17. No Church in the Wild
17
No Church in the Wild
Urban and Multiethnic Contexts as the New Frontier of Youth Ministry
Dr. Daniel White Hodge is a much beloved, gifted leader who comes to us with an uncomfortable message, at least for some. In today’s world we are continually assaulted with injustice, inequities, and multiple reminders that the rhetoric of equality and Christian community is often inadequate, if not empty. The issue of race and class continues to be a real force, threatening both the nation and the institution of the church. Hodge reminds us of our own history—a history that most who have grown up in suburban as well as middle- and upper-class settings have been immune to. Those days are gone.
As we seek to be God’s family and to participate in God’s adoption of all his children, we must recognize that we have hindered the family from living as a family. We all carry assumptions, biases, prejudices, and even methodology that perpetuate oppression and segregation. Hodge’s chapter reveals to us that we must find a better way to empower the powerless, share leadership, and listen more keenly to the voices of those outside our comfortable circles, even when those messages are uncomfortable or even offensive.
We chose Hodge because he has earned the right to lead us in this vital and rarely exposed conversation. May you take him seriously and commit before the Lord to be a faithful witness to God’s call to all of his children.
As you read this chapter, consider these questions:
By the time he got to me he was flustered, exasperated, and defeated. As soon as he walked over to me, he exploded. “These kids are lost! Lost, I tell you!” He began pacing, trying to make sense of the experience he had just come from, talking as much to himself as to me. “These are the end times, Dan! That’s all that I can figure out!” As he sat down and began to regain his composure, I gently asked, “What exactly are you referring to here?” He responded, “These kids at camp! They are so lost!” I was still somewhat puzzled because I knew that this outreach pastor had just come from a youth ministry “outreach” camp.
“It was a disaster! It started out badly, and it got worse from there. They didn’t even give the gospel a chance.”
I have known my friend for a long time, and I knew that he had had plenty of experience as a youth speaker, but something about this camp had really gotten to him. My pastor friend, who is white and from a suburban church ministry context, felt out of place, not “welcome,” and—more significant—that “these kids,” as he continually called them, were “lost.” As we continued to talk, he shared with me his frustration: the way that he had been taught to do ministry—especially camping ministry—was now outdated. As he relayed his next grievance, the light bulb came on.
“They didn’t give me a chance! It was like they were in gangs!”
It turns out that not only were these particular kids not from white suburban churches but also most were ethnic minorities living in urban contexts. He is white, and most of the campers were not. He confessed that his message was not relevant for them, and rather than looking at his own youth ministry teaching philosophy and methodology, he blamed the students. It never occurred to this friend that in order to connect with young people who had come from different contexts than he did, it would go a long way to attempt to build a bridge of trust and understanding. He would later reveal to me that because most of the campers were Latino and black, he assumed membership in gangs and also associated them with being “lost” and “unsaved” without first seeking to know them. As we talked, I realized that not only was this weekend difficult for both him and the kids he had spoken to but also what he and those at the camp experienced was a signpost to a new trend that few can see or are even willing to look at.
A good friend of mine has been doing urban youth ministry for thirty years. Every summer an affluent, mostly white youth group comes out to do “mission work” in his community in the inner city of Seattle. Over the years my friend had seen close up what many have been noting for years, especially in suburban, white church youth groups. Students coming to serve had changed over the years. Fewer students were coming, and those who did come demonstrated a deeper sense of theological apathy and personal entitlement. Most lacked the spiritual zeal that used to mark these experiences. Eventually my friend in Seattle discussed this with the director of that church: “What if we do something different this year? Our group has grown significantly and our students’ faith is growing. What if we came out to you guys this summer and worked with your group?” My friend told me that the pastor was so put off by this suggestion that he said, “What do you all have to offer us? That’s not how it works.”
A change and shift has occurred over the past few decades—and even more acutely over the past few years—that has shifted how we think of urban, suburban, rural, and youth ministry. This “shift” involves much more than just pedagogy. The change is comprehensive: it is methodological, missional, philosophical, theological, sociological, and ministry-driven. The two narratives I have relayed reveal a worldview that the “urban” is “out there” and still in need of “help.” It reveals ideologies and perspectives that are rooted in long-standing mantras of racism and social ignorance by many in white, suburban church contexts. The urban and multiethnic reality is now, and what used to be the “inner city” has become the reality for all of us, to at least some extent. The growing gentrification in most cities, fragmenting of central business districts into “uptowns,” and an increase in “progressive planning” have created a dislocation for many who once called the inner city home. Suburban churches are now finding a more “colorful” demographic in their contexts, and most have little to no intercultural and/or interethnic training or awareness, complicating the issues even further.
Jay Z and Kanye West title their opening song on the album Watch the Throne “No Church in the Wild.” In the lyrics, they reveal an almost humanist ethos, which is rooted in an even more ambiguous theology regarding “church.” “What’s a god to a nonbeliever? / Who don’t believe in anything?” What might that mean for youth ministry? Further, how does that affect youth ministry in both suburban and urban contexts? What does it mean for the youth pastor when the methods of old aren’t working anymore? Do we blame the young for our inability to understand and, more important, adapt? What happens when the model of youth ministry and our youth ministry formulae have run their course? Jay Z and Kanye aptly answer: there is no church in the wild because those contexts are difficult and ambiguous, thus creating a gap in the way we understand youth ministry and the engagement of nontraditional youth ministry settings.
This chapter asserts that urban and multiethnic contexts are becoming the new future for youth ministry, making them not only imperative to understand but also to engage. A church in the wild is needed—that “wild” being the unknown, the foreign, the complex, and the ambiguous. Urban and multiethnic settings are growing and changing. The image of the suburban, white, relatively homogeneous youth ministry will have to adjust to and adopt new ways of thinking, ministering, and engaging this new generation of young people. I will give a brief overview of the changing urban context and then suggest some concepts of engagement regarding urban and multiethnic youth ministry. Let’s begin by exploring how some of these changes occurred in the first place.
The Urban Emergence
This chapter is not intended to offer an exhaustive treatment of the rise of the post-industrial society and urban gentrification. Great scholars and urban ethnographers such as Daniel Bell, Mike Davis, Andrew Wiese, Melvin Webber, Josh Sides, and Harvey Cox treat these issues well and give insight into the urban emergence. For our purposes it is enough to briefly highlight the key areas of significance over the past thirty years with the help of these and other scholars and to expound on certain moments that have created the urban-suburban blend we see now.
The later years of the 1960s marked the beginning of what most scholars and cultural theorists call the postmodern/post-soul era. The 1970s brought in a significant rise in urban populations, and the number of poor almost doubled from that of the prior two decades for blacks and Latinos. Cities were growing, but not in a functional way. To understand this better, it’s necessary to take a brief look into what was happening in the prior two decades.
In the late 1950s and early 1960s the first wave of what would be called deindustrialization began to occur. Businesses began to find it more profitable to outsource their work, pay less in benefits, use cheaper labor, and ultimately generate larger profits for the shareholders. This adversely affected black and brown communities. A fragmentation of the middle class began to take place, and the number of people in poverty began to rise. The American economy was beginning to change, shifting from an industrial economy to one more focused on technology and highly skilled labor, which paid a lot more but required more specialized training and education. Because of sweeping and sometimes subtle discrimination in colleges, many blacks and Latinos found it difficult to compete with peers who had specialized degrees. The aerospace industry, for example, did not typically hire blacks. Moreover, if an applicant did not have the necessary training or pedigree, there was no point in applying. Todd Boyd notes, “We’re not talking about people who had careers. We’re talking about people who had jobs. If you have a job you are dependent on that job. So when that factory closes, you are in essence assed out.” By the late 1960s, most of those thriving factories had disappeared. In the wake of this loss, nothing was put into place for the thousands of workers now out of a job.
By 1968, with deindustrialization in full swing, many corporations left the United States to go to Mexico, India, and China. The once hopeful, growing, and generally enthusiastic black and Latino middle class was being systematically dismantled and began to crumble. The black generation born during the mid- to late 1960s was in worse financial and social shape than the preceding generations. These new generations were growing up without black leaders and visionaries such as Martin Luther King Jr., Bobby Seal, and Malcolm X. What’s more, there were very few programs that could handle and deal with the significant rise in black families who were jobless. To add insult to injury, many blacks—some who volunteered in search of work—were recruited into the army and went on to fight and die in the Vietnam War. During the height of the US involvement in Vietnam (1965–69), blacks, who formed only 11 percent of the population at that time, made up nearly 13 percent of the soldiers in Vietnam, with the majority serving in the infantry. Although some statistics are not precise, the percentage of black combat fatalities was roughly a staggering 15 percent.
On Thursday, March 10, 1975, eleven years after the height of the civil rights movement, an entire section of the Los Angeles Times, “A Ghetto Is Slow to Die,” was dedicated to this very real phenomena in the black community. John Kendall researched families and the economic structures from 1963 to 1975, stating, “The fearful live behind protective bars and double locks. High schools are graduating functional illiterates.” He also asserts that “little has changed in the basic conditions of the black ghetto in 10 years since the Watts riots erupted.” The article brings to light a sobering reality—one that did not offer a very promising future for anyone living in ghetto-like conditions, which principally meant blacks. Kendall continues by saying, “Some black people have got businesses; some professionals have gotten into significant jobs. But if you talk about the masses or that guy who was in trouble in ’65, it is more difficult now.” The social manifesto that so many black churches fought to create and instill was surmised in one word: survival.
In essence, once deindustrialization began and developed, large swatches of the black and Latino community lay in financial ruin. What little capital and access to education that blacks and Latinos had by the early 1960s began to wither away and create a distinct ghetto that was ripe with anger, people searching for answers, and an increasing disenfranchisement from the rest of American society. Combine that with police brutality (a fundamental element in the anger behind the Watts riots in 1963), racism within almost every system in America, and social structures that tended to see blacks and Latino youth as rebels, communists, and those “outside” American society, and you have a volatile mixture for social upheaval and shifting. Additionally, the young people who witnessed this societal shift would become the grandmothers and grandfathers of the first hip-hop generation. The 1970s ended with large, overcrowded ghettos and a lack of hope for many youth.
The 1980s did not present a better “America” for ethnic minorities living in urban conditions either. Unemployment, further disenfranchisement, and the rise of the suburban complex took place during this decade. “White flight,” as it came to be known, was the sign of affluence for those who could afford it, and the first wave of black and brown families began to emerge in the suburban context. This “moving up” within the social class system was reflected in television shows like The Cosby Show, The Fresh Prince of Bel Air, and even Different Strokes. Shows like these showcased educated black families living an idealized “American Dream” and also highlighted the increase in multiethnic families moving into suburban areas, giving white America its first transmediated glimpse into black America.
But by the 1990s urban renewal was a term synonymous with gentrification, and the inner city would once again change and shift. While not all “urban renewal” was detrimental to those who were poor and/or disenfranchised, the bulk of it displaced multitudes of families, many of whom were black and Latino. For example, the addition of the Staples Center in Los Angeles displaced over one thousand families living in that community, either through coerced placement or property tax increases, which left families, many of whom had owned homes in that area for three generations, without a home in a difficult rental market. The displaced families had little to no recourse as they did not have strong political networks or connections with civil lawyers. Moreover, many of these families were already living at or near the poverty line, so the cheaper place to move and live was the suburban context. Thus began the first wave of the suburban-urban blend. By the late 1990s many black, Latino, and lower-middle-class whites/Euro Americans saw themselves living in the suburban landscape, trying to survive. As inner cities were becoming transformed and “renewed,” the suburbs were beginning to change demographically, and few churches were prepared to receive these families, much less welcome and embrace them as their own.
The 2000s ushered in a new type of youth: the millennial. As Bakari Kitwana reminds us in his book, Why White Kids Love Hip Hop, the urban and black element of popular culture was a fascination for many white youth because it became a voice for them in their developmental years. The 2000s also saw the largest growth in ethnic minorities leaving cities because factors such as rent, cost of living, and education were more manageable in the suburbs. Further, suburban, white youth became enthralled by black popular culture—especially hip-hop—and suburban, white/Euro American youth welcomed the hip-hop cultural style from their newfound neighbors.
In the 2000s, according to Elizabeth Kneebone and Alan Berube, suburban poverty began to outgrow urban and inner city poverty. Furthermore, the color of poverty—which had primarily been a black and Latino urban issue—was and is now shifting. Many white, suburban, once upper-middle-class families are experiencing severe forms of poverty. The Census Bureau and The Department of Labor of Statistics reports that one in four children in America lives in poverty conditions, and many of those children do not live in what was once considered to be “the hood” or “bad parts” of town. They live in suburban cities like Lakewood City, Ohio, a suburb of Cleveland. In 2000, only 7 percent of its population lived below the poverty line; between 2008 and 2010 that number rose to 16 percent. Orange County, California, which is stereotypically mediatized as white, rich, and “well-off,” is one example of this trend. More than one-third of residents are ethnic Latino. Between 2000 and 2011 suburbs surrounding Seattle, Washington, saw a 79 percent increase in poverty; around Austin, Texas, a 143 percent increase; and around New York, a 27 percent increase. Couple that with how, in 2011, racial and ethnic minorities made up more than half of the US births in a twelve-month period, which ended in July of that year. While whites are still the dominant racial group in the United States, ethnic minorities are rapidly closing the gap at nearly 40 percent of the population. Our country, and therefore our ministry context, is clearly changing. But does our training, philosophy, theology, and social engagement reflect these changes? More important, are we as youth workers, pastors, educators, and practitioners able to respond to these demographic changes, especially in terms of how we think about and do youth ministry? Could we learn from our brothers and sisters in ethnic and urban communities “another way” of doing youth ministry?
In the next section of this chapter, I will assert the importance of multiethnic youth ministry as well as the main issues that underlie moving forward with valuing, engaging, and training a multiethnic generation of leaders and youth.
Adopting the Urban Multiethnic Youth Ministry in the Wild
The pastor friend of mine at the beginning of this chapter continued to struggle through his own issues regarding race, class, and the shifts needed in youth ministry. He and I met for a number of months and continue, to this day, to have some tough yet honest conversations about this subject. But I am proposing much more than a conversation—more than just a sidebar to your ministry. What I am proposing involves actual change. It is about embracing and adopting a multiethnic theology for youth ministry, diving into issues of race, class, and even gender to increase our love and care for those whom God loves and has called. Not everyone is prepared to think, much less to act, differently. The other pastor I mentioned earlier, who refused the offer of urban youth coming to serve his youth ministry, has not spoken to my friend in Seattle for almost five years, and his ministry continues to decline and struggle. The issues of multiculturalism and diversity are never easy to engage; we all have layers of hidden agendas, assumptions, and expectations that can derail our attempts to learn and grow. Further, the issues of race and ethnic identity are a phenomenon that the United States, at large, has yet to fully delve into as a social issue. But the gospel never called us to take the easy road. Jesus’s ministry was not one of ease and simplicity, and the apostles encountered many obstacles in spreading Christianity. Yet we often equate Christianity with safety, security, and comfort, compressed with the concept of “being blessed.” As the context of youth ministry continues to change, let us take a closer look at what this movement might involve in terms of an urban multiethnic ministry, especially as we seek to participate with God in adopting all those whom he calls as members of his family.
Three Suggestions for Change
What follows are three suggestions that I have found to be powerful agents of change in the advancement of urban, multiethnic youth ministry. As I wish to avoid the five-step process that is sometimes employed to “repair” the worldview problem rather than deal with it in its entirety, these suggestions stand as guideposts that have worked in a variety of contexts.
First, good intentions never work. Good intentions are just what they are: good intentions. While the intent may be noble, righteous, and principled, it is the effect that makes all the difference. Youth workers may feel they are doing a “good” work for the ethnic minority community of young people they are working among, but without knowing the real need of the community, they are perpetuating a form of destructive neocolonialism in that setting. If the leadership of a church, for example, is not willing to encourage or even allow leaders from an ethnic minority population to hold positions of power and influence, positive rhetoric and good intentions become meaningless. The intentions may themselves be biblical, yet without both a willingness to surrender their own ethnic power and better understand race and ethnic identity for themselves, they will only replicate their initial biases. This, then, perpetuates a white colonial model of ministry and an actual captivity of the gospel in terms of “right” and “acceptable” forms of doing ministry and theology. This is a barrier to the very idea of an urban and multiethnic youth ministry call. When one assumes that his or her racial, economic, or class-driven brand of the Christian faith is “the right way,” the power of the gospel is lessened and at times completely lost. To authentically serve Christ in today’s world, we in leadership must foster both an attitude and a theology by which we can honestly wrestle with how issues of race and class in the United States impact our life and ministry in the church. In that sense, it is strongly recommended that white youth leaders immerse themselves in opportunities to learn, grow, and, in many cases, repent. Excursions like Sankofa, which pairs up leaders from a variety of ethnic backgrounds as they tour museums and historical locations in the South, can provide the impetus for honest inquiry and faithful change. Experiences that bring God’s people together help to tear down walls, making it possible for us to move and work toward a biblical appreciation for much-needed racial reconciliation. We need to take an honest look at the issues of racism and classism as an urban multiethnic generation of young adults makes their way into the leadership of our churches and ministries.
Second, we must move beyond the great-white-hope mentality. This mentality paralyzes ethnic minorities because it places white/Euro Americans above and over “them” in terms of power, authority, and status. Privileged and racially unconscious white/Euro Americans tend to come to multiethnic relational and institutional settings from a stance of power and domination, usually without even realizing it. It stands to reason that this attitude and internal elitism carries itself into ministry settings, especially ones in which there is a “hero” role involved. While this tendency is not limited to white and Euro American leaders (the sin associated with the abuse of power knows no race or gender), it can be aggravated when the “hope” becomes that of a white, male, seminary-educated, heterosexual leader to “save” “those people” from whatever is defined as their need or sin.
Moreover, when key positions in ministry are not reflective of the community that is being served, then neocolonialism once again becomes the default and the “great white hope” is squarely placed on white leadership. Examples of this abound, even when people mean well. A renowned urban ministry in Southern California, for instance, has been in the Hollywood area for almost two decades. Because they do good work and ministry, they have gained national attention. And yet, in a predominantly black, Latino, and Asian community, their senior leadership remains primarily white/Euro American. This is but another example of the “great white hope” in action, even if the leadership cannot see it. “We,” meaning the white/Euro-American leadership, will “save you”; therefore the grip on power remains controlled by individuals who do not reflect the community. What is needed is a communal approach to engagement, an approach that says, “We are with you and we are on the journey with Christ together. In this way relationship and community can be built eye to eye and soul to soul rather than from a position of power.”
Third, we serve a multiethnic Jesus, so let us start representing that in the curriculum, teaching, and theologies of our youth ministries. For decades, urban, multiethnic youth have been subjected to the image and theological meme of a white, blond, blue-eyed Jesus who is ultimately foreign to them. James Cone tells us that there needs to be an image of a Jesus that is both relational and racially appealing to people; one that ethnic minorities in America can adjoin to; one that is socially aware of the struggles of blacks, Latinos, and all nondominant groups; and one that will have compassion on them because of their hardships. Rap artist and ghetto mystic Tupac Shakur took the ideology of the black Jesus a step further, talking about a Christ figure for the ghetto. A heaven for the thug. A Jesus for the poor, disinherited, and dislocated. A Jesus who did not live a “safe” life. An image of Jesus that moves against the Western norm of a Jesus who is white and therefore unrelatable. A Christ who is radical, at times angered, forceful, uses strong language, and yet is consistent and loving while maintaining his God status in a context of the urban environment.
For many, especially those living in the dominant Christian culture, this is a difficult image of Jesus to comprehend. This is not the traditional form of Jesus found in Christian bookstores and on church walls. For many Christians—including many other evangelical Christians—this image is simply too irreverent and sacrilegious. Yet this is a vital contextual and theological discourse for those who seek to bear witness to the God who has made himself known and is therefore relatable to any people group—particularly those who are seeking a church in the wild. The image of a radical, activist, multiethnic Jesus who connects with the downtrodden, the sick, and the person in pain is the Jesus who, as the opening chapter of Matthew reveals, was and is a multiethnic Messiah—for two reasons. First, his lineage is an example of the diversity within the human genome, and second, God created us in his image, and that image encompasses every expression of humanity. Clearly, then, our ministries should reflect at least an appreciation of and unity in that diversity. Thus, we need an engagement with the Jesus of Scripture and his multiethnic heritage; we need to move away from the domesticated and theologically incomplete image by which he is all too commonly known. A new theological pathway is waiting to be discovered and carved out for those who are willing to take the challenge of adopting an urban multiethnic youth ministry in the wild.
Conclusion
There is much work before us, and the rise of urban, multiethnic students will continue in the future. It is imperative that we move out of our comfort zones and into the realness of what youth ministry is becoming. As Soong-Chan Rah reminds us,
We face a challenging reality. We live under the reality of the oppression of the Western, white captivity of the church. We may claim that our version of evangelicalism is culture-free, that we are merely trying to be culturally relevant, or that we are trying to maintain the church’s tradition, and thereby ultimately reject the claim of cultural captivity. But, the reality of the situation is that Western, white culture dominates American culture and, in turn, dominates American evangelicalism.
Rah challenges us to move past this sobering reality. Recognizing and addressing these realities will help us to engage with the family of God and work alongside urban and multiethnic youth ministries to incorporate, at least at some level, these new ways of thinking about and doing youth ministry in any context.
This chapter represents only a basic primer of the complexity and depth of the issues we face in today’s society. My purpose has not been to fully address in depth the various issues we must work through as we seek to live together as brothers and sisters in God’s family. Even though I have only scratched the surface of such issues as intercultural communication, diversity competencies, gender issues, and our historical understanding and methods of youth ministry, my intent has been to start you on the road to awareness and action as you lead and love young people in the body of Christ. Each of these areas needs our dedicated attention, but we need to recognize immediately that the infusion of multiethnic youth and emerging adults is upon us in every setting, church, and ministry. We can no longer ignore this demographic shift or the church’s historical biases and injustices. The future of youth ministry, and indeed the church as we know it, rests on our ability and willingness to cast new vision, empower men and women of diverse backgrounds and communities to use their gifts, and see ourselves as siblings of one Father and one family. To be a church in the wild challenges us to deal with the issues and struggles that divide us and disempower the diverse gifts and hearts of the body. As my friend discovered at camp that weekend, we can no longer blame the kids or the culture. The day has come to rather grab one another by the hand and work together to heal the church.
