22. Rethinking Church Strategies and Structures
The best way to understand Steve Argue is to read his Twitter page (@steveargue):
PhD. i teach. Pastor. study topics on adolescence, emerging adulthood, and spirituality. speak. write. eat vegetarian. love running.
Except for the vegetarian and running references, Argue is one of a kind. He is a thinker, a well-trained trainer, a great youth worker, and an even better teacher of youth ministry at Fuller Theological Seminary. He completed his PhD at Michigan State University, and he was until recently a core leader (they call it “Life Development Director”) at one of the more influential churches in the country (Mars Hill in Grand Rapids, Michigan). He is also one of the kindest, most intentionally compassionate people I have ever met. When you look at his picture (you can see it on this book’s website at youthministry.fuller.edu) you can see that he is unique.
Argue is exceptional not only because he is an experienced church person, a deep thinker, and a significant leader who needs to be heard, but he also gets how much we need to change how we do youth ministry. In this chapter on strategy and structure Argue suggests that change should begin with who we are as youth ministry leaders. His advice is practical and real. As we close out this book, Argue’s call to inspire our congregations to intentionally engage adoptive ministry as learners is vital for anyone who wants to bring change to an institution that may be somewhat stuck. By focusing on those in front of us, whether that person is a middle school early adolescent or an exhausted volunteer, Argue gives helpful insight into pastoral care with a deeper calling—adoptive ministry.
Although Argue does not spend a great deal of time using the language of adoptive ministry, throughout this chapter he makes it clear that intergenerational connectedness matters only when there is a commitment to authentic family-like relationship. While Argue focuses on practicalities, it is important to read this chapter within the framework of the rest of Adoptive Youth Ministry. Argue’s insights and advice are vital practices for any youth worker, and especially for someone attempting to move a congregation from the inside of the organization. Keep in mind, however, that the ultimate goal of adoptive youth ministry is for every young person to come to know and believe that he or she is an important part of God’s family on earth.
As you read this chapter, consider these questions:
“We want to hire a youth pastor . . .
who’s smart and funny
and relevant and traditional
and young, but not immature
and mature, but not too old
and a leader who can follow
and creative and organized and musical
but not too artsy
and radical in an acceptable way
and married or married to Jesus
and masculine yet sensitive
and feminine but not too feminine
and can hang with our students and our parents
while hanging with her/his own family
in a perfectly balanced way
and spiritual in a practical sort of way
and practical in a spiritual sort way
and up on current events and historical events
and can predict the future of all things youth-related
and get our kids “on fire” for Jesus
in a safe environment
that avoids controversial issues like sexuality, poverty, or war
and can fill in on Sundays when the senior pastor is gone
and keeps office hours (this person should be in the office)
and goes out to meet students in their individual environments (this person should not be in the office)
and knows something about children’s ministry
and college ministry and small groups and programming
and can give his or her all but not burn out
and is willing to commit for the long haul
though we may not commit to him or her.
Furthermore, since youth ministry is changing, this person needs not only to understand family ministry and intergenerational ministry but also must solve the problem of young people leaving the church.
Do you know of someone?”
I have encountered forms of this montage with church leaders often—too often. It’s an impossible list forced into an impossible “youth pastor” job description with the intention of solving what seems to be an impossible challenge for youth ministry. The demands placed on the “ideal” youth pastor grow more and more overwhelming as we continue to learn about adolescent development, spiritual formation, sociological forces, neuroscience, theological turns, multiculturalism, pluralism, sexuality, and so on (the topics keep growing). We’re only beginning to discover how deep the youth ministry project hole goes.
As we realize that youth ministry challenges are broader and deeper, the expectations concerning what the youth pastor needs to be, know, and do keep expanding. As ridiculous as the above “job description” seems, it’s not measurably different from the expectations that are placed on youth pastors by desperate senior pastors, visionary boards, students, and overwhelmed parents. Mix these demands with present and future youth workers who desire to serve God through ministry, care about students, and establish themselves in the ministry world, and you have a cocktail for disaster that sets up everyone for failure.
If we care about our (typically) younger pastors who serve in the majority of youth pastor roles, churches cannot stuff one more line item into their job descriptions. It is time (it’s been time) for youth ministries in church contexts to reframe what “youth ministry” means and what role the “youth pastor” plays. Thinking about the place of youth ministry and the role of the youth pastor within a church context challenges churches to step back and consider—both theologically and missionally—what they are trying to accomplish.
Before we proceed, allow me to offer a few assumptions that frame my approach to addressing this challenge. First, while some will agree that youth ministry needs to be rethought, they will argue that youth ministry has failed and even damaged young people’s spiritual lives. There are movements within the church to eradicate youth ministry and to get churches to repent of this practice, which they see as ineffective, damaging, and unbiblical. I share their concern for advocating for young people but reject their conclusions; I believe that arguments to eliminate youth ministry are biblically unfounded and practically disingenuous. Yes, there is poor youth ministry out there (just like there is poor ministry for any demographic), but that does not take into account the great ministry that is being done or capture the faithful work of so many youth pastors (paid and volunteer) who love and walk with adolescents as society’s marginalized.
Second, youth ministry doesn’t need knee-jerk responses to the growing research we have on adolescents and their spirituality. Churches, youth ministries, and youth pastors don’t need the zeitgeists perpetually bombarding them with the latest and greatest topics and methods, which only oppress local ministries and drive them to ministry attention deficit disorder, insecurity, and impotence. When I first entered ministry as a youth pastor, my senior pastor told me that most pastors overestimate what they can do in a year and underestimate what they can do in five years. The topics raised in this chapter and book appeal to the five-year vision that values process and incremental change. Chasing the youth ministry flavor of the moment is not necessary or helpful to you or your ministry.
Third, youth ministry has come of age, and we must think critically on this whole experiment. Ministry fueled on good intentions is not enough. You probably picked up this book (or your professor assigned it) because part of being a youth pastor and ministering involves being critically self-reflective about your theology, assumptions, and practices. Rooted in the youth ministry experiment are the essential components of question asking, ministry innovation, and doing whatever it takes to thoughtfully and carefully connect the gospel and adolescence. Any good youth pastor is haunted by the question “What is good news to our students?” and is dissatisfied with prepackaged, generic answers. Therefore, we must be vigilant in our youth ministry practice; doing something “because we did it before” is woefully shortsighted (at best) and dangerous (at worst). Further, any reimagining of youth ministry practices means a reimagining of youth ministry roles. The two are inseparable, and I often see youth pastors who want to change their students, their parents, their church, and their world but are unable to change themselves. Be thoughtful. Be careful.
Fourth, context matters. My own ministry interactions and friendships have exposed me to ministry in urban, suburban, rural, national, and international venues, and I am convinced that context affects ministry practice. What works in one context won’t work the same way in another. Youth ministry is not generalizable. At best, we can learn from one another. In addition, each of us is tasked with understanding information pertaining to youth ministry and translating it into our contexts. For the sake of your students—no matter how great the resource—every Bible study tool needs to be rewritten and every book needs translation; while every success story can be celebrated, it cannot be replicated. Valuing context requires the hard work of taking ideas and reworking them for your contexts. It also means rejecting two responses that I hear often from youth pastors. I have seen some youth pastors hide behind their context, rejecting any challenge to their theology or praxis by saying, “Well, it’s different here.” Of course your context is different, but that does not mean youth pastors can be irresponsible and dismiss research, theology, or the challenges of our day. On the other end of the continuum I have seen youth workers trying to replicate everything they hear and read, with little success. There is no singular “biblical” approach, perfect formula, or timeless ministry idea (no matter what the promotional piece says). There’s only you. Youth ministry requires you to understand and test ideas against your contexts so that you can best serve your church.
Fifth, I recognize that my own personal background has brought insights and limitations to my perspectives. I am a white male who has grown up and ministered primarily in suburban contexts. While I have worked as a volunteer youth pastor, experienced parachurch ministry, and taught and trained youth pastors in seminar, college, and seminary settings, most of my proper youth ministry experience has been in larger, multistaff churches. My ministry journey has given me insights and given me blind spots; this chapter will likely highlight both.
Sixth, as someone who has been invested in the church, please understand that any critique I offer on youth ministry is not from afar. The questions I raise, the struggles I feel, and the hopes I cling to emerge from a desire to critique and improve youth ministry, of which I am part. Any critique one offers requires that person not only to point out the problem but also to work toward solutions. Thus I extend a hand of friendship to my readers, asking that they join together with me in loving God, loving others, and being courageous enough to contribute to innovative youth ministry.
The changing and challenging demands piled on the youth pastor have raised important questions about what youth ministry should be doing and what role the youth pastor inhabits within this context. It starts, however, with reimagining the youth ministry within church contexts.
Reimagining the Youth Ministry List (by Looking behind It)
The youth pastor superlist described above both humorously and grievingly captures the challenge facing youth ministry. As youth ministry has successfully attended to adolescents, it has also unearthed the complex challenges associated with young people. Unfortunately, as we have identified new challenges associated with serving adolescents, the “solution” has been to add corresponding correctives to the youth ministry list and the youth worker job description. This is problematic for a number of reasons. First, and most obviously, youth workers don’t have space for one more thing. Typically, they don’t have the time, experience, resources, or authority to address the multifaceted challenges facing adolescents. When youth workers are expected to do everything, they run the risk of doing nothing. We must reimagine their role.
Second, the complexities associated with advocating for adolescents require churches to recognize that the challenges associated with teenagers are not a youth ministry problem but a church and societal problem. Any hope of addressing adult abandonment, poverty, education, mental health, family dynamics, or loss of social capital requires a systemic perspective that calls for the investment of all adults—of which youth workers and the church are one resource, directly and indirectly serving young people and the worlds in which they live and move.
While the challenges we are discovering open a Pandora’s box of challenge and possibility, I will remain focused on youth ministry within the local church while recognizing that many youth ministry initiatives beyond the local church share the church’s passion and conviction and are doing some very good work. Still, the local church is theologically unique in its mission to proclaim the gospel through the reenacting of God’s story within a tangible community—word, sacrament, mission, and love gain context within a local faith community.
Youth ministry in local church communities must reimagine its approach by first ceasing the additive practices that cram more things into youth worker job descriptions. This does not mean that churches do not need to change and that youth ministry must ultimately be seen through the lens of adoptive ministry, but youth workers must begin to bring this corrective in whatever ways they can. In the meantime, churches must commit to refrain from adding to the list without first reimagining what forms the list. This requires systemic and creative thinking that is not simply outsourced to the youth pastor job description but also is embraced by the whole faith community. The practice of reimagining youth ministry begins by reworking the youth worker role. Those of you seeking a new job as a youth pastor can use this as a guide for your next call. Those of you who have current youth director/pastor positions may find reimagining your role more challenging for your church. Remember that a revamped list doesn’t mean simply editing the youth pastor’s list so that he or she can keep doing similar, but fewer, things. It means challenging youth pastors to reimagine their role, competencies, training, and trajectory.
For the sake of simplicity, I will use the term youth pastor to refer to the main person who thinks and implements youth ministry initiatives. I will assume this title to be broad, covering everyone from volunteers to part-time and full-time staff. I recognize that even this continuum assumes certain challenges and resources. However, I hold to the idea that pastors are volunteers, and part-time and full-time staff dedicated to working with adolescents; they respond to God’s call in their lives to serve adolescents, their families, and their communities. Pastors care for those entrusted to them, create spaces for people to follow Jesus and, at times, lead them where they may not want to go. Through it all they ensure that every leader aligns his or her ministry and rhetoric toward adoptive ministry. I remind my seminary students that the difference between a “youth director” and a “youth pastor” is that directors respond to what people want while pastors shepherd people where they need to go. This is the heart of being a “youth pastor,” no matter what the title.
To reimagine the youth ministry approach and the youth pastor role requires theological and philosophical shifts that reframe the way both are situated within the missional practices of the local church. The youth ministry “list” and the youth pastor role must change when youth pastors prioritize learner-centered pedagogy, commit themselves to pastoring adults as much as adolescents, and focus on transitional moments as the space in which transformative faith happens. For each of these categories, I will explore in practical terms what it means for the youth pastor and, systemically, for the whole church.
Reimagining the Youth Pastor as a Learner-Centered Teacher
Most youth pastors know that they need to teach somewhere, somehow. What I have discovered, however, is that most youth pastors, no matter what form they use (large group, small group, one-on-one, writing, etc.) tend to think that a “good” lesson, sermon, talk, or Bible study is one that they deliver well. The reality is that how well we deliver a lesson doesn’t equate to learning. Asking “How did the teaching go?” is the wrong question. A better question is “How did the learning go?” This is learner-centered pedagogy (teaching). In learner-centered pedagogy, attention is placed on the learner—who they are, what they think, and what story they bring to the teaching/learning space.
Learner-centered pedagogy assumes that adolescents (the learners) are not blank slates, empty vessels that need to be filled, or passive individuals to whom teachers download information. They are active learners who seek to connect what they have already known, perceived, or experienced with the new information or experiences they encounter. I have heard too many youth pastors lament or complain that their students “don’t know the Bible” or “don’t care about the Bible.” A learner-centered teacher takes the perspective that if learners aren’t learning it’s the youth pastor’s responsibility. Assuming that you have given them the right Bible verse or the best talk on sexuality fails to take into account where the learner is or what the learner needs. It also reduces the Bible to a list of magical statements that change people. Good teaching learns to value and cultivate good learning, which encourages active learning that invites the learner into the idea, the story, or the question. This approach is a much more challenging task for the youth pastor and for the entire church.
What This Means
A learner-centered posture is more than theory. It frames the way teaching and learning are done in a church context. When I explain this to pastors, I say that they must be committed to excellent content embedded in nurturing contexts. Both content and context require careful attention that encourages teaching and learning in relational spaces that allow for questions and meaning making. By content and context I mean the following: Content gives attention to the curricular scope and sequence that have been developed to ensure theologically sound and developmentally appropriate teaching and learning. This includes weekly programming, small group resources, and retreat materials that encourage students to further their understanding, questions, meaning making, and formation. Content calls students to connect their stories to God’s story. It is the responsibility of the youth pastor to faithfully tell this good story, which is rooted in the faithful teaching of Christianity’s narrative theology.
Context gives attention to the relational environments needed to create safe and open dialogue with peers and volunteers. Relational connection can be cultivated through volunteer training, formal small groups, and mentoring. Volunteers must be trained to interact with students in ways that communicate they are present and available, inviting them to articulate and ask questions of faith as they make sense of themselves in relation to God and others. Good youth ministry contexts create space for students to connect their understanding and experiences with God’s story.
In Philippians 3:10, Paul declares that he wants to “know Christ.” This concept of truly “knowing something” is established through the intersection of what one learns (content) and what one experiences (context). Formation happens at this intersection.
What This Means for the Youth Pastor
In practical terms, a learner-centered pedagogy that emphasizes content and context will impact the way youth pastors do ministry in some of the following ways:
What This Means for the Youth Pastor’s Church
Beyond good youth ministry, the perspectives described above are essential for the whole church. When it comes to teaching and learning, many churches have conflicting values that often divide “big church” from youth group and contradict learner-centered teaching with teacher-centered teaching. Youth pastors must advocate for the values stated above not because they’re just “good for the kids” but because they are good for everyone. I am not suggesting that youth pastors square off against senior pastors (youth pastors are sure to lose!) but that they consider the following:
The goal, then, is to create learner-centered environments in which learning is valued, people are encouraged to be active (vs. passive) learners, and the entire church becomes a learning community in which questions are valued and faith conversations are expected. The challenges that arise from this approach include the absence of simplistic answers, the disruption of black-and-white thinking, and the dominance of a single perspective. The hope is that faith for the whole community becomes relevant and the church becomes a space where the real questions of life and faith can be explored. Table 1 below describes how we have tried to think about creating learner-centered environments, emphasizing the intersection of content and context.
Content and Context for Learner-Centered Learning
Middle School
High School
Emerging
Adult
Content
• Learning the story of God
• Questions of content
We must teach them the story and how the pieces connect together. We must avoid moralism.
• Practicing the story of God
• Questions of congruency
We must help high school students see that what they know must be integrated with what they believe and do. This is a learning process. Experience and knowledge inform each other.
• Extrapolating the story of God
• Questions of meaning
Emerging adults bring new questions to the narrative; there must be room to question, doubt, and make sense of their complex world. Pat answers will not do.
Context
• Space to explore and experience
Be sensitive to the development of middle school students and that they need space to learn, understand—and learn and understand!
• Space for honesty of fears and doubts
Questions are abundant, and space needs to be made for them to ask the hard questions as they begin to make their faith their own. Failure to do this damages the formational process.
• Space for dialogue and creativity
Emerging adults need more than conformity. Growing up does not mean bowing to the status quo; it means actively interacting with it. Everyone must change.
Learning Killers
An uninteresting environment
Faith/formation matters in daily life.
An unsafe environment
Questioning faith is essential, expected, and encouraged.
An undynamic environment
Faith looks different from that of parents. It needs community.
An unshared environment
We are in this together. Learning and transformation is desired and expected by all, not just those we think we’re ministering to.
Reimagining the Youth Pastor as Promoting Sacramental Volunteerism
Youth pastors must begin to see their role as pastoring not only adolescents but also those who volunteer in their ministry. On the surface, this doesn’t appear to be a radical idea, but I would like to propose a definite shift in the youth pastor and volunteer relationship. Too often, we witness youth pastors recruiting volunteers to do only that—volunteer. Often the word volunteer communicates the expectation of “giving a few hours,” “helping out,” “chaperoning,” or “making a difference in someone’s life.” These types of expectations affect the way we invite adults to serve in our youth ministries. We often invite volunteers into our youth ministries expecting more of them than we should and promising them more than we can deliver. No wonder volunteers drop out and burn out. No wonder youth pastors sometimes maintain a love-hate attitude toward volunteerism.
Volunteering isn’t essentially about giving a few hours, showing up to supervise, or even changing a teenager’s life. We want volunteers to love God and love the youth. What’s more, our spiritual journeys don’t end when we reach adulthood. Most volunteers have their own questions, doubts, fears, hopes, and aspirations. When we ask people to join us in working with our youth ministry communities, we are not getting youth ministry experts; these are people who have lived life a little bit longer than our adolescents and who are willing to engage in the adolescent community. We are all in this spiritual journey together.
When youth pastors take this perspective seriously, they must realize that they need to reframe their relationship with their volunteers. Volunteers are not experts. Neither are they the supporting cast of the youth pastor superstar. They are simply people willing to follow Jesus in community with adolescents. In your youth ministry community, you will likely discover that volunteers are working through their own formational and personal challenges. Youth pastors, then, must pastor their volunteers as much as they pastor their adolescents. While there are pragmatic reasons for doing so—such as increased retention, longevity of volunteer involvement, and benefits to volunteer-adolescent relationships—I suggest that volunteerism is, in its purest sense, sacramental.
What This Means
A sacramental perspective toward volunteerism shifts a youth pastor’s mind-set from getting volunteers to “help their ministry” or “change a kid’s life” to highlighting the theological possibility that when volunteers choose to participate in the lives of teenagers, they encounter the living Jesus. Where two or three are gathered, and wherever we serve the least of these, Jesus is present. And where Jesus is present, everyone is transformed. Volunteering isn’t just an option or something people do in their spare time. Rather, volunteering is a necessity—primarily for the spiritual lives of the volunteers. People need to volunteer as though their spiritual lives depend on it. In serving and encountering others we see the resurrected Jesus and are transformed.
Volunteers in youth ministry, therefore, are not needed to stand at a distance, monitoring spiritual behaviors. They are invited to join in the journey of following Jesus themselves—a journey that involves us in the tension, pain, hope, controversy, insecurities, and hopes of life. There is nothing safe about it, not for adolescents or volunteers.
What This Means for the Youth Pastor
When it comes to youth pastors inviting volunteers into youth ministry, we must reimagine what volunteerism looks like. A vision of healthy volunteerism includes both expectation and support. In terms of expectations, I suggest that a sacramental view of volunteerism will inform the way we reimagine our work in the following three areas: the way we recruit, the way we train, and the way we evaluate.
We Recruit Differently
As I mentioned above, let us repent of making promises we can’t keep. You cannot guarantee that volunteers will change a student’s life. It is more truthful (and likely) to promise that students will mess up volunteers’ lives. (Try saying that at your next recruiting push!) But the deeper issue is this: we don’t recruit volunteers because students need volunteers; we recruit volunteers because adults need to volunteer for the sake of their own spiritual formation.
We need to convey to our volunteers that when we give of ourselves—whether to youth, emerging adults, young couples, or senior citizens—we are putting ourselves into the relational space of another. In the case of youth ministry, we are inviting potential volunteers into the life of a shared community so that we can begin to understand the lives and worlds of adolescents as they begin to understand the lives and worlds of the adults who spend time with them. Who is changing whose life? Exactly. I have seen many volunteers quit because, as they told me, “I didn’t sign up for this.” I realized they were right. I promised them impact, not pain. I promised them they’d see lives change, just not their own. And I realized that I failed them by the way I recruited them. No more. State your expectations up front. Accurately frame who a volunteer is and what a volunteer is stepping into. You owe it to them.
We Train Differently
Volunteer expectation and support can be articulated in volunteer training. Volunteers need two things: a clear vision of their role and a community who nurtures their formation. Space does not permit me to go into great detail here, but I want to suggest that both of these volunteer needs can be addressed through the following initiatives.
First, create a volunteer handbook that frames the role volunteers have in the youth ministry. This is more than creating a job description. The job description is only one, small element. The way you actually create the handbook models the priorities you have for your volunteers. Keep these things in mind:
Second, create a volunteer training arc in which the primary goal is to nurture the spiritual formation of your volunteers. If volunteerism is about volunteers following Jesus, youth pastors must take this seriously. Spiritual formation coupled with serving provides the perfect intersection of content and context in the lives of our volunteers. Our church has come up with a yearly training arc that invests in our volunteers. Below is the rhythm we have implemented.
Summer
Early Fall
Late Fall
Winter
Training Arc for the Formation of Volunteers
Timing
Summer
Early Fall
Late Fall
Winter
Spring
Topic
Discern and Decide
Work with youth ministry staff and core leaders to discern the training-arc topic for the ministry year.
Train
Introduce the topic to your volunteers. Establish this theme as your focus for the year and provide ways for volunteers to express the theme in their volunteer ministry.
Retrain
Volunteers have had time to think about the training theme and work with it within their volunteering experiences. Remind and retrain based on volunteer feedback (what’s sticking, what’s unclear, what new questions have surfaced?).
Go Deeper
Invite an expert on the topic to formally train your volunteers. Volunteers will now be familiar with the topic and will likely have deeper questions. This promotes new perspectives and encourages deeper understanding.
Celebrate
As the ministry year ends, take time to reflect on your theme. What have volunteers learned about God, themselves, and ministry? Celebrate the ways they have grown and been challenged.
Spring
We Shepherd/Assess Differently
Let’s face it: simply having volunteers makes a youth pastor grateful. The thought of assessing their performance seems counterintuitive, especially since we aren’t going to give them raises! If we situate assessment within the context of formation, however, we begin to realize that assessment is part of the formational process we owe to our volunteers. Without a clear assessment process, assessment often gets reduced to whether we like the volunteer. But there’s a better way. If you have established solid recruiting promises, clear expectations, and consistent support through training (formal and informal), you can have a fruitful conversation with your volunteers at the end of the year—and you need to have that conversation. There are many approaches to this process, so I’ll offer just one as an example. I encourage you to develop your own.
Assessments may have the following categories:
Expectations
Personal Formation
Future
Reimagining the youth pastor in terms of pastoring volunteers is essential because it acknowledges the role the youth pastor plays in the spiritual formation of her or his volunteers, reframes volunteerism as sacramental and formational for volunteers, and reverses the flow of formation—rather than adults doing things for students, students are invited into a shared formational process.
What This Means for the Youth Pastor’s Church
I have made the assumption regarding the pastoring of one’s youth ministry volunteers that the annual calendar fits into the broader church calendar. While I think this is a reasonable assumption, it is important for youth pastors to compare their plan with the broader calendar of the church to prevent conflicting priorities. For example, we realized that our volunteer weekend was typically the same weekend as the fall kickoff for the whole church. Asking our volunteers, who are invested members in our church, to be absent from that gathering was a disservice to them and to our broader church. We now end our retreat by going to church together. In addition, many of our volunteers are younger and also serve in our kids’ ministry. To be gone for youth training affected their volunteer needs, and we had to carefully ensure that everyone was cared for.
More broadly, this approach to pastoring our volunteers has a dramatic effect on raising the volunteer expectations and support of all those who volunteer in the church. Expectations, theology, investment, and support can help other ministries but also have the potential to create tension between ministries. Also recognize that if you are shepherding your volunteers well you are preparing them not only for your ministry but for any future ministry as well.
Reimaging the Youth Pastor as Bridge Builder within (Necessary) Transitions
It is old news that churches continue to segment ministries and thereby solidify the silos those segments create. Cries for churches to break the barriers and even deconstruct the segments are heartfelt but, in my estimation, misguided. Churches must hold generalizability and specificity in tension. It is true that segments can turn into silos; for some churches, these silos, in turn, become mini-kingdoms that fight other ministry kingdoms for resources and attention. It gets ugly, but I don’t blame pastors for being passionate about their ministries and ferocious in advocating for their constituencies. As I see it, the silos have developed through a combination of unhealthy practices and a passion for a particular ministry.
What This Means
Dismantling silos by creating generic ministries like “family ministry” may offer a better structure, but it fails to address the unique formational needs of kids, students, and emerging adults. At the same time, siloed ministries that don’t communicate and work together to create a broader developmental and formational arc are also shortsighted. The youth pastor role cannot be eliminated, but again, it is essential that her or his role be reimagined. Gone are the days when youth pastors can be “hip with the kids” and simply be concerned with their own ministries. I won’t hire a youth pastor who can’t speak to children’s ministry issues, explain to me what emerging adulthood is, or talk to me about the pastoral needs parents have. Through the youth pastor role we can address both the need for youth ministry to include a broader, generalized view of ministry and the need for youth ministers to be experts in their field, ensuring attention is paid to the transitions in a young person’s life.
What This Means for the Youth Pastor
Therefore, the role of the youth pastor must include being a bridge builder. In learning theory, bridge building is a crucial element for those transitioning from one way of knowing to a new, more mature way of understanding. The transition is also a time of great anxiety as a young person leaves one way of relating to faith and community and moves toward new, more complex expressions. From a church perspective, we must recognize that young people are constantly navigating new ways of relating to their faith community as they transition from childhood to emerging adulthood. They are changing, and we must change with them.
The role of the youth pastor, then, is to build bridges between old and new forms of knowing and relating. Too often, ministries “graduate” young people from one siloed ministry to the next, assuming that they will assimilate. Research and experience show that as students get older, attrition increases and often culminates in youth “leaving the church.” Youth pastors can address siloing, attrition, and transition better by being the bridge builders. Bridge building acknowledges that young people are being challenged to move from one form of knowing toward another. Bridge builders are advocates who start where young people are and provide intentional ways to walk with young people until they are willing to let go and journey to other side of the bridge. Too often in youth ministry we yell from the other side of the bridge, “Come here! It’s awesome! We’re cool!” Young people need more than that.
While young people who have graduated from high school are often accused of “leaving the church,” interpreting this through the perspective of “transitions” and “bridge building” can help us to see the situation differently. Consider, first, that those graduating from high school are faced with one of the biggest shifts in their spiritual lives—they are forced to relate differently to their faith community. They no longer have youth group or age-graded programming and are asked to relate to their church as adults, but they are typically given very few cues to help them through this transition (unless they get married!). Second, churches have not provided clear bridges that emerging adults can use to relate to their faith community. Worse, many churches blame emerging adults for their failure, accusing them of “leaving the church.” Imagine how an emerging adult feels—they no longer have a clear way to relate to the church and have received no help in making these transitions, and then they’re blamed for it.
What This Means for the Youth Pastor’s Church
As bridge builders, youth pastors can address this challenge and advocate for young people by focusing on two important transitional perspectives that affect the whole church: developmental transitions and epistemological transitions.
Developmental Transitions
The most obvious transitions are those that happen between the developmental breaks young people experience between grade school, middle school, high school, and post–high school (college, military, work, gap year, etc.) ministries. Space does not permit us to debate whether these transitional gaps in church should follow the educational system. It is enough to say that culturally there are established transitions in your community that most families experience and to which the local church must pay attention. Again, for young people, each transition represents a shift in the way they relate to their faith community. The way they are treated, the expectations we place on them, and the support we give them change. We must help them and their parents make these transitions. Remember that the questions, fears, and anxieties that surface have less to do with whether young people like the program and more to do with young people and parents learning to relate to your church in a new way. The student who is suspicious of a new program may just miss their old teachers and friendships. The parent who wants you to take care of their kid the way their church programs did for them (or at least how they think they did) in grade school must learn that, as parents, they must play a more active role in their child’s spiritual development. As you pastor, you can promise to walk with them, help them to interpret this new relationship, give them resources to participate well, and challenge them in their own spiritual development. Great ideas have surfaced in light of developmental transitions.
Here are a few ideas that we have tried to capture.
Epistemological Transitions
I’d like to take this idea of transitions and the youth pastor as bridge builder a bit further. If we talk only of structural and developmental elements, we miss the deeper, underlying essence of Christian formation. Transition ultimately challenges us to reimagine our understanding of faith. For many, faith has been taught, communicated, and believed to be something that most people “get” when they are young. The resulting mentality, then, is to provide programming that preserves and protects them from “losing” their faith. Transitions become more about church retention and attrition, which contributes to the misguided understanding that many churches have concerning young people “leaving” church (assuming that they have lost their faith).
Epistemologically—how we know what we know—youth pastors need to recognize that faith is actually one giant transition. It is dynamically changing, and the role of youth ministry is not to preserve young people’s faith as much as it is to help them mature it. Maturity is about transformation, change, and transition from less mature forms of faith to more mature and reliable ways of living our faith.
When understood in this way, faith has verblike qualities. It may be more accurate to call it “faithing.” Faith is a verb more than a nounlike possession on which young people act. Faith is the way humans make sense of their world. People make meaning in order to connect and hold together the barrage of information they are continually learning and experiencing.
In light of epistemological transitions, faithing is a difficult task. First, new information is constantly bombarding people, increasing the amount of information they must juggle. Second, people need to find epistemological equilibrium. In other words, if pieces of information they acquire don’t fit, the human psyche is compelled to find a way to make them fit. People can’t live in disequilibrium; life has to make sense. Failure to see faith as a verb and relegating it to a noun we fear they’ll “lose” misses the role we must play in building bridges that encourage their formation within their complex worlds, rather than the simplistic preservation of a world that no longer exists.
When the amount of information or the depth of an experience overwhelms the existing ways in which people process data, people can’t assimilate it all. They must accommodate it. Accommodation requires a destroying of one’s current way of faithing in order to reconstruct a new, bigger, and more complex way to handle the new information/experience. Accommodation occurs as one works through crises and disorienting experiences by constructing a more reliable way to faith. When we hear students who have traumatic experiences say, “I’m not sure I believe in God anymore,” understanding their struggle as faithing in more mature ways rather than losing their faith affects the way we support them.
When we think of faith as perpetual transition, we begin to see faith as a process that is owned by the whole church. We must work together to ensure that our young people are given support and opportunities to grow their faith, creating ministries that prepare them for a life of faith that is dynamically changing and growing. The youth pastor’s role can no longer be to protect the faith and create “safe places” for young people (as though faith were safe!). Instead, he or she must provide space for young people and the whole community to journey together as their faith changes, grows, and matures.
For our church, this has informed many of our ministry approaches. Below are a few examples.
What Does It Mean to Bring Young People into “Big Church”?
I lament the common term big church because it communicates that many young people see the main church gathering as being for “them and not us.” I have been told that large church services are not for young people because the topics discussed are too complex for young minds. This assumes, however, that church and faith are merely intellectual exercises and that the main service is a lecture hall. Adoptive ministry advocates and mentors need to be reminded that the “main service” of word, sacrament, symbol, and ritual is not a lecture hall as much as it is a family gathering where people from diverse backgrounds join together to reenact the story of God together as a family. Young people may not understand everything, but they see adults praying, singing, taking communion, and responding to God’s story. We learn more about the family of God when the family gathers. The more that we (and the leaders we serve) focus on adoption as the goal of youth ministry, the better we can help young people understand that this gathering is not just for others but is also actually where they belong.
In our church’s context, we recognized that we needed to prepare young people to engage in our gathered community time, but we also needed to prepare our adults to welcome and receive those young people. To prepare relationally separated adolescents for participation in the community gathering, we take them through recordings of our services, starting and stopping the video to point out what is happening and what we are doing while kids (and parents!) ask questions. As we are preparing the kids to join the family room we are reminding the adults that young people are not guests but participants, even siblings, in the community. We try to emphasize—to everyone—that we are all formed through the faith of one another as the family of God.
Summer Is for Everyone
We have discovered that when we scale back segmented programming in the summer, we have an opportunity to deliberately address the whole community through creative teaching and by placing an emphasis on the conversations people have with one another when they leave church. It has been observed that the best conversations happen not only when older people ask questions of younger people but also when both groups mutually ask and answer questions. This is another way in which faith grows.
“Post–High School” Starts Junior Year
One of the ways we can prepare our students for faith after high school is to begin preparing them during their junior year. The teaching arc that we have established for our juniors and seniors shifts toward helping them think about the faith questions they are already starting to ask regarding their identity, belonging, and life’s purpose. Giving them permission and space to express doubt, ask questions, make sense of their faith prepares them for a dynamic faith that must change and mature.
Resist College-Age Ministry
One of the commitments we have made is to resist creating a college-age ministry program that looks like our youth ministry programs. This is tough for two reasons. First, having a ministry where college kids show up always feels really good and makes churches feel like they’re doing something. Second, many college-aged students (especially the more spiritually immature) want a college-age ministry.
In light of our emphasis on faith as dynamically maturing, we recognize that we want all of our programming to promote a “formation-forward” approach. This means that our programming must do more than meet the needs of our age groups; it must move them forward in their faith maturity. If it is true that emerging adults are challenged to relate to their faith community differently, then we do them a disservice by providing them “adolescent” forms of programming. “Youth group” for college students is formation “backward” not “forward.” Youth pastors and those working with emerging adults must reimagine the relationship between emerging adults and the church. What is “good news” for them? What kind of community do they need? How does their involvement and service grow us as a community? Can we take their questions, critiques, and doubts seriously? This approach ultimately challenges every church’s theology, values, assumptions, and purpose.
Reimagine
The youth pastor list can’t get any longer. Youth ministries in the church need youth pastors to reimagine the way in which they advocate for young people as well as their own role in that process. This brief exploration suggests that we can start by reimagining youth pastors who are committed to promoting learner-centered pedagogy, forming adults through the sacrament of volunteerism, and being bridge builders in the dynamic transitions of faith. Hopefully, these necessary perspectives can contribute to rethinking both youth ministry’s purpose in the local church and the youth pastor’s role, affecting churches’ priorities, strategies, and structures. I hope these ideas inspire more ideas as we continue to live into this great youth ministry experiment together.
