Chapter 18 of 31

13. Adoption Extended

13. Adoption Extended

13

Adoption Extended

Creating a Welcoming Space

PAMELA ERWIN

Adoptive youth ministry rises and falls on creating welcoming spaces for teenagers and emerging adults. There are few welcoming spaces for the young. Growing up today means leaping from adult-controlled agenda to agenda, within which a child is welcomed and received when and if he or she is able to serve the needs and expectations of that agenda. Whether it is in school, in a sport, or playing an instrument, those who present as smart, “gifted,” and talented are welcomed. Those who, for whatever reason, do not seem to be as adept at playing up to the performance demands placed on them recognize that if they don’t “measure up” they won’t be welcomed. Yet all young people today—even, and in many cases especially, those who rise to the top—know that they are one missed extra point, one exam, and one poor performance away from being welcomed. In our society, by the time adolescents reach high school, they are wondering who wants to welcome them regardless of their performance.

One of the great benefits of seeing ministry, especially youth ministry, as participation in what God has done by claiming us as his own children (thereby making us siblings) is that a (healthy) family doesn’t impose an agenda. During my last Sunday in our little church after I graduated from college, the pastor defined the church as a family: “And a family is where when you show up, they always take you in!” Likewise, this chapter addresses what we are about in youth (and every) ministry: we take in anyone who would but come. That is what it means to create a welcoming space. We strategically and proactively structure and design our ministry, our programming, and our life together in order to join in what God has done.

Pamela Erwin is the right person to write this chapter. She has always epitomized the idea of a welcoming space. From her years as an urban youth minister to her time in seminary as a surrogate “mom” and big sister to the younger students—in her leadership everywhere she goes—Erwin personifies the Lord’s desire to receive and welcome all who would come. An outstanding teacher, a warm counselor, an honest colleague, and a committed friend, Erwin helps us to think deeply about what it means to create the kind of environment that fosters an adoptive ministry.

As you read this chapter, consider these questions:

  • Discuss the meaning of shalom-friendship as defined in this chapter. How can youth ministry programs foster an environment of shalom-friendship?
  • Why is it important to create a welcoming space for others?
  • Describe the relationship between programming and building relationships in the context of youth ministry. Are these entities at odds, are they in partnership, or do they simply coexist?
  • The author adapts Alan Roxbury’s discipleship rules for the purposes of this chapter. Discuss these rules and how they might be appropriately applied to a specific youth ministry context.
  • The time passed quickly. I had spent the past five days visiting ancient Roman ruins and churches, attending an Italian cooking class, and walking down the cobblestoned streets of Florence and Rome. The weather was flawless: brilliantly blue skies, warm but not too hot, and crisp, gentle breezes. Springtime in Italy. My senses were bombarded at every level: from the brilliant hues of the flowers—vivid pinks, reds, and purples of oleander and bougainvillea; the scintillating smells of roses and jasmine intermingling with the smells of fresh bread and Italian sausage; and the clipped sound of shoes on cobblestones and the rapid-fire conversations of people hurrying past.

    On my last night in Rome, I walked through Campo dei Fiore and past the Pantheon to a delightful restaurant where I shared a meal with two young women who were studying and living in Rome for a semester. Over eggplant parmigiana and risotta con carciofi e funghi, I listened as they shared with me the ups and downs of a semester abroad. Both were students in small, Midwestern Christian liberal arts universities. Each had different reasons for studying in Rome. One came from an Italian-American family and wanted to make a connection with her family history. The other wanted to have a different kind of experience from what her small, close-knit community offered. They had become friends in part because of their similar Midwestern background but also because they both shared a strong Christian faith. Their first few weeks in Italy had been exciting. They experienced lots of firsts: a different climate and culture; a new language; vivacious, boisterous people; and people of conviction and faith—people very different from their own experience.

    One of the most challenging discoveries was that many if not most of the other American students did not share their faith convictions. Some of the students had some level of religiosity, but many wanted nothing to do with conversations about religion, faith, or God. These two young women had welcomed each other because they found in each other a kindred spirit—a kinship—of joy and love for Jesus Christ.

    As we talked about the new and unfamiliar things they were experiencing and learning, they talked about their struggles and loneliness because of the lack of a Christian community. Both of these students were naturally outgoing and quick to engage others in conversation. One of the young women, Mara, related an experience that happened in the first few days after their arrival in Rome—an experience that left her quite discouraged. They had just arrived in Rome after completing two weeks of intensive language orientation. Each of the students moved into the separate apartments that would be home over the next four months, apartments they would share with several other young women from the States. Mara was eager to develop a community that would sustain her during her study abroad. The study-abroad group had a Facebook page set up to help students connect, and she decided that she would post a message inviting others to start a regular Bible study. Mara was extremely discouraged by the responses she received. She felt ridiculed and mocked. One student, she said, responded with, “I’m an atheist. Can I come to your Bible study?” Another chimed in, “I’m Muslim. Can I come?” And on and on with a variety of other negative responses. Mara felt humiliated and isolated. We spent the next few minutes talking about ways that they could support, care, and pray for each other and opportunities to seek out Christian community beyond the boundaries of the American student network to which they were connected.

    As I headed back to my hotel, I pondered many things from my conversation with these two delightful women. They shared a precious faith and sincere desire to love and serve God, and I prayed for God to provide them with a strong support network that would strengthen their faith and develop and mature them as believers during their stay in Rome. But I kept hearing the questions posed by the other students on Facebook. Sure, these students may have made their comments in jest and derision, but the questions remained: “I’m an atheist, can I come to your Bible study?” “I’m a Muslim. Can I come?” Other questions began to spill forth in my consciousness as I began to drift off to sleep, “I’m ________, can I come?” My final thought as the street sounds lulled me to sleep was a phrase from my childhood, “Whosoever will, let him take the water of life” (Rev. 22:17 KJV). Over and over in the Gospels—particularly in the King James translation, the Bible of my childhood—you hear the phrase whosoever will. Lexicons note that the word for whosoever is a word for which we don’t have a good English equivalent. When whosoever is coupled with the word will, we get the understanding that anyone who determines to do something can. Whosoever will. While the students who posted those comments meant to be hurtful, the answer to their question is the one that was rolling around in my head as I went to sleep: Of course you can come. Whosoever will, may come.

    What would a Bible study—or a youth ministry—look like if we extended an invitation and truly envisioned that all were invited and that any who desired to be with us were welcome? What if our youth ministries were places of generous hospitality where each person felt valued and honored? This chapter explores what youth groups might look like if we created a welcoming space for those who don’t look like us, for those who don’t think like us—a space for others.

    At this point you may ask, “Why would we want to do that?”

    At a philosophical level most youth workers probably believe that the gospel is for whosoever will may come, but the day-to-day messiness of living that out in a youth ministry setting often pushes us into the reality of only the ones who look right, act right, and play by our church rules are welcome. What that really means is people who look like us. I served for many years as a youth pastor in a downtown church. The small, family-like neighborhood of houses around the church had over time been replaced with apartment buildings and small businesses (years later, the church building became the downtown police station!). As the neighborhood became more urban and longtime church members moved to the suburbs, the church membership became predominantly older, commuter congregants. I was the part-time youth director for a handful of teens who lived in well-kept manicured suburban neighborhoods but whose parents maintained ties to the church of their youth. Each week as young people came to youth group activities they passed through an urban community of kids who were rough around the edges and had no place to go but to the front door of our church. In my tenure as youth director I worked hard to engage youth leaders and teens in reaching out to the young people in the neighborhood. By the time I left to pursue a seminary degree, the youth group was about fifty-fifty suburban youth and urban, neighborhood teens. You can imagine how messy that youth group was, as well as the conversations I had with parents concerned for the “safety of their kids” and the discussions I participated in with church leaders about the mission of the church. The night a teen pulled a knife at Wednesday night supper on another teen who was sitting next to a couple of sweet eighty-year-old ladies was a night I’ll never forget.

    After I had been at seminary for about six weeks, I had a conversation with the pastor of my former church. He was excited to share with me that they “had finally gotten rid” of all of the neighborhood kids. Things could finally calm down. “It was just too messy with them showing up.” Clearly, there are significant and real concerns that need to be addressed in opening up the doors of a youth ministry to the neighborhood. However, the assumption that church (or youth ministry) should not be messy is a fallacy of the purpose of church and thereby youth ministry. As I listened to the pastor’s joy in ridding the church of the neighborhood teens, Jesus’s words to the Pharisees who questioned his hanging out with “tax collectors and sinners” were blasting in my head, “Healthy people don’t need a doctor, but sick people do. Go and learn what this means: I want mercy and not sacrifice” (Matt. 9:12–13 CEB). Showing mercy is fluid and organic; it forces us into face-to-face encounters with others. Being the church is messy, no doubt about it.

    Creating Welcoming Space

    As we consider creating welcoming spaces for the “others” in our church communities, three foundational principles frame the discussion. First, God has issued an invitation to whosoever will to be adopted into kinship relationship with God and the people of God. The Holy Spirit is at work, as Paul reminds us in 2 Corinthians 5, reconciling the world to God through Jesus Christ. God is doing the sending and invites the church to participate (John 20:21: “As the Father has sent me, I am sending you”). A second guiding theological foundation is that the reign of God extends beyond the doors of the local church. The church—the youth ministry—serves as a sign and foretaste of the present reality of the reign of God. Our youth groups are instruments of the Spirit’s activity in the world and point toward the coming reality of God’s reconciled people. The third theological principle that frames this discussion of creating welcoming space is that youth ministries are launching pads, not the destination.

    It Is God’s Mission, Not the Mission of the Church

    Mission. We talk a lot about mission, and often we assume that we know what we mean by that word. But do we? At a minimum, mission is about going and doing, the efforts exerted in pursuit of a specified goal. The word mission came into the English language in the mid-sixteenth century from the Latin word missio meaning “to send” and denoted the sending of the Holy Spirit into the world. The Triune God sends out the Holy Spirit to accomplish the reconciliation of God’s creation, which is effected through the redemptive work of Jesus Christ.

    This understanding of mission has been turned on its head over the past five hundred years; what began as the sending of the Holy Spirit has become the sending of the church. Mission—the ministry of reconciliation—is God’s mission, not the mission of the church. The idea that it is the church’s mission is a philosophical underpinning of most youth ministries; we tend to believe that the responsibility is ours—we are the ones on mission. Success or failure belongs to us. As the church, we are fulfilling the mission of God.

    God’s mission in this world is [God’s] and [God’s] alone. The glory of God, not the church, is the ultimate goal of mission. Our role as the church . . . is a humble participation in [God’s] grand scheme. (Frost and Hirsch, ReJesus, 29)

    At first glance, this may seem a quibbling over semantics, but this underpinning shapes the choices we make about the way we do ministry. For example, we say youth ministry is not about numbers and size, but if you ask a youth worker how it’s going, the quick response will typically be about numeric growth or the latest big event. If we dig below the surface, two assumptions are often at play. The first is a conviction that the success or failure of a ministry is our doing. A second parallel assumption is that it is also our work. Underlying these twin assumptions is what Brian Kirk and Jacob Thorne call the “fear factor.” Our ministries and our actions are driven by a fear that if we don’t have high energy and if we aren’t growing in numbers then we are failing. Youth workers (me included) often run at a fast pace, like hamsters running in a cage; we schedule activities, run Bible studies, and plan for retreats and mission trips. At the root of this activity is the belief that we are the ones doing the sending and that the accomplishments of the youth group are our responsibility. We measure our worth (our success) by how much we do and how many youth show up. Kirk and Thorne rightly note, “One of the most amazing results of letting go of our fears and trusting God is that we discover youth ministry isn’t all about us. We discover that it isn’t about how charismatic we are, or how many teenagers we attract to the ministry, or how competent we are at developing great programming.” It is about the Holy Spirit at work. As we turn our understanding of mission upright and acknowledge that the mission belongs to God, we are acknowledging that it is not up to us alone to fulfill this new sending but to align with it and serve it until God has accomplished the mission. This attitude calls us to let go and shift our emphasis from what we are doing to what God is doing. If the mission is God’s, the role of our youth ministries must then shift to bearing witness to the good news that God is active in the world.

    Craig Van Gelder and Dwight Zscheile, ministry scholars who have spent decades considering the mission of the church, contend that youth ministries must adopt an eschatological dimension—that is, by embodying the present the reality of the Holy Spirit’s work and presence in our lives we serve as a sign and a foretaste pointing toward the future reality. God’s work is a work of reconciliation that draws people (young people) “from every tribe, language, people, and nation” (Rev. 5:9 CEB). Creating a welcoming place for the diversity of people in our neighborhoods is an act of pointing toward the future reality of God’s reign.

    It is God’s mission that has a church rather than a church that has a mission. (Van Gelder and Zscheile, Missional Church in Perspective, 4)

    In his book Missional: Joining God in the Neighborhood, Alan Roxburgh describes a Monday morning visit to a neighborhood coffee shop. As he sat drinking his coffee, he overheard a conversation at a nearby table (who of us hasn’t done that on occasion!). As the people at the other table talked about “finding spiritual moorings in a world complicated and unmanageable,” his mind began to drift to the kind of standard questions that we ministry types ask, questions that focus on getting people through the church doors: How can the church be more relevant to these people? How do we get these people in the coffee shop to church on Sunday?

    As Roxburgh posits, we typically think that the answer to people’s spiritual questioning lies in getting them to come to church. His conclusion is that we are asking the wrong questions. If the mission, as noted above, is God’s mission, the rightly framed question is “What is God doing?” along with the follow-up question, “And how do I join in?” Roxburgh ends his ruminations by stating emphatically: “When we are truly seeking to know what it means to be God’s people, we will want to know what God is up to in our neighborhoods and communities and what it means for the gospel to be lived out and proclaimed in this time and place.”

    The implications for embracing the mission of God and inviting the youth group to participate is that we move from a WWJD (what would Jesus do?) perspective to a WTSD (what’s the Spirit doing?) perspective. The former is about a moralistic, individual decision (a good thing). The latter, however, is the more valuable question for a youth group seeking to embrace God’s mission in its community. Youth ministries, like the broader physical church, are launching pads for ministry, not the destination.

    The result of understanding mission as God’s doing and not our own is that the emphasis shifts in terms of what we do in our youth ministries. Youth ministries are no longer the destination but the launching pad for sending young people into the world to participate in the work of the Holy Spirit. As the launching pad, our youth ministries become places where we recharge (worship) and refuel (educate, train, and equip) students to be involved in their neighborhoods, schools, and families. This idea is really a reclaiming of the Great Commission in which Jesus gives the biblical mandate to “go and make disciples” (Matt. 28:19). Suffice it to say that the focus for youth ministry shifts from programming to preparing. I would argue that the first step in creating an inviting and welcoming space for young people is to get outside the walls of the youth ministry and into our neighborhoods and communities. We have to develop the reputation for being a place where others are welcomed. We often think we develop such a reputation by getting people to come in so they can experience how welcoming we are on the inside. People come because they have already experienced our welcoming embrace from the outside.

    These three principles provide the context for a discussion about creating a welcoming space, and I will return to these ideas throughout this chapter.

    Fostering Shalom: A Generous Hospitality

    Kayla lives to dance. Since she was a little girl, she has taken dance lessons and performed at every opportunity and venue available. She is passionately committed to dance, practicing two to three hours most days. As a fourteen-year-old, Kayla is also involved in her youth group at a church she has been a part of since birth. When she was in fifth grade, her parents and her youth pastor began to talk about Kayla’s transition to the youth group. As Kayla is a child with Down syndrome, her youth pastor and her parents wanted to ensure that the transition to youth group was a good one and that the youth group was a welcoming space for Kayla. There have been bumps along the way, as is typical for any youth group, but Kayla loves going to youth group almost as much as she does dance. Almost.

    Jake and Amy are fifteen-year-old twins who live in a large metropolitan area and attend a large public high school that is culturally and ethnically diverse. Their parents are members of a church near their home and in the neighborhood in which they live, a neighborhood that in the past thirty years has also become very diverse. In the past couple of years Jake and Amy have resisted attending church with their folks. Most Sundays, they stay at home while their parents go alone. Jake and Amy would readily tell you they don’t feel like they belong in the youth group at church and that they don’t feel very welcome. The church is almost exclusively white. Jake and Amy are African American. Their youth pastor wants the youth group to be more diverse but doesn’t quite know where to start.

    Jaynace’s best friend is Jasmeen. Jasmeen’s family moved to the United States so that her mom could teach at the local university. She and her family are Muslim. All Jaynace knows is that she and Jasmeen have great fun together and spend most of their free time together. Jasmeen has gone to youth group with Jaynace on occasion, and she seems to have a good time when she is there, but she tells Jaynace that it all feels very strange and the other students look at her weird if she says the wrong thing or asks the wrong question.

    Kayla, Jake, Amy, and Jasmeen are typical teens. In every small town, rural community, or large metropolitan area, there are hundreds, if not thousands of teens just like them. What would it look like, what does it look like, to create a welcoming space for them?

    Shalom Paradigm: A Generous Hospitality

    Creating a welcoming and safe place for young people, especially ones who don’t look or act like the typical youth in our youth groups, compels us to seek the shalom of the neighborhood. The ancient Hebrew understanding of shalom is a multifaceted concept that defies a simple definition of “peace.” A shalom paradigm seeks to offer generous hospitality to any young person in our community. Youth groups offer shalom as they encounter their communities as an immigrant-stranger and as a welcoming host.

    But you are a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people who are God’s own possession. You have become this people so that you may speak of the wonderful acts of the one who called you out of darkness into his amazing light. Once you weren’t a people, but now you are God’s people. Once you hadn’t received mercy, but now you have received mercy.

    Dear friends, since you are immigrants and strangers in the world, I urge that you avoid worldly desires that wage war against your lives. Live honorably among the unbelievers. (1 Pet. 2:9–12 CEB, italics added)

    Immigrant-Stranger

    Stories of immigrants (i.e., foreigners) and strangers are interwoven throughout the biblical story. In the Old Testament we hear the story of Abraham and Sarah, called by God to become strangers in a foreign land, a land that God established for them. We hear the story of Moses growing up as a stranger in Pharaoh’s house and later called to return to that land in which he was a stranger to serve God in leading the Israelites out of Egypt. Furthermore, the Israelites are encouraged to remember their time as strangers in a foreign land and extend hospitality to strangers in their midst: “Do not mistreat foreigners who are living in your land. Treat them as you would an Israelite, and love them as you love yourselves. Remember that you were once foreigners in the land of Egypt. I am the LORD your God” (Lev. 19:33–34 GNT).

    The image of God’s people as strangers is carried forward into the New Testament story. Peter calls us to remember that God’s people are immigrants and strangers in this world and we are to conduct ourselves as such in our encounters with the others among us. If we are to understand our role as God’s people and how to participate with what the Holy Spirit is doing in the world, we must endeavor to comprehend this notion of stranger and immigrant.

    Peter, in using the two words immigrant and stranger, gives us a clear and emphatic picture. The first word, paroikos, describes a person (or community) that is without any rights of citizenship. Citizenship in the ancient Roman world (of which Peter was a part) held great significance. Roman citizenship granted, at minimum, legal and political protections, including protection against taxation, slavery, and physical punishment. Citizenship also granted citizens freedoms to enter into contracts and to own property.

    The second word Peter uses, parepidemos, is a word that connotes a person living in a country that is a foreign place, a place where the customs, language, and values are not one’s “first language.” With these two words, Peter paints a picture of a people who don’t readily speak the language or understand the customs of the place where they live. What’s more, they don’t experience the rights of citizenship. They do not have an expectation that they will experience the same freedoms, rights, and privileges of the citizens of the place. In the broader Roman society, Peter is suggesting that disciples should have no expectation that they will be treated with the same dignity and respect as those who have citizenship. This idea of being God’s people, of being noncitizens and foreigners on the one hand, can be traced all the way back to Abraham and Sarah. But on the other hand, God is calling us toward God’s reign over creation through the power of the Holy Spirit and the redemptive work of Jesus Christ, restoring spiritual citizenship to all who desire to enter in. The Scriptures affirm that God’s call goes even further—to adopting us as God’s own children. Thus, as we remember that we have been accepted into God’s family, our calling as the expression of that gift is to participate in God’s kingdom work as agents, seeking to adopt “foreigners” and “strangers” as our rightful vocation.

    As an outcome of our own adoption in Christ, the concept of gracious hospitality plays into this stranger-immigrant conversation. Again, thinking about the ancient worlds of the Old and New Testaments is helpful. Hospitality—the receiving and welcoming of guests—is rooted in a sense of generosity. The typical notion of extending hospitality involves the host welcoming as a guest the lost, the immigrant, the foreigner, and the stranger. This idea of being kind and generous to friends and strangers can be seen in the biblical stories. But, as Roxburgh notes, the primary emphasis is of God’s people remembering that they were once a stranger and foreigner to God—that they received hospitality from God and thereby those in God’s family.

    After these things, the Lord commissioned seventy-two others and sent them on ahead in pairs to every city and place he was about to go. He said to them, “The harvest is bigger than you can imagine, but there are few workers. Therefore, plead with the Lord of the harvest to send out workers for his harvest. Go! Be warned, though, that I’m sending you out as lambs among wolves. Carry no wallet, no bag, and no sandals. Don’t even greet anyone along the way. Whenever you enter a house, first say, ‘May peace be on this house.’ If anyone there shares God’s peace, then your peace will rest on that person. If not, your blessing will return to you. Remain in this house, eating and drinking whatever they set before you, for workers deserve their pay. Don’t move from house to house. Whenever you enter a city and its people welcome you, eat what they set before you. Heal the sick who are there, and say to them, ‘God’s kingdom has come upon you.’ Whenever you enter a city and the people don’t welcome you, go out into the streets and say, ‘As a complaint against you, we brush off the dust of your city that has collected on our feet. But know this: God’s kingdom has come to you.’ I assure you that Sodom will be better off on Judgment Day than that city.” (Luke 10:1–12 CEB)

    In this passage, we see a vision of hospitality. Jesus tells his disciples to be ready and willing to receive the hospitality of the townspeople they visit. They are the strangers, without resources or rights of citizenship. They are to sit in the midst of the people who extend hospitality. “They are to become like the stranger who needs to be welcomed as a ‘guest’ and welcomed to the table of others who may be very different from us.” When we come to our relationships in our communities and youth groups from the vantage point of a stranger, we set aside our superiority. When we remember, like Israel, that God has adopted us—we who have done nothing to deserve such a gift—we can freely welcome others as our adopted siblings. We come with open hands to receive what young people have to bring and offer us. Yes, we are the adult leaders, and yes, we can and should offer hospitality to the young people in our youth group, but we start with the posture of stranger.

    As we follow Jesus’s command and go into our neighborhoods, we not only go as an immigrant-stranger, but we also go as host, joining the Spirit at work by extending the shalom and the invitation to adoption through gracious hospitality to those we encounter. As noted above, the Hebraic concept of shalom is multifaceted, reflecting the restorative work of God in God’s humanity.

    Shalom-Wholeness

    One component of pursuing shalom in a neighborhood is to pursue wholeness and soundness. What that looks like depends on the community one lives in and the young people who inhabit these spaces. Our street has a sign at each end of the block that states “Blind Child Area.” One could debate the sensitivity of the framing of that statement (and we have!), but the motivation is commendable. A young woman who is visually impaired lives on our block. The sign stands as a commitment to the neighborhood’s pursuit of her wholeness and protection.

    On the west end of this same city block that I call home live eight other young girls, ages one month to seventeen years. Each of these nine daughters of God represents a variety of ethnicities and cultural backgrounds: African, French, Irish-American, African American, Chinese, Swiss, and a Midwestern Scandinavian. Each brings to their world a variety of talents and abilities (e.g., dancing, soccer, piano, basketball, biology and physics, acting, etc.), along with unique personalities, individualities, and a few challenges. If I am going to be a part of creating a welcoming and safe place for these young women I will need to pay attention, first, to who they are and, second, to how the Spirit of God is at work in their lives. God is already present in their lives. My role is to participate with what God is doing. To do that, I need to know them, to learn them—to hear their stories and listen for their voices. I need to invite them to tell their stories, to share their lives. Only then can I know what we—the church/youth ministry—can do to foster wholeness. A pivotal understanding of a shalom-wholeness is that we are instruments of God’s life-giving shalom.

    Shalom-Welfare

    After God cleaned house in Jerusalem and almost everyone had been carted off to Babylon, the prophet Jeremiah, paying attention to what God was doing, sent a letter to the elders in exile. In this familiar story, the prophet counsels them to settle into their new neighborhood: get married, have children, build houses, and plant gardens. Jeremiah paints a picture of a neighborhood that is healthy and whole (a shalom-wholeness) and further encourages them to “promote the welfare [shalom] of the city where I have sent you into exile. Pray to the LORD for it, because your future depends on its welfare [shalom]” (Jer. 29:7 CEB).

    The image that God draws for these exiled Israelites through the proclamation of Jeremiah is of a vibrant people living in the very heart of a society that does not know God; at the same time, however, it is a society in which the spirit of God is very present and active, bringing the possibility of well-being through God’s people as they join in with God in the work that God is doing. When I bake chocolate chip cookies with my neighborhood teens, I am taking a step toward participating in what God is already doing in their lives. All I have to do is show up and pay attention. The simple act of living life together opens us up to the possibilities of partnering with God’s Spirit in bringing shalom-welfare to the young people in our world.

    Shalom-Flourishing

    Another side of the multifaceted aspect of shalom is the notion of flourishing and prospering. Inextricably intertwined with shalom-like wholeness and welfare is the image of a neighborhood that is thriving and prospering, a place where good things are happening. I am a wannabe gardener; plants seldom thrive in my yard. Every once in a while—more by coincidence than by my green thumb—a plant will be awash in blooms. Last year I had a squash plant that simply would not stop producing squash. Every day there would be three or four more squash to collect. Only with the first frost in October did that little plant stop producing. It was flourishing! The Spirit is at work, often in ways unseen by us, bringing the possibilities of flourishing and prospering to young people. Kayla, the young dancer mentioned previously, got involved in dance because a church friend of her parents noticed how much the tiny toddler loved music and thought that dance might be a way to provide healing and wholeness to her body. Through dance she has discovered a way to thrive and flourish.

    Shalom-Friendship

    A fourth aspect of shalom is to extend friendship. In the context of youth ministry, extending friendship is twofold. First, we must help youth in our youth groups identify ways to extend friendship to their peers. A simple gesture is sometimes all that is needed to extend shalom friendship. A couple of years ago I was observing a youth ministry student as she completed her internship in a large suburban church south of the Twin Cities. The Wednesday night senior high youth group often had about two hundred youth in attendance. This night was no different. As the worship time began, students began to gather with their friends in the youth worship area. As a nonparticipant observer, I sat outside the circle, watching from a distance. It was easy to spot the students who were by themselves; they didn’t seem to have a natural connection to the broader group. As several of these students hung back along the edges of the room, I noticed three or four students break away from their clusters of close friends and introduce themselves to the visitors. “Good,” I thought, “their youth leaders have been teaching them well about being welcoming.” As each of the students invited guests to join their groups in worship, I noticed one young woman introducing her new “friend” to her cluster of friends and clearing a spot for her in the middle of the group. Each of her friends made sure to introduce him- or herself and assisted the visitor in finding her way through the service. These are but simple gestures of friendship that promote shalom and offer a foretaste of the future reality of the reign of God.

    A second aspect of shalom-friendship involves the role of adults. As Jason Linker describes, a welcoming space for youth demands that adults be active and involved—not simply as volunteers but as mentors. He describes the role of natural mentors as “non-parental adults, such as extended family members, teachers or neighbors” who “provide support and guidance as a result of a relationship developed with the help of a program.” These kinds of relationships, according to Linker, go through the following general phases:

  • Listening and asking probing questions. The first phase demands lots and lots of listening. A friend of mine talks about ironing while her son talks to her about his day. She has no need to iron, but the iron and the ironing board provide a safe space for listening. Somehow it provides safety because the focus is not on him. I have used this insight repeatedly. Sometimes I come up with a joint project, or sometimes it’s a simple task. Always it diverts the direct focus from the young person I am talking with and allows him or her a measure of safety.
  • Mutual self-disclosure. This is not a time to unload one’s dirty laundry but a time to allow the young person to know that you are real and human and that you have your own struggles. This phase comes after a significant period of time during which you simply listen.
  • Wrestling with issues together. This phase involves talking it out together. I often start with questions such as “What do you think is appropriate?” and “What does your gut tell you?” Then I toss in some soft questions: “Have you thought about . . . ?” “What about . . . ?” We dig deep together.
  • Serving as a guide. As an adult mentor, one never leaves students at the wrestling phase, if at all possible. They need to have a clear sense of guidance and direction. We don’t direct. We guide—typically by asking questions and allowing the student to process them.
  • Genuine caring—authenticity. In this kind of adult-teen relationship, there is no room for projects. Their successes and failures are not things for us to revel in or discuss with others. This phase is the foundation for our relationship with young people: genuine and authentic care, trusting God for the work that the Spirit is doing. Jake and Amy, the African American teens in the predominantly white church, didn’t need to be someone’s project; they needed someone to talk alongside them, someone with whom to wrestle through the issues of race and identity in our society and, particularly, in our churches. Cierra, my sixteen-year-old granddaughter, is biracial and struggles with some of the same issues Jake and Amy do. She is fortunate to live in a neighborhood where she has several natural mentors. In a recent incident in which she was hurt by some racist comments, an adult in our neighborhood, who is also a member of our church, invited her to a book discussion of the book The Skin I’m In. She felt so empowered by the discussion and the support of her adult mentor that she gave a speech in her English literature class about the experience.
  • Shalom-Justice and Reconciliation

    A final aspect of shalom is the intertwined aspect of justice and reconciliation. A neighborhood committed to shalom is a neighborhood “that embraces outcasts and foreigners.” In the case of our youth ministries, outcasts and foreigners are the young people who don’t look like us. Perhaps they are students with cognitive or physical disabilities. Perhaps they are students who come from different ethnic or socioeconomic backgrounds. Perhaps they are young people from a different faith background (a different Protestant denomination, Catholic, Jewish, Muslim, etc.). Perhaps they are young people with no religious background or experience. Whatever attribute defines them as “other” puts them in an outcast or foreigner category. A true shalom community offers an open door to whosoever will. As Jeannine Brown describes this aspect of shalom:

    Jesus focused His new community around two central commandments that bring together the law and the prophets—to love God wholeheartedly and to love one’s neighbor fully. One’s neighbor is broadened and specified to include those outside one’s own circle. Even a person’s enemies are now included in the category of neighbor. . . . The divine vision for the covenant community now centered in Jesus is the actualization of the truth that in Christ “there is no longer Jew or Greek, there is no longer slave or free, there is no longer male and female” [Gal. 3:28 NRSV].

    A little over three years ago, I met a young woman in the local coffee shop that I frequent. I noticed immediately that she had the most vivacious laugh and embodied a love of life and people. I, like everyone else, was drawn to her. As she made my Americano, I would talk with her. Over time, we began to ask each other more personal questions. She learned about my teaching at a Christian university. I learned that she and her family had moved here from Tunis and that she was Muslim. I also learned that she finished up around the time I would typically drop by, and she began to stop by my table. I didn’t come to our friendship as a blank slate (nor did she), but I didn’t need to flaunt my Christianity. My faith is a natural part of who I am. It was evident to her, and she would sometimes ask me questions. Our deep friendship also allowed me to ask her questions about her faith. And here we are three years later. We are still talking. She has a great interest in the God I love. I am trusting that the God who is working in my life is at work in hers too. Beyond that, I have a friend whom I deeply love and respect.

    If you have gotten this far in the chapter, you will have already determined that what I am arguing for is ministry that is less about programming and more about building deeply rooted relationships in one’s community—about being a welcoming stranger to the young people in your neighborhood networks. A primary emphasis of this chapter has been that we need to know and learn the young people in our community first; as we come to know them, we can begin to see what the Spirit is doing and where the Spirit is moving, and then we can begin to think about we do. In that vein, I return to my earlier suggestion that the youth group is not the destination but the launching pad. As a launching pad, the youth group offers opportunities for young people to recharge and refuel (worship) and a place to prepare (educate, train, and equip).

    In my thirty-plus years of youth ministry, I have developed a well-earned reputation for organization and attention to developing structured programs. However, as I have become convinced that the mission is God’s—not mine—I am convinced that my energies should be less devoted to programming and more devoted to fostering an environment in which students can engage with adults, who must always keep an eye toward moving them out the door so that they can encounter the gracious hospitality of strangers (the other) as they live as strangers in their world. In these last few paragraphs, I’ll unpack a few ideas about ways to contemplate a kind of youth ministry that fosters a welcoming space and pays particular attention to students outside our typical frameworks.

    Throughout his book Missional: Joining God in the Neighborhood, Alan J. Roxburgh offers a list of “rules” for aspiring missional church leaders. I have adapted them to this discussion for being a community that seeks shalom and gracious hospitality in our youth ministries.

    The Rules

    Be Local

    “Buy local” is a common admonition these days, encouraging us to support local businesses and farms. In a similar vein, gracious hospitality that seeks to participate in the Spirit’s shalom-making invites us to be local. Identify what local looks like for your ministry and community, and be local. Being local involves imagining how you can develop close-knit relationships that move beyond church boundaries and intersect the places where you live and work. Being local might take the form of small group ministries, a neighborhood school, a homeschool network, or a city block. The main idea is that being local takes one outside the confines of the youth ministry.

    Leave Your Baggage at Home

    In Jesus’s words to his disciples, he admonishes them to “carry no wallet, no bag, and no sandals” (Luke 10:4 CEB). Leaving those things behind ensures that we will be strangers, not guests. Jesus’s disciples show up with nothing and are thereby dependent on those in the community to extend gracious hospitality. Notice that Jesus doesn’t send them out to the ones in their community who don’t have wallets, bags, or sandals. He sends them as the ones in need of hospitality—not the ones offering it. When we approach our participation with the Spirit from that vantage point, we leave behind our agendas, assumptions, and self-confidence at the boundaries of relationship.

    Don’t Move from House to House

    In other words, stay put. Each admonition from Jesus draws his disciples further and further from a world programmed and controlled by their own self-determination. Hang in there and let the relationships develop on their terms, not your own. Take time to really get to know one another. It is easy to look for a new neighborhood, a new church, or a new youth ministry when times are challenging, and they always get a little more challenging once you get to know one another.

    Eat What Is Set before You

    “The rule of eating what is set before us is about our readiness to enter into the world of the other on his or her terms rather than on our own.” As a teacher, every year I get a new group of students. I don’t get to choose. They are my table. When you move into a new home, you may choose the home, but your neighbors are your neighbors. You haven’t chosen them. They are your table. Maybe in your effort to be present in your neighborhood you hang out in your local coffee shop. You have chosen to do that. But you haven’t chosen the people who show up each day. They are your table. As Roxburgh notes, the rule of eating what is set before you involves a commitment to “be present with someone else in ways that meet them in their context and environment.”

    Listen People into Speech

    I spend a fair amount of time each week driving teens from one place to another. When I was younger, I used to try to be the energetic, vivacious mom and youth pastor. It was draining for me and often awkward and embarrassing for the teens in the car. These days I’m more inclined to be quiet. I’m respectful and polite. I talk, but more often I listen, especially if there is, as is often the case, a car full. I don’t listen to be nosy but to learn. It’s amazing what you can learn about what’s important in their lives when they see you simply as the chauffeur.

    Conclusion

    In the Gospels we discover many instances in which Jesus encounters others in the context of their world, their relationships, and their lives. One such example is the woman at the well. In this story, we see Jesus encounter her as an immigrant-stranger. “Will you give me a drink?” (John 4:7). She responds as a welcoming host. But then he returns the favor and offers her shalom—life-giving water and gracious hospitality. Like Jesus, youth ministries that want to create welcoming spaces for young people will need to join the Spirit-led movement of extending the reign of God in the world beyond the walls of the church.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑