3. Welcoming Wounded and Broken Adolescents into the Family of God
Dr. Marv Penner is widely considered one of the most significant and influential youth ministry leaders anywhere. Penner, a Canadian, spends most of his time teaching, leading, consulting, training, and equipping youth ministry scholars, practitioners, and students in Canada and the United States but also travels extensively throughout the world, helping people to think deeply about today’s adolescents and helping them to respond faithfully in the name of Christ. Whether he is teaching in Korea, speaking in Latin America, or consulting in Europe, Penner brings a wealth of ministry experience, comprehensive knowledge, and global sensitivity to those who serve the young. Among Penner’s primary ministry foci, he is particularly well known for helping kids and families in crisis, which is what we have asked him to share in this chapter.
As Penner writes about “wounded and broken adolescents,” it is important to know and remember two things. First, although Penner is describing young people who have experienced a relatively serious brokenness that presents itself in a variety of ways, his perspective is that most kids will encounter some level of similarly traumatic experience along the way. Penner is not addressing an isolated occurrence—just in case we encounter a child, teenager, or emerging adult who is broken or wounded. He is expecting us to realize that we will regularly and consistently encounter woundedness in ministry. Emphasizing the necessity for community involvement (what we have already described as the essence of participating in God’s work of adoption), Penner points out that we must be prepared to recognize and respond to kids and families in a way that promotes not only short-term relief but also long-term communal engagement.
The second issue at the heart of Penner’s chapter, which consistently surfaces in his speaking and teaching ministry, is that he has come to believe that all kids are bruised and wounded as a result of today’s performance- and image-oriented society. Penner’s work contributed significantly to my books on this subject, Hurt and Hurt 2.0: Inside the World of Today’s Teenagers. He has been an advocate for helping the church and youth workers in particular to be very careful as they lead and serve young people in the name of Christ. What I call “systemic abandonment” (when adults abandon their responsibility to consistently protect, nurture, and guide the young as their primary legacy) Penner and others sometimes refer to as “systemic isolation,” which describes the effect of the loss of social capital and adult nurture. While the upfront message of this chapter regards the extraordinary brokenness that young people sometimes experience, the subtext is vital: every single teenager or emerging adult we serve has their own share of wounds they are dragging along behind them.
As you read this chapter, you may notice that Adoptive Youth Ministry is not a cookie-cutter, one-formula-fits-all type of book. As we drew together a wide variety of thinkers, scholars, and leaders who have influenced and continue to influence youth ministry thinking and practice—and whom we believe should continue to influence youth ministry for years to come—we decided to invite them to write out of their own history, experience, and style. Thus Penner’s chapter has a unique flavor and style that is particular to him. Instead of trying to edit the authors into stylistic conformity, we have chosen to go this route because we feel they have earned the right for their individual voices to be heard, especially those who have a long and distinguished track record as key influencers and leaders. We believe this adds to the richness and diversity of expression in this book.
As you read, consider these questions:
The email came in just before midnight. The despair in its words was almost palpable. “I’m so lost. I’m so alone. There is nothing in my life that feels good. Just don’t let me cut. I got no one and nothing. Please don’t let me cut.”
Sadly, the writer’s situation was so highly dysfunctional that self-injury seemed almost like a rational response to the brokenness of her circumstances. Her family was destructive in the worst sense of the word. Abandonment, neglect, abuse, and betrayal were all she had experienced in her short fifteen and one-half years of life. Granted, it had turned her into a survivor—a fighter, a gutsy street kid who was determined to make it on her own—but in order to ensure her safety she had cocooned herself in a shroud of attitude that none but the most persistent would ever get inside.
Our paths had crossed by the will of the Child Protection Agency in our community. After a few standoffs she must have realized that I wasn’t going away, so she reluctantly opened up. Once she had trusted me with her story and recognized that I wasn’t put off by it, she began to invite me into the day-to-day realities of her complicated world. The late-night email that day was her way of checking in and letting me know that things weren’t okay.
I replied with a quick (and likely too clichéd) response that told her I believed in her, Jesus loved her, and that I was looking forward to seeing her in the morning at a coffee shop near where she was staying. But only a few minutes later she responded in the form of a one-line email and attached photo. “I cut agin. Pleez don’t be mad. Pleez don’t give up on me.” It was the photograph that really told the story. A cell phone picture of her left hand with the word Daddy roughly carved into her palm. I found out later it had been a sharp shard of glass. I responded with a much less clichéd message to this much more urgent cry for help, communicating my profound sadness for her, making sure she didn’t need a trip to the emergency room, and reconfirming our breakfast arrangements.
When I met with her in a coffee shop the following morning, I knew I was in for a tough conversation. Not sure where to start, I gently asked her, “If your hand could speak, what would it tell me?” Without even raising her head she used her wounded, still-oozing left hand to pull up the sleeve on her right arm, revealing the words ugly, stupid, worthless, and unlovable carved in her skin in the same macabre font. Gently rubbing her forearm with her Daddy hand she quietly said, “Maybe if I had a daddy I wouldn’t feel this way about myself.” And then, with what felt like a rhetorical question she asked, “Is it wrong for me to wish I had a daddy?”
The deep longing to belong, to be loved, and to be valued that was expressed in her question is at the heart of much of the brokenness experienced by teenagers in the world today. Desperate for meaningful relational connection but often finding only disappointment, they manage their loneliness in whatever ways work best. For some, it’s the bizarre cycle of self-harm; for others, drugs or alcohol numb the pain; for still others, parties and promiscuity distract them from the deep loss they are feeling inside. Some find a form of community in street gangs or clusters of friends that become surrogate family; some become citizens of the global community of gamers and spend every waking moment participating in what feels like very significant work. For too many the predictable plot lines of pornography provide them with a fantasy role to play in which, for brief moments, they can pretend they belong. Sadly for some the pain of rejection and loneliness has become so intense that they detach themselves from any meaningful relationship and live their lives resigned to a lonely and isolated existence, often creating a relational buffer by communicating an angry, sullen, or indifferent attitude that defies anyone to enter.
What all of these young people have in common is that their exterior behaviors, attitudes, relational patterns, and emotional symptomology mask their complex and often unrecognized interior cries for response. On the basis of visible evidence they are labeled as cutters, anorexics, gang bangers, shoplifters, addicts, fighters, problems, sluts, runaways, troublemakers, and losers, and most adults in their world sincerely believe that if “the outside” could simply be rearranged everything would be fine.
Like my young friend who bared her soul when she bared her arm that morning, there is so much more going on that must be understood if we are going to provide a place of safety and belonging for wounded and broken adolescents among us. We cannot simply assume that calling them to behavioral or attitudinal conformity represents a victory in their lives (or in our ministries).
A “Look under the Hood”
Although in many ways adolescence represents a unique chapter in the human development story, individuals who are navigating the transition from childhood to adulthood appear to have at least one significant thing in common with all people. At their (our) core are some powerfully motivating needs that have potential to fuel choices and behaviors. Many keen observers of human nature—both academic and nonacademic—have attempted to identify these innate longings of the human soul. Some examples include the longing to be loved unconditionally (apart from performance or achievement); to know that one’s life has a purpose (making some sort of significant impact in the world); to be desired (being pursued is tangible evidence); and, of course, the longing to belong (to live in relationship or community.) These represent a sampling of the most commonly identified internal forces that have been observed and experienced.
While some might be intrigued by the exercise of determining which of these longings should be included in or excluded from the “official list,” there is perhaps a more productive exercise to be undertaken. We need to ask ourselves why the longings are there in the first place—both in the souls of the young people we serve and in each of our own hearts.
If, in fact, these longings are common to all (whether consciously experienced or not), it stands to reason that they are part of God’s sovereign design. In his infinite wisdom, why would the Creator have wired his human progeny with profound needs that demand satisfaction? It may be the simplest theological question to answer, given that God is a God of relationship.
Clearly, he placed these longings in each of us for the divinely ordained purpose of drawing us to himself. He knew that no human would ever be fully satisfied until his or her deepest longings were met in him.
The Scripture actually uses a commonplace metaphor to help us understand the intense urgency of satisfying these longings. Thirst is something all humans are familiar with. Psalm 42:1–2 declares,
As the deer pants for streams of water,
so my soul pants for you, my God.
My soul thirsts for God, for the living God.
Isaiah 55:1 is an enthusiastic invitation to
Come, all you who are thirsty,
come to the waters;
and you who have no money,
come, buy and eat!
Come, buy wine and milk
without money and without cost.
And certainly the conversation between Jesus and the Samaritan woman in John 4 puts all of this into a New Testament perspective when a woman—clearly longing to be loved, significant, pursued, and welcomed—is offered living water. Jesus promises that those who drink the water he gives them will never thirst again (John 4:14).
But there’s a problem. In spite of the open invitation from the ultimate Source of thirst-quenching satisfaction, our natural predisposition as post-fall human beings is not to run to our heavenly Father to quench our thirst. Instead, we look for ways to satisfy our longings that will not require us to remain in a relationship of dependence on the true Thirst-Quencher. Jeremiah 2:13 describes the two-sided coin of our inherent self-reliance and independence.
My people have committed two sins:
They have forsaken me,
the spring of living water,
and have dug their own cisterns,
broken cisterns that cannot hold water.
The prophet is saying that we look for ways to quench our thirst that allow us to manage and control our sources rather than to rely deeply on the One who finds his greatest delight in seeing us satisfied. Of course, the satisfaction we experience is short-lived and in the end disappointing. The cisterns simply do not hold water.
So, you may ask, what does this little theological side trip have to do with understanding and responding to wounded and broken teenagers? What I am suggesting is that adolescents often find themselves involved in personally and relationally destructive behaviors in a desperate need to have their thirst quenched. Any veteran youth worker or high school teacher has plenty of stories of young women who have compromised their moral convictions for the sake of experiencing the feeling of being loved. They will tell stories of young men who, in a desperate need to feel like they belong, will surround themselves with people of violence and evil to be part of the gang. Stories of students who cut, or drink, or shop to distance themselves from the pain in their lives are common. The cycle of brokenness is not easily interrupted.
When a faith community provides a young person with a welcoming place to belong, a meaningful way to make a difference in their world, and a family that loves and pursues them unconditionally, God’s people are responding, in the name of Jesus, to the deepest core needs that a youth can experience. When we understand that, as God’s family, we have been entrusted with this “ministry of reconciliation” that Christ began (2 Cor. 5:18), we can serve as his ambassadors, speaking on his behalf into the lives of the young people who cross our paths.
The thirst that I have been talking about is not unique to adolescents. The longings I identified are common to humans of all ages, young and old. What makes them a significant factor for adolescents is that the thirst becomes palpable during these crucial years. It is the first time in an individual’s young life that they have the capacity for a conscious awareness of their desire to be loved, to be significant, and to belong. What this means in practical terms is that early adolescence is also the stage of life where, for the first time, they have the emotive capacity to process the deep pain and disappointment of not feeling loved, believing they don’t have any significance, and experiencing the loneliness of being on the outside looking in. This can make adolescence a trying time for young people and creates an opportunity for ministry that cannot be ignored by those who want to make an eternal difference.
But . . . It Gets Even More Complicated!
As a specialist in cognitive development, Jean Piaget spent much of his life helping us to understand the transition from childlike to adultlike thinking. In its most basic terms he pointed out that children tend to think in simplistic, literal, black-and-white ways while adults are able to process complex concepts, conflicting ideas, and more sophisticated problems. During adolescence the transition to more mature cognitive approaches takes place. This shift has enormous implications for understanding what is going on in the minds of the adolescents we work with.
Because of their more limited cognitive aptitude, children tend to experience life in simple, literal terms. They generally live in the moment, experiencing life as a series of isolated, consecutive events or “snapshots” that may or may not eventually find their way into long-term memory. This is not to imply that the experiences of childhood have no impact on future development. When preadolescent children experience the absence of love, significance, and belonging, there is an unmistakably erosive effect on their souls. They simply don’t have the cognitive capacity to contextualize and sort out the events that are occurring until later in life.
Mid-adolescence, ages fourteen to twenty, changes all of that. The brain undergoes some significant changes in terms of neurological complexity (a miraculous process that we are learning more about as a result of new technologies that allow us to “look inside”), and as a result, early evidence of “formal operations” (Piaget’s name for adultlike thinking) begins to emerge. This newly discovered cognitive sophistication allows mid-adolescents to begin thinking about their world at a much deeper level. They are able to process conflicting ideas, combine concepts in their head without any concrete evidence, think creatively at a whole new level, and begin to imagine the outcomes of certain choices, even though they have never experienced them before.
A practical outcome of this new level of thinking is that for the first time in their young lives they become aware of their personal narrative. At this point, the adolescent is able to look back over the “snapshots” of childhood memories and begin to weave them together into his or her own story. When those snapshots are marked primarily by pain and disappointment, the story that emerges tends to read like a tragedy. A series of memories where love was absent, relational attachment (belonging) was negative or unavailable, and feelings of worthlessness or insignificance were common result in a story line that often expresses itself in low self-esteem or even self-loathing.
When the notion of thirst/longing is combined with this new capacity to process one’s own personal story line we begin to understand how complex life can be for a mid-adolescent who has experienced the pain of rejection, loneliness, and self-doubt. The opportunity to provide for these young people a place of relational safety, community, and significant involvement represents one of the highest callings of any faith community. But it gets even more complicated than that!
The Perfect Storm of Mid-adolescence
One more crucial element must be factored in if we truly want to understand what is going on at the deeper levels of a young teenager’s life. Developmental psychologists have examined the journey through adolescence from a variety of perspectives, and many of them agree that a primary challenge/task of this stage of life is identity formation. The “Who am I?” question looms large for teenagers—whether they are consciously aware of it or not.
It’s not that a person has no identity until they reach adolescence. For most children, their identity is well-defined from quite a young age. But what their identity is based on needs to change in order for a healthy transition to adulthood to take place. In early childhood, their identity is linked directly to their family of origin. They are “Bob and Susan’s son,” “Jeff and Lisa’s daughter,” or “Josh’s little sister.” As they enter early adolescence they begin to intuitively sense the need to establish themselves as individuals apart from the ties to their family of origin, but since the brain is still developing they cannot yet reflectively consider their life in relationship to others. To further complicate matters, puberty has brought about significant changes, endowing the adolescent with the body of an adult and the brain of a child. It is in mid-adolescence, when the brain begins the process of moving from concrete, “first person” thinking and awareness to the abstract abilities of the mature brain, or “third person” thinking and awareness, that they are able to consider in a more objective way who they are compared to others.
The first stage of this process commences when they begin to chafe at being known only in relation to their parents or siblings. As early adolescents they often begin to assert their individuality by pushing back on their relationship with parents and siblings as a means of creating some distance. This stage is often disconcerting for parents, who may experience it as personal rejection and react by holding on tighter, linking their own identity to that of their child, and creating tension that simply makes the transition more difficult. This process of discovering one’s self is essential to establishing a coherent adult identity and can be as terrifying for the adolescent as it is for the parent.
At this point, all of the dimensions of early to mid-adolescent development come together. The emerging personal story line is shaped by a growing sense of disappointment in relationships that are not providing unconditional love, significance, and belonging commensurate with the longing for those things that are bubbling into the adolescent’s consciousness. This becomes the backdrop against which important identity formation decisions are made. The word decisions is used intentionally. Adolescents begin to make some identity assumptions based on their interpretation of what they have experienced in life so far. Understanding these assumptions is crucial to responding appropriately to adolescents in transition.
The vocabulary of personal identity in adolescents generally consists of adjectives or metaphorical images. When my young friend (whom I introduced at the beginning of this chapter) carved those self-deprecating words into her forearm that night, she was simply reminding herself of who she believed herself to be. The assumptions that led to the conviction that she was ugly, unlovable, stupid, and worthless were simply her best attempt at making sense out of her personal story. Although the adjectives she chose are painfully negative and patently inaccurate, she embraced them as her own because they made complete sense of her story. Her desire to be loved, valued, taken seriously, and seen as attractive had been ignored by the people closest to her. Instead, she had experienced the opposite—hence the words by which she chose to define herself.
For some, a picture or metaphor more accurately portrays how they see themselves. They identify as a bag of trash, a piece of crap, a little lost puppy, or a bird who can’t fly as a way of illustrating the subjective experience of what their lives feel like and how they see themselves. One young woman I was working with (who gave me permission to quote from her journal) expresses it so articulately:
Life works for me as long as I view myself as a worthless piece of crap. If I see myself as a whore, a nothing, then everything makes sense. All the pain, betrayal, and powerlessness of my past becomes clear. I am a whore so that’s why I was sexually abused when I was ten years old. I am worthless, so that is why my mom drank. I am a slut, so that is why I was assaulted when I was eighteen. I am a hard, cold, calloused, tough woman hiding a frightened little girl inside. A little girl who is convinced that being female is what got her into trouble in the first place, so she cut off her beautiful long hair and gained weight. All this little girl wants is to be held in the big strong arms of her Daddy. The whore image protects the little girl from ever being hurt again but it also keeps her from running into Abba’s open arms of love. You see he is male, so therefore he will hurt me.
As she reviews the events of her life—the memories of an alcoholic mother, the abuse she experienced at the hands of one of her mom’s many boyfriends, the date rape in her senior year of high school—she clearly comes to some conclusions about how those events define her identity. The images combine to give us a sense of how she sees herself. The worthless piece of crap, the whore, the slut, the nothing, the terrified little girl hiding behind the tough exterior of the calloused young woman she has become give us a sense of just how deeply entrenched these assumptions can be.
Perhaps the saddest part of seeing young people who have defined themselves with such painfully negative assumptions is that they often go through life without ever having those assumptions challenged in a loving, caring relationship or healthy, supportive community. Instead, they build a precarious existence on the foundation of the words and pictures that define them.
Obviously, young people who have lived in a traumatic or dysfunctional relational environment as children tend to have more deeply entrenched identity issues to work through.
The Source of Adolescent Pain
Some young people are broken or wounded because painful things have happened to them. The range of hurtful circumstances that teenagers find themselves in seems endless. Perhaps they are caught in the middle of a painful family breakup; it could be the tragic loss of a parent, sibling, or friend in an accident or suicide; the diagnosis of a terminal disease is devastating news for some. Sexual abuse, public humiliation, bullying, being dumped by a boyfriend or girlfriend, being cut from the team, struggling with weight or complexion, living with a learning disability, an emotionally absent dad, a demanding or verbally abusive mom—the list can go on and on, and as I compile this list, each entry represents a young person I know. We identify them as victims because the pain they live with came about as a result of someone else’s choices or circumstances, which were completely beyond their control. The pain they live with is not of their own doing.
But not all of the pain young people live with comes about as a result of victimization. Some are hurting because of choices they made themselves. Perhaps they chose the wrong friends and now find themselves in destructive relationships. They may have chosen to make their studies a low priority and have eliminated a whole range of options for the future as a result. They have chosen drugs, alcohol, self-injury, or pornography as a means to self-medicate and now find themselves trapped in an addiction that seems impossible to break. They chose to quit school, to have unprotected sex, to run away from home, to play video games instead of doing their homework. Again, the list of ill-advised choices that teenagers make could go on forever, but in this case the painful outcomes are a result of their own doing.
Wouldn’t it be convenient if we could simply classify hurting teenagers as victims or agents? On the one hand, we would immediately know how to respond. If we were dealing with a victim, our role would be to come alongside and provide support, encouragement, and empathy. We would remind them that what happened was not their fault and assure them that it was not fair. We would do all that was possible to protect them from further victimization and surround them with a community that was committed to helping them find healing.
On the other hand, if we were dealing with an individual who was the agent of his/her own pain, we would firmly hold them responsible, help them to understand the connection between their choices and the unanticipated outcomes, and exhort them to make wiser choices in the future.
Of course, it is not that simple. I am reminded of a conversation I had with the person sitting next to me on a flight one day. I was on my way to train a group of social workers on how to care for teenagers who self-injure, and I was editing a few presentation slides on my computer screen. My seatmate glanced over, saw what I was working on, and asked incredulously, “What is up with those kids?” I replied, “It’s complicated.” He continued, “Do you work with those kids?” After I told him that I do work with those kids, his next question made me smile just a little. “Why doesn’t someone just tell them to stop?” It was a reminder that many people make the assumption that behavioral choices are made in isolation. But those of us who work with hurting teenagers know that it is complicated; very often people make bad choices because bad things have happened to them. The pain of victimization expresses itself in behaviors that are destructive in ways the individual might never have anticipated. The complex interplay of victimization and agency requires us to take a much more thoughtful approach than simply offering a hug for the person who appears to be a victim or a kick in the pants for the person who seems to have chosen his or her lot in life. Compassion always looks through both lenses and forces us to see the connection. When the apostle John introduces us to Jesus he says, “The Word became flesh and made his dwelling among us. We have seen his glory, the glory of the one and only Son, who came from the Father, full of grace and truth” (John 1:14, italics added). In this beautiful description of the Savior we see the balanced approach we are called to make in response to the brokenness of teenagers around us. Jesus was “full of grace and truth.” Grace takes into account the woundedness that is often a precursor to unhealthy choices young people make, and truth calls them to a higher level of volitional intentionality as they sort out how they will respond to the pain that is inherent in their story.
The promise of Psalm 68:6 (NLT) is that “God places the lonely in families.” As faith communities committed to the spiritual well-being of next generations, we must embrace the opportunity to be family for the young people around us. Whether their need for connection is rooted in the painful reality of a family of origin that was abusive and neglectful or they simply find themselves in the normal adolescent transitions of disengaging from their biological family, we are called to invite young people in and welcome them as Jesus would. It should be noted, however, that the cost of adoption is greater than many faith communities are willing to pay, and the integration of young people, particularly those who come with “baggage,” may feel like an intrusion. But when we reflect on the price that was paid for our adoption into God’s family and the baggage we brought, we can more generously and gratefully open our doors and our hearts.
The truth is that most of the young people we work with today are hurting much more deeply than they or we are willing to acknowledge. They camouflage and cover up their pain for a variety of reasons. Most often, when I have asked them why they hid their stories of brokenness from the people around them, their reasons were rooted in mistrust. They have tried to reach out for help in the past and have been ignored, belittled, exposed, rebuked, or given clichéd advice that seemed to have no relevance to the depth of their pain. The implications are obvious: we must create communities in which trust is nonnegotiable. Until a youth is able to trust an adult there will be no opportunity to talk about the issues that really matter. This means calling leaders to lives of absolute integrity. It means vetting and training our volunteers carefully to ensure that they understand what a precious and fragile gift the trust of a young person is and that they must guard that trust carefully. It means living our lives transparently and honestly so that students can see what it looks like when imperfect people are committed to growing spiritually through painful or difficult circumstances.
But it’s not only the young people themselves who live in denial. As youth leaders and parents we also have a tendency to diminish the seriousness of what young people are dealing with. Again, when I have asked youth workers and parents why they prefer to pretend that everything’s okay, the issue is either pride or inadequacy. Pride declares that “our kids” don’t struggle with those sorts of things because if they did it would be a reflection on us. Inadequacy tells us that if the struggles young people describe are true, we don’t have a clue where to start them on their journey toward healing.
Step 1: Know That Adolescent Pain Is Real
The first step in responding to the brokenness of hurting young people around us is to admit that the pain is real. The world is a cruel place for kids today. Our churches are called to stand as islands of safety in the midst of the cultural chaos that young people must navigate today. Pious platitudes, clichéd “steps to victory,” Bible verse Band-Aids, and guilt trips for those who fail to conform are simply not helpful within the family of God. The prophet Jeremiah speaks out against the spiritual leaders of his day. Sadly, the indictment he declares could be addressed to many church leaders today.
From the least to the greatest,
all are greedy for gain;
prophets and priests alike,
all practice deceit.
They dress the wound of my people
as though it were not serious.
“Peace, peace,” they say,
when there is no peace. (Jer. 6:13–14)
Ignoring and belittling the pain of young people is not an option.
Step 2: Adults Need Young People, and Young People Need Adults
Families are intergenerational. When young people are invited into a family of faith it is important that they are invited into a relationship that crosses generational lines. While a strong case can be made for peer-based ministry structures, it is important for a young person exploring faith to be exposed to individuals at all stages of spiritual maturity. In healthy families, grandparents provide wisdom, stability, and a sense of longevity. Parents offer guidance, relationship, and intentional involvement. Siblings create opportunity for shared experiences, camaraderie, friendship, and mutual accountability. These generational benefits can be experienced in a faith community that understands the value of breaking down age-based silos and creating opportunities for all the generations to connect with one another. The benefits that come about as a result of pursuing intentional intergenerational interactions are numerous and broad, reaching across generational lines.
The faith experience of senior saints in the community is enhanced when young people are invited to challenge the status quo and call congregations to remain relevant in the face of cultural changes. The passion and energy of youthful presence can give older folks confidence that the mission of their church will continue into the foreseeable future. On the other side of the equation, young people benefit from the wisdom and experience of older believers who choose to make themselves relationally available and share the lessons they have learned in a long life of faith. They must be caretakers of the young, who, while they have a great deal to offer the faith community in their energy and perspective, still need adults to nurture and guide them without judgment or condemnation. Older believers offer a picture of what mature and seasoned faith looks like to young believers who are just beginning their walk with Jesus. Their prayers and encouragement can give a struggling young person the courage to press on, even in the face of difficult or painful circumstances.
Because young people are caught in the awkward stage of detaching from their family of origin they often need the involvement of other adults to be the voice of “parental wisdom” and provide nonjudgmental presence in the face of life’s challenges. In this way, the church can be a great example of a “village” raising children. Youth workers, mentors, teachers, coaches, and small group leaders fall into this category of men and women, one generation ahead of the young people they serve. Teenagers who have the benefit of at least one committed nonparental adult in their life reap enormous benefits. Imagine the benefit of a fully committed community of believers who each see themselves as significant to the spiritual well-being of the young people in their midst—a whole congregation of “youth workers.” By the same token, those adults who are intentionally invested in the spiritual lives of younger individuals are motivated to make their faith their own. They find themselves helping young people wrestle with biblical truth and in the process of doing so are forced to solidify their own convictions. Everyone wins.
Being the Family of God Changes Everything!
My family adopted a newborn baby girl when I was thirteen. As we eagerly anticipated her arrival we made some significant changes to our home. We paid careful attention to potential safety hazards around the house, and we prepared a room in which our new little sister would be comfortable. Our shelves were stocked with food that would be suitable for her infant palate. Lifestyle and scheduling adjustments had to be made when she came to live with us. In short, everything changed when the dynamics of our family were impacted by the arrival of the new and needy little member. When a church decides to get serious about opening their family to young people with unique needs and challenges, it will require them to make enormous adjustments. It can no longer be “business as usual.”
In the face of this realization too many congregations simply decide the cost is too great. Inviting the “wrong kind of kids” into the family will destroy the peaceful predictability of what currently exists. There’s a chance that some of their “badness” will rub off on the good kids who currently occupy the pews. Staffing adjustments might need to be made to address the greater demands that come with young people who have issues. Liturgy might need to be adapted to create a more user-friendly environment for young people who are unfamiliar with traditional worship. Sermons will need to be rethought to ensure that they are relevant and helpful for honest young people who won’t put up with clichés and pat answers. Just like any family that adopts a new member, life is never the same. But it is what we are called to, and the benefits are immense.
I began this chapter thinking about the deepest longings of the human soul. The thirst to be loved, to know that one’s life has purpose and meaning, and to find a place to belong is something that every one of us identifies with deeply. I discussed the fact that the natural predisposition of sinful humans is to find ways to quench their thirst on their own terms—often with disastrous outcomes. Is there an alternative?
When young people who consider themselves to be unworthy and unlovable encounter the gospel they are invited into a relationship that is marked by absolutely unconditional love. Romans 5:8 reminds us that God demonstrated “his own love for us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us.” Thirst quenched!
When young people who identify as weak, stupid, and worthless discover that God has a completely different view of them—and has laid out a specific plan and purpose for them—it radically changes their view of themselves and their future. “For we are God’s handiwork,” Paul tells us in Ephesians 2:10, “created in Christ Jesus to do good works, which God prepared in advance for us to do.” Thirst quenched!
When young people who see themselves as outcasts, losers, or undesirable are invited into a community where they are welcomed and invited to participate—in some cases even before they believe—it provides them with the assurance that they belong. First Corinthians 12 uses the metaphor of the body to describe the interdependent nature of the family we are all invited into. In verse 27 Paul summarizes by saying, “Now you are the body of Christ, and each one of you is a part of it.” Thirst quenched!
The self-deprecating assumptions that are made by young people in response to their pain and disappointment are meant to be challenged in healthy community. This is the context in which the lies of the enemy (you are unlovable, ugly, stupid, worthless) can be exchanged for the truth of the gospel that declares, “Those who are led by the Spirit of God are the children of God. . . . Now if we are children, then we are heirs—heirs of God and co-heirs with Christ” (Rom. 8:14, 17). There is no higher calling than this.
