19. Adoptive Leadership
Some leaders are kind controllers. Others are relational encouragers who let people “do” their ministry. Still others seem more concerned with pleasing their supervisors, or in the case of youth ministry, their multiple supervisors (parents, pastoral staff, other youth workers, and even kids). Yet in order to lead a theological ministry in which our goal is further reaching than the immediate results we so often seek, we need healthy, trained, and committed leaders who know that they are called to encourage and empower their peers to serve well, as well proactive leaders who are willing to be honest, to teach and train, and to guide those exploring their ministry gifts. At least on the surface, we need people who are both collaborative and in charge. How can one be both a guiding and an empowering leader? That is what Bill MacPhee shares in this chapter.
MacPhee knows what he’s talking about. For more than two decades he led large and powerful adoptive youth ministry programs (before anyone called them that!). He always had a stable full of “senior” volunteers and another large group of new and inexperienced volunteers and staff. During the last five years of MacPhee’s high school ministry, there were several hundred students attending Sunday ministry, midweek youth group and small groups, and over 125 adults involved in direct ministry. MacPhee knew each one—every student, (almost) every family, and every leader. This chapter tells what he learned from his ministry experience, from others along the way, from what he experienced with leaders who supervised him, and from ministry and congregational friends. MacPhee is as competent and accomplished a leader as I have ever been around, in large part because he leads with humility; he listens and encourages others to live into their own calling. Perhaps that’s why for the past five years he has been giving his life to lead the spiritual formation of students, faculty, and staff at a large Christian school. MacPhee lives as—and knows what it means to be—an adoptive leader, one who sees every person as a gift from God and who is able to do whatever it takes to ensure that he or she is given every opportunity to find a place in God’s kingdom family.
As you read this chapter, consider these questions:
Introduction
The church that takes seriously the New Testament call to embody vital community recognizes that this calling is much deeper than mere programming or even strategy. It is a way of thinking, an attitude that drives everything else a church says or does in the name of Christ. Leadership that has done its work to reflect the calling to be unified in Christ knows that this attitude begins with the leadership. In terms of youth ministry, community doesn’t simply happen; few young people will naturally feel drawn to initiating relationships with an adult community that sits back and waits for them. Adults must be the initiators of relationships with the young. More than this, it takes the church community as a whole to recognize that they are the ones called to welcome and include children and young people even as they nurture their journey into full adulthood and Christian maturity. In a church that heeds Jesus’s “one command” in John 13:34 to “love one another,” both staff and lay leadership recognize that they must lead as an extension of this command. Thankfully, churches are discovering that the role of building lasting and authentic relationships with teenagers can’t be relegated to a lone youth pastor but is the call of every adult within the church family.
In Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community, Robert D. Putnam details ways in which we are increasingly disconnected from our family, friends, and neighbors. Our networks of connections are diminishing. Putnam’s title is drawn from the reality that more people are bowling but fewer are joining leagues. What he refers to as “social capital” the New Testament calls “fellowship.” William Damon offers this profound warning, “Isolation is the one condition that can turn a family adversity into a developmental tragedy for a child,” and calls for the support of a community-wide, “virtual extended family.” Dennis Guernsey, author of A New Design for Family Ministry, describes this community appropriately as an embracing church—a “family of families.” Within the church, as networks of families connect with one another and do life together in partnership with local youth ministry leadership teams and other caring adults, adolescents are caught up into a community of welcome, embrace, and spiritual nurture.
To create a youth ministry environment in which the young are valued requires a new yet timeless leadership mind-set and approach. Those serving as the point person for local church ministry to adolescents must lead the way by inspiring, informing, inviting, and modeling for the rest of the church.
Models of Leadership in (Youth) Ministry
How do you define leadership? The US Army Field Manual defines it as “influencing people.” For anyone who is in Christ, the question becomes more pointed, regardless of the actual setting: what is unique about Christian leadership? For our purposes, then, how is leadership practiced or how is power structured in typical youth ministry and church environments? In Leadership by the Book, Ken Blanchard, Bill Hybels, and Phil Hodges argue that leaders need to ensure that the development of people as a primary goal is at least on the same priority level as bottom-line agendas for money, numbers, profit, prestige, or any other current ministry motivations and measurements. As leaders who see their vocation as an expression of their calling as agents of the kingdom of God, regardless of the role in which we are placed, we must constantly ask ourselves, do we develop or deplete people? In adoptive youth ministry, where we participate in God’s declaration of our familial status as siblings, the way in which we see leadership—either as using or controlling people for our own ends or as serving and setting free God’s people to welcome and invite young people into the church family—determines whether we are adoptive or simply trying to do a “good job.”
How are the pressures and demands of life and leadership manifested in most churches and youth ministries? A youth worker, especially someone who is young, eager, and (usually) just beginning to gain life and call experience, may get hired by a local church because he or she seems to love kids. Inevitably, pressure mounts to produce a certain number of kids and programs to justify the job, or maybe even a sense of personal identity. Where there is ministry “success,” programs multiply, volunteers need to be recruited, and the machine is more difficult to keep going. Things are busier and more chaotic, but for what purpose? In our more honest, stressful moments, we discover that we easily resort to using and directing people in order to help run “my ministry,” with “my kids,” using “my volunteers.” We may think we are serving and setting people up for their ministry of adoption, but in fact we have succumbed to the call to “be good” in our “work” of youth ministry.
This all-too-common scenario could be called the “pre-Jethro” Moses style of leadership. Moses was on point “from morning till evening,” with people standing “around him.” Jethro wisely inquires, “Why do you alone sit as judge?” Moses assumed his only option was to lead solo as the lone conduit of God’s information and decision. Jethro gives timeless advice: “What you are doing is not good. . . . You and these people . . . will only wear yourselves out. The work is too heavy for you; you cannot handle it alone.” Jethro prescribed a new plan that placed Moses as part of a team, enabling him “to stand the strain” and, in turn, assuring that “all these people [went] home satisfied.” Jethro urged Moses to learn a new way to lead.
In the midst of overwhelming responsibility and need, this is the tension every leader faces in ministry: we, like Moses, may also want to be, even feel the need to be, the master helmsman functioning at the pinnacle of leadership focus, identification, influence, and power over the needs and expectations in our ministry. But Jethro’s intervention provides an important correction to Moses’s controlling nature: he provides an alternative to the more common, autocratic, and hierarchical leadership style of his son-in-law. Trina Soske and Jay Conger, writers on the Harvard Business Review Blog Network, note, “Despite the continued popularity of the ‘great man’ theory of leadership and our romantic attachment to the idea of an individual that’s going to ‘ride in and save the day,’ leadership is a team sport.”
A key issue every leader must wrestle with is the appropriate use of power. How one chooses to wield power ultimately reflects one’s sense of identity as a leader in dialogue with the expectations of how power can be used within a particular cultural context.
Robert K. Greenleaf is credited with coining and helping to define our modern understanding of servant leadership, both in business and in the church. His perspective focuses on the two essential realities of leadership: orientation and motivation.
The servant-leader is servant first. . . . It begins with the natural feeling that one wants to serve, to serve first. Then conscious choice brings one to aspire to lead. That person is sharply different from one who is leader first, perhaps because of the need to assuage an unusual power drive. . . . The difference manifests itself in the care taken by the servant-first to make sure that other people’s highest priority needs are being served. The best test, and difficult to administer, is this: Do those served grow as persons? Do they, while being served, become healthier, wiser, freer, more autonomous, more likely themselves to become servants?
Greenleaf grounds his understanding of servant leadership in a Latin phrase used in Roman times to designate the key leader: primus inter pares—“first among equals.” Greenleaf maintains, “There is still a ‘first,’ a leader, but that leader is not the chief. The difference may appear subtle, but it is important that the primus constantly test and prove that leadership among a group of able peers.” This model refers not so much to the organizational structure but instead highlights the key relationships; this fosters an openness of communication that leads to greater collaboration among leaders, no matter the organizational structure. A primus inter pares leadership mind-set can be fostered effectively even within a hierarchical structure.
A primus inter pares leadership mind-set is found within the apostle Paul’s letters to the family of families, especially in Romans 12:3–8; 1 Corinthians 12; and Ephesians 4:1–16, where he focuses on how the household of God can function not only with unity and diversity but also with hospitality, especially as it embraces the youngest members. His words, like Jethro’s, invite a new way to look at family relationships and leadership in the church—even if the organizational structure is hierarchical. The role of the youth minister serving those he or she leads as primus is to nurture the gifts and power of others in order for the whole church to function in such a way that every person is included and needed in the body of Christ. In this new paradigm,
[Leaders] would still function in significant roles and positions, but they would operate from among rather than over others, seek participation more than make a presentation, establish connections before expressing content, and ask questions as much as give answers. They would also recognize that change emerges as people are encouraged to make unique contributions and as conversations take place within various parts and levels of an organization.
Living and Leading as the Beloved Child
When a leader’s identity has been securely formed and saturated in the life-giving grace of God’s love, power is wielded with more equity and responsibility for the good of all, especially the young. Few Christian leaders have articulated a primus inter pares approach to authentic identity formation as it flows into spiritual leadership better than Henri J. M. Nouwen, who put power on display in books such as In the Name of Jesus, The Return of the Prodigal Son, and Life of the Beloved.
A plethora of opportunities and experiences in life, especially in ministry, engender discouragement to the point of making us want to quit or tempting us to bear down and use the power of our office without regard for the best of those we lead. In these times and moments it is easy to feel as if our sense of self and our ability to fulfill the expectations of our vocation are called into question. In these moments we must pause and, with settled assurance in our relationship to God, lean into the fundamental question, “Who am I?” The answers that we and others give to this question largely determine what kind of leadership environment and ethos is created.
In his brief yet penetrating book In the Name of Jesus, Henri Nouwen articulates three common yet inadequate answers we and others give to this nagging yet indispensable question of identity:
The dilemma Nouwen explores involves how we try but can’t control the ultimate answer to these questions because of our own human frailty, the whimsy of others’ opinions, or the fate of circumstances. In trying to form an identity with answers to these three questions we are tempted to define ourselves by opinions and circumstances outside ourselves. We constantly shore up our inner angst by trying to make ourselves look and feel better than we know we truly are, often at the expense of those we seek to lead. This defensive response eventually creates chaos within a leadership team and ministry environment. Is it an overstatement to suggest that the vast majority of organizational conflict and confusion is likely traced back to leaders using their power to heal a void with their own sense of identity?
What sets Christian leadership apart, according to Nouwen, is our ability and willingness to settle into our own true identity by listening to the voice of our first love, the love of our heavenly Father. The apostle Paul, having heard that voice on the road to Damascus, said it this way: “I urge you to live a life worthy of the calling you have received” (Eph. 4:1, italics added).
In Life of the Beloved, a follow-up to In the Name of Jesus, Nouwen helps us to grasp that, in order to discover and embrace our true identity, we need to hear the Holy Spirit speak from within instead of listening to the external, dark voices yelling lies of self-rejection. “Do something relevant, or spectacular, or powerful.” This takes great courage, determination, and a community of grace. What’s more, this gets at the fundamental issue of leadership: if we lead others seeking to be satisfied in our ability or reputation to feed our need for acceptance and love, we will use others. It may be subtle for some and overt for others, but when one’s motive is twisted by self-need and brokenness, using others is difficult to overcome. If, however, we believe the gospel and are able to discover who we are apart from what we do or what others say, we find we have the ability to lift others above ourselves. So which voice(s) are you listening to?
Nouwen asks, “What voice did Jesus listen to?” and “When did he hear it?” Certainly Jesus matured in his ability to listen to and recognize the voice of his Father, but at a pivotal point a declaration from heaven rang out, “You are my Son, the Beloved; with you I am well pleased” (Luke 3:22 NRSV). Jesus’s power to resist the devil’s temptations came from his settled sense of identity, which was deeply rooted in his relationship to his Father; everything about his life and ministry flowed from that relationship!
Nouwen urges us to also consider the timing of the Father’s public declaration of Jesus. God was “well pleased” prior to Jesus’s public ministry—before he performed miracles, taught the crowds, called the disciples, or did anything especially newsworthy. In terms of ministry start-up, Jesus hadn’t done anything yet to deserve this statement. The Father’s love and declaration did not depend on Jesus’s doing or controlling anything; these things didn’t come about as a result of the opinion of others. “This is my Son, whom I love.” According to Nouwen, that voice is what helped Jesus discover and live into his true identity as the beloved Son.
The implications of Nouwen’s observation are profound, especially as we contemplate our leadership and its impact on the vulnerable lives of adolescents. We must hear and listen to this same voice. Nouwen declares that we too are, in Christ, granted the status of “beloved child.” This same voice sustained Jesus throughout his ministry, convincing him of what he knew to be true (“Abba, Father, . . . everything is possible for you”; Mark 14:36). As we listen to this same voice and hear this same affirmation, we are granted the assurance that who we are is settled long before we are right, or good, or gifted.
According to the Scriptures, in Christ the Father has declared, “You are my beloved child!” This message is for you and the world around you to hear. Furthermore, the second sentence adds texture to the first—“with you I am well pleased.” You belong to the Father as his beloved, and he is pleased with you—regardless of your title, position, or performance. There are voices from the outside measuring us by what we do or control. But there is a more important voice that comes from heaven. We can choose to listen to the external noise or the internal voice of the Spirit. This is a lifelong struggle for any leader, informing our understanding of identity, call, and mission. Parker Palmer, noting that our standing before God is what empowers our vocation, says,
Today I understand vocation quite differently—not as a goal to be achieved but as a gift to be received. Discovering vocation does not mean scrambling toward some prize just beyond my reach but accepting the treasure of true self I already possess. Vocation does not come from a voice “out there” calling me to become something I am not. It comes from a voice “in here” calling me to be the person I was born to be, to fulfill the original selfhood given me at birth by God.
Our spiritual life and leadership will be determined as we let this calling grow inside us, letting our leadership flow out of an inner reservoir of grateful yet secure humility. This is our anchor—the voice from above that says, “You are my beloved child.” Prayer, according to Nouwen, is to stop talking and listen to that voice, do the hard work to believe that voice, and then progressively discover what it means to become the beloved of God.
In practice, what do we do to begin living into the life of the beloved (to live in the name of Jesus)? How do we cultivate a climate conducive to a beloved community? In addition, how does our knowledge of our belovedness impact our leadership? Nouwen gives the following pastoral counsel to young leaders:
This is the beginning of leadership, but it will continue to be a lifelong and career-long journey. “If you don’t love Jesus, you will soon discover that being a pastor or a church leader is not really a very good job. You will be overworked, underpaid, overstressed, and underappreciated. But if you do love Jesus, you will discover as so many others have that it can be the most wonderful and exciting job in the world.”
Leading Volunteers
When we lead out of the authentic sense of vocation as God’s beloved children set free, we are forced to ask, “Which is the preferred leadership model—primus inter pares or top-down hierarchical controllers?” Is one style exclusively better than the other? In Building Strong People, Bobbie Reed and John Westfall frame the thesis of their book with a penetrating question: “Are you building a strong ministry, or are you building strong people who minister?” The answer not only reveals our motivation but also the focus of our efforts, which manifests our preference.
Jesus said, “The greatest among you will be your servant” (Matt. 23:11). With these words Jesus summed up his critique of his foes. The Pharisees considered themselves great leaders, having taken the mantle from Moses to guide Israel. But Jesus unmasked their hypocrisy as he addressed his disciples: “Do not do what they do, for they do not practice what they preach. They tie up heavy, cumbersome loads and put them on other people’s shoulders, but they themselves are not willing to lift a finger to move them” (Matt. 23:3–4). Jesus exposed their leadership as mostly for show, used to control and to impress others for their personal gain. Jesus wanted his followers to take note as they prepared to become the leaders of the church. Should not we, as disciple leaders, heed this warning ourselves?
Our attitude creates a leadership ethos that eventually leaks out. Ron Martoia calls it the “leadership leak.” Are we more concerned with assuring our status or facilitating a platform for leadership in the service of those we lead? Does our positional power benefit us or alleviate the burden of others? Are we building a ministry to be recognized, one that is spectacular and powerful, at the expense of helping others, or do we see our roles as empowering those we lead? While it may seem obvious that “first among equals” is the preferred posture of Christian leadership, virtually every model of leadership in the church, especially those that have been extracted from the business world (another world?), is at best learning how to be a benevolent and kind hierarchy. It is true that the disciples in the church had a leader—first Peter, then James—but they were primus leaders who functioned as equals. On the one hand we can easily recognize that our theological responsibility in the body of Christ is to love, nurture, and lift up one another as co-disciples and co-siblings. On the other hand, when leadership involves a paycheck or a title, by default we know it falls to us to “make it happen.”
How do we navigate this dichotomy? To use Paul’s metaphor of the body in 1 Corinthians 12, how can we encourage the “hand” who holds all the cards when we, as the “eye,” are the ones who can see the cards (notice, there is one Head, and that is Christ; the rest of us are merely body parts working together)? To put it another way, is there a place and theological justification for hierarchical leadership in ministry? Does the primus inter pares leadership model make room for command and control? Consider Jesus cleansing the temple, or Peter doling out discipline to Ananias and Sapphira, or the apostles leading the early church in Acts 6. What about Paul, especially when he was in conflict with Peter, Barnabas, and John Mark? These and other challenges convince us that love is not the opposite of power and strength. Rather, it is our use of power and our belief in the giftedness and calling of all we lead as equals that is the foundation for Christian leadership.
Churches and people need and want strong leadership that exerts loving power for the greater good of each individual and the whole. In this kind of relational environment more and diverse leaders are raised up, with deeper loyalty, to meet a greater variety of ministry needs and goals. At times leaders must make decisions, often without the full agreement of the community they serve. Though some call this hierarchical leadership, it is actually delegated authority on behalf of the whole. Essentially, this is what it means to be a leader: to know how to discover and maintain the appropriate balance of primus leadership as a general style and commitment and yet risk being seen as hierarchical when it is necessary and appropriate.
Situational Leadership
Paul Hersey and Kenneth Blanchard introduced the situational leadership model in Management of Organizational Behavior. In the words of Walter C. Wright, Hersey and Blanchard “developed a leadership model that sees leadership as a relational continuum with four distinct styles of leadership behavior tied directly to the specific follower.” Core to situational leadership is the determination of the leader to adapt his or her leadership style in any given situation to fit the competence and commitment level of the follower within his or her real-time context. Situational leadership presents four quadrants or leadership styles that are consistently primus and yet appropriately hierarchical.
As you consider applying situational leadership to your ministry context, think about specific people you know who might fit in each of the four quadrants.
S1—Directing. This person is probably an inexperienced and relatively new volunteer who is enthusiastic and ready to go. In this quadrant, your leadership style is mostly hierarchical, though still grounded in love—“do this now, in this way.” We give this person specific and simple tasks, with few details. The conversation might be mostly one-way, though we will wisely take time to clarify instructions. While permeated with love and confidence, this leadership style may feel mostly hierarchical.
S2—Coaching. This person has a few initial experiences in actual ministry but may be a bit disillusioned. His or her experience of ministry and adolescents may have been initially overwhelming and discouraging. This person’s initial excitement is wearing off because actual ministry is more difficult than he or she imagined. Many leaders lose volunteers at this stage because they fail to give the right kind of supportive attention that breathes courage back into a shell-shocked newbie. This person still need lots of direction and also support, encouragement, and a sounding board to check reality. “You can do this!”
S3—Supporting. This volunteer is now more capable; having pushed through inevitable obstacles and difficult kids or parents, he or she has some significant and fruitful ministry experience behind him or her. But fruitful leaders in this quadrant are typically still unsure whether they can do this task alone, without being held by the hand. They still need and want your support, but that support gravitates toward encouragement of their leadership strengths, trusting they have what it takes to lead. You are mostly encouraging them to figure out next steps—you trust them, and you tell them so.
S4—Delegating. This leader is now able and willing to make ministry happen and to train and raise up other leaders. You are able to give this leader less time in both direction and support. As a trusted team partner, you have not only gained loyalty and love but have also multiplied leadership.
Situational leadership reminds us that we need to know our partners in ministry and apply the appropriate kind of support and direction depending on their commitment and competence. Whenever a new skill or responsibility is required, any given leader can quickly move back to the S1 quadrant, needing clear and straightforward direction until he or she builds new competence and confidence, which will lead to greater commitment. This requires a primus leader to pay close attention to the team, offer timely and appropriate support, hand over real responsibility, and empower others to live into the call God speaks to them.
But situational leadership is not the goal. The goal is increasing the maturity, confidence, and competence of specific volunteers and entire teams. The more confident and competent the volunteer, the more important it becomes to function as a fully equal primus leader. The more insecure and immature the person being led, the more he or she will want and need you to be hierarchical and seemingly directive in style, at least for a season, while maintaining the attitude of mutual respect and equality. Our goal must always be to lead volunteers and teams into maturity and interdependence by intentionally moving them along the continuum toward confidence and competence. Our goal is individual, team, and community transformation and empowerment. Primus leadership needs to be adaptable and flexible, which is why the model of situational leadership is so important.
Cultivating Healthy Leadership Environments
The word recruiting, when applied to church ministry, is a bit distasteful—it can sound manipulative and self-serving. Rather than recruiting, we are essentially inviting people to consider participating on an adoptive leadership team, becoming a part of the family that embraces young people. A common perceived plight and/or question voiced by many leaders is, “I don’t have enough helpers for my program. How do I get more leaders?” Most likely you have felt the panic and desperation that comes from knowing you need others to join you in loving, leading, and adopting kids.
Health breeds health, so in Christian leadership people come first. Considering what I have discussed, does your theology and practice of leadership lead you to treat people as objects to fulfill your agenda or as individuals discovering and living out the emerging call that God is growing in their lives? Jesus calls all of us, as we align our lives to his purposes, to participate in his kingdom work. We have the great honor of connecting with all sorts of laborers in God’s great rescue operation. Every person is a potential candidate for the ministry to which God has called each one. Everyone is called to serve others, regardless of whether they know it or not, and all of us are on a continuum of personal development and gift discovery, increasing our confidence and competence as we enter into ministry.
Consider some of the reasons we avoid inviting volunteers onto a youth ministry team. We may lack faith—we possess a shaky belief that God and people will come through. Recruiting takes a lot of work—it is messy and complicated. Our pride gets in the way—no one can lead the ministry as well as we can. We struggle with nearsightedness—we perpetually get caught up in the urgent rather than important. We have an inability to relate to adults; as a result of our work, we have become isolated from an adult community. We are stubbornly unwilling to empower others through mentoring and delegation; we define our identity by what we do rather than what others do. In addition to all of this, insecurity may continue to fester deep inside.
A Secure Leader versus an Insecure Leader*
A Secure Leader
An
Insecure Leader
Encourages others’ attempts
Sabotages others’ efforts
Points out others’ strong points
Brings attention to others’ faults
Overlooks flaws
Uses others’ flaws as ammunition
Readily admits own mistakes
Is defensive and justifies mistakes
Gives away credit to others
Demands or manipulates credit
Rejoices when others succeed
Is jealous of others’ successes
Is excited when others do it better
Is easily intimidated
Is willing to risk to improve
Plays it safe to retain position
Is content to remain anonymous
Requires others to notice
Is quick to build teams
Wants to do things himself or herself
Doing Church as a Team
We must build people first and then allow ministry programs to flow out of our relational response to need and gifting. For example, we often start a summer program planning process with the question, “What do you want to do?” We fill the calendar and then must go out and find (and even beg) adults to staff and lead the programs we planned—whether or not they sense a call or the gift to lead within the purpose of this effort. When we understand our primary or ultimate task to be running programs, we will be tempted to use people through coercion, even if they are not the right people for the role. Frustration, discouragement, lack of trust, and burnout often result.
An alternative is to ask God, “Who are the people, both adults and students, you have given us, and how can we develop these people in order to fulfill the calling you have for them, and for us, in the ministry you have given us this summer?” “Us” language reveals a more conducive attitude toward both people and programs, within the family of families.
Characteristics of Exceptional Volunteers
What kind of adults do we seek to influence the lives of students through our relational and programmatic networks in ministry? Be on the lookout for leaders who are willing to make one of their highest priorities the acceleration of healthy development in adolescents.
When it comes to thinking about the prototypical volunteer we might seek for leadership in a ministry to adolescents, what kinds of stereotypes exist in our churches? What image gets flashed across our minds? Doug Fields lists ten stereotypes: young, funny, athletic, good in front of crowds, strong teacher, lots of Bible knowledge, outgoing personality, charisma, understands youth culture, and owns a van. To create an embracing culture in which young people are drawn into life-altering and inclusive relationships within the wider spiritual family, we must force ourselves and convince others to break out of stereotypes and consider the relational dynamics and actions that matter to kids.
I don’t ever care what a person’s spiritual gifts are. I want to know two things: Do they authentically love Jesus Christ, and do they like people? —L. David Cowie, former senior pastor, University Presbyterian Church, Seattle
When you are building a team and consider a potential volunteer, ask, “Are they relationally driven?” This doesn’t mean your team can’t benefit greatly from task-oriented folks, but it is imperative that every member can get along with people and is able to work through conflicts. If you have been in ministry for even a short time, you have probably encountered people who have a passion for working with kids but don’t like or can’t relate to anyone else, especially other adults. This will sabotage a ministry; it creates toxicity and prompts kids to run.
If volunteers are moving toward allowing Jesus to form their lives spiritually, are grounded in their love of God, and like people, you will be able to address inevitable challenges and resolve relational difficulties. Notice that the emphasis is on liking people, not just kids. This matters. Everyone in the church body is a potential contributor for service in support of adolescents. We must open our eyes and expand our vision about the possibilities and calling of a wide variety of people who can surround students with care, both up close and at a distance.
Cultivating Strategies for Finding Volunteers
What would you do if you had ten potential and capable volunteers right now? Do you have a plan for how you would care for and deploy them into ministry? The plan needs to include their ministry description, assignment, parameters for leading, and ways they will be trained and led. A clear and simple pathway to real ministry is attractive to potential volunteers. Your well-thought-through plan will take you to the next level in developing a thriving volunteer team.
The plan helps transition from maintaining to building a ministry.
Here is a profound relational ministry axiom: take good care of the few volunteers you have and let that investment spill over into the rest of the church and organization. How you treat the few will determine how many and what kind of other leaders are drawn to join the team. Are you looking past your current team, wistfully moaning about the lack of volunteers?
As you take care of the people God has given you, you will discover a significant cultivating strategy: your best recruiters are your current team members. Outstanding volunteers are drawn to the ethos created by a high-functioning leadership environment. Vital volunteers who love their ministry experience will naturally tell others about the team.
For leadership, achieving a vision requires motivating and inspiring people to stay on board and move together toward a common goal. To do this well, a leader must recognize basic human needs such as the need to make a meaningful contribution and to belong. Individuals in an organization bring with them their values and deeply held beliefs, their aspirations and desires to achieve. Leaders who can acknowledge and tap into these sources of creativity and passion will find the fuel needed to transform the idealism of their vision into a lived reality.
As we learn to love one another on the team, we determine to be the people of God before doing the work of God. A word of caution: don’t let the desire for rich adult community overshadow ministry to students. We must hold the two in balance. Stoking the vision of each individual team member, including the impact each can make as a member of a dynamic team, leads to healthy interdependence—“we are better together.” Max De Pree wisely taught his leadership team that “effectiveness comes about through enabling others to reach their potential—both their personal potential and their corporate or institutional potential.” Inviting potential volunteers into a loving team of like-minded leaders who are making something happen that is bigger than them is compelling.
As we design a programmatic response that leads to adoption, we discover that every youth ministry program is an opportunity not only to accomplish ministry goals but also, and primarily, to facilitate transforming relationships between healthy adults and students who are connected to their families. A healthy team is facilitated when volunteers know experientially that they are indispensable to the fulfillment of the ministry vision and dream.
Volunteers often worry about their effectiveness—their fit, skill, and relational capacity with kids. People are not afraid to give of themselves and invest deeply in ministry, as long as they are not left alone to figure out what to do next. Volunteers need support, encouragement, and resourcing. As primus leaders we must curate materials, opportunities, and people who will invest in the ongoing development of the team.
Highly developed volunteers can’t afford to waste their time investing in busywork or babysitting; they need to know that, along with the kids, they are moving toward deeper formation in Christ. If you ask most people about their experience of being on a typical church committee, more than we may want to admit will likely reflect that their relationship with Christ suffered while serving. Remember, we develop rather than use people. Be the people of God before you do the work of God.
This is the primary responsibility of the primus in a Christian ministry. We do this in response to the needs of the individual people God is calling our way. Our path is intentional because we care not only for what the volunteer produces or gives to us but also for him or her as a unique and valuable person. As a result, healthy people attract other healthy people.
Leader Selection
When selecting potential leaders for ministry, we will refuse the temptation to fling wide the door, giving cavalier access to students. We will be selective—since it is easier to hire than fire. We will be protective—of kids, other leaders, our own reputation, and our church. We will be direct—by asking pointed questions as we pursue concerns. We will be discerning—by taking the time to evaluate motivation. We will be clear—by providing tangible steps for a potential volunteer to take in order to be on the team.
In Purpose Driven Youth Ministry, Dough Fields provides ten clear steps a potential volunteer will take to get formally placed on a ministry team. You may want to adapt this list for your ministry context. The potential volunteer will move through the following steps:
Though there is flexibility in the precise order of these steps, this flow ensures prospective team members are guided through the process in a way that helps them, and you, make an informed decision.
Provide a Volunteer Application Packet
A volunteer packet that includes everything volunteers need to understand the nature of serving in the ministry should be readily accessible to interested people. This packet will also provide the information you need to make a good decision about their involvement.
The volunteer packet potentially includes: a welcome letter; an overview of what students need in a caring adult; the purpose statement and values of the church and ministry; general job descriptions; the involvement steps; the application; and a request for references and background check. Healthy teams have clearly established roles, responsibilities, and expectations.
An effective volunteer application includes general information—like name, contact information, marital status, education, and church affiliation. Be sure to ask about the leader’s spiritual pilgrimage, ministry background, and experience but also include an opportunity for personal responses. Give space and ask a few open-ended questions about the volunteer’s motivation, preferred roles, character issues, and criminal history. Finally, be sure to ask for references and seek permission to conduct a background check.
Meet for an Interview, Face-to-Face
Be proactive and set up a face-to-face interview for the purpose of discerning the appropriate fit and placement for each potential volunteer. Once again, it is important to receive the completed application prior to any interview. This will ensure that you have adequate and helpful information as you dialogue about possible roles. Meet in a comfortable setting so that you can be relaxed yet intentional in getting together. Review the application before the interview and develop a list of questions that can guide the discussion. Get in the practice of holding back a promise about involvement in the ministry until after you meet for an interview. Invite the volunteer to talk more about his or her application, life journey, ministry experience, and passions. It is in this interview that you can begin to get clarity together on whether that person fits best in a support or direct ministry role.
Contact Their References
Find a way—whether through phone, in person, or electronically—to receive honest feedback about the character of the potential volunteer. This assumes you have already requested the names of several people who could serve as a reference. Ask the reference, “What are some strengths this person brings to youth ministry, and do you have any reservations you can share with me?”
Invite Them to Observe the Ministry
Make sure that during the selection process, and preferably early on, you give the potential volunteer a mandated monthlong opportunity to observe several of your ministry programs that include students. This is not the time to engage in direct ministry roles or demonstrate ministry skills but rather to observe “who we are and what we do.” It is important he or she gets a feel for the nature of what the ministry is about and to see students and other volunteers in action.
Assign a Mentor or Coach for the Volunteer’s First Year
It is vital that no volunteer be sent into ministry without proper orientation and support. A mentor or a coach is someone who has been around student ministry, especially within your church context, for a while. Some of the best coaches are longtime leaders who are ready for the transition to being a “leader of leaders.” This is the kind of veteran who can walk alongside and offer support, encouragement, and training on the go while keeping a watchful and caring eye on the new recruit. This is especially important during the first three months. Most volunteers who quit in frustration do so early on. The coach can provide all the initial orientation and training to help the new leader not only get off on the right, confident footing but also get the sense that he or she is truly a full-fledged member of the team. This is a good place for careful situational leadership, which was discussed earlier.
Conclusion
In youth ministry, leaders represent the community of faith. As a primus leader, your role is to call the church to adoption. Leaders become adoption mentors as they model welcoming care, inviting children and adolescents to fully participate in the life of the community. Adoptive youth ministry exists only to invite young people into the community. This is why youth ministry is so valuable and important. The ministry itself is a bridge between the abandoned world of adolescence and the family of God. Recruiting, choosing, training, nurturing, and leading volunteers and staff is a vital part of helping young people to know that they matter—and that people care about them.
