9. Thinking Ecclesiologically
9
Thinking Ecclesiologically
Teenagers Becoming Part of the Church
The topic of this chapter is where our calling in youth ministry firmly resides: the nature and activity of the church (what is called ecclesiology). Dr. Mark Cannister, longtime professor at Gordon College, opens his chapter this way: “Transformation happens most deeply in the lives of teenagers when they are engaged in the broader life of the church and connected to a network of caring adults.” As Cannister describes what this means in terms of the church’s calling, he helps us to see how the idea of adoption embraces both the nurture of the young by adults as well as the responsibility of the congregation to help young people engage as participants in the community of faith. Making use of Don Coryell’s notion of young people as “reservoirs” provides an additional theological foundation for youth ministry as a place of nurture and training as well as contribution and participation.
Unique to this chapter is Cannister’s emphasis on the role of the youth ministry’s participation with the leadership of the local church through the strategic promotion of practices that enable and enhance adoption (although he rarely uses the term). The role of membership, for example, is a case in point. If you are part of a church or denomination (or even a parachurch organization) where membership is not emphasized, not important, or simply operates differently than Cannister describes, that does not mean this section doesn’t apply to you or your ministry. He makes it clear that the meaning behind membership, and therefore any other activities that may signify or encourage inclusion and connection to the body, is an important element of connecting young people to the whole. However a given church formalizes or invites children and teenagers into the relational and participatory community of faith is the responsibility of both the church leadership and the youth ministry leadership.
As you read this chapter, consider these questions:
The movie Failure to Launch is a romantic comedy about three men in their thirties who, having failed to take the leap into adulthood, are still living at home with their parents. They are not ready to engage fully in adult society, and in many respects the adult world is not ready to embrace the three of them. They simply refuse to grow up and embrace the transition from adolescence to adulthood.
This transition is less mysterious than once imagined. The reality is that we are who we were, and our faith commitments tend to follow a rather predictable pattern. The research of the National Study of Youth and Religion, led by Christian Smith, found a significant amount of religious stability and continuity among those moving from adolescence to emerging adulthood. Even those who are likely to decline in their religiosity as young adults can be identified in the adolescent years by observing key factors related to religious decline. Smith notes that
the lives of many teenagers who are transitioning into the emerging adult years reflect a lot more religious stability and continuity than is commonly realized. Everything simply does not change. The past continues to shape the future. This is important to know, because it means that religious commitments, practices, and investments made during childhood and the teenage years, by parents and others in family and religious communities, matter—they make a difference.
While Smith identifies several factors that contribute to high levels of faith among emerging adults, personal relationships with adults (parents and other caring adults) who connect teenagers to the faith community in the middle and high school years are necessary in almost all cases. Further, Lisa Pearce and Melinda Lundquist Denton found that teenagers who were the most committed to their faith reported that, in addition to having parents and close friends who shared their beliefs, they were also connected to a faith community that provided “a welcoming, challenging atmosphere that values and integrates youth.”
Transformation happens most deeply in the lives of teenagers when they are engaged in the broader life of the church and connected to a network of caring adults. This is not meant to minimize the role of student ministries, which are the launching pads of adolescent faith transformation. Nothing is more reflective of healthy student ministries than students who launch into the full and robust life of the church. For this to happen, however, the broader church must be prepared for and committed to receiving teenagers into its midst by valuing them for who they are and allowing them to contribute to the whole life of the church. This perspective is very countercultural, as few institutions embrace the notion of allowing students to contribute to the adult world.
Dave Coryell suggests that most churches view students from one of three perspectives: as rocks, receivers, or reservoirs. Churches that view teenagers as rocks do not see much, if any, value in their young people. Adolescents are understood to be adults-in-waiting who must patiently wait their turn to take on significant roles in the church. Their opinions on leadership decisions in the church are not valued, and they typically have few meaningful relationships with adults. Worship services in these churches are rarely designed to engage or involve teenagers.
Churches that view teenagers as receivers foster a culture of “passing it on,” which places adolescents as recipients of the church programs, values, norms, ethics, traditions, and beliefs. Students become static receptacles of the church’s teachings and are offered few, if any, avenues of contribution outside the student ministries programs. While there is much for teenagers to learn, faith formation requires contribution and involvement that is more significant than a faith passed down from the previous generation.
Churches that view teenagers as reservoirs understand that students have much to contribute to the life and ministry of the church. Adults in these churches are willing to build relationships with teenagers and invest the time necessary to develop their gifts and talents, encouraging them to contribute in nearly every aspect of church life. In this sense, students are contributing and connected to the life of the whole church.
Making Connections
In our technological society, life is predicated on connections. We are constantly connecting with people via text messages, cell phones, email, video chats, and Facebook. As long as these connections remain viable, all is well, but as soon as a network drops a call or a server goes down we feel helpless and disconnected. All of this technology certainly makes connecting easier, when it works, but it also has the potential to proliferate superficial connections.
Our technology certainly keeps us connected with more people faster than ever before, but what level of connection is being maintained? Is the church increasing or decreasing in its ability to live out the “one another” passages in Scripture? More than fifty times following the ascension of Christ, the Scriptures remind God’s people how to live in community with one another as the early church is being established. For example, we are called to accept (Rom. 15:7), admonish (Col. 3:16), build up (Eph. 4:29), care for (1 Cor. 12:25 KJV), comfort (1 Thess. 4:18 KJV), confess to (James 5:16), be devoted to (Rom. 12:10), encourage (1 Thess. 5:11), fellowship with (1 John 1:7), forgive (Eph. 4:32), greet (Rom. 16:16), honor (Rom. 12:10), love (Rom. 13:8), pray for (James 5:16), serve (Gal. 5:13), and submit to (Eph. 5:21) one another.
Living in community is different today than it was in the early churches of the New Testament era. Life is demanding and fast paced, but in some ways our technology helps us to stay connected and live out these “one another” passages. In other ways, our technology interferes with our ability to live out these commands. No matter where we land in a conversation concerning things that compromise community, it is important to realize that we are not the first generation to struggle with the issue. As the author of Hebrews encourages the Hebrews to persevere in their faith, he emphasizes the importance of community. “Let us hold unswervingly to the hope we profess, for he who promised is faithful. And let us consider how we may spur one another on toward love and good deeds, not giving up meeting together, as some are in the habit of doing, but encouraging one another—and all the more as you see the Day approaching” (Heb. 10:23–25). Staying connected is essential to caring for one another, and churches that care for one another are churches in which people are connected to one another in authentic and meaningful ways.
For students to become connected to the whole church, the whole church must highly value community. Many churches, large and small, work tirelessly to ensure that everyone feels connected and welcome in the faith community. For churches of only a few hundred people this is easier, as everyone knows everyone and gathering the whole fellowship together in one place is not too difficult. Churches that number more than a thousand people tend to develop small groups, regional groups, or some kind of community-group system that helps people to connect with others who live in close proximity, are in a similar stage of life, or are interested in similar issues. There are myriad strategies for fostering fellowship in large churches, and most make community development a priority because of how easily people can fall through the cracks in the setting of a large church.
Churches that are most at risk for failing in the area of fellowship are those in the five- to eight-hundred-persons range. These churches, which are often growing fast, have outgrown the small, family-church size in which connection and community happen almost naturally. But they may not have realized that people are falling through the cracks. Once they begin pushing the one-thousand-persons size, it will become obvious that a community strategy is essential. In the meantime, they are in danger of believing that everyone is connecting as if they are still a small, family church.
To place a high priority on connecting students to the larger congregation, the church must be committed to the value of community and “one anothering” among its adults. Such modeling is essential to the success of inviting adolescents into the fellowship of the whole church. Once a church has established a deep commitment to community, the assimilation of adolescents becomes the responsibility of the entire community, the whole pastoral staff, and all parents of teenagers. This is not an endeavor that can be executed by the youth minister alone.
Making connections usually begins in the student ministry itself, as faithful adult leaders connect with students. It is essential that these connections happen not only at the regularly scheduled programs but also between programs. Adults make connections with teenagers by demonstrating a curiosity about the interests of teenagers. This type of relational ministry is often the lifeblood of student ministries, yet it doesn’t always translate to assimilating students into the life of the broader church. Assimilating teenagers into the whole life of the church requires making connections with multiple adults who will speak into their lives in a variety of aspects of the church.
Many teenagers already have multiple adults in their lives. They have teachers, coaches, youth leaders, scout leaders, and music teachers. When my daughter was in high school she regularly connected with her small group leader at church, her flute instructor, her track coach, her yearbook adviser, and her Young Life leaders, all of whom are wonderful role models and most of whom are Christians. They are not all part of our church community, and there is nothing wrong with that. But what if there were another two or three or four adults from our church with whom she was connected as well? There were, and I will talk about them a little later. Each of these connections, large and small, helps teenagers to feel engaged and connected to the local congregation that is their church home.
Consider for a moment the places in which teenagers make connections with adults on a Sunday morning at church in addition to the student ministries venue. Perhaps each week at the front door they shake the hand of the same greeter, who knows them by name. Perhaps they sit in the same seat of the sanctuary each week with family or friends, surrounded by the same adults who know them and who offer a friendly inquiry into the happenings of their week.
A few times every year most churches baptize or dedicate children, depending on the tradition of the church. The occasions are marked by the joy of parents and grandparents, the endearing innocence of babies, and often the baby’s surprised reaction to the experience. One aspect common to all such rituals involves asking the congregation a question, and the question is always something like: “Will you promise to love, support, and care for these children as they live and grow in Christ?” To which the congregation gives a rousing: “We will!” But do they? And how? Unfortunately, if you asked most church members to name the children they had promised to love and support, they would be at a loss for words.
But what if, in that moment, rather than everyone in the congregation (especially a large congregation) pledging to love and support every child, a small handful of adults pledged to love and support one child, or one adult small group pledged to care for one child and his or her family? Children’s baptism and dedication pledges were designed in the context of small, family-style congregations and still function well in that context. Larger churches, however, need to consider adapting these pledges for their context in such a way that it is truly meaningful. Imagine a family coming forward with their child and ten or fifteen other adults and children who compose their life community or small group, who commit to walking alongside this child in faith for the next two decades.
Connecting children and teenagers to a broad range of adults in the church must be done with great intentionality. But connections alone are not enough. While it feels very supportive for students to be known by other adults in the congregation, formation of individuals and communities requires contribution. When teenagers matter and student ministry is a priority of the church, students are afforded opportunities to contribute to the whole life of the church.
Making Contributions
After every big win, the stars of a sports team always say the same thing: it was a team effort, and everyone contributed to this win. Sure, some players may contribute more than others, but in order to win in team sports, everyone must contribute. This is not just a phenomenon in sports. The same is true in the arts. There may be lead actors in a play or musical, but the whole cast contributes to the performance. Leonard Bernstein, the great conductor, was once asked which instrument in the orchestra is the most difficult to play. His quick-witted response was “second fiddle.” Bernstein went on to explain that he had no problem recruiting people to play first violin, but finding someone to play second violin or second trumpet or second flute with as much enthusiasm was always a challenge. Yet if nobody played second, there would be no harmony in the music.
Every instrument contributes to the majesty of a concert. Every player contributes to the beauty of a game. Every believer contributes to the splendor of the church. Without the contribution of every person of every age group, gender, ethnicity, and stage of life, the church does not radiate her full splendor as the bride of Christ. It is as though players have been left on the bench or musicians have been left backstage, and while the spectators may not notice their absence, the coach and conductor are keenly aware of the deficiency. Coaches and conductors quickly recognize when something is missing from their group because they understand what a complete team or orchestra looks and sounds like. I fear that we have forgotten what the splendor of church looks and feels like because we have segregated age groups for so long. We have accepted a new definition of normal in which children and teenagers are spectators in most settings and contributors only in their age-appropriate contexts. Sometimes children and teenagers remain spectators in their age-appropriate contexts as well.
Allowing teenagers to contribute is not only important for the faith formation of adolescents; it also benefits the entire community and the faith formation of everyone who is a part of it. We hear this truth whispered on a regular basis from volunteers in children’s and student ministry when they say, “I get more out of teaching Sunday school than I give”; “I learn more from the teenagers in my small group than they learn from me”; “Those young people keep me young at heart.” These are testimonies to the mutual contribution that is apparent in our lives. A few moments of reflection brings a sea of examples of the ways in which people younger, older, and peers contribute to our lives. Theologian Marcia Bunge reflects on the important contributions children make to adult faith formation:
Many Gospel passages turn upside down the common assumption held in Jesus’s time and our own: children are to be seen but not heard; and the primary role of children is to learn from and obey adults. In contrast, the New Testament depicts children in striking and even radical ways as moral witnesses, models of faith for adults, sources or vehicles of revelation, representatives of Jesus, and even paradigms for entering the reign of God. . . . Viewing children as models for adults or vehicles of revelation does not mean that they are creatures who are “near angels,” “closer to God,” or “more spiritual” than adults. However, these passages [Matt. 18:2–5; 19:14] and others do challenge parents and other caring adults to be receptive to the lessons and wisdom that children offer them, to honor children’s questions and insights, and to recognize that children can positively influence the community and the moral and spiritual lives of adults.
Bunge further suggests,
The idea that children can be teachers, bearers of revelation, or models of faith has often been neglected in Christian thought and practice. However, throughout the tradition and today, we do find theologians who have grappled seriously with these New Testament passages, forcing them to rethink their assumptions about children and exploring what adults learn from them. For example, Friedrich Schleiermacher emphasized that adults who want to enter the kingdom of God need to recover a childlike spirit. For him, this childlike spirit has many components that we can learn from children, such as “living fully in the present moment,” being able to forgive others, or being flexible.
The church is a wonderfully multifaceted community in which there is great opportunity for individuals of all ages to contribute. When I was a teenager, my family belonged to a church that had blended services long before blended or contemporary worship was popular. One of the more traditional aspects of the service was the processional in which the choir and clergy marched down the center aisle during the opening song and took their seats on the platform. Teenagers walked in the procession carrying flags and serving as acolytes. One acolyte led the procession with a cross just ahead of the choir while two others served as flag bearers just behind the choir; the fourth acolyte proceeded just behind the flags and in front of the clergy. I remember as a teenager thinking that I was playing an important role in the worship service. No doubt the choir members could find their way down the center aisle and into the choir stalls without me leading them with a cross in hand, but in my teenage mind I felt that the worship service could not begin without me leading the procession. I felt like I was contributing to something important and something larger than myself.
When I was serving as a youth minister, I regularly received calls from people in the church asking whether some teenagers could help with the women’s luncheon, the men’s breakfast, child care for an event, or the annual fall festival that raised money for missionaries. My response was always the same: “I can think of several students who would do a great job for you. I’ll send you a list of their names and phone numbers so that you can contact them directly.”
This simple yet strategic response accomplishes several things. First, when youth ministers are constantly asking students to do things, they communicate the subtle message: “He or she only calls me when they want something.” That’s not healthy for an authentic relationship, and this strategy cuts down on the amount of asking that the youth leader needs to do. Second, this gives other adults in the congregation an opportunity to connect with teenagers. By naming a specific person to contact (not the whole student ministry mailing list), a youth minister is placing a high level of confidence in the student, and the adult’s connection to the student will likely be a positive experience. Third, students are empowered when other adults see value in them and reach out to them. Time and time again, I would walk into a youth meeting, and a student would come up to me saying, “You’ll never guess who called me last night!” The notion that another adult in the church—worship pastor, children’s minister, chair of the women’s guild—would ask them to contribute to a church program outside student ministry blew their minds. Students feel valued, empowered, and honored when other adults ask them to contribute to meaningful ventures.
When my kids were teenagers, I worked hard to find ways both large and small for my son and daughter to connect with other caring adults and contribute to the ministries of the church. When they were younger and my wife and I were part of the communion-serving team, we would involve our kids. When we left our seats in worship to acquire the communion trays, they came with us. My wife and daughter would take one aisle as my son and I took another aisle, moving the communion trays from one row to the next. After the service we all helped to wash the dishes in the church kitchen, along with other adults. This monthly act of service offered a brief, simple, and stress-free moment of connection with caring adults and the opportunity to contribute to the ministry of the church.
Both of my kids know and are known by our pastor of adult discipleship, Doug Whallon, who has nothing to do with the student ministries of the church. Because I regularly taught or hosted an adult Sunday morning class, our family would arrive at church early, and I would ask Kasey and Ryan to help set up the room by distributing handouts around the tables while I fussed with the technology and my wife organized the food. Each Sunday, without fail, Doug (and often his wife, Mary) came by the room, thanking all of us for our service and taking an interest in the happenings of Kasey’s and Ryan’s lives that week. Each fall Doug and Mary would have a picnic for the adult discipleship committee members and their families—yet another opportunity for children and teenagers to connect with adults of the church.
My daughter served with the student worship team in the high school ministry. Every few months, that worship team leads music for the church worship service. This is not designated as a youth Sunday; the high school pastor will not let the teenagers be introduced as if they were guests leading worship. He wants teenagers leading worship to become the norm, not the exception. Students have the opportunity to contribute to worship among their peers in the student ministry as well as to the all-church worship service. This brings a unique life and vitality that would otherwise be absent from the congregation.
My son has been obsessed with acting since he was in elementary school. From time to time the worship arts ministry of our church performs short dramas to frame the sermon, so I asked the drama leader whether she would consider casting teenagers in some sketches. She agreed to give Ryan an audition, and he was cast as an iPhone-wielding teenager in the Christmas Eve drama about a family struggling with the real meaning of Christmas. The role required weeks of rehearsals on Wednesday evenings and performing in five Christmas Eve services over the course of three days. This is a significant commitment, but for several years he was a regular in the Christmas Eve dramas. I am thankful to the worship arts ministry for helping him to connect with other adults in the church and allowing him to make a significant contribution to the most well-attended services of the year.
Other students in our church serve in the nursery, children’s ministry, Vacation Bible School (VBS), and the café. From time to time students play in the orchestra in worship. My hope is that as time goes on, other avenues for students to contribute will emerge. There’s nothing to wake you up on Sunday morning like a high five from a teenage greeter at the door. And what teenager wouldn’t want to tell adults where to park their cars?
Some churches have been even more strategic in assimilating teenagers into the life of the church. From the very start of North Point Community Church in Atlanta, Andy Stanley and his team decided not to offer any programs for high school students on Sunday morning. They have a great high school ministry on Sunday afternoon, but Sunday morning is designed for high school students to contribute to the ministries of the church. Most students contribute to the nursery, children’s ministry, or middle school ministry during one hour of the morning and attend the worship service during the other hour of the morning. Their vision for high school students on Sunday morning is for them to serve for an hour and worship with the whole church for an hour.
People often suggest that there simply are not enough roles for all the teenagers to have an opportunity to contribute to the faith community. At Second Presbyterian Church in Memphis, Todd Erickson is so committed to having every teenager contribute to the church that he pulled the staff together and they took the time to identify all the possible areas where teenagers could contribute. Eventually they came up with enough areas that every one of the hundreds of students in their church has the opportunity to make a significant contribution each year. Todd believes that discipleship is an active, not a passive, process and that real success in student ministry is plugging students into the church in such a way that they are contributing to the church family. As in many churches that value the contributions of teenagers, Todd has dozens of high school juniors and seniors serving on the middle school ministry team, with the mentoring of adult volunteers. Freshman and sophomore high school students take responsibility for leading the VBS program under the mentoring guidance of caring adults. These students don’t simply show up for a week to serve as counselors. They are involved in the entire ministry development process, beginning with planning meetings in the winter and contributions to creating and implementing the VBS program in the summer. Another group of students leads the sixth-grade transition program, which includes several events throughout the year designed to help kids make a smooth transition from children’s ministry to middle school ministry. They have created a tradition of Tuesday morning prayer groups, which are organized and run by teenagers. The church is committed to a local community program for tutoring the refugee population in Memphis, and teenagers are fully integrated into the leadership of that program as well.
Likewise, Jim Byrne at The Falls Church in Virginia seeks every opportunity for teenagers to contribute to the ministries of the greater church body. In the summer, numerous high school students serve as leaders for the middle school day camp operated by the church. In worship services, some students play in the worship band while others serve as acolytes. In this Anglican church, Jim has created an acolyte program that is respected by teenagers and parents alike, raising its level of importance and allure. While in many churches mission trips are segregated by generation, Jim took the forward-looking approach to short-term mission trips by emphasizing family mission trips and mainstreaming students into adult mission experiences. While he occasionally still offers a mission trip just for teenagers, the emphasis is on encouraging people to contribute to church missions as a family, with parents and teenagers experiencing outreach together.
Perhaps the boldest strategic decision Jim made, with the full support of the church leadership, was to eliminate the high school Sunday school class in favor of offering students opportunities to contribute to the Sunday morning experience. Students serve in the children’s ministries, set up various rooms for Sunday morning programs, and direct traffic in the numerous parking areas surrounding the church.
When students contribute to the church, they become an authentic part of the family, and once you are part of a family, you go where the family goes. One of my mentors taught me long ago that people do something for one of two reasons: either it’s fun or it’s important—and fun never lasts! While there’s nothing wrong with using fun and entertainment to engage students in ministry, at some point ministry, church, and faith have to become important as students genuinely become integrated into the family of God. When I call my kids for dinner, they show up because it’s dinnertime, not because of the entertaining meal that is being served. (Sorry, but we don’t serve a lot of entertaining meals.) As Erickson says, “When kids are coming to contribute, the church becomes family, and they show up for family dinner no matter what we are serving.”
When students are invited to contribute to the life of the church, they are afforded opportunities to put their faith in action and experience meaningful engagement with the broader community of faith. Inviting students into this kind of contribution must be done intentionally, and it is the responsibility of the entire leadership of the church.
Membership Matters
Once upon a time, membership in a local church had its privileges. Members were afforded certain accommodations that were not available to visitors. Old North Church, one of the oldest remaining church buildings in Boston, is famous for its two lanterns, which signaled Paul Revere that the British were heading toward Lexington by sea as he rode his horse through the county warning the patriots. Revere was never a member of Old North Church; his family was Congregationalist, not Anglican. But those who were members in 1775 were able to purchase a pew for their families. Not unlike purchasing seats for a concert or ball game today, the practice of purchasing church pews assumed that the better the location of the pew, the higher the price. Touring historic churches on the East Coast reveals that church members often owned family pews. Ownership was indicated by a brass medallion, engraved with the family name and affixed to the pew.
Another historic example of privileged membership in the church was the common policy of church members receiving discounted fees for church events. I remember churches offering member prices and nonmember prices for attending VBS as late as the 1970s. One would be hard-pressed to find churches with such a fee structure today. On the contrary, as evangelicalism became more popular, churches began to eliminate as many barriers to attendance as possible. Programs such as VBS became outreach oriented, and everyone was charged the same price or none at all.
Likewise, participation in nearly every aspect of the church has been opened to regular attenders rather than limited to members only. No longer does a person need to be an official member of the congregation to sing in the choir, contribute to the worship team, join a pastoral care ministry, or do almost anything else. In many churches nonmembers can participate and serve in nearly every aspect of the church except on the church board. Even the way churches determine their size has changed from the number of members to the weekend worship service attendance number. Denominational churches often have a greater number of members on the rolls than people in worship, while independent churches often have far more people in worship than they have members. All of this raises the question: Does membership matter?
Anyone who has led a confirmation class or a baptism preparation class for teenagers (depending on your tradition) has faced the question of the relative importance or unimportance of membership for teenagers. Rarely do teenagers see any value in becoming official members of the church, even when they have grown up in the church. Their posture is typically that there is no payoff for them to become members. Why bother to become a member if the only reward is being allowed to vote at the annual congregational meeting? This is a self-centered response, to be sure, but few churches have offered teenagers any other significant reasons to engage in the membership process. When churches ignore the issue of membership, they communicate to young people a poor understanding of theology and a poor understanding of community.
Theologically, membership is about belonging and contributing to a community of faith. Our misunderstanding of the very nature of membership is exposed regularly when we ask one another, “Where do you go to church?” Fundamentally, we must understand that the church is not a place to which we go. The local church is not a building or a location; it is a community of believers committed to the work of God’s kingdom. In one of their final gatherings with Jesus, the disciples asked whether he was about to restore the kingdom of Israel. His response was that they were to be his witnesses in Jerusalem, Judea, Samaria, and to the ends of the earth (Acts 1:6–8). They were looking for a Jesus to establish a kingdom, and he said, essentially, “You are the kingdom. You are the church. You are the community of God.” The kingdom of God is nothing less than the community of God’s people, committed to one another and empowered by the Holy Spirit. Mark Dever describes the importance of church membership:
A temple has bricks. A flock has sheep. A vine has branches. And a body has members. In one sense, church membership begins when Christ saves us and makes us a member of his body. Yet his work must then be given expression in an actual local church. In that sense, church membership begins when we commit to a particular body. Being a Christian means being joined to a church.
Scripture therefore instructs us to assemble regularly so that we can regularly rejoice in our common hope and regularly spur one another on to love and good deeds (Heb. 10:23–25). Church membership is not simply a record of a box we once checked. It’s not a sentimental feeling. It’s not an expression of affection toward a familiar place. It’s not an expression of loyalty or disloyalty toward parents. It should be the reflection of a living commitment, or it is worthless.
The New Testament never establishes a dichotomy between membership in the church universal—that is, a believer’s commitment to Christ along with all believers past, present, and future—and membership in the local church. Once people professed their faith in Christ they were baptized, symbolizing their new life in Christ and their commitment to the community of faith. Membership in the early church was never a second step after baptism. When people accepted Christ they also accepted his bride, the church, and they immediately entered into fellowship with other believers in the local church. Today membership has often become an entirely separate process from confirmation or baptism, suggesting that a personal commitment to Christ is more important than a commitment to the community of faith. New life in Christ is viewed as essential, while commitment to the church is seen as optional. This dichotomy further undermines the value of community in the church by creating a system of elitism. When we do not enthusiastically view teenagers as potential members of the church, we communicate that they are not worthy of such a status. This is expressed in the teenager response to the question of why they do not become members of their church: “Because nobody really cares whether I’m a member.” Once again, the church becomes another institution in teenagers’ lives that is perceived as not caring about them.
Becoming members of the local church upon their profession of faith in Christ is an important aspect of assimilating teenagers into the community of faith. Membership matters for teenagers for a variety of reasons, which require us to rethink membership as an important aspect of the assimilation process.
Taking a Stand
Membership declares before God and others that we are part of a particular local faith community that has been entrusted with the gospel, and it is through the visible church that God expects us to live out our faith. The majority of Paul’s letters are written to local congregations or to their pastors. Nowhere in the New Testament are there individuals floating around in “just me and J. C.” land. Yet that is exactly what many faithful teenagers are doing because the church has not embraced them as committed, contributing members of their fellowship. Christians have always belonged to a local church, because the visible church is a witness to the invisible body of believers.
Membership provides a visible commitment to Christ and his people in the same way that a marriage covenant provides a greater level of commitment than simply living together. As a wedding ring is a clear and public statement concerning one’s identity as a committed spouse, so church membership makes a clear and public statement about one’s identity as a committed Christian. This commitment is directly tied to the “one another” passages mentioned earlier. We are called to love, comfort, serve, forgive, admonish, and exhort one another, among other things, but this occurs only among those who are committed to one another in a healthy faith community. Such a community provides a place where we can live out these characteristics of a life in Christ, with real people who have real needs and real problems and real faith. While this often happens within a student ministry group, it must also happen throughout the church. Teenagers must become members of the larger church community, “one anothering” the whole family of God and demonstrating their commitment to the bride of Christ, not just to the youth group.
Living in Obedience
Paul uses the image of the body as a metaphor for the church (1 Cor. 12; Rom. 12; Eph. 4). Being a part of the body requires connection. An arm that is not connected to the body is not part of the body. The family of God is connected to and belongs to one another: “For just as each of us has one body with many members, and these members do not all have the same function, so in Christ we, though many, form one body, and each member belongs to all the others” (Rom. 12:4–5, italics added). Membership is a visible sign of being connected to the body and a commitment to obey all that Christ has commanded. Joshua Harris suggests that the best thing the church does is to bear witness to new life in Christ, and that is best done in community:
One thing a local congregation does best is to show your non-Christian neighbors that the new life made available through Jesus’s death and resurrection is also the foundation for a new society. By living the Gospel as a distinct community, the church down the street accomplishes the important mission of displaying the transforming effects of the gospel for the world to see. Others won’t be able to see this larger picture if we remain detached from each other and go our separate ways.
Scripture contends that believers are to submit to and obey the leadership of the community of faith (Heb. 13:17), and the only people who are charged with being accountable for leading God’s people are pastors, elders, and overseers of the local church. Chuck Colson writes, “Of course every believer is part of the universal church. But for any Christian who has a choice in the matter, failure to commit to a particular church is failure to obey Christ.” Without being a faithful member of a local church, it is impossible to follow this model of Christian community.
Further, the leaders of the church are instructed to care only for those who have committed themselves to their care and become faithful members of the local church (Acts 20:28). Without making a commitment to a local faith community, it is impossible to function as part of the body and enter into a caring community that provides the accountability essential to fostering faith formation. As Mark Dever suggests,
The practice of church membership among Christians occurs when Christians grasp hold of each other in responsibility and love. By identifying ourselves with a particular local church, we are telling the church’s pastors and other members not just that we are committed to them, but that we are committed to them in gathering, giving, prayer, and service. We are telling them to expect certain things from us and to hold us accountable if we don’t follow through. Joining a church is an act of saying, “I am now your responsibility, and you are my responsibility.”
This is a countercultural statement that says we are committed to one another and we are more interested in giving than receiving. When this attitude is reversed and membership is more about receiving than contributing, we become a reflection of our consumer-driven culture, focused on engaging others only for what they can do to benefit us. There are few areas of our contemporary culture that challenge students to sacrifice for the good of the community, and the church should take its rightful place at the head of that line. Holding students accountable in a manner that offers grace and truth contributes to their humanity and to the common good of the church and society at large.
Building Up the Body
It is hard to imagine effectively contributing to the growth of a local church as a detached and autonomous attender. The church comprises many people with a variety of gifts and talents for the clear purpose of equipping one another and building up the body of Christ (Eph. 4:11–16). We understand the growth of the church to be the continual transformation of lives as more people come to faith and faithful people are continually sanctified. The strength of the body determines the power of our witness to the gospel. A church that is a strong and faithful body of believers is a powerful witness, while a church that is weak, divisive, and self-centered produces a poor witness. The unity of a faith community is a strong witness of Christian living in a secular culture. Together we proclaim to the world the character of God by loving one another, persevering through tough times, and serving the community at large as the bride of Christ.
Together we grow in maturity by building one another up, challenging one another, and learning from one another, “attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ” (Eph. 4:13). Only then are we no longer susceptible to false teachings and evil temptations. Instead, we become a community marked by Christ and held together by every supporting member as each person contributes to the body of believers.
Intergenerational ministry extends well beyond student ministries and incorporates every generation and all ministry areas of the church. The term intergenerational student ministry is an oxymoron; intergenerational ministry must always be owned by the entire leadership of the church and infiltrate the entire faith community.
