Chapter 23 of 31

18. Adoptive Youth Ministry

18. Adoptive Youth Ministry

18

Adoptive Youth Ministry

A Latin American Perspective

HOWARD ANDRUEJOL

Any comprehensive book concerning the foundations of youth ministry must take seriously how the world is changing. One of the most significant changes in recent years is the reality that we do not do ministry in a single-culture vacuum. We live in a global world, and in the United States we are part of a global society. According to the Census Bureau, in 2013 there were 54 million Hispanics living in the United States; this population is now the nation’s largest ethnic or racial minority group. To serve in ministry within the context of contemporary culture—especially ministry to young people—it is vital that we learn how leaders in non-Caucasian groups view and practice youth ministry. Not only do we need to walk alongside one another in ministry, but we also need a clearer grasp on what God is doing around the world and across our nation.

When we began the search for someone who could bring his or her history and perspective to Adoptive Youth Ministry, the single name that kept surfacing was Howard Andruejol. As Youth Specialties has spread throughout the Hispanic (Spanish-speaking) world, offering conferences, books, media, and magazines, Andruejol has been a central figure in shaping youth ministry training both in Latin America and around the world (Hispanics reside in nearly every nation). He knows youth ministry—not only Hispanic expressions of youth ministry but also the theological reason for and necessity of youth ministry in every context.

We are excited for you to read Andruejol’s chapter and watch his video at youthministry.fuller.edu so that you can learn what youth ministry looks like in Latin America. In so doing you will not only have a deeper grasp on what brothers and sisters are doing in the name of Christ for kids, but you will also be able to more clearly see how participating in God’s adoptive ministry can strengthen your own call and practice of ministry. As Andruejol puts it in this chapter, “Adopting a younger one is the biblical ministry in the church; it’s the real youth ministry. To help kids feel safe with us, in a protected zone as the sheep when they are taken care of by their shepherd. This is the kind of leadership that we need today.”

As you read this chapter, consider these questions:

  • How would you describe youth ministry as you know it to be different from how Andruejol describes youth ministry from a Latin American perspective? In what ways are they similar?
  • What are three specific insights or statements from this chapter that can help you practice adoptive youth ministry more effectively?
  • Where have you seen power in leadership affect ministry? Describe what it looked like. Have you ever seen empowering leadership in ministry? Describe what that looked like.
  • How can adoptive youth ministry be practiced in a setting that is controlling? What can a youth worker do to encourage an adolescent or emerging adult to be connected to a community in which they may not necessarily be embraced and welcomed?
  • Latin America is a young region. According to the Statistics Division of the Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC), more than 40 percent of our population is under twenty-five. According to UNICEF, more than 100 million are between ten and eighteen, and about 15 million of them live in extreme poverty. Corporación Latinobarómetro reports that eight out of ten of those between sixteen and twenty-five consider themselves a religious person—either Catholic or evangelical.

    The way we do youth ministry today in our countries will affect the future of the church here and around the world.

    Our Heritage in Latin America

    I confess that defining our context in one word seems a little bit bold; nevertheless, I feel it is something both simple and necessary to do. The best description is oppression. In any circle of our societies, it is tangible. We have grown up under oppression, and that’s the only thing we have seen.

    It is not necessary to go back to the times of the conquest in order for our cultural environment to stand out. Just a simple glance at the governments of the past century will show how those who have reached power have been looking to take advantage of their size to dominate, control, manipulate, and oppress the people who have elected them by their sovereign will. Of course, certain cases of absolute tyranny in some of our countries stand out.

    This system of oppression is notorious in the family environment as well. There are far too many stories of adults (also called “greater” in the sense of superiority) who abuse children and adolescents, including verbal, physical, and emotional abuse, or all of the above. This is because one person is always on top, and the rest are under—one who dominates and others who are dominated. A victim and a victimizer.

    Are we safe at the church? No way. It takes only a shallow observation of the pastoral office to know that we suffer within this ecosystem of oppression as well. In this case, the abuse extends is tentacles to the spiritual domain. Titles and positions in organizations are a symbol of great power. It is true that power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. In the church’s realm, there is one on top and the rest lay below. There is one who commands and many who obey (or at least are expected to do so). According to those in leadership, power is to control those who are called their followers. This is the perfect bait for the unsuspecting victim to fall into the claws of abuse.

    We have become so used to oppression as a way of life that we do not need social scientists to describe it. In some cases oppression may be subtle, but for those who live in Latin American, it is simply a fact. In terms of a ministry perspective, people are used to living under submission to a superior power. Decision making belongs to those who are in higher levels of authority. It is very obvious that this responsibility belongs to certain people within organizations, so when it comes to making decisions concerning one’s personal life or family, it is easy to yield that right. People unquestioningly follow those who are in control. Accordingly, the expression of creative ideas or alternative points of view is for the most part unacceptable. Whether it is in society, family, or church, even mild dissent is considered a sign of rebellion. In the church one does not question the pastor; you obey him (and it is almost always a him). You don’t query his word, or you are seen as causing division. One is in command, and the rest obey.

    As I write these lines, I imagine the expression of some Latin youth leaders that I know. I am sure that they would look at me with worried eyes. “Isn’t this the way things are supposed to work?” As I say, oppression is so much a part of our ecosystem that it is hard to show a fish the water where he swims. How I am opening this chapter might cause many to call me rebellious or audacious for opposing what pastors, leaders, bishops, and modern apostles teach—and how they teach and how they lead is with power and authority. To question this, even in the church, goes against everything we have been taught about living under leadership. They rule; we follow.

    In the Latin America context, you don’t question that authority. If someone dares to try escaping from this prison, there are only two ways out: confront and dispute in protest or ascend to a position of power. You become one of them, or you are against them. We are either the victim or the victimizer. In the Latin psyche, there is no middle ground.

    A Different Church?

    Once again, we don’t need to go very far to asseverate that at church the pastor is king. And in youth ministry, the leader is king—simply a smaller version of his or her immediate supervisor. As leaders would describe this arrangement, the vast majority of Christians are incapable of making right choices, either morally or in ministry, unless they seek the opinion and receive the approval of their leadership. They are incapable of feeding their own spiritual lives because they are trained to believe that they are incapable; the pastor or youth leader must tell them the proper way to pray, to read the Bible, or practice any spiritual discipline. We haven’t been taught to grow and learn—only to obey those above us.

    Therefore, Christians are immobilized when it comes to showing leadership. They will not develop their spiritual gifts or fulfill their unique calling unless they have the approval of their spiritual superior. And if they refuse to do so, there isn’t much to do about it. People clearly know that they shouldn’t embark on any ministry opportunity, especially outside the walls of the church, unless they have the cobertura (coverage) from their pastor. Even if you think about going to a conference or an event outside your church, the pastor needs to approve it. You can only do something that pleases God if you have the blessing and protection from your superior. Period.

    One way to describe this situation is to say that Christians in Latin America suffer from codependency. They wait for their leaders to tell them what to do, and in some cases, this includes all aspects of life: personal, family, financial, professional, and spiritual matters—the list goes on. This is why our churches flutter around any character with charisma, with an attractive personality to hypnotize us with his so-called leadership. Spiritual oppression is subtle, and yet it is a powerful force in our church communities. There is one leader and perhaps a few lesser leaders; all others serve as complacent followers.

    Implications for Youth Ministry in a Latin American Context

    In light of the state of our church culture, youth ministry inevitably is and has long been considered a springboard to “real” ministry. Even though youth ministry may be a platform to exert power—the well-known youth ministry leaders exert great influence—the “real” ministry of leading a church stands above any status someone could enjoy in youth ministry. Being a senior pastor, often called the “pastor general” (not for the wide responsibility of leading the church but in the sense of a military leader), is who and what God blesses. Herein lies respect, and with that respect there is power.

    After spending more than ten years in full-time youth ministry in our local church, I had the privilege of watching a group of our kids grow as leaders. One of our young adults was ready to take over the team of youth leaders and lead the ministry. In the midst of that transition, our church needed a senior pastor. After refusing to accept several times, I finally agreed to help in that position. (I love our church, but I love youth ministry in a very special way!) The news of my new responsibility quickly spread, and when I saw a friend in the halls of a seminary in our city, he immediately greeted me with a happy “Congratulations!” I said, “What for?” Without hesitation, he replied, “You’ve made it! Now you are a real minister!” I felt so sad and angry.

    To so many in our faith communities, working with teens is just a technical stopover on the way to greatness. As some would say, “Practice with kids. If you mess them up, no problem; we can always find some more.” In youth ministry, a successful program is what matters most. And by that I mean that one that exhibits a sense of activism, commitment, and other evidence of how powerful and capable one is in leadership. If the youth leader is skilled enough to mobilize the masses, if he (again, in our context this type of leadership is generally limited to men) gets them to follow him and builds a following, then his ability to demonstrate his talent to be a real leader will get noticed. Up the ladder he goes.

    This is why in our context the focus centers on the creation of a model that focuses on the mechanics of ministry. Procedures are described concerning how to run the church, how to be spiritual, and how all followers are expected to comply with those instructions. Each of our kids becomes simply a number, a perishable statistic, a face with no name in the crowd. Their stories don’t matter, and their crises don’t matter; their destiny is not important. We just want them to obey, follow along gladly, and live within the system.

    In Latin American Christianity, we lack an understanding of a healthy biblical concept of community and servant leadership. While we may read the books, listen to the speeches, and follow the well-known Christian leaders—even using the words that they use—unfortunately these words do not convey the meaning intended.

    Sadly, leadership in our context involves as least one if not all of the following conditions:

  • individuals in power
  • authority and privileges
  • program engineers
  • codependency promoters
  • And regrettably, community is usually defined as one of the following:

  • a group of people in the same room
  • all those who attend an event
  • participants or collaborators of a program
  • just another face in the crowd
  • A Tragic Consequence

    Our young are not provided with a healthy environment for their development. A safe atmosphere in which they can grow through the travails and heartache of adolescence is nonexistent. There is no individual response to crisis and no provision of ministry opportunities because individuals don’t exist in the community. Young people are simply attendants of a weekly meeting. As a matter of fact, many leaders would prefer not to know their stories because it would imply involvement, or lack of involvement, in their lives. Young people are consumers of programs, and the few who are taken into account are at best coproducers of those programs, not people to be individually affirmed, listened to, or honored. They have never experienced a spiritual church, much less a healthy community in which they are treated as siblings of those in leadership. The idea that children and adolescents must be included, welcomed, and nurtured by the adult community as members of the same family—the concept that the leaders are not “surrogate parents” but actually co-siblings—is foreign. This biblical concept of adoptive ministry is so countercultural that it is completely unknown.

    Some leaders do eventually wake up to their lack of care and interest when they perceive that kids are leaving the church. However, this response is rarely due to an authentic desire to nurture the young as Christ has taught (see Mark 10:13–16) but rather because it is important that a powerful leader does not to lose them. If success is measured in programs and attendance, less equals failure. Those youth who leave do so because they don’t find their needs met. These could range from deep intrinsic issues such as struggling with a sense of identity or purpose in life to issues as superficial as being discontent with an irrelevant and boring program. Many sincere and faithful young people today believe that it is better to leave in search of new spiritual horizons. They might seek out a new church that offers better events with more resources that impress the crowd. There are many churches to choose from; in our countries there are churches on every corner. The options are many. Yet even if they walk in new fields, the same problem persists: the lack of spiritual support that true community can provide is rare across many if not nearly all of the church communities in Latin America.

    Eager to keep their adolescents from straying, leaders have begun to think of strategies for retention. They typically fall into the default response of raising their programming standards to create new and better events that compete with those deemed attractive at other churches. Of course, the cycle of performance and oppression over staff, volunteers, and even parents continues as more financial and human resources are required. But the church still depends on a few people who administer the youth program. In most cases, those faithful volunteers are ultimately responsible for leading the youth group and youth programs. They tend to feel exploited as they are left alone to solve the urgency of bigger and better programs that will attract even the most disinterested teenager. The lack of resources, encouragement, time, and people in youth ministry is self-evident, and willing volunteers are scarce at best. Young volunteers lead and execute the ministry; the absence of adults in youth ministry is undisputable. And since youth ministry is program based, it becomes just another department managed by someone, external to the life of the church. Adults are excluded. Youth ministry is seen as a necessary evil. “We’ve got kids—somebody has to do something with them,” the adults might say. “And it’s not going to be us! We don’t know what to do with them.”

    The church and adults have abandoned the nurturing of youth. They are strangers, and yet they demand tangible results. That is why youth ministry in Latin America is reduced to a weekly activity prepared with great effort for an anonymous audience. Success is measured by attendance, enthusiasm, and budgets. The less trouble, the better. Even pastoral care in youth ministry, something that North American youth ministry has worked hard to incorporate, is totally absent in Latin America. Many youth leaders would argue that the name says it all: if it is supposed to be pastoral care, then that is something reserved for pastors, which they are not. At least, they don’t see themselves that way.

    Even discipleship itself, the core calling of ministry, has been reduced to a thirteen-week curriculum—in particular, a program specially designed as preparation for baptism and the indoctrination of new believers.

    Is There Hope?

    Though some leaders are sincere, they can still be sincerely wrong. It is true that most youth ministry leaders, and especially volunteers, have not been exposed to any other way of doing things. Is it fair, then, to demand from them a more effective ministry, a more communal and adoptive-focused ministry? Of course it is. None of us exercises ministry perfectly, and none of us has the ideal point of view. When we allow our cultural history, experiences, and assumptions to dictate how we go about our ministry to the young, we are responsible for the outcome. We cannot do youth ministry or any ministry on our own, with our own resources and perspective. We must return to the voice of the one who calls us in the first place. It is our God, primarily through the gift of the Scriptures, who can lead us into what can authentically be called Christian ministry. This is the key to adoptive youth ministry, in which we do everything we can to design and practice a ministry that lines up with what God is doing in bringing young people to faith. They have been, in Christ, adopted as his sons and daughters. It is, then, the church’s job to join in that work. That is adoptive youth ministry.

    Emerging generations need a new style and practice of leadership that can nurture and equip them to be fully embraced by the body of Christ. Although many youth leaders haven’t been exposed to any other model of Christianity, if we return to the biblical text we can become a transition generation. As we follow how God teaches us to function as leaders and equippers, we will lead our young with a model of relationship rather than oppression. This is the power of Paul’s use of the term adoption, for when we see ourselves as family, and especially as co-siblings with all other believers, both the young and the old, regardless of status, are empowered to live into their calling as members of God’s family.

    Working within such distorted history and practice, how can we mobilize the church to embrace adoptive youth ministry? What can we do to teach a church lacerated and abused by oppression and power to become a community that adopts new generations and encourages them to come into our midst as family, just as they are? For such a long time we have tried to make kids become us, to convert them into our adult molds, with the intention of controlling them. We think that if they become like us, then we will be able to understand them and have them under our command.

    What should a new leadership and a new youth ministry look like in a Latin American context? How can we come closer to our kids in order to impress on them a fingerprint rather than the scars of power and abuse? I firmly refuse to offer a model because it would be my model, and then I would become the authority and impose it on others. Instead, I appeal that we urgently come back to the biblical text and let the Scriptures shape our new lens.

    I understand this means going against the flow, and I know it won’t be very attractive to some. In a world where more is better, it doesn’t sound good to talk of growing until you become a mini-church, for example. Nevertheless, my hope is that some leaders will be wise enough to understand that the church is not ours. Neither our lens nor our wisdom should reign. This is why we need to come up with new metaphors that can communicate the biblical sense of Christian leadership and community.

    Until today, the concepts that have been used fall too short and divert completely. To see God’s work as a business scheme, a military structure, or a mere hierarchy is to follow the guidelines of this world, which is controlled by the prince of darkness. Christ said that he would build his church. Why are we so anxious for the statistics of church growth? Is this really what Jesus had in mind?

    Allow me to clarify a couple of things. First, I totally agree with the creation and implementation of organizational structures that allow us to communicate and cooperate better. If we get better organized, we will better fulfill our mission. The biblical text didn’t give us instructions on how to accomplish the Great Commission; we are told what to do but not how to do it. This invites us to exercise our creative freedom. It reminds us that somebody has to think and create a good way to come together and get organized, an effective way according to our context, needs, and opportunities. What I completely disagree with is imposing the organizational structure on the community dimension of the church. When did we forget that we don’t have authority over people’s lives? Only Christ has complete authority in the heavens and the earth. When did we forget that he is the Good Shepherd who lays down his life for his sheep and that it’s his voice that each one of us should listen to and obey? The supremacy is Christ’s and not ours, especially not those in leadership.

    Second, this is not a new problem. As I’ll address later, Jesus emphatically declared that our model for leadership should not follow the guidelines of this earth. It is proper to explore again the relational dimension of the church and the pastor’s role as a way of life rather than a position in an organization.

    A Look at Scriptures with New Lenses

    Forgotten Responsibilities

    To the elders among you, I appeal as a fellow elder and a witness of Christ’s sufferings who also will share in the glory to be revealed: Be shepherds of God’s flock that is under your care, watching over them—not because you must, but because you are willing, as God wants you to be; not pursuing dishonest gain, but eager to serve; not lording it over those entrusted to you, but being examples to the flock. And when the Chief Shepherd appears, you will receive the crown of glory that will never fade away. (1 Pet. 5:1–4)

    Someone must have read these verses incorrectly and interpreted them to mean that our calling is to “be shepherds of God’s programs that are under our care.” The pastoral responsibility is to dedicate the necessary attention to the lives of the people who constitute the flock of Christ. It is a privilege entrusted from heaven, not a mere designation that puts us in charge of a program.

    This flock belongs to the Lord Jesus Christ (Acts 20:28). Thus we should be reminded that Christ is the one whom the sheep should listen to; he is the one to whom they should submit and whom they should consult for any decision in their lives—not the pastor/CEO of the church/organization.

    The work of each youth leader is the same work as the pastor with the sheep of the flock. It involves five main responsibilities:

  • Feed the sheep. Train kids to read, understand, apply, and proclaim the biblical text. If we suffer today from spiritual malnourishment, it’s because in our ministries we have too many meetings called “Bible study” where we don’t study the Bible (1 Tim. 3:16–17).
  • Guide the sheep. Help them know the will of God and obey it. This requires biblical discernment and surrender to the will of God (Matt. 28:20).
  • Protect the sheep. The main danger is the intrusion of ideas apart from biblical truth in the minds of kids; their worldview cannot proceed from the values of this world (2 Tim. 4:1–4).
  • Heal the sheep. Those who are hurt by the crises in life, the slavery of sin, and the shamefulness of bad choices need pastors who love them unconditionally. Only a ministry that becomes a safe zone will be able to lead them to restoration (Gal. 6:1–2).
  • Gather the sheep. This has nothing to do with weekly meetings but rather with the strengthening of a community and the construction of relationships that are healthy, spiritual, and mutually edifying (Heb. 10:22–25).
  • It is impossible that an event, meeting, or program can fulfill these responsibilities. These responsibilities demand time, tenderness, and personal attention, and they certainly cannot be achieved from a platform of oppression. They cannot be done from above. They require men and women who are spiritual and faithful to the call—leaders who can relate at the same level with teenagers as they nurture them. It is so sad that many leaders read the word pastor and immediately associate it with the boss or CEO of their local church. This is not in keeping with the thinking of the biblical authors. They used the term to refer to those who gently cared for the well-being of the believers. It’s a gift from above, not an organizational designation.

    The apostle Peter gives us a concise look at the wrong way to develop pastoral care (1 Pet. 5:2–3). The following ways of doing ministry will only hurt our kids:

  • Ministry as an imposed, forced obligation
  • Ministry that seeks any kind of personal gain or benefit
  • Ministry that assumes we own their lives and master them
  • A clear distinction can be made between ministry that hurts kids and ministry that leaves a legacy, an indelible fingerprint on their lives. The right way to do ministry as a pastor includes:

  • Ministry by our own will, in response to God’s call
  • Ministry with enthusiasm and internal motivation
  • Ministry that kids follow not because we force them to but because we are an example
  • Major erudition is not required to understand this great pastoral commission. Of course, the lack of Bible reading means that these fundamental passages for our ministry philosophy end up being ignored or never even noticed. While understanding this kind of pastoral ministry may be simple, exercising it is complicated. It requires engagement; it demands time and energy, sacrifice and commitment. It’s much easier to make programs than to care for people. Nevertheless, how glorious the moment will be when those who have responded faithfully to their work and have genuinely cared for Jesus’s sheep will receive from his very own hand the imperishable reward (1 Pet. 5:4). Dear leader, be faithful to your call.

    Abused Exhortations

    Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they keep watch over your souls as those who will give an account. Let them do this with joy and not with grief, for this would be unprofitable for you. (Heb. 13:17 NASB)

    But we request of you, brethren, that you appreciate those who diligently labor among you, and have charge over you in the Lord and give you instruction, and that you esteem them very highly in love because of their work. Live in peace with one another. (1 Thess. 5:12–13 NASB)

    Someone once said that to the boy with a hammer, everything looks like a nail. Likewise, the way that we see the Scriptures depends on the lens with which we read the Scriptures. Generally speaking, we tend to bring our own worldview to the text rather than allowing the text to shape our minds. Far too many leaders have seen texts like Hebrews 13:17 and 1 Thessalonians 5:12–13 as the biblical basis for demanding unconditional obedience, respect, and (why not?) a few presents from time to time. Given the paradigm of oppression, these passages fit very well in this framework and justify the victim and the victimizer by the codependency that unites them. But I firmly believe that the biblical authors were not communicating this message to the believers back then, and thus it’s not what the Spirit wants to communicate to the believers today.

    We should remember that both passages are addressed to believers who were still growing in their faith. Regarding the readers of Hebrews, we know that they should have been teachers already but they needed to be reminded of the basics of faith (see Heb. 5:11–12). Concerning the believers in Thessalonica, their discipleship lasted only about one month, during the time that Paul stayed in that city. As a result, there were many topics left to discuss and truths to be clarified.

    But a sober reading of the passages gives us sufficient light by which to see a proper interpretation. If we read with no prejudice, we will note that neither text pleads for leaders to have a position of superiority or authority over the lives of the believers. It’s just the opposite.

    The text in Hebrews highlights that there are leaders who look after the souls of their flocks to such an extent that they know they’ll be accountable for their actions. Without a doubt, this evokes the great pastoral commandment that Peter talks about in his first letter. There are those who recognize the divine gift in themselves to gently and patiently nurture the flock. They know that it’s a responsibility carried out under the gaze of the Chief Shepherd Jesus Christ, and with all their heart they focus on feeding, guiding, protecting, healing, and gathering the sheep. Their work is an invaluable gift to those for whom they care. In other words, what a privilege to count on men and women who sincerely make the effort to take care of us! To people like them, why shouldn’t we pay attention? To those who point us toward the voice of Jesus, the Good Shepherd, why shouldn’t we listen?

    It seems to me that the author of Hebrews was telling those believers, “Look! What great spiritual leaders you have! Listen to them; follow them. Support them.” In spite of organizational titles, there are people who exercise a pastoral ministry with our teens. We don’t call them pastors, but that’s the role they play. It is to these mentors, counselors, and teachers that our kids should listen. They should seek out these leaders when they need to make choices because these are not people who want to rule over them; these leaders want to guide our kids to their Lord.

    Of course, there are CEOs in our organizations and churches, people with the title of “pastor” who don’t do this. They demand to have the last word on every matter and are offended if their opinion is not taken under consideration. They attack with texts like Hebrews 13:17: obey your pastors. There’s no reason why we should be following these people. In the case of 1 Thessalonians 5, we find an exhortation to be considerate with those who exercise a very particular ministry in our lives. It has nothing to do with the position they have at church but with the relationship they have with us. Note that the passage says that these people labor, have charge over us, and give instruction.

    Those who see through lenses of programs and oppression interpret “labor” as the responsibility of a full-time, paid person, with an office schedule and public roles in the local church; “have charge over” as the ones who organize events, meetings, or programs and possess a title and a position in projects, committees, or departments in the local church; and “give instruction” as the rebuke that they should generously share with all those who don’t submit to their authority. But once again, this interpretation doesn’t seem to be what the author had in mind when he wrote these exhortations.

    The work that was expected from those in leadership in the early church was pastoral—to look after the flock, as we have mentioned in 1 Peter 5:2 and Acts 20:28. This is a special role; working in an office can be done by anyone. To have charge over and to give instruction are pastoral tasks that recall the interest for the care and well-being of the person, not a position over him or her. The passage highlights the relationship of cordiality, unity, and fraternity that should exist between a believer and those who care for him or her pastorally. It is not a position or a personality; it is relational ministry.

    The Path to Greatness

    Jesus called them together and said, “You know that those who are regarded as rulers of the Gentiles lord it over them, and their high officials exercise authority over them. Not so with you. Instead, whoever wants to become great among you must be your servant, and whoever wants to be first must be slave of all. For even the Son of Man did not come to be served, but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many.” (Mark 10:42–45)

    Success in our world is often measured in the wrong ways; too many boast of the number of people who serve them. Because Jesus affirmed that leadership is service, the behavioral framework we seek cannot be built on business or military models. Peter reminds us that we are not lords over those we serve but an example to follow. Jesus is the example, the perfect reason to convince us to follow his steps. Why should we lead by example and service? Because Jesus showed us that way. If we are going to become leaders who don’t abuse their power and are not tyrants, it’s because the very Lord of Lords, the sovereign one, humbled himself and gave his life on the cross.

    When we forget that leadership is about giving and not receiving, we walk on the wrong path. We stop talking in terms of loving, caring, and serving kids. When we as pastors stop caring for the sheep and expect the sheep to care for us, we walk away from being a true disciple. We follow our own dreams, our own glory.

    The service we can provide to those we care for has nothing to do with activities inside a program. That is a matter of collaboration. It’s good, but it’s not service or ministry per se. To serve is to give your life to rescue people from their deep need, just as Jesus gave his life for our rescue. It implies engagement in what’s happening in the life of others. Service is not limited to a meeting; it’s a sacrificial relationship. Service is leadership; it is being disciples of Jesus (John 15:12–13).

    Needless to say, this greatness doesn’t fit with the publicity models and marketing campaigns that resound with such fanfare. As a friend used to say, many leaders dream of seeing their names on a billboard or the poster of a big event when they should be seeking to see their names in their kids’ contact lists as someone whom their young people trust and would call with any need.

    An Intergenerational Ministry Inside and Outside

    Up to this point I have emphasized the shortcomings we face in the Latin American context regarding youth ministry and the whole church. We need to come close to Scripture with no prejudice so that we can discover, as if for the first time, the divine instructions that allow us to see our calling with new lenses. We are pastors who care for the new generations, who guide them gently and patiently. We are not superiors; we are servants.

    This unequivocally means that youth ministry is not for just a few.

    Traditionally, we have delegated the responsibility to a small group of volunteers (or victims, as some would say). Not only do we segregate, but we also measure success by the impact of the events they organize. Totally wrong. While youth ministry is certainly the call of that small group, it is also the call of every believer. I know that many adults don’t like to participate in specific activities for youth. Many of us don’t like to stay up late, eat junk food at camps, run and get dirty, or go showerless for several days. But that doesn’t disqualify us from working with kids; it just means we don’t work certain events, and that’s fine.

    If leadership means influence, then we need to offer as much positive influence as we can, surrounding the new generations with mentors. This is both strategic and relational; what’s more, it is God’s expectation for the entire church. In Titus 2 we find Paul’s instructions to his faithful teammate regarding some problems in the communities of believers in Crete. Verse 1 begins with a reminder to Titus of the need to communicate sound doctrine, with no contamination. In the following verses, the sound doctrine is described, and it doesn’t resemble what we’d read in a book of systematic theology. Sound teaching should always result in sound application. As some would say, orthodoxy and orthopraxis go hand in hand.

    In the first verses of Titus 2 we read about the character and behavior of the believers. As Eugene Peterson paraphrases: “Your job is to speak out on the things that make for solid doctrine. . . . We don’t want anyone looking down on God’s Message because of their behavior” (Titus 2:1, 5 Message). In Titus 2:2 Paul speaks of the older men. As we read the entire passage, note that it does not refer to those who play a role in leadership in the community of believers; it refers to every older man. Verse 3, similarly, talks about older women. I once asked our church at what age a woman was considered old, though I didn’t encourage that conversation because I didn’t want to hurt anybody’s feelings. In the case of these women (as well as the men mentioned in v. 2), qualities of character and behavior are mentioned. These women are called to be righteous with a purpose: to teach the younger women (v. 4). Again, I asked our church at what age a woman is still considered young, which was a much easier conversation to manage! But beyond that, it’s fascinating to realize the connection that exists between the women in verse 3 and those in verse 4. The word that Paul uses to refer to the older women can be translated as “women of advanced age.” Although it doesn’t say how old these women are, we know that these they are further along the path of life, in front of the younger ones.

    My daughter is ten years old as I write this, and for her, almost all the women in our church are of advanced age, ahead of her in the trail of life. Many of them have already made choices regarding their spiritual lives, families, marriages, professions, and ministries. They have gone through stages of crisis, victory, tears, happiness, loneliness, abundance, and scarcity. They have felt close to God and far from God; they have had questions and doubts. These are women of faith who have experienced assurance, convictions, and fears. They have known God in that walk of life and possess experiences that have enriched them. On top of that, they are righteous women, examples to follow in character and behavior. No, they don’t form part of the team that organizes youth activities; no, they don’t go to camps or come for lock-ins. But they are called youth pastors. They are called to invest their lives in other girls like my daughter so that they can be surrounded by mentors who teach them how to become women of God.

    We see the same regarding boys. Verse 6 reminds us of what boys need to learn: self-control. The example for them is Titus (v. 7) and other men who show that same character and behavior (v. 2). This is an intergenerational ministry in which everyone is called. This is the whole church exercising a powerful influence in the lives of the new generations. All of us, advanced in age, leaving a legacy and an indelible print. A position is not required, just a relationship. It’s not about one on top of all but one next to others.

    Therefore, when we talk about getting only parents involved in youth ministry, we are falling very short. In reality we should talk about all of us sharing the youth ministry as a church: parents and anyone advanced in age, young adults, single mothers, the elderly, couples with no kids. Not in programs, but in meaningful relationships. We should encourage everyone in the church to take the initiative and build spiritual friendships with children, adolescents, and youth—to become mentors and models. Adopting a younger one is the biblical ministry in the church; it’s the real youth ministry. It means helping kids feel safe with us, in a protected zone, just like the sheep when they are taken care of by their shepherd. This is the kind of leadership that we need today.

    Given the oppression that exists in leadership, by which people are seen only as laborers for programs, we don’t hear this kind of message from the pulpit. At the church the program is king, not relationships. Ministry means participating in a program, not in somebody’s life. This unfortunate reality leads me to denounce a very serious problem that limits the way in which many people could fulfill their call to youth ministry in a formidable way. This same tyranny in leadership preaches that ministry happens only inside the walls of the church; they say that ministry means being involved in the operational machinery of the local programs, and they condemn any effort that is done outside the control and the territory of the local church.

    Many schoolteachers don’t know how important their ministry is, as a consequence of this oppression. Many leaders who are propelling parachurch projects wouldn’t dare to say they are genuine youth pastors. The church has called them rebellious and excommunicated them from the ministry’s benediction. They are anything but ministers. They are labeled employees, academic professors, administrators, or sport coaches, all of whom are disconnected from the kingdom of God. But this is not true. The influence they exercise in the life of kids is genuine and much deeper than what many so-called youth pastors achieve in a ninety-minute weekly meeting. These “excluded ones” are doing the true work of God—with God’s blessing and with God’s lenses—even though they have been told otherwise.

    It is very sad to see that many church leaders demand that these faithful ones abandon their spheres of influence just because they are outside the church. Instead, many leaders require that these people give their time and energy to the service of the organization in which they have a membership rather than to their calling. These heroes are divested of their powers and told to give their lives to setting up chairs and passing out handouts at the door. Youth ministry doesn’t happen just in a meeting. It’s about adults interacting with kids at the church and outside the church. It’s a community of leaders who are mentors, who care for kids until they see those kids reach maturity. It’s people who walk alongside young people and one another, during good times and bad times. Youth ministry is the positive influence that draws us closer to Jesus, that interferes with sin, that heals us in crisis, and that rejoices in obedience. Youth ministry is men and women who love the new generations. It’s a network of people who represent a safe zone in which younger ones are protected, helping them feel secure, encouraged, cheered, instructed, and corrected.

    The young in our region of the world don’t need more events; they need more of these pastors. We should equip others and encourage those who already serve in that role.

    Some Critical Recommendations

    We Should Not Impose New Models

    Although it is still necessary to create models and it is vital to continue to develop strategic intents, we should not think that we have the solution and the only answer. Imposing the same style of ministry for all would result in stagnation. Every innovation should arise from the effort to create a healthy community in which intergenerational youth ministry flourishes. And there are many ways to do this.

    The Tyranny of Authority Should Be Stopped

    We await a leadership driven by genuine and unconditional love. We seek pastoral care and service as a critical element for effective discipleship. Though in the past we have produced supporters—fans of some leader with great charisma—rather than disciples of Christ who learn his Word, follow his example, and share his mission, we need to break that mold now.

    Let’s Build a New Intergenerational Ministry

    This relational approach should be modeled and intentionally developed. Very few leaders today have experienced the gift of a mentor or leader in a biblical sense. But it’s a disadvantage, not a disability. That said, we need to learn carefully and quickly in order to become a transition generation. We have the opportunity to pass on new lenses—which show us God’s perspective—to the next leaders of the church.

    Final Thoughts

    Latin America today is a force in the preaching of the gospel. While there’s much to correct, its presence and influence are undisputed. Thus, Latin America cannot be ignored if we want to develop a real global perspective of the church. Furthermore, in countries like the United States, the contact is more direct. Due to immigration, many youth leaders have been working with kids from a Latin American background for quite some time. Some of those teens are from a third culture. The information in this chapter might also help us to understand their behavior or the kinds of ministry their families are used to. In addition, the opportunity for cross-cultural mission from and to Latin America is great.

    Many leaders from Latin America are leaving their countries for the United States, Europe, or even the “10/40 Window,” a region between ten and forty degrees north latitude that missiologists since the 1980s have targeted as being strategically significant. These sent ones will surely bring with them (without noticing) the lenses they inherited from their culture. Knowing their context will help us to understand them and encourage them with patience. I also have in mind the good number of youth groups and adults who travel to our cities for short-term projects. I value tremendously the love that brings them and the heart that moves them. I am truly convinced that we can generate great projects when we work together—and I don’t just mean material resources. It’s obvious that people with more financial resources can support initiatives that relieve urgent needs in our communities. I am referring to working one next to the other rather than the model of one on top of the other. Unfortunately, this was the scheme used by some missionaries who came with good intentions, invested, and left a legacy. Too often their mentality was to instruct—or should we say impose—a way to see and live Christianity. They became the figures of authority and we, domesticated by oppression, took everything they said and taught us as the only right way to do ministry.

    If people come to our region with the wrong lenses and don’t allow the locals to talk about their true needs and opportunities, they will retain the ideas they already have—the ones they brought with them. In many cases, those ideas will be the ones they want to keep. It would be very different if short-term missionary experiences focused on learning from the local people. What if the local people helped their visitors understand their context, exegete their culture, and create their own models of ministry? The richness of the experience would be of great value for all.

    May the Lord help us in his grace to be faithful, good servants who leave a legacy to the following generations. May we assume, in his power and through his Word, the responsibility of adjusting the course of the church so that we all may become the salt of the earth and the light of the world.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑