8. Youth Ministry, Adoption, and Culture
If there is any single voice who has helped youth ministry practitioners around the world to think critically and theologically about culture, it is Walt Mueller. Mueller has served the church as an author, consultant, encourager, thinker, speaker, and teacher for nearly three decades. While some decry people with influence and degrees, assuming that they do not understand the field or the trenches, Mueller has always been deeply engaged in both. He understands the demands of youth ministry; he spends most of his time walking alongside those who are working in churches and parachurch organizations with teenagers, and he is one of the most respected leaders in helping parents, educators, and youth workers to understand the cultural pond they find themselves immersed in.
This chapter, like a few other chapters in Adoptive Youth Ministry, is an example of a significant leader’s particular and unique perspective. As representative of his other writings, this chapter both describes the world in which we all live and helps us to navigate what today’s culture brings and does to all of us, especially young people. The way that Mueller leads us is by looking at the specificity of what he calls “youth culture.” His intent from the outset is threefold: first, to help us realize that our ministry to young people is cross-cultural; second, our understanding of how young people see and experience their cultural setting will help us to be more deliberate and careful in our ministry to them; and third, by having a greater awareness of the changing culture in our kids’ lives we will be better able to “contextualize” our ministry to speak into the world in which they live.
On this chapter’s webpage, not only will you be able to look more deeply at Mueller’s perspective and the work of the organization he leads, the Center for Parent and Youth Understanding, but you will also be able to stay on top of the trends and issues that he mentions. His organization is also available for seminars and consultations for churches, communities, and denominations.
As you read this chapter, consider these questions:
My good friends Ben and Cindy starred in a reality show. The show tracked the stories of couples who chose to adopt. In every instance, the individual stories were embedded in good lighting, strategic camera angles, and carefully edited video clips, all of which were held together with perky narration and a musical soundtrack designed to elicit heart tugs, tears, and warm feelings from viewers. That was certainly the case for me as I watched Ben and Cindy’s very touching televised story of adopting three elementary-aged siblings out of an orphanage in South America.
We should cry tears of joy at adoption stories. Adoption is about making rights out of horrible wrongs and wholeness out of brokenness. It’s about working to bring shalom into young and vulnerable lives struggling to live in the wake of the effects of sin, brokenness, and systemic abandonment. It’s about offering a place to call home to those who have no real home, providing familial love and relationship to those who have had no family due to choice or circumstance, and bestowing a standing and inheritance that didn’t exist before the adoption. In so many ways, adoption is about belonging. How can we not be moved by adoption?
But any family that has gone through the process of adoption will also tell you that adoption, like everything else in life, includes a good dose of messiness. Shouldn’t that be expected when broken people adopt broken people?
For my friends Ben and Cindy, their TV show only told the feel-good part of the story. Their decision to adopt was also a decision to enter into a clash of cultures as they were integrating three young children from another country who spoke another language and lived by another set of customs and rules into an American family. While family life (adoptive or biological) is never easy, smooth, and squeaky-clean, Ben and Cindy faced even greater difficulties due to cultural differences. They had to learn not only how to be parents but also how to be cross-cultural missionaries.
The story of the growth and expansion of God’s family—the church—in today’s rapidly changing world is similarly complex. God’s family is made up of broken people who await the day when they and everything else will be made new. God is not only bringing together a family made up of people, tribes, and nations separated by geographical and cultural differences (“all the world”), but he is also calling and adopting children and teens who live in our homes and communities into his family. And while these adopted children of God (John 1:12–13) may live with us, their world is very different from ours. We cannot assume that they think, talk, believe, or act the way that we do. Consequently, the family of God—both globally and locally—will always be multicultural in some way, shape, or form. This reality necessitates our willingness as older and more mature sisters and brothers in Christ (including parents, pastors, youth workers, Christian educators, and mentors—the entire local church body!) to see ourselves as cross-cultural missionaries who must assume a cross-cultural posture if we are to effectively communicate the message of the gospel (invite them into the family), nurture them in the gospel (integrate them as growing members of the family who both contribute to and benefit from their place as siblings), and send them forth with the gospel (equip them to be kingdom bearers in the world who interact with and function in culture to the glory of God).
I have found it helpful to visualize cultural change through what has become known in the world of technology as “Moore’s Law.” In the mid-1960s, Gordon Moore, the cofounder of Intel, postulated that the number of transistors a circuit board could hold would double every two years. All of us who are computer users have benefited from the reality of what Moore predicted, as this kind of exponential growth has resulted in rapid changes in computer technology and speed. (Have you ever considered that the smartphone in your hand has more power and potential than the NASA computer that landed the first astronauts on the moon?) In the same way, the rate of cultural change is reaching speeds that those of us who were doing youth ministry in the 1970s and 1980s could never have imagined! The size and scope of the world is expanding far beyond our familiar surroundings and experience. The world of the emerging generations is not our world. Their distinct youth culture is not our culture.
A few years ago, I spent a day speaking to a group of youth workers about the changes taking place in youth culture and the cultural trends they needed to address in their ministries. A young youth worker came to me afterward and said, “Thanks for today. Everything you talked about I’m seeing in my ministry. This has been very helpful.” “Where are you doing ministry?” I asked. He replied, “I’m working in the high school I graduated from. It’s an after-school mentoring program for at-risk kids. I go back on that campus and the culture of these kids is so different from when I was a student.” Curious about his age and how long it had been since he had graduated, I asked, “When did you graduate?” His answer: “Last year.” Indeed, culture is changing at breakneck speed.
If we are to answer God’s call to reach out to the mission field of the emerging generations and incorporate those among them who are called and adopted by God into the life of our churches as our siblings in the faith, we will experience three inevitable and inescapable realities related to youth culture. First, we will have to embrace the reality that we are engaging with a culture that is different from our own. Our living together as brothers and sisters adopted into the family of God will be cross-cultural in nature. Second, when we go from our culture into theirs, we will experience some amount of culture shock. But the level and intensity of that shock can be buffered if we take the time to understand culture and how it functions in people’s lives, particularly in the lives of those from the emerging generations God brings in to our midst. And third, our ministries of evangelism and nurture to the young in our midst will require us to know their culture, contextualize our efforts, and speak to the unique issues and challenges they face that come with following Jesus in the midst of this rapidly changing culture.
These realities are not at all unique to our times. The model for this type of cross-cultural adaptation is the incarnation of the God-man, Jesus Christ. God sent his son Jesus, a particular man, into a particular world at a particular time and to a particular place. “The Word became flesh and blood, and moved into the neighborhood” (John 1:14 Message). Jesus lived among those to whom he ministered. He participated in their lives by sharing in their day-to-day activities and tasks. He became intimately familiar with their language, values, beliefs, customs, and thoughts.
The Scriptures also give us numerous models of unique people (messengers and missionaries) sent to unique cultural groups to communicate the unchanging message of the gospel. The apostle Paul stands out as one who adapted not the message but his presentation of the message, depending on the audience and their culture. When we read the book of Acts we see how his presentation changed and adapted from audience to audience. Of course, he wasn’t just thinking on his feet. This man who became “all things to all men” had, as Jerram Barrs says, “done his homework. He respected his hearers sufficiently and had a deep enough care for them that he had worked at understanding their ideas and their religion.” He learned their “language” so that they were able to understand the message he was called to communicate.
The New Testament is filled with letters written to communicate clearly with individuals and churches who had unique spiritual needs that had to be addressed in the contexts of their distinctive cultures. Church history and missions are filled with these same types of examples, but so are the fields of missiology, translation, and contextualization, which have burgeoned as Christians throughout history have realized the necessity of knowing both message and audience if effective communication and ministry is to take place.
This task is especially important for anyone hoping to evangelize and nurture young people in a rapidly changing world. In an interview with Time magazine, twentieth-century theologian Karl Barth said that he advised young theologians to pursue knowledge of both Scripture and culture when he said, “Take your Bible and take your newspaper, and read both. But interpret newspapers from your Bible.” Barth knew how essential it was to know both the message and the cultural issues to which that message had to respond.
Theologian John Stott believed that the foundation for effective cross-cultural communication and ministry is what he called “double listening.” This is the ability and resolve to listen to two voices at one time. He says that all Christians are called to “stand between the Word and the world, with consequent obligation to listen to both. We listen to the Word in order to discover evermore of the riches of Christ. And we listen to the world in order to discern which of Christ’s riches are needed most and how to present them in their best light.” With our understanding of the Word (Bible) and the world (newspaper/culture) we can then contextualize the gospel and our ministry efforts in meaningful ways that speak to the emerging generations and to the unique cultural challenges and pressures that they are facing in today’s world.
In A Many Colored Kingdom: Multicultural Dynamics for Spiritual Formation, Gary Parrett offers guidance on how to become a “culturally sensitive minister.” He relates a helpful real-life example of the importance of an exhaustive and multilayered approach to getting to know a young person and his or her culture.
To illustrate, let us consider the case of a young woman who was part of a church project that I and several others worked on years ago. I will call her Sandy. Suppose I was a new pastor in Sandy’s church and desired to minister to her in a culturally sensitive way. How could I equip myself for the task? As a shepherd, I would be committed to knowing my sheep, each one, individually, seeking the same spirit in which our Lord Jesus, the Good Shepherd, ministers to his own (see John 10:10–30). I might ask the question, “Who is Sandy anyway?” How might I answer this query? Sandy is a Korean-American teen-aged girl. These few descriptive words, by themselves, evince the complexity of the challenge. I must understand something about the meaning of “American” and of “Korean” and of the hybrid form, “Korean-American.” But there is also the matter of being a teenager in America. Thus, I must also know something about so-called youth culture and the various potential influences it can have on Sandy. She is a young woman, not a young man, and this too is a critical piece of who Sandy is. But the case is more complex still. Sandy lives in a particular geographical region of the United States. She is part of an evangelical church youth group. It is a Korean-American youth group. She reports to me that it is very different from the other Korean-American youth groups in her area. She thinks the “climate” is more spiritual in her church than it is in others she has visited. She attends a particular high school and, at that school, “hangs” with a particular group of friends. We could, of course, continue the exercise, but the point should be clear. A person’s culture is multilayered and exceedingly complex.
This task of contextualization is an essential ingredient in effective youth ministry. Contextualization is defined both as “taking the gospel to a new context and finding appropriate ways to communicate it so that it is understandable to the people in that context” and “the practice of declaring or depicting and living out the gospel message in cultural forms and terms drawn predominantly from the frame of reference of those you are communicating with.” Again, the book of Acts and Paul’s New Testament letters show the apostle’s consistent commitment to contextualize his message to his hearers, shaping his presentation to each unique audience in order that they might have the opportunity to hear the good news. He was “faithful and relevant, not merely trendy.”
We are all responsible to be on our toes, knowing not only our rapidly changing culture and its effect on the emerging generations but also how culture is subtly changing as it develops and how it is uniquely affecting the individual young people God places in our lives. In other words, it is necessary to search for, recognize, and understand the unique aspects that mark the culture of your particular mission field of young people. Missions theorist Sherwood Lingenfelter says that “we must be learners and let them teach us before we can hope to teach them and introduce them to the master Teacher.” In effect, we must become like the men “from Issachar, men who understood the times and knew what Israel should do” (1 Chron. 12:32). Dean Borgman challenges us to realize that one of our main tasks “is to make divine revelation (the Bible and especially Jesus Christ) relevant and coherent to any particular age and society. To fulfill that task with regard to young people, we must learn a great deal about culture.” For example, what does their culture say about issues like identity, materialism, vocation, play, relationships, marriage, sexuality, racism, entitlement, narcissism, and so on?
Consequently, our youth ministries must not only grapple with some foundational questions about culture but must seek, develop, and communicate well-framed answers to these questions among our individual church family, along with the pursuit of the practical implementation of each:
What Is Culture?
Culture is what we believe, what we do, and how we live our lives from day to day. It is the identity that defines us individually and binds us to others who think, do, and live in a similar manner. Stott describes culture as “a tapestry, intricate and often beautiful, which is woven by a given society to express its corporate identity.”
While most spiritual siblings from across the generations in our churches generally speak the same language and share a common faith in God, there are markedly different cultures present. These differences are occasioned by a multiplicity of factors including our ages, where we grew up, and the kinds of families that we come from. Our life experiences and contexts are different. We all engage with different cultural influences and artifacts. The “tapestries” of our lives do share some common threads, but each is unique. Our individual cultural tapestries contain “values and assumptions which are expressed in a life style” that are unique to ourselves and those like us. Our cultures transmit the meaning that life has for each of us. Our cultures are where, how, and what we have lived, are living, and will live in the future.
Social scientists define and describe culture in a variety of ways. Missiologist Harold Netland has studied the need to understand and know culture as a necessary step in engaging those who have been shaped by the pluralism of our twenty-first-century times. He says:
It is helpful to think of culture as a historically transmitted pattern of meanings embodied in symbols that are reflected in behavior, values, ideas and institutions through which people understand the cosmos and their place in it, communicate with each other and structure communal life patterns. As such, culture includes the products of a wide variety of human activities—reflection upon life experiences and the world around us; communication with others; the establishment of normative patterns of individual and communal behavior; relationships with others; social and political institutions, artistic expressions and so on. Culture includes the many dimensions of social life through which people make sense of their experiences and pass on to succeeding generations the wisdom and expectations thus acquired.
William Romanowski offers a simpler and more direct definition of culture as the way that “humans define and live in God’s world.” It is “a collection of ideals and beliefs, values, and assumptions that makes up a kind of master plan for living and interpreting life.”
When I speak to those who desire to understand and minister to the emerging generations, I offer them a simplistic working definition of culture that captures the essence of how we can most easily begin to understand how our children and teens define and live in God’s world. Simply stated, culture is “the soup” that the emerging generations swim in every day. Consequently, if we want to engage the young for the sake of the gospel, we’d better take the time to know what’s in the soup.
The soup bar at one of our local mega-buffets serves as a great example of how to understand and examine the cultures of our young. In this particular restaurant, the soup bar typically features three soup selections every day. I have watched how people choose their soup. As they arrive at the soup bar, they grab a bowl before making their selection. Then they step back and scan the small cards on the counter that name the type of soup in each of the large steel soup tureens. Before placing soup in their bowl, they will lift the steel lid off the tureen, grab the ladle, and stir the soup so that the ingredients are evenly distributed. Then, after the soup has been stirred, they will lift a ladleful and examine it visually. They want to know the soup’s ingredients. If they like what they see, they’ll fill their bowl. If not, they may move on to examine the next selection in the same manner.
If we and our church families are to effectively engage our children and teens with the truths of the gospel in ways they can hear and understand, we must step up to their world, lift the lid, stir it up, and look carefully at the unique and ever-changing mix of cultural elements and forces they live and swim in every day. We cannot escape the reality that those elements—which may seem strange, unusual, and even frightening to us—make up their environment, shape the way they look at the world, and define and govern how they live their lives. We might even be tempted to close the lid because we don’t like what we see. But if we hope to effectively communicate God’s unchanging good news and nurture the faith of the young in our midst, it’s not an option to avoid facing and understanding the culture that reveals so much about who they are, why they’re that way, what it is that gives them meaning in life, and how they choose to live that life in God’s world.
For the cross-cultural missionary called to go into the world of the young (i.e., every member of our adopted faith family), it’s important to approach our observations and perceptions of each unique culture by understanding three foundational aspects of culture that are shared by all cultures in all times and all places. These foundational aspects include the characteristics of culture, the elements of culture, and the functions of culture.
What Are the Characteristics of Culture?
What are the characteristics of culture that we must understand if we are to prepare ourselves and our churches to effectively take our place and fulfill our role as cross-cultural missionaries to children and teens growing up and living in the twenty-first-century world?
First, we must understand that culture is a good thing that has been created by God and given to humanity as a gift to use and perpetuate. In the book of Genesis, we read about the wonder of God’s creation as he spends six days forming and filling the heavens and the earth. On the sixth day, the Creator of the universe creates the crowning point of his creation:
Then God said, “Let us make mankind in our image, in our likeness, so that they may rule over the fish in the sea and the birds in the sky, over the livestock and all the wild animals, and over all the creatures that move along the ground.”
So God created mankind in his own image,
in the image of God he created them;
male and female he created them. (Gen. 1:26–27)
On the seventh day, God rested. But even though God was done creating, the work of creation carried on. His image bearers now inhabited what he had made, and he gave them the responsibility to enjoy, care for, and develop all he had made. He gave them the responsibility to “work it and take care of it” (Gen. 2:15). Before resting, he blessed the image bearers he had made and commanded them to “be fruitful and increase in number; fill the earth and subdue it. Rule over the fish in the sea and the birds in the sky and over every living creature that moves on the ground” (Gen. 1:28). As theologian Albert Wolters says of God’s instructions to the people he made in his image and of their responsibility to his created order, “People must now carry on the work of development: by being fruitful they must fill it even more; by subduing it they must form it even more. Mankind, as God’s representatives on earth, carry on where God left off. But this is now to be a human development of the earth. The human race will fill the earth with its own kind, and it will form the earth for its own kind.”
In effect, “We are called to participate in the ongoing creational work of God, to be God’s helper in executing to the end the blueprint for his masterpiece.” As God-imaging and God-commanded cultivators of the creation, our creativity results and is expressed in human culture. We become, as Andy Crouch so effectively explains, “culture makers.” Culture is a good gift given to us by God, entrusted to us by him to develop as responsible stewards. This implies not only that it is wrong for us to label culture as “evil” or a place for Christians to avoid (as so many have!) but also that we need to nurture the emerging generations into embracing culture as “a playground” on which to celebrate and indulge the imago Dei.
Second, culture is universal among all humans. While our cultures will differ from generation to generation, place to place, and time to time, everyone lives in and does culture no matter who they are. Wherever there are people, there is culture. The songwriter who prayerfully constructs her music to the glory of the one who has redeemed her and the unredeemed songwriter whose only desire is to bring glory to himself are both made in the image of God. As a result, both have been made and called to cultivate the creation. Whether they do so consciously or not, to the glory of God or not, both are making culture. Culture is a common human endeavor.
Third, culture is shared as a system for living by those in a particular society. The same is true for subcultures within a society. A visit to a local high school reveals that while there is a general culture of students with shared values, attitudes, and behaviors, the larger student population can be divided into several unique subcultures. There are the band members, the athletes, the scholars, the goths, and the cowboys, among others. Each particular group is marked by a unique mix of beliefs, behaviors, interests, language, dress, and so on that binds them together while distinguishing them from the other groups. They are little “societies” sometimes populated by no more than a handful or “cluster” of students. But each individual finds his or her identity and some sense of security in the group because of a shared culture.
Fourth, culture is not something we’re born with. Rather, we are born into it, and it is learned. Missiologist David Hesselgrave points out that culture “is not biologically determined or restricted by race.” We learn and live our culture as we grow up in our families, schools, churches, and communities. For the most part, we unconsciously assimilate the culture that is lived around us, including all of its rites, habits, rituals, and behaviors. It is what becomes normal to us because “it’s always been that way.” But in a rapidly changing world full of options that are easily accessed through our globalized media, more and more young people are consciously choosing to adopt and live out cultures that are markedly different from those within which they have been raised.
Fifth, culture is an integrated whole. Like a living organism, every culture is made up of many different parts that are all interrelated; it is an ecological system. Add a new ingredient, eliminate a component, or change something ever so slightly, and the entire composition is altered. Each part affects the others. If a culture places high value on human life, that value will be reflected in human relations, in conflict resolution, in medical practices, in how business is conducted, and so on. If humanity is devalued, that will be reflected in attitudes and behaviors related to issues like abortion, euthanasia, treatment of workers, friendships, and so on. The responsibility of the cultural observer is to discover and understand each part of the cultural soup and how those parts combine and relate as a whole.
Sixth, culture isn’t static. In a rapidly changing world, cultures will not only grow, change, evolve, and develop, but they also will do so at a faster and faster pace as the years go by and the rate of change continues to accelerate. Cultures will develop new elements on their own, assimilate elements of other cultures, and discard those elements that are either outdated or no longer necessary. Consequently, those who desire to understand the culture of the emerging generations can never assume that their job is a once-and-done endeavor. It is an ongoing process that requires continued and diligent observation on a day-to-day basis. While we may stand in the same spot in our yards day after day, the air that we breathe at that spot changes from minute to minute. It’s never the same air twice. So it is with culture in our fast-paced world. Every minute brings change.
What Are the Elements of Culture?
As the cross-cultural missionary stirs the soup, there are certain ingredients to look for, examine more closely, and seek to understand. While they might at times seem small and insignificant, these individual ingredients are nevertheless important because they are part of the whole system and can offer us valuable insight into who young people are, how they think, what they value, why they do what they do, and—most important—how we can best reach them with the gospel and then nurture them into integrating Christian faith into all of life.
No doubt the growing list of social media miscommunications occasioned by the cultural ignorance of the older generations who didn’t grow up in a social-media-saturated world reveals the need to examine two levels that exist in every culture. Consider this now-famous text exchange (thanks to the viral nature of social media!) between a mother (digital immigrant) and her teenaged son (digital native). Mom: “Your great aunt just passed away. LOL.” Son: “Why is that funny???” Mom: “It’s not funny David! What do you mean?” Son: “Mom lol means laughing out loud.” Mom: “Oh my goodness! I sent that to everyone. I thought it meant lots of love. I have to call everyone back. Oh God.”
This simple illustration offers an example of the two levels of cultural ingredients that always exist and the importance of looking for, examining, and understanding both. There is the level of culture that we empirically see, feel, hear, taste, and touch every day of our lives. In this case, it was the texting slang “LOL.” But the fact that the same texting slang was used by two different people from two different generations with two different meanings reveals a deeper level of culture. That second level is the unseen foundational level that lies beneath the outward expressions that we encounter every minute of every day. It is the level of underlying meaning. Foundationally, the mom used “LOL” as she understood the abbreviation in the vocabulary of her culture—to indicate to her son and other relatives that she was concerned for them in the midst of hearing this grievous announcement. To her son, “LOL” not only meant something entirely different, but it was also entirely inappropriate in light of Aunt Martha’s death!
Our examination of both levels of cultural elements helps us both to understand the meaning of the outward expressions of another culture that are unfamiliar to us and also to understand and address the tension that exists when the same expression—whether a word, behavior, or texting slang—is used and understood by different people from different cultures in different ways.
Cultural analyst Patty Lane likens these two levels to an iceberg. The “objective culture” or visibly expressed parts of the culture are the part of the iceberg that can be seen above the surface of the water. The hidden aspect that lies beneath the surface of the water is what Lane calls the “subjective culture.” As I have looked, examined, and analyzed youth culture over the years, I have found it helpful to understand these two levels of cultural elements this way: the underlying level of a culture is best described as a “worldview,” and the visible upper level of a culture that expresses that underlying worldview is best described as what the “world views” when they observe people from that culture living out their lives every day. What then are the distinctives of each level?
What lies beneath, at the level of worldview, is the “subjective culture,” which is made up of the values, attitudes, assumptions, beliefs, knowledge, and ideologies held by the people in that culture. As one who studies youth culture I want to stir up the soup young people swim in every day and seek to understand what they believe—either consciously or unconsciously—about God, humanity, life’s purpose, relationships, and so on. I want to seek to discover how they are answering the basic worldview questions. What lies beneath at the level of worldview supports, guides, and defines everything that lies above. “This is the internal part of culture that drives or motivates the visible, objective culture.”
Above the worldview level is the level of what the “world views.” This is the culture that is expressed in daily life. It includes everything we do, everything we make, and how we do and make it all. Because it is more visible, it’s easier to recognize and describe, but it can be puzzling, strange, and difficult to understand. Sometimes our assumptions about the meaning beneath what we see can be totally off base, thereby jeopardizing our ability to connect. Lane refers to this dangerous practice as “misattribution.” It’s that tendency to assume or assign our own sense of meanings and motives to someone’s behavior or objective culture based on what we think those meanings or motives are. If we fall into that easy-to-fall-into trap, our ignorance will cause us to miss the mark on what those meanings and motives really are. To fully understand the meaning of the objective aspect of culture that the world sees, we have to know the underlying worldview, or subjective culture. With time and practice spent observing culture and asking the right questions, we can begin to learn how to use the objective cultural expressions that are seen to help us discern and understand the underlying unseen worldview. The seen and unseen are interrelated, and both must be understood. When approached and examined together, they can help us to understand the emerging generations with a depth and accuracy that will open doors for communicating God’s good news in ways that can be heard and understood by our young audience.
One example that illustrates how this reality works out in life is tattoos. For the most part, the members of the older generations in our churches grew up in world where tattoos were relatively rare in the mainstream culture. Tattoos were limited mostly to the subcultures of bikers and combat vets. Not so in today’s world. Tattoos have gone mainstream. However, many in the older generations look at the objective culture inked onto the bodies of those who are young and have no idea what they mean or why they have them. Based on my own observations of adults, we sometimes view tattooed young people negatively or with scorn. At first glance, some might think that the markings are repulsive, meaningless, faddish, or something that will cause regret later in life. In some cases this might be true. But usually we have fallen into the trap of misattribution, and we haven’t even come close to understanding tattooed young people, their lives, and their culture. If the older generations would take the time to probe deeper by asking about the underlying meaning of someone’s tattoos, they would be able to establish rapport with those who are tattooed and learn so much more about them and their lives.
Ask some young people about their tattoos. Their eyes will light up with excitement. Our question and their response indicate two realities. First, it says “I have an interest in you.” They know that I care enough about them to take the time to let them speak, to listen, and to understand. Second, it tells me that their tattoos mean something important to them. When it comes to tattoos, every picture does tell a story; we need to ask questions and then listen. More and more young people are telling their stories—their subjective culture—through the visible and objective culture on their bodies. Once we know the story, we are better able to speak the gospel to the real issues, questions, needs, and brokenness that exist. Consequently, our audience will be able to hear and understand. If we try to talk to our young people before listening to their reality we will, as Francis Schaeffer has said, “only beat the air.” Schaeffer writes, “We must realize that we are facing a rapidly changing historical situation, and if we are going to talk to people about the gospel we need to know what is the present ebb and flow of thought-forms. Unless we do this, the unchangeable principles of Christianity will fall on deaf ears.”
The subjective worldview of the emerging generations is being expressed in their objective culture in a variety of ways and through a variety of channels. As we seek to understand and reach the emerging generations, we must look for and analyze those channels of behavior and expressions that will give us further insight into who young people are, how they think, and how they live in the world. The following list, while not exhaustive, highlights a few of the main visible and objective ingredients in the youth culture soup that warrant attention as we seek to understand and reach young people. Like tattoos, each can give us great insight into young people, their worldview, and their culture.
How Does Culture Function in the Lives of Kids?
I spent a good portion of my childhood summers swimming in the neighbor’s pool. By the time my mom would call me out of the pool and home for dinner, you could see the effects of being in the water for hours all over my body. My eyes were red, my skin was shriveled, and my head was clogged from the time I had spent underwater.
Swimming in the soup of today’s youth culture isn’t any different, except that our kids are in the “water” twenty-four hours a day. It affects every square inch of their lives in powerful ways. To assume that culture has no influence or function in their lives would be to make a mistake that would lead us to misunderstand who they are and ultimately forfeit our ministry effectiveness. What are the influences, effects, and functions of culture that we need to understand as we shape our cross-cultural ministry approach to the emerging generations?
Culture Is a Map
I remember one of my college professors—a man who had served for many years as an overseas missionary—telling us a story about one of the clashes he experienced as an American living as a foreigner in another culture. One day as he was walking down the street, he saw a man blowing his nose in a curious and strange way, which he had seen many others doing as well. My professor watched as the man stopped walking, leaned forward, covered one nostril with his thumb, and proceeded to exhale hard through his other nostril, emptying the contents of his sinuses right there on the busy sidewalk. This time, his curiosity—and disgust—finally got the best of him. When the man was done, my professor walked up to him and boldly asked in the native language, “Excuse me, sir. Why is it that you blow the contents of your nose onto the sidewalk? I find that to be unhealthy and rather repulsive.” The man looked at my professor and responded, “That’s not repulsive at all. What’s repulsive is what you Americans do. Why do you blow it into a rag and carry it around in your pocket all day?” Both saw the other as odd, while each was doing what they had been taught was normal.
The story serves as a simple illustration of how each man had been taught the “proper” and appropriate way to tend to a runny nose by his respective culture and the powerful role the culture played in teaching him how to live his life. Their cultures had functioned (as all cultures do) as maps, pointing them down the “roads” and to the “destinations” of what was accepted and normal in each particular culture. That didactic role and function of culture exists everywhere in all cultures, and it is especially strong in the lives of children and teens.
The power of culture to teach and shape the young is always strong and significant because of where young people are in the process of physical, emotional, intellectual, social, and spiritual development. On a journey from point A, the dependence of childhood, to point B, the independence of adulthood, the emerging generations are on a quest to discover the meaning of life and find answers to the questions they have about life. Living in the midst of a developmental period marked by more earthshaking change and uncertainty than they’ll ever experience again in their lives, they wonder what is happening to them, where all the change is leading, and where they will wind up. Consequently, they are constantly looking consciously and unconsciously for a map to guide them along the way. The map that unfolds before their eyes in today’s world is the map of their 24-7 youth culture. The map functions as an effective teacher, telling them how to think, what to think, and how to live in the world. The culture defines and shapes their reason for getting up in the morning and guides their decisions on how to spend their day once they’re out of bed.
In effect, culture is directive in that it serves to transmit “the meaning life should have for people.” It is an inescapable fact that we are all products of our culture, and the young are no exception to this rule. It would be a great mistake to miss the simple fact that they are passing through the change-filled period of life that leaves them most open and vulnerable to the influence of culture. Culture’s influence on them during their teenage and young adult years will shape the way they view the world, relate to the world, and live the rest of their lives.
While culture’s mapping influence is always strong, our current globalized and technology-driven culture has created an environment in which the volume has been turned up on culture’s power to shape and teach the emerging generations. In today’s world, elements of popular culture such as music, media, marketing, and digital technology increasingly fulfill this directive role, which has been abandoned by parents who are either physically absent by choice or circumstance from their children’s lives or emotionally and/or spiritually detached because they take little or no interest in the emotional and spiritual nurture of their kids.
Because of their nature and developmental stage, children and teens are like sponges. This fact can be seen in Deuteronomy, where God charges parents and the community to live out his commandments and to “impress them on your children” by talking about them everywhere and at all times (Deut. 6:4–9). But when parents and the community fail to fulfill these “mapping” responsibilities in a deliberate and unified manner, the lessons concerning a biblical worldview can’t and won’t be heard. Of course, even though the lessons are absent, young people continue to probe, question, and learn. They seek out maps and teachers who speak to their needs. In his ongoing analysis of media, George Gerbner has found that its power to teach young people has increased vigorously in recent years. He says, “For the first time in human history, the stories are told not by parents, not by the school, not by the church, not by the community or tribe and in some cases not even by the native country but by a relatively small and shrinking group of global conglomerates with something to sell.” Those conglomerates reach out through the expansive media network for the purpose of generating profit. They do so through advertising products to a generation they have targeted because that generation is loaded with disposable income. Not only are the conglomerates selling product, but they are also selling a worldview and a way of life that will live on in the hearts and minds of young people long after the product has been used and forgotten.
In centuries past, this “mapping” function of guiding the young into what to believe and how to live was an essential part of Christian education, which took place in both the home and the church community. Adopted children of God who were older and more mature in their faith took seriously their responsibility to deliberately and carefully teach, nurture, and equip the young among their number. Though not always consistent, the history of the church recounts how those who were converted to the faith and adopted into the family of God were nurtured in the faith “carefully, prayerfully, and intentionally, with thorough understanding at each stage” of life. This educational “mapping” process is known as catechesis, a word derived from the New Testament word for teaching, katēcheō. “The primary definitions of this term are ‘to share a communication that one receives’ and ‘to teach, instruct.’ Its overtones point to the weight and solemnity of the instruction being given.” J. I. Packer and Gary Parrett define the task of catechesis as “the church’s ministry of grounding and growing God’s people in the gospel and its implications for doctrine, devotion, duty, and delight.”
When the church and home do not intentionally engage in answering the questions of curious young people in ways that will shape them as Christians while grounding them in the gospel for life, young people will still long for and look for answers. In other words, they will seek out and find surrogate teachers and instructors. Because the culture is omnipresent, pervasive, attractive, enticing, and powerfully convincing, it is the culture that will shape their lives. In other words, catechesis will always take place for the simple reason that kids are like sponges. When the church and home aren’t doing the catechizing, the culture will assume that role, offering a 24-7 education that maps out belief and behavior for kids.
Consequently, this is why we need to embrace Barth’s idea of Bible and newspaper and Stott’s practice of “double listening.” We need to know both Word and world. On a practical level, we must read what our kids read, watch what they watch, and listen to what they listen to. This practice of examining their cultural soup allows us to see how the culture is mapping life. Next, it is our responsibility to respond by either affirming the cultural map’s directions because it conforms to God’s will and way or challenging and correcting the cultural map because it is sending them in the wrong direction.
Theologian Darrell Guder gives some guidance when he says that the role of Christians as we interact with other cultures is not primarily to identify the visible characteristics (the objective aspects that the worldviews) of a culture and then apply Christianity to it. The “primary issue, instead, is to identify, name, and critique the ways in which various social realities form or make—cultivate—a people.” In other words, we are not only to come to an understanding of the visible, objective scenery of what lies along the way as the map of culture serves to direct the path of young people, but we also must discover where it’s sending them and how it’s telling them to get there. We must ask, “How is culture shaping them, and what is it teaching (catechizing) them to think and live? How is it shaping their worldview?”
What the map of culture teaches is a way of life. It is our responsibility as cross-cultural missionaries to deconstruct the map and understand how it guides the young each step of their way. To know their map is to know them. Then, and only then, can we enter their lives with a truly Christian response that answers their questions, affirms what’s right with the culture, challenges what’s wrong, and thereby correctively guide their steps in line with the map of a biblical world and life view.
Culture Is a Mirror
My friend Denis Haack understands the reflective power of culture. He writes that one of the reasons Christians should be monitoring, observing, and understanding culture is that it can be “a window of insight into a worldview we do not share.” I like to envision myself standing behind young people as they look into the mirror—or window—of their culture. As I look over their shoulders at the reflection of their lives I want to look at their art, music, advertising, social media, and film, as well as all the other elements of culture mentioned earlier in this chapter. It is especially helpful to look at their habits and observable patterns of behavior, as these offer us great insight into who they are and what they believe. What is reflected back helps me to understand them at a deepened level.
Haack encourages us to actively seek out these “windows of insight” and mirrors into cultures with different worldviews for two reasons.
First, it will give us information about that worldview, about the ideas and values which it contains, and second, it will help us to see life from the perspective of that worldview. If we are to understand those who don’t share our deepest convictions, we must gain some comprehension of what they believe, why they believe it, and how those beliefs work out in daily life. In other words, a window of insight allows us a tiny glimpse inside a worldview we do not share.
Understanding the reflective power of culture and its ability to function as a mirror can serve us in powerful ways as we seek to understand values, attitudes, trends, behaviors, and ideas that have taken hold of the emerging generations and their culture. In addition, by viewing and using young people’s culture as a mirror, those called to minister cross-culturally to the emerging generations will raise their level of understanding of how their own culture has functioned specifically in their lives as a map. It’s another way that we are able to increase our ability to listen and understand. Once we have listened to both Word and world, we can bring the light of God’s Word (through our teaching and modeling) to either correct or affirm the cultural messages.
Culture Is Always Moving and Never Neutral
While culture is never neutral regarding where it comes from (it always references a worldview), it is also never neutral in terms of where it’s going. Just like his human image bearers, God created culture as something good. And just like humanity, culture is marred and polluted as a result of the fall of humanity into sin. Paul tells us that creation joins humanity in “groaning” for redemption and liberation from its “bondage to decay” (Rom. 8:18–23). Until that time of ultimate and final redemption comes, culture and all its elements will be involved in a process of pushing and pulling as its elements, values, attitudes, and behaviors either reflect and bring glory to the kingdom of God or reflect and bring glory to the world, the flesh, and the Devil. As C. S. Lewis describes this reality, there is “no neutral ground in the universe: every square inch, every split second, is claimed by God and counterclaimed by Satan.”
Theologian Albert Wolters offers helpful clarification as he differentiates between “structure” and “direction.” Wolters says that “structure refers to the order of creation, to the constant creational constitution of any thing, what makes it the thing or entity what it is.” When the “thing” we’re talking about is “culture,” we understand its structure to be something positive and good. In its substance, essence, and nature culture was brought into existence by God at creation as part of his perfect created order. “Direction, by contrast, designates the order of sin and redemption, the distortion or perversion of creation through the fall on the one hand and the redemption and restoration of creation in Christ on the other.” In other words, all the ingredients in the cultural soup (language, art, social media, apps, books, etc.), all societal institutions (schools, corporations, marriages, churches, families, etc.), and all human functions (emotions, sexuality, rationality, etc.) are marked by the fingerprint of the Creator and the fingerprint of the fall. As a result, they are moving in the direction of either obedience or disobedience to his law. They are never neutral. “To the degree that these realities fail to live up to God’s creational design for them, they are misdirected, abnormal, distorted. To the degree that they still conform to God’s design, they are in the grip of a countervailing force that curbs or counteracts the distortion.”
As we look at the culture of the emerging generations, every element must be viewed as a map and a mirror. In addition, we must go a step further and discern, under the authority of God’s Word, between those ingredients in the soup that are moving in a direction away from God’s order and design, which must be renounced, and those that are worth retaining, transforming, and enriching because they are moving in the direction of God’s order and design for the world.
I have encountered the complexity of this task repeatedly in my years of speaking to people about contemporary youth culture. I usually encounter the greatest amount of resistance, protest, and disagreement when I show an audience of Christian adults a music video or film clip from the culture of the emerging generations. As you can imagine, the experience forces many adults out of their cultural comfort zone.
In the early 1990s I began showing a powerful music video, “Jeremy,” from the band Pearl Jam. To this day, the video is not only relevant but also listed consistently as one of the top-five music videos of all time. The song and video tell the horrible story of a struggling thirteen-year-old boy who is cut off relationally from his parents and peers. His parents constantly fight, and they fail to give him the attention and love he needs. In school, his peers make fun of him and pick on him every chance they get. As the song comes to its ugly climax, the lyrics tell us that “Jeremy spoke in class today.” The video shows him “speaking” as the powerless and pained young man takes his destiny into his own hands. He walks into the classroom, throws an apple on the teacher’s desk, pulls a pistol from his pants, and proceeds to shoot himself in the head in front of his classmates (the act itself is implied rather than shown).
People wondered what kind of sick and sinful man I was to show such a dark and violent video to a group of adults in a church. Despite the protests, I continued to show the video for years. Why? First, it offered adult viewers a powerful “mirror” experience. The video’s popularity and staying power were testimony to the fact that it was putting into words and pictures the reality of many young kids—kids whose cries for love, time, acceptance, and direction were not being heard by adults. In effect, it was a powerful wake-up call.
Second, I always processed the video with adult viewers by explaining that I thought what they had just seen was one of the most powerful and biblical music videos they’ll ever encounter. No, Pearl Jam’s lead singer and songwriter Eddie Vedder makes no claims to be a follower of Christ. But the song and the video combine in a creative package that truly reflects creative excellence. In that way, Vedder is imaging God. In addition, the song’s message clearly shows the downside of what happens when God’s order and design for the family is not followed. As a piece of art, “Jeremy” was not neutral. In its direction, it was sending a strong message of truth about God and his design and order for his creation, calling all those who viewed it to see how our sinful, culturally accepted distortions of family and relationships have deep and abiding negative consequences. The message is clear: something is wrong, and it must be made right. The video opens tremendous doorways for discussion regarding the answers to the questions posited by a truly biblical worldview.
What Now? Faith, Culture, and the Family of God
Over my years of ministering to youth and studying culture, I have learned that certain core commitments are essential if we hope to speak the truth and nurture the young among us to live the truth in the midst of our rapidly changing world. I’m convinced that we must embrace and pursue these core commitments—in cooperation with the Holy Spirit—to build the church. They should be part of our individual and corporate makeup, marking every nook and cranny of our lives every minute of every day. Two of these commitments are especially relevant to our current discussion of culture.
A Commitment to Be a Student of the Word
As the emerging generation cries out for redemption, they are not ultimately crying out for a relationship with another human being. They are crying out for a restored relationship with their Creator. It is a cry for adoption. If the crux of my ministry is to point them to that relationship, not only must I be in that relationship myself, but I must also studiously seek to grow in both my knowledge of the One who has adopted me and my knowledge of myself as an adopted child of God.
After twenty-five years of what most would say was a successful and fruitful ministry, Henri Nouwen came face-to-face with a simple question that caused him to rethink and evaluate every aspect of his ministry: “Did becoming older bring me closer to Jesus?” He says that he found himself praying poorly, living isolated from others, and preoccupied with the tyranny of the urgent. In his words, he felt he was experiencing “spiritual death.”
No doubt, each of us has experienced the same struggle at some time and at some level. When we submit ourselves to the painful yet helpful process of self-examination, we begin to see the source of our struggle with greater clarity. We soon realize that not only do we experience spiritual death, but we also begin to lose our missional effectiveness as our passion for Christ and our knowledge of the Savior diminish and disappear. We are left powerless and passionless, with nothing to give.
The antidote is to maintain single-minded commitment as a student of the Word—a commitment that involves three crucial and complementary elements that are characteristics of spiritual vitality.
First, we must prayerfully seek to grow closer to the resurrected and incarnate Word, Jesus Christ. Nouwen says that “Christian leaders cannot simply be persons who have well-informed opinions about the burning issues of our time. Their leadership must be rooted in the permanent, intimate relationship with the incarnate Word, Jesus, and they need to find there the source for their words, advice, and guidance.” Nouwen believes the avenue to this intimacy is through the disciplines of contemplative prayer and theological reflection, where time spent with Christ yields the benefit of “thinking with the mind of Christ.” Perhaps part of the blame for the ineffectiveness of the church in reaching the emerging generations is rooted in our lack of consistently exercising these disciplines. While we may be taking the time to know the culture and developing well-planned strategies (based on that cultural knowledge) to be relevant, our lifeline will be cut, and our strategies will cause us to connect to young people without life if we are not first and foremost committed to nurturing our own relationship with Christ.
Second, we must prayerfully seek disciplined study of God’s written revelation of himself. Not only does God have much to say to us, but his Word addresses our contemporary situation and the unique issues facing the emerging generations. Our theological reflection should focus on systematic and disciplined study of the written Word. The failure to know and study the Scriptures as the truth that serves as the foundation for all of life is both a horrible mistake and a recipe for certain ministry disaster and ineffectiveness. Perhaps without knowing it, we have allowed our faith journey to begin and end through a faulty and unconscious literal misunderstanding of Jesus’s words to Nicodemus, “You must be born again” (John 3:7), as if birth—or getting “saved”—is all that is required of us. We come to faith but fail to foster and live the faith in a consistent, integrated fashion. Marva Dawn speaks to the importance of knowing the written Word in today’s postmodern culture if we hope to reach the young: “Raising genuinely Christian children in a culture that rejects as oppressive any comprehensive meta-narrative is NOT a lost cause IF the church stands as an alternative community formed by the meta-narrative of God’s revelation to humankind.”
Third, I must consciously guard against the temptation to reinvent, redefine, or reimagine the Word in my own image—a mistake encouraged and easily (often) made in our twenty-first-century world. It will become easier and easier to sacrifice true biblical faith and understanding on the altar of relevance as our culture shifts deeper and deeper into a post-Christian worldview. Consequently, we must focus on rediscovering and treasuring the truths of orthodox biblical faith, which continue to be relevant from era to era. Thomas Oden’s own spiritual journey from liberalism led him to conclude that classical orthodox Christianity—“the consensual core of beliefs that has been held by a majority of the church throughout the span of its historical existence”—will prove to be a vital source of postmodern orthodoxy.
With the culture catechizing and shaping the thinking, believing, and living of the emerging generations, how can we steer them in the right direction? It starts with our commitment to live in that direction ourselves by being students of the incarnate, resurrected, living, reigning, and written Word. We cannot live, share, or communicate what we do not possess. To lead, we must seek to be led.
A Commitment to Be a Student of Culture
When the apostle Paul finds himself in the unfamiliar pagan culture of Athens (Acts 17), he first walks around the city with his mouth shut and ears and eyes open. He absorbs as much as he can about the culture not only so that he can find evidence of their spiritual hunger but also so that when he opens his mouth to communicate the good news about Jesus Christ he can speak in a language and manner that will invite the Athenians to truly engage with and hear what he has to say. Paul has it right. He realizes that he must not only engage in disciplined study of and reflection on God’s written and incarnate Word, but he must also work to intimately know the culture of those to whom he has been called to minister.
Dean Borgman affirms that “theology begins with an awareness of God and with the exegesis of Scripture.” It is not enough to simply know the Word, even though it might sound like it’s the “holy” and “spiritual thing” to do. We must also know the world. Borgman says, “We often overlook the necessity of an exegesis of culture or world in which we were raised and to which we minister. . . . Theology is a systematic expression of God’s Word in a particular time and space.” Listening and understanding the unique cultural situation of the audience is a necessary prerequisite to effective ministry, that is, ministry that our audience is willing to listen to and able to understand because they have first been listened to and understood. As Gene Veith says, “To ignore the culture is to risk irrelevance.”
Because the culture is changing quickly day by day and is never identical from person to person, group to group, or place to place, cultural literacy is an ongoing process rather than a once-and-done exercise. Even if we find it to be frightening or threatening, we must “stir the soup” and “lift the ladle” regularly. This requires us not only to be aware and wise to the values, attitudes, allegiances, and behaviors of the members of the emerging generations we know and love but also to be aware of what they are reading, watching, and listening to. Then we must engage these elements by reading, watching, and listening to them ourselves. Failing to know the music, films, television, social media, advertising, magazines, and other expressions of young people will lead to failure in ministry. The current shift in worldviews and the rapidity of cultural change require our diligence in cultural exegesis and cultural awareness more than ever before. Dawn writes that there is ample evidence of our failure to do so: “It seems to me that much of the poor child-raising I observe arises because pastors and parents, churches and communities don’t understand what they are up against in their endeavor to form Christian character in young people.” Cross-cultural missions theorist Duane Elmer knows that the remedy lies in understanding what they are up against: “The better we are at interpreting culture, the fewer conflicts we will experience, the more we will be able to build authentic relationships, and the greater will be our ability to communicate God’s truth.”
Our ability to connect with the emerging generations and to establish credibility in their eyes is facilitated through our commitment to diligently work to understand their cultural context. As Myron Augsburger has said, “Unless we so immerse ourselves in the Muslim way of viewing things that we are tempted to become Muslims, we will never reach the Muslim.” The same holds true for our approach to the emerging generations. We must be committed to know and understand their culture better than they understand and know it themselves.
Conclusion
Kids are like the rest of us: broken, groaning for redemption, and longing for a place to belong and to call home. For many, their yearning is amplified by the fact that broken family situations and the lack of healthy peer relationships have left them with a huge relational void.
Regardless of whether or not their lives are marked by excessive relational brokenness, all members of the emerging generation are looking for a place to call home and a people to call “family.” They want connections, relationships, and community. The larger body of Christ should integrate the emerging generations as it assembles for worship, missions, fellowship, education, and service. In other words, we must stop our destructive practice of implementing programs that separate the body of Christ along generational lines because we believe that the only way to effectively minister to and reach the young is to keep them separate. For example, we must ask ourselves why we are so quick to remove teenagers from the opportunity to worship with the older, wiser, and spiritually gifted brothers and sisters in our congregation. Why do we want to start a separate culturally relevant “youth worship” experience just for students? Doing so robs the body of Christ of its ability to function properly. Do we really believe that the young have nothing to offer the old, and vice versa?
One of my heroes of the faith, Francis Schaeffer, knew all too well the importance of understanding and knowing culture. At times, he was criticized for his engagement with people and their cultures. People would ask him, “Why don’t you just preach the simple gospel?” He answered, “You have to preach the simple gospel so that it is simple to the person to whom you are talking, or it is no longer simple.”
We are a family, a multicultural family. Let’s start listening to each other and living like it.
The scope of this chapter, as it relates to culture, is limited. While there are a multitude of youth ministry issues, skills, and sensitivities that must be pursued and developed in response to culture, the task before us in this chapter is to develop a cursory and basic understanding of how those of us in the older generations (in this case, anyone post–high school age) can begin to understand, address, and cross the cultural-generational gap that exists between generations as a result of rapid cultural change. While the definitions, explanations, and basic understandings presented here do apply at some level to all manner of cross-cultural ministry, the focus of this discussion is specific to the engagement of teenagers and their unique youth culture. This chapter is deliberately introductory in nature and therefore limited in scope and depth.
