to prepare youths for life and ministry—to be contextually relevant.

Relational concerns

Secondly, there is the relational aspect of the preparational approach in youth ministry. I share your conviction that there has to be more than relationships. Like you said: “The social events, one-on-one encounters, informal gatherings, and trips that such youth workers plan are aimed at building relationships and fellowship between the leaders and the youths, as well as among the youths themselves. But there has to be more.” Although I know you are not dismissing the importance of relationships, I want to ask you this: given the absolute necessity of pastoral relationships for teaching, should we not explore the relationship and relational and preparational aspects more in-depth?

Preparing youths for life and ministry implies change—and we know that people change only when they feel safe. Without a sense of safety, then, they will resist change—in particular, they will not see our preparational efforts as helpful. In Dynamics in Pastoring, Firet explores this issue in depth: after a psychological and educational exploration, his conclusion is that nurture focuses on the quintessence of being fully human. That is, when we want people to change into fully functioning human beings, they need to be nurtured. If we want to get adolescents involved in this process of becoming what they have been created to be, then a relationship aimed at change (what Firet calls an agogic relationship) is necessary.3 This relationship is essentially a pastoral one and asks for a basic pastoral posture on the part of the nurturers.

My reason for bringing up this line of Firet’s is to make a deduction concerning the approach in your chapter. I often ask myself how it came about that churches can do so much teaching with so little result. Observational research led me to the conclusion that because of the lack of a caring pastoral relationship, teaching has taken place without learning. In church, children and adolescents learn in direct relationship to the measure of care they experience.

How would you respond to this? You probably remember the findings and remarks of Larry Richards concerning advice-giving in youth ministry. “I’ve suggested that a ministry-facilitating relationship,” I remember him writing, “is one in which the adult admits and expresses his equality with youth as persons by encouraging mutual self-revelation and in which youth and adult each learn to trust the other with his thoughts and feelings and experiences, knowing that he is valued and respected.”4

How can churches can do so much teaching with so little result? Because of the lack of a caring pastoral relationship, teaching has taken place without learning. In church adolescents learn in direct relationship to the measure of care they experience.

Ministry-based approach

My third observation has to do with the importance of what you call a ministry-based approach over an activity-based youth ministry. I think you are correct in this distinction. Even our activities should have ministry in focus.

Yet what about providing ministry opportunities that befit age-specific abilities and needs of children and adolescents? I would link this with your strong emphasis on family. Would it be fair to say that, in the long run, not many church youths will do what they have not seen their parents do as Christians? Some say that even up to 80 percent of all youths eventually take over the life and worldview of their parents. And we all know that “works of service” (Ephesians 4:12) is an attitudinal thing and needs to be modeled by significant adults.

Leadership development

Finally, I want to thank you for your words about the organization of leadership in the Preparational approach:

If youth ministry is to multiply and grow, leader development is essential. Volunteers need training and equipping in effective youth ministry knowledge and skills—which can be provided through local workshops, regional and national conferences, printed materials, and multimedia resources. Often prospective leaders learn on the job as they begin working with youths in informal ways and gradually assume more responsibility.

Let me make two observations about this point. First, I assume that you work toward creating an atmosphere for this approach in which the leadership sees a local church as a training unit. If that is the case, I would be in full agreement. When we follow through on your discipleship emphasis, this is inescapable. The basic meaning of the discipleship concept (especially taking its Old Testament root seriously) is not so much following in the sense of imitating but learning (the Greek word manthanein). Being disciples of Christ indeed implies learning. The older but still relevant book of Wilson rightfully carries the title: With Christ in the School of Disciple Building.5

Second, I worry about how easy it is to turn a church into a school, which it is not. Would you agree that a safeguard against this temptation might be to develop the relationship training or service even stronger? This would help distinguish a church from a school—which, ironically, students tend to work to get out of, rather than embrace to become prepared for works of service.

Notes

1. J. Firet, Dynamics in Pastoring (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1986), 53–58. (See his references to well-known Old Testament scholars.)

2. Firet, 55.

3. Firet, 179, 246. See also Duffy Robbins, The Ministry of Nurture (Grand Rapids: Youth Specialties/Zondervan, 1990).

4. L. O. Richards, Youth Ministry, 10th printing (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1978), 139–148.

5. C. Wilson, With Christ in the School of Disciple Building (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1979).

↑ Back to top

↑