Rejoinder Mark H. Senter III
Rejoinder from the Strategic Approach
Come on, friends, your criticism is like rearranging furniture on the deck of the Titanic. As unsinkable as the church is, we simply cannot stay on board our current cruise liner. If nothing else, youth ministry of the 20th century has taught us that we need to do something fresh. The Strategic approach may not be the new vessel but at least it takes a good shot at grounding youth ministry in continuity with a biblical view of the church.
While I wholeheartedly affirm the biblical concept of inclusiveness, not just with youth ministry but also across racial, economic and gender lines, I see it happening best in a fresh new generation of churches. Similarly, I wholeheartedly advocate the church’s mandate for missional activity, especially among those who are spiritually disenfranchised, resulting in inclusive congregations of Christian believers, but I see it happening best where biblical values can be addressed within fresh patterns of relationships, in other words emerging churches. Yes, I affirm the responsibility of the family and faith community to prepare young people for their spiritual journey, but see it most possible where the end goal is a missional, inclusive congregational fellowship. I contend this is most possible through periodic formation of generationally relevant churches.
To paraphrase the words of our Lord, “I have not come to abolish your approaches to youth ministry and the church but to fulfill them.” My point is that we simply will not be able to honor the biblical mandate for the church to fulfill its purpose in the world if we keep pursuing our objectives within the existing structures. It is time for new wineskins.
Giving up on the church?
Does this mean the Strategic approach is giving up on the existing church? Is this a move to scrap the old wineskins? Not at all. It is merely suggesting that new wine needs to be put into new wineskins. The metaphor only stretches so far, so let me state it another way. The Strategic approach enables the mother church to become healthier because it forces her to make sacrifices of people and resources to birth a new church. Mission stops being something done with our money somewhere else, it becomes something our children do starting here and continuing close by.
If framed in a win-lose scenario, where the youth church wins and the mother church loses, then everybody loses. But when viewed as a win-win situation, the mother church becomes healthier when giving birth to a daughter church. The newborn will be healthiest when the mother church pays attention to her own spiritual health. It is my contention that the strategy, when handled as a vital and welcomed part of the mother church’s vision and mission, will redirect energies that were formerly squandered in pettiness into a richness of spiritual fruit.
Does this mean the Strategic approach is giving up on the existing church? Not at all. I am only t suggesting that new wine needs to be put into new wineskins.
Yet I feel like I need to return to your question, Malan. Am I giving up on the established church? Your question is quite fair. Let me be straightforward with you. I see the greatest hope for accomplishing what you describe as the biblical normal for the church to be found in creation, not in reform. New churches have a far greater possibility of being redemptive than do older, established churches. Obviously there are exceptions, but as a rule the most creative and dynamic ministry occurs within the first 10 to 20 years of a church’s existence.
As rich as the Christian heritage is, our traditions sap spiritual vitality. Reform in local churches is energy intensive. I feel the best stewardship of ministry resources is found in church ministry that is entrepreneurial in nature. The absence of a church polity accepted by orthodox and free, Lutheran and Reformed, Brethren and Wesleyan, Catholic and Pentecostal churches suggests to me that God is more interested in the redemption of man worshiping in a faith community than in conforming to an order of service or form of church government. I think this can best be accomplished by a strategy of church planting using the most gifted people available.
So what happens to established churches? Do we just let them die? Even if biological growth was the only means of keeping established churches alive, I am quite confident the mother churches would not close its doors. There will always be a group of young people who choose to remain in the mother church. If a new youth minister is hired prior to the departure of those involved in the church-birthing process, the new person will have the opportunity to begin building a new youth ministry even while the established leadership is moving on to a new and exciting ministry.
Church split?
I agree with you, Chap and Wes, when you warn of the downside effects that could take place if church-birthing is done with a negative attitude. If the Strategic approach is viewed as a euphemism for a church split, the strategy is in trouble. The youth minister, instead of bringing innovation to a new generation of ministry, will extend the inward focus of self-centered churchmen to succeeding church leadership. Pharisaical youth pastors turned senior pastors may pass along to the new church abnormalities in the spiritual genetic structure. In such cases, the daughter church will not be healthy. In all likelihood, the health of the mother church will be placed at risk as well.
This is not a “love it or leave it” mentality. Church-birthing youth ministry, unlike a youth church, is an attempt to capture the spiritual dynamic of a generation of Christian youths that express in fresh forms the biblical modes of God’s coming to his people.
Not a youth church
I was pleased that you did not mistakenly assume the Strategic approach to be synonymous with the current Youth Church fad. Youth Churches are just another form of the ghettoization of a generation of young people. The idea, while attractive to many, appears to me to be nothing more than an in-house, worship-based, missional approach. While I applaud all efforts at missional ministries and encourage any missional efforts that are tied to worshiping the Lord of heaven, I feel the idea does not overcome the need for continuity of discipleship or assimilation into a broader faith community that I addressed in my article.
Church-birthing youth ministry, unlike a youth church, is an attempt to capture the spiritual dynamic of a generation of Christian youths in order to bless other generations by expressing in fresh forms the biblical modes of God’s coming to His people. No, Chap, this is not a “love it or leave it” mentality. If it becomes a “my way or the highway” mindset, then the efforts will self-destruct. The unity of the body of Christ will be scandalized. Church birthing requires loving and responsible care similar to that required for bringing a healthy child into the world.
Evangelism
All of us have acknowledged that evangelism, especially for the disenfranchised, is a weak spot for youth ministry. I would contend that even a missional approach has a tendency to settle in and go native after a while. By that I mean a “go oriented” youth evangelist finds her niche and then invests the majority of her energy in evangelistic ministry within that niche. In a very limited fashion the “go” ministry becomes a “come” ministry for a specific population of disenfranchised youths. Is that a problem? Absolutely not, unless that sub-population of the youth society has been substantially evangelized (whatever that means). Then it is time for the “go” to start all over again.
The Strategic approach to youth ministry is merely an attempt to replicate that go or come strategy in a more holistic fashion. In addition to evangelism, the church-birthing ministry grows young people and the adult believers associated with them into a lasting faith community nourished by the other seven modes of God’s coming that you developed so well, Malan.
Is there not a vulnerability to losing the missional vision in the Strategic approach? Absolutely! That is why the emerging leadership is key. Mission must remain a priority of the church-birthing pastor.
Training of pastors
But mission is not the only manner in which God comes to His people. The experience of the youth ministry genesis churches I cited and many more suggests a gifted youth minister turned senior pastor is the key to balanced effectiveness. After all, it was gifted people that Christ gave to the church (Ephesians 4:7–13), not committees, strategies, or boards. In none of the youth ministry genesis churches I have researched, however, does this mean a one-man show. Gifted leaders attract other gifted people. The eight-fold coming of God is experienced in the strength of a multitude of gifted Christian leaders.
What does this mean for the training of church-birthing pastors? Is there a set of ministry skills needed before assuming the role of pastor/leader in a new church? Are youth pastors equipped to lead churches? The answer is complex. Many youth pastors would make awful pastor/leaders. They are still novice adults, passionate about young people, but still experimenting with the responsibilities associated with the world in which they will live for the rest of their lives. No training, formal or informal, will transform these people into effective pastors.
The Strategic approach is the best and highest form of stepping stones—especially for a person who is passionate and effective as a youth minister and thereby qualifies to continue serving as a midwife for a new church.
Church-birthing pastors fit no set of leadership traits, except effectiveness in communication skills. They share no single approach to ministry training, except a deep desire to maintain integrity with God and his Word. Most are lifelong students (at least so far). Some have formal training, others do not. Leadership styles differ from the very outset of their ministries. Theological and biblical concerns tie church-birthing pastors firmly to the issues of the day, yet these issues drive church-birthing pastors back to the same Scriptures that sustained Augustine, Luther, Calvin, Wesley, Spurgeon, Barth, and the theologians of our day.
With all this discussion about where youth ministers could be in their late 30s, the idea of youth ministry seems to have disappeared. What will happen to contact work on the high school campus, small group Bible studies, worship songs, concerts, retreats, mission trips, and lock-ins? Most of these will go on just the way they did before, except now they will have both a long-and short-range objective. The youth minister must be effective in evangelizing and discipling young people or else there is little reason to think they could lead in giving birth to a church.
Stepping stone revisited
I know what you are saying, Wes—it is just a sophisticated way of bringing back the stepping stone philosophy of youth work. You commented that “it seems that this opens the door to those who are not truly motivated to minister to youths today, but rather have their eye on a future church.” Two comments seem appropriate. In the first place, many youth ministers view youth ministry as a stepping stone to a larger, more influential youth ministry in another church. The net result is a revolving door of youth ministers. In my opinion, the Strategic approach would dismantle this status-driven motivation and refocus the energy on a more biblical ecclesiology.
My second comment has to do with the fact that a de facto stepping-stone philosophy already exists. Except, the stepping stone is out of ministry. Because there is no clear career path for youth ministers (except into larger churches or some administrative role in parachurch agencies, such as area director) or because growing families place increased financial demands on youth workers, many of the most gifted ministry people find it necessary to leave ministry, rather than burn themselves out.
I guess what I am saying, Wes, is that the Strategic approach is the best and highest form of stepping stones. I am not talking about the recent seminary graduate who cannot land a senior pastorate and so takes an associate pastor position where most of the responsibility rests with youths, until such time that a “real” pastoral position opens up. I am talking about the person who is passionate and effective as a youth minister and thereby qualifies to continue serving as a midwife for a new church.
One size fits all?
If I counted correctly, you raised 17 or 18 criticisms or questions about the Strategic approach. Most of these, to my surprise, were process questions focusing on how this rather novel idea might become a reality rather than on its theological viability. I tried to address these questions in my comments above. Still, situations will differ. The only way these questions can be answered is in the local situation. This simply cannot be a “one size fits all” proposal.
Conclusion
As I end my rejoinder, I would suggest the following questions, drawn in part from your responses and your chapters. These could serve as wonderful tools for the youth ministry to prevent serious flaws from being built into the church-birthing process.
Thanks for all of your wonderful interactions as we examined the Strategic approach to youth ministry.
