12. Thinking Long Term
A great deal has been written in recent years regarding the number of young people who “leave the church” after graduating from high school. Regardless of which study we use, the numbers are depressing at best and staggering at worst. Compared to generations past, the idea that most children raised in the church will grow up to be involved, faithful members is showing itself to be all but obsolete, at least for Western expressions of the Christian faith. This has created quite a stir among those who study church trends and especially among those focused on children and adolescents. Research is ongoing, and books, articles, blogs, seminars, websites, and the like continue to wrestle with ways in which we can enhance the likelihood that young people will remain committed to the church when they move out and head into their adult journey. Dr. Cheryl Crawford of Azusa Pacific University is one of those researchers.
While several different methods have been used to get at the issues that affect young people’s interest in their parents’ version of active Christian faith, Crawford devotes herself to a method known as qualitative research. Rather than relying solely on surveys and group interviews, she deeply engages and consistently walks alongside several adolescents-turned-emerging-adults as they wrestle with the faith that they will carry into the early years of adulthood. Crawford takes us into this experience and helps us to get to know the people beneath the statistics, enabling us to hear the stories that shape their journeys.
For each twist and turn, every explanation and rationalization, Crawford introduces us to faces and voices seeking to make sense of their newfound freedom from convention and authority as they move toward independence and spiritual autonomy. Depending on your age, your particular story, and your understanding of how precarious the tightrope is between the relative safety of the teenage years and the transition into an adulthood rife with big questions and little support to navigate them, you might identify with one or more of the people Crawford introduces. You might even know someone who shares a similar story. Regardless, there are two lessons we hope you take away from this chapter. First, every person’s story is unique, worthy of our respect and attention, and constantly being reshaped and rewritten through the emerging and early adult years. There is no one way someone comes to own his or her faith, and for almost everyone the road is windy and filled with obstacles. Second, our hope is that you develop a long view of youth ministry: the way we prepare the child for the road is far more important than how we try to prepare the road for the child. This is the psychosocial as well as theological reasoning behind our advocacy for adoptive youth ministry. Young people both long for and need a substantial number of people (what we call convergence) who offer a unified message of encouragement and support (what we call congruence) in order to develop the sense of self they will need to allow for the faith of their parents and adult community to be a meaningful component of their development. In both parenting and youth ministry, there are no guarantees concerning ultimate spiritual outcomes; what looked like or indeed was a powerful inner commitment to faith may or may not thrive, much less last, into the twenties and beyond. Yet there is ample evidence in this chapter that those children and teenagers who received what we are calling an adoptive style of ministry focus seemed to have a clearer path to making their own decisions.
Our goal in this chapter is for you to remember that youth ministry is one part of a marathon, or one leg of a triathlon, as opposed to a single-focused hundred-yard dash during high school. Ministry to the young doesn’t begin when they reach ninth grade or end when they graduate from high school. It is what happens along a young person’s lifespan that contributes the most to that person making a decision regarding Jesus Christ and the kingdom of God. We do know that what tends to make a difference in the long haul is ultimately the depth and quality of the relationships a person experiences while growing up. As with the other chapters, the issues presented here are neither complete nor final. Crawford is committed to making this a major part of her work for years to come, and through this book’s website she will be updating her findings and conclusions, doing what she can to make herself available for conversation.
As you read this chapter, consider these questions:
Miguel begins his freshman year at a large public university with a bang. Tall, athletic, and socially adept, he easily finds fun and friendship by hanging out with his roommate and other freshman guys from his dorm floor. The partying begins Wednesday night and doesn’t end until the wee hours of Monday morning. Drinking eight to twelve beers and smoking pot become a mainstay of Miguel’s daily regimen. He has decided not to look into the Christian fellowship groups or a local church because he feels like he doesn’t have the time. Besides, one of his friends told him that the fellowship group on campus was cliquey. His faith is “on hold” for now; maybe after college he’ll think about God again. But still he misses what he used to feel as God’s presence in his life. When he is honest with himself, even fleetingly, he feels rather empty. But Miguel just can’t seem to drum up the motivation to find his way back to faith right now.
Julia attends a well-known private school in the northeast. She has a Christian roommate with whom she has bonded. She’s a bit surprised by the pervasive nature of alcohol at her school but decides, along with her roommate, to go ahead and drink occasionally so they can hang out with their new dorm friends. Julia and her roommate go to parties simply to be social and not miss a significant part of college life. She is committed to limiting herself to one drink per party and reports never indulging further. Julia has gotten involved in a campus fellowship group and local church; she describes her faith as challenged but growing.
Robert knew he was headed for a life in engineering since his junior year of high school. A regular at youth group, he also felt like he was committed to the basic tenets of the Christian faith. Accepted to a large, prestigious university, he pursued both his faith and academics with rigor. Although very shy, Robert was befriended by boys and girls on his dorm floor. He did everything with this small group of friends—meals, basketball games, and even parties. But he refused to drink or do drugs—even on a campus that canceled classes and provided a quad for students to smoke pot on 4/20. During his first two years he did well academically and soon became a leader with the on-campus Christian fellowship group. But something changed toward the end of his junior year. He not only began drinking but also stopped actively pursuing his faith. He decided that it was something from his past, that it was irrational, and that it no longer made sense or was relevant for him.
Three young people active in youth ministry. Three stories. Three different faith trajectories after high school.
What determines whether someone will continue to pursue a relationship with God during college and perhaps the rest of his or her life? All three of these college students hail from at least marginal Christian homes and solid youth group involvement throughout high school. So what’s the difference? While Miguel seems to have put his relationship with Jesus on hold, Robert has decided to walk away, and Julia has continued to develop hers. Was Julia prepared to pursue her spiritual relationship with Jesus more than the other two? Was something more decisively and clearly resolved for Julia before entering college than it was for Miguel and Robert?
Youth workers typically want to talk about implications: What should we do to ensure that our students will choose Julia’s path rather than Miguel’s or Robert’s? But it’s not that simple. Obviously there are no guarantees, and every person will go through his or her own journey of faith. A growing body of evidence indicates that youth ministry makes at least some difference in whether a young person will continue to own his or her faith into adulthood. In this chapter we look at the general impact parents, church, other adults, and peer practices can have on adolescents as they grow into their faith and into their adoptive family of God.
It is important to say from the outset that salvation and sanctification (growth in our relationship to Jesus) are God’s work—not ours. It is God who draws us to himself, plants a desire to know him in our hearts, and adopts us into his family. But as fellow believers, we are called to be God’s hands and feet on this earth, meaning that there are ways we can crack open doors (and sometimes very small windows) of opportunity for students to desire a growing relationship with their Maker and Savior. In an adoptive ministry, the family of God on earth—the local expression of the “body of Christ”—represents Jesus to all disconnected outsiders, which includes kids in youth ministry as representatives of the God who is called Father. A family-like environment in which the adults proactively seek to include and welcome young people to participate as members of God’s family gives long-term ministry a much better foothold for lifelong faith to develop.
Parents
At the outset we must begin with a basic discussion about parenting in general. As a researcher who has interviewed parents, observed hundreds of parent teams, and researched parenting, some general themes emerge in relation to lifelong faith. Among these themes are age differences, marital issues, continuity versus discontinuity, and specific practices that are helpful for creating an environment where lifelong faith can take root and flourish.
Parental Age Differences
I visited new parents and their newborn in a hospital recently. When I visited the nursery, most of the babies looked about the same size, weight, and so on, but I was unprepared for how varied the ages of their parents would be. My friends were thirty, while other parents cuddling their newborns looked to be nineteen, in their mid-thirties, and over forty. The same is true of the parents whose kids attend your youth group. Just add thirteen years—not only to the newborns but also to their parents! Although middle school kids are all twelve to fourteen years old, the parents of these kids could range anywhere between thirty and the mid-fifties! We may be somewhat aware of the developmental stages of children and adolescence, but have we considered how the ages of the parents of particular young people might affect them? Most youth workers think of parents as homogeneous—one size fits all. When we talk about “parents,” we rarely consider how different parents may be.
If, for example, you have a student in the middle school youth ministry whose parents are in their early thirties, it is safe to assume that they had this child at an early age, possibly a very early age. You might also consider that the couple (if there is a couple) may not actually be the birth parents, or perhaps only one of them is a birth parent. It is possible that, due to their ages at the time of the child’s birth, they had a rough go of it along the way. They were barely out of high school and nowhere near adulthood, and yet they took on the responsibilities of partnership (sometimes marriage) and parenting. When they were barely able to take care of themselves, they became responsible for someone else. The odds are fair that the parent(s) had to depend on extended family to support them, perhaps financially and practically. It is also possible that they had to play catch-up with adulthood for most of their journey; some might even rely on others to provide the bare necessities of life.
To continue this scenario, what happens in this family when the parents find out that their child’s favorite leader gives their child a flyer during Sunday school and says, “I can’t wait to take you to camp! Tell your mom you’re going!” Excited and ready to sign up, the child hands over the flyer, and the first thing Mom does is look at the price (buried at the lower right-hand corner of the handout): $400! The ministry opportunities we often take for granted are way beyond this family’s reach. Not only is this enough to keep the student from attending camp, but it may be enough to drive the family from church out of frustration, anger, or even guilt.
As a youth group leader you may not see this parent much and may even conclude she is negligent because of her absence or lack of involvement. While we have no idea what struggles this parent faces daily, we are often quick to judge on the basis of her “uninvolvement.” Having borne a heavy weight of responsibility since her adolescence, this parent is weary. How do we best support her?
For many in middle- to upper-middle-class and/or suburban Caucasian settings, typical youth group parents are likely in their early to mid-forties. Most likely they are still married and on average started a family around the age of thirty. Their family plans coincided with their careers and (subconsciously) with their maturity level. They began a family as adults. They had time to get their heads and hearts together, so their parenting might be more consistent. They were generally prepared for starting a family—mentally, psychologically, and financially. Buying the necessary stroller, car seat, bassinet, and diapers was all part of the plan.
For adults, the forties are an interesting developmental stage. Careers are moving and shaking. In describing the psychosocial development of humans, Erik Erikson labels this stage “generativity vs. stagnation.” He is calling attention to the focus of the forties: production. For those who have successfully made it through the six prior stages of psychosocial development, focus now turns to “making a mark” on the world. The two most common pursuits during this stage are raising children and work production. While most parents are heavily invested in their children, they are also in the throes of their career. Concerns about promotion, a job change, or layoffs hover continually as they balance the onset of puberty within their families.
These parents are constantly torn between family and career choices. Walking into several homes, I have been welcomed by the multicolored “family calendar” that parents use to debate who will take on which family responsibility for the upcoming week. Although most parents in this age group want to be consistently there for their kids, they constantly feel the pull of work obligations. Few at this stage of their lives are willing to risk their jobs, even for deeply held family commitments. Most US workers have difficulty turning off the phone, coming home early, or saying no to trips; as a result, they are available to their work 24-7.
For many who are employed in youth ministry (depending on the demographics of your community), these forty-year-old parents might be typical. Communication with them is difficult because they are often busy and distracted. They commit to events they end up being unable to attend because of last-minute work demands, communication gaffes, family needs, double-booking, or plain exhaustion. They may forget to sign or even return a permission slip because it was lost in the shuffle of life. In attempting to involve them in ministry, leaders may get frustrated by what seems like the parents’ unwillingness to commit. In reality, they are simply torn—caught in the continual squeeze of daily life demands.
Finally, what about the parents who had your youth group kid when they were forty-one years old? These parents either married late, are on a second (or more) marriage and wanted children, or were surprised by an unplanned pregnancy. Perhaps the child you work with is by far the youngest in the family or has only stepsiblings. While the parents in this case may be more attentive to the needs of their child than to the needs of their careers, they can have their own unique challenges, such as managing a multigenerational household or navigating stepfamilies and ex-spouses. When this late-birth infant knocks on the door of your high school ministry, the parents will have already qualified for AARP membership (being in their mid- to late fifties). They must concurrently plan college and retirement. Not only are health issues beginning to concern them but also their parents are now elderly and struggling with the multiple and complex issues of aging and death. On the one hand, they are experienced parents who have “made their mark” with family and work, but on the other hand, they struggle to keep up with a contemporary teenager and the culture that surrounds him or her. While they may be engaged as their older children journey through adolescence, they are typically unaware of current trends in media or youth culture.
Different ages and stages: it is important to recognize that although kids in your youth group are similar in age, the ages of their parents may range from thirty to sixty. Uniting this group of parents will present challenges, yet the diversity of your parents can greatly enrich your youth group. Recognizing their various challenges and strengths is vital in terms of your assumptions, expectations, communication, and engagement. Take a minute to think about your youth group. Do you know (roughly) the ages of your parents? Consider what assumptions you make about them. Do you have the same expectations for all parents? What is your mode of communication? Finally, how can you best engage parents of all ages with your youth ministry?
Relationships: Continuity and Discontinuity
Most parents report an astonishing increase in tension with their kids beginning in early adolescence (think middle school). Some of this tension is the result of puberty, given all the hormonal and body changes. Some researchers believe it has to do with an adolescent’s increased cognitive ability. He or she no longer accepts the “because I say so” reasoning from parents, questioning their authority and wisdom.
Researchers who look at adolescent relationships hail from two different perspectives. Those who argue for continuity maintain that a good, connected relationship early on leads to a good, connected relationship during adolescence. Based on attachment theory, psychologists propose that a good infant-bonding relationship leads to a healthy child-parent relationship, which is followed by a positive, communicative adolescent-parent relationship. Those who maintain a discontinuity perspective argue that as humans mature, we develop more sophisticated cognitive and social skills, leading to distinct ways of interacting during each developmental stage. Therefore, a good relationship between a daughter and her mother may not necessarily lead to an honest, open, and positive relationship during puberty.
It seems that the key to this distinction is found in holding the two perspectives in tension. Yes, a positive, healthy initial relationship most assuredly paves the way for healthy future relationships. However, if parents do not adapt the way they relate to their children as they mature, the relationship will deteriorate.
Jude is raised by two loving parents who almost overly coddle him as an infant. He is a happy baby who senses the security and love his parents offer. They are tuned in to his feeding and diaper needs and take every opportunity to express their unconditional love to him. As Jude becomes a toddler, diapers and bottles are no longer necessary. So how do they show their unconditional love? Spending time playing and reading with him, encouraging his creativity, and being present when he has a need. Although Jude will still need to know their presence and experience their unconditional love during adolescence, it takes on a different appearance. His parents’ love need not be as conspicuous. It might mean being available when least expected and tuned in to the ups and downs of relationships or being willing to talk but not pushing an agenda.
Building a solid relational foundation during the early years but adjusting the way we communicate presence and unconditional love during the years when kids are working so hard to become increasingly independent is vital. As adolescents grow up, they may act as if, and even occasionally believe, they want to be totally independent from adults, but the reality is that they still very much need our support, presence, and undying love. They need and long for the blessing of both continuity and discontinuity.
Parental Practices
Back to our three friends whom I introduced at the beginning of this chapter: Miguel, Julia, and Robert. At the outset it is essential to make this disclaimer: raising kids is not template-worthy. There is no secret formula, no list that begins, “If you do x, y, and z, your child will continue to follow God throughout his or her life.” No insider’s classified list of dos and don’ts. Such lists and formulas ignore the uniqueness of each child—their DNA, temperament, skills, abilities, and backgrounds. What’s more, they ignore the uniqueness of each parent and their marital relationship.
While interviewing students and their parents for a research project on lifelong faith in young people, I grew more aware of the incredible complexity involved in parenting adolescents. Each situation is extraordinarily unique. There will never be a masterful how-to book that provides all the answers for lifelong faith. What follows, however, are some common experiences of those who sustained faith a few to several years out of college. Based on research and interviews with both adolescents and their parents, these practices may add a few tools to the resource kit you carry as a youth worker.
If you met Miguel, for example, you would like him from the minute he walked in the room. He is a sensitive, reflective, expressive twenty-something who loves adventure. He showed up to one of our interviews fully geared up for skiing in frigid temperatures the rest of the day. He has traveled all over the world with friends and family. Recently settling into a stable job, he lives in an urban area populated with young professionals. On summer weekends, he enjoys motoring out as far as his gas will take him to catch some deep-ocean fish. He also loves basketball and beer—I’m not certain in what order.
Miguel’s parents were very open and candid with me about where their son is at spiritually. They knew he had wandered and did not know why. Miguel was raised in a small town where his family was very involved in a local church. His father was on the elder board, and his mother volunteered in various ministries throughout his school years. According to Miguel’s parents, Friday night was a popular party night for both parents and high school students in their hometown. Although they were frequently invited out to adult parties, Miguel’s parents stayed home and weekly hosted large groups of kids at their house. The kids played games, watched movies, and just hung out under Miguel’s parents’ sober supervision. They intentionally chose to become the place kids wanted to be—the safe place. And so they hosted, week after week.
Every night before Miguel went to bed, his father prayed over and with him. And every Sunday he woke up Miguel and drove him to church. During the later years of high school Miguel opted to go to church rather than youth group. Especially during his senior year, he felt his youth group had become cliquey and judgmental.
Miguel was a different kid at school. He did not want other kids to know he was a Christian because he did not want to be held accountable to a certain lifestyle standard (drinking, sex, pot, etc.). In reality, when Miguel began his college freshman year he had already checked his faith at the door. His parents simply did not know.
Julia has a different story. When her family (parents and three sisters) moved to a new town when she was in seventh grade, they visited multiple churches and agreed not to choose one until they all agreed. Once they settled into a church, each member of the family became involved. Mom joined the women’s ministry team, and Dad found a men’s Bible study group; the girls all jumped into their appropriate age-group ministry. Dad was asked to become an elder about two years later.
Two parenting practices make Julia’s experience unique. Every night her family sat down for dinner and evening devotions, which consisted of a Bible reading and story and then prayer. Everyone participated without exception. Perhaps even more unique is the commitment Julia’s dad made when they relocated to this new town. He became a telecommuter so that he could adjust his work commitments according to his priorities, not his boss’s. He committed to taking each daughter out for breakfast individually one day each week. They spent time at breakfast talking about what was going on in each of their lives, sharing prayer requests, and, finally, praying together. Perhaps I am somewhat of a cynic, but I actually questioned the reality of this kind of familial commitment. Yet one day three summers ago I saw this father and one of his other daughters sitting in a car outside a restaurant at breakfast time. And yes, they were praying together. There’s a lot more to Julia’s story, but in terms of parental practices, the commitment and consistency of this family is noteworthy.
Robert is an interesting guy. When I first interviewed him, I noted how painfully shy he is. He is probably one of the most introverted people I have ever encountered. Yet he was drawn into a small crowd of college students who journeyed through college together. Although his friends partied throughout college, Robert would not take a drink until the end of his junior year. He was heavily involved in a campus Christian organization, spending time outside regular meetings with the adult adviser. He asked a lot of questions and enjoyed being treated as an adult in terms of their conversations.
By the beginning of his senior year, Robert decided he was an atheist, posting his resolution on Facebook. Although his parents had encouraged him in his faith, he decided against it, saying it was illogical. In one of my conversations with him, Robert told me he had believed because his mother believed, but over time, he decided his father was a more credible resource for such important life decisions. After all, he was an engineer like Robert. Although his father is not an atheist, he is what Robert refers to as a “minimally committed” or “Sunday only” believer. At least somewhat influenced by his father’s lukewarm faith, Robert chose an even more extreme route—atheism.
The greatest lesson I have learned from Robert about parenting is that we need to help our kids understand their faith with all of who we are. If we don’t help them connect both the mind and the heart to their faith, they develop a dualistic understanding of faith: I can be a “Sunday Christian” and yet not consider my faith to mean much outside that. However, according to this understanding of faith, a choice will need to be made—faith by heart (feeling) or faith by mind (logic). For those who sustain a faith well beyond high school, most were encouraged to connect and integrate their faith in both heart (emotions, time) and mind (conviction) in some way during high school. As a result, the different aspects of their faith were not competing and eventually negating each other in the years after high school.
Parenting Conclusions
Most parents would agree that parenting adolescents is probably the hardest thing they have done in their lives. The terrain is ever-changing and the issues never-ending. Consistency from both parents is essential. Active, not-in-their-face engagement and presence is required. Sharing family devotions or other spiritual disciplines seems to help build the foundation of their growing faith, and ensuring that our kids know that we love them unconditionally is key. How else will they experience the unconditional love of God?
But the story does not end when they graduate from college. Emerging adults are far from figuring out who they are by the time they receive their degree. Although these twenty-somethings think they are adults and have life figured out, parents and the other adults who love them need to continue to engage them in reflective and hopeful conversations. For the most part, they still need to process who they are as they navigate their first real jobs and living situations. Oftentimes, they do not take the time to reflect. They still require the thoughtful, compassionate conversations parents can offer.
Faith that lasts is faith that continually develops. Growing in faith requires thoughtful reflection on one’s life and circumstances. Parents can be our best conversation partners, if perceived as safe and loving. Regular phone calls, texts, and emails assure our kids that they are still on our minds, even though they have moved out and moved on. As parents we still need those one-on-ones with our kids. One of the parents I interviewed fishes regularly with his son, traveling into the deep waters for one to two days at least three times a year. That kind of quality time together provides opportunity for conversations that are more than 255 characters, the maximum length for a standard text message. For some reason, doing something together encourages more openness than simply sitting across the table from each other. Maybe it’s the perceived casualness that prompts more honest conversations, or maybe it’s the subconscious awareness that we have taken significant time out of our schedules to be with our kids. That in itself signals value and love.
Parenting is not a job. It is a lifelong commitment to love, support, and encourage growth in our sons and daughters. It is a huge commitment and requires the support of both the church and other adults.
Church and Other Adults
Churches are as diverse as the families they serve. No two are alike. Interestingly, the smaller churches seem to gravitate toward intergenerational ministry more than the larger ones do, perhaps out of necessity. In this section I will talk about the necessity of changing the way we think about church and family.
The United States is probably most guilty of elevating the nuclear family above the extended family and the church. In his groundbreaking and provocative book, Rodney Clapp asserts, “The negative declaration: The family is not God’s most important institution on earth. . . . And the positive declaration: The church is God’s most important institution on earth.” In America, we seem to almost idolize the nuclear family, thinking that it is God’s primary vehicle to accomplish his work. Clapp spills a lot of ink in his book outlining a biblical view of the family, which in essence he extends to the local church—in other words, church as family.
What does it mean when we advocate for church as family? We extend the boundaries of our nuclear family to include our church family. Dr. Diana Garland explains, “The Christian family is one of adoption. From the account of Jesus’s conception and adoption by Joseph into David’s line, to Jesus’s last act from the cross, God provides us with the hope and reality of adoption as a way of forming families when we follow Christ. All followers of Christ belong in a family, and it is the work of Christ’s church to turn this hope into reality.”
Beginning in the early years of childhood, other adults from church are naturally included in our lives. Most churched parents drop their children off at Sunday school before entering the sanctuary (or the “mother ship,” as some have been known to call it). The people who care for our children during church have a natural relationship with our children. Rather than pigeonholing them in our minds as simply “Micah’s Sunday school teacher,” what prevents us from engaging that person and inviting him or her into our family? If the teachers already have a positive relationship with our child, isn’t it natural to include them in our broader family?
If we begin to embrace “church as family” when our children are young, other adult voices are granted the right to be heard with little debate. Sarah, who is forty, single, and Micah’s Sunday school teacher, has been part of his life since he was in second grade. She has been an assumed family member as long as he can remember. She’s been there for family holidays, birthdays, illnesses, and graduations. When Micah hits high school and seems to distance himself from most adults, he continues to share with Sarah. She has proved herself to be “safe” and has literally been adopted as family.
When Micah goes away to college and struggles with alcohol, drugs, or sex, Sarah is most likely the person with whom he will confide. She’s been there with him through a lot of tough stuff over the years and continues to be his advocate and confidant. She’s not only considered “safe” but has demonstrated an unwavering love and concern for Micah since he was in second grade. There is great power in close, extended family relationships.
I asked one of the male students I had been interviewing since high school who he would go to if he was in a crisis. At the time, he had graduated college and was twenty-three years old. He told me it would be his eighty-five-year-old mayor. It turns out she befriended him and was invited into his family when he was in junior high. They met on an all-church community service project and worked side by side picking up trash. From that day forward, she was welcomed into his family, by his invitation. They ended up co-teaching a Sunday school class throughout his high school years, deepening their connection. When he went off to college and struggled with some substance abuse issues, she’s the one who called to check up on him. And she was the only one with whom he shared his struggle with pot and alcohol.
Church as family demands intentional intergenerational vision and strategy. For a long time many churches have embraced the “one-eared Mickey Mouse” model of youth ministry. This model perpetuates the separation of youth ministry from the other ministries of the church. Although the initial reasoning was to enable youth pastors to minister specifically to the developmental needs of adolescents, it ended up cutting them off entirely from the rest of the church congregation. When our kids left to go away to college, they returned to a church they never knew, which is yet another reason they fall off the map during the college years.
But for those college freshmen who return to home churches that function as their extended family, they run into welcoming arms—a homecoming! They naturally become part of the entire church family because they always have been part of the family. These emerging adults have many relationships in and among the congregation, maintaining a sense of belonging that supersedes generations.
Churches can perpetuate this sense of family by encouraging staff and congregational contact with students as they journey through and beyond college and young adult life. What college student or person in the military does not love a care package with home-baked cookies? Regular texts, emails, letters, and phone calls can and do maintain the bonds created while in middle and high school over the years and miles. When a student graduates, when a young adult takes a step toward a career or achieves a milestone in his or her young life, when a young couple gets married, the entire faith community celebrates alongside and with them as they move into adulthood and maturity.
Church as family responds affirmatively to our call to adoption. By adopting all members of the church into our family, we are able to provide the necessary support for our youth as they traverse the arduous terrain of adolescence and emerging adulthood. Once someone is adopted into a family, they become a permanent member of that family. I am suggesting that churches embrace a family culture by adopting its members into their family. It not only provides a cohesive experience for kids as they move through the various ages and stages, but it also invites other adults to speak into their lives. It provides a broader foundation of support for kids as they enter into adolescence—guided by the presence of concerned and loving adults who are already known to be supportive of them.
In 2002, Dr. Chap Clark correctly noted the dangerous trend resulting from the “one-eared Mickey Mouse” model of youth ministry. At that time, Clark challenged youth ministers with a new goal: “to assimilate authentic disciples into full participation in the life of the community of faith and the church.” This goal appropriately describes the nature of ministry as adoption. Welcoming kids into the church family by means of adoption and inviting them into the full life of the community, where the church operates as a family, is what it takes to provide the kind of environment in which kids have the best chance to explore and ultimately embrace their faith.
Many will argue against such a practice because kids don’t want to hang out with adults. But this is not true, especially when adults initiate respectful and meaningful relationships with young people. In today’s world—where young people feel far safer and more comfortable with one another than with adults—peer influence significantly impacts adolescents today. The next section addresses that concern, recognizing the impact of same-age friends without giving in to the cultural myth that kids do not want to be with adults. They do, but they also need one another.
Peers versus Friends
Although I have used peers in the title of this section, the term is a misnomer. Researchers today have clarified what has been misconstrued in the past. Peer refers to “a person of the same age, the same social position, or having the same abilities as other people in a group.” The argument against using such a word to describe influence among friends is that most people are not influenced by people just because they are the same age, maintain the same social position, or have the same abilities. Adolescent psychologists prefer to call this “friend influence,” noting that one of the more influential forces in adolescents’ lives is their friends, not their peers.
Ask adolescents who has the most impact on their life and without missing a beat they will tell you it is their friends. And, given the onslaught of social media outlets (Facebook, texting, Twitter, Instagram, etc.), they are in constant contact with their friends. In the past parents could monitor whom their kids were spending time with, but today, with the advent of social media, kids can be connecting with a range of friends within a span of minutes. They are impacted not only by the shared messages but also by the shared photos and taglines. Both fact and fiction travel among friends in a moment’s time.
Most adolescents function in that “need to know” mode so fear being out of touch from their friends. They are afraid if they miss something, they will be left out in the cold. Every parent and youth worker has noticed this shift in urgency. Adolescents do not want to be separated from their cell phones for any length of time because they need to stay “connected” with their friends.
Since 1950, Erikson’s “Eight Ages of Man” (the central chapter in his Childhood and Society) has mapped out the developmental psychosocial sequence for infants through senior adults. Each of Erikson’s stages relies on the resolution of specific “crises” that lead toward mature and healthy development. Adolescence is identified as the time period in which young people either figure out who they are, resolving the identity crisis by exploration and commitment, or leave this stage failing to define themselves.
Erikson’s Eight Ages of Man*
Age
Psychosocial Conflict
Infancy (0–1 year)
Basic trust vs. mistrust
Early childhood (1–3 years)
Autonomy vs. shame
Play age (3–6 years)
Initiative vs. guilt
School age (6–12 years)
Industry vs. inferiority
Adolescence (12–19 years)
Identity vs. identity confusion
Early adulthood (20–25 years)
Intimacy vs. isolation
Adulthood (26–64 years)
Generativity vs. stagnation
Old age (65–death)
Integrity vs. despair
Childhood and Society
Robert Kegan added to Erikson’s developmental sequence in 1982. Kegan’s research led him to believe the identity task did not occur until later in adolescence. He proposed the addition of the stage “affiliation vs. abandonment” during adolescence. Kegan recognized the intense need for adolescents to feel connected, to feel like they belong. Kegan’s work provides an explanation as to why adolescents are so impacted by their friends during this stage of life.
Remember Julia, the college freshman whose faith was pretty foundational to her life decisions? One of the unique aspects of Julia’s life is the connections she shared with one of her high school friends. She and Emily went to the same high school, played in the same orchestra, participated in the same small Bible study group, attended the same Christian camp, and ran track together. Although they did not identify each other as a best friend, they ran in the same circle in multiple venues.
Why is this important? Kids’ lives today are very fragmented. They live in multiple friend circles. The kids who attend their high school probably are not on the same travel sport teams. They most likely do not attend the same church, never mind small group. Rarely would they attend the same Christian camp. This fragmentation of life allows adolescents to fragment their identity: they can be different people in different settings. Social media only complicates matters. How an adolescent presents herself on Facebook or Twitter can be dramatically different from the kid who leads worship at youth group. Her language on the soccer field might just be a little grittier than her language at church.
But if an adolescent has a friend who travels in the same circles, identity becomes more integrated in every aspect of his or her life. An adolescent cannot fluctuate his or her identity based on setting if the same friend is present in most settings, holding him or her implicitly accountable.
Julia had the advantage of a consistent friend in multiple circles. Miguel and Robert did not. They had friends at school and friends at church, but there was no crossover. Miguel didn’t want anyone at school to even know he was a Christian because that would mean he would have to act differently. Robert was shy; he primarily kept to himself at school but connected somewhat at church. Neither had the support of a trusted friend in the many settings in which they found themselves. They lived different lives in different settings, leading to a lack of integrated faith.
Julia sought out Christian friends when she arrived at college because being a Christian was core to her well-integrated identity. Miguel decided to “shelve” his faith during college, wanting to “do the college thing.” He graduated three years ago and has not yet resolved his faith identity. He believes he will come back to his faith once he gets married and has kids, “because I was raised with it.” Robert has disconnected from his high school and college friends but remains close with his parents and sister. He simply knows he is an engineer and an atheist and does not seem to be searching for anything more.
Conclusion
Three stories, three different faith trajectories. Parents, church, other adults, and friends all impact spiritual growth. Although I have addressed each of these in terms of their effect on adolescents, the key is integration. If the church embraced adoption as a model of youth ministry, not only parents but also other adults and friends would be considered family; they would live out what it looks like to remain faithful and serve throughout one’s life. If all generations of our churches were to come alongside parents—as family members—to help raise “our” kids, we would be able to provide the consistent relationships kids need as they traverse the difficult terrain of adolescence.
Ultimately, youth ministry as adoption rests on an understanding of the church (what we call ecclesiology) by which members live into their calling of church as a family, extending the borders of the nuclear family to embrace those with whom we worship on Sunday morning. It involves expanding our ministries to include multigenerational opportunities so that all church members can get to know one another. The church needs to be a place where kids are known because they have been invited to do life with their church as family. Are we willing to expand our idolized view of the nuclear family and to include other believers—for the sake of our kids? That is our challenge and our call to adoption as a model for youth ministry.
