Chapter 16 of 31

11. Thinking Globally

11. Thinking Globally

11

Thinking Globally

An Asian American Case Study Approach

DAVID JIA HWA DOONG AND JINNA SIL LO JIN

The world has changed, and is changing, at a rate few could have envisioned even a few decades ago. One of these changes is the reality that what many have viewed as a Western if not exclusively North American phenomenon—the nature and impact of adolescence—is now worldwide. For today and tomorrow’s youth workers this fact alone may not seem all that important, unless one were to travel to parts of the world affected by this massive social shift. But another impact of global change is the way in which our cities, schools, and churches are facing an ever-increasing globalization in our own communities, whether we have sought it or not. Immigration, international education and business opportunities, ease of travel, and even entertainment and cultural trends have created a global culture impossible to evade. This chapter, then, helps us to understand the world we now live in, especially as it relates to ministry in today’s global society.

The question we are asking at this point is how does a person who is committed to a theologically grounded ministry in our rapidly changing world “think globally”? We are intentionally not asking whether one should be thinking globally but rather making the case that global thinking is a de facto requirement for contemporary ministry. Regardless of where we are or what we specifically do, our ministries will interface with people of other ethnicities, lands, and peoples. How we think about them theologically is an important aspect in ministry—especially youth ministry—as we seek before the Lord to faithfully represent the gospel as God’s love for his whole world. More directly, most youth workers will engage students who come from different backgrounds and bring with them different assumptions and needs, all of which are related to the universal issues that come with adolescence.

David Doong, PhD, and Jinna Jin, PhD, from Taiwan and South Korea respectively, study practical theology, with an emphasis in youth, family, and culture. While their experience flows from an Asian immigrant context, their interaction with youth and family ministry people and ministries around the world gives them a broad perspective on the issues related to youth ministry in a global context. In this chapter, they report that systemic abandonment (as described in Hurt 2.0) is not simply a US or even Western cultural phenomenon but rather is part and parcel of every culture that has ready access to the internet and American movies and television. They also note that there is great upheaval around the world when it comes to understanding and dealing with this new generation of global young people. Following this assessment, Jin and Doong offer a helpful primer on global adolescent worldviews and values emerging from different cultures, the issue of identity in these contexts, and a description of how this plays out specifically in an Asian and Asian American adolescent community.

As you read, our hope is that you will consider the assumptions and even racial and ethnic prejudices you carry concerning people and adolescents outside your ethnic heritage. Whether you encounter an exchange student from Chile, a second-generation Asian American, a first-generation Latina who recently moved to town, or an African who has immigrated with his mother, you will have the cultural awareness of what it means to honor Christ as you connect to and honor them.

As you read this chapter, consider these questions:

  • In what ways does your experience growing up hinder your ability to “think globally”? How does your background enhance your ability to “think globally”?
  • What people and/or cultural groups outside your own do you believe you are most familiar with? What would you describe as the major differences between you and the majority of the students you work with when it comes to worldview, values, identity struggles, or other issues?
  • Which people and/or cultural groups are you least familiar with? What would you describe as your assumptions regarding their worldview, values, identity struggles, or other issues?
  • In considering the youth ministry you envision being involved in, what are some things you need to consider and/or be aware of when it comes to minority, immigrant, or simply different kids?
  • Esther is a second-generation Asian immigrant. Before her family came to the United States, her father was the department head of a large corporation and her mother was a middle school art teacher. When they moved to America, they couldn’t find jobs equivalent to their previous ones due to language and cultural barriers. Instead, they opened a restaurant. After years of diligent work, they bought a decent house in a good school district.

    Esther is now a junior in high school. Like many other Asian Americans who live at the intersection of two cultures, she is going through an identity crisis that indigenous teenagers do not face. Although her family’s financial situation is stable, they continue to work late hours. Esther is often home alone. Her parents, committed to her integration into American society, arrange many after-school programs to ensure that she takes full advantage of her education and maintains high grades. Her parents are also involved in church in their new neighborhood and had encouraged, even forced, Esther to attend the youth group. Esther’s parents expect their daughter to assimilate into mainstream American culture.

    After going on a short-term summer missions trip to a developing country with the youth group, Esther started to see a bigger world and felt challenged to live differently. One day Esther asked her parents whether she could quit one of her after-school programs and volunteer for an organization that does social work instead; she even told them she would like to be a social worker herself one day. Her parents reacted angrily and said that social work is not a good job to have as an immigrant. Esther was upset and argued with her father. Her response made her parents even angrier, and they grounded her from the youth group. Esther sent a text message to her youth pastor about what happened. She had been touched and moved by both the youth group and the trip, and now her parents, who had forced her to get involved, were trying to get her to walk away.

    Imagine you are Esther’s youth pastor. What would you do?

    Understanding Global Teenagers

    Today’s youth ministry is rarely homogeneous. Even a few decades ago, most youth workers needed to concern themselves only with the single culture of the youth and families they served. In contemporary society, however, it is vital that those called to minister to the young in God’s name work to understand the cultural heritage and practices of the youth and families whom they work with; not only does this help youth workers be culturally sensitive, but it also helps them to connect the gospel with their daily lives. In beginning this process it is important to keep in mind that there are basic universal characteristics of adolescents regardless of their cultural background and that these characteristics become the backdrop against which we can look more deeply into the uniqueness of a family’s particular culture.

    First, the concept of adolescence is relatively new around the world. It is constantly morphing and changing, and every society struggles as they respond to this new transitory population. Up until the past few decades, only two basic life stages were recognized around the globe: childhood and adulthood. While there has been some discourse throughout the centuries (in the times of Plato and Aristotle and in the Middle Ages) concerning the nature and behavior of the young (some even use the term adolescence), these references generally focus on people who were either older children or young adults. As Chap Clark states, it was in about 1900 when the universal idea of adolescence (as we understand it now) was first noticed. At the turn of the twentieth century in the United States, scholars and researchers began noticing that a new stage—no longer child but not yet adult—had emerged in contemporary society. This stage soon became known as adolescence.

    People often seem to have negative attitudes about this uncertain and constantly changing stage of life. Instead of treating adolescence as “a unique phase of life that must be understood and [dealt] with on its merits,” adults tend to think adolescents are a problem. Christian Smith and Melinda Lundquist Denton strongly state that adults “typically frame adolescence in ways defining teenager life per se as itself a social problem and adolescents as alien creatures, strange and menacing beings, perhaps even monsters driven by raging hormones, visiting us from another planet.”

    A second aspect of adolescence that carries global implications—in addition to the prevailing uncertainty and negative attitudes regarding adolescence—is that rapid cultural changes across the world make adolescence more confusing for youth and society alike. In the midst of this confusion, and perhaps because of it, the general consensus is that young people have been isolated from the adult world. As Clark states:

    Some researchers believe that culture has changed so quickly that the developmental, societal, and relational needs of children have been neglected in recent decades and that by the time children reach adolescence they have been left on their own to attempt to navigate the path toward adulthood. . . . The adolescent is left to discern how to handle the multi-conflicting messages related to home, stable relationships, and internal security—all while trying to figure out how to survive lengthened adolescence. This only adds to the aloneness most feel.

    Although each culture may vary slightly depending on cultural factors, evidence suggests that in every society with access to the internet and American movies around the world children and adolescents have received less interpersonal nurture, fewer opportunities for being around adults, and less social capital than in any time in history.

    Third, having lost the normative and ongoing proactive nurturing relationships with adults that all children in every culture once experienced and therefore being left to navigate the journey toward adulthood that adolescence requires, adolescents have created their own subculture. Clark refers to this as “a world beneath, a world in which rules, expectations, a value system, and even social norms are created to maintain an environment in which the middle adolescent can achieve the single most important goal of this life: survival.”

    To survive—to feel safe and included—adolescents create their own world where adults are not invited or welcomed. Although younger generations feel they have no choice but to create a world apart in which they rely on one another for social support, life guidance, and mutual self-protection for their own survival, they further encourage this cycle of separation from adult society.

    Different Cultural Assumptions

    Worldview and Values

    While all young people find themselves having to rely primarily on themselves and their peers to navigate the complexities of today’s world, this process is even more difficult for minority and immigrant youth. For those ministering to minority youth (often referred to as “people of color”)—even those raised in the United States and especially immigrant minority children and youth—it is vital that youth workers recognize that the pull toward isolation and loneliness is even greater; therefore, they must work hard to develop appropriate cultural sensitivity. We acknowledge that it is unrealistic to expect a youth pastor or leader to learn everything about every culture. There are, however, three distinct areas of which any person serving a minority, immigrant, or community must make a careful study: family, relationships, and perspectives on human development.

    The definition of family differs from culture to culture according to its worldview and values. Family can mean different things to different people in different cultures. For example, the dominant Anglo-American definition of family emphasizes the nuclear family; Africans focus on a network of kin and community; and Asian families include both their kin and community as well as their ancestors. Puerto Ricans tend to have more flexible boundaries among the family and surrounding communities, while African Americans esteem mothers and especially grandmothers. As opposed to Puerto Ricans, Italians and Greeks have very definite family boundaries.

    People from different cultures interact differently. Take, for example, verbal communication: people from a Jewish heritage often value cognitive clarity when communicating verbally, while people from an Anglo background (especially the United Kingdom) tend to use verbal communication in a utilitarian way. Chinese tend to avoid direct communication and employ symbolic means of communication, and while Norwegians also tend to avoid verbal expression, they do it more out of an ethic of respect and politeness and do not employ symbols. Italians tend to use words to express the emotional intensity of an experience, while the Irish are more reserved in expressing feelings toward one another, and especially toward outsiders. (What’s more, they generally cringe when an American tells them, “I’m part Irish!” because every American they have ever met, including African Americans and Latinos, claim to be “part Irish.”)

    The assumptions and worldview behind people’s interactions also differ from culture to culture. Consider the behaviors of students in a youth Sunday school class when the teacher asks a question. Students from some cultural backgrounds are more comfortable raising their hands to express their opinions while students from other cultural backgrounds are more likely to stay silent. Though it may seem natural to read disengagement into the silence of the students, this may simply be an example in which cultural heritage and training is the culprit, rather than disinterest. Certainly this is also true at a microlevel with children or anyone from the same culture. A boisterous seventh-grade boy who is a recent immigrant from Korea and a wildly fun African American girl may both be far more vocal and directly engaged than a naturally shy girl from Colombia. Temperament, unique family dynamics, and a parent’s modeling are all as important as cultural heritage for those trying to care for a child or teenager. The key, then, is that the person working alongside young people of all shapes and stripes must take great care not to pigeonhole a child or adolescent without getting to know them, their family, and their unique personality in order to serve them well.

    A more egalitarian assumption of social relations operates in some cultures, such as the majority (or dominant) culture in America, whereas a more hierarchical assumption operates in other cultures, like those of Korea and China. The egalitarian assumption of social relations assumes that everyone is “equal” and considers interpersonal relationship to be two autonomous individuals who are similar in status. It is important to be aware that while the assumption of social equality is the prevailing social worldview in the majority culture in America, it is not universal. This also affects how children and youth act and interact, especially in controlled settings such as church and ministry programs.

    Last, different cultures have different understandings of basic human development. Psychologist Monica McGoldrick and her colleagues argue that “eastern cultures tend to define the person as a social being and categorize development by growth in the human capacity for empathy and connection. Many Western cultures, in contrast, begin by positing the individual as a psychological being and define development as growth in the capacity for autonomous functioning.” The cultural vision of adulthood influences people’s decisions and priorities through their transition from adolescence to adulthood. What does it mean to be an “adult”? For most Americans, being an adult is associated with one’s ability to be independent. For most Asians, being an adult is more associated with one’s ability to look after one’s family; being independent is just a means to get there.

    Identity Issues Related to Cultures

    Adolescence is a period of identity formation and exploration. Youth in general experience an identity crisis, seeking to find out who they are and where they fit in the larger society. Youth from minority or immigrant cultures in America particularly experience another layer or dimension of identity crisis. Not only do they have to navigate the question “Who am I?” along with their dominant culture peers, but they must also answer this question with the need to determine how their ethnicity and identifiable community relates to their understanding of self.

    There are many variables that can influence a person’s ethnic identity, including their family history (immigration, social and economic status, etc.) and their own trajectory for the future. Narrative is very influential in shaping a person’s individual and ethnic identity. Almost all American families have experienced migration, either forced or chosen. McGoldrick notes that “the hidden effects of this history, especially when it goes unacknowledged, may linger for many generations.” The following questions are helpful in naming a person’s narrative of migration: Why did the family migrate? What were they seeking? What were they leaving behind? Understanding how the shared migration memory of a group shapes the way they live in the present as well as the future is vital. For example, whether a group of people has experienced oppression or been given the opportunity to thrive impacts how they see themselves in relationship to America and how their ethnic identity is shaped.

    Most scholars agree that, for the most part, people who have lived in America longer are usually more assimilated into the majority culture. However, it is also important to distinguish a group of people’s enculturation in their public and private lives. It is much easier for people to act according to the majority culture of America in public settings. However, for many subgroups who do not feel automatically included in the dominant culture, the influence of people’s original culture may take much longer to change in their private lives, if it ever does. In the film The Butler, an example of this is brilliantly played out by Forest Whitaker in the character of Cecil Gaines. At the White House, Cecil is impeccable in his ability to live, work, and serve, and at home with his friends and family he is able to be who he is without needing to “fit in” to the dominant culture. Most minority communities are not actually interested in “assimilating” into someone else’s culture. They would rather be honored for who they are and included, welcomed, and, yes, “adopted” by siblings who embrace them for who they are, as they are as Jesus’s siblings.

    Characteristics of Asian American Youth and Family

    The American Dream

    America historically considers itself a melting pot of different cultures and ethnicities. Each ethnic group has a unique migration history; some came to seek liberty and others to find refuge. Especially for those who did not migrate by their own will but did so by either force or enslavement, the term melting pot has always been a hard one to accept (few use the concept today, seeking rather to welcome without “melting” another’s heritage). For Asians, however, migration has generally been motivated by economic drive and opportunity. In the nineteenth century, the Chinese were the first to arrive in the United States, followed by Japanese, Korean, and Filipino immigrants. The first Chinese immigrants came to work for the gold mining industry in California. Later, other Asian groups such as the Japanese, Korean, and Filipino people came to Hawaii as sugar farm worker recruits. Asian immigrant history starts with the yearning to seek better work and a better standard of living. Sucheng Chan states, “Asian immigrants came to the states primarily to earn a living,” which is the primary reason most come today. Recent immigrants still seek better lives, although they no longer have to work on sugar farms.

    Still, working and living in a foreign land as strangers has been a difficult journey. The first Asian immigrants were often treated like slaves, receiving unfair wages and unjust treatment. In the midst of hardship and under tremendous pressure to merely survive, they have had little chance to achieve their understanding of the “American dream.” While enduring hardship and sacrificing themselves (usually without the ability to claim their own rights), the earnest hope and prayer for all first-generation Asian immigrants is that their children will be given better lives—the life they dreamed of that never came true. For them, the American dream represents the end of suffering as second-class citizens and an end to racial and ethnic injustice. No matter how hard early Asian immigrants worked, they were not considered American citizens. They were treated as “forever foreigners.”

    Like all Americans, Asian immigrant families depended on education as the chief means for upward social mobility because most believed that education was the only way to save their children from the unfairness and hardship they endured. Moreover, Asian immigrants demonstrate some particularities regarding their approach to education. Min Zhou states that “what is unique about the emphasis on education among Asian Americans lies in the family’s control over educational choices and the community’s institutional support. Families set high expectations for their children and instill in their children that educational achievement is a family honor as well as a means to secure future livelihood.”

    Both the immense support and the strong pressure from their families has led Asian children to perform exceptionally well in academics. At the same time this tremendous pressure can be a significant burden for the children, who are trained and prodded to sacrifice everything—their interests and desires and dreams—to faithfully fulfill the family’s dream for them and to honor their family.

    In this light, when Esther (in the opening story) expressed her desire to quit the after-school program to become a social worker, it was seen as a threat to her family’s hope and future security. This conflict within an Asian American family is not resolved by simply debating the merits of social work as a respectable job or a benefit to society. Their long history of hurt, anxiety, and the earnest wish to achieve a better life (especially for the children) has driven families to make tremendous sacrifices on behalf of their children. The elusive but nonetheless perceived reality of the American dream lies at the root of this tension for Asian immigrant families. For an outsider to step into this familial space uninvited (no matter how credentialed or well-meaning) and without an understanding of this powerful dynamic and worldview will make things only worse for both the parents and the child.

    Interpersonal Relationships

    Different cultures have different assumptions and concepts regarding interpersonal relationships. The concepts of “self” and “community” can mean different things to people in different cultures. As youth pastors, it is important to be aware of how different cultures attach different meanings to the same words, such as identity, community, and self.

    When I (David) first came to America, I was flattered when I heard people call me “friend.” I had great expectations toward my new “friends.” However, it only took me a couple of weeks to realize that when people call me “friend” in America, it often means that we are, at best, acquaintances and that my expectations for these new “friends” were never going to be met. This personal experience in my own life showed me how people from different cultures use the same words but the meaning and worldview attached to them can be very, very different.

    The most important principle of relationships in Confucianism and in Confucian-influenced cultures is ren—not justice, equality, or freedom. Ren is the moral ideal in Confuciansim, and it is a comprehensive term encompassing love, benevolence, human-heartedness, sympathy, and perfect virtue. Ren flows out from one’s affection to his or her family based on filial piety toward the whole of humankind, which means that a person treats others differently according to their relationships. A person’s loyalty lies with his or her family. For example, a person is expected to treat his or her parents in certain ways and other older adults in other ways. Children are expected to submit to their parents as a way to share their loyalty to the family. Luo Lu writes, “A person in the Confucian tradition is seen primarily as a relational being defined in specific dyadic relationships.” People raised in Confucian cultures relate to others depending on the status and history of their relationships with them. A person is expected to follow different expectations and rules in different kinds of relationships. The closer one’s relationship with the other person, the more duties one will have toward him or her.

    This strong emphasis on filial piety is passed on through various rituals and has significant implications in terms of the way people incorporate faith in their lives. Take, for example, ancestral worship. In traditional East Asian culture, ancestors who pass away become gods who watch over the family, bringing prosperity and blessing to one’s descendants. People worship ancestral gods for protection and blessing over their own families. For Esther’s parents, going to church might mean similar things. On the surface, the family goes to church regularly to worship, but they might unconsciously take worship as an exchange for God’s provision and blessing on the family. Esther’s loyalty and obedience to her parents comes prior to her self-fulfillment. One is expected to live for one’s family first. At the same time, God is perceived as the One who watches over and blesses one’s family.

    For most Americans in the majority culture, community is a group of individuals who gather under the banner of common causes, interests, or tasks. For most people from Asian cultures, however, community is more than a mere gathering of individuals; it is an extension of self, a place where people pledge mutual commitment to one another. The American concept of community emphasizes personal rights, individual goals, and freedom rather than harmony, while the Asian/Confucian concept emphasizes duty, societal goals, and harmony rather than freedom. In the case of Esther, most Americans from the majority culture might consider the decision hers to make, a personal “choice” that is her right. Most Asians, on the contrary, are more likely to consider career as a communal decision, impacting everyone in the family. In the eyes of her parents, Esther is not just an independent individual on her own personal journey toward adulthood; she is also a highly connected, integral extension of the family. Through the lens of Confucian culture, Esther’s decision to change her major and drop biology class is something that must concern the whole family, and to make this all the more complicated and difficult for an American to understand, she should have known this! Esther’s example illustrates the need to deeply probe the core values that govern and regulate relationships in Confucian-influenced cultures in order to seek to understand how a single series of events can engender so much anger, pain, and conflict.

    Identity, then, is interwoven with interpersonal relationships. One of the major differences between the Confucian and Western understandings of identity is whether identity is constructed or assumed. In Confucian culture, a person’s identity is built into his or her place in the existing web of relationships; therefore, people do not choose their identities but assume the roles given to them by society. Mainstream American culture encourages youth to explore and construct their own identities, while Confucian culture emphasizes a youth’s given role in family and society.

    Hierarchical Cultures

    To communicate effectively with people from Asian cultures, even to the third generation, it is important to understand the meaning and reasoning behind social hierarchy in Confucian cultures. When I (David) first came to study at Fuller Theological Seminary in Pasadena, California, from Taiwan, I had a hard time addressing my professors by their first names. In Taiwan, one should address a professor by his or her title, “Professor.” It was very uncomfortable for me to drop the formal title and address my professors by their first names. In my Taiwanese/Chinese culture, one is expected to treat people who hold higher authority with a different set of rules. For example, children are expected to submit to their parents without shaming them in public, and students are expected to respect their teachers without questioning their authority directly.

    As youth pastors, understanding the meaning and reasoning behind social hierarchy enhances our ability to connect and communicate with students and their parents who were raised in and/or are from Confucian cultures. Confucian social hierarchy is embedded in a concept called li. Li is the ritual that guides people’s behaviors. People in Confucian culture are taught to comprehend and express ren (love, sympathy, virtue) by observing li. Observing li is not blind submission to a ritual; rather, it is a process of learning and the cultivation of a highly held value (of ren) through observation and participation in rituals, followed by reflection on the meanings behind the rituals in order to more fully embrace and comprehend ren.

    Confucianism identifies five primary relationships in society and forms corresponding li to ritualize how one should interact with people in these relationships. These five primary relationships are ruler and subject (government and citizen), parent and child, husband and wife, older sibling and younger sibling, and friend and friend. Confucianism teaches that peace and harmony can be achieved only if every person knows his or her proper place in society and upholds his or her responsibilities in relationships. A set of li ritualizes how people should interact in these five relationships. It is significant to point out that four out of the five primary relationships exist in a clear hierarchical structure; citizens are expected to submit to the ruler, children to their parents, a wife to her husband, and younger siblings to their older siblings.

    Due to li, direct confrontation and communication usually does not work well within Confucian hierarchy. How should children express disagreement with their parents when they are expected not to express disagreement in public? How should students express disagreement with their teachers when they are expected to submit to the teacher’s authority? Under these circumstances, indirect communication is not a means of being dishonest but a way in which to express disagreement while abiding li and maintaining appropriate politeness. Direct confrontation is not how people in Confucian culture usually handle conflicts. In the example of Esther, her parents did not come to the youth pastor to address their concern directly but rather expressed their concerns through indirect ways, such as grounding her from youth group.

    Individuals in Confucian culture find their place in society through assuming roles defined by li. In the majority culture of America, people tend to value others based on their occupational roles and their contribution to the society. While this is also partly true in a Confucian culture, people give a higher priority to relational roles tied to one’s family (such as being a father, a daughter, etc.) over one’s occupational roles (such as being a teacher, a pastor, etc.).

    According to Confucianism, in the mind of parents the role of a youth pastor is similar to that of a teacher. Teachers are highly regarded by both students and parents. Parents expect teachers to teach students the concept of ren and ways in which to observe li. Youth pastors are also expected to encourage their children to be good students and study hard. They should be role models not only in faith but also in academics. One study shows that Chinese eleventh graders are more likely than their American counterparts to identify teachers as significant role models.

    In the majority American culture the role of children differs from that in Confucianism. In Confucian culture, the proper role of the children is to submit to their parents, honor their families, and carry on the family legacy. In American society, children are expected to grow into autonomous individuals and eventually become independent from their parents and interdependent with adults. In Confucian culture academic achievement is an important aspect of being a “good child” because it links to the demonstration of good character and honoring one’s family. For parents, academic achievement is more than an achievement; it is proof of one’s moral character. A child’s academic success means more than being brilliant and smart; it means being diligent, perseverant, and responsible. Academic achievements are tied not only to a child’s grade but also to one’s major. Asian parents typically regard law school, medical school, and PhDs in engineering as successful majors. In the eyes of Esther’s parents, her shift from biology to social work is not just a change; it also represents a downgrade in her academic performance.

    Shame-Honor Culture

    Although there are many arguments on this matter, generally speaking, shame is the primary ethos for Asian culture, while guilt holds that position in the West. Because of this difference, both cultures have different values and patterns of behavior. Miller Creighton defines shame as “awareness of inadequacy or failure to achieve a wished-for self-image which is accompanied by, or originally arises from, the fear of separation and abandonment,” while guilt is “generated whenever the boundaries of negative behavior, as established by the superego, are touched or transgressed.” The anxiety of shame arises from the fear of separation or loss of the loving parent; conversely, the unconscious threat in guilt anxiety is not abandonment but punishment or retribution.

    This shame is deeply related to the collectivist character in Asian culture. Young Gweon You states, “Asians put high value on the harmonious integration of group members. So shame, possibly evidence [sic] by its emergence during the bounding stage, is more profoundly associated with the fear that one’s inadequacies will result in the loss of union with or expulsion from the group.”

    In other words, Asians may feel shame when going against the harmony or expectations of the community, which is not sinful or criminal. In Asian culture, it is of primary importance to uphold the expectations and harmony of one’s group. For Asian families, the goal of rearing a child is to create an individual who is in harmony with the community. If a child fails to carry any obligation that is expected of him or her as a member of the family, the child may feel extreme shame. This failure also brings shame for parents who have failed to raise their children to keep the harmony of family and society. Thus children in shame-based and collectivist cultures are under constant observation, supervision, and control.

    Because of this fear of separation in a collective shame culture, both children and parents feel shame when children fail to keep up the expectations and obligations of family and community. One of the representative examples in this matter relates to academic achievement. For Asian families, choosing a major or job is not an individual matter, and both a child and parents feel shame if the child fails to get into a good college. While a child may certainly feel frustrated toward him- or herself for failing to get a good SAT score or get in to a good college, the primary cause of shame for the child would be his or her failure to meet the parents’ and community’s expectations, which would also result in fear of abandonment by them. The parents also would feel shame for failing to raise the child well, fearing separation from mainstream society as well as the immigrant community.

    Multiple layers of shame can be uncovered in the story of Esther. First of all, by expressing a desire and interest that is against the ideal expectations of her family and immigrant community, Esther caused them great shame. As a result, she probably feared separation and abandonment from them. For her parents, Esther’s actions also prompted tremendous shame and fear, as her divergence from expected norms indicates their failure to raise their child well. Finally, because Esther revealed this issue to a youth pastor who is not only a complete outsider but also a representative of God and church, her parents felt terrible shame. This inflamed their feelings of shame and failure to present a wished-for self-image of parent and child that is loving and harmonious, without any family issues.

    Theological Reflection

    In regard to the overall theme of adoption in this book—that is, making the youth faithful disciples of Christ by adopting them as co-siblings into the family of God—we must remember that adoption is not simply a ministry strategy but a biblical truth that shapes all followers of Christ. We are all adopted into God’s family as his sons and daughters, and therefore we are all brothers and sisters, one to another. Being in God’s family is a radical message, especially for many cultures around the globe. It changes our relationship with God and others; it alters how we view one another and how we relate to one another. The author of Hebrews says that Jesus is not ashamed to call us brothers (and sisters) (Heb. 2:11). We are accepted and embraced into God’s family.

    Three questions can help us to deepen our understanding of this adoption narrative and its implications for youth from any nondominant culture:

  • What are the youth adopted into?
  • How does adoption change people’s life trajectories?
  • How does adoption change our relationships and communities?
  • In an East Asian cultural context, these three questions have lasting implications. First, what are we adopting the youth into? Of course, the easy and theologically correct answer is the family of God or God’s kingdom. In practice, however, we are often tempted to adopt the youth into something else. In mainstream American church, it is tempting to adopt the youth from a minority culture into the dominant American culture (which is not really adoption at all, as defined in the introductory chapter). Conversely, it is also tempting for ethnic churches to adopt youth into a reinvestment in their culture of origin. It is natural to adopt the youth into the culture that we are used to, particularly if we don’t give it much thought. Adoption of those from minority or immigrant cultures does not mean forcing others to look like, talk like, think like, and behave like the dominant culture, the church, or society. Adoption has great power because it enables the ones being brought into the family to come as they are. To be the adoptive “family” of one Father (Eph. 4:6) is to be a family in which no single culture is dominant and everyone’s background, heritage, and cultural values are honored.

    Theological reflection on what we are adopting the youth into enables us to be aware of the difference between our cultures and the gospel. It is tempting to associate the culture we learn in our local church with the Christian message of the gospel. However, local church life is shaped not only by the gospel preached from the pulpit but also by the congregation’s tradition and history, socioeconomic factors, surrounding cultural contexts, and so on. Instead of assuming that the culture we are used to is Christian, we should consider other cultures as God’s gift to help us better understand our own culture through comparison; in this way, we can discern gospel and non-gospel influences.

    The goal of youth ministry is to adopt the youth into the family of God, recognizing that the ministry is located within a certain culture and is called to witness the gospel to that culture. The church is not called to import the American majority culture to youth, nor is it called to preserve one’s minority cultural heritage. The church is the eschatological community of God; as such, it is called to witness the gospel in all cultures, adopt people from all cultures into the family of God, and shape people through the gospel revealed in Jesus Christ.

    Second, how does adoption change people’s life trajectory? As mentioned earlier, the narrative of Asian immigration is dominated by an economic drive—the desire for better opportunities and better lives. Asian immigrants are constantly under pressure—first to survive and then to prove themselves in a foreign land. This Asian version of the American dream is driven by fear and insecurity; as they seek a better life for their children, their insecurities diminish. For Asians, the American dream is less about possibilities and opportunities and more about security. The most obvious way for many Asian immigrants to achieve social mobility and economic stability is through education. Education is not about identity exploration or career exploration; it is primarily about social mobility.

    Third, how does adoption change our relationships, belonging, and value? The shame culture that is embedded in Confucianism is about acceptance and being valued in the community; people are driven by the fear of being rejected and considered worthless. On the surface, a shame culture is about honor, but the fear of rejection lies just beneath the surface. When Adam and Eve sinned against God, shame was one of the first consequences; they hid from each other because of their shame. Shame is a feeling of inadequacy about oneself. People living in shame try to live in community with one another by covering themselves up. Because of this shame culture in Confucianism, people try to act appropriately in order to be accepted by their families and the greater community. One of the most powerful idols that people worship in Confucianism is not ancestral worship but rather the idol of “pleasing others.” People constantly evaluate how others are evaluating them. This constant evaluation causes people to act in more reserved and cautious ways toward one another, especially before they feel accepted and recognized.

    The gospel frees people in shame cultures from the fear of rejection. God adopts people into his family who trust in him by grace, through his son, Jesus Christ. People are accepted into God’s family as they are. Church is a gathering of people who are all adopted into God’s family by this same grace. If a person from a shame culture truly believes the gospel, then it changes the way he or she evaluates him- or herself and how he or she interacts with others. Shame culture tells people to perform in order to be accepted and valued by their community. The gospel tells people the opposite: they are accepted and valued as they are. Therefore, they can live according to God’s grace.

    Adoption into the divine family first changes our relationship with God. Then we can learn how to relate with God and others according to this new relationship. It opens up a new way for people to belong and find their value in community. It is not only the youth that need to be adopted into the family of God; the adults need it as well.

    Practical Implication

    So far, we have addressed the particular characteristics of Asian American culture and the unchanging biblical concept of adoption. Next we want to ask: What does it mean to think globally in terms of youth ministry? How should youth workers connect with kids who are from various cultural backgrounds? In a cross-cultural setting, what are practical ways to help minority young people become more integrated into the family of God as disciples of Christ (even if only one minority teenager is involved)?

    We close by offering some practical steps for practicing youth ministry while thinking both biblically and globally.

    First, cultural sensitivity does not mean that we need to learn and understand everything about every culture. Rather, it means that we should acknowledge our ignorance and be willing to learn. The reason why we use Asian American culture and its particular way of thinking as an illustration is to demonstrate how different and complicated the invisible cultural forces are and how difficult it is to understand them with only a cursory look. Doing ministry while thinking globally requires that those who are involved with youth humbly seek to learn how to carefully observe and be attentive to what is going on in the families and cultures of the youth (current practice), avoiding judgment of their behaviors and/or giving them immediate answers.

    Second, cultural sensitivity does not mean that we must simply accept all cultural differences without dialogue, relationship, and respectful conversation before the Lord. Rather, it means that we respect the beauty and benefits of other cultures while recognizing that all cultures manifest both good and negative aspects; the goal is to create an environment in which the Bible guides our way. Theological reflection on adoption with cultural sensitivity, serious listening, and observation enables us to be aware of the difference between cultural forces and the gospel.

    Third, doing youth ministry while thinking globally means being with people as they take the risk to believe in God’s love and entering into a new adopted family together from our respective cultures. Through authentic listening, observation, and analysis, we must discern the cultural ills that need transformation and restoration in order for the church to become the biblical culture of God’s family. We then need to provide a safe environment for people from different cultures so that they can risk practicing unfamiliar yet biblically driven faithful action. Recognizing cultural differences does not mean that people change their perspectives or adjust deeply held convictions and values overnight. Being culturally sensitive in God’s family recognizes that all of us are on a path of learning and growth; we need each other so that we can help each other be transformed. In reality, doing youth ministry in cross-cultural settings is a messy picture of facing fears, taking risks, failing, and retrying new ways of life, which requires much patience from everyone, but especially those in leadership. In terms of practicality, training volunteers in youth ministry to have cultural sensitivity is a great place to start.

    Last, doing youth ministry in a cross-cultural setting requires continuous discernment of and surrender to the Holy Spirit, who is already at work in every culture. Our work is not adopting young people into our own culture but rather into the community of God. Our work is not saving them from their inferior cultural background so that they can be part of our superior culture; it is helping them have an authentic relationship with God so that they can live as a member of God’s community and participate in God’s mission. Thus, we should not assume that our culture is better than the cultures of others. We need to continuously remember that the Holy Spirit is everywhere, working within every cultural context. Our job is to discern how the Holy Spirit is working with the particular people in our ministry. As we have said, it is impossible to learn about and know every culture or to understand people completely. However, it is possible for us to be faithful servants, to discern and follow the Holy Spirit, who is already at work and has a perfect plan for our people.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑