Chapter 22 of 27

Response from a Preparatory perspective Wesley Black

Response from a Preparatory perspective Wesley Black

Response to the Strategic Approach from a Preparatory Perspective

by Wesley Black

Thanks, Mark, for an intriguing view of youth ministry that fascinated me with its possibilities. You almost converted me! For it holds out the hope of youths taking significant roles of leadership and involvement in the movement of God for now and the future.

One of the perpetual concerns of Christians revolves around who will carry on the mission of reaching our world for Christ—a concern that your Strategic approach addresses, albeit untraditionally. Church youth leaders are regularly frustrated to see young people who were once active and involved in the youth group drop out as they move into college and young adulthood. The stereotype says that they return when they reach 30, get married, have children, and get tired of sowing their wild oats.

The pattern today, however, is that those young people are seldom returning to church. So those churches that were once vibrant and filled with youthful energy are now only faint images of dynamic Christian life. There are plenty of reasons to be concerned, and the Strategic approach boldly steps in to solve the problems.

Better alternatives

Your chapter presents better alternatives than some other approaches do to the weaknesses of the past. Let’s face it—we have not done a very good job in some critical areas, especially evangelism. “The evangelization of youths was less and less a normal part of church youth ministry,” you write. “To put it bluntly, it simply was not happening.”

Too often, growth of youth ministry has been biological. That is, the children of adult church members join the youth ministry in greater numbers than those who are not in the church culture. We hoped this latter group would come, planned for them to be a part, and strategized creative ways to reach out to them. But still we have not done an adequate job in this area.

Is the Strategic approach realistic and reproducible? I wonder if churches that grow out of such an approach continue parenting new congregations, or settle in to building one growing congregation? Are there any second-generation churches built on a Strategic approach?

Another weakness of the past was the view of youths as the future of the church, rather than the church of today. As you put it, “In general, young people were not valued for what they brought to the church family as much as for what they would someday become.” We wanted them to become mature and step into leadership sometime in the future, when they were grown up and ready to accept more responsibility. But we did not provide adequate places for them to be personally involved at their current levels of maturity and responsibility as adolescents.

This weakness probably grew into the accepted mode of teaching and discipleship that has been practiced in most churches. You mentioned this in your argument about the “factory model of nonformal education which came to dominate formal education in the later part of the 19th century.” I agree that we should have been more intentional in developing better teaching or learning models, rather than simply accepting the mode of public school education. As you stated in the opening scenario, “Churches, including Sheila and Roger’s, adopted a schooling model of discipleship.”

While some forms of this schooling model results in effective transmission of content, it ignores the affective and skills areas in many cases. Even in the cognitive domain, few of us can disagree that many teens who have attended church classes most of their lives are still woefully ignorant of the most basic of Christian teachings.

Cell groups, accountability groups, one-to-one discipling, peer ministry programs, and mentoring strategies have been attempts to creatively approach alternatives to the informal schooling model that we see every Sunday in churches and youth groups.

“Discontinuity of relationships and specialization of content,” you write, “become the normal way of doing education.” This can result in poor teaching and even weaker emotional ties to the very organism we hope to strengthen. As you said, “A realistic appraisal of youth groups a decade after graduation suggests a disappointingly small number of alumni remain in either their home church or other churches.” It often takes an intentional, ongoing effort to maintain contact with youths and young adults after they move away from home and the church to go to college or start their careers.

You made a strong point when you said, “Unless the youth leader maintains a meaningful contact with graduates and encourages them to attend church together, very few establish a lasting relationship with a local church.” We can hope that our best efforts with youths will result in active, involved, motivated young adults who step into significant leadership roles.

It seems to me that your approach opens the door to youth ministers who are not truly motivated to minister to youths today, but rather have their eye on a future church.

But this is seldom the case. One reason lies in the entertainment approach of the past. But even those with more spiritually challenging approaches were guilty of creating a passive, stagnant youth group. “The explosive power of youthful Christian idealism wasted away in a series of youth society meetings and related committee assignments,” you pointed out. “Churches, both liberal and conservative, settled into an uneasy slide toward religion more defined by a social agenda than by the power of God.”

You particularly indicted the Preparatory approach when you quoted Erb: “In other words, the real tasks of the church [were] being performed by deacons, elders, and such persons, but young people up to, say, 30, [were] engaged in a sort of play by which they [would] be fitted for genuine work later on.” We must make the involvement and nurture of youths genuine and significant if we are to truly prepare them for future leadership roles.

Benefits

Another reason the Strategic approach makes sense is found in this approach’s benefits, which you articulated convincingly.

I often speak with youth leaders in ethnic churches where the worship services are in their native language. They are concerned with keeping their youths, most of whom speak English, active and involved in the church. Their Bible study classes are normally in English, while their parents’ classes may be in their native language. As you said, these churches “use an English-speaking youth service as a means of creating an American style service within the same church.” Their parents often face the dilemma of wanting their youths to stay faithful to their heritage and their church, but also wanting them to have a relevant, meaningful experience with their faith community. The solution is often a “church within a church” arrangement.

Another benefit of the Strategic approach deals with the person and ministry of the youth leader, especially female youth ministers. It is true, as you said, that doors may be closed for some women to become pastors of new churches. But other churches that would restrict the pastoral role to men will still allow females to lead their youth ministries. I think the Strategic approach could still allow opportunities for women, even in those churches, to lead the effort and groom male interns to become the pastors of those new churches.

Female or male, the youth minister is moved into a significant position in the overall mission of a church when that church practices the Strategic approach. As you wrote, “Church leadership has treated youth ministers as novice adults rather than permanent parts of the church’s strategy of discipleship and world evangelization.”

And I liked your emphasis on the motivation behind the Strategic approach. “A premise of the Strategic approach to youth ministry,” you wrote, “is that the best manner in which to renew the church is through systematically establishing new churches based in an evangelistic vision, a profound submission to the Word of God, and the power of God’s Spirit in the contemporary world.”

My criticism of the Strategic approach falls into two categories: the process of the Strategic approach, and issues revolving around generational and family concerns.

Realistic and reproducible?

My first concern deals with the process of the Strategic approach. Is it really realistic and reproducible? You presented some good illustrations of isolated examples in which a new church grew out of an existing youth group. The most visible example of this is Willow Creek Community Church. But does the philosophy continue there? Have other churches sprouted from the existing Willow Creek youth ministry? Is it a Strategic approach now? It is obviously a strong evangelistic ministry, but I wonder if churches that grew out of a Strategic approach continue the pattern or settle in to build a strong growing congregation. Perhaps it would be good if we could see some second-generation churches from a Strategic approach to youth ministry.

Avoid problems of the past?

Another question of process deals with the best way to avoid problems of the past with young leaders who launch new churches. You made a good point that we must view youth ministry “not so much as a means of turning out models of Christian living to perpetuate existing church ministries, but as the best opportunity to launch a vital Christian witness to shape the faith community for the next generation.” But if these teens are to assume leadership in a future, separate church, how will they know the existing problems and avoid them in the future? Are they doomed to learn only from their own mistakes and stand the chance of repeating the errors of the past?

How will teens learn the models and leadership skills necessary to organize and carry out the structure of a church? I am not arguing for the perpetuation of an existing, flawed model of the church, but for the organizational and leadership skills needed to function as a group in any effective manner. Is there not the danger of immature, narrowly focused programming that may miss some critical ministry functions due to the lack of mature leadership experiences?

Accountability of the youth minister

Another problem with the process involves the accountability of the youth minister. You mentioned this danger in discussing an emerging pastor who does not have theological training. In that case the mother church or campus ministry is to “hold the young pastor accountable for developing the ability to think and act Christianly.” This seems to be a shaky proposition because of the youth minister’s split loyalty: on one hand, the youth minister owes allegiance to the mother church, while on the other hand he is creating a separate entity that is different and distinct from the mother church. It seems that the youth minister (a future pastor) could misinterpret any theological correction from the mother church as an attempt to preserve the traditions of the past, which he hopes to correct in the new church.

Stepping stone?

Still another process problem lies in the idea that the youth ministry of the mother church is simply a stepping stone to a new church. You touched on this in the “profession argument” when you wrote that “by the time youth ministers get to the point where they can be effective professionals, they will begin pulling out of youth ministry and head into a senior pastor role.” While you acknowledge the difference between the old stepping stone motivation and the Strategic approach, I still think there is a trap here. You went on to say, “The idea of youth ministry being a church-birthing process provides a career path and may even attract a new type of gifted person to a youth ministry career.” It seems that this opens the door to those who are not truly motivated to minister to youths today, but rather have their eye on a future church.

Earlier you said that youth ministers should be chosen with the “primary objective…to develop a team of spiritually mature young adults and start a new church.” This sounds a lot like someone who has the prime intention of starting a new church with a secondary intention of ministering to the needs of youths in the present. If the new-church genesis takes longer than originally envisioned, the youth minister could become increasingly frustrated with youth ministry and long for his larger pastoral role over a new church.

We have to be careful that the Strategic approach does not become just a manipulation of young people. Youth ministers must be concerned about developmental, cultural, and generational needs of youths, more than simply using them as a process for starting a new church.

Youth ministry of the mother church

And what about the youth ministry of the mother church after a new church starts? Will it continue or move out to the new church? After all, most of the current youth leadership will become the nucleus of the new church. What will become of the rising youths in the mother church?

Parachurch workers building a church

My final objection to the Strategic approach as to process deals with parachurch workers building a church from their youth groups. So many parachurch workers seem to have a bias against “church” in the first place, with its structures, organizations, and traditions (no matter how relevant or effective). Why would they want to create something they perceive as a hindrance? Wouldn’t a newly created form of church still hold problems for the free spirited, entrepreneurial approach that drives many parachurch workers?

Generational and family issues

After process concerns, I believe that the Strategic approach has weaknesses in generational and family issues. You acknowledged this when you wrote that “the danger of the youth group genesis church is that it may be limited to people who are the about the same age as the youth pastor and younger.” You referenced this earlier: “The Strategic approach to youth ministry creates a community of leaders and youthful Christians.” Then you said this “calls upon the youth ministry to be and become a holistic intergenerational church that is relevant to the world in which it lives.” It seems to me that the very nature of this approach works against intergenerational interchange.

True, youth leaders may offer some adult role models. But I fear that in most cases these youth leaders will be youthful adults who are disenchanted with the traditions of the past and actually resist contact between their youth members and others of different generations who may potentially sidetrack efforts to create a new vibrant, untraditional body. You hinted at this again when you wrote that “the youth-group-genesis-church vision needs the exchange of ideas between generations, in order to accurately determine the leading of God.” You hit the nail squarely on the head: youths can benefit greatly when they hear the stories of faith from those of different generations. The Bible is filled with examples of those who listened and learned from both the victories and mistakes of other generations.

If the youth minister is moving toward the hope of launching a new, separate entity, and the youth group is going to be the nucleus of that effort, what will be the role of parents and younger children in this plan?

I also believe that youths need both church and family nurture to grow into Christian maturity. The Strategic approach seems to discount the influence of families on their young. It seems to build on the experiences of peers and church youth leaders only. If the youth minister is moving toward the hope of launching a new, separate entity, and the youth group is going to be the nucleus of that effort, what will be the role of parents and younger children in this plan? Will youths move away from their parents into a new church or will their parents move along with them? You did touch on this briefly, but it still seems unclear how this process plays out. Where will the lines of separation be drawn? Will part of the family (parents, small children, older relatives) be left behind in the mother church while youths and young adults populate the new genesis? If the older and younger members of the family also move, how much does this diminish the possibility that the new genesis will be different from the older mother church?

Finally, when new converts are assimilated, assuming they are youths or older adolescents, what is the hope of reaching their families? Will there be an intensive effort to reach out to them, or will they be left to find their own way without a warm invitation from the new genesis church?

↑ Back to top

↑