Chapter 15 of 31

10. Thinking Critically about Families and Youth Ministry

10. Thinking Critically about Families and Youth Ministry

10

Thinking Critically about Families and Youth Ministry

ALLEN JACKSON

When it comes to parents and youth ministry, opinions tend to span a single continuum. On one end are the parents, who serve as the primary disciplers of their children; in this context, youth ministry is best when it supports the parental role or even gets out of the way (“youth ministry’s job is to support families”). On the other end of the spectrum is youth ministry, whose task it is to represent the gospel to children and adolescents; in this scenario, parents are encouraged to support the work of the church or even get out of the way (“the parent’s role is to support the youth ministry”). Allen Jackson, professor at New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary and longtime youth ministry author and trainer, takes on this conversation by removing the polarity of the positions. With personal (and painful) honesty and thoughtful reflection, Jackson demonstrates that there does not need to be an inherent battle between parents on the one hand and the church (or other Christian youth ministries) on the other. We need each other.

Jackson writes from the perspective of a mountain sage. He is gently casual but well read; he is humble, yet he offers deep insight; he is willing to ask questions as a learner, yet his conclusions land with conviction. In this chapter, we are given the opportunity to hear what various voices are saying as well as a deeper glimpse into what the fuss is about. Yet Jackson allows us to see that we are all in this thing called youth ministry together, that adoption must happen both within families and within larger groups of people, and that the church is called to be unified.

In the course of your ministry, you will likely be handed a job description (at some point) that ignores parents altogether. When you are in the midst of the work of youth ministry—giving talks and lessons, leading trips and small group, recruiting and training leaders, handling budgets and meetings and expectations—it is vital that you keep in mind the reason for this book and the essence of this chapter. The goal of youth ministry is that every young person—every child, every adolescent, every emerging adult—is to be embraced, known, encouraged, and equipped to participate in the body of Christ as a full participating member by the entire community. Parents matter, as do the elderly, the nursery workers, and the staff. This is our calling.

As you read this chapter, consider these questions:

  • How does your experience as a follower of Christ compare with how Jackson describes his son, Steven? What was your parents’ relationship to your faith journey, and how did the church encourage/discourage that journey?
  • If you had to choose a side, which would you land on: “parents are the primary disciplers of their children” or “the church is the primary discipler of the young”? What are some of the downsides of taking the position you chose over the other?
  • What has been your experience of nonparental adults being close to you in your faith formation? What are the hallmarks of your relationship with them? How can we foster the best of those characteristics in ministry to adolescents?
  • Steven’s Story

    Steven was a junior in high school and riding the wave of athletic success and popularity. His adolescent growth spurt had produced dramatic results—he grew almost a foot taller and close to a hundred pounds heavier in less than two years. On an August weekend in 2005, he had a spectacular game in the preseason football “jamboree” and was looking forward to a great year on the gridiron.

    His family was intact and traditional. His parents were involved in leadership positions at church. Mom and Dad had been faithful to attend ball games, Bible drill competition, awards ceremonies, and anything else in which Steven was involved. Family time was important, and devotions were common (not so regular as to say they never missed, but regular enough that he would remember that they took place). His dad was a former youth minister and still working in ministry. His mom had been a youth ministry intern and Young Life volunteer in her younger days and remained very active in church.

    Steven was very social. He gravitated toward groups of boys and girls who shared his interest in athletics and who went to school with him at the small Christian school he attended in New Orleans. He seemed to take turns between being influenced by his friends and being an influencer among his friends. He had a streak that resisted authority, not unlike his dad, but he rarely got into trouble at school. His coaches were his heroes, and their rules and approval were sufficient to keep him focused on the positive.

    He also found a groove in a small group at church. Even though his family was very active at church and Steven went regularly—including the trips, the concerts, the Disciple Now weekends, camps, and retreats—he never bonded with the youth pastor. In his junior year, however, he bonded with his small group leader. He talked about spending time with the group and looked forward to time at church with them and the adult leader who guided the group. It seemed that “Mr. Clint” said all the same things that his family said at home, but when he said them, it was cool.

    On that particular August weekend, the Friday football game was followed by the game film on Saturday, but by that time the news and weather folks were talking about a weather event that would affect the New Orleans area. Her name was Katrina, and she hit New Orleans as a category 3 hurricane on August 29, 2005. The levees that were supposed to protect the city breached, and the entire city was flooded. Like most other students in New Orleans, Steven evacuated with his family. He would not return to his home for a year.

    Steven gravitated to a different group of friends in the city to which his family relocated. He attended a new school, lived in a new neighborhood, and worked a part-time job in a different place. He was not as connected with sports, and he met some people who helped him along a path that would result in behavior that his family and church didn’t embrace. He would return to his original school for the spring semester, but sports injuries and the instability of most structures in New Orleans meant that his life was not the same. He had changed.

    The small group at church would not meet again. Mr. Clint moved permanently to Texas, and the youth pastor moved to Tennessee; the guys in Steven’s small group scattered with their families. Whatever impact the group made on Steven’s life was minimized by the short time that they were together, yet the impact of being a part of the group was not lost on Steven’s family, especially as they reflected back years later.

    I will summarize the rest of the story (though it is still being written) by confessing that Steven is my son. His journey into young adulthood included destructive alcohol and drug use, four different colleges, and almost two years in a faith-based rehabilitation program to help deal with his demons. I often wonder whether his life would have been different if the small group had continued to nurture both faith and friendship during that critical junior year. I am grateful to God that as a young adult he seems to have the substance abuse issues under control. However, like so many in his generation, he has only a marginal interest in church and/or spiritual conversations.

    As many parents do, I began to beat myself up. Did something go wrong? Did I mess up as a parent? What could I have done/not done? Should the church/youth ministry have done more? How could I have partnered with the youth minister to reach out to Steven? Should I have spent more time with him? Was his attention deficit disorder a factor? I know I cannot answer most of these questions, nor can you if you are a parent who is going through a similar journey. I know that as a youth minister I have dealt with desperate parents who have blamed everything and everyone for the poor choices made by their son or daughter; some spent years in desperate guilt over what they perceived they could have done differently.

    How can the church or youth ministry partner with parents who are in pain? What is the role of the church or youth ministry? Is youth ministry, as some have suggested, an outdated and obsolete aspect of church life? I believe that God brings groups of families together in this thing we call church in order to allow us—in community—to worship him and to journey through life in this fallen world.

    Help from the Community of Faith

    Another story about an adolescent and faith can be found in Luke 2. While most of us consider the nativity to be the main feature in this particular chapter, the events at the very end of the narrative are interesting to me.

    Every year Jesus’ parents went to Jerusalem for the Festival of the Passover. When he was twelve years old, they went up to the festival, according to the custom. After the festival was over, while his parents were returning home, the boy Jesus stayed behind in Jerusalem, but they were unaware of it. Thinking he was in their company, they traveled on for a day. Then they began looking for him among their relatives and friends. When they did not find him, they went back to Jerusalem to look for him. After three days they found him in the temple courts, sitting among the teachers, listening to them and asking them questions. Everyone who heard him was amazed at his understanding and his answers. When his parents saw him, they were astonished. His mother said to him, “Son, why have you treated us like this? Your father and I have been anxiously searching for you.”

    “Why were you searching for me?” he asked. “Didn’t you know I had to be in my Father’s house?” But they did not understand what he was saying to them.

    Then he went down to Nazareth with them and was obedient to them. But his mother treasured all these things in her heart. And Jesus grew in wisdom and stature, and in favor with God and man. (Luke 2:41–52)

    The reader might not notice that twelve years passed between verses 40 and 41. The Christ child has become the Christ adolescent, and Joseph and Mary have taken him to Jerusalem. At the time, faithful Jewish families living in the kingdom of Judah made three trips to Jerusalem each year (see Deut. 16:16) for the observance of major religious holidays. One of them was Passover, which celebrated the deliverance of the Israelites, under the leadership of Moses, from the Egyptians.

    Usually it is noted that Jesus was mature beyond his years; it was only natural that he would be in the temple teaching, even though his parents were frantic over his absence. It intrigues me that he was missing for twenty-four hours before they even thought to look for him. As a parent of middle schoolers, I would have been concerned if I could not locate my children for an hour, much less a day. The key is in verse 44: Thinking he was in their company, they traveled on for a day. The phrase “in their company” means that Joseph and Mary thought Jesus was walking home with another relative or friend of the family. They figured he was walking with Uncle Mordecai and talking about the Torah, which was good because it reinforced the lessons they were teaching at home.

    What a great reference point for youth ministry. While I admit I may have embellished the narrative, the essence of the verse (which I believe I have put in context) highlights that, according to the traditional Jewish mind-set, the community of faith came alongside parents to help raise children. Samuel was sent to Eli at a young age when his calling was recognized. The wilderness wandering of the Israelites depicts the community of faith traveling together. At the risk of exposing my thesis early, I believe the best possible faith formation environment is a partnership between family and the community of faith. Richard Ross, a passionate voice for students and their families, says, “When church and home link arms in mutual support, teenagers are the most likely to prosper as adults with a lifetime faith.”

    My first experience in Sunday school came as the result of a man in the church who drove an aging school bus through the neighborhoods to pick up children; my sister and I got on the bus. My parents loved me and provided for me, but church was not a part of our weekly rhythm. I owe my first glimpse of what it means to follow Jesus to a gentleman who got up early on Sunday, put gas in the bus, kicked the tires, and greeted every adult or child who boarded the bus with a smile and a word of encouragement.

    My first experience with a youth group was in a small church in Georgia. While I had other ways to get to church besides the bus, I still attended with my sister. Though tiny by mega-standards, my church had adults who stepped forward as youth ministry volunteers. I was “raised” spiritually by adults in the church who treated me like family. I believe I was better for the examples of men and women who volunteered to work with teenagers. My own father was drawn to faith in his later years because he saw the growth of spiritual seeds that had been planted in his children by other adults in the church.

    I also know of instances in my church where empty nesters helped young moms—especially single ones—who had to work to make ends meet. In an age of cocooning, it is important for parents to realize that other parental voices are speaking into the lives of their children. Parents instinctively reach out to other adults to help in areas where they feel inadequate—coaches, music teachers, and tutors in higher math—but having a Mr. Clint as a faith mentor or a couple as parenting mentors or a Sunday school teacher who simply validates the spiritual conversation inspires confidence that wisdom is being shared.

    Where This Chapter Fits

    In a book that is a compilation of the work of a number of contributors, there will likely be some ideas, concepts, strategies, or even research that seem redundant. I apologize ahead of time for any repetition here. The main question that drives me—both from my own story and as a professor in a seminary—is, “What is the best model of interaction between youth ministry and family with the goal of authentic discipleship?” This chapter is about the context of the church partnering with families in youth ministry. I happen to teach youth ministry at both undergraduate and graduate levels in a seminary. I hear youth pastors describe their ministry settings with regard to families. I desperately wish I had a magic pill or an automatic formula to help them help their churches to see genuine discipleship—incubated in the home, modeled by godly parents, and supplemented by quality spiritual formation at church.

    Our task in youth ministry is to join parents in helping students set and reach spiritual (discipleship) goals that complement the academic, social, and career goals that help them to launch. I joke with parents that our job as parents and as youth ministers is to get rid of these teenagers. What if we helped parents articulate goals that finish a sentence that goes something like this: By the time they graduate from high school, they will be able to . . .

  • describe their own faith story.
  • recognize the value of commitment as a disciple.
  • understand how to study and interpret the Bible.
  • practice spiritual disciplines.
  • develop and demonstrate Christ’s character.
  • make wise decisions.
  • develop godly relationships.
  • make an intentional impact on others.
  • If you are a parent or a youth minister perhaps such a list can be a point of discussion for you and other adults who speak into the lives of your teenagers.

    Youth Ministry Takes a Beating

    A few years ago, research began to emerge that youth ministry was broken. Most studies indicate that students who had been active in youth ministry, active in church, and active in spiritual practices were still “leaving” the church. The common phrase “what we have been doing hasn’t worked” supported the evidence: the church was not retaining students as young adults. Youth ministry was criticized as having become one more source of entertainment with rock-climbing walls, video arcades, and youth rooms that environmentally and technologically rival a nightclub. A major accusation was that youth ministry was being done “in silo,” away from the watchful eyes of parents and other church members.

    As a professor and youth culture observer, I see that parents bear some responsibility for the detachment and outsourcing mentality of youth ministry. Sure, youth ministers sometimes (in error) feel that they know better than parents how to spiritually nurture youth, but I have been amused to discover the different ways that parents outsource. There are etiquette counselors to coach manners, specialty coaches to train athletes, tutors for academics, and therapists for discipline and anger management.

    Also, the vocabulary of “church” and “spirituality” indicate that at least some of these students are disillusioned with organized religion but may have an affinity for God. While the definition of “leaving” is a bit fuzzy (some students left the church but did not necessarily leave their faith), the numbers point to a kind of exodus.

    Some studies claim that as little as 4 percent will remain Christian (an oft-repeated but seldom-verified number), while others suggest there’s virtually no exodus. The following is a summary of the most-cited studies that point toward the departure from church by the millennials:

  • The Southern Baptist Convention’s Family Life Council study in 2002 indicates that 88 percent of students leave after high school and do not return to the church.
  • A LifeWay Research study in 2007 found that 70 percent leave, although 35 percent eventually return.
  • An Assembly of God study indicates that 66 percent of students check out.
  • A 2006 Barna study, titled “Most Twentysomethings Put Christianity on the Shelf . . . ,” indicates that 61 percent leave the church.
  • A fair estimation, according to Timothy Paul Jones, a professor at Southern Seminary, is the LifeWay research assertion that about 70 percent of students who had attended church twice a month or more for at least a year during high school dropped out after high school. Jones also points out that the trend of declining attendance in church among young adults is not new. At least since the 1930s, involvement in religious worship services has followed a similar pattern.

    The National Youth Study of Religion was (and is, as of this writing) a massive longitudinal study of American teenagers designed to “enhance our understanding of the religious lives of American youth from adolescence into young adulthood, using telephone survey and in-depth interview methods.” Christian Smith, the lead researcher of NYSR, told us that evangelicals “behaved badly with statistics” and quickly dispenses with the 4 percent statistic. Smith and his team conducted extensive research on the spiritual attitudes of American students and published their results in a number of books and articles, including three books and a movie that summarize the attitudes of a generation toward religion and spirituality.

    It is beyond the scope of this chapter to go into depth about the study, but the results served as a wake-up call for youth ministry in three major ways. First, the exodus has been confirmed, though not to the extent that some alarmists have pronounced. Too many students detach from the church following their youth group days, though some return as middle-aged adults. Second, too few students possess the devoted mind-set of a disciple. Third, too few families are involved in actively discipling their students, but when they are, devoted discipleship is more likely to occur.

    Several books followed the NYSR research: Almost Christian, by Kenda Creasy Dean; Youth Ministry in the 21st Century, compiled by Rick Lawrence and Group magazine; The Family Friendly Church, by Ben Fruedenburg and Rick Lawrence; Rethink, by Steve Wright; and Transforming Student Ministry, by Richard Ross. All of these books are important interpretations of the NYSR, and all agree that in many cases moms and dads have dropped the ball with discipleship; they also agree that outsourcing to the church is not a healthy model for discipleship. Peter Benson, president of Search Institute, in the foreword to Passing on the Faith by Merton Strommen and Richard Hardel, parallels the trend in outsourcing at church to that of the modern school system.

    Families have extraordinary power to shape the lives of their children. This is so obvious that one would think it unnecessary to say. Unfortunately, a conspiracy of social forces has diminished the influence of family. Take, for example, the importance of a child’s educational achievement. Educators know that the highest level of learning occurs when family and school interact as partners, moving in the same direction during a child’s educational development. Families create positive learning environments at home—modeling, encouraging, and rewarding learning, while schools respect and encourage this family engagement. The family-school partnership is reinforced by frequent parent-teacher dialogues and parent engagement in school policies and programs. This partnership is essential. Unfortunately, it is also uncommon. National studies tell us that all too often families give away their power and depend on schools alone to promote their children’s achievement. And then the finger pointing begins. Teachers blame parents for being too busy with work and personal agendas to be attentive to the family role in learning. Parents blame schools for being out of touch with family pressures. Certainly, the reasons for parents’ lack of involvement are complicated. But the reality is that family influence on learning has gone underground; it has become a latent, dormant power. Families’ influence on faith development parallels this reality. We know from documented studies and from our own intuition that parents are essential actors in their children’s faith journey. Theoretically, congregations should support families in activating and using this power. Just as quality learning results from a strong family-school partnership, family strength results from a solid congregation-family partnership.

    Some have suggested that the title of Dan Kimball’s book They Like Jesus but Not the Church is the rationale for the attitude of some in the emerging adult generation who disdain the politics and the perceived message of “being against” in many churches but who have an affinity for God (or at least a “higher power”). Yet for whatever reason and using whatever metaphor, young adults are leaving the church at least for some period of time. Much of the blame for this trend has been laid at the feet of churches who do youth ministry “in silo” or apart from the dynamics of discipleship within the family.

    A Weed in the Church

    A movement has arisen in the past few years that sees youth ministry as a harmful element in the discipleship of teenagers, even going so far as to label it as a “weed in the church.” According to some who propose a model called the Family Integrated Church, youth ministry is the problem. The premise is that age-segregated ministry in general and youth ministry in particular has become a place where the discipleship of students is outsourced. I strongly affirm the criticism of a youth ministry that has a drop-off lane. The last thing that youth ministry needs is to become a place where the discipleship of students is turned over to the experts.

    The solution, according to the voices in the Family Integrated Church, is to eliminate age-segregated ministry and return the responsibility of spiritual nurture solely to parents, and especially fathers. I agree wholeheartedly with half of their objective. Parents are the primary disciple makers for their children. Are some youth ministries alienating parents and becoming their own kingdom? Perhaps. Do fathers need to take their duties seriously? Certainly. Should youth ministry and families partner for shared goals? Absolutely.

    While this book is a helpful corrective to the abuse of age segregation, I think the greater problem harming youth and families is what both Jon Neilson (a pastor to collegiate students at a church near Chicago) and my children identify: both families and youth ministries have allowed a widespread ignorance of the gospel, Scripture, and the place of a disciple in the world.

    What of Those Who Stuck Around?

    On a blog post titled “3 Common Traits of Youth Who Don’t Leave the Church,” Jon Nielson suggests three characteristics of students who do not leave the church:

  • They are converted.
  • They were equipped and not entertained.
  • Their parents preached the gospel to them.
  • The post is not necessarily based on research, and an appropriate critique is that Nielson’s list is too simplistic. He proposes that if a student is genuinely converted, participates in a youth ministry that equips him or her for service, and has parents who preach (and live out) the message of Jesus, he or she will not leave the church as an emerging adult. However, some of the comments in response to the blog post are as revealing as the post itself. One example:

    Here’s why the youth are leaving the churches, they’ve wised up. They realize the dogma of 2000 years does not apply to them. They are learning that a good, loving God does not need continuous praise or strict adherence to a Book that still can’t be translated correctly. Most of all though, kids are leaving the church because they see the hatred that is spewed from the pulpit against anyone who isn’t conforming or might be different. I’m glad the youth are moving away from that sort of strict observance because it’s the only way the world will ever come to a census [sic] that will allow everyone to be who they are without retribution and condemnation.

    A baby boomer who reads the paragraph above would probably tell the person who left the comment to grow up because the comment is immature and egocentric. However, it points to a major disconnect; it sounds like the person who posted it does not feel like his or her voice is heard or that the things he or she values are valued by the church. The silence of personal involvement is deafening. Where are the pastors, parents, or small group leaders who might have a conversation or a relationship with this person? Perhaps the person has never been to church and is slinging judgments from afar, but it is possible that he or she represents the statistic of those teenagers who gave up on the church.

    I kept hearing about the students who left for various reasons, so I decided to conduct some informal research. First, I spent some time with my own two children, asking them about the highs and lows of church for them. They both acknowledged that we had modeled and encouraged involvement in church that went beyond mere attendance. While I admit I did not do everything right as a father, my kids were not outsourced to the church. Yet their observations were astute. They did not really feel challenged to great things like they were in their athletic or theater endeavors. They felt like there was a lot of repetition and that many of the programs or events seemed so similar as to be interchangeable.

    Moving on from my own children, I realized that I had students in my classes at seminary who were emerging adults, who were in a generation where the norm was to leave the church or faith of their childhood (if any) and who represented the 10 percent or “devoted” minority of the National Study of Youth and Religion. I also realized that they were an accessible representation of students who did not leave the church or faith of their youth. So I asked them why they stayed. Assuming that seminary students represent young adults with a “connected” faith post–high school, I asked them about things that they connected with their decision to go into ministry.

    This was not quantitative data collection but rather a qualitative process in which I listened a lot and tried to find categories. I used a grounded theory approach by which I assigned each student to write an essay about their life from middle school through college. I gave very few guidelines and allowed them to use bullet points, stream of consciousness, and partial sentences—whatever kept the flow of recollection going. I then coded their responses to try to identify the friendship patterns, school configuration, family dynamics, church involvement, and extracurricular activities. My assumption was that I could identify at least some patterns that were different from those of students who did not remain active in their faith.

    Their faith stories fell into three categories. Some students had never “strayed” (though some of them went through a “disconnected” or “apathetic” season in their faith journey). Some students had returned from a walk on the wild side (some wilder than others). Some students came to faith after high school.

    About 75 percent of them indicated that their parents or grandparents were influential in faith formation. All who indicated that family faith was strong described it as “authentic” or “real,” though some described parents as “controlling.” About half indicated that “surrogate” or other adults besides parents (extended family, church, community) were spiritually influential. Adult volunteers in youth ministry were often described as “mentors.” I rarely heard that church was positive unless friends were mentioned.

    Most worked between ten and twenty hours per week in a part-time job or played varsity sports. If family was not the catalyst for faith, then a friend had usually been the influence. “Youth group” was mentioned more positively than “church.” All of the young adults who said that they were far from God, either because they strayed or because they were lost, were brought into or back to a vibrant faith by a friend. Even the young adults who never strayed indicated the presence of a spiritual mentor.

    Most interesting in my conversations was that ninth and/or tenth grade was pivotal. More than three-fourths of the students indicated that something significant happened in one of these school grades. They wrote statements such as, “I became a Christian at camp”; “I knew I was called to ministry”; and “I knew it was real on a mission trip.” From my perspective, it seems as if someone was there to guide them when they were able to process abstract thought in terms of application. If psychologist Jean Piaget is right and concrete thought gives way to the abstract cognitive ability, it is not surprising that these young adults appreciated and accepted the challenges that came from a deeper understanding of what it means to be a follower of Christ.

    Finding Balance

    As in most things that generate emotional response, it is sometimes difficult to appreciate the merit of positions that seem to be polar opposites. Yet a balanced perspective is both appropriate. It is important to hear the concerns voiced by the Family Integrated Church and at the same time acknowledge that age-segregated youth culture exists in every area of life. A healthy position acknowledges that some youth ministers and youth ministries have alienated families. In an interview with Rick Lawrence in Group magazine, Richard Ross says, “It is so obvious to those of us that have been doing this awhile that the family environment around young people is a major variable in how things go for them in adulthood.” If students credited parents with spiritual direction, they described parents who authentically lived out their faith. A healthy position digs into statistics for accuracy while at the same time being honest about the need for change. Jones writes,

    The news that youth ministry had failed to keep kids connected to the church resonated with these young leaders’ existing feelings of frustration. This widespread frustration yielded some very positive results. This frustration fueled the development of healthier ministry strategies than the fun-and-games approaches the youth ministers had inherited. The results included ministry approaches that emphasized discipleship, community, and the cultivation of intergenerational relationships.

    Jones edited a book that summarizes the spectrum of youth ministry models regarding youth ministry and family. In summary, “Family-Integrated Ministry” involves an emphasis on intergenerational discipleship but considers age-segregated ministry as humanistic and nonbiblical. “Family-Based Youth Ministry,” a term made popular in a 1994 book by Mark DeVries with the same name, places emphasis on programs according to ages and interests, but with facilitation of family interaction through intentional activities and training events. “Family-Equipping Ministry” involves maintaining age-organized ministry while reorganizing the congregation to call parents to become active partners in the discipleship of their children.

    In all three models, the value of parents as primary disciple makers is stated. Parents do need to see themselves as the main source of discipleship for students, but they also need to recognize value in the community and collective discipleship that takes place in youth ministry.

    My friend Walt Mueller from the Center for Parent Youth Understanding (CPYU) penned a concise synthesis on the reconciliation of the tension between jettisoning youth ministry as harmful outsourcing and the tendency of families to yield the work of discipleship to youth ministry.

    Let me offer some brief and direct thoughts on the relationship between church, youth group, and family that are restatements of things we’ve been saying here at CPYU since the get go:

  • The Scriptures are clear: parents are primarily responsible for the spiritual nurture of their children.
  • The youth group, Sunday school, youth pastor, youth workers, teachers, and congregation are to offer deliberate secondary spiritual guidance and nurture in support of parents.
  • Youth ministries that establish separate youth worship services at times when the “big people” are in “big people church” are nurturing kids into a needs-based understanding of worship and the Christian faith. Not only that, but they are dividing up the body of Christ. Children, teenagers, young adults, parents, middle-aged adults, senior citizens . . . all of them need to be worshiping together to experience the full breadth and depth of the body of Christ and to exercise and benefit from the giftedness of all.
  • Youth workers should be recruiting and equipping an army of adults to love, relate to, and mentor kids.
  • The church and youth group cannot ignore the growing number of young people who are growing up without a parent or parents in the home, and the growing number of kids whose search for redemption in the absence of home-based spiritual nurture lead them to the church and youth group.
  • One Size Doesn’t Fit All

    In 1993, George Barna published a book titled The Future of the American Family. Barna lists a number of living arrangements that might be called (by some) as families. He contrasts the traditional family (people related by marriage) with the “nouveau” family (two or more people who care about each other). His point is that families in Western culture are moving away from traditional families and toward the nouveau model.

    The 2010 Census revealed that more and more Americans are living alone, in blended or extended families, non-married cohabitation, domestic partnerships, and so on—pretty much what Barna predicts. Homes with mom and dad, 2.1 children, and a white picket fence are becoming a minority if not a rarity.

    Married couples were present in 48.4 percent of households, but only 20 percent of households contain married couples who have children living with them. According to MetLife, almost 20 percent of households have children (of any age) from a prior relationship(s). Almost one in ten of the families represented by the census are single parents living with their children.

    On the one hand, the ideal incubator for spiritual formation is an intact family. Ben Freudenburg, in a critique of the errant strategy that discipleship happens only in the church, suggests that church leaders demonstrate a greater awareness of family discipleship by changing the thinking from a church-centered, home-supported ministry to a home-centered, church-supported ministry. On the other hand, families should be able to count on the church for a little help.

    One of the most repeated questions of models that view discipleship as the exclusive responsibility of families is, “What about students who have no family spiritual involvement?” I asked Dr. Smith about the place of youth ministry in such cases. He indicated that in the absence of parents who are actively pouring faith into the lives of teenagers, the only other significant predictor of a devoted student is the presence of a youth minister in his or her life: “I did investigate what factors predict that teens are highly religiously involved when their parents are not. And there were only a few things that stood out—one of them was that the teen is in a church that has not only a youth ministry program but a full-time, paid youth minister.”

    One size doesn’t fit all. Different families need different influences to help them to guide their children down a productive spiritual path. Adolescence is fluid, and declarative statements about the best youth ministry model are not always helpful. Predictability goes out the window with teenagers because their faith choices are not always based on rational or normative factors. Consider the contrast between the journeys of my son and me: I found my way into church without spiritual nurture at home, and my son found his way out of the church (and thankfully back in) even though he had spiritual nurture at home. In these and all cases, the human dynamic is the X factor. Statistics are meaningless in the face of individual stories. Furthermore, God is not limited by our strategy, our circumstances, our models, or our expectations.

    Abandonment in a Culture of Specialists

    The purpose of this chapter is to think critically about youth ministry and families. Hopefully, the interaction between church and family is one that facilitates discipleship. However, the model of youth ministry is only one of several issues that come to mind. The pace of life for adolescents and adults is frenetic, and the lack of mental health resources, quality education options, and even recreational options for teenagers is well documented. The feeling of isolation from adults that Chap Clark describes as “abandonment” is almost a paradox in a social-media-driven culture. Despite constant connectivity, Clark observes that “those who control and define the systems and structures charged with nurturing and training up our young (and especially those who have the power associated with them) are either ignorant of how destructive life is for today’s adolescents or unwilling to take the wide array of indicators seriously.”

    Finally, the aforementioned trend of outsourcing has placed many adolescents in the care of adults—but not always with adults who are motivated by the best interest of the teenager. Anecdotal conversations with students reveal tremendous pressure from teachers who act like “their class is the only class I have,” coaches who say, “You have to choose between football and anything else,” or juvenile justice workers who gauge success by the lack of another arrest.

    Changing educational models have muddied the waters as well. I recently read that New Orleans has the greatest per capita percentage of charter school enrollment of any city in the nation and that the New Orleans suburb Jefferson Parish is the number two county in the United States for private school participation. Only Hawaii and Delaware have a greater percentage of children in private schools than Louisiana. The movement to private and charter schools, as well as home schools, seems to indicate that parents—particularly middle- and upper-class parents—have decided that the education afforded in public schools is inadequate. In the article I read about New Orleans schools that largely emerged as charter schools following the rebuilding effort after Hurricane Katrina, one parent said, “It’s the size of the classes and the community (feeling) at the school.” “Also, every kid has a computer, they have all the tools they need.”

    While it is not the purpose of this chapter to debate the flight from public schools, the question “What about other peoples’ kids?” is appropriate for both school and church. If middle- and upper-class students are taken out of schools and if age-segregated church programming (i.e., youth ministry) is eliminated, the influence of families who are willing and able to be part of the process is taken from students who do not have such involved families. Clark calls this the benefit of the “tribal connection.”

    In the not-too-distant past, even in the United States, communities were just what the name implied—networks of friends and neighbors who knew one another and carved out a life together. . . . The benefits of this tribal connection are obvious, especially in light of how far our culture has drifted from that. Not too long ago, even single parents were not alone in raising their kids, for someone was always looking out for them. Even as “rebellious” adolescents, young people knew they were valuable members of the community, were genuinely enjoyed and appreciated, and therefore were given boundaries and protected.

    Sadly, many students do not have intact or healthy family environments. I volunteer as a minister in the juvenile detention center in New Orleans, and one inmate remarked to me, “I don’t know anyone who knows anyone who has a father living at home.” Some parents have allowed their own agendas to take precedence over the identity and faith development of their teenagers. Clark states, “The mid-adolescent students who struggled the most in nearly every category of adolescent development—for example, self-concept, sexual behavior, substance abuse, and trust in friends or authority figures—almost universally came from a family system in which the home was not a safe, supportive environment.”

    What if parents who are involved in a local church youth ministry served as an advocacy group for all teenagers in the community? What if they organized to speak on behalf of students who might not have a voice? Clark goes on to suggest that students need parent advocates who might speak for more inclusion in sports, more reasonable and accessible school environments, and “regular meetings at which all those who work with adolescents . . . come together to help one another assess their unique and collective efforts to care for each child and adolescent in the community.”

    What Do Students Need from the Faith Community?

    I said earlier that I believe that parents can use a little help from the faith community. I mean all parents: parents like me who are wondering what they did wrong, parents who are raising children on their own, parents who are making the best of a blended or extended family, and parents who could care less about spiritual things. I also believe that the privilege and responsibility of youth ministry is to partner with all families to intentionally create environments that combine the best of families with the best of the faith community in order to see students mature physically, mentally, emotionally, socially, and spiritually. I don’t think it is coincidental that following the “Where’s Jesus?” episode of Luke 2, the author states that Jesus “grew in wisdom and stature, and in favor with God and man” (Luke 2:52).

    It is time to land the plane that is this chapter, so I will conclude with two lists and a quote. The first list is from Kenda Creasy Dean in her book Almost Christian, with an understanding (stated near the conclusion of the book) that the faith of teenagers is “the legacy of communities that have invested time, energy and love in them, and where the religious faith of adults (especially parents) inspires the faith of their children” and that faith formation is a “labor of love.” Working under the assumption that churches partner with parents to minister to adolescents, she says that the community of faith should give five things to students.

  • A creed to believe in—the articulated beliefs that students develop and defend. Dean’s premise is that students need a sense of certainty about their faith. Statements of faith from their community of faith are powerful statements of God’s involvement and concern for their lives.
  • A community to belong to—peer involvement as well as relationships with other adults who befriend them, with whom they enjoy talking, and who give them lots of encouragement
  • A call to live out—a sense that students exist for a purpose greater than themselves, that they are on earth to be the hands and feet of Jesus in helping and serving others
  • A hope to hold on to—inspire and equip toward a confidence that this world is not all there is, that there is a promised “next,” and that God controls the future of this world and the next
  • A world to share with—as Dean writes, “The essential mark of maturity in Christians—as in peach trees—is generativity. Mature faith bears fruit.” Her emphasis is on both an evangelistic generativity and the presence of the fruit of the spirit (Gal. 5:22–23).
  • The youth ministry is a part of the larger congregation, not a kiosk outside the store at the mall. As such, youth ministry should integrate and facilitate the greater goals, including the ones Dean identifies.

    Richard Ross describes the partnership between family and church, identifying at least three ways in which youth ministry might extend the faith lessons from home.

    Give opportunity for leadership roles at church. Part of the “silo” problem in youth ministry design is that churches treat students like they will one day be the church but not now. Ross advocates helping students to identify and deploy their spiritual gifts in significant roles in the faith community.

    Allow and facilitate challenging experiences. Challenges like missions and internships and gap-year programs help students to move toward adulthood and to see that they can accomplish great things. Ross quotes Tim Elmore, saying, “Our message to [the young] has been more about safety and maintenance than about adventure and calling. We have been protecting them rather than preparing them and coddling them instead of calling them out—challenging them to seize opportunities and make a significant contribution.”

    Intergenerational relationships. One of the clearest ways churches can augment family discipleship is to surround students with persons who are younger than and older than they are. Certainly siblings, parents, and grandparents are part of their home orbit, but at church they may be taught in Bible study by a senior adult or be asked to assist with Vacation Bible School for children. Part of spiritual maturity is what psychologists call “de-centering”—the realization that the world is bigger than one person. Students can observe mature faith in older persons and see the eyes of a child light up when a student shows interest in them.

    Conclusion and Discussion

    Here comes the quote. In the final chapter of Chap Clark’s book Hurt 2.0, the last section on the last page is titled “Communities Must Make Sure That Each Student Has a Few Adult Advocates Who Know and Care for Him or Her.” The last three sentences on that page read: “Every adult must attempt to add to the cumulative message of protection, nurture, warmth, and affection. It takes several consistently supportive and encouraging messages to counteract the effects of systemic abandonment. By far the best way to help our young is by being a chorus of support and a choir of commitment.”

    What Clark says in Hurt 2.0 about abandonment sets the pattern for healthy youth ministry. Students need both family and surrogate family. They need Mr. Clint to be crazy about them, and they need the senior adult who sends them notes; they need the pastor and youth pastor to know both their names and their dreams. They need to see discipleship lived out in families so that they will have a vision and a pattern for passing on faith to their own children. They also need to see church as an organic and local body that worships together, works together, and does life together. They need local bodies that are not self-contained but are part of a larger family called the body of Christ.

    When adolescents are launched into adulthood, they do not leave without the expectation they will attach themselves to a community of faith wherever they go so that they can be a significant part of a greater effort—being salt and light and voice in a culture that needs them.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑