Chapter 6 of 31

1. The Strategy of Adoptive Youth Ministry

1. The Strategy of Adoptive Youth Ministry

1

The Strategy of Adoptive Youth Ministry

CHAP CLARK

Consider this unsolicited email from an eighth-grade boy to his youth pastor about the multigenerational mission event that people from his church were going to attend.

“One of my biggest reasons of why I want to go is to worship God in that huge mass amount of people! If I think church camp is amazing then this has to crazy awesome, and I think it’s great! Not only we get to have fun and worship but we get to have a work experience too! I can’t wait to meet people and find new siblings!”

There’s no easy way to say this: The American evangelical church has lost, is losing and will almost certainly continue to lose our youth. For all the talk of “our greatest resource,” “our treasure,” and the multi-million dollar Dave and Buster’s/Starbucks knockoffs we build and fill with black walls and wailing rock bands . . . the church has failed them. Miserably.

—Marc Yoder, “10 Surprising Reasons Our Kids Leave Church”

Adoptive ministry is the biblical calling describing our role in recognizing and participating in God’s declaration that in Christ we have been called “children of God” (John 1:12). As churches attempt to build community among those who gather together as God’s people, adoption is the term used as the biblical foundation for drawing disparate people into the family-like intimacy we have been invited to in Christ. Adoptive youth ministry, then, provides the biblical foundation for the inclusion of young people into the core of the Christian community.

When I first began using the term adoption to describe how we are called see ourselves as connected siblings of one another in the church—and therefore how we envision ministry to the body and beyond—not everyone immediately jumped on board. Essentially, those who struggled landed in two basic camps.

First, some people believe the term is confusing because it is most commonly used for families adopting children into their home. Clearly the word is embedded within a very specific context. Wouldn’t it confuse people to use the term in a different, albeit broader, way? This is actually a strength of its use. For this very reason, Paul chose this term to break down the walls dividing the early church. Using adoption to describe what it means to live together in God’s family concisely raises the bar of the relational connectedness and intimacy we are called to in Christ. People already know that to adopt a child changes everything—not only for the child but also for the receiving family. By using this familial language, this same intentionality is applied to who we are and how we function in the community of faith, thereby capitalizing on the term’s familiarity. In using adoption we are more readily able to embrace the complexity, the messiness, and the emotional energy that comes with taking in a child who, by nature of the choice the family makes, is endowed with all the rights and privileges of a biological child. Those I have talked with who have adopted children or are adopted themselves have overwhelmingly resonated with the concept of adoption as a grounding theological base for youth ministry, and every ministry.

The second objection involves the implicit implication such a label will have on the term intergenerational, which is currently in vogue. As many churches have come to recognize fragmentation in the church and how it creates multiple communities within a single congregation, they have instituted programs and strategies to connect people of various groups and ages. Some who have embraced the concept of “intergenerational ministry” wonder whether adoption is too top-down a word. However, this assumes that intergenerationalism levels the playing field of communal engagement and that as young people and older people are given the opportunity to know one another they will be drawn to one another as equals, or at least co-participants. Last year at a summit of youth ministry writers and leaders, I was given a few minutes to pitch the idea of adoptive ministry. One participant remarked, “I don’t think ‘adoption’ is an especially helpful metaphor for youth ministry. It is hierarchical and devalues kids.” This comment and the resultant conversation forced me to think more deeply about what I mean by adoptive ministry. Any ministry concept that devalues young people is clearly not what is appropriate in the desire to integrate young people into the life of the church community. As mentioned in the introduction, adoptive ministry is not about adults “adopting” the children or adolescents of a church as their own. Rather, because God is the one who adopts all of us, adoptive ministry is more directly communal and inclusive, more straightforward and therefore easily explainable, and far more radical than any previous foundational theology of youth ministry practice.

Participating in what God declares as truth is the reality of who we are together as his children. In the course of teaching, writing, and speaking about this subject in various contexts, this discussion has not only caused me to describe more carefully the implications of adoptive ministry but has also given me greater confidence that adoption is the most helpful and direct biblical metaphor for the church in today’s atomized society. Since it has been declared by God that we are siblings of one another, we are members of the same household and family, and we hold the same standing before the God who has called us. Nothing could be less hierarchical.

Adoptive ministry, however, is less about fostering diverse relationships and more about changing our fundamental mind-set of how we relate to one another in the church. It is first and foremost about attitudinal change; structural change will follow. The shift from where we are to where we need to be is significant, but in today’s culture of disinterest and disdain we are losing both kids and relevancy; we simply have no choice. We must move from the historical complacency of institutional and programmatic defensiveness into the uncharted, mysterious, and uncontrollable waters of abandoned life together in Christ. This is what adoptive ministry means.

Adoptive Ministry

The Move from Institution to Organism

Several years ago, while trying to integrate various perspectives on organizational dynamics and group leadership, it occurred to me that anything of merit begins with an idea (e.g., “we need more efficient transportation”). With any idea that matters, we must create a structure that promotes the idea in a specific context (a contextual application of the idea, as in “we need a car with four wheels and rubber tires”). As we refine the application, we almost always begin to see the structure as being essentially one with the idea, and we end up protecting and controlling the structure that promotes the idea (e.g., “Consider a car; how many wheels does it have? Of course. Four.”). Yet to keep an idea alive in a changing environment, the temptation to control or contain how it is applied and constantly seek to restructure the essence of the idea must be resisted. (“Why not five wheels, on plastic tires?”) To maintain the integrity of an idea in any fluid climate means we must be willing to change how we envision the idea in different settings and contexts. What matters, then, is the idea, not how it is structured or applied.

I have come to see all change in these terms. Ronald A. Heifetz and Marty Linsky remind that “people do not resist change, per se. People resist loss.” There is such great power in maintaining what we know and what we have become comfortable with that anytime a “fixed” idea is challenged—even by simply asking a question or proposing a new way of thinking—our default response is to become nervous. We wonder what will happen if what we have believed in and relied on is lost. Yet this must happen in order to change how youth ministry has been practiced for decades. We must move from running a program to being a family—from functioning as an institution to living as an organism.

The Evolution of the Idea

For an idea to go anywhere, it must have some sort of structure to give it legs. Once a rudimentary structure is in place, especially in its early iterations, the structure may go through fits and starts; yet if the idea has merit, eventually the structure enables the idea to gain momentum. At this stage, whoever owns the idea is forced to choose. Most typically, the choice is made to commit to and therefore formalize the structure by creating an organization with layers, hierarchy, tenets, and procedures in the attempt to ensure that the idea continues in its current iteration. Once this happens, however, the idea becomes subject to the power of the organization itself and has only one trajectory—to become so codified and rigid that it becomes an institution. In this use of the term, an institution is an organization that is in the business of perpetuating itself by using the power of the organization to keep it going and the rhetoric of the idea to give it perpetual legitimacy. Once this occurs, the idea is no longer what drives practices and structure because the institution is now in control. Depending on the power of the institution and how deeply the leaders cling to it, changing or even questioning the assumptions, tenets, and reasoning of the institution is extremely difficult. It becomes, in essence, a closed system in which outside forces and voices are perceived as threats to the integrity of the institution’s reason for being. The idea is considered to be alive, but the idea has been strangled by the power of the institution. If not dead, the idea is buried so deeply it is only a matter of time before the institution becomes an empty shell devoid of meaning.

In my experience, this process is inevitable without dedicated and deliberate leadership. As an example, take the idea of socializing the young in a society. The child needs to be taught not only concepts but also history and values and must be given the opportunity to observe these in action. So a society may choose to gather the children together in order to pass on the story so that the children will be ready to enter the greater community as peers when the time is right (this signifies the structure, the contextual application of an idea). Over time, as curriculum is developed and teachers are trained, the structure gains traction and soon becomes an organization. But unless the caretakers of the idea fight to keep the idea at the center, the organization will become so formalized, with layers of hierarchy and tenets that maintain the status quo, that it will morph into an institution that retains the idealized rhetoric to “socialize the young” but is now so powerful and solidified that it has become an idea unto itself.

What, then, is the antidote to institutionalism? How can an idea be maintained with integrity, even in changing environments? At the point where the idea begins to take shape as a structure, the crucial decision needs to be made by those who control the idea: either we commit to our structure—what we have learned, how we think about what the idea means in a given context—and evolve into an organization that eventually slips into an institutional morass, or we continually campaign on behalf of the idea and become an organism, an open system that seeks out any and all input in order to keep the idea alive. The choice is always the same: commit to the messy, unknowing life of a living entity by being willing to experiment with new structures and pursue any questions that would cause the idea to thrive, or settle for a fixed (and proven?) structure that may appear healthy but in the end will ultimately self-destruct the idea. Interestingly, the two most common uses of the term institution (besides marriage) are education and the church, both of which are hugely powerful institutions with long histories, time-honed practices, and sacred assumptions that only the most “out there” are willing to attempt to improve.

Let’s return to the education example mentioned above. With all of the data available on how growing up is changing—how boys and girls develop differently and the way in which the brain matures—should the way contemporary education is delivered be reconsidered? Are we willing to go back to the original idea, that is, to develop mature, healthy adults who will take what has been given them and move the story forward? Can we ask questions like why middle school? What if schools were made smaller? What if boys and girls were educated separately? Why five days a week? Don’t ask. The goals of education have become so limited for most kids that the surface of socialization is barely scratched as educational institutions seek to develop “competencies” in order to stay “competitive” with other societies. Education is now about data (raw content) and information (integrating data into categories). Socialization and the making of healthy, interdependent adults begins with data and information. Young people need help to move beyond mere content into knowledge (connecting the dots created by data and information into a cohesive landscape where true interdependent interaction and deliberation can take place), with the ultimate goal of producing men and women who embody wisdom—who can use knowledge to contribute to the greater good.

Now, what about the church? How do we “do” church? How is staff hired? How is the church going to be structured? Most important, what is the strategic goal for ministry?

For the church to become a family—which, in terms of health, means our life together needs to be experienced as an open system, or essentially as an organism—we must be open to thinking differently about how to operate as a community. We must be strategic and holistic, but we also must be willing to ask any and every question that would keep us from living into who we are called to be. After all, the first church (Acts 2) did not have a preordained plan or organizational structure in place. All that is known is that those in the early church quickly bonded to one another, and the family grew: “All the believers were one in heart and mind. No one claimed that any of their possessions was their own, but they shared everything they had. . . . More and more men and women believed in the Lord and were added to their number” (Acts 4:32; 5:14).

Even within the time frame that the New Testament was written, over time the structure of the local church morphed into a more visible and boundaried entity. Local “overseers” were identified, vetted by carefully crafted qualifications (Titus 1:7–9), and apparently appointed by centralized leadership from the outside (Titus 1:5). These leaders were organizationally, at least somewhat, trained by and under the authority of the apostles or their designates, and “God’s flock” was instructed to follow their leaders.

To the elders among you, I appeal as a fellow elder and a witness of Christ’s sufferings who also will share in the glory to be revealed: Be shepherds of God’s flock that is under your care, watching over them—not because you must, but because you are willing, as God wants you to be; not pursuing dishonest gain, but eager to serve; not lording it over those entrusted to you, but being examples to the flock. And when the Chief Shepherd appears, you will receive the crown of glory that will never fade away.

In the same way, you who are younger, submit yourselves to your elders. All of you, clothe yourselves with humility toward one another, because,

“God opposes the proud

but shows favor to the humble.” (1 Pet. 5:1–5)

This structure apparently held for several generations: “overseers” or “bishops” led, and people followed. The New Testament documents, however, consistently stress that there is one Head, that is, Christ, and we are all his children, each endowed with gifts and called to unity. Similar to Aristotle’s vision of leaders functioning as peers—“first among equals” (primus inter pares), which is based on what one scholar has described as “friendship”—the appeal is to “make every effort” to maintain the unity of the Spirit regardless of role or status within the body.

As a prisoner for the Lord, then, I urge you to live a life worthy of the calling you have received. Be completely humble and gentle; be patient, bearing with one another in love. Make every effort to keep the unity of the Spirit through the bond of peace. There is one body and one Spirit, just as you were called to one hope when you were called; one Lord, one faith, one baptism; one God and Father of all, who is over all and through all and in all. (Eph. 4:1–6)

During the writing of the New Testament, this hierarchical structure seemed to be less about power and authority and more about maintaining the integrity of the idea of the gospel, but over time it slipped into organizationalism and ultimately morphed into an institution. As early as the second century the body of Christ became functionally stratified, separating the body into those who were in control and those who were not. Depending on the integrity of the leadership (along with other factors such as geographical location, local history, and applied theology), the local community has struggled ever since to be faithful to the biblical mandate of living as an organism while generally finding itself operating under the weight of an institution. For centuries, this institutionalism has encouraged some to be heard and expected, even forced, others to be silent. In most places and across most theological expressions throughout church history, this struggle has led to the almost complete dismantling of the biblical metaphor of the family-church.

With so many people feeling so deeply isolated and disconnected, now is the time for the body of Christ to reimagine biblical community and to reinvigorate family life together. That is what adoptive ministry is about. Primus inter pares (“first among equals”) is not simply a philosophical ideal to be co-opted as mere rhetoric by the power of institutionalism; it is how we are called to live. In terms of youth ministry, this means that young people are co-siblings with all others in the community—functional “equals” even while needing to be nurtured and led into maturity. In today’s church we need to dismantle the institutional baggage of power and hierarchy by recognizing that we are all in this together, young and old alike, because we are God’s family. Pope Francis sounded a similar refrain in his 2014 Christmas address to the Curia, which was referred to by news outlets as a “scathing critique of Vatican officials.” The pope described the Vatican’s leadership as having “spiritual Alzheimer’s. . . . We see it in the people who have forgotten their encounter with the Lord . . . in those who depend completely on their here and now, on their passions, whims and manias, in those who build walls around themselves and become enslaved to the idols that they have built with their own hands.”

Anything less is not New Testament Christianity. As the world has changed and as the church has seen not only its status but also its impact significantly decrease, we have no choice but to reexamine who we are and how we are called to live together. Jesus calls us salt and light (Matt. 5:13–14); Paul calls us Christ’s body (Rom. 12:5); God the Father calls us his children (John 1:12). In Christ, we are not an institution—we are a living, breathing, messy, and powerful organism. We are family.

Adoption and the Current State of Youth Ministry

In 1988, Stuart Cummings-Bond wrote an article that was to become an important marker on youth ministry’s developmental journey. His concept of the “One Eared Mickey Mouse” got very little play initially, as most wondered why this could possibly be a negative thing. Youth ministry was focused on kids and Jesus Christ, not the church, so to be an appendage to the larger “head” seemed almost natural. When Mark DeVries wrote Family Based Youth Ministry a few years later, leaders in the field (especially those who had been doing youth ministry for a while) knew that youth ministry was missing something by going it alone apart from the church. Within a few years several books and dozens of articles had been written in an attempt to get youth ministry to take parents seriously, as youth ministers began to realize that adolescents need more than a few dedicated adults and a viable peer support system to become mature, interdependent adults. At the turn of the twenty-first century, most youth workers understood that youth ministry meant some level of parent ministry.

As Mike Yaconelli decried that “youth ministry as an experiment has failed,” the most prominent discussion in youth ministry circles was why so many active youth ministry graduates were walking away from faith after high school, and several emphases emerged in the practice of youth ministry. Some advocate a much deeper partnership with parents, even to the point of questioning whether youth ministry is doing more harm than good. Others push for strengthening the practices of youth ministry so as to “expect more” from youth group students. Leaders of this view seek to raise the bar on what is demanded of (“challenging”) early and late adolescents. The proponents of this perspective encourage adolescents to become more active in their faith—from “acquiring fire” to “daring to share” their faith and doing “hard things” to change the world. However, what has picked up considerable steam across the entire youth ministry world and is being accepted in widely divergent circles is the conviction that youth ministry work must be deeply embedded within the ministry of the church, regardless of the specific emphasis. This perspective, perhaps most notably expressed in the Sticky Faith project of the Fuller Youth Institute, recommends structuring youth ministry practice as a holistic partnership between youth ministry, congregational leaders, parents, and the congregation at large. Even youth ministry parachurch organizations, which for the most part have been insulated from youth ministry practice trends, have recognized the necessity for a more holistic and ecclesial approach to their ministry.

The pieces, then, are in place for reimagining youth ministry as integrated into the life of the church. For years many youth ministry leaders have recognized the importance of multiple people in a child’s life for developmental health and have also promoted both parental and church-wide participation in the discipleship life of adolescents. The trend toward intergenerational relationships is obviously a theologically and psychosocially positive trajectory. What has emerged to date, however, is more akin to a programmatic adhesive patch to a flawed historical problem. Youth ministry, in fact any ministry, that fundamentally segregates a congregation into parts as its primary thinking and mode of ministry will inevitably hinder the work of the Spirit in creating a new community within the church. While done with the best of intentions, creating an environment of intergenerational relationships without actually enabling deep and lasting, intimate, intentional connectedness among various members of a congregation will have little sustainable impact on the life of either the young or the old. Though heightened interest in getting diverse populations within the church together is a positive trend, the conceptual or theological framework has not been available to take youth ministry as far as it needs to go. So long as parents are equipped and encouraged and young people and adult congregants develop relationships, the prevailing hope is that a strategically and programmatically fragmented congregation will develop long-term faithful followers of Jesus. Simply tweaking what has always been done—a parent class here, an intergenerational mission day there—isn’t enough. The goal and practices of youth ministry and all ministry need to be thoroughly reenvisioned so as to become God’s visible family on earth. We are the family of God, and all ministry must be strategically and programmatically oriented to reflect this reality.

The Strategy of Adoptive Ministry

In Starting Right: Thinking Theologically about Youth Ministry (2001), I proposed a new structure of ministry programming. Unlike other models that use a similar “funnel” format, this model—“The Funnel of Programming”—urges programming targeted to the level of interest expressed by those we serve. In the chapter titled “The Myth of the Perfect Model,” I use the following categories of expressed interest and appropriate “levels” of programming:

  • Outreach—people who would choose not to attend a “Christianized” event or program
  • Entry level—people who are willing to attend a Christian-branded program or event but are not interested in being a part of a significantly spiritual activity or event
  • Community building/discipleship level—those who are willing to be a part of a significant spiritually focused event or program
  • Intimate relationship level—this level is for those who are not only willing to attend significant spiritual events and programs but are also willing to personally connect themselves to others in the pursuit of spiritual growth. This level serves as the training ground for developing spiritual community in Christ.
  • Mentoring level—as the final stage of this strategic process of integrating (in this case) adolescents into the body of faith, this is the level at which an adult personally mentors a young person, “assimilating” them (as I called it at the time) into the community of faith.
  • The Funnel of Programming provides a strategy for attempting to connect young people to the church as the goal of youth ministry. Guiding this strategy is the philosophy that a person needs to be “in” Christian family-like community in order to be “in Christ.” The flaw of this model, as I now see it, is that assimilation should not be the goal of ministry to outsiders, including the young. As mentioned in the introduction, assimilation requires the person being assimilated to adapt to the dominant group. This is not only offensive but it is also a stumbling block to authentic communal engagement. In using the model represented in Starting Right, we may do all the right programmatic things to mentor young people into the body, but what this inevitably means is that they “get” to sit in church, enjoy our music, appreciate the talking points, and make themselves “feel” a sense of attachment to the programmatic gathering of adults. This is not the idea behind Adoptive Youth Ministry.

    The categories, however, do provide a helpful starting point for thinking critically about a strategy for participating in God’s adoptive process. I propose, therefore, a revised version of the Funnel, which I would like to title “Strategy for Adoptive Ministry.” Note that this strategy is not limited to youth ministry but is an intentional approach to helping anyone who feels disconnected from the center of the community to come into the family-like intimacy that God’s household promises.

    Outreach. It is important to remember that many people not only feel disconnected from the community of faith but are also intentionally left out of the Christian community. The strategic concern, then, is to offer adoptive ministry as the motive and message of evangelism. We seek not to make adoptive children of those who are not interested in being part of the community; rather, we are witnesses to God’s invitation to them to join the family the Spirit creates in Christ (John 1:12). Thus evangelism is less about “making converts” than about serving others (Matt. 25:31–46) and witnessing to God’s desire to gather his children for the wedding feast of the Son (Matt. 22).

    Welcoming level. For a person who is willing to participate on at least the periphery of the community of faith, even if they are resistant to full participation in faith practices or spiritual engagement with others, strategic adoptive ministry seeks to create space and an environment where he or she feels welcomed. This is one of the places where targeted ministry can be valuable (e.g., youth ministry, women’s ministry, senior ministry); most people need to feel safe with their peers prior to investing in relationships outside their relational comfort zones. However, this assumes that while delivering “targeted ministry” programs and structure, leadership is so committed to adoptive ministry that anything they do within the mini-community is to be strategically located as a segue to adoption.

    Engaging level. When a person has expressed an interest in personal faith, the role of adoptive ministry is to encourage this individual journey while framing the full experience of faith within the context of Christian community. This is where most ministries fail because when we promote private faith we sometimes communicate that personal faith is the end goal. This level is the place where leadership affirms a person’s individual journey while engaging him or her toward a deeper, more intimate familial expression and corporate experience of faith.

    Diverse relationships level. This level is the strategic place of connecting people to the broader family of faith, which leads to a recognition that all believers—whether in a local church, a given denomination, across town, or around the world—are part of the same family. By investing in a microcosm of intimate family-like relationships with a diverse community of faith siblings, men and women—both young and old—are encouraged and equipped to live differently as members of God’s historical and global family.

    Adoption level. As the community gathers—whether in small groups, for missions and service, or to serve the family internally or intentionally as they seek to engage with those outside the family of faith—the rhetoric, style, and experience of the gatherings must be an intentional recognition of the reality of our station as family. For example, this means that “worship” is never limited to singing certain songs with a particular flavor; gathering together is a comprehensive communal opportunity to collectively thank the Father who calls us his own.

    Conclusion

    Adoptive youth ministry means we participate in what God has declared and is in the process of realizing throughout his human family, the church. To create an environment where all community members believe that they belong, are welcome, and are part of the visible family of God, we must first recognize how institutional the church has become and proactively work to move toward becoming an open-system organism. This requires leadership, rhetoric (verbally and in print) that is more than mere words, and a change in attitude across the entire community. Once we have done the hard work of being willing, as a Spirit-led family, to align with God’s work among us, the next step is to assess and appropriately respond to the different needs of those who are furthest out. In terms of youth ministry, we must rethink our practices—programs, events, structure, and everything we “do” in the name of youth ministry—so that those who need to feel welcomed are embraced, those who are called to move beyond “personal” faith are proactively engaged with Jesus’s “one command” to love one another, and those who have few or no authentic relationships are provided the encouragement, training, and opportunity to participate in the community as a family member in the full body of faith.

    This is the reason for Adoptive Youth Ministry, and every chapter will address various aspects of youth ministry as a whole. Rarely does an author use the language of this particular chapter, but each writes so as to help the reader strategically move forward with a commitment to adoptive ministry. We encourage you to visit the website dedicated to this book and concept at youthministry.fuller.edu. By engaging in a community that is going after adoption as the core concept for youth ministry, our desire is that we will all learn from one another.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑