Chapter 12 of 27

Response from a Strategic perspective Mark H. Senter III

Response from a Strategic perspective Mark H. Senter III

Response to the Preparatory Approach from a Strategic Perspective

by Mark H. Senter III

As I read through your chapter, Wes, I found a deep love and respect for the church. As you presented your Preparatory approach to youth ministry and the church, certain phrases jumped out at me, each suggesting how you envisioned youth ministry connecting to the local church:

  • “A ministry-based Preparatory approach has a clear purpose for every activity: the development of mature Christians in the church, both now and for the future.”
  • “Youth ministry belongs to the church.”
  • “Youth ministry is everything a church does with, to, and for teenagers.”
  • “Theologically, there may be no division between youths and anyone else in the church.”
  • “The church is the home of youth ministry.”
  • “The purposes of the church are the purposes of youth ministry.”
  • Ownership

    What seems so powerful to me about these statements is the idea of ownership. There is no them and us. It is all we. As you wrote, “There may be no division between youths and anyone else in the church.” The church is the home not only of youth ministry, but also by implication of a wide cross-section of young people as they explore their ties to the family of God. At the same time, the church is home to people of all generations. For youth ministry to be effective, the church has to be vigorous. For such vigor to emerge and be sustained, everyone must have a sense of ownership of all aspects of the ministry.

    Like you, Wes, I have concerns over churches where young people are viewed as problems to be solved. I wish there were more churches where older men (does that mean my age?) grill free hamburgers for unchurched teenagers who hang out in the church parking lot on Saturday nights. Unfortunately, I fear this is an exception rather than the norm.

    Similarly, I worry about churches where young people have little commitment to the ministry as a whole. In these youth ministries, worship means “our” music and instruments. Witness lacks focus beyond “our” friends at school—not even including the families of “our” friends. Stewardship expects the money to support “our” own activities or mission trips. In these churches, adults are seen as obstacles to be avoided.

    In both cases the church is impoverished.

    Laboratory

    Your idea that we view youth ministry as “a laboratory in which disciples can grow in a culture guided by spiritual coaches” is a helpful image. (Especially clever is the ambiguity of your use of culture. We could have some fun imagining a freshman in a petri dish.) One purpose of a laboratory is to allow learners to fail in a safe context and discover specific skills in the process. A lab is a hands-on place, where involvement is essential to learning.

    Even apart from the petri-dish image, however, culture remains ambiguous. Are we talking about the youth culture or the church culture? Perhaps we should add one more: the heavenly or kingdom culture of God. Actually, a youth ministry is richest when young people learn to live in all three. If the youth culture is ignored, the youth ministry becomes inbred, and in time all its genetic flaws (so to speak) cause abnormalities to appear. If the church culture is ignored, especially in this postmodern age, young people lose an opportunity to learn the stories of godly people who have made possible the fellowship they are enjoying. If the culture of God is ignored, young people may assume that the flaws of the other two cultures are normal.

    The image of the laboratory is not that of programs or discipleship. The idea that comes to my mind, Wes, is the idea of experimentation. I think this is what was happening as the disciples followed Jesus through the Galilean countryside. They were not squeezing themselves into an existing system of worshiping Jehovah—the Pharisees had all the formulas for that. Nor were they creating something entirely new—Christ constantly pointed out the continuity between the law and the prophets and his own teaching. What they were doing was trying out fresh ways of discovering and worshiping God. Our Lord called it “new wineskins.”

    Your Preparatory approach carried a new wineskin flavor. Unfortunately, too often the church prefers the old wineskins. I suppose that is why our Lord spent as much time outside the synagogues as in them. I suppose this is where camps, retreats, mission trips, and small groups on the high school campus fit in. They are all laboratories where young people test their Christianity.

    Separate program

    The major question I have, Wes, relates to how this laboratory called youth ministry brings about the growth and maturity you desire. The very nature of a laboratory is that it is a separate place. It is not the real world, but imitates the real world for the purpose of learning and understanding. While it is safe to say, “youth ministry is everything a church does with, to, and for teenagers that builds them into becoming the church,” all you have described is culture (no petri-dish puns this time): the informal educational process through which the values and customs, language and symbols of a population of adults are passed to the next generation.

    Before the Industrial Revolution and even today in small churches and congregations in preindustrial situations (Third World situations primarily), young people learn what it means to be a Christian by living among Christian people. There are no intentional Christian education programs. To rephrase the bumper sticker, learning happens. Culture is the most powerful teacher because the learners do not realize they are learning.

    What I heard you saying, Wes, is that youth ministry is and must be a separate program, but never divorced from the larger church culture. In tribal cultures young boys and girls have well-defined rites of passage as they move from childhood to adulthood—“separate programs,” in essence, intended to initiate children into adulthood. They are within the culture but distinct from the rest of it. In fact, unless you are an adult male, you will never know what is involved in the initiation rite for young boys. The same is true for young women.

    About your idea of youth ministry as a lab: one purpose of a laboratory is to allow learners to fail in a safe context and discover specific skills in the process. A lab is a hands-on place, where involvement is essential to learning.

    One aspect of the initiation rite is a naming process. With the tribal elder’s approval, young boys in particular are given a name that describes or suggests how the boy sees himself. Perhaps that is what the Preparatory approach to youth ministry is all about. It is a naming process, preparing young adults for what they will be in the church. A name change in preparation for ministry is throughout Scripture: Jacob becomes Israel, Simon becomes Peter, Saul becomes Paul. While I do not see the naming process included in your description, I think we both can conceive of a number of places where it has happened informally and could happen formally with the blessing of the faith community.

    But isn’t confirmation, as practiced by many churches, such an initiation, such a naming process? I think not—unless confirmation is transformed into something very different than is usually practiced today. Today confirmation programs most commonly initiate young people out of the church, not into it. After the formal ceremony, young people tend to disappear from the church. I believe the problem is that the confirmation process is designed for just the head, not the whole person.

    Now let me combine the laboratory idea with the initiation rite. If youth ministry is a laboratory that initiates young people into full participation in the faith community, then most of the structures you have described will play a role. As you say, the Preparatory approach will have “a clear purpose for every activity.” Every activity will assist the young person to discover their “new name” and how they will serve the faith community.

    One interesting side benefit of this idea is that it might defuse the arguments of a small but vocal group of former youth workers who claim that adolescence is not a biblical idea and therefore should not be used as a basis for ministering to people during their teenage years. Adolescence is a product of modern education, they claim, and was introduced by G. Stanley Hall in 1905 with the publication of his classic work, Adolescence. But even in the Bible there was a rite of passage from childhood to adult roles, illustrated (in part) by Jesus at age 12 going to the temple for the Feast “according to the custom” (Luke 2:42). If youth ministry is a contemporary expression of this rite of passage, it fits within even this more restrictive view of biblical ministry.

    Changes in the church

    If youth ministry is the church’s primary means of preparing young people for full participation in the faith community, the most important question we can ask is this: What are the values of the faith community? All four authors of this book agree that the three essential functions of the church are ministry to God, ministry to believers, and ministry to the world. If the tribe/church places the highest value on these functions and demonstrates them in the life of the tribe/church, then initiated young people will quickly assume leadership in promoting the same values.

    The five areas of resistance to change in the church, which you cited from Merton Strommen, must be tackled by the adults in the tribe/church before young people have a chance of becoming the church described in Scripture. If Strommen is right (and I fear he is), youth ministry as it is commonly practiced today is highly successful: for the young people who survive their contact with the church and are initiated into the tribe/church demonstrate the same disinclination to change that they learned from the adult community, and for the same reasons: tradition, personality, ideology, affiliation, and demonic power. Young people have very effectively absorbed these negative values and are perpetuating them into the next generation.

    Unfortunately, this is not the kind of success we want. Yet it is not the fault of the youth minister or youth ministry. If we are not comfortable with the values of church youths, the place to look is at the adult members. Three questions about the adult congregation might help focus our understanding of the youth ministry:

  • In what ways do the adults of the congregation minister to God?
  • In what ways and with what frequency do the adults of the congregation minister to Christian people?
  • In what ways and with what frequency do the adults of the congregation minister to people who have no relationship with Jesus Christ?
  • How can we expect younger members of the tribe/church to absorb Christian values that are not a part of the daily life of the church? Certainly, God has used young people to trigger renewal and missionary movements—but those examples are rare and serve as stinging rebukes to the carnality of adult believers.

    While your suggested changes for the church might be small steps in a healthy direction, Wes, I think much more is needed if our young people are to be prepared for a biblical model of what the church is all about. Anything we wish for among our young people must first be true among our adults.

    Conclusion

    I may owe you an apology, Wes, for taking your chapter and building on your definition while ignoring much of your descriptive material. It is my conviction, however, that the Preparatory approach has in its heart a biblical image based in the church that we must explore.

    I must confess, however, I am not optimistic about the willingness of the church to change. Was it Thomas Jefferson who said, “What a democracy needs is a revolution every 20 years”? I would say the same thing about the church—which is why I proposed the Strategic approach to youth ministry. Youth ministries need to become the breeding grounds for baby churches at least once each decade. It is my firm conviction that as churches birth new churches, both become healthier—and the new-generation church quickly takes on a vitality that the parent church could not recapture or perhaps never had.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑