Chapter 9 of 31

4. Technology and Adoptive Youth Ministry

4. Technology and Adoptive Youth Ministry

4

Technology and Adoptive Youth Ministry

BRADLEY HOWELL

Everywhere I go parents, pastors, and youth workers want to talk about technology. “Technology” is a broad topic with many facets and aspects, to say nothing of the myriad debates concerning the impact of various technological media. In one recent seminar, I received the following five questions back to back:

  • What does social media do to kids’ relationships?
  • How much time should my kid spend playing video games and watching Netflix?
  • How does texting affect my son’s ability to have a conversation?
  • At what age should my child get a smartphone?
  • Is “cyber counseling” a helpful trend?
  • This is a book about youth ministry, primarily a textbook but also a handbook for anyone who desires a comprehensive resource about the practice of adoptive, or communally driven, youth ministry in today’s complex society. Because this is a book, we run the risk of talking about the issue of “technology” in a way that makes the content obsolete before this book even goes to print. This chapter, then, does not attempt to specifically answer any of these questions, especially the more contextual, cultural, or even timely queries that youth ministers will be asked about in a parent’s meeting or seminar. Instead, Dr. Bradley Howell helps us to think about technology, especially as various issues relate to the concept of adoptive youth ministry. After providing a general overview of how technological advances are received in the three stages of adolescence—early (ages roughly ten to fourteen), middle (fifteen to twenty) and emerging adult (twenty to mid- to late twenties)—Howell then provides a primer on “Perspectives on Digital Connectivity” and closes with a resource list for further study and discussion. While a good and important starting point for the conversation, this chapter is simply intended to get you thinking about this vast area as you develop a healthy and contextually appropriate adoptive youth ministry.

    This highlights why we have added to this book the component of digital connectivity with our authors. On the website youthministry.fuller.edu, Howell, like every author, has a page for this chapter’s topic (as well as his contact information). As a scholar and professor who is constantly looking at issues related to youth ministry and technology (like all of the authors in Adoptive Youth Ministry), Howell has made himself available for a conversation or a web interview for an individual or a class. For this topic in particular, he will continually add to the website new resources, articles, and information. Howell is committed to the continuing study of the impact and power of technology, especially as it relates to youth ministry, and he is a helpful resource as we head into a future of more technological uncertainty.

    As you read this chapter, consider these questions:

  • What were the most significant technological issues for you in middle school? In high school? As an emerging adult? What made them significant?
  • List and prioritize the top five most significant technological issues that youth ministry leaders will have to deal with in the next few years. How does this chapter help you to understand them and give you the ability to critically reflect on them?
  • What from this chapter is important to share and discuss with parents to help them get a better handle on dealing with technological issues?
  • Howell closes the chapter with the assertion that the issue is really not about technology but about how people use technology (i.e., digital connections) in a changing society. His caution is to remember that our role as youth workers is to be about people, which is especially true for those committed to participating in God’s adoptive work. What are some ways we can use technology to enhance adoptive youth ministry?
  • Gun in one hand and a camera in the other, the frustrated father targets a small black laptop lying unceremoniously on a patchy, dying lawn. As had already been explained earlier in his video, his teenage daughter’s efforts to hide her social media rants about her parents had failed. Apparently, being grounded for months on end did nothing to change the heart of this adolescent digital lamenter. As a repeat offender, she was about to enter a whole new level of paternal discipline (likely without her knowledge): the digital twilight zone of viral video parenting.

    Fully loaded with hollow-point rounds and fueled with self-justified enragement, her father effortlessly squeezes the gun’s trigger. As the first shots ring out, the viewer’s imagination intuitively fills in the stunned cheers of exasperated parents everywhere. Shot after devastating shot discharge from the gun until the ammunition is spent and the object of the father’s wrath resembles something more akin to a black mangled mass of plastic Swiss cheese than a gateway to the digital realm. If this father’s daughter is to have any future rants, they will not be hurled at the digital world stage from this computer.

    Perhaps we should be thankful that the vast majority of families would never seriously consider posting their pain, disappointments, and dramatic acts of retribution online as casual enjoyment for tens of millions of people. However, not unlike the undernourished grass backdrop to the digital spectacle, too many households struggle to maintain a well-nourished, healthy family in a culture of digital relationships. Whether adoptive youth ministers love or hate technology, they know all too well that many of the families entrusted to their spiritual care are being torn apart by digital behaviors. We see it on our teens’ online posts, we hear about it in small groups and parent meetings, and every once in a while we are conscripted to the unenviable task of digital referee.

    Yet the technological world juxtaposes the digital pressures families navigate with another pressure an adoptive youth minister must tackle: the artful task of actually using technology to augment an adoptive ministry. This frustration is amplified when videos like the one described above go viral while the (of course) deeply life-changing and spiritually important youth group digital messages often appear to go unnoticed. On one hand, technology seems to promise that, with just a few well-placed keystrokes or a creative viral video, any one individual could have most of the earth’s population as their audience. On the other hand, many youth workers find they struggle to grab their own students’ attention, much less discover some utopian technological promised land. Complicating this dichotomy is the sea of competing digital applications, voices, and digital tools. Employing the right one in the best way to reach the most youth feels like a never-ending uphill battle.

    How did we get here?

    “You’ve Got Mail!”

    That phrase, with its corresponding squeaks, squawks, and bleeps summarizes well the transitional marker of the internet’s incursion into the general public’s mental awareness. During much of the 1990s through the dawn of the new millennium, homes and businesses were relentlessly infiltrated by heaps of AOL CD-ROM disks. These discs would arrive daily through technology magazines, office supply stores, and what was increasingly being labeled as snail mail—the traditional post office. This colossal marketing campaign invited the user to become a cyberspace pioneer, with AOL as the virtual gateway. This all took place barely two decades ago—a nanosecond in world history but an eon in the digital age.

    The internet adopted in the 1990s was itself an innovative tool for passing information and enabling multicomputer collaboration. At some level it even had the capacity to augment human relationships through online chat rooms and Instant Messaging (IM). But chat rooms required coordination if two people who actually knew each other were to use them at the same time. Plus, only half of the US population at that time ventured onto the internet, and only about a quarter of those folks were even willing to try chat rooms; consequently, people primarily relied on email to digitally connect. So, at its core, the first public rendition of the internet was a platform for sending and receiving information.

    Of course, emails were not the only data that the internet was useful for. The entertainment industry, the business world, national sport teams, governments, and even religious communities voluntarily (in response to social pressure) began to explore website design and development. This quickly developed into an impressively massive worldwide web of interconnected bits of data that, to some extent, put the individual user at the center of it. The mental image of the internet as an information superhighway was born.

    For the youth worker who finds him- or herself caught between parents who adopted this mental model of the internet as an information superhighway and a generation of young people who did not, this is a subtle but important distinction. The information age shaped the perspective of modern parents and their spiritual communities toward an internet that existed to give and receive information, but it was considered to be a virtual world—a shadow of the real thing—and socially isolating. That understanding of the internet is a far cry from the mental model that a new generation of internet adopters would soon take.

    At the dawn of the new millennium (or “Y2K,” as it had been labeled), three-quarters of adolescents were active internet users. Unlike adults of that time, teens were multitasking; they kept IM applications open while they were doing homework, gaming, or listening to music, and consequently, they found they had many friends available to exchange emails or IM with. But the mental model that adults were using to understand the internet had no framework for interpreting this type of activity. In an information superhighway model, the internet is “virtual,” not real; it is about information, not people. Despite how teens were actually using the internet, the popular “socially isolating” label stuck. The fragmentation had begun, and the digital divide, an antithetical mind-set to an adoptive ministry, was taking root and about to explode.

    In 2002, an innovative social platform arrived in the virtual universe that would radically alter the trajectory of a document-based interconnected digital network. Utilized first by Friendster and then MySpace, this development cultivated a remaking of the internet into a beta version of itself: Web 2.0. The fundamental change that Web 2.0 brought over the next half-decade was to make the internet synonymous with the humans who would adopt it. Increasingly, people did not merely send and retrieve bits of information between each other—they digitally re-created themselves, their likes, their activities, and their friendship structure online. The internet was morphing from an interconnected web of documents into an inter-webbed connection of humans.

    The implications of this relational shift were huge, but during the shift it was difficult to make sense of what was actually happening. The revolution would be commonly likened to the invention of the Gutenberg press. Not surprisingly, with the dominant paradigm of the internet being an information superhighway the rhetoric of thought leaders centered on a shift concerning information control. Likened to the days of the Reformation, the old guardians of information would be replaced. Yet no one was quite sure what the fallout was actually going to be.

    During this period it became increasingly evident that there was an oversimplification of adolescent internet use and a general acceptance of treating teens as a “monolithic social entity.” Fast forward to our current time. Teens today are not all using the internet in exactly the same way, but they continue to be treated as if they are. Where this cultural oversimplification mind-set enters the spiritual community, it is more like a cancer to the human body, threatening to distort, destroy, and devour the spiritual body. Terms like “digital native” and “internet addiction” marginalize an entire generation while simultaneously relieving adults of the responsibility to bridge the digital divide. Furthermore, marginalization allows adults to expect teens to act at adult standards of digital behavior yet abandons adolescents to discover on their own what that even means.

    Marginalization remains a significant concern not only among the general population but among researchers and ministry experts as well. Consequently, contemporary researchers typically need to wade deep into the data to extrapolate the differences of how early, mid-, and late adolescence each approach their digital decisions. For adoptive youth ministry leaders, though, understanding how the different adolescent stages of development play out in the digital universe is of foundational importance if they want to be caring adults who can truly come alongside adolescents.

    The Digital World for Adolescents

    Concrete Minds in the Bounce House of Conceptual Space

    Observe a group of early adolescents (roughly middle-school aged) for fifteen minutes and they may appear to be consumed by technology. It may also seem like they are making their own decisions about which digital activities they choose to engage. However, because they are closer to childhood than adulthood (in terms of their brain development), their sense of self and the freedom of leisure options are more shaped by their family then something as abstractly reflective as digital choices. Even their friendships are not exempt from this family influence.

    Across the developmental spectrum, adolescent offline friendship networks are almost exclusively with other young people of the same age, and these networks extend themselves into the digital world. For these young adolescents, their peer groups consist of the natural relational pools that, for most eleven- to fourteen-year-olds, are a reflection of their family’s lifestyle and relational commitments and connections. These pools include extended family, school, and extracurricular activity. An early adolescent’s digital activities are constrained both by these peer groups and the technology that is available to them. If given the choice, early adolescents report to adults that they would prefer to interact face-to-face with their friends then play online with them. But for the most part, that option is beyond their control. Early adolescents generally go where they are taken, so digital interactions are the only available substitute for face-to-face ones.

    Mentally speaking, even though early adolescents are only beginning to be capable of reflecting on their own perspective as well as the perspective of others, most adults believe they should be able to frame their actions in line with what the broader society would consider as being socially appropriate. While they have been compelled to deal with thorny issues of adolescence at this age—how I see myself and how I think others see me—consistent and rational “third person” thought applied to the concrete problems that they encounter remains an elusive goal. This means that the concrete dynamic of early adolescence requires that they approach digital tools from their own limited sense of reality. What matters to an early adolescent is what is happening in the here and now, which has fairly dynamic effects for the conceptual world of digital tools.

    When concrete thinking is the mode of operation for early adolescents, interesting scenarios begin to ensue. I had the opportunity to observe one such development unfold while exploring how digital relationships affect offline ones. During my research I was spending many afternoons observing adolescents in public settings. One particular gender-mixed group kept passing through a local fast food restaurant on their way home from school, and over a period of days a drama unfolded that was rooted in their concrete thinking. They had all joined the same digital community that required raising and selling animals while building an online farm. They had shared login information with everyone in the group in order to demonstrate to the novices how the site worked, reveal various insider shortcuts, and help one another keep their farms growing. To the concrete-minded young people involved, this made perfect sense.

    After a few days though, an adult dropped what may as well have been a virtual grenade on this group of aspiring digital farmers. One mom made her daughter change her login credentials. According to the daughter who had to report this to her friends, Mom had threatened to ground her from the computer if she were to share her login with her friends again.

    Now, without having a chance to hear from the mother, the most likely conclusion a reasonable adult would come to is that Mom could envision the complications of someone else pretending to be her daughter online, while these middle school students clearly had not. But what mom did not envision was the relational fallout that was about to occur among this specific group of friends.

    Without any conceptual framework to navigate this new development (appeals to a mother’s discipline were not enough), tempers quickly soared, friendships were questioned, and name-calling ensued. The girls in the group demanded access to their friend’s site; the boys more or less just sat there, nodding their heads back and forth to the verbal volley. Then, as quickly as it started, the fight ended unresolved with the girls darting out of the restaurant in tears. The poor guys were left sitting at the table, ice cream dripping down their fingers, completely dumbfounded. They had just witnessed the inadvertent fallout of a parent’s best intentions but had no conceptual understanding of what they were experiencing.

    While I have no way to know for certain what (if anything) happened in the next stage of the fight, it does not take much imagination to understand that name-calling in person oozes into digital space. Without anyone being able to articulate it (at least for this particular group), sharing login credentials had subconsciously become a measuring stick of friendship validation. When one of the friends could no longer measure up, the response was to turn on that girl.

    How to deal with middle school girls being extremely mean to each other, both online and off, continues to be among the most common concerns that youth ministries, teachers, school administrators, and families face. Early adolescent girls appear to be constantly on relational high alert and are quick to determine relational status. Research appears to confirm this.

    In a report conducted by the Pew Research Center’s Internet & American Life Project on teens and cruelty online, almost every single twelve- or thirteen-year-old female had an opinion as to whether others were mean or kind to each other in digital space—about two-thirds chose kind, one-third chose mean, and about 3 percent chose “it depends.” No other grouping of teens comes even close to this level of certainty about their peers, and the report makes special note that this is statistically significant. Early adolescent females are the most relationally intuitive people on the digital landscape. Their male counterparts, however, were the most likely of any adolescent group to report that their peers were kind; they were also the most likely to give a nebulous answer on the quality of digital relationships. So, unlike their female peers, it seems that most early adolescent boys think everything is just kind of, sort of, well . . . fine.

    For an adoptive youth ministry, this implication is noteworthy. These girls are actively listening to digital conversations and deciding whether people like them or not in their online interactions. Actions of adults both online and off will be constantly and relentlessly weighed. The implications do not end in the youth worker’s relationship with girls in this age group; they carry over into other relationships that early adolescent females are trying to balance. Thus an adoptive ministry-minded adult must always keep in mind a young person’s context with each digital engagement.

    There are other land mines as well. Concrete-minded early adolescents do not have the intrinsic ability to anticipate the emotional disruption their own actions can cause others online. Students regularly do multiple activities on their computers or leave themselves logged in after they have left the screen. On occasion they can even leave in the middle of an online activity if their attention is snagged or if their parents demand it. With all of these demands for attention, it is little surprise that their like-minded peers find themselves in half-finished conversations and activities, but middle school students are unaware of this.

    Adults, however, are deeply concerned about how young people treat one another online, and rightly so. It turns out that “being ignored” is the most common reported form of adolescents being mean to each other online. Yet concrete-minded early adolescents who physically leave their computers while being logged in, engage in multiple activities simultaneously, or even send comments of retaliation to others who ignore them online have little intuitive awareness of how their actions affect others online. Even something as simple as understanding that their friend at the other end might not actually be there may be difficult to understand without being prompted to do so.

    Youth leaders, parents, coaches, and teachers can all step into this gap. Middle school students need adults who are a part of their offline world to experience the online world along with them—to get in there and play games online together, to share, care, and be a pastoral presence in a digital landscape. They need adults who will take the time to understand the digital world from the context of the early adolescent. This means we cannot merely take the internet in terms of how we want it to be or how we wish to use it. We need to take it as it actually is. Early adolescents need adults who do not accidently ignore them because of their own adult tendencies to multitask. They need adults to be living, walking, and intentionally modeling grace in day-to-day digital life together.

    Mid-adolescents and the Internet

    Friendship Clusters Offering 24/7 Emotional Support

    It will be another generation before mid-adolescents (ages fourteen or fifteen to nineteen to twenty-one, on average) will have parents who grew up with digital relational tools as a significant aspect of everyday life. By then it is quite possible that some new technological innovation will have been introduced that will change the nature of human interaction as it is commonly understood today. This is not a prediction that something never heard of before is about to be launched but rather a reflection on the fact that parents often ask why teens today can’t talk on the phone like they did when they were teens. In interactions with parents, my normative strategy is to remind them of what life was like for them as teenagers: if their parents were at all like mine, they were not as concerned about teenage telephone habits as today’s parents are about internet habits. Yes, my parents were frustrated with how much I tied up the telephone, but no one accused me of losing an ability to hold a conversation, not being able to look adults in the face, or that my brain was being rewired (arguments that accentuate fragmentation). The concerns of parents when I was a teenager were basically about convenience—there was often only one phone line, and the teens were typically clogging it up.

    The problem with the fragmenting statements is not whether they are true; the concern is expecting a different outcome without actually being involved in day-to-day life. Research consistently affirms that most adults simply are not all that present in the digital lives of adolescents. Many adults likely do not even know where to start. In addition to the difficulty of personally monitoring the online and digital world of their children is the proliferation of new digital tools, apps, and technologies that allow and even encourage mid-adolescents to diversify their online practices. The development of new apps and updates to existing ones are relentless, and with every new technology and option teens are drawn deeper into the digital environment. Web 2.0 is the perfect digital environment for egocentric, newly abstract mid-adolescents.

    Mid-adolescents, by definition, are shifting from the childlike concreteness of awareness and integration into the ability for abstract thought. In their everyday interactions, however, they have not fully developed an internal, autonomous self or a central, formalized identity that integrates how they behave and operate in their various relational contexts. Parents, teachers, coaches, and others who interact with mid-adolescents online see the result of this phenomenon when they happen along a post that they were never meant to see. Mid-adolescents understand that their actions affect others, but they do not have the life experiences that provide a realistic perspective on the intricacies and nuances of human communication and relationships. Even if a person of authority never deliberately meant to come across a digital post that they were never intended to see, the mid-adolescent perceives this as a breach of trust. From the adolescent’s perspective, he or she is completely justified in being appalled by such an act, regardless of the propriety or appropriateness of the original post.

    As Web 2.0 reached its first decade of existence, many of the social media sites still collected all of a participant’s contacts into a single, mass group. This caused the various relational boundaries to bleed into one another in digital space; in geophysical space they would have been more isolated. While connecting with adults has never been the primary intent of mid-adolescents when they initially engage with digital tools, adults are coming in and out of their digital interactions, at least at some level. As they do, adults expect mid-adolescents to behave online as if they are adults—that is, as if they are fully individuated and therefore aware of the possible consequences of how they interact online, especially toward those who are not in their inner circle of peers. Of course, this is not typically at the forefront of a mid-adolescent’s thinking when he or she is flying in and out of various digital environments. Consequently, in digital networks mid-adolescents are rarely even aware of what adults would consider a mature ability to present a cohesive and integrative mature “self” across all platforms and websites. When their inconsistency and perceived lack of integrity in their online identities have been exposed to adults, the most common response is to blame the adults who “caught” them at being somehow “less than” they presented themselves in direct interactions and to dive deeper into the relative safety and anonymity of their peer group—what Chap Clark calls the “Worth Beneath” in Hurt 2.0.

    As mentioned earlier, teens connect online with those they know offline. It is not the technology itself that is the most captivating for teens; it’s the access that tech gives them to their friends. Among mid-adolescents, there is a general belief that digital tools increase a sense of connectedness among their peer group. This social network consists of their friendship cluster—a very loyal and typically gender-exclusive small group of friends who watch out for one another. These clusters are described in friendship terms by mid-adolescents, yet recent research of this age group tends to support the notion that the cluster is more a “network of mutual self-protection” rather than support system of adultlike, self-sacrificing friendships. Because the point of the mid-adolescent friendship cluster is mutual self-protection and the ability to navigate the mid-adolescent years in perceived community and relative enjoyment, the basic structure demands a loyalty to the values of the cluster. While previous generations were safely bound by direct interpersonal modes of communication, mid-adolescents, through offline relationships, are increasingly being exposed in the online world for all to see. As the adults in their lives adopt each new technological tool, they increasingly need to find new ways to keep the world beneath hidden from adult view. However, digital space is increasingly becoming the only location where adults are bumping into teens.

    Lack of Geophysical Space in an Ever-Changing World

    One increasing change in our culture is the amount of space available to adolescents. Typically, physical space has been an important ingredient for developing friendship networks that promote individual identification and group distinctiveness. However, actual space set aside for adolescent use has been shrinking. Furthermore, any space that is created for adolescents often leaves them out of the design process; they are frequently presented with environments that they find foreign, unusable, and even hostile to their desire to connect with one another. Given that adolescents are actually losing space for relational development, they are understandably turning to the internet to facilitate peer socialization. The result is that digital space is now a place where adolescents interact with the various social groups in their lives, each of which develops its own unspoken norms to guide behavior and from which teens are learning to differentiate their identity from others. This systematic removal of teens from public spaces reduces opportunities for intergenerational interaction and a broader sense of social solidarity, more so than in any other time in history. The result is a series of generational silos that are becoming increasingly foreign to one another.

    Early in social media, adolescents were limited to creating alternative user profiles within a specific social media site to balance their demonstration of loyalty to their friendship group and navigate the expectations of adults. Some social media sites have been developing ways that a person can more easily distinguish between their natural circles, but young people tend to find those tools somewhat cumbersome and awkward. It is becoming increasingly easier for friendship clusters to migrate to different digital tools that allow for both a wide audience of peers to invite themselves into the intended interactions and relationships of the more dedicated cluster group and for adults to digitally wander among their most sacred of friendship groups. They may feel betrayed and violated by those who observe their digital life uninvited, yet at the same time mid-adolescents continue to expose themselves in places and ways that summons the masses to enter. While teens are more comfortable than the general public about displaying themselves on the internet, this does not mean they have the life experience or skills to deal with the ripple effects of the increased visibility. This confusing dichotomy is the trademark of mid-adolescent online interaction. Adolescents need to be included in the design, development, and use of physical space where they can interact with adults who will fully embrace mid-adolescents for who they are. Then, in the same way that teens use tech themselves, life lived in the physical world will have the opportunity to reflect itself in the digital.

    Emerging Adults and the Internet

    Emerging adults (between twenty and the late twenties) have learned to use online interactions with a greater sensitivity to how they present themselves to the world at large. While they do not have the geophysical restraint issues that they exhibited when they were younger, they continue to use digital tools primarily to remain connected with those whom they have an existing, or promising, personal connection. Similar to mid-adolescents, emerging adults find that digital tools add a positive dimension to their already existing relationships. In a way that is comparable to mid-adolescent behavior, the quality and nature of offline relationships are mirrored in the digital ones.

    However, there is something different about how emerging adults understand and utilize the web in their social interactions and behavior. Increasingly, young adults are turning to the internet to meet new people, and it appears (although the research is preliminary at best) that many emerging and young adults believe using social media to expand their relational network is not only appropriate but also a sound strategy for finding romantic partners. According to research, meeting new people was rated as the most positive reason to engage in online dating sites; conversely, wading through piles of false profiles was rated as the most negative aspect of these same sites. While this has proved to be a necessary part of the online dating experience, the process is like using a machete to forage through a dense jungle: even when the false or misleading profiles are cleared away, the path is not necessarily all that clear to users, especially those who are new to the process.

    Even among legitimate profiles, it appears to be a common practice to manipulate content or pictures to emphasize or enhance one’s appearance and to a lesser degree social standing in order to be successful on digital dating sites. This was especially true for women, with men being more critically aware of a potential date’s attractiveness than females were. Complicating this further, emerging adults are only beginning to learn to balance self-promotion with desirability, so these online dating sites become a kind of hyperrelational tool in developing one’s own sense of identity and then filtering that identity through a vast sea of others’ hyperrelational attempts at public identities. For emerging and young adults, negotiating the social media landscape in order to find meaningful relationships requires the delicate and often significantly difficult task of balancing three competing factors: garnering attention to one’s self by enhancing (or at least highlighting) one’s characteristics and attractability and attempting to grow into an integrated, mature person who is recognized and received as an interdependent and individuated adult while trying to determine the maturity and authenticity of others on the social network.

    Given this struggle, it is astonishing that emerging adults are also more likely than their younger counterparts to post sexually explicit material online (astonishing because this behavior is an appeal to attract potential suitors by exposing one’s external attributes while actually wanting desperately to be attractive for much more intrinsic and enduring qualities). Among a majority of males and a minority of females, a social acceptance of pornography is developing, and this attitude spills over into online behaviors. Increased levels of sexual activity are in line with Erik Erikson’s theory that in the oldest stage of adolescence there is an increased concern with sexual attractiveness and identity. The issue, of course, with the casual excesses of sexuality and promiscuity represented in contemporary digital networks, is that it sets up both men and women for almost certain disappointment in the quality and longevity of ensuing relationships. However, relational land mines are not limited to digital promiscuity.

    Perhaps surprisingly, some emerging adults are turning to online gaming sites to discover and develop relationships. While online gaming remains a relatively limited research field, one online gaming study suggests that emerging adults are also using these sites for relational and even romantic connections. Yet, in an ironic twist, those who turn to online gaming communities for the specific intent of meeting new people report a greater sense of loneliness and family fragmentation than those who play with friends or family. Playing massive multiplayer online games with friends and family strengthens those relational bonds, while searching out new people weakens existing relationships.

    Technology is not merely an exception to physical presence; it can be a partner. But turning to technology to meet one’s needs for human relationships seems to lead to a cycle of turning back to digital connections and away from face-to-face human connectivity. This fragmenting cycle will potentially estrange their existing relationships, putting at risk their very desire to find someone to love and be loved by.

    The implication for adoptive ministry then is found in how we view technological tools. Similar to other stages, we must always begin with the people we desire to serve, and those people need to be people with whom we interact in and around our geophysical spiritual community. While online gaming accountability groups may have some value, attempts to build relationships and evangelize strangers online may well result in our facilitation of the estrangement of other relationships. Instead, spiritual communities need guidance in building bridges with emerging adults in their geophysical relationships—bridges that will develop into relationships that can be augmented with digital tools.

    Other Current Perspectives on Digital Connectivity

    Adolescent development was chosen as a primary way to consider adolescent tech use because it easily provides a framework for understanding adolescent context, giving the astute youth worker a simple structure from which to evaluate the conflicting voices of tech guidance. Therefore, this information serves only as a conversation starter for the reality and impact of tech on an adoptive youth ministry. The effects of social media on brain development as well as formational concerns, the cultural acceptance of multitasking, and privacy issues are just a few of the myriad digital realities with ministry implications that could be addressed. Formational ideology and multitasking are highlighted here.

    Formational Concerns

    Psychologist and MIT professor Sherry Turkle is a researcher and specialist on how technology interacts with human sociability. While Turkle initially believed that the internet held promising opportunities for human identity and relational exploration, she now has the conviction that Web 2.0 reduces opportunities for identity experimentation, primarily because most digital self-representations are archived. By this, Turkle is talking about digital footprints: posts, texts, uploaded videos all can remain present online and follow students into their future. From Turkle’s perspective, these activity logs keep adolescents somewhat stuck in past expressions of identity, thus hindering their ability to experiment with new expressions and forms of identity, as is required in order to grow into healthy adulthood.

    Another concern is reflected in the title of Turkle’s book, Alone Together, where she proposes, “At the extreme, we are so enmeshed in our connections that we neglect each other.” In Turkle’s research, the effect of digital technology is a growing dependence on the digital tools to build and enhance relational intimacy instead of the actual people these represent. Turkle, for example, demonstrates how cell phones have so come to embody a person’s social safety net that “having a feeling without being able to share it is considered so difficult that it constitutes an emergency.” Perhaps we see this in how teens (and adults) keep their phones beside their beds in order to be fully available to others in their life, when what they might really need to be a good friend tomorrow is a good sleep tonight.

    Danah Boyd, however, believes that concerns about how our digital connections affect the human condition are really a concern of the adult population. For Boyd, adults, on the one hand, tend to focus on the tech over the deeper formational issues because the technology is the easiest to see. Teens, on the other hand, are more concerned about what it means to participate in the public sphere and treat technology tools as a given. Similarly, though from the perspective of a marketer, Paul Adams suggests that successfully using digital tools requires being less focused on the tech and more focused on people. The formation of individuals, as well as their inclusion into community, begins with people, not the technology.

    Exposing the Myth of Multitasking

    To many, multitasking is a style of handling daily life that is not only acceptable but also preferable. The research, however, tells us that if someone is in the habit of engaging in multiple media activities at the same time, he or she is likely not doing any of them very well, or at least as well as if he or she were focused on a single event or experience. As it turns out, it might even be destroying a person’s ability to think clearly about even the most mundane tasks. In a Stanford University study, compared to their more focused peers, those who engage in heavy media multitasking had a more difficult time focusing on important information, ignoring irrelevant data, or even being able to switch between tasks without constantly thinking about many other things. Heavy media multitasking means it is likely taking longer to do everything and none of it is probably getting done as well as it could. Likely this includes relationships. What is more troubling than the consequences associated with adults who embrace this way of living is that there is an even more significant effect on children and adolescents.

    Similar research, led by Stanford University professors Roy Pea and Clifford Nass, indicates that multitasking appears to be having a negative social and emotional developmental effect on “tween”-aged girls (ages eight to twelve). Preteen girls who were heavy media users, whether social media or entertainment-based, trended toward feeling more isolated and different from others (in a negative way), got less sleep, and had more friends that their parents thought were bad influences on their daughters. While this sounds depressing, the solution that researchers discovered was a relatively simple one.

    Preteens need face-to-face interaction if they are going to develop a positive sense of social and emotional well-being. Children need adults who will not only walk alongside them but who will also look at them face-to-face and engage together in conversations. But this solid research has simply not been able to make a dent in the overwhelming cultural commitment to advertising directed at the very young that encourages and manipulates them to engage deeply in all forms of the individualistic and impersonal activities of social and entertainment media. The marketing of the Amazon Fire phone from AT&T is a prime example. In this ad, seemingly independent, multitasking hipster kids, coffee press and all, school adults on how to maximize the technological capabilities of their new phones. The boy proclaims, “I’ve been on this earth nine years, and I’ve never seen anything like it.” At the time of this writing, this commercial last aired on the Cartoon Network, implying a strategy to have kids convince their parents that this is the best phone to buy.

    Looking beyond the Flux Capacitor: It’s Not Really about the Technology

    When young people are not around older people outside structured and controlled settings—such as a classroom, a practice, or even riding in a car to a competitive sporting event—they do not learn the rules and norms of the society. As the culture has become more fragmented and children have less access to downtime, or any nonspecifically regulated time with adults living out their metanarrative, they have a hard time learning how to think, how to behave, and how to move forward as productive and assimilated members of society. At the heart of this generational and time segmentation, technology further isolates the young from the adult in society, which becomes problematic for the culture as a whole. Historically, children and newcomers learned the landscape of the culture by simply being together, by rubbing shoulders with one another. When someone—a child, an immigrant, or a young adult who, for whatever reason, had not received the proper experience or environment—did not seem to live up to the societal norms and values of that society, he or she was considered as someone who needed to be trained. Whether this was reflected in acts of communication (i.e., interrupting), an invasion of social space (i.e., crowding into each other), or any other behavior, attitude, or expression that represented a violation of the rules and norms of society, the perpetrator was generally considered to be merely naive, or sometimes intentionally rebellious. Historically, no culture has deemed the child or outsider to have “lost” some seemingly innate ability. It was understood that this person had just not properly learned what was socially appropriate (or was somehow deliberately pushing against the rules). For those who needed training, the typical response was to help the child or outsider become a greater part of the community through time, interaction, and deeper exposure to the culture.

    This is not to suggest that mediated interactions between generations do not have their place. Christianity has relied heavily on media technology throughout its history: Scripture can be viewed as a form of mediated communication between God and humanity; Paul’s letters are deeply personal writings with greetings to very specific individuals; and the Reformation was fueled by mediated tech developments. Therefore, mediated tech is not foreign to the human reality.

    Fairy tales, for example, served the purpose of teaching adult lessons and community values to children. The difference is that adults told these stories to their children while they lived life alongside and together with them. Children observed and experienced how to live in community as adults modeled it. While almost every parent of an adolescent today deals with their children and teenagers regarding their perception of the dangers of the internet, only about a third of parents actively engage with their adolescents or their adolescent’s friends online. The result is that children and adolescents are defining and learning interpersonal social interaction without the opportunity to shape these within the context of adult interactions. For adolescents, this diminishing of mutual participation in everyday life means that they are often left to their own peer groups, somewhat mediated by the limitations of social interactions, to determine socially acceptable values, expectations, and practices. For parents, it likely means that their role has been reduced to more of a police officer or a protective detail. Teenagers then discover—either unintentionally or in hindsight—that they have a different set of values, rules, and norms from the dominant, adult-controlled society. Parents are thereby left by default as the last line of training and equipping for adult life that young people have. Many parents do not feel equipped or, frankly, do not have the capacity to fully respond to the social deficits that separation and fragmentation has created in their children. They need a community to join them.

    While it might be possible for adults relatively to stay up on what adolescents are doing online, many wish that their children would be more responsible and “web savvy” and avoid those parts of the web that hinder their socialization and development. In both cases—monitoring web access and activity and trying to influence web behavior creates an adversarial relationship between the child and parent, and thus places the relationship focus on the behavior of the child. What is almost always missed in this parental dance is that all the while something incredibly significant is happening. Young people are developing and consistently reinforcing patterns of behavior and values that are unique social interactions separate from the larger community. They are in the process of developing a multitude of microcultures of which adults themselves have become naive outsiders. Each of these developing online cultures requires adult missionaries who will step into, understand, and engage with that unique relational world.

    Conclusion

    Digital tools are embedded in everyday life. The rapid pace of innovation, the ongoing proliferation, and the societal willingness to adopt new digital technologies suggest that digital connectivity is going to be the ongoing and daily reality for all young people for the foreseeable future. Those who appreciate that technology is not the enemy per se of physical presence will recognize it as a tool to be understood and utilized as an invitation to deepen existing human relationships. As adolescents are pushed to society’s margins and their social interactions are increasingly developed apart from adults, technology will likewise continue to augment this reality and further isolate adolescents from adults. This is what parents, teachers, coaches, and youth workers must avoid.

    The idea that someday technology will unite the world under a common message is a utopian myth. Instead, geophysical presence will need to combat fragmentation by being more intentional, more gracious, and more seeking of interpersonal understanding. To accomplish this, adoptive youth workers will need to see themselves as missionaries, seeking first to understand the students they serve and their relational context in order to facilitate deeper personal connections, foster a sense of being embraced by the community, and promote greater inclusion of the youth within the ongoing body of Christ. Only by focusing on people will digital tech become a tool that augments an adoptive reality.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑