2. Understanding the Changing Adolescent
Dr. Steve Bonner is not primarily a college professor, although he is a sought-after and excellent teacher. He has not spent his life and career sitting in libraries, offices, and classrooms, yet he is a solid scholar. He is a pastor and a youth pastor who has spent years in the trenches of ministry with kids and families. He is also a deliberate and thoughtful researcher, someone who has taken that experience and history and immersed himself in what people are saying about the changing adolescent landscape in order to better serve young people and their families. His “day job” is being a college professor, but Bonner has stayed deeply involved in and connected to the church and to adolescents, their families, their communities, and their world.
Bonner was asked to draw together the latest and best research on adolescent development so that at the outset of this book the reader can understand what growing up is like for today’s youth. Employing the metaphor of flying in a helicopter across the rolling countryside (Bonner was a flight engineer and senior crew member in the Army), he helps us to see the bigger picture. Bonner knows and understands childhood and adolescence both from the ground and from several thousand feet up. His insights and perspective provide valuable insight for those entering into adoptive youth ministry. As described in the introduction, our goal is not to get a church to “adopt” kids as their “own” children but rather to train and encourage adults to think of themselves as a family and to see children, teenagers, and emerging adults as their siblings who need them as they grow in their lives and faith. The task in youth ministry, then, is to help connect the young to their older brothers and sisters in the body of Christ through adoptive ministry. This takes a working knowledge of the basics of adolescent development, and Bonner gives a good start in that journey.
A historic tenet of youth ministry has been that in order to serve kids well we cannot only be concerned with the spiritual development of the young people we walk with, but we must also be aware of who they are and where they are in their journey as adolescents. Human development cannot be separated from spiritual development. What is appropriate teaching, counseling, guidance, and ministry to and for a twelve-year-old must be different from how we walk alongside a nineteen-year-old. In any ministry—but especially in one so volatile and precarious as adolescent ministry—we must understand who adolescents are, what they need, and what they are going through. Our call is to try to understand this from both a general and a specific perspective, which is the purpose of this chapter. Generally, it is important that youth workers—volunteers and staff alike—have a basic understanding of what all adolescents go through as they grow up, what we call a macro awareness of adolescent development. As we work among them, we must also develop a micro understanding of each one’s unique story within that general context.
As you read this chapter, consider these questions:
Introduction
A Bird’s-Eye View
Several years ago I served in the US Army as a Chinook helicopter flight engineer, logging nearly five hundred hours of flight time throughout my enlistment. Early on in my training I took a trip that has ever since been etched in my mind.
The mission was to deliver supplies to a base on the East Coast. The route took us directly over the Smoky Mountains just as the leaves were changing.
Growing up in southern California I had never experienced the changing of the seasons. The landscape that spread out before me that afternoon takes my breath away to this day. A quilt of fantastic and brilliant colors seemed to hover in midair, intricately woven together by green fields, blue streams, and brown dirt roads. It spread out underneath me for miles in all directions. Millions of trees were changing, literally before my eyes. It was a tremendous sight, and on this flight I realized what a “bird’s-eye view” really meant. I could see the country roads crisscrossing through the trees, bridges suspended over rivers, trucks meandering on their journeys, the occasional hawk, and the farmhouses that occupied space in open fields.
As I contemplate adolescent development and its importance for ministry to adolescents within the theological conception of adoptive ministry, I cannot help but recall that early fall afternoon and my encounter with the Smoky Mountains. My perspective enabled me to see so much more than if I were on the ground. I was able to see the journey ahead and where we had come from. I was able to see the contours in the terrain and the changes in elevation. In a sense, I was able to anticipate where we would be and what the journey to that point would require. In this chapter we will take a similar bird’s-eye view. What might the youth worker see from this perspective regarding the adolescent landscape? What insight into the adolescent journey could we gain if we were able to see the lay of the land, and how does this insight enable adoption in our churches?
The Ying-Yang CD
I had been the youth pastor in a growing rural church for a few years. In the short time that I was there I was able to make significant inroads into the local school systems. One-third of the members in our congregation were schoolteachers in these systems, and our pastor of nearly thirty years at the time (he is still there!) had, in a real sense, become the community pastor. I rode these coattails right into the school systems and started building relationships.
One Wednesday afternoon I received a call from a distraught PE teacher asking for help. He and his colleague had confiscated a CD player from a student with an illegal (what we used to call “burned”) copy of the Ying-Yang Twins. To make matters worse this teen was from my youth group. They hoped I could shed some light on the situation. With eagerness beyond my maturity, I agreed to help.
To be honest, I had never heard of this bombastic duo. With the CD in hand, I went home and did some research. If you are acquainted with the Ying-Yang Twins’ music, then you might have an idea of what I was walking into as a youth minister in a relatively conservative part of the country and denomination. It didn’t take long for my self-righteous indignation to boil over. I resolved to address the matter that night at youth group. I tossed out what I had been working on and quickly pieced together the most articulate, doctrinally prepared argument for cultural criticism and engagement I had ever written. It was a masterpiece. They would be persuaded by sound theology, Scripture quotations, and sheer logic.
I failed miserably. First, in my exuberance I had failed to spend any time in prayer, and God certainly was not about to bless what I was determined to do. Second, in my zeal I had not even considered that the person who had prompted my lecture might actually be present. For that young man and his friends, it was not one of my finer moments. Third (this one came out of thin air), as I was hitting the finer points of my theological argument a most terrifying thought occurred to me: this is not limited to a single incident with a single person in the youth group; they are all listening to this music! I stopped midstream and asked them outright. Yes, the majority of them had their own burned copies (another issue, I know), but then came their retaliation. They had listened to me, and now it was my turn to listen to them. They were indignant. I had insulted them and their music. I didn’t realize it at the time, but when I left the church building that night, not only had my arrogance taken a hit but also my lack of awareness of who I was called to lead. I had begun a new journey of discovery that brought with it new challenges and new questions.
A New Perspective
As I reflect back on that turning point in my youth ministry journey I can definitely say that I wish I knew then what I know now. Certainly those kinds of situations can initiate rich periods of growth and development. In particular, that experience helped me to ask questions of adolescent development that I had not been prepared to ask. Had I been able to look at the situation from above rather than from below (where I was firmly rooted), I would have been able to see more of the landscape. I would have seen the obstacles in the journey—both directly ahead and down the road. Taking in the adolescent journey from above could have enabled me to be much more sensitive. Looking back, I could have seen the origins of pain and suffering so prevalent in the teens I worked with. Specifically, I might have been reminded of the broken families and grandparents struggling to raise their grandkids. I might have remembered that my teens were being raised in broken and fractured systems that often did not have their best interests at heart. With a view from above, I could have anticipated and avoided the relational setbacks that occurred as a result of my blunder. All these years later, I wish I could have that one back.
Why a Different Path?
The study of adolescent development is a field exploding with innovation, research, and growing and varied perspectives. What was certain a few years ago in the landscape of adolescence is now questioned. Adolescents in today’s culture are changing quickly, and research struggles to keep up. Just a few short decades ago it was common to think of adolescence in terms of early and late, with young adulthood beginning as one graduated from high school and transitioned to college. As the 1980s gave way to the ’90s, practitioners working with this age cohort began to recognize significant changes in the way adolescents negotiated their environments. It was not long before the term middle adolescence, or mid-adolescence, began to show up in academic and even popular literature. Generally speaking, early adolescence corresponded to junior high. Middle adolescence was understood to be the new high school phenomena, while late adolescence was pushed to the college years and beyond. The explanations for this apparent shift have been wholly unsatisfactory, and the continued divergence in the literature points to this uneasiness. Research has produced very little in the way of progress toward a universal agreement or even understanding of these developments. Perhaps this is because those in the field of adolescent research have persisted in studying adolescence through the lens of age and stage rather than through markers of development.
Much of the focus and history of adolescent development has zeroed in on identifying the age at which one transitions from one stage to another. Complicating the landscape further are the many prominent and classical theories of adolescent development. John Santrock identifies four theoretical orientations: psychoanalytic (Freud and Erikson), cognitive (Piaget and Vygotsky), behavioral and social cognitive (Skinner and Bandura), and ecological (Bronfenbrenner). I do not disagree with those who would argue that these various theoretical orientations provide different pieces to the “adolescent developmental puzzle.” Each should be considered in turn. However, many of these classical developmental theories contradict one another and were written before the development of mid-adolescence in the 1990s. Developmental psychologist Susan Harter even goes so far as to suggest that the traditional developmental icons “have fallen from theoretical grace” as they “held little explanatory or predictive power in furthering our understanding of specific behaviors.”
In this chapter I aim to chart a different course rather than argue for a particular age-and-stage perspective of adolescence. While perhaps appropriate for children and adults, the age-and-stage means of identifying growth in developmental maturity during the adolescent process is becoming more tenuous. The lack of consensus in the literature with regard to the age that adolescence begins or ends, whether two or three stages exist, or how age corresponds to these stages is evidence enough that, at best, the landscape is constantly changing and, at worst, something is amiss. Harter acknowledges that in her long history of research, writing, and teaching development she has come to realize that the breakdown of age and stage all blend together. Therefore, I intend to take the reader to an altitude at which we can see and identify the significant markers of development that dot the adolescent landscape. I believe these markers have widespread agreement and are supported by the literature. Further, I contend that both the youth pastor in training and the youth pastor in the trenches benefit from having identified the hazards (markers) that are interspersed along the adolescent landscape so they can be more effective companions on the journey. As a result, youth pastors, parents, and the church at large are in a better position to facilitate and encourage adoption within the local church.
Markers along the Adolescent Landscape
If you will, imagine climbing into my CH-47D helicopter (you may have to google it to get the image). The blades quickly beat the air into submission as it climbs to an altitude suitable for giving us a perspective on the adolescent journey. Below we see the fourteen-year-old whose CD was confiscated. Looking behind him we can see the terrain he has already traversed. Sharp unanticipated curves in the road, such as the divorce of his parents, mark a significant transition in this young life. We can see where his dad abandoned him and left his mom to handle the strain of raising him on her own. Immature and unable to support him, she arranged for the boy to be raised by his grandfather. Looking ahead, we can see several markers in the journey that he will have to navigate to make it successfully to adulthood.
These markers are interrelated. They crisscross and fold into one another, much like a patchwork quilt. While none of these markers are wholly dependent on one another, each informs and helps to shape the others, thus providing a more holistic picture of the adolescent landscape. Separately, each is significant and needs to be thoroughly understood in order to better assist the developing adolescent in successfully navigating the approaching terrain. Taking these markers together enables us to successfully assemble an adult ground team to assist the adolescent in traversing the oncoming landscape.
As I consider the adolescent developmental landscape, three significant markers need to be pointed out: the timing and duration of adolescence, the reality of multiple selves, and the growing reality of objectification. It is my opinion that if one has a working knowledge of these current markers, how they intertwine, and how they serve as the impetus to many other developmental issues, then the youth pastor, with the help of the adopting church, will be able to assist the developing adolescent traverse the terrain of adolescence.
Timing and Duration of Adolescence
After the Ying-Yang devotional (that’s what I began to call that unfortunate Wednesday night youth group gathering) I began to ask the adolescents I served questions about their perception of life and faith and also the role the church played in their lives. Their collective response awakened something that had been dormant inside me: young people, when given the chance, hold storehouses full of experience and perception to share that I, and most adults I knew, rarely access. In the wake of that evening I began to realize that, without a greater understanding of what they were going through, I could not help them to learn how to discern between competing values and longings, grow through a rugged and difficult adult terrain of expectation and agenda (including in the church), and take on faith at a deep, lifelong level. What also became clear is that these kids needed adults in their lives other than me; there was no way a single leader who planned and orchestrated events, gave talks, and ran programs could make a dent in what they needed. I knew their journey through adolescence was longer and more difficult than mine had been, but I really did not know how so. I soon realized that if I was going to actively involve more adults in the lives of my youth, I needed to better understand the experience of adolescence, which begins with getting a handle on the timing and duration of adolescence. What are the markers of adolescent development? It begins with timing.
Is Adolescence Extending?
Our country has transitioned through some massive cultural shifts in the past century. Two shifts in particular deserve mention: the loss of a shared corporate story (what some call a metanarrative) and the steady rise of systemic abandonment and resultant isolation of children and youth from adults. These major transitions gave way to a new stage of development in the human lifespan—adolescence. As I intimated above, this stage of development has been thoroughly studied and exhaustively documented. As our country transitioned from the twentieth to the twenty-first century, developmentalists acknowledged that this stage of the journey was taking longer to navigate. The contributing factors are varied and complex, but one common thread runs through them all: kids are increasingly separated from adults. While the diminishment of adult relationships will be seen throughout this chapter, this reality deserves brief mention here because it hints at larger systemic issues that have contributed to this malaise. For as long as adolescence has been a field of study it has been accepted that adolescence begins in puberty and ends when the individual becomes an adult. This presupposition presents two significant issues for those interested in helping adolescents on their journey. First, current research suggests that puberty is progressively starting earlier, especially for females. If it is starting earlier, this complicates and necessitates a rapid and careful response. Second, while no one can precisely label (especially chronologically) when adolescence ends, it is clear that its beginning is rooted in the process of the body and mind changing in preparation for adulthood and that the transition into adulthood is rooted in the social environment and how the particular person responds to that environment, both externally and internally. If researchers are in disagreement (even those late adolescent/emerging adults/young adults who were interviewed don’t know, though the culture at large agrees with the latest brain studies that it is somewhere between the mid- to late twenties), then we must adjust our ministry strategies toward both ends of the spectrum as we seek to adopt young people into full and active participation in the family of God. In what has become a rather colloquial saying, author John Santrock suggests that “adolescence begins in biology and ends in culture.” This statement seems to capture, rather succinctly, the elusive and rapidly shifting nature of adolescence.
Decrease in the Age of the Onset of Puberty
In the United States and in Europe, data on the age of the onset of menarche has been collected and recorded. “Declines in the age of menarche have been reported from the late 1800s to the mid-1900s.” This trend continued downward until the middle of the twentieth century, when it seemed to level off. At this point, two independent works—the Pediatric Research in Office Settings study and the population-based National Health and Nutrition Examination survey, which were published in 1997 and 2002—reported earlier sexual maturation in American girls. The study published in 1997 of 17,000 girls indicated that the initial signs of puberty were occurring much earlier than had been recorded previously. The most recently published research continues to support this downward trend. S. Cesario and L. Hughes report that girls in the “United States appear to be maturing at an earlier age and documented incidence of precocious puberty is on the rise.” The obvious question is, why?
While many theories have been reported, the most popular in the media is the obesity or BMI (body mass index) theory. The BMI theory holds that there is a correlation between the onset of the age of puberty and weight. Early weight gain is often cited as the culprit since the chemical leptin, which is produced by fat cells, is a component necessary for the progression of puberty. With the percentage of overweight kids nearly doubling between the decades of the 1970s and 1990s, this correlation was easily made. While on the surface there seems to be a correlation, what has not been reported widely in the media are the studies that point out the inconsistencies with the BMI theory. Though there are too many inconsistencies to discuss here, three important studies deserve mention. These studies report that an early relationship to BMI was not apparent in African American girls and was negative in boys; furthermore, BMI remained constant where researchers found that the onset of puberty dropped from a mean age of 10.9 in 1991 to 9.9 in 2006. While the BMI hypothesis is predominant in the mainstream consciousness of American culture, its standing in published research is undecided.
Given the growing body of research, it is interesting that the ecological predictors of the earlier onset of puberty have not received the same attention in the media as the BMI predictor has. Numerous studies have linked the earlier onset of puberty to ecological and psychological stress.
Collectively, this research demonstrates that the early onset of puberty cannot be attributed exclusively to BMI. Any childhood practitioner has long known that a healthy and stable home life is important to healthy outcomes. For the better part of two-plus decades of research, ecological and familial stressors have predicted the onset of puberty. Certain of this relationship, Julianna Deardorff and her team state, “Environmental conditions, particularly those in the family domain, influence the timing of puberty in girls. Specifically, the absence of a biologically related father has been shown to accelerate reproductive development.” While this assertion may seem shocking, it does not surprise those of us who work with children in the church. A growing body of current research demonstrates that chronically stressful ecological environments influence the onset of puberty. If adolescence begins in biology, as Santrock has suggested, then ministry to youth in the church must adapt to this changing reality. Programming for children’s and youth ministry programs needs to be revisited in light of this significant marker of development, which presents crucial implications and opportunities to the church that seeks to adopt its youth. Given this new reality, is it too far a stretch to ask, what constitutes ministry to adolescents?
Difficulty Determining When Adolescence Ends
I have taught for some time that if we are going to be effective in reaching adolescents, then we need to know where they are and the obstacles that prevent or slow down their psychosocial and spiritual development. The continuing challenge, however, is that adolescence is a moving target; it is constantly changing. I have marshaled evidence that demonstrates, biologically, that adolescence is beginning earlier. Interestingly, youth ministry’s collective eye has focused on the other end of the journey. If Santrock is correct in that adolescence ends in culture, this strongly suggests that youth ministry is taking place in an environment never before realized.
Determining when adolescence ends and adulthood begins is extremely difficult. Prior to our current cultural context (a couple of decades ago) a person was considered to be an adult when he or she graduated from high school. At that point a person was said to have individuated and developed a core self. Whether one went on to college or directly into the workplace, he or she was understood to be an adult. Generally speaking, this is no longer the case. Citing years of his own research, J. J. Arnett suggests that those on the upper end of the adolescent journey should be known as emerging adults rather than late adolescents or young adults. While his argument as to why this age group (eighteen to twenty-one) is not known as late adolescents or young adults has only muddied the already murky waters of adolescent developmental research, his suggestion that the top three criteria for adulthood are accepting responsibility for oneself, making independent decisions, and becoming financially independent is helpful. These criteria are true of anyone in that age range, though they are accomplished gradually and occur incrementally. That it is taking longer for young people to transition into adulthood is well accepted; perhaps it is best to leave it there. Crossing the threshold of adulthood is generally taking more time, and recognizing the rather fluid nature of the landscape is important in helping young people navigate the journey. In my estimation, emphasis and debate on this age and stage effectively turned the researchers’ focus from the important developmental changes taking place in junior high and high school that, as will be demonstrated below, have contributed to the lengthened duration of adolescence.
Multiple Selves
My research into the timing and duration of adolescence supported what I knew instinctively—adolescence was changing. But the Ying-Yang devotional revealed something I was not expecting: my teens seemed to be leading double lives! I was not expecting the backlash I received, especially from my most spiritually active teens. How could they profess obedience and allegiance to Christ on the one hand, and then listen to this music on the other? It didn’t make sense. Were they hypocrites? Were they intentionally duplicitous? Did they just not care? Did they even know? These questions led me to our second marker of adolescence: the reality of multiple selves.
Cognitive Propagation
It is widely understood that the transition from childhood to adolescence brings with it dramatic physical, emotional, and cognitive advances. While much has been written about these developmental changes and their implications for youth ministry, the development of the cognitive is most important for our current discussion. As adolescents move deeper into this transition it becomes evident that their sense of self becomes increasingly differentiated. With the development of abstract thought, they become aware that their self-representations begin to shift; that is, their sense of self is not internally consistent and leads to a “proliferation of selves.” Harter says that for junior high students “a critical developmental task, therefore, is the construction of multiple selves that will undoubtedly vary across different roles and relationships.”
Cognitive advances facilitate this propagation and, in concert with social pressures, perpetuate the development of multiple selves. When young adolescents develop the ability of abstract thought they actually lack the developmental-cognitive ability to integrate the abstractions that develop within each socially constructed self. Thus, while an adult is able to fully and intelligently engage adolescents in each self-representation, adolescents do not have the ability to apply abstractions across the many socially constructed selves. Each self (or persona) is, in effect, compartmentalized. The adult who seeks to engage the adolescent will encounter inconsistencies in the adolescent’s self-presentation. Ironically, this inability to integrate abstract thought across their multiple selves actually serves to protect young adolescents from opposing and contradictory characteristics. In other words, the contradictory characteristics do not generalize to the other selves, are generally undetected, and thus reduce potential conflict. As the adolescent ages, however, their cognitive-developmental abilities continue to develop, and they soon are able to make comparisons.
The young adolescent progressing in age and maturation (typically understood to be middle adolescence) not only develops the ability to compare self with friend, self with mother, self with father, and so on, but will also pick up on the inconsistencies. Now the adolescent can overlay realizations, attributes, and characteristics developed in one role-related self and compare and contrast those realizations in other selves. While these contradictions are realized, the adolescent does not yet possess the cognitive-developmental ability to integrate these multiple selves. The “awareness of these opposites causes considerable intrapsychic conflict, confusion, and distress given the inability to coordinate these seemingly contradictory self-attributes.”
The Ying-Yang devotional unfolded among a group of junior high and high school adolescents. What I could not have foreseen that night was their immediate negative reaction to my harsh critique of their music. Their response shocked me. At the time I could not reconcile the contradictory behavior I was suddenly faced with. I had experienced phenomenological whiplash! The experience opened my eyes (and my ears), and I quickly tuned in to this emerging reality by turning my attention to facilitating integration rather than perpetuating proliferation.
Proliferation of Selves
I learned that I was facilitating the proliferation of multiple selves among the adolescents in my youth group. While I certainly did not do this intentionally, I soon realized that as children cognitively develop the ability of abstract thought in adolescence they begin to pull away. That is, they develop self-protective mechanisms. The most drastic of these mechanisms is the development of multiple selves.
As youth transition from elementary to middle school, and later to high school, they are introduced to increasingly public social comparisons and adult conditional support. The transitions that come with education (and parallel transitions in church, inasmuch as the local church models their education program after the local school system) heighten the young adolescent’s self-consciousness. The priority in most elementary schools is on effort. A child is encouraged to work hard and do better. When one transitions into adolescence, however, schools “heighten the salience of social comparison.” In junior high and above, poor performance is equated to a lack of academic ability—an association that is often processed publicly. “The emphasis on social comparison is a pernicious new influence that leads to the conclusion that everyone but those at the top of the academic ladder [is] intellectually incapable. This, in turn, ushers in a need to protect the self.” This performance pressure facilitates the development and proliferation of multiple selves, which is a function of self-protection and preservation.
When we couple the social comparison perpetuated by adults with the conditionality of adult support, adolescents struggle to keep up. Adults force adolescents to adopt a new self when they communicate that their approval is conditional. Of course, this is not really support; the conditions placed on the adolescents are actually socially constructed hoops they must negotiate in order to please the adults in their lives. This performance-based acceptance is particularly damaging when it comes from trusted adults: parents, grandparents, coaches, and ministers. When the adolescent experiences high levels of conditionality, hopelessness is the result, and high levels of hopelessness translate into low levels of self-esteem. Consequently, the adolescent experiences the developmental need to protect the emerging self, causing the proliferation of multiple selves.
If low conditional support facilitates the perpetuation of multiple selves, then high levels of unconditional adult support facilitate integration of the selves. Adult-driven systems contribute, enable, and perpetuate multiple selves, but significant psychosocial research has shown that adults can also help to facilitate the integration of adolescent multiple selves. Research demonstrates that higher levels of cognitive development require higher sustained levels of adult support and scaffolding. When this support is not present, adolescent cognitive development may even be delayed. Research reveals the benefits of adult support or scaffolding at progressively higher levels of cognitive development. My own research, which will be discussed below as an emerging concern, demonstrates that adolescent cognitive attainment is taking longer. Collectively, research persuasively shows that when adolescents (and by extension, children) are effectively left on their own to develop, cognitive attainment slows down. When adult support and scaffolding is consistent from childhood through adolescence, higher levels of cognitive development are facilitated at younger ages. Could the lengthening of adolescence and the proliferation of multiple selves be tied directly to increasingly lower levels of adult support? I believe so.
The call to adoption is particularly poignant given the realities described above. What adolescents need are more faithfully committed adults who are willing to be fully present in their lives. The church is strategically and theologically positioned to offset the proliferation of multiple selves in adolescents. By providing high levels of unconditional support through a network of loving adults, the adolescent reality of multiple selves can be arrested and higher levels of cognitive attainment achieved. What this research demonstrates beyond a shadow of a doubt is that kids desperately need adults to become healthy adults. Furthermore, they need faithful, committed adults to become faithful, committed believers.
Objectification
I stated above that these markers are interrelated. While they can stand alone they tend to fold into one another. Taken together they present a formidable landscape for the adolescent to negotiate. The marker of objectification is particularly iniquitous because it cuts theologically to the heart of personhood. What’s more, this marker tends to run just below the surface of the other markers, enabling the rupture that continues to grow between youth and adults. The objectification of our young is also the most difficult to pinpoint as it is most often clothed in the language of love and sacrifice and is, therefore, laden with emotional weight.
Adolescents need a core group of adults to journey with them in order to reverse the effects of these markers and successfully traverse the adolescent landscape. I examine this marker last because it so often goes undetected, even though it is present in every arena of an adolescent’s life, especially where adults are present. It was Chap Clark’s term systemic abandonment in Hurt that slowly opened my eyes to this reality and my own objectification of youth in my sphere of influence. I could not agree more with Clark; more adults are needed to undo and reverse the trends of systemic abandonment. Ironically, either through outright neglect, abuse, or objectification—which are all forms of systemic abandonment—the very adults who can reverse the tide are the ones enabling these very markers of the adolescent landscape to persist. As we turn our attention to the objectification of our young, we will first consider the theological issue of personhood and then take up three primary ways in which objectification occurs in the lives of adolescents.
Denial of Personhood
Christianity has long affirmed the fundamental theological assertion that to be human is to be a person. Created from the triune community, relationship is essential to personhood. To be a person is to be in relationships. As John Zizioulas says, “There is no true being without communion. Nothing exists as an ‘individual’ conceivable in itself. Communion is an ontological category.” Our culture tends to perpetuate the unhealthy notion that people are their interests or their functions. Christianity, with its commitment to personhood, claims that people are their relationships and as imagers of Christ are “communal structure[s] because Christ is in communion with the Father and the Spirit.” As preconditions for the ontology of personhood, being and relationship are rooted in the reality that humans are image bearers of God. Humanity created in the image of God has dignity. Therefore, a person “cannot be used merely as a means by any[one] . . . but must always be used at the same time as an end.” The dignity of every person must be protected and never exploited or manipulated and certainly never used as a means to an end. Consider the words of Louis Pojman:
We cannot think of our personhood as a mere thing, for then we would have to judge it to be without any value except that given to it by the estimation of someone else. But then that person would be the source of value, and there is no reason to suppose that one person should have unconditional worth and not another who is relevantly similar. Therefore, we are not mere objects. We have unconditional worth, and so must treat all such value-givers as valuable in themselves—as ends, not merely means.
Objectification is the act of turning a human being into a thing or commodity. When this happens the person is depersonalized. When a person’s humanity is ignored, used, or not properly acknowledged, that person is harmed; his or her personhood is denied. Being reduced to a thing diminishes the humanity of the one being objectified. Using a “person as an object, in the sense of a mere instrument for someone else’s purposes” consequently reduces “this individual to the status of a mere instrument.” It is my contention that adolescents are being used by the adults in their lives as means to adult ends. This objectification occurs in the many adult-controlled and adult-driven systems, organizations, and institutions that adolescents find themselves in.
Extracurricular Life
Student athletes, student dancers, band members, and drama students (to name a few) are all commodified and objectified by the adults in their lives when they are used for any adult-driven end. When parents use students vicariously to recover something from their own childhood, they are objectified. When commercial interests commodify students, they are objectified. When coaches, instructors, and directors use students to win competitions and thus secure their own status, adolescents are objectified. And, as alluded to above, objectification is made worse when the adolescent trusts the one doing the objectifying. Thus when the cognitive-developmental ability of abstract thought progresses, the adolescent is able to reflect on how adult-driven agendas have used them for adult gain. Ontologically, they may not fully understand the depersonalization that has occurred, but they can feel it. They learn early on what it feels like to be used. When this occurs at the hands of trusted adults, the betrayal and damage are magnified. It is objectification that helps to facilitate and speed up the protective mechanism of multiple selves mentioned above.
Adults are present in every arena across the adolescent spectrum of extracurricular life. When adults engage adolescents solely through adult-driven performance agendas, kids are harmed. These very systems, originally for the benefit of children and adolescents, perpetuate the self-driven agendas of adults. While they are often clothed in the rhetoric of play and physical/emotional benefit, they actually serve the needs and desires of the adults who perpetuate these extracurricular activities.
Education
As a youth pastor I actively sought creative ways to engage my students outside their involvement in church. Doing so permitted me access to the other selves my students had developed. Since adolescents spend the majority of their time in school, I became a substitute teacher. Access to the hallways and lunchrooms of my teens enabled me to learn a great deal about adolescents and youth culture; however, I was not prepared for what I would learn from the adults. As the months passed, I got to know many of the teachers at the middle and high school levels and eventually gained their trust. The frustrations they aired around the lunch table were telling.
Frustration, fatigue, and burdensome federal and state regulatory requirements had, over time, created calloused hearts. Many of these teachers were simply going through the motions. Whatever zeal or passion they had when they answered their calling had long dissipated. As they discussed issues in their classrooms it became clear to me that they were not engaging their students as persons; instead, students were treated as objects to be sorted out and negotiated. Of course, there were exceptions. The freshly minted teacher would offer idealized words of hope, but they were quickly reprimanded and put in their place.
Around the table teachers would share names of the exceptional students and lament those who were poor performers, troublemakers, or both. The less than desirable students were more often than not described in negative and dehumanizing terms. I knew many of these students; I knew about their home lives and the daily struggles they had to overcome simply to make it to school. These teachers were trusted by the community to educate and mold young minds, but their students had become mere objects to be negotiated. These students were viewed and treated as something to be sifted and sorted, not persons to be engaged and loved.
The descriptions and treatment of their students bothered me greatly. As I dug deeper and asked more questions, I discovered what I have come to understand as an innate institutional malaise. What I experienced then is now considered common knowledge—if anything, it has gotten worse. Our educational model is still perpetuating the factory model of education: input raw product (the student), then shape, mold, and manipulate the product to produce a society-worthy end product. While there are noteworthy exceptions, thoughts concerning the student’s humanity, development, and family are hardly considered or are seen as obstacles to overcome. Furthermore, many school systems place an inordinate amount of weight on their student’s standardized test scores. When a teacher’s performance review or the job security of school administration is tied to these scores, we should not be surprised. Teachers now commonly train their students to test well on these exams.
Adolescents who have grown up in these systems have been conditioned to believe that their self-worth is tied to their performance on these (and other) tests. Here we see conditional approval and support at its worst. Those who score high receive praise and adoration, and those who do not are often derided. Approval and support from teachers and administration depend on successful performance, and the adults running the education system determine what successful performance looks like. Ultimately, adolescents are being used as a means to the adult end of promotion, recognition, and job security. Students raised in these systems are taught conditional support and approval. They are conditioned to believe that their self-worth and their sense of self is tied to these performance-driven adult agendas. These adult-led systems (along with the extracurricular activities) actually force adolescents to pull away from adults and cognitively drive them to develop multiple selves. In the end, they are only trying to protect themselves. The lack of genuine and authentic adult support coupled with adult objectification of adolescents facilitates and perpetuates this troubling reality. Do they trust adults? Generally, no, and why should they? As abstract thought kicks in they are able to differentiate and reflect on how adults have used them as means to an end; as a result, they pull away. This objectification sets up the dilemma we now see prevalent across the spectrum of adolescence, even in youth ministry.
Youth Ministry
I hinted briefly above that I inadvertently contributed to the development of multiple selves in those adolescents to whom I was called to pastor. I now believe that objectification occurs in youth groups across the country, and it is particularly hazardous to the spiritual and cognitive development of the emerging adolescent. First, when objectification occurs in youth ministry it compounds the objectification that is taking place in the other arenas of the adolescent’s life. Our churches must be places of refuge and safety, not another system of adult-centered performance-driven agendas that must be carefully negotiated by the growing adolescent. Second, the objectification of adolescents (and children) in our churches undermines the very theology we profess. When we objectify our students we fracture the imago Dei in their developing self-concept. Consequently, their spiritual and developmental journey is lengthened, and their transition to healthy, God-fearing adults is jeopardized. When they begin to sense this abuse, the gospel we proclaim becomes hollow and meaningless because they are being forced into the all-too-familiar performance-driven agendas they negotiate everywhere else.
If we are honest with ourselves, as church leaders we have a lot in common with the teachers mentioned above. While we quietly convince ourselves that we are not like them, our leadership and peers deem us successful if we are able to bring in the numbers, even if our current rhetoric says size and number are not important. We fall back on techniques and fads geared to generate numbers, and our teens are objectified in the process. Often, youth pastors tend to gravitate to those teens who seem to be more likable, though perhaps I am the only one who has done this. We massage our guilt with hollow and empty arguments. Ultimately, when we sift through, label, and categorize our students, are we not also objectifying them? Sometimes we even publicly trumpet the more spiritual. And when the athletes, dancers, and musicians in our groups perform well do we not celebrate them openly while often ignoring the “lesser” achievements of others? Isn’t our support and approval often tied to their performance? While there are certainly exceptions, my intention here is to illuminate what has perhaps become the default practice rather than the exception.
Our churches can be places of safety and security for adolescents, but the silent denial of teenage personhood must be addressed. The church is uniquely positioned to address and reverse this trend and live up to the high calling of ministering to adolescents. When the adults in an adolescent’s life artificially impose the marker of objectification, adults within the church can offer their presence, suffer alongside, and model hopeful lives. The youth pastor cannot help adolescents to navigate this terrain alone. Full adoption by the church is necessary for successful navigation of the adolescent landscape.
Emerging Concern
Early in this chapter I presented a brief argument for taking a different path when considering the development of adolescents. I agree with Susan Harter. The old standby theories need to be reconsidered when it comes to adolescence, especially when we realize that the most prominent of those developmental theorists were doing their work before the onset of mid-adolescence. Culture has changed. Families have changed and so too have adolescents. My position on considering a different path involves my own experience and research. Though I have alluded to the central concern above, I will treat it here in full: cognitive attainment of adolescents is taking longer. While this could certainly be one of the markers discussed above, I feel it deserves to be set apart because, when woven together, the other three markers and sub-aspects of those markers are contributing to and perhaps even creating this reality.
Delayed Cognitive Attainment
I transitioned into full-time teaching of youth ministry at the university level in the fall of 2008. In my first semester of teaching I discovered that the majority of my freshman and sophomore students were manifesting many of the same psychosocial characteristics as the high school students I had just left; they had not yet integrated their multiple selves. Moreover, I found myself in conversations with colleagues who reported that their students seemed to be less mature. I verified these anecdotal findings with colleagues at other universities and, after a series of events and a couple of years’ time, a colleague and I presented research at the annual national conference of the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools Commission on Colleges (SACSCOC).
In that SACSCOC session we presented qualitative and phenomenological evidence that contemporary college students are not as cognitively prepared for the overall college experience as students several decades ago. We attributed this diminishment to the psychosocial phenomenon of extended adolescence and then suggested ways that student services, faculty, and assessment leaders might respond. That session generated substantial discussion and was well received. While the evaluations expressed the need for quantitative data—a lacuna we admitted at the time—the overwhelming response of our colleagues in that session encouraged a redoubling of efforts to understand just what and why this was occurring. Blaming cognitive diminishment on extended adolescence seemed rather vague. I soon realized that the key to understanding the diminishment could be found in understanding the psychosocial reality that turned me on to this issue in the first place: mid-adolescent multiple selves.
Was I experiencing a lengthening of mid-adolescence among my students? Though this question runs counter to some of the prominent theories surrounding this age group, it was plain to us that our incoming students lacked the cognitive developmental acumen to integrate their selves. My colleagues and I were (and are) experiencing diminished cognitive abilities in our undergraduate students. In the spring of 2013, we launched a longitudinal study to gather new quantitative evidence. After one year of data collection, our research suggests the rate at which eighteen- to twenty-year-olds are attaining the level of cognitive development expected of them in previous decades has slowed.
What Extended Mid-adolescence Means
This new psychosocial reality has significant implications on the expected academic, moral, and social performance of incoming students. With this evidence (both qualitative and quantitative) in hand, the current developmental paradigms need to be revisited. Our research demonstrates that it is taking longer for young people to transition through adolescence. Holding to a particular age or stage at this point is irrelevant. The issue is not that young people (whether one refers to them as teens, adolescents, mid-adolescents, or late adolescents) are less capable cognitively but that they are not reaching cognitive attainment as soon as they once did. The speed of attainment has slowed, thus their ability to get out of or emerge from adolescence has slowed. It is simply taking longer for adolescents to attain the requisite cognitive abilities to transition into emerging adulthood/young adulthood. When we witness diminished ability in the classroom and across campus we tend to hold the opinion that students are coming to us dumber, but this is not the case. Students are arriving on our campuses less cognitively mature, but why?
The larger purpose of Adoptive Youth Ministry seeks to address this reality. I suggest that what we are experiencing in our classrooms and what our data demonstrates is the result of the cumulative effects of adolescents who have, essentially, been left alone to journey through adolescence. Chap Clark recognized the damaging effects of systemic abandonment in his Hurt research. When kids are systematically left to their own devices to individuate into adulthood, their progression is slowed. The evidence for increased adult support is convincing. Susan Harter cites recent and credible research that indicates that “cognitive solutions will not necessarily emerge automatically with development. Nor will the potential benefits of movement to late adolescence necessarily accrue. Development may be delayed or even arrested if there is not sufficient support for the transition to higher levels of conceptualization . . . [there is] compelling evidence for the role of support or scaffolding at higher levels of cognitive development.” Additionally, R. E. Dahl argues that it is absolutely crucial for adolescents and young adults to have access to adult social scaffolding. As adolescents progress through adolescence there is greater need for social scaffolding from adults if adolescents are going to achieve optimal cognitive development. If this is true of adolescents, how much more so is it true of children? Is it possible that what we are witnessing on college campuses is the cumulative effects of years of diminished adult support? The implications and opportunities for the church are substantial.
Moving toward Adoption
From the vantage point of that CH-47D helicopter, we can much more effectively survey the adolescent landscape. We can see the main hazards/markers of the adolescent journey and how they intersect and enable the others. Now that we have taken the bird’s-eye view of adolescent development, we are in a better position to identify the central reality that ties all of these markers together: the lack of loving adult relationships. Simply stated, adolescents need adults—a great many more than we realized! Through loving and sacrificial adult relationships, adolescents will transition through adolescence much faster. Through the abundance of adult relationships, adolescents will integrate their selves much earlier than is currently the norm. Through theologically grounded and prophetically positioned adults, adolescents will be able to realize their full potential as persons created in the image of God. The church is uniquely positioned to turn the tide. By being fully connected to, embraced by, and included in the historic body of Christ, adolescents can safely and securely transition into and become healthy adult believers.
