Response from a Missional perspective Chap Clark
Response to the Strategic Approach from a Missional Perspective
I was bombarded by two overwhelming impressions as I read your chapter, Mark: one, this is fascinating, creative, and wild stuff. Two, this is an idea that is so far-fetched and unrealistic for most churches and youth ministry programs that it borders on fantasy.
Yet you have gathered, analyzed, dissected, and codified relevant data in a way that compels the reader to abandon tightly held methodological and programmatic convictions by asking some new questions and being open to creative answers. I commend you for advocating such an approach with both academic and theological support.
I fear that the Strategic approach, however, has some fundamental flaws that, upon closer examination, reveal a strategy that would consistently be the exception rather than the strategic rule of the future of youth ministry.
Compelling aspects
Yet there are several compelling and frankly exciting aspects to your argument. I agree that contemporary youth ministry, especially as it has evolved in middle-and upper-class communities in North America over the past 30 to 40 years, needs to be overhauled. It struck a chord in me when I read how young people often experience the church as foster children (a concept used here and in Malan Nel’s article). As dominant cultures around the world segment off and flee from the young, similarly the church loves to resolve what is uncomfortable by pushing it aside.
In many ways, then, youth ministry can be summarized for many adults in the church as a necessary nuisance. In most churches adolescents are a constant reminder of what adults have lost in postmodernity, and how they have lost the sense of control they once had in the good old days, which makes them uncomfortable. But churches that want to survive the coming decades recognize that there must be something for the kids. This dichotomy polarizes the contemporary church; for members—especially older ones—do not want young people to influence (or even interrupt) the traditions and modes of the establishment in the church. Yet they also know that the church cannot survive without them eventually assimilating into the mainstream community somehow.
That said, Mark, your Strategic approach is a response to the church’s innate discomfort with accommodating adolescent culture in the systemic structures of the church. In other words, this is your chapter’s clear premise: the best way to resolve the conflict between elderly (Big Church) and the young (Youth Church) is to take the young and create a church environment one could not have otherwise. Essentially, the emphasis of the article smacked of a “love it or leave it” mentality.
In most churches adolescents are a constant reminder of what adults have lost in postmodernity—among other things, a sense of control like they once had in the good old days.
Mere euphemism
Many a church has experienced the harrowing and even bloody battles over worship styles, music, dress, liturgy, and even sermon content. Indeed, there comes a time in almost every church when a group senses that the need to leave (“split,” or more politically appropriate, “plant”) is stronger than the desire to work through issues as a committed fellowship body. In this case the more “appropriate” course of action is to create a new environment without the millstone of hassles and pain of the past. I cannot shake the feeling that the Strategic approach is essentially euphemistic.
The question then becomes: Is this a bad thing? Is it theologically ill-advised, this strategy of targeted ministry that relies on the breaking up of the young from the old? (I know the article attempted to claim an intergenerational bent and commitment, but it still gave little historical or pragmatic support for this actually occurring in a church that would incorporate such an approach.) In my opinion the only answer to such a question is, “It depends on many complex factors” (which is why, as I stated at the outset, this Strategic approach intrigues me).
On the surface I tend to agree that this approach is a viable and possibly even desirable course of action for a youth ministry program. As the executive administrator of a large church, I also have felt the temptation to start over. My frustration, fear, and impatience all turn on when it comes to trying to motivate a local church, especially one of any size.
Your approach would cause a generational conflict in the body of Christ. As you mention, parents and children would have to decide which church to connect to.
But if I am honest, I do believe that most of the theological and pragmatic scaffolding for the Strategic approach is neither remotely possible for most churches nor ultimately a theologically and developmentally appropriate strategy for the few who could pull it off. In this critique I offer four pragmatic and three theological concerns.
Extremely difficult
First, my pragmatic concerns. The Strategic approach is at best extremely difficult for most churches to pull off. It demands a great many complex factors to come together instantaneously in order to come close to fulfilling your goal. Almost like the “beginning of life” argument, when God decides to intervene in our world, random events do occur in such a way that things change. In the examples described in this article, the Creator has seemingly helped to create a few of these types of programs ex nihilo.
Willow Creek, Lawndale, and the church in Nepal (a bit of a stretch, that example) are all wonderful examples of movements that experienced the unique stamp of God as complex sociological factors miraculously gelled. However, to try and analyze these (and other) moments in church history and then produce a reproducible model for the church at large is highly questionable. First, the approach requires an almost fully trained and equipped pastor—not just a called and gifted person with youths and a few adult leaders, but a highly skilled visionary strategist who is able to teach, disciple, lead, and eventually mobilize. This person must not only be able to maintain what is good for a large youth ministry program, but also able to lead a transitionary team through the maze of tentative newness. There are very few of those folks around.
Some drop through the cracks
Secondly, those who thrive in their involvement with the congregation at large would suffer a huge loss when the youth ministry loyalists moved on. Like the American loyalists during the Revolution, who still loved England, families who embrace their church community would be torn to see the support group for their kids ripped away from them.
Generational conflict
Thirdly, your the approach would cause a generational conflict in the body of Christ. As you mention, parents and children would have to decide which church to connect to. Older, more traditionally minded persons in a congregation may at first enjoy the quiet comfort of knowing there were no kids around to keep asking for drums on Sunday morning, but soon the voices of the young who are passionate for Jesus would be sorely missed. In discussing this approach with author Doug Fields (Purpose Driven Youth Ministry), he responded, “What adult wants to go to a youth church?”
Inward focused
Lastly, and perhaps most importantly, the emphasis continues to be inward focused. You may offer a nod toward student outreach, but in reality the missional philosophy driving this approach remains very similar to the more traditional models of youth ministry—“Just build it, and they will come.” What the youth ministry builds may include cool worship, relevant preaching, and fewer old people around—but it still will not be enough to attract from the dominant culture those who believe the church is irrelevant, arrogant, and antagonistic to their lives. Will the Strategic approach cause the church to be more missionally minded? I seriously doubt it, for the amount of work, effort, and focus required to actualize such an approach would far overwhelm the desire to strategically incarnate the church in the world of the lost.
Theological validity?
I also question the theological validity of your approach, Mark. First, you write that the youth minister is the flag bearer for the Strategic approach. In describing the approach, you begin the first three steps by focusing on the individual (“youth minister develops a solid youth ministry,” “youth minister…begins painting a picture,” and “the team the youth minister has assembled” [italics mine]).
It is evident throughout this article that there is a key person in the casting and implementation of the approach, and that this person is the one who will lead the group to the Promised Land. But the New Testament church is about body life, body function, and communal leadership. Henri Nouwen claims that Christian leadership must be “mutual and communal.” Theologically, your approach has a “forced” feel due to its reliance on a single leader.
Dangerous emphasis on numbers
Secondly, there is an undue and relatively dangerous emphasis on numbers to define a valid methodology. Few theologians would argue that programmatic success (in other words, numbers) is among the most important criterion for evaluating a theologically appropriate course of action. But in the historical defense of the approach, the article equates numerical growth with theological appropriateness in Nepal, Willow Creek, and Lawndale. I am not convinced that these (or any other) programs deserve to be highlighted as theologically desirable methods of ministry simply by the sheer numbers of people they attract. This logic would have to say that the rapid growth of the Black Muslim movement is due to the blessing of God.
Distinct community
Thirdly, you seem to make a subtle assumption that youth ministry is and should be a distinct community. I believe you are correct as a diagnosis, but are lacking in your interpretation of that as either a theologically appropriate or sociologically necessary descriptor of youth ministry. I believe that youth ministry must fight the tendency to pull back from the rest of the local body of Christ and do all it can to assert itself as an expression of the church at large. Youth leaders are not registered aliens who hold a green card as a member of a foreign society. They are, instead, representatives and ambassadors of the entire congregation in caring for the unique needs of adolescents. Theologically, young people and old people are members of the same body of Christ. I believe the Scriptures teach that God desires his people to “be one.”
The New Testament church was not designed as a factory, a corporation, or a series of disjointed, fragmented programs loosely connected by money and facility. It was, and therefore remains until Christ returns, a body and a family of closely connected, tightly woven, clearly broken, but mercifully reassembled people. Young and old, cool and nerd, organ and electric guitar. Perhaps it was Dennis Guernsey who wrote, “We are the church, and we are family. Let us get on with our business”—and I would add, together!
