Chapter 10 of 31

5. Screen Time

5. Screen Time

5

Screen Time

A Window into Teens’ Dreams

CRAIG DETWEILER

There is no one like Craig Detweiler. He is a first-rate thinker, filmmaker, scholar, teacher, and passionate advocate for justice and integrity. We consider Detweiler one of the most important voices in the national discussion on the intersection of pop culture and theology. Detweiler, a PhD theologian who lives in Malibu, California, is widely respected in Hollywood and in film schools around the world. His voice is an important one, and we are grateful to have him as an author in Adoptive Youth Ministry.

I first got to know Detweiler when we were on the team facilitating a youth leadership program cosponsored by Young Life and Fuller Theological Seminary and funded by the Lilly Endowment. His role was to help our young prodigies wrestle with and integrate their understanding of the Christian faith with the rich texture of popular culture, mostly experienced through film. When he showed the film Dogma (starring George Carlin as Cardinal Glick) to our first-year class of Young Life high school juniors who had been nominated as “student leaders,” I remember the somewhat heated and profoundly impressive conversation with a few of us in the hallway. Detweiler was convincing, but only because he knew what we had yet to discover—film reflects us and often reflects God in ways that most people fail to recognize. Using film to expose the underbelly of cultural faith and helping teenagers discuss movies and thereby see and experience God in new and deeper ways is Detweiler’s greatest gift; he is a faithful, honest, insightful, and highly gifted facilitator. This chapter, which weaves together a convincing tapestry of cultural observation and examples of God shining through a variety of creative expression, is quintessential Detweiler; you are in for a treat.

As with many of the chapters in Adoptive Youth Ministry, this chapter does not overtly point to participating in adoption as the ultimate goal of all ministry, especially ministry to the young. He seeks a deeper engagement with society and with our God, inviting us to bring that into our ministries. As we do and as we explore what Detweiler shares with us, it is our job to find ways to bring adults and the young together so that we can, as siblings and regardless of our ages or backgrounds, explore our society together in the interests of the mission of God in the world (“thy kingdom come, thy will be done”).

As you read this chapter, consider these questions:

  • How can “pop culture” be a “conduit for God’s general revelation”? What is Detweiler’s point when he describes popular culture as a way God communicates with the world he loves?
  • When you were in high school, did your parents watch what you watched? Were they interested in being students of your culture and world? What was your interaction like with your parents regarding television, video games, movies, the phone, and the internet?
  • Detweiler spends a great deal of time in Acts 8. Look carefully at this text, and consider what is he saying about our interaction with popular culture and society in the name of Christ. What are some tangible ways to engage in today’s society?
  • Why do you watch what you watch? Think of a recent movie you saw that some in your church might be critical of. What drew you to that film? How did it make you feel? What did it say to you and say about you? Do the same with a favorite television show or band/song.
  • Years before Facebook started asking us to list our favorite movies, music, and shows as a way to define ourselves, I would ask my college students about what stories spoke to them. What was their all-time favorite film? For many years, two consistent answers emerged. The guys’ favorite film tended to be Se7en (1995). The women in my film classes loved Pretty Woman (1990). I found these answers frightening and fascinating, particularly given the demographic I was teaching. These were students from Christian colleges and universities who chose to pursue a semester in Hollywood at the Los Angeles Film Studies Center. These were the most media-savvy students from Christian college campuses, and their all-time favorite films were about a serial killer enacting the seven deadly sins on his victims and a romance/fantasy about a hooker who wins over a corporate raider.

    Were the students suffering from a slippery rather than a sticky faith? These sounded like half-baked, “almost Christian” responses devoid of a thoughtful ethic regarding entertainment. While the inclination may have been to shout “What?!” I decided to adopt a posture asking “Why?” Why did these R-rated stories speak into these students’ lives? Could seemingly disposable pop culture become a conduit for God’s general revelation? And if so, how could I learn to listen carefully to pop culture?

    Perhaps my students had been so sheltered in their upbringing that they found the horrors of Se7en sobering, a disturbing wake-up call about the depths of evil. Maybe director David Fincher’s vision was so visually arresting that they couldn’t resist its dark, nihilistic allure. What if they were drawn to Se7en because it illustrated the wages of sin that they heard so much about but hadn’t dared to test? In this case, Se7en became a remarkable cautionary tale, a visceral warning. These messy, repellant images may have approximated the impact of Jonathan Edwards’s famous sermon, “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God.”

    What about Pretty Woman? Julia Roberts’s iconic role was rooted in her considerable charm and easy laugh. It was fun watching her undercut the snooty attitudes of those Rodeo Drive salespeople who judged her. Had Cinderella stories been so normalized for young Christian women that they found Pretty Woman’s journey from prostitute to trophy wife enlivening? Or did the women in my class find the love of Richard Gere for a woman of ill repute remarkably affirming and biblical? Hadn’t Hosea married a prostitute as a prophetic act? Didn’t Jesus undercut the Pharisees’ judgment by inviting them to cast the first stone of aspersion at a woman in similar circumstances? Maybe Pretty Woman actually reflected Jesus’s enduring love for us, despite our self-denigrating actions.

    Whatever the reasons for the students’ pop cultural attachments, the roots of their fandom may be far more spiritual than we or they realize. In studying what they watch, we may uncover students’ hopes and dreams and nightmares. By engaging in deep, empathetic listening, we may find points of connection for Bible studies, sermons, and counseling situations. Pop culture burrows into teens’ hearts and minds in ways that sermons or Sunday school may never touch. So I’d rather start from that soft, soulful space than try to work from my agenda to their passions.

    I study adolescents’ cinematic inspirations because a profane, violent R-rated film transformed my teenage years and accelerated my spiritual search. As a high school senior, I was scared straight by Raging Bull, an uncompromising portrait of self-destructive World Middleweight Champion Jake LaMotta. I felt many connections with how this boxer cut himself off from friends and family, shunning the brother and wife who loved and supported him. Even as an angry young man, I didn’t want to end up like Jake, alone and in a jail cell, banging my head against a wall and shouting, “Why? Why? Why?” When the movie ended and the credits rolled, Raging Bull hooked me with the seemingly obscure conclusion, “All I know is this: once I was blind and now I can see.” I didn’t know at the time that it was drawn from John 9:25, but I inherently sensed it was true. I had watched a brutal two-hour portrait of blindness that opened my eyes. The talks I’d heard at Young Life about a personal relationship with Jesus Christ suddenly took on a new urgency and appeal. Six months later at Young Life’s camp Windy Gap, I committed all I knew of myself to all I understood about Jesus. It was a revelatory, life-giving turning point.

    How can God use profane pop culture to spark sacred searches? This question has dominated my work as a youth minister, a filmmaker, an author, and an educator. I have invested years of study into general revelation, natural theology, and the power of God to use talking donkeys and mere stones to speak. From Braveheart to Bruce Almighty, I compiled stories of how movies moved people from despair toward hope. Real-life role models in The Blind Side and fantastical heroes in The Book of Eli model the power of faith to transform lives. Television series like Lost invited us to consider the divergent values of faith versus science (the whole of Psalm 23 was recited on Lost during prime time). Religious questions that were rare in the era of Touched by an Angel have become commonplace on shows that range from Bones to Glee.

    As a parent of two teenagers, I watch what they watch. But I want to do more than monitor the content they consume to check for inappropriate words or scenes. I want to potentially help them find God amid all the electronic inputs. The Kaiser Family Foundation reported that American kids ingest almost eleven hours of media content every single day (with the amount rising annually via multitasking). Is that time away from God, removed from divine influence? If so, then heaven help us all. Given our kids’ limited time in Sunday school or youth group, I hope and pray that God might speak through their extensive screen time. Their playlists are a window into their worries. Their favorites may form a picture of their passions or aspirations. I want to watch and listen carefully.

    My fourteen-year-old daughter’s favorite television show was Glee. It was an unabashed celebration of outsiders, the Gleeks who occupy school bands and choruses and clubs. The Fox show’s creators turned even the most painful high schoolers’ questions of identity into an opportunity to burst into song. My daughter’s favorite character was Blaine, a gay teenager engaged in a fairly intense romance with Kurt, the talented soloist and central protagonist of the series. Why did she have such a rooting interest in Blaine and Kurt? Why did she resonate with their songs? Listening to pop culture is far more than an academic exercise. It is central to my calling as an educator, a screenwriter, and a parent.

    Biblical Models for Pop Cultural Plunges

    Who can teach us how to come alongside our students’ or our children’s spiritual search? Who models cultural engagement in the Scriptures? The incarnation is the paramount example of entering into others’ shoes. In The Message, Eugene Peterson translates John 1:14 as “The Word became flesh and blood, and moved into the neighborhood.” Jesus literally stepped into our situation. His public ministry occurred in the marketplace. It was rooted in compassion. When I see students walking past one another, staring at their smartphones, scrolling for updates, I recall that when Jesus “saw the crowds, he had compassion on them, because they were harassed and helpless, like sheep without a shepherd” (Matt. 9:36).

    In Acts 17, we find Paul engaging in public debates in the marketplace of Mars Hill. He studies the Athenians’ cultural artifacts as an entry into gospel proclamation, connecting what they have made for an Unknown God to the God revealed in Jesus Christ. He quotes from popular Greek poetry as both a bridge from their thinking to his thinking and as a point of contrast. Jesus engaged in the same shift when he declared in the Beatitudes, “You have heard that it was said . . . but I tell you” (Matt. 5:21–22). He raises the stakes of discipleship by building upon the things people already know, discuss, and embrace. Careful listening and familiarity with the lingua franca, the language of the day, precedes effective proclamation.

    In studying the Scriptures, I found the first cross-cultural Christian was actually Philip in Acts 8. He was on the run, fleeing persecution in Jerusalem, when he headed toward Samaria. As an outsider and exile, he was able to communicate with a marginalized community. An angel told Philip to head south toward Gaza. Perhaps his experience in a foreign land enabled Philip to receive the angel’s instructions more clearly. We often think we need to be in a place of safety, security, or peace to find God’s call. But the unfamiliar surroundings in Acts show us that a place where we are challenged or off-kilter may sharpen our spiritual antennae.

    Philip encounters an Ethiopian eunuch who had gone to Jerusalem to worship. While the eunuch may have longed to serve the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, his ethnicity and especially his physical alteration would have prevented him from entering the holy temple. The removal of his sexual organs ensured that he was not a threat to the queen he served. Yet it also separated him from the purity codes observed by God’s people according to the Torah. The eunuch’s spiritual hunger had not been satisfied.

    The Spirit instructed Philip to go to the chariot, where he heard the man reading from the book of Isaiah. Their exchange is a model for how we may dream our evangelistic endeavors will unfold. As Philip approaches, a spiritual search is already under way. Philip asks a simple question, “Do you understand what you’re reading?” In Greek, you hear the wordplay, “ginoskeis ha anaginoskeis?” The difference between reading and understanding (just an ana-) is small but significant. We may challenge students in youth group to read the Bible. But all too often they lack sufficient background or context to unpack the powerful implications. The same could be said for their favorite pop cultural plunges. They know when they love a movie or a show, but they may not fully grasp why it pierces their heart or expresses their deepest longings. Seeing, they may not see. Reading, they may not understand.

    The Ethiopian eunuch answers Philip’s question with a question, “How can I (understand) unless someone guides me?” Eugene Peterson notes the subtle but significant difference between an invitation to explain and an invitation to guide. Both words are rooted in the Greek verb “to lead.” Peterson distinguishes how “the explainer, the exegete, leads the meaning out of the text; the guide, the hodegete, leads you in the way (hodos) of the text.” Drawing on his years in ministry, Peterson suggests, “Pastoral-biblical hermeneutics presupposes exegesis but involves more. The African invites Philip into the chariot to accompany him as his guide. This is going to take some time. . . . Philip decides on hodegesis. He climbs into the chariot and shares the journey.” This is youth ministry at its best. It starts by getting in step with God, following the Spirit’s lead. It expands by paying attention to what the Ethiopian eunuch is already reading (or watching or texting). It gets deeper when we’re invited into their world, to accompany them on the journey. Philip’s story provides us with a sound ministry method: listen to the Spirit, listen to what people are listening to, and get invited to guide their understanding of God’s ways. Surely we can all practice the art of listening and ask the simple question, “Do you understand what you’re reading, watching, or listening to?”

    Why We Watch What We Watch

    Our pop cultural habits reflect our passions, interests, and needs. Our favorite shows offer something we need—from surrogate friends and family to a laugh or a cry. When my children were young, Winnie the Pooh served as a calm, comforting friend. In elementary school, The Suite Life of Zach and Cody offered a silly alternative to their constricting classrooms. In adolescence, Supernatural enabled my daughter to deal with dark forces that she couldn’t always name or explain. It exposed her to the scary and wondrous reality of the ineffable. The summer she watched eight seasons of How I Met Your Mother on Netflix coincided with confounding mating rituals. While not every relationship needs an intervention and their Bro Code doesn’t always work, she was able to gain perspective on her own romantic entanglements via the comedic spouse seeking portrayed on the show. Glee offered a space to wrestle with myriad adolescent issues, from teen pregnancy to sexual identity. The characters learn to embrace their otherness, to find a place in the world as an artist or creative force (both in high school and beyond).

    We turn to pop culture when we can’t quite name our dilemmas. We may go to the movies as a way to buy time. It holds our demons at bay for a couple of hours. It offers some distance or perspective, a chance to worry about somebody else’s quandaries. The best films and television series offer a vicarious experience where we can enter into the suffering of another and perhaps gain control or mastery over our own struggles. Surely, Jesus offers the most vicarious example of taking on our suffering, entering into our world and our pain.

    Pop culture invites us to identify with a character. It is an opportunity to see ourselves in someone else’s story—both our siblings in God’s household and those whom we are called to love—and step into their struggles. The film or show might be aspirational (like the teens overcoming the odds in The Hunger Games, Harry Potter, or even Pretty in Pink and Ferris Bueller’s Day Off). These Hollywood stories offer happy endings and reassurance. Independent films offer darker, more cautionary tales, such as The Perks of Being a Wallflower, Garden State, Fruitvale Station, and Short Term 12. These are hard-won hopes that may leave viewers more disturbed than when they arrived.

    The arc of pop cultural icons can also serve as instructive stories. Tweens who grew up watching Hannah Montana are confronted by the outrageous habits of an older, saucier Miley Cyrus. Those who once idolized Britney Spears or Justin Bieber may find their faith in their teen idols tested. What used to be pure and simple may look much grainier in later adolescence. Twenty-somethings are only starting to put their faith to the test. They can potentially avoid making the same mistakes as their fallen idols, or they can slide into the same prolonged adolescence. Conforming one’s convictions and behavior takes a long time and continues into later adolescence (aka the twenties).

    Youth ministry must be thought of as something that extends far beyond high school or college. Following the arc of both fictional characters and tabloid celebrities is a way to talk about hard choices and bad decisions. The travails of former teen stars illustrate how tough the transition to adulthood can be. More freedom also means more temptation. Discussions of the arrested development of a Lindsay Lohan or Justin Bieber may prove a far more effective springboard than a Bible study leader imagines. When Cory Monteith of Glee died from a drug overdose, his fans were forced to wrestle with addiction, mortality, and the consequences of actions. A special episode of Glee offered the characters (and the audience) an opportunity to grieve. Hopefully, adolescents will also learn from the comebacks of Demi Lovato, who struggled with eating disorders, or Robert Downey Jr.’s recovery from substance abuse.

    Pop culture often takes us places we haven’t been. Film noir like Memento or The Dark Knight may take us to scary places we don’t want to dwell in. Horror films like The Exorcism of Emily Rose and Sinister offer a safe way to wrestle with literal demons. From fantasies like Lord of the Rings and Harry Potter to science fiction like Star Wars and Star Trek, movies can open up vistas and possibilities we have never imagined. It can expand our vision. Documentaries may raise our awareness of communities in crisis and deepen our hunger for justice. The intensity of the movement that arose from Invisible Children and the subsequent YouTube campaign, “Kony 2012,” caught even its creators by surprise. My daughter has been challenged toward a healthier diet by documentaries like Super Size Me. Fifth graders in our community protested a class field trip to Sea World after seeing the plight of orcas in Blackfish. Independent films made outside the Hollywood system will often afflict the comfortable with a prophetic edge.

    Television traditionally offers comfort. Sitcoms like Cheers center on a bar where everybody knows your name. The formulaic nature of television formats offers up familiar feelings (and repetitive patterns), from the warmth of Modern Family to the procedures on Law & Order and CSI. As more channels compete for our fragmented attention, reality television often depends on outrageous personalities and behavior. It is a form of shock TV rooted in titillation. Television is increasingly taking us to disturbing places we haven’t been, inviting us inside the mind of a serial killer like Dexter or meth dealers like Walt and Jessie on Breaking Bad. As youth ministers compete for teens’ limited attention, we may be tempted to take teens to places they have never been rather than creating a comfortable space. It is tough to compete with $200 million entertainments laden with special effects. I do not suggest that youth ministers attempt to compete with pop culture via various stunts. Perhaps we need to recover the comforts and familiarity of beloved television shows; a safe space where everybody knows your name can be a great gift to harried teens.

    YouTube is a boundless resource for both oddities and familiarities. Viral videos arrive via strange and unexpected found footage. The outrageous and outlandish often pop out from the crowd. We can subscribe to YouTube stars who look/think/act like us. Popular channels are often built upon direct address—adolescents talking to one another, building an audience of peers; followers become a surrogate family. From writing a song to just putting our feelings out there, YouTube promotes the feeling that we are not alone. Pop culture allows us to process our pain via solidarity. Whether through traditional media outlets or the burgeoning world of social media, YouTube, Vimeo, or Vine, teens find comfort and refuge in screen time.

    “Grilled Cheesus”: A Case Study

    Glee tackled faith and doubt in an episode that series creator Ryan Murphy predicted “would be our most controversial yet.” “Grilled Cheesus” premiered October 5, 2010, and attracted an audience of over 11 million viewers in the United States alone, the highest rated scripted program for the week among viewers aged eighteen to forty-five. The copresident of the New Directions glee club, Finn Hudson, is shocked to discover the face of Jesus on his grilled cheese sandwich. Although he’s not the most religious person (“he sort of worships Eric Clapton and Chad Ochocinco”), Finn takes this appearance as a sign and decides to pray. He kneels before the sandwich and asks “Grilled Cheesus” to please let the McKinley High football team win its first game. In return, he offers to “make sure we honor you this week in glee club.” The episode is about why we pray, what kind of bargaining we do with God, and how we respond when our prayers are or aren’t answered. It begins with an incidence of general revelation and unfurls in all kinds of unexpected ways.

    “Grilled Cheesus” also deals with questions of religious liberty, particularly what is allowable in a public school setting. Does singing religious songs in Mr. Schuester’s classroom violate the separation of church and state? When Finn suggests the glee club “pay tribute to Jesus” in music, students like Kurt Hummel resist: “Sorry, but if I wanted to sing about Jesus, I’d go to church, and the reason I don’t go to church is because most churches don’t think very much about gay people or women or science.” Mercedes, an African American student with Christian convictions, retorts, “I don’t see anything wrong with getting a little church up in here.” Throughout the episode, the producers of Glee go to great lengths to ensure that every attack on religion is followed by an affirmation of faith; each salute to the Divine is met by a skeptic’s objection. The show mirrors the cultural tension between Christians and atheists who continue to argue about how much religious expression is allowable in the public square. Are we promised freedom of religion or freedom from religion?

    Having rallied the New Directions glee club to sing songs for Jesus, Finn returns to the sandwich with an additional request. He admits, “I didn’t go to Sunday school, so I don’t know if God works the same as a genie and I only get three wishes, but here’s the thing . . .”: Finn wants to get to second base with his girlfriend, Rachel. He makes a deal with God: “Considering that I’ve devoted a week of my musical life to you, I hope that you can see it in your heart to answer my prayers. Amen.” While such reasoning may seem absurd, it is not too far from the type of magical thinking used by many adolescents. In what has been famously termed “Moralistic Therapeutic Deism,” many students perceive faith as being a pretty good person in order to please a fairly remote deity. Religion is seen as a merit system in which God rewards good behavior. They may see success in life as an appropriate gift commensurate to their faithfulness.

    Beyond Finn’s deal making with Grilled Cheesus, the efficacy of prayers is tested in a sensitive, life-threatening situation. When Kurt’s father has a heart attack, Kurt’s friends and teachers rally around him in the hospital room. With Burt Hummel hooked up to tubes and monitors in the hospital, Kurt seeks a sign of life, but his father fails to squeeze his hand. Back at school, Mr. Schuester says, “Our thoughts are all with Kurt.” Mercedes sings a gospel song about “being in a very dark place and turning to God,” Whitney Houston’s hit “I Look to You.” While Kurt appreciates her musical gift, he admits he is an atheist who doesn’t believe in God. He thinks, “God is kinda like Santa Claus for adults.” (Certainly that’s how Finn has approached “the Cheesy Lord.”) Kurt also sees God as kind of a jerk, especially for making him gay and then having Christians tell him it’s something he chose, “as if someone would choose to be mocked every day of their life.” The scene reflects the ongoing cultural tensions swirling around gay rights, gay marriage, and some Christians’ responses. Kurt tells his friends, “I appreciate your thoughts, but I don’t want your prayers.” He walks out of the class.

    The nemesis of the glee club, cheerleading adviser Sue Sylvester, goads Kurt into filing a formal complaint with the school board. Haven’t his rights been violated by religious intrusions in Mr. Schuester’s classroom? The guidance counselor, Emma (who is also Mr. Schuester’s girlfriend), is furious. Emma bursts into Sue’s office and asks, “What happened to you, Sue, that made you such a miserable tyrant?” In perhaps the most vulnerable scene in Sue’s bombastic history on Glee, she talks about her childhood hero, her big sister, Jean. Sue recalls the cruel things that others said about Jean, mocking her Down syndrome. Sue tells Emma, “I prayed every night for her to get better and nothing changed. So I prayed harder and after a while I realized it wasn’t that I wasn’t praying hard enough. It was that no one was listening.” Earnest, unanswered prayers can turn into doubt and even bitterness. Sue comes to see that “asking someone to believe in a fantasy, however comforting, isn’t a moral thing to do. It’s cruel.” She cannot reconcile a loving God with her sister’s unchanging condition.

    Here is the crux of the entire episode. While it may be tempting to see the show as mocking religion (via Jesus’s face on grilled cheese) or advocating for gay rights (through Kurt’s speeches), a deeper, core question slowly emerges. Those engaged in empathetic listening will recognize that objections to faith are usually rooted in far more painful, personal issues. We may respond too quickly to surface objections and never get to deeper issues of doubt. As Philip paused beside the Ethiopian eunuch’s chariot, so we have an opportunity to listen in to ancient questions reposed for twenty-first-century teens. Several core questions lie beneath all of Glee’s jokes, songs, and political posturing: “Why doesn’t God answer my prayers?” “How can I believe in God amid all the suffering (in my life, in my family, in the world)?” “Grilled Cheesus” is about far more than how gay people have been treated by Christians. It raises timeless questions of theodicy, how to reconcile a good God with a cruel world. Glee reveals how a young, hopeful, and faith-filled Sue Sylvester slowly became the angry, volatile, and scheming Coach Sue. Show creator Ryan Murphy summarizes the situation: “Sue’s an atheist, but I love that she doesn’t want to be. . . . She and [Kurt] are both saying to the world, ‘Prove us wrong: If God is kindness and love, make me believe in God.’” This is the challenge of theodicy: explaining how a loving God can preside over a fallen and broken universe. It is a blatant cry for meaning, for hope, and for answers. Murphy calls it “the scene I’m most proud to have been involved with in my entire career.”

    We will often find these enduring problems of theodicy expressed in Psalms and in contemporary pop songs. As with the best musicals, Glee’s songs express characters’ feelings and advance the story line. In the center of the episode, Rachel lights a candle and sings Barbara Streisand’s hit “Papa, Can You Hear Me?” from Yentl. It is a highly particular and appropriate expression of Jewish faith and devotion. In the hospital, Rachel, Quinn, and Mercedes take turns praying for Kurt’s father. Yet, when Kurt discovers them, he is offended by their actions. He has brought a Sikh to apply acupuncture to improve circulation in Burt’s brain. Kurt mocks their prayers: “Amazingly, needles pierce the skin better than Psalms.” What makes Kurt so curt with his friends, so bitter toward God and resistant to prayer?

    Before Mr. Schuester’s class Kurt admits, “I need to express myself.” He reflects on his mother’s funeral, when they were lowering her body into the ground, and he was crying. He goes to his life moment of the greatest pain, confusion, and crisis. Kurt remembers the assurance that came from his father squeezing his hand: “Knowing that those hands were there to take care of me, that was enough.” He sings the Beatles’ “I Want to Hold Your Hand” for his father, turning a song rooted in romance into a prayer for healing. This is the kind of deep listening that pop culture (at its best) invites. An adolescent in crisis may interpret a show or a film in ways that the creators never intended. Our job is to figure out why that pop cultural form speaks so profoundly to their hearts. While Kurt sings, the class falls silent. Flashbacks to a young Kurt, learning to ride a bicycle with his father’s help, provide a poignant glimpse into his backstory. Father and son engage in a tea party, with a young Kurt teaching his dad the proper protocol. It is clearly suggested that Kurt’s gay identity was forming from an early age. The flashbacks conclude at the funeral, where Kurt’s father reaches back and grabs Kurt’s hand, offering comfort and reassurance in his hour of deepest need. The song concludes with Kurt (and the class) in tears. In Kurt’s deepest existential crisis, he found comfort not in God but in his father’s hand. With his father potentially dying, Kurt cannot take comfort in his friends’ prayers (or God). By listening to Kurt’s song, we see where his faith resides (in his father’s hands) and why even that hope is now being threatened and undermined.

    After class, Mercedes reaches out and challenges him not to cut himself off from “a world of experiences that might surprise you.” She says to him, “Do me a favor. One thing: come to church with me this Sunday.” They have dedicated their upcoming Sunday worship service to Kurt’s dad. Kurt agrees to attend even if worship is just genuflecting to “the Great Spaghetti Monster in the Sky.” Mercedes asks the church to direct their prayers toward Burt Hummel and to her friend Kurt. She acknowledges his unbelief but challenges him to believe in something more “because life is too hard to go through it alone, without something to hold on to, and without something that’s sacred.” Mercedes dedicates a rousing gospel version of “Bridge over Troubled Water” to Kurt. Here we see a common and lovely Christian response to a friend in crisis. Perhaps he cannot pray, but the body of Christ, as a caring community, still seeks to surround him with love and support, adopting him as one of their own.

    Finn’s quick conversion is followed by an equally fast renunciation of faith. He bows down in the locker room for a third prayer and asks for another favor. Finn prays that he will become the starting quarterback again. He reasons, “I can deliver your message to the world more powerfully if I’m the most popular guy in the school again.” Having lived and worked in Hollywood for years, I have heard many versions of this prayer—from athletes, politicians, and entertainers. We vow to praise God if and when we are lifted up: “Make me rich, famous, and powerful and I will shout your name across media formats.” It echoes the deal that Salieri tries to strike with God in the Oscar-winning drama Amadeus (1984). As a dedicated Christian, Salieri promises to praise God through his songs. And yet he wonders what kind of capricious God would lavish far more profound musical gifts on a lewd, faithless fop like Mozart. Instead of praising God’s gifts revealed through Mozart, Salieri turns bitter and vows to destroy his musical rival. When we make deals with God that fail to unfold according to the terms we have outlined, our faith can quickly devolve into doubt, anger, or even revenge.

    Finn’s prayers are seemingly answered when the starting quarterback, Sam, gets injured in the game. This outcome seems rather twisted to Finn. Feelings of guilt and confusion prompt him to confess to the guidance counselor. He feels terrible about Sam being injured because of his prayers. But Emma explains that Finn’s prayers toward a grilled cheese sandwich didn’t result in divine intervention, saying, “You didn’t hurt Sam,” and “God didn’t let you touch Rachel’s boobs, Rachel did.” Emma reframes Finn’s nascent theology, telling him, “God works in all kinds of mysterious ways, but I’m pretty sure he doesn’t spend a lot of time trying to speak to us through sandwiches.” There is general revelation, but there is also foolish attribution or misguided deal making with the divine. Finn is disappointed; he thought he had a direct line to God. He doesn’t want to feel like everybody else, like he’s just floating around through space. He responds to his shattered view of God as genie with an angry version of REM’s hit song, “Losing My Religion.” He identifies with Kurt’s doubt. In a defiant, direct address to God, he sings/shouts, “I thought that I heard you laughing / I thought that I heard you sing,” but it turns out, “That was just a dream / Just a dream.” He tells the class, “I used to think God was up there looking over me. Now I’m not so sure.”

    Are we meant to see Finn’s entire experience as foolish and comic? Two concluding scenes suggest where the producers’ intentions reside. Sue plays chess with her big sister, Jean. Sue asks Jean whether she believes in God. While Sue holds fast to her atheism, which is rooted in the world’s cruel behavior toward her sister, Jean says, “God never makes mistakes. That’s what I believe.” Jean asks, “Want me to pray for you, Sue?” Sue replies, “That would be nice.”

    After his church experience, Kurt talks to his still-comatose father. He admits his mistakes: “I should have let those guys pray for you.” Through tears he says, “I don’t believe in God, Dad. But I believe in you. And I believe in us. You and me, that’s what’s sacred to me. And I’m . . . I’m so sorry that I never got to tell you that.” As Burt’s finger begins to move, Kurt springs to his feet. Tears of sorrow shift into tears of joy and relief. He may not have been uttering a prayer, but his hopes are answered with this sign of life.

    As always, the episode concludes with a song. The New Directions sing Joan Osborne’s 1996 hit, “One of Us.” It asks a series of timeless theological questions like “If God had a name, what would it be?” and “What would you ask if you had just one question?” before the chorus ponders, “What if God was one of us?” In the audience, Mr. Schuester and Sue listen to the choir. He wonders whether she will press the issue of a religious song being performed by the students at a public school: “Will you get me fired? Will you report me?” Listening to the song with a furrowed brow, Sue answers with a simple “No.” The church/state question has been put aside for now. Finn finishes eating his grilled cheesus sandwich. He no longer preserves it as a magic totem. The unexpected appearance of Jesus that sparked his short-lived faith has been devoured.

    Did the producers try to make our search for God look ridiculous? Were they mocking those moments when we try to find the face of God in a cloud (or a sandwich)? Ryan Murphy admits they played the Cheesy Lord for laughs but that “you read stories about it every week. People see the face of God in, like, bird droppings or corn flakes. To me, what that says is that in our society right now, people are just so desperate to believe in something.” Cocreator Ian Brennan described the episode as “a very honest take on how we think about religion today.” When thinking about Glee’s youthful audience, Brennan said, “Some of the kids don’t know yet what they believe.” Murphy reflected on his own religious upbringing (quite similar to Kurt’s) as a gay teenager in Ohio. He told TV Guide, “I do believe in God,” adding, “I think religion gave me great structure and discipline and order. . . . The older I get the more I feel like God is a collective good. I think that’s what the episode is saying. That’s what all these kids are desperately trying to find in their lives.” Surely youth workers can find points of connection with such an earnest search. Murphy acknowledged his overriding goal with Glee: “I wish there had been something to launch conversations about feelings and emotions in my household when I was younger.” Murphy concludes, “When the show is at its best, that is what I think we’re doing.”

    Considering Contexts

    Would I recommend that youth ministers show the “Grilled Cheesus” episode to their teens? Not necessarily. Every city, school, church, country, and culture has particular sensitivities and interests. What sparks a conversation in one setting may shut down discussion in a different context. By following Philip’s lead in listening carefully to what students (and their parents) are watching and discussing, youth leaders can discern what shows and what theological questions are bubbling to the surface. Denominational concerns may make a show like Glee too incendiary in particular settings. Yet in churches that are already asking teenage members to vote regarding denominational ties, this episode of Glee may offer a way to wade into contentious issues. I would recommend that youth ministers watch the episode regardless of their particular feelings about gay marriage and denominational divides. Watching what our adoptive siblings watch does not mean we necessarily agree with or even endorse the beliefs and practices of Hollywood. We engage pop cultural activities in order to have a deeper understanding of and humble discernment toward teens’ proclivities. “Grilled Cheesus” raises issues that extend far beyond political flashpoints. Questions of theodicy follow in the wake of deaths from cancer, car wrecks, and natural disasters. Teens seeking to make sense of the world will invariably find their childhood faith challenged by real-world situations. The producers of Glee may be asking questions parents and youth workers might not be prepared to deal with, but if pop culture has raised the question, then our teens are already wrestling with the theological implications of pain, suffering, and death. Teens need caring adults and role models to come alongside their questions, to see what they’re watching, thinking, and feeling. Like the eunuch, adolescents may desperately need someone to explain it to them.

    Engagement with pop culture has traditionally diverged along denominational lines. With more churches opting for nondenominational status, how might a youth minister discern what is timely, appropriate, and wise to watch? H. Richard Niebuhr provided an insightful survey of historic theological responses in his classic, Christ and Culture. Protestants tend to vacillate between avoiding pop culture whenever possible to justifying movie watching for the sake of ministry. In his seminal book, Reel Spirituality, Robert K. Johnston describes these positions as Avoidance, Caution, and Dialogue. Sacramental traditions (Catholic, Orthodox, Episcopalian) tend to view Christ as “of” or “above” culture. They may focus less on how much sex, violence, or profanity occurs in a pop cultural form than the overriding theme or values expressed in the picture or show. While some may avoid watching Glee because of the homosexual characters who express their disgust with the church, other Christians may find it offers moments of “divine encounter” in which God speaks through unlikely means. What some denominations might consider blind embrace and compromise, others may consider a source of natural theology and spiritual breakthrough. Wherever a church tradition may fall on the theological spectrum, all members of the body of Christ are encouraged not to judge one another.

    Christians have always debated what cultural standards and practices should be embraced or avoided. In Paul’s letters to the Romans and Corinthians, he challenges Christians with different understandings of how to live not to judge one another. While our pop cultural diets are not equivalent to the ancient debate about meat sacrificed to idols, the concern that we are to carry toward others’ relative strengths or weaknesses carries on. We are not to cause our brothers and sisters to stumble in their faith (1 Cor. 8), yet we often get confused about our responsibilities and roles in regard to Paul’s references to being weak or strong in faith. We may judge those who will not watch R-rated movies as weak while they consider themselves to be strong or mature. We may feel judged (as weak or worldly) for something we watch when it genuinely doesn’t cause us to stumble (thanks to the strength of our faith). When we lord our convictions and conscience over others and condemn their practices, we are falling into the divisive practices that Paul warns against.

    In Grey Matters, Brett McCracken discusses how we (mis)use the Bible to justify our choices in relation to what we watch, what we eat, and what we drink. He sees far too much ethical compromise in the name of ministry or cultural dialogue and calls his generation of believers to rise above the hipster Christian pose and rationale. Sometimes we turn Paul’s promotion of unity into categories we use to judge one another or divide ourselves. Yet the conclusion in Romans seems abundantly clear: “The one who eats everything must not treat with contempt the one who does not, and the one who does not eat everything must not judge the one who does, for God has accepted them” (Rom. 14:3). Whatever our choices and practices regarding pop culture, Paul asks us not to judge one another.

    Responses to pop culture may also diverge widely according to race, gender, and age of the audience. Others may ignore programs we consider “must-see TV.” Shows we have never watched may be essential viewing for communities beyond our purview. The Nielson ratings for television programs vary widely between Caucasian, African American, and Hispanic viewers. While Caucasian viewers may have made NCIS a top-ten show, African American viewers prefer NCIS: Los Angeles (perhaps because it stars LL Cool J). Scandal is the top-rated show among African Americans, but enough “other people” watch it to place it in the top-ten programs overall. Scandal creator and executive producer Shonda Rhimes remains one of the few African Americans to run multiple networks programs (like Grey’s Anatomy and its spinoff, Private Practice). She brings a distinctive voice to her programs and leans into the racial diversity reflected in her cast and characters. Millions of Hispanic viewers tune to Univision and their hit programs like Que Vida Me Robo and Que Pobres Tan Ricos. Univision caters to a demographic that is expanding (and perhaps youth ministry should follow suit with more Spanish-speaking staff and volunteers). Advertisers are increasingly interested in reaching targeted markets. The Nielson ratings subdivide audiences into particular age groups (ages 2–11, 12–34, 18–49, over 50). Nickelodeon programs like SpongeBob SquarePants or iCarly attracted the most kids ages two through eleven, while teens gravitated toward Fox programs like Family Guy, The Simpsons, and Glee.

    The Internet Movie Database separates their lists of the top-ranked films by genre and gender. Women’s all-time favorite films may diverge from men’s lists. A savvy youth ministry leader will tailor his or her events and talks to reflect the interests of the local group. Attention to subtle and sometimes significant differences in favorite songs, shows, or films should be factored in before choosing illustrations for talks or Bible studies. Pop culture offers an easy way for teens to express their passions as well as their likes and dislikes and provides a way for youth professionals to enter into dialogue around those significant stories. Pop culture that moves us (like Raging Bull!) might be offensive or even reprehensible to others. God may speak to us through a program that causes others to stumble. Such is the mystery of God and the elusive nature of general revelation.

    The days of a singular youth culture united around a particular text or show are waning. The proliferation of television networks and channels has splintered adolescent interests across a wide variety of programming. Time-shifting devices like the DVR or an online streaming service like Netflix allow teens to binge watch or catch up on a program when it is convenient. Only live events like the Super Bowl or MTV’s Video Music Awards may capture a large swath of teen attention in a singular moment. Massive series like Harry Potter, Twilight, and The Hunger Games may capture large segments of teens’ imagination, but adolescents may reserve a greater passion for a story they feel as if they have discovered. My daughter’s interest in Blaine’s relationship with Kurt on Glee was rooted mostly in her love for actor Darren Criss’s music career. She followed his theater troupe, StarKid Productions, and their satire, A Very Potter Musical. Thanks to social media, teens can rally around particular stars, bands, or shows in remarkably personalized ways. Adolescent culture is best understood as a series of smaller cultures. The fragmentation of our taste and resulting fan clubs and followings has become a form of culture making itself. The smartphone and social media have turned every adolescent into a potential broadcaster and marketer.

    While pop culture morphs into new media forms, a global perspective can make us aware of the biases inherent in American entertainment. The ideologies embedded in Hollywood’s productions (young is better than old, rich is better than poor, sex is the ultimate expression of love) may appear strange to international audiences. Americans raised on a steady diet of gun-toting action films may not realize how abrasive and violent our “entertainment” may appear to foreign audiences. The villains we choose for our movies may castigate those who do not deserve to be stereotyped on the big screen. I can recall feeling embarrassed by our cultural exports playing on television screens in Mongolia. To see Jay Z singing “Big Pimpin’” on a massive yacht outside an American culture of affluence was downright disgusting. Muslim nations may be right to reject TV series that sexualize and objectify women (and men). Yet Americans may be scandalized by the sexuality and violence that permeates Japanese manga. Our values are reflected in what we create. We may not realize how much influence pop culture has exerted on our desire to be famous, to be noticed, or to be loved for something beyond our looks, our power, or our riches. Youth ministers need to develop discernment to see through the messages being sent across our screens. A countercultural youth ministry may need to elevate films or programs that question the status quo and promote kingdom values.

    If the tendency in pop culture is to break down audiences according to race, culture, or age, perhaps youth ministry should focus on opportunities to bring people together across ages and interests. It is the rare film franchise like The Fast and the Furious that offers substantive roles to actors across the racial spectrum. It celebrates a diverse family onscreen, where people’s unique gifts (for car theft!) create a stronger whole. A band of outsiders is adopted into a loving gang that covers one another’s back. The healthy box office receipts for the Fast franchise suggest how much interest follows those who can aggregate audiences across race and culture. Perhaps youth ministries could be known by their ability to bring teens together from a variety of backgrounds and heritages. Consider how prophetic and powerful it would be if churches could bring together teens who separate themselves at school. Imagine drawing all of those separate tables in the cafeteria around one common table, united around the body and blood of Jesus celebrated in communion.

    Perhaps one of the (not so) secrets of Glee’s success is the remarkable diversity in the cast and characters. Mr. Schuester makes room for every kind of adolescent in the New Directions. Kids who have lost parents like Kurt join forces with teens raised by two dads like Rachel Berry or those born into mixed marriages like Tina Cohen-Chang. There is room on the football team for Artie Abrams in his wheelchair and a place on the cheerleading squad for Becky Jackson, despite her Down syndrome. Such radical inclusiveness can be considered as either a television fantasy or an aspirational challenge. The Glee Project was a reality TV contest that offered fans a chance to win a part on the show. Winners ranged from the cross-dressing Divine Adams to “a teenage Jesus,” Samuel Larsen. Both were added to the choir, pushing the boundaries of what adolescence includes. We live and minister within such confounding and challenging times.

    How does the Bible deal with such cultural collisions? In Acts 8, the Ethiopian eunuch wanted to join a Jewish tribe, but his background separated him from their worship practices. Philip crossed cultural lines in coming alongside this African. Even after Philip explained the good news about Jesus, the eunuch may still have wondered whether this wondrous love applied to him. When the eunuch spots some water he asks, “What can stand in the way of my being baptized?” This can be read as an exclamation and affirmation (nothing!) or as a hesitation and question. Did one have to become a Jew to be baptized? Was there a racial, cultural, gender, or sexual barrier to following Jesus? Having faced rejection in Jerusalem, the eunuch might have wondered, “What are the rules of your tribe, Philip? Is there room for someone like me?” Philip baptized the Ethiopian eunuch, extending the early Christian community beyond its Jewish roots. The first non-Jewish Christ follower was a sexually ambiguous black man. Philip fulfilled the kinds of promises that the prophet Isaiah had imagined. In Isaiah, the Lord promises to the eunuch who keeps his Sabbaths, “I will give them an everlasting name which shall not be cut off” (56:5 RSV). Talk about a divine sense of humor. Imagine the glee that occurred when the eunuch discovered the Lord offers assurance that “my house shall be called a house of prayer for all peoples” (56:7 RSV).

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑