Response from a Missional perspective Chap Clark
Response to the Preparatory Approach from a Missional Perspective
The article on the Preparatory approach to youth ministry was filled with assertions, practical suggestions, and philosophical assumptions that I found helpful and engaging. The many angles of youth ministry—what it is and what it needs to become—made it clear that there is much to be said for seeing youth ministry in a Preparatory way.
Too busy to sin
Your comparison between the activity-based and ministry-based youth ministry philosophies was an important reminder that so many youth ministry programs—maybe even most of them—operate in a knee-jerk, responsive entertainment mode of simply trying to keep the young people in the church. I believe that the article is absolutely correct in its stinging critique of an activity-based ministry that is created without purpose, vision, or strategic structure. Youth ministry must have a driving reason for being that goes beyond a baby-sitting mentality, beyond the need to keep students too busy to sin. Neither raison d’être will have any kind of significant or lasting impact. It is a stretch to even label this kind of thinking “youth ministry.”
Laboratory
Another strength of your argument was your view that youth ministry is a laboratory where the adult leadership functions in the role of spiritual coaches. The Preparatory approach, more than the Inclusive Congregational and Strategic approaches, takes seriously the transitionary realities of adolescence.
When lifespan theorists recognized this eight- to fifteen-year process as a legitimate phase of human life, they acknowledged what people who work with youths had known and experienced for years—this is the only stage of life that is transitionary in essence. The entire phase is one massive transition, from being a relatively sheltered and safe child (ideally, hopefully, usually), whose life and being are defined within the external context of the family system, to living as an interdependent, relatively autonomous adult whose sense of self is determined and ordered from within. In between, the shift from being entirely reliant on outside influences for meaning, security, help, safety, satisfaction, and purpose to learning what it means to take personal responsibility for these things occurs while the teen learns how to function in a society where the “other” matters as well as the self. This shift comprises very difficult sociological and psychological processes. And as the culture fragments, deconstructs, and disavows any commitment to the rising generations’ needs, the adolescent phase has become all the more difficult.
Youth ministry approaches and programs that do not take this complex, varied, and intrinsically dangerous process seriously, by providing an atmosphere of tender nurture, can do more harm to young people even than approaches that ignore them. The tenet that contemporary adolescents need adult coaches is the Preparatory approach’s single most important contribution.
Belongs to the church
In addition, the assertion that “youth ministry belongs to the church” provides a theologically vital scaffolding to the youth ministry task in any church context. Youth ministry should not be delegated to the few, but rather embraced by the entire local expression of the body of Christ. Surely some people will serve as the direct, hands-on expressions of the church’s ministry to the young. But those adults who are not directly involved must be just as committed, just as pro-kid, as any Sunday school teacher or youth worker volunteer, or even paid staff.
Ecclesiological status quo
Yet some of your assertions remained incomplete when compared to the missional mandate of the church as an organism. For example, the Preparatory approach seems to be a relatively traditional one (albeit the best of the traditional) to youth ministry. Programs primarily run by adults…student involvement in decision-making…a church that cares about ministry focused on adolescents—these all add up to what many churches are basically doing already. Some are doing a better job than others, of course, but in general this approach seems to support the ecclesiological status quo of youth ministry, at least from the 1970s onward.
The tenet that contemporary adolescents need adult coaches is the Preparatory approach’s single most important contribution.
My most serious criticism of what seems to me a traditional view of youth ministry, and thus of the Preparatory approach, is the lack of strategic focus on the missional mandate of the church. The goal of theologically appropriate youth ministry, like any ministry, if it is to fulfill the call of our Lord to be his witnesses (Acts 1), must be to “go into the world” (Matthew 28). Granted, the Preparatory approach does have a missional component, but it is far from strategic, is not an explicitly stated out-come of the entire ministry focus, and thus is relegated to the historical yet flawed strategic methodology of “kids bringing friends” to outreach events. The fact is, they usually do not bring friends; when they do, the friends they bring are almost always the kind of students already inclined to church involvement without the goad of evangelistic and strategic energy. The Preparatory approach edges closely to the reason why the church of the last 50 years has suffered: there is little strategic commitment to the “going” mandate of the gospel.
Take, for example, the adult church members who cooked the hamburgers for the students who were hanging out in the church parking lot. The effort was admirable, the reported initial results exciting, and as a result the church patted itself on the back for being concerned for the lost youths. But upon closer examination, this ministry arose and functioned more out of knee-jerk compassion than theologically reflective strategy for mission. You assert that “under the banner of youth ministry is anything that a congregation does that touches the lives of teenagers in any way, formally or informally.” So this desire to cook some hamburgers implicitly falls “under the banner” of the youth ministry.
But this anecdote illustrates a tremendous flaw in traditional youth ministry. A real need of young people ignited a programmatic response out of a strategic context of the youth ministry program. So faced with this event, which on the surface has a missional component to it, I am full of questions: What happened to those kids? Who followed up with them? How were they assimilated into the youth ministry? Into the church? Your article states that this gesture “opened a lot of conversations and friendship with the kids who parked there,” but did it strategically draw these adolescents into the family of faith? And, if so, how?
I believe that the church can learn a great deal from the Preparatory approach to youth ministry. But prepared to what?
Prepared to what…?
I believe that the church can learn a great deal from the Preparatory approach to youth ministry. But prepared to what? The most significant preparation must prepare young people to become integral and committed believers. This implies, as presented by Jesus himself in John 15, a connection to the Vine and expressing that connection with a willingness to love the body. Then the church is ready and able to program and strategize what it means to be Christ’s witnesses to the world (Acts 1). I fear that, as written, the Preparatory approach to youth ministry will do little to motivate an entire church to commit strategic resources toward reaching an entire generation that has yet to either hear or experience the power, love, and forgiveness of the gospel.
