Chapter 5 of 27

Response from a Preparatory perspective Wesley Black

Response from a Preparatory perspective Wesley Black

Response to the Inclusive Congregational Approach from a Preparatory Perspective

by Wesley Black

It seems to me that the opening scenario of your chapter hints at the problems addressed in this approach: a group of church leaders struggles with the best approaches to dealing with youths and how to shape the congregation’s youth ministry. Yet there are no youths present for this discussion (at least none are mentioned, or are reported to have said anything). It is a group of adults in a discussion about youths.

Perhaps this is one reason the congregation is in a predicament. There is low youth attendance and participation, drug abuse among some of the young people, and inadequate funding for some youth programs. The pastor, however, feels urgently that the proper response is not yet another program for youths, but an inclusive congregation approach with youths to involve them at every level of congregational life.

The pastor’s comments apparently get a mixed reaction from his congregation. There is some doubt and even some cynicism in the congregation’s comments: “You’re sounding rather biblical, Pastor, with the olive tree and all…But where are we going with all this?” The pastor’s conclusion is that the church must be prepared to change—a radical suggestion for this church, as it would be in many churches.

I find your views of the church and the inclusive role that youth ministry plays in the life of the congregation very similar to the Preparatory approach in many ways. There are critical differences, however. Nevertheless, the Inclusive Congregational approach has a number of positive points. For the purpose of this response, I would like to mention two positive reactions and two negative reactions to the Inclusive approach.

Theological arguments and view of the church

You state the case in a solid theological argument. This chapter spells out the basis for youth ministry as an expression of the whole congregation, on the argument that the work of the people of God includes what we traditionally call “youth work” (among other names and descriptions). You state unequivocally that you reject “the traditional dichotomy between youth ministry as a duty of the local church and youth ministry as an organized form of working with youths” apart from the ministry of the church.

In this case, first and foremost, you couched the argument admirably in theological terms. It is biblically well-grounded and based. You proceed with a short but comprehensive description of the functions of the church and the various modes of ministry, including the threefold formula of serving God, serving one another as a community of the faithful, and serving the world. This is expressed in eight ministries drawn from solid biblical references. All this grows out of the overall purpose of communicating the gospel of Jesus Christ.

You remind us that the congregational body is incomplete without children and adolescents, and that youth ministry comes up short without the relationships that come from inclusion in the congregation.

I believe you rightly emphasize that youth ministry is not another mode of God’s coming to children and adolescents, but is instead “about finding a place for youths within every ministry and among the people that the ministries are designed to reach and serve—the people to whom God comes by means of the ministries.” You said it well.

Furthermore, I appreciate how you unwrap the several modes of youth ministry. In worship, for example, you underline the benefits to intergenerational experiences. While there are ample arguments for age-specific worship times, those adolescents who spend time worshiping with only their peer group risk shallow, one-dimensional experiences before God.

You remind us, too, that the congregational body is incomplete without children and adolescents, and that youth ministry comes up short without the relationships that come from inclusion in the congregation.

Youth ministry tasks of the church

You and I also agree about the functional areas of youth ministry within the scope of the congregation’s work. Youths, you write, cannot be franchised out to someone else for their spiritual nurture and growth, but are the congregation’s responsibility—a responsibility that is “inalienable and not transferable.”

This tenet, by the way, is echoed by the Search Institute’s Peter Benson in his book All Kids Are Our Kids, in which he reminds us that it takes many voices, with similar values and life examples, speaking with intentional redundancy, to provide the assets that youths need in today’s secular world.1 Youth ministry calls for all Christians to be witnesses to the life-changing message of Christ, not just a few specialized youth workers who can relate well to youths.

In addition, you emphasize that youth ministry is a task of the whole church—despite the fact that seminaries typically and unfortunately teach youth ministry as a kind of supplement to other, seemingly more important, forms of pastoral ministry. You conclude rightly that “as long as the whole is reduced to a part, even the part—in this case, education/catechesis—will not come into its own.”

This leads to the conclusion that the pastor and congregation have a responsibility to include youths in the priorities and functions of the congregation. This is easier stated than done—though you seemed to recognize the difficulty in this approach when you wrote that “the challenge for leadership and parents is to go to the drawing board with the youths. Together this new approach and its consequences must be thought through and worked out.” (Which, in fact, is a good argument for the Preparatory approach to youth ministry: adults working with youths to train them to assume leadership for their ministry now and in the future. But more about this in my chapter on the Preparatory approach.

There is much to commend in the Inclusive Congregational approach. Yet there are two areas that I believe are weak: a poorly defined description of youth ministry, and a weak view of the developmental needs of adolescents.

Just what is youth ministry?

You write that your definition of youth ministry is comprehensive yet “differentiated and focused.” What exactly do you mean by this? There are strong arguments for comprehension and inclusion, but little to explain how to express youth ministry in tangible ways. “Youths need all that adults need,” you rightly state, “but there is a difference between how to feed that need in a 10-year-old and how to feed that same need in a 50-year-old.” But you do not clearly describe how those two experiences are different.

Again, you write that “preaching is still preaching, but it is focused on and directed at the youths. This focus is determined by the youths’ phase of life and the needs peculiar to that phase.” Yet how is that to be done? Will it happen in the course of congregational worship times? If so, how is it focused? Will it happen in occasional sermon examples and illustrations, or through customized sermons written especially for youth? You recognize the difficulty for pastors to pull this off in a congregational that spans several generations (“To be contemporary as well as traditional is no easy matter”). But isn’t there a need for separate times of preaching, teaching, ministry, and interaction with other youths? Don’t they need their own time as well as meeting corporately with the congregation? And does the Inclusive Congregational approach even permit this?

You seem to hint at the answer when you say, “Then their Sunday school classes moved to meet on Sunday afternoons, and the adolescents developed under the leadership of two of the local pastors at their own vibrant, but very traditional, worship service in the evening.” However, isn’t this something different from an inclusive approach? You seem to be moving toward separating the youths from the larger body in order to focus on their worship needs.

Programs similar to your Inclusive Congregational approach have historically proven faulty, at least when American mainline denominations adopted them particularly during the 1970s: several denominational offices dismissed their youth staffs and officially encouraged congregations to approach youth ministry from an inclusive perspective, as you recommend in your argument. Youths were to be considered full members of the congregation. Yet churches that followed this approach suffered setbacks in their youth ministries from which many congregations and even some denominations have never fully recovered.

I believe that too often churches attempt the Inclusive Congregational approach only to have their efforts reduced to tokenism, in which a youth is placed on each standing committee in the church. Or they structure all programs and educational groupings so that everyone is experiencing a similar type of ministry (normally something decided by adults). Or youths are invited to be a part of all discussions and decisions of the congregation, with little regard for the limited attention span or interest level of adolescents.

Just what are the developmental needs of youths?

It strikes me that your view of adolescents’ developmental needs is weak. “Few other modes of ministry,” you write about pastoral care, for example, “explain as well… that children and adolescents need all that other believers need, only to a greater extent and in a differentiated, yet focused way.” What does this mean if not that, at times, youths need to be set apart for specialized forms of ministry?

In discussing diakonia or service, after pointing out that Strommen determined in empirical studies that youths have a specific inclination to a service-oriented life, you write, “This mode is therefore about involving the youths, at their level of maturity for certain kinds of service, in the comprehensive service of the congregation in this world…and at the same time involv[ing] the youths in service suitable to their age.” The problem here is that too often congregations want youths to participate as adults participate, rather than as youths participate. Youths need developmentally specific ways to channel their energies and idealism; they need their own ways to put into practice the movement of God in their lives. They need to be able to serve in ways that are different from adults. The entire congregation will benefit from this youthful inclination to serve unselfishly (even though they may act quite selfishly at times.)

Churches that do not recognize the need for youths to invest themselves in something meaningful and worthwhile to them miss out on contributing to the proper nurture of youths and fail to benefit from the fruits of their students’ youthful idealism and energy. You seem to recognize that “this kind of church,” as you put it—accurately I believe—“loses the youths and shoves them into the arms of any person or organization that cares and treats them like they’re important.”

There may be yet another developmental blind spot, this one in your discussion of marturia, or witness. You got it right when you wrote, “One witnesses to a 10-year-old differently than to an adult. Furthermore, a 10-year-old witnesses to others differently than an adult does.” This is especially true among adolescents. Who better to witness to a teenager than another teenager? Your concession under scores the need for preparation and focus on youths witnessing to their peers. But how is this accomplished? More importantly, how is it done with specific focus and within an Inclusive Congregational approach? Your chapter is fuzzy on answers to questions like these.

Finally, I am troubled by how apparently little regard the Inclusive Congregational approach has for unchurched adolescents. This approach seems to deal mainly with those who grew up in church or those who attend with their families. While I appreciate the emphasis on family ministry, there are huge numbers of adolescents outside the family of God—adolescents who can often be reached by the witness of a peer and so brought into the family.

Approaches like yours have historically proven faulty, at least when American mainline denominations adopted them particularly during the 1970s. Many congregations and even some denominations have never fully recovered.

Notes

1. Peter Benson, All Kids Are Our Kids (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1997).

↑ Back to top

↑