The Missional Approach to Youth Ministry Chap Clark
The Missional Approach to Youth Ministry
Scenario: stranger in a strange land
Tony is a high school sophomore. Typical of everyone he knows, he has never been to church and doesn’t plan to go. God is a power he respects. Religion, however, just gets in the way of life.
But Tony has a friend who has been badgering him about going to church with her.
“Not really church,” she says, “more like a youth group.” Whatever that is, Tony thinks. So just to get her off his back, Tony says he’ll go—but just once.
When the sophomore arrives at youth group, he finds a cluster of people in one corner playing guitars and others standing around talking in small groups. After some very long moments, Tony finally spots his friend.
They sit together on the thin carpet and talk for a few minutes before a 30-year-old guy wearing an earring plugs his guitar into an amp and, with a kind of garage-band style, plays and sings a few songs; some students sing along, others don’t. Tony has never heard any of the songs before.
Two students from Tony’s school do a dialogue kind of skit about lying to parents. Then a guy jokes about being homeschooled (which Tony has heard of, but never met anybody who actually was) and gives some announcements. Another student, one of the guitar players whom Tony recognizes from school, asks everyone to form groups of five to share (share?) and pray. Tony sits quietly, declining to speak (even when asked), watching for his chance to break for the door.
After the prayer time ends, the earring guy tells a story about a student who was caught lying…then says something about God and Jesus…and finally reads from a book Tony assumes is the Bible (though, having never seen a Bible before, he can’t be sure). The speaker talks about how “non-Christians” think and why “they do what they do.” Gradually it dawns on him that that this guy is talking about him. Anger boils inside Tony, but he manages to keep a lid on his feelings.
The speaker then makes a joke about how boring the minister is and suggests that the students hold a tic-tac-toe contest during next week’s sermon—for prizes. (Tony thinks it’s curious that one church leader would talk this way about another.) He then finishes his talk by pointing out that there are “student leaders” who “are always there for you, if you want help with lying.” He mentions a guy Tony knows from cross-country, the same one he saw trip another runner during a meet last fall but later denied it happened. Sure, Tony thinks, that’s the first person I’d go to for advice about lying.
When the speaker finishes, Tony bolts for the door, but his friend is right on his heels.
“I’ve gotta go,” Tony explains.
“Thanks for coming” is her only response. No questions about what he thought or how he felt. If she had asked, Tony might have said something like, “They sang songs I didn’t recognize—or even like—made me pray with strangers, used words I didn’t understand, and insulted me and my friends. I knew church was going to be like this.” But she never asks, and so the visitor leaves quietly, never to come back.
On his way home, it occurs to Tony that if this is what religion is all about—some private club where he obviously isn’t a member—then who needs it? Then he mellows for a moment. Maybe I should try the church service someday. Then he remembers what the earring guy said about the pastor’s sermons. Why bother? That guy’s boring, too!
Heart of the problem
For those raised in the church, a youth group may not feel like a private club with its own culture, rules, and norms, but to many of those on the outside that’s how it has felt for decades. As the secular culture becomes increasingly post-Christian, the gap widens between those who feel qualified for membership and those who don’t. The gulf between the church youth culture and the secular youth culture increases, but the official-yet-unwritten mandate of contemporary youth ministry has stayed the same for years:
But there has been a subversive movement in youth ministry that has gained momentum over the last several years. For many in youth ministry, even among the leaders of the movement, the church—that umbrella organization that sponsors youth ministry—is considered a necessary nuisance. The prevailing view? Churches do not really care about the needs of kids. The church staff, especially senior staff, do not understand kids. Parents and lay leaders are usually the greatest threat to effective youth ministry. Among some youth workers, pastors are the brunt of jokes, worship services are ridiculed, music ministers are written off, and parents are contradicted.
The speaker talks about how “non-Christians” think and why “they do what they do.” Gradually it dawns on Tony that that this guy is talking about him.
Is this what youth ministry is supposed to be about? Programs that highlight those mid-adolescents who are lifted up as exemplars and leaders, who somehow have more than usual influence over their peers? A separate, exclusive discipleship program that uses the resources of a church while it bites the hand that feeds it? Can youth ministry be simply described and explained by listing the meetings, events, and programs that sociologically define who is “in” (that is, those who know and appreciate or resonate with the songs, the language, and the expectations of the youth ministry) and who is “out”?
As outlandish as these dubious goals of ministry sound, the fact is that for large numbers of adolescents (probably the majority), youth ministries in churches (and even in parachurch organizations; parachurch roughly meaning alongside the church) represent a world that is foreign, irrelevant, and even occasionally offensive. Despite all the focus, energy, history, and money that has gone into youth ministry over the last several decades, secularized and disenfranchised adolescents are not any closer to viewing the local church as a viable sanctuary for relational stability, peace, and hope. It’s not even an option for them. “The curtain must be pulled back,” Mark Yaconelli writes. “If we are to keep young people involved in the church and if we are to renew our congregations, we first must acknowledge that many of our current forms of youth ministry are destructive.”1
A Definition of the Missional Approach
“The gospel is always conveyed through the medium of culture,”2 declares D. L. Guder. The Missional approach to youth ministry recognizes that there are cultural barriers that separate adolescents from adults. This is not only true of the secular adolescent world, but also the world of churched young people. Therefore, youth ministry as mission is defined as the community of faith corporately committed to caring for and reaching out into the adolescent world (of both churched and unchurched young people) in order to meaningfully assimilate them into their fellowship. “Even when I am old and gray, do not forsake me, O God, till I declare your power to the next generation, your might to all who are to come” (Psalm 71:18).
Description of the Missional Approach to Youth Ministry
Since its inception, youth ministry has evolved out of a mission conviction. Generationally focused ministry programming has emerged from a concern that the church was losing its ability to impact an increasingly distant and discontented segment of the population. Thus youth ministry pioneers and entrepreneurs took the foundational mandates of the church—worship, Christian nurture and training, and social commitment and evangelism—and contextualized it for this evolving subculture. Ultimately, regardless of denomination and tradition, mission is often cited as the basic reason for youth ministry. In light of increasing cultural fragmentation, this commitment and focus have never been more necessary.
Adolescents now represent both a definable culture as well as a legitimate phase of the life span. The church really has no choice, then, but to reach out to this group of people, to bring the gospel to the world of the adolescent, with the ultimate goal of assimilating each child into the greater body of Christ as expressed in the local church. As F. F. Bruce states: “No member (of the body) is less a part of the body than any other member: all are necessary. Variety of organs, limbs and functions is of the essence of bodily life. No one organ could establish a monopoly in the body by taking over the functions of the others. A body consisting of a single organ would be a monstrosity.”3
The Missional approach views Christian adults as missionaries and adolescents as a people to be reached with the gospel of Jesus Christ. Principles that guide cross-cultural ministries around the world apply to youth ministry. Lingenfelter and Mayers suggest six orientations in ministering cross-culturally: time versus event, task versus person, dichotomistic versus holistic thinking, status versus achievement, crisis versus noncrisis, and concealment versus vulnerability orientations.4 Missional youth ministry accepts the fact that each of these orientations will shape the manner in which young people will be reached, evangelized, and made part of the body of Christ. Consequently the church that ministers to youths must embrace the culture in which adolescents live, just as Christian churches in India or Brazil or Nigeria have contextualized in order to become the kingdom of God in their various cultures.
Justification for the Missional Approach
Theologically, few would argue with the idea that youth ministry is an important mandate of the church, regardless of how it is defined. Ecclesiologically, however, youth ministry has become in many cases a praxeological nightmare, for in a wildly changing culture the church is hard-pressed to address such a dynamic force as youth culture. The vast majority of churches want a vibrant youth ministry; but the bulk of them want to create and sustain a healthy youth ministry out of pragmatic need, rather than theological and ecclesiological conviction. This is the paradoxical quandary of contemporary youth ministry: churches are screaming for youth ministry (an “excellent one,” at that—high-powered, entertaining, and theologically and sociologically safe), but there are few pastors, parents, and even boards who are convinced that God has called them as a church to mobilize their resources in order to penetrate a distant and disruptive generation.
But the church is clearly called to influence and care for the secular culture and, more specifically, the youth subculture. The church is missional in that its mandate is clearly focused on God sending his people into the world as light and salt—“You will be my witnesses in Jerusalem, and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the ends of the earth” (Acts 1:8). “We have come to see that mission is not merely an activity of the church,” writes Darrell Guder. “Rather, mission is the result of God’s initiative, rooted in God’s purpose to restore and heal creation. ‘Mission’ means ‘sending,’ and it is the central biblical theme describing the purpose of God’s action in human history.” The missional church then becomes “the instrument of God’s mission.”5
In terms of youth ministry, then, the church is called less to take care of its own by creating an isolated private community, and more to be a dynamic force of intentional penetration into the adolescent world. A missional youth ministry will contain elements of community, but never for the community’s sake (in other words, to acculturate churched young people, or to “keep our kids safe and healthy”). The goal is not to simply focus on those who already are involved in a given church’s youth ministry program. The theologically driven missional mandate of youth ministry is to bring the gospel and the kingdom to every adolescent. The church must step up and allow this theological axiom to shape and alter ecclesiological traditions and norms.
For most adolescents, youth ministries in churches represent a world that is foreign, irrelevant, and even occasionally offensive.
As the church attempts to realize its biblical mandate of missional youth ministry, the issue is to rediscover its historical and fundamental missional commitment and focus and proceed accordingly. In the world of contemporary youth ministry methodology, models are everything. From the frenzied merchandising of youth ministry products to the hype of the newest program, event, or philosophy, the North American youth ministry movement seems to be increasingly susceptible to fame, marketing, and spin. Most professional youth workers who are struggling with uninterested and disengaged students, complaining parents, uncommitted leadership, and unsupportive senior level staff and laity will too often jump at anything and everything that may help to jump-start the ministry. This eventually translates into a youth ministry methodology that ultimately measures success by the interest and enthusiasm of students (and their parents), the pat on the back from the leadership of the church, and the perceived relative stability of the program. Then when the current model, plan, or program fades or students lose interest, the youth worker frantically searches for the next hot thing to get the machine up and running one more time.
Segmented generations
But if youth ministry is faithful to its missional commitment, to assimilating students into the life and faith of the local church, then none of these indicators—student or parental response, pleased leadership, or programmatic stability—are suitable for measuring success. While each of these are potent and legitimate markers in understanding how people feel about youth ministry in a given church environment, none of them use the end goal of youth ministry as the significant or even a single criterion for measuring ministry success. As a mission, a church must keep before itself the primary reason for having a youth ministry program: The world has segmented the generations. God has called his people to be a family, and so the church must create a bridge of love, trust, and support to encourage the disenfranchised adolescent to be welcomed as a member of the family of God. The apostle Paul puts it this way: “Therefore, as we have opportunity, let us do good to all people, especially to those who belong to the family of believers” (Galatians 6:10).
This means that the only true measure of success in a youth ministry program is the ability and willingness of a church to fully assimilate growing adolescents into the adult fellowship. This does not necessarily mean letting them come to church with earrings or even expecting them to attend services. A church committed to adolescents will create a worship environment and church community where the generational differences, tastes, and life situations and experiences are equally appreciated and equally valued with any other segment of the church community. This inclusiveness has not been the hallmark of the contemporary church community for several decades. But, as theologian/psychologist Dennis Guernsey put it, the church that resists stylistic, material, and substantive change in order to avoid embracing and assimilating new kinds of people into it’s fellowship is making a grave mistake. “If we preach a gospel that neglects the welfare of the whole in exchange for the happiness of the individual, then the Church as a living, pulsing body is weakened, as is the welfare of the family. We must recover the priority of interrelationships.”6
Most churches want to create and sustain a healthy youth ministry out of pragmatic need, rather than theological and ecclesiological conviction.
Then and Now—A Brief History of Modern Parish Youth Ministry
The scenario described at the beginning of this chapter, while grossly reductionistic and exaggerated, depicts an often stale and culturally ignorant state of parish (or local church-based) youth ministry. The youth ministry forms of the past 30 or more years have changed very little, for the identical program described in the opening scenario could have taken place in 1972—in fact it did! Yet in most settings a commitment to the programmatic structures and forms seems to be etched in stone.
Although the roots of the ministry movement targeting the adolescent population have been active for several decades, what is now called youth ministry is really not that old. The youth ministry we see today, now a worldwide movement, recognizably began to emerge as an ecclesiological force in the mid-to late-1930s, around the time of mandatory high school.7 The teenager subculture was taking on a power and identity all its own, and (not surprisingly) the churches were left behind in these sweeping cultural changes. The church was seen by many to be inherently irrelevant, boring, and out of touch with the modern and youthful world of adolescents.
Beginning with youth ministry pioneers like Jim Rayburn (Young Life), whom Dean Borgman calls “the founder of modern youth ministry,”8 and Jack Hamilton (Youth for Christ), so-called parachurch youth ministry movements emerged, as people committed to church-based ministry sought to address this generational disloyalty and discontent. Mark Senter describes this movement:
Jim Rayburn forged the high school club methodology which would be perfected in the Young Life movement in the 1940s and 1950s. A nearly identical strategy was adopted by the Youth for Christ International club division in the 1960s and then found its way into church youth groups during the decade of the 1970s. Rayburn’s contribution was at the heart of the parachurch contribution to church youth ministry.9
Prior to 1970, parish youth ministry relied primarily on volunteers and occasional interns.10 The parachurch movements, driven by a commitment to professional trained staff, were building tremendous momentum and influence. The church had a choice—stand back and disparage these ministries for stealing kids from the parish’s programs or learn from them and bring the parachurch program into the parish. Increasingly, most church programs (that could afford it) chose the latter tack and essentially created what Stuart Bond referred to in 1989 as a “one-eared Mickey Mouse”: a parachurch program under the structural umbrella of the local parish.11 To many this was the final step in the evolution of youth ministry. The church had the best of both worlds—an attractive, relationally sensitive, culturally relevant program for their own students; and a mechanism to keep them involved in their church. Now there would be no need for church kids to leave ecclesiological home and get involved with Young Life or Youth for Christ. In this scenario, the church could provide the program they wanted—and their kids would never want to leave the church.
The Great Divide
But, as history has proven, this proved to be a debilitating flaw in church youth ministry. As Senter notes,
Once again the church copied the technology of parachurch agencies, this time Young Life and Campus Life, and employed their methods to maintain youth groups of Christian adolescents in church settings while practically ignoring the vast majority of young people who had not made a commitment to the Christian faith.12
Thus the great divide between the church and the secular adolescent world began to take shape, all in the name of youth ministry. Church youth groups, designed to ensure adolescent congregant loyalty to the church, by default built systems, norms, and attitudes that implicitly (and sometimes explicitly) excluded secular students. In an increasingly secularized society, the gulf widened to the point where today the majority of kids would not even consider attending a church or religious event or program.13 In 1986, Jim Burns claimed that “programs attract kids; relationships keep them.”14 That may have been true in the early years of modern parish youth ministry, but not today. For the vast majority of church-based adolescents, programs are seen to be irrelevant at best and aggressively oppressive at worst.
The problem historically was not what the church programs copied from the parachurch, but rather what they did not copy. What was modeled was not the essence of the parachurch youth ministries (especially Young Life and Campus Life) but the form of the program. Jim Burns, in a 1997 Christianity Today interview, stated, “We who did youth ministry took the Youth for Christ and Young Life models—they were the best models—and brought them into the church.”15 The methodological models practiced by Young Life (and later by Campus Life), and the domestic evangelistic club-based program of Youth for Christ were created as tools to achieve one purpose—to reach out to young people where they lived in order to bring the gospel to this disenfranchised culture.16 The vision behind these and other organizations was a missional commitment of the church toward the lost, in this case adolescents. The model itself, and especially the specifics of the program, was not the commitment. The vision and mission is what mattered. Historically the youth parachurch movements were far more concerned with the core of their mission than the delivery system or programmatic methodology. For example, for years Young Life shunned the club as the key to Young Life ministry, for the organization’s theology held fast to the idea of “adults reaching kids for Christ” as the core value, whether or not a club, camp, or small group was ever methodologically involved. This focused commitment is perhaps the single key factor to the historic success of these ministries over the years.17
But when church youth ministry began to move toward modeling itself after the success of the parachurch methods, by concentrating on highly produced youth groups, flashy programs, and relevant talks targeting the least-common-denominator student, it unknowingly abandoned one of the local church youth ministry’s primary missions—to create an environment where churched adolescents are communally nurtured in their walk with Christ in order to ultimately assimilate them into the larger body of the local church. The church is to be the place where care, training, teaching, discipling, and spiritual formation can flourish with a missional end goal—“Go and make disciples of all nations” (Matthew 28:19). Now secular young people discount the church as a viable influence, and for so many anything that sounds religious is instantly and forthrightly rejected. What went wrong?
When churches and denominations chose to focus parish youth ministry on the prominent youth minister and a series of programs, they failed to recognize that, up until the 1970s anyway, at the core youth ministry had been more concerned with mission and less with program. The power and impact of a missional youth ministry approach was due to its focus—to contextually care for and thus reach the student who did not want to be reached and to share the love of Jesus Christ with the student who did not know that Christians cared. A student touched by this missional emphasis would naturally be prone to experience the church as a caring community who accepted her as she was. But the local church allowed itself to define youth ministry as one program of the church, instead of a basic theologically driven mission of the church. Thus the last 20 to 30 years have seen youth ministry move from a mission-driven, outreach-oriented, culturally sensitive expression of God’s incarnational care for all people to an entertainment-based series of events, programs, options, and classes.
Saddleback and Willow Creek
Two particularly influential programs have sought to change from a program-driven to “purpose-driven” focus—Saddleback Community Church’s Purpose-Driven Youth Ministry and Willow Creek Community Church’s Student Impact. Each organization (and resultant resources) seeks to bring a missional focus to the church’s ministry to adolescents. Both of these programs are highly missional—but define mission differently. According to Bo Boshers, Willow Creek targets “three groups of people: seekers, believers, and leaders.”18 In this philosophical schema, the seeker is defined as “someone who is interested in spiritual things and is investigating the claims of Christianity.”19 By this definition the missional commitment of this program excludes those who are not actively seeking. Saddleback’s philosophy, on the other hand, does not define its ministry focus to only those who are interested, but also targets “community students,” defined as “teenagers living within a realistic drive of our church.”20 The programmatic philosophy behind the first of Saddleback’s “five purposes of the church” is “Mission: We communicate God’s Word through evangelism.”21
The only true measure of success in a youth ministry program is the ability and willingness of a church to fully assimilate growing adolescents into the adult fellowship.
So although both programs, key leaders, and resources are held up as cutting edge youth ministry programs, in print at least, Saddleback’s purpose-driven philosophy is more in line with historic parachurch focus on the mission of the church than is Willow Creek’s. In defense of Willow Creek’s philosophical position on reaching out to uninterested adolescents, the argument has been made that their position considers all uninterested nonbelievers as at some level, and therefore is targeting the same types of students that Saddle-back tries to reach. This apologetic, however, rings hollow given a careful reading of Student Impact materials. With all of the emphasis given to philosophical focus and vision drivenness, Willow Creek’s basic philosophy remains that of the contemporary church youth ministry: students must first come in order to be drawn into the ministry (italics in the following are mine).
At Student Impact, we want every student who walks through the door to feel accepted. Some who come have mohawks and tattoos, while others look as if they just shopped at the Gap. No matter what these students look like, each is accepted into a team with other students from his or her high school. New students are introduced to other team members and get an overview of the night. It’s like a party just for them.22
This is absolutely appropriate for a seeker because a seeker will not mind coming to something he or she finds interesting in the quest for information and truth. But this philosophical focus, while important and significant, is still not entirely missional in that a nonseeker will likely show her lack of interest by not showing up.
Saddleback, on the other hand, seeks to take the uninterested student more seriously by including him in the community. These students are therefore specifically targeted and sought out. Like historical youth ministry philosophy, programs for these students are usually logistically connected to the church facility, but this is not always the case. Home-based Bible studies and discussion groups are designed to address and alleviate the uninterested student’s innate fears. Even this commitment, however, can be over-shadowed by an emphasis on a “come to us” programmatic mentality and methodology.
Church youth groups, designed to ensure the loyalty of its adolescent congregants, by default built systems, norms, and attitudes that implicitly (and sometimes explicitly) excluded secular students.
These two programs—Willow Creek and Saddleback—are unquestionably the most significant forces in church-based youth ministry philosophies to date. Even with the popularity and unquestioned success at several levels, however, these and other church-based youth ministry programs must continue to evaluate their missional programmatic commitments and strategies. Every youth ministry must constantly ask itself Who are our targets? How do we best reach out to them? Where do we want these students to end up when they leave our program? This is especially true in a youth ministry climate that has relegated youth evangelism to early and middle adolescents by committing to a philosophy that leaves evangelism entirely up to the students. For when the essence of a program’s evangelism is simply encouraging students to bring their friends to a church-based program, this immediately sets out of reach that vast number of young people who have no Christian friends to bring them.
Willow Creek clearly holds to this strategy when Bo Boshers states, “There can be no outreach without Christian students who care for their non-Christian friends.”23 Saddleback’s Purpose-Driven Youth Ministry nuances this view in acknowledging that even the most devoted young disciple needs adults to partner with the core students: “Youth ministries that successfully reach unchurched students are almost always led by a leader with a burden for the lost.”24 But even Saddleback’s primary method for reaching out is to encourage the core students to bring students to their programs, which they refer to as the “friendship evangelism challenge.”
Peer to peer
The movement to peer evangelism as the main thrust of a youth ministry’s missional focus is an inadequate strategy for at least three reasons. First, the latest research on peer relationships makes clear that adolescents choose friends who are most like themselves. Somewhere in the early onset of mid-adolescence (13 to 14 years of age), peers become more important in the lives of young people. The current form of grouping has become known as clustering, where mid-adolescents choose three to eight students to bond with based on their self-concept during this roughly five-year period. These clusters then choose other clusters with whom to align, again based on similar self-concept, identity, and ego strength. The interesting thing about the clustering phenomenon is that these groupings of clusters, or “cousin clusters,” consistently struggle against social participation with other cousin clusters for fear of being either tainted (if they perceive the other group is less socially competent) or rejected (if they perceive themselves to be less socially competent). The upshot of this newly emerging, adolescent social structure is that when someone is encouraged to bring their friends to a church-sponsored event, few outreach students actually attend because the potential target group—their friends—comprises a relatively small group of students. By default, then, those programs that rely on student-to-student come-to-our-church evangelism attract only those students who are similar to the church’s young people!25
Thus the last 20 to 30 years have seen youth ministry move from a mission driven, outreach-oriented, culturally sensitive expression of God’s incarnational care for all people to an entertainment-based series of events, programs, options, and classes.
The second way that peer evangelism is lacking as the sole methodology for a missional commitment to youth ministry is that adults are asking students to do what they themselves are deathly afraid of and do quite poorly at best. Adults rarely bring a friend to church-sponsored events, unless they are absolutely convinced that this friend will positively respond to both the invitation and the experience. There seems to be a worldview in youth ministry, however, that believes that students are more socially secure than adults and can therefore risk alienation and stereotyping as they are challenged to “do” evangelism. The research on mid-adolescence and peer relationships shows exactly the opposite. Mid-adolescents, by definition, are far less socially secure than adults are. Identity has yet to be formed, the peer group is taking on enormous power and influence, and the rules and norms of the adolescent experience are in constant flux. Youth workers who push students in this area risk limiting students’ growth in Christ in several ways:
Lastly, limiting a missional commitment in youth ministry to peer or friendship evangelism creates a mission mind set that is program centered. When we ask students to bring their friends, our responsibility as adults is reduced to providing a program that is designed to draw those friends into our ministry. Our goal, then, becomes active participation in our ministry. We are thereby forced to continue a cycle of attractive and relevant programs so that our students’ friends will continue to be enticed to come. In a program the staff is responsible to make certain that the machine continues to run. The program becomes the product, and the congregation (in this case the students) becomes the consumer. This cycle continues where expectations of programmatic excellence become the bottom line for ministerial evaluation and effectiveness, with the goal being students who like the program.
While it has its place within the broader context of a youth ministry philosophy and methodology, peer-to-peer ministry is inadequate as the primary missional thrust because it only draws kids who are like the students already participating in a given program. We ask of adolescents what we hardly ask of mature Christian adults, and it can create a program-centered ministry. These three issues, however, are exponentially magnified when youth ministry is defined as a mission of the church with an end goal of full assimilation into the locally expressed body of Christ.
As stated, youth ministry is not simply about attracting and keeping students involved in one of the generationally focused programs of a large, disconnected body. It is about bringing young people into full participation in the local church family. Missional youth ministry takes adolescents and their culture seriously enough to provide them a sociological and theological bridge from the secularized world of the young into a broad, rich community of faith, hope, and love.
For a church to be truly missional, the goal is clearer and more central. The staff, lay adult leadership, and even the entire congregation are missionaries to a specific population—whether they are involved or not, willing to come or uninterested, seeker or lost wanderer. A missional commitment to youth ministry means that a congregation sees adolescents—regardless of their current involvement—as deserving love, focus, and care. Programs shift and change, methodology is fluid, and young people are encouraged to pursue Christ in the context of an accepting community of adults who care.
A widening gulf: today’s adolescent world
As mentioned above, the target or goal of youth ministry must clearly be established. If the goal of a parish-based youth ministry is to provide an environment where the congregation’s young people can be nurtured, cared for, and disicpled, then in some ways what is happening in the secular community may not matter. However, if youth ministry is more broadly defined within the context of the church universal’s missional mandate, where every young person is our mission field, then it is essential to understand what is happening in the world of secular adolescents.
The distinction between secular and sacred in the adolescent context is far too narrow, for two reasons. First, a kind of cultural spillage will have some effect on even the most spiritually cloistered of young people. It is important to recognize that even an appropriately acclimated Christian student will carry at least some of the marks of the dominant generation. Nearly all churched students carry the baggage of the culture in their psyches.
But second, and even more theologically and ecclesiologically important, is that churched adults and leadership must not be allowed to deny that the church must be a place of refuge and welcome for the most desperate of the lost. If the church has created a sociological climate that makes assimilation or even casual interest difficult (if not impossible, at least in some cases), then the church has ceased to be the church and has become a members-only club.
People, even young people, have not changed all that much over the years; but the world has changed dramatically since the beginning of the modern youth ministry movement. In the last 30 years we have experienced great change in technology, geopolitical structures, cultural rules, norms and values, and even what many believe to be the most profound shift in thinking in several hundred years (the move from a modern to a postmodern worldview). This rapid change has caused church leadership to become reactors rather than responders. Most have made attempts to keep up with the many changes occurring in the culture around us, but there is always something else to worry about, something new to understand, and someone else to listen to. Amidst all of this turmoil, adolescents have been on their own to make sense out of life.
When the essence of a program’s evangelism is simply encouraging students to bring their friends to a church-based program, this immediately disqualifies that vast number of young people who have no Christian friends.
The cluster phenomenon mentioned earlier is but one of the significant societal changes that has had a deep effect on modern adolescents. In the mid-1980s, Canadian youth minister Donald Posterski noted that the adolescent social scene was changing and Canadian students were gathering in smaller groups than in the previous decades.26 Although his data were helpful in pointing to a sociological shift in the high school world, there was not enough clear information available to fully develop the implications. The survey Posterski and his team used uncovered an emerging trend, especially in the United States, and many believed that he had discovered something very important to the future of youth ministry.
Jim Burns and Duffy Robbins both note Posterski’s research, but neither provides any other collaborative data for the shift or detail methodological changes that will need to be made to recognize something is going on in the world of young people.27 The idea was too new. In 1992 Mark Senter rightly noted this as a future “megatrend of the coming revolution” when he stated that, based on his research, “Posterski proposed the best way to minister to young people was through their cluster of friends.”28 Senter went on to give an example of an East Los Angeles pastor who had used this concept to “evangelize (adolescents) in group Bible study settings.”29
If the church is not going to strategically and proactively address the sweeping cultural shifts of the past 30 years, the vast majority of young people—who will soon be our main-stream adults—will enter adulthood believing that the church is basically irrelevant and cares about them only when they show up at church. The target of every form of ministry in the church must have, at least as an end goal, a missional mindset in order to fulfill its call in Christ. Every student must be sought out and relationally and incarnationally enveloped with the aroma of Christ.30 As Dean Borgman insists, “More than ever, today’s youth ministers must function first as missionaries, then as social workers, and finally as pastors. Furthermore, these professionals are effective only if youth ministers have proved themselves as real friends of particular individuals and groups. Communities and churches need to see youth leaders as critical bridges to youth culture.”31
The missiological mandate of the gospel (Go!)
To many, youth ministry is healthy, effective, and has come of age as a movement.32 To others, however, parish or local church-based youth ministry is in need of a major overhaul. As in the church, our historic assumption has been that all we need to do to minister to the uninterested and disenfranchised is to open the doors of the church, offer a program, and get our constituency to bring their friends. We actually believe that the church is a safe, attractive place for those who have been culturally and relationally removed. But as New Testament scholar Darrell Guder claims, “Neither the structures nor the theology of our established Western churches is missional. They are shaped by the legacy of Christendom. That is, they have been formed by centuries in which Western civilization considered itself formally and officially Christian.”33
The same can be said of modern youth ministry. We have become convinced that our programs, music, and ethos of youth ministry are enough to reach the lost, uninterested, and disenfranchised. Even if we have made some programmatic and philosophical changes in how we “do” youth ministry in the attempt to win the seeker, any programmatic, “come to us” methodology for evangelism, Christian witness, and mission in the world will, by its very assumptions, exclude the masses. When we fail to acknowledge how far away from us the culture has moved, we also fail in our ability to impact this broken generation. This is especially true in the vast majority of adult worship services. Even when a youth ministry program is able to reach a secularized adolescent, any attempt to assimilate that student into the life of the larger church is often doomed from the start. Very few churches see youth ministry as their missional mandate. That’s why they hired a youth minister, after all. Yet this attitude and spirit destroys any hope of fulfilling the ultimate goal of youth ministry.
Missional youth ministry is a youth ministry that is driven by an entire congregation’s commitment to reach the adolescent population, both those who show up and those who do not. In a missional youth ministry, youth ministers and pastors are equippers of the laity who do the face-to-face, incarnational, hands-on ministry to those who will come to us and those who will not. But they are not called to be program directors or, as one elder put it, party planners. Youth ministry paid staff and volunteers make up the hands, arms, and feet of the body of Christ to the young of a congregation and community.
The church, however, has become a place where we do not want others around who force us to talk openly about what we believe and why, who cause us to constantly rediscover who we are in Christ, and who push us to tell others our unique stories. The church seems to want to program the relational intimacy and interconnectedness of our lives right out of the equation. But the very presence of the young and vibrant threatens the security of our stained-glass system. Yet openness to that kind of pressure is exactly what it takes to have a missional commitment to the adolescent world—that pressure is exactly what it means “to go.” The church is not the church without this kind of relational struggle and give-and-take. “Life is not to be lived through autonomous selfhood but through relational connection,” writes Steven J. Sandage. “Our individual stories are shaped and constrained by the stories of others.”34
In a missional youth ministry, there is a commitment on the part of the staff to “go” into the cultural settings and world where modern secularized adolescents live. Outreach to the “community,” to use Fields’ term, is seen to be a three-way partnership between the church at large, the youth ministry adult staff, and the “core” students (defined as those who experience the church environment as their spiritual community). Evangelism is thus the cumulative conviction of the entire local family of God to reach out to students on their turf (to borrow a historic parachurch term). Relational, no-strings-attached contacts are made with students in settings—both relational and physical—where the target student feels safe to encounter another person, regardless of their age, who genuinely cares.
Changes That Must Be Made
For a church to recapture the Missional approach to youth ministry, the following people or groups must commit to substantive changes regarding the youth ministry task: the youth ministry leadership team, the youth minister or youth pastor, the senior pastor (and other church staff), and the lay leadership of the church.
Youth ministry leadership team
This group must refocus on the heart of the youth ministry task in every aspect of the program and ministry. There must be a willingness to receive students who walk through the door and to become a ministry that has a go-to-them mentality of adolescent ministry. The leadership, lay and paid, must see themselves as representatives of the entire congregation, being ambassadors and representatives of the church at large. Here are some specific changes that can be made. The youth ministry leadership team will:
Youth minister/youth pastor
The staff leader of the youth ministry must see herself as both a point person for a specific ministry, as well as a member of the leadership of the whole. Youth ministers must constantly resist the temptation to fight for their own programs or exclusively focus on the rights and needs of adolescents or strategically seek to move the youth ministry agenda ahead of other needs and concerns of the church. As with all associate level staff positions in a church, it is vital that the youth minister remember that Christian leaders must model Scriptural body life: “Do nothing out of selfish ambition or vain conceit, but in humility consider others better than yourselves. Each of you should look not only to your own interests, but also to the interests of others” (Philippians 2:3, 4). Here are some specific changes that can be made.
Youth ministers will be wise to—
Senior pastor and other church staff
In the life of any church, the single most influential person is the senior pastor. Over the last several years, many senior pastors have sought to stay out of the day-to-day running of their church, hiring competent staff to run their ministry so they don’t have to think about it. But inherent in the role of senior pastor is the responsibility to oversee the theologically appropriateness of each program and to ensure that each program moves the congregation into communal conformity into the image of Christ. We are the body and Christ is the Head. Every program must be held accountable for its commitment to the whole.
Missional youth ministry takes adolescents and their culture seriously enough to provide them a sociological and theological bridge from the secularized world of the young into a broad, rich community of faith, hope, and love.
In addition, the senior pastor has to lead the way to receive the young of the congregation and the community. A senior pastor has tremendous influence over a community’s willingness and ability to create an environment that is warm, relationally and sociologically safe, and an inviting place of refuge for the young or any other member of the congregation. Here are some specific changes that can be made. Senior pastors should—
The lay leadership of the church
Theologically, the laity are the mainstay of any church body and the staff are employees. Thus, the real influence of any church, should they choose to express it, is in the lay leadership. Therefore, for any tangible change to take place in how a church body will receive and envelop adolescents, lay leadership is most in need of a strategic commitment to a Missional approach to youth ministry. Even a few strong lay people who are convinced that it is the spiritual responsibility of a local church to reach out to all young people and make a place for them in their community can effect great change. Here are some specific changes that can be made. Lay leadership should:
Conclusion
Missional youth ministry is an extension of the local body of Christ, where every person who desires to belong to the community is welcomed. Programs, then, are useful tools to attract and win those who are ultimately willing to come to a church, but they are never the end goal or focus of evaluation. In a missional youth ministry, each program is specifically and strategically analyzed to ensure that the focus is an intentional reaching out to those who may feel unconnected, with the goal of seeing that they are ultimately connected to the church at large. When students do feel relationally safe enough to attend a program, even then the program is not the end-all. Instead, a new student who attends a missional youth ministry event is embraced by the core students and adult leadership in such a way that there can be no doubt that their personal value to both the person and the church body has nothing to do with any level of programmatic participation. As Rollie Martinson, youth ministry expert for the Lutheran (ELCA) church, states, “Youth ministry belongs to God through the ministry of God’s whole church.”35
This type of approach does not presuppose that student leaders will not be able to use their gifts with their friends. Rather, they will be allowed to be adolescents themselves, on the journey that requires, by definition, the freedom to walk tall and occasionally fall down. The youth group is a community of broken people who are committed to loving one another, but it is not the only community of the church. The other programs and members of the church family are always respected and valued, parents are friends and partners of the leadership, and the worship service and other church events are cherished opportunities to celebrate the life of Christ as a body. Missional youth ministry seeks to present the community of the church as the end, not simply another (and often less desirable) community.
If the church will not address the cultural shifts of the past 30 years, then most young people will enter adulthood believing that the church is basically irrelevant and cares about them only when they show up at church.
God’s call is for the entire church community to create a relational environment where people, young and old alike, can experience a deep, rich, family-like environment where discipleship, equipping, nurture, training in spiritual disciplines, and mentoring all occur. This is what all people, and especially young people, need from the church.
In the evolution of church youth ministry, the focus has been on two things: the students that attend the church, as the target of the ministry; and outreach, defined as “bringing your friends to youth group.” While these two programmatic and philosophic focuses have served the church, with varied results, for the last several decades, a gap has widened between the people who have grown up in the church, own the church, and love the church, versus those who live outside of the sociological and spiritual boundaries of the local parish. This has created a family crisis. The church, especially as expressed in and through youth ministry, must recapture its historical theological roots and redefine its mission. Youth ministry and the local church are called to be a mission community with a missional commitment to rich Christian community that spills over into the secularized adolescent world. As Darrell Guder reminds us, “A missional ecclesiology must clearly identify and resist all attempts to equip the church merely for its maintenance and security.”36
Notes
1. Mark Yaconelli, “Youth Ministry: A Contemplative Approach,” The Christian Century, 28 April 1999, 2.
2. Darrell L. Guder, “Missional Context: Understanding North American Culture,” Missional Church: A Vision for the Sending of the Church in North America (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1998), 18–45.
3. F. F. Bruce, 1 and 2 Corinthians (Greenwood, South Carolina: Attic Press, 1971), 121.
4. Sherwood G. Lingenfelter and Marvin K. Mayers, Ministering Cross-Culturally (Grand Rapids: Baker, 1986), 27–26.
5. Darrell L. Guder, “Missional Church: From Sending to Being Sent,” A Vision for the Sending of the Church in North America (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1998), 4–5.
6. Dennis Guernsey, A New Design for Family Ministry (Elgin, Illinois: David C. Cook, 1982), 99.
7. Dean Borgman, “A History of American Youth Ministry,” in The Complete Book of Youth Ministry (Chicago: Moody Press, 1987), 67–74.
8.
. 69.
9. Mark Senter, The Coming Revolution in Youth Ministry (Wheaton: Victor, 1992), 125.
10. This overview and timeline is to be viewed as a macro-historical analysis. The actual dates and programmatic/philosophical influences vary greatly. Every church, locale, and denomination can trace its youth ministry roots in different ways and at different times.
11. Stuart Bond, “The One-Eared Mickey Mouse,” Youthworker (Fall 1989). Presbyterian youth pastor Stuart Bond addressed the issue of fragmentation in the church by describing the relationship between the youth ministry program as a “one-eared Mickey Mouse” with the church at large as Mickey’s head. In his description of church youth ministry, the point was made that youth ministry had become more and more separate as congregants. To take this illustration further, youth ministry has become, in essence, a semi-parachurch community loosely connected to the local congregation.
12. Senter, 142.
13. Although there are some who claim that there are more church-going young people than not (George Barna among them), there is no reliable empirical research even close to supporting this assertion. In nearly every community in North America, the number of adolescents that willingly attend a church, even on an infrequent basis, is vastly outnumbered by those that do not. This is an unchurched and religiously disinterested generation.
14. This comment was made by Jim Burns, President of the National Institute of Youth Ministry, during a seminar at the Youth Specialties 1986 National Youth Workers Convention.
15. Jim Burns, quoted by Wendy Murray Zoba in, “The Class of ’00,” Christianity Today, 3 February 1997, 21.
16. Subculture may bit a bit more accurate categorization of the adolescent community, but the differences between the Christian cultural world and the secular adolescent world are great enough that fully demarcating the difference with the term culture seems appropriate.
17. Perhaps this acclaim is not quite justified today, for there are those who critique many of these organizations for being as committed to their methods as are parish youth ministries. If so, then the concept of “missional” youth ministry is even more necessary to lift high, for if the parachurch organizations have capitulated to elevating form and method over vision and end goal, then the parish must take action in not neglecting this lost generation.
18. Bo Boshers, Student Ministry for the 21st Century (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1998), 95.
19.
.
20. Doug Fields, Purpose-Driven Youth Ministry (Grand Rapids: Youth Specialties/Zondervan, 1998), 88; Fields, 51.
21.
.
22. Boshers, 99.
23.
. 224.
24. Fields, 105.
25. For further adolescent clustering research, see—
26. Donald Posterski, Friendship: A Window on Ministering to Youth (Scarborough, Ontario: Project Teen Canada, 1985).
27. Jim Burns, The Youth Builder (Eugene, Oregon: Harvest House, 1988); and Duffy Robbins, The Ministry of Nurture (Grand Rapids: Youth Specialties/Zondervan, 1990).
28. Senter, 177.
29.
.
30. Phillip Yancey, lecture to a course on spiritual formation at Denver Theological Seminary, Winter 1996.
31. Dean Borgman, When Kumbaya Is Not Enough: A Practical Theology for Youth Ministry (Peabody, Massachusetts: Hendrickson, 1997), 6.
32. Although this point is too broad for this discussion, many, if not most, youth ministry professionals and leaders believe that the observable success of Doug Fields’s Purpose-Driven Youth Ministry, the Student Impact movement of Willow Creek, and Youth Specialties is proof that youth ministry is healthy and on solid ground. For reasons I have stated throughout this chapter and several others, I am not so convinced.
33. Guder, “Missional Church: From Sending to Being Sent,” 5–6.
34. Steven J. Sandage, “Power, Knowledge, and the Hermeneutics of Selfhood,” Mars Hill Review, No. 12 (Fall 1998): 65–73, 72.
35. Roland D. Martinson, Effective Youth Ministry: A Congregational Approach (Minneapolis: Augsburg, 1988), 12.
36. Guder, “Missional Connectedness: The Community of Communities in Mission,” Missional Church: A Vision for the Sending of the Church in North America (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1998), 268.
