14. Spiritual Formation
14
Spiritual Formation
It’s a Matter of Time
When it comes to spiritual formation—sometimes called “discipleship”—the most common understanding is that it is something we do with those we lead. Typically, this is where most youth ministry people spend the bulk of their “content” time and energy. We “teach,” we do “small groups” to study the Bible or discuss an important topic, or we engage in a few other practices or activities where young people “learn” what they need to “know” about the Christian faith. In everyday parlance, spiritual formation is what happens when content is delivered and those being “discipled” take in what they learn and are somehow changed.
While this is a vital topic—certainly the understanding and passing on of the content of the gospel does encourage faith to be formed in us—this chapter takes us in a slightly different direction. We are not saying that Bible study, corporate prayer, and other spiritual disciplines are not the means by which the Holy Spirit grows us in our faith and resultant holiness. Rather, Dr. Tony Jones reminds us that it is in the practice of our faith—what he refers to as experience, in community—that God does his best and lasting work in us.
Jones is a teacher, thinker, pastor, and theologian. He is steeped in youth ministry and a mentor to those seeking to understand spiritual formation. In a style all his own, Jones opens his chapter by quoting Aristotle and listing several Greek words for knowledge and wisdom; he understands that as we are formed spiritually we grow in our knowledge of our God as well as in wisdom concerning how to live out that knowledge. While Jones generally writes in a warm, conversational style (there are fewer endnotes than in most chapters), as a seasoned theologian, thinker, and leader he does tend to get a little technical at times: “[We] are called to be an earthly instantiation of the very eschatological kingdom that Jesus inaugurated.” Yet his counsel is clear and approachable, and provides a helpful understanding of the process of spiritual formation.
In setting the stage for his perspective, Jones’s citation of Aristotle teaching “teenagers,” while chronologically correct, could lead the reader to assume that a seventeen-year-old hundreds of years before Christ was the developmental equivalent of a high school junior today. The current debate centers on how different today’s adolescent experience is from the post-child, pre-adult era of centuries past. Most who study adolescence, including me, see this as a relatively new phenomenon in which the process of adolescence takes much longer. What is clear in this chapter, however, is that Jones isn’t as much comparing today’s adolescent development with ancient Greece as he is acknowledging that mid-teens have the capacity for high-level thinking and accomplishments but lack the life experience to function as adult peers in society (as brain development studies show). His point is that spiritual formation is a process that requires time and experience to be maturely realized. Regardless of the amount of Bible studies, mission trips, or service projects an adolescent attends, a teenager needs a laboratory to practice what he or she knows, in the context of the continuity of others who have gone before him or her, to grow into adult spiritual maturity.
This chapter culminates in Jones’s reminding us that our faith is a “lived human endeavor” and that practice and experience lead us toward maturity. This is why adoptive youth ministry is so vital to how we conceptualize even the most traditional aspect of youth ministry—what we typically call discipleship. Although Jones doesn’t say it directly, adoptive ministry is participating in what God has declared is true, and as older brothers and sisters embrace, encourage, train, and equip the young to participate in the body and the kingdom, they must remember that adolescents still need the support and guidance offered to them by youth leaders, mentors, and other adults committed to them and their developmental journey. The community of siblings is what they need to grow as followers of Christ and as men and women. Moreover, it gives them the experience they need to become fully functioning peers.
As you read this chapter, consider these questions:
Aristotle would have made a good youth pastor.
He was a youth worker, of sorts. The great philosopher lived 350 years before Jesus was born, and mentored and tutored Alexander the Great while the future conqueror was just a teenager. Then Aristotle moved to Athens and founded the Lyceum, a school where he taught philosophy, natural history, and science to teenagers and young adults.
Perhaps all that work with teens provided Aristotle with the keen insight that he developed concerning youth and their development. Aristotle’s Nichomachean Ethics, likely written during his time at the Lyceum, is among his most famous and influential works. Therein he spells out the concept of phronēsis, a certain type of wisdom.
A lot of the terms Aristotle and Plato use for knowledge have English derivatives—theōria, sophia, epistēmē, technē, praxis—but not phronēsis. That’s because it’s one of the ancient world’s less-remembered concepts. Traditionally, it’s been translated “prudence,” but that’s not quite right. These days, authors tend to render it “practical wisdom,” but that’s not quite right either. It’s easiest to understand phronēsis by contrasting it to other forms of knowledge and wisdom in Aristotle’s view.
First comes epistēmē, from which we get the word epistemology (the study of knowledge). Epistēmē is scientific knowledge: universal, testable, and independent of context.
Next comes technē, from which we derive the words technical, technique, and technology. Essentially pragmatic in nature, this knowledge is entirely context-dependent and developed by practice, not intellect. Aristotle uses this term to talk about craft workers and tradesmen.
Finally, phronēsis: Always directed toward action, phronēsis is the kind of knowledge that requires both intellect and experience. It’s dependent on context too and varies across situations. Phronēsis is laden with values—unlike the other two types of knowledge. It is the wisdom that we use to make ethical and moral decisions.
As you might guess, I’m arguing that phronēsis is the type of knowledge that best describes the Christian faith. It’s a combination of intellectual study and real-world experience. It demands of us ad hoc decision making based on a value system that we have internalized. It’s based on the interplay with generalities and particulars. Aristotle is very clear on this point: phronēsis cannot be attained simply by memorizing a universal set of rules. Phronēsis demands experience; a human must put this knowledge to the test in a real-world situation, learn from that situation, then repeat the process. That’s how phronēsis is developed.
Why You Can’t Find a Wise Teenager
You know what scares me? In some states, kids who live on farms can start driving when they’re twelve. As I write this, my three kids are fourteen, thirteen, and ten, and the thought of any one of them driving makes me go hide under the bed. If I send the fourteen-year-old to the basement to get his socks out of the dryer, he’ll come back thirty minutes later having done thirteen things—and getting his socks won’t be one of them.
We know why adolescents are terrible drivers: they get distracted by every little thing that crosses their mind or line of vision. And we know why, as they age, they become better drivers: the prefrontal cortex of the brain—the part that regulates behavior and enables judgment—is the last part of the human brain to develop, not reaching maturation until about age twenty-five. In other words, there is a physiological explanation as to why a thirteen-year-old has less impulse control than a thirty-three-year-old.
Aristotle didn’t have the benefit of pediatric neurological studies, but he did have his own experience of teaching teenagers. With that under his belt, he was able to write:
An indication of what has been said is that while young people become geometers and mathematicians and wise in such things, they do not seem to become practically-wise [phronetic]. The explanation is that practical wisdom [phronēsis] is concerned also with particulars, knowledge of which comes from experience. But there is no young person who is experienced, since it is quantity of time that produces experience.
The reason that you don’t have to count “one-one thousand, two-one thousand, three-one thousand” between you and the car that you’re tailing on the freeway is that you have enough experience driving that you have a feel for it. If you’re tailgating the car in front of you, you have a sense that you’re too close, and you back off. No matter how much they pounded that into your head in driver’s-ed class, you had to learn it on the road, from experience.
The Christian faith is no different. You can get kids memorizing all the Bible verses you want in Sunday school and Vacation Bible School, but until they have got to put their Christianity into practice, those verses aren’t worth the piece of candy that the kids get for reciting them.
Christianity is fundamentally a lived human endeavor. No amount of study is a substitute for that. Youth group, camp, retreats, lock-ins, you name it—each serves a purpose and each is valuable in its own way, but none of those activities or events has anything like the effect of living the Christian life on a day-to-day basis, over time.
There’s a reason that, when an adolescent learns to drive, there’s a progression: first there’s class, then a behind-the-wheel lesson, then time with a learner’s permit. Even after the license is attained, it’s provisional. In my state, for the first six months any driver under twenty can’t drive between midnight and five o’clock in the morning and can’t have more than one passenger. That’s because the state of Minnesota knows what Aristotle knew: it is quantity of time that produces experience.
The church needs to learn this lesson.
Experience Takes Time
My ten-year-old is a hockey goalie, and in Minnesota, that’s a big deal. It means lots of ice time and expensive pads and emails every week from goalie coaches who want me to buy lessons.
Our city’s rink happens to also be the practice rink of the Minnesota Wild, a National Hockey League (NHL) team. A couple of times last season, the Wild practiced right after my son’s team, so we stuck around to watch. Because he’s a goalie, and goalies are a bit thick in the head, he wanted to stand right behind the goal during the Wild practice. When NHL players take the ice, they have a tradition of shooting the practice pucks as hard as they can at the goal posts, making various clanging tones. I’ll never forget the look on my son’s face the first time we saw those shots from that vantage point, through the plexiglass just behind the empty net. His eyes were like saucers. Then the goalie skated into the net.
At ninety miles per hour, an NHL slap shot travels from the blue line to the goal in .456 seconds. If the shooter is inside the blue line and the goalie is at the top of the crease, halve that. It’s about a quarter of a second of reaction time. Yet when the Wild goalie took the net, he saved four out of every five shots, gloving them nonchalantly, kicking them out with his leg pads, swatting them away with his stick.
In the car on the way home, I asked my son what he was thinking. He was stunned at the speed of the shots in the NHL practice. “I’ll never be able to save shots like that!” he said. Yet the Wild goalie is only thirteen years older than my son. What happens in those intervening years?
Of course, it would be terribly irresponsible for me to send my kid out on the ice with the Wild. He’d be injured or worse within seconds. There’s no way that he has the reflexes and technique to make a save on an NHL slap shot.
However, as he advances through the ranks of hockey, his reflexes and technique will develop. He’ll get coaching, and he’ll learn from experience in practices and games. If he decides to stick with goaltending, he’ll move from Mites to Squirts to Pee-Wees to Bantams. If he’s good enough, in five or six years he’ll play high school hockey and face sixty-mile-per-hour slap shots. If he’s really good, he’ll see seventy- and eighty-mile-per-hour shots in college. And if, by some dint of fate and exceptional talent, he were to make the NHL, well then he’d obviously be capable of gloving a ninety-mile-per-hour slap shot.
But he would see thousands and thousands of shots between now and his purely hypothetical NHL career.
In the church, we have an unfortunate habit of treating Christianity like it’s one-size-fits-all, and that size is adult. Sure, we have Youth Sunday, and we have got children’s worship. But when you go into the sanctuary and look at the big show on Sunday morning, it’s designed with adults in mind. The prayers, the music, the sermon—each is developmentally appropriate for adults, not for adolescents.
The same goes for how the church is run. The council or elder board or vestry meetings are very adult-ish. So are committee meetings and votes that are run on parliamentary procedure. (I move, I second, all in favor, Aye!) Each of these processes privileges the adults in the congregation, and each marginalizes the teenagers. Asking a teen to sit on a board or a committee is a bit like asking my son to practice with the Wild—it’s not developmentally appropriate.
If we are serious about adopting adolescents into the center of congregational life rather than leaving them on the margins or, worse yet, outsourcing our adolescent ministry to parachurch groups, then we have to seriously consider how our churches are formed and organized. We can’t simply make accommodations for teenagers, like we do for other marginalized groups. Instead, we have to make the developmental needs of teenagers constitutive of congregational life itself.
Implications for Adoption
At the heart of the adoption model of youth ministry is the metaphor of family. Like you, I know many families for whom adoption is part of their story. And although each family’s adoption story is unique, they share the common experience of adoption fundamentally changing their families.
One couple I know has adopted two children—one from an Asian country and one from a Latin American country. They have made it a point to incorporate aspects of those countries’ cultures into their family, including food, holidays, history, and travel. The parents in the family did not simply assume that their kids would become enculturated to the parents’ northern European ancestry, even though their kids joined the family as infants. Instead, they allowed the children’s native cultures to change their family. That family is now the mixture of the ancestries of the parents and the children in a very tangible way.
Another couple I know had two biological children of their own when they adopted two adolescent brothers out of foster care. Because of their ages, these boys already had ten years each of their own history, which included abandonment by their parents, the foster care system, and their Mexican ancestry. The adopting family—both parents and children—knew they were in for a challenge, but their struggles were more difficult than they expected. Their family is different as a result.
Perhaps you built a papier-mâché volcano as a child. After you added the baking soda you poured in the vinegar to produce an impressive—but safe—fountain of lava. The chemical reaction that takes place when sodium bicarbonate (baking soda) mixes with dilute acetic acid (vinegar) produces carbon dioxide gas. When those two elements mix, an altogether new element is formed.
That’s what happens in an adoptive family. It’s not that adoptive children are absorbed into a biological family and the family doesn’t change. It’s that when the adoptive children and the biological family mix, a new family is formed.
However, when adolescents are “adopted” into the life of a congregation, the congregation rarely changes. Maybe a youth room is built along the edges of the building; I have even been in churches where the youth room is a converted closet, sending a very clear message to the teens.
The Sunday morning worship is not changed to accommodate the adolescents’ different learning styles. Instead, the teenagers are expected to dress, sit, and act like adults, even though nearly everything in the teenage constitution cries out against this.
Neither does the organizational structure of the congregation change. Instead, meetings are held at night (when adults can come), coffee is served, long and often boring reports are presented, and Robert’s Rules of Order are observed—all of which militate against the active participation of teenagers.
Teenagers are a chemical catalyst in any group of people. They ask questions that adults have been socialized not to ask, and they wear clothes and speak in cadences that adults find distracting or even disrespectful; they are not developmentally able to sit still and listen to monologues for extended periods of time. But instead of inviting the chemical reaction that occurs when adolescents are vigorously mixed into the central life of a congregation, most church bodies do everything they can to avoid the potentially volatile chemical reaction. They push teenagers to their own space, assign them their own minister, and hope they don’t disrupt their congregational stasis.
Theological Foundations of Adopting a Marginalized Population
Likely the most common way to interpret the miracles of Jesus is as a sign of his messianic power. Indeed, that’s the way that many of his contemporaries interpreted them. Often, when Jesus performed a miracle, accompanied by a brief saying or teaching, the crowd dispersed and, the Gospel writers tell us, the people were amazed at the power of Jesus. His miracles around Galilee and even in Jerusalem led him to be feted as the Messiah on Palm Sunday, welcomed into Jerusalem as a heroic victor.
But there’s another way to look at Jesus’s miracles, particularly the healing miracles. Jesus was born into a culture that, like many in the ancient world, took a very dim view of any human who had a physical ailment. In first-century Judaism, that view had been codified into laws, regulations, and rituals. Anyone with a physical infirmity was considered “unclean” and therefore shunned. They could not, for instance, worship in the temple, the very center of Hebrew religious life. Further, if a “clean” person even touched an “unclean” person, the former would have to go through a ritual ablution before being allowed to again worship in the temple.
Who was considered unclean? A paralytic, a leper, a demoniac, a blind person, and even a menstruating woman. Yet each of these persons Jesus touched and healed, effectively bringing them back into cleanliness and back into the center of Hebrew religious life.
Among the most telling of stories in the life of the earliest church is recorded by Luke in Acts 3:1–10. Sometime after Jesus’s crucifixion and resurrection, Peter, John, and some of the other disciples are in Jerusalem, walking together to the temple to pray at the appointed hour. There, a man who has been lame from birth and regularly sits by the gate to the temple is asking for alms. Notice that this paralytic man is sitting right at the boundary of the sacred space, but he is barred from crossing the threshold.
When the crippled man reaches out to them, Peter does not hand him loose change. Instead he looks the man in the eye and says, “I don’t have any silver or gold, but what I have I give you: In the name of Jesus Christ, stand up and walk.” Then, Luke tells us, the man’s ankles and legs grow strong before their eyes; he stands up, and he grabs his mat.
You may remember what comes next from the chorus of the old Vacation Bible School song: “He went walking and leaping and praising God, walking and leaping and praising God. . . .” But what that song leaves out is where the man does his dance. After being healed, he immediately runs into the temple. He crosses the threshold, into the very space from which he had previously been forbidden. He moves from the margins of Jewish religious life right into the center. When he gets inside, we’re told the people say, “Isn’t that the man who sits outside asking for alms?” Yep, that’s the same guy.
Now, we don’t know what happens next. But it would be nice to think that he spent some time telling all those “clean” people in the temple what it’s like to be “unclean,” to be at the margins, and to be shunned. There’s no question that he remembers that feeling. It is part of his story, even though his legs now work.
Materially, time and time again Jesus healed those who’d been officially pushed to the margins of Judaic life. Spiritually, Jesus’s miracles were a foretaste of the eschatological kingdom that he promised is coming in God’s ultimate reign. In this way, the miracles can be seen as signposts pointing to the time when no one will be on the margins, when all people will be at the center of God’s life and rhythm.
As long as we have free will as humans, some people will be at the center of power, and others will be at the margins. That’s inevitable. It’s the price we pay for the freedom we enjoy. But Jesus showed in his healing miracles that a time is coming when that will no longer be the case.
Here’s the rub: the church is supposed to be a foretaste of that kingdom. We who make up the “body of Christ” are called to be an earthly instantiation of the very eschatological kingdom that Jesus inaugurated. In other words, the onus is on the church to ensure that marginalized people are ushered into the very center of our communities of faith. And guess what? That’s going to change our churches.
From the Margins to the Center
I know of a church, a very old church—over one hundred years old—that didn’t have any seating for disabled persons. Week after week as the pastor preached from the pulpit, he watched a wheelchair-bound parishioner jockeying for a place in the sanctuary. If he rolled in the aisle, the ushers asked him to move because of fire code. Same thing if he stopped in the doorway. His chair couldn’t fit behind the last pew unless he positioned it sideways.
The pastor became so frustrated that he came into the sanctuary on a Saturday, with a chainsaw. He cut off half of a pew in the middle of the sanctuary, making a space for his congregant. That pastor has moved on to another church, but the sawed-off pew remains. They didn’t even sand off the rough edges. The congregation wants to leave it in its rough state as a reminder of how difficult it can be for someone on the margins to make it to the center of a church community.
Any number of similar anecdotes can be proffered for any number of marginalized peoples in the life of the church. For many years, churches were officially segregated—now they’re just informally segregated. And the list of stigmatized people in the church is longer than your arm: unwed mothers, divorcees, LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender) persons, the mentally ill, the obese, the homeless.
And teenagers.
Think of where the teenagers sit in your Sunday morning worship service (that is, if they attend). Probably, it’s not at the center. More likely it’s in the back row.
And think of the sermon illustrations used by the pastor. Probably, they’re not about when she was in middle school. More likely, they’re oriented toward adults.
What about the litanies of prayer? Do they include prayers about school, peer pressure, the temptations of alcohol and drugs and sex? Probably not.
Even the version of the Bible that’s used in worship is most likely a translation favored by the adults.
If we’re going to get serious about adopting adolescents into the family of faith, then we really do need to get serious about it. We need to usher them into the center of our worship life, into the organizational structures of congregation. They need to have a say on the budget, on the staffing, on the mission.
Central to the adoption thesis is that adolescents aren’t an “unreached people group” in need of specialized evangelism. They are as much members of the family of faith as any other group. And as a group that has been traditionally marginalized, they deserve an extra effort from those of us who traditionally hold the power in these communities.
So let’s return to Aristotle. Remember, he said that young people learn phronetically—that is, by a combination of intellect and experience. Think about my son learning to play goalie, or a person learning to drive, or a kid who’s really into chess or cello. In all of these cases, a person takes lessons and practices. Intellect and experience combine to create wisdom, a brand-new compound of the initial two elements.
Prayer is a central practice of our faith; it has been since the time of ancient Israel. It’s no surprise that we emphasize prayer in our churches—both adult-oriented worship and youth ministry. But how are we teaching young people to pray? Are we doing it in a developmentally appropriate way, or are we firing the equivalent of ninety-mile-per-hour slap shots at them?
One very concrete way that we can heed Aristotle is by introducing our adolescents to prayer in ways that are appropriate. After experiencing success at a primary level, they can gradually step up to a secondary level. For instance, every middle school teacher knows that the attention span for a thirteen-year-old is limited. Can you imagine a teacher at a public middle school asking the kids to go from playing a high-energy game to listening to a twenty-minute monologue to closing their eyes and sitting in silence for five minutes? No way. They’d know that it’s unfair to ask an adolescent for such a quick mental and kinesthetic turnaround. Yet that’s how many middle school ministries are run.
Spiritual formation happens, guided by the Holy Spirit, when we attend to the needs of the adolescents in our care and when we provide ways for them to develop that they can handle.
At the risk of repeating myself, let me say that there is no substitute for experience. Aristotle said it, and we know it in our bones. If our congregations are really serious about adopting adolescents and ushering them into the center of congregational life, then we have to continually remind ourselves that they are gaining experience every day. Teenagers are bound to mess up, to make mistakes that we think are totally preventable and avoidable. That’s endemic to adolescence. What these adolescents need is a community into which they can be adopted—a community that understands that they are gaining experience; a community that surrounds them with supportive adults who help them process those experiences; a community that provides experiences of spiritual formation and development that are appropriate to their ages. Ultimately, adolescents need to be adopted into communities that are flexible enough to change when teenagers are moved from the margins of communal life to the center.
