Chapter 12 of 31

7. Thinking (Practical) Theology

7. Thinking (Practical) Theology

7

Thinking (Practical) Theology

MICHAEL MCENTYRE

We as editors are committed to continuing the conversation concerning the best thinking and practices that youth ministry brings us. Beginning with the book When Kumbaya Is Not Enough: A Practical Theology for Youth Ministry, by Dean Borgman in 1995, the field of practical theology has been the primary theological launching pad for theologically oriented youth ministry.

For those who are steeped in practical theology literature, there are many different ways to describe the process, and the field is far from clear in terms of what and how practical theology actually operates. While this conversation is obviously beyond the scope of this book, we do need to make this point: what sets practical theology apart from other theological perspectives is its emphasis on the starting point of theological inquiry. Practical theology starts with the context, or the current practices, of what it is we are seeking to understand. In general terms, practical theology’s four basic questions and tasks (as summarized by Princeton’s Richard Osmer) are:

  • What is going on?
  • Why is this going on?
  • What ought to be going on?
  • How might we respond?
  • Our intent in Adoptive Youth Ministry is not to wholesale replace that grounding perspective but to learn and grow from the way practical theology has defined the practice of youth ministry. This chapter, by Michael McEntyre, is the way we have chosen to make that connection between practical theology and participation in God’s adoptive work in the church. As we work to consider youth ministry as the church’s participation in drawing those who are not included in the dominant community of faith into the family of God—which obviously includes adolescents and emerging adults—we can and should continue to rely on the insights of practical theologians who specialize in youth ministry. This chapter and the webpage dedicated to practical theology as an aspect of adoptive youth ministry are intended to help you understand how the work of youth ministry has been theologically conceived over the past several years.

    As you read this chapter, consider these questions:

  • This chapter uses Urie Bronfenbrenner’s Ecology of Human Development to describe growing up (a model some find difficult to understand on first glance). In this chapter, how does McEntyre explain and make use of this “ecological model” to explain practical theology in youth ministry?
  • What is the definition of practical theology? In reading this chapter, why is practical theology important? How does it help us to be theologically grounded, and how is it reflected in how we “do” or “practice” youth ministry?
  • Practical theology is basically a process by which we reflect as a community on what we need to do in order to think critically about how God would like us to better align ourselves with our Lord’s purposes in creation. List five or more areas of ministry that might need to be examined critically and reflectively in order for a community of faith to move in the direction of adoptive youth ministry.
  • When I was in seminary, I went to see a professor with a question about a grade he had given me. As I sat down across the desk from him, he leaned back and asked, “What’s your story?” Not quite sure what he meant, I began to ask my questions about the assignment he had given. He interrupted me and said, “That’s not your story; that’s your problem. Before we get to your problem, I want to know about your story. Tell me about you.” The conversation that followed was simple, yet its impact on our relationship and my approach to ministry would prove to be profound.

    Much of my time in seminary was spent learning about God’s story. My Old Testament classes focused on how God’s story has been revealed to us throughout history. My New Testament classes examined how the fullness of God’s story was reflected in the work of Christ. My Greek and Hebrew classes helped me to appreciate the original languages first used to share God’s story found in Scripture. My theology classes explored how humanity has sought to understand and interpret God’s story over the ages. My preaching classes honed my skills on how to best communicate God’s story to a congregation. All of these classes came together to proclaim the beautiful and complex symphony of God’s story.

    As I entered my first ministry position, I was excited to share what I was learning with the students in my youth ministry. As each new revelation about God’s story was introduced to me, I would eagerly form it into my next Sunday school lesson to “enlighten” my middle school and high school students. I would love to say that my messages were received with as much enthusiasm as they were taught, but I think you can imagine what happened. My well-crafted monologue with three points and a clever illustration didn’t make it past the second paragraph before the interruptions began. Amazingly, the students did not seem to care what it meant that a particular passage was written in the middle voice in Greek. And my quotes from Barth and Augustine might as well have been pulled from a fortune cookie. You see, in my eagerness to share God’s story, I didn’t take the time to listen to the stories of the students who were right in front of me. That’s when I remembered my professor’s comment to me: “Before we get to your problem, I want to know your story.” Looking back, this was the moment when I began to realize the power and value of practical theology.

    This chapter will explore why it is important for youth workers and leaders to develop an accessible framework of practical theology for ministry. The content will explain how practical theology has come to be defined and how it has emerged as a discipline. The goal will be to identify and explain the characteristics that are generally seen as unique to the discipline of practical theology in order to create a framework to engage the use of practical theology for guiding our ministry. In conclusion, I will share why I believe incorporating practical theology into ministry is not just good practice but also essential to the work of adoptive youth ministry.

    The world is, to paraphrase a famous novel by Charles Dickens, a tale of two stories. We have God’s story of the world and humanity’s story of the world. In response to God’s story, prominent Canadian theologian Douglas John Hall writes, “Humanity is telling its own story, improvising scenarios, creating roles for itself—for all the other creatures, too, and of course for God!” Taking the time to understand these stories is important. A person’s story is about more than information. Our story is our life, the narrative of who we are. Stories hold power, enable perspective, foster respect, build relationship, and create space for community. Our personal stories shape and are shaped by the stories around us and combine to create the stories of our neighborhoods, our schools, our churches, our culture, and so on. All of these stories play a part in what Hall refers to as humanity’s story.

    Psychologist Urie Bronfenbrenner describes in depth how these stories influence one another in his book The Ecology of Human Development. Bronfenbrenner suggests that our development, our stories if you will, have a ripple effect through the various systems of context in which we live. This ripple does not simply travel outward but flows back and forth, allowing layers to mutually affect one another. Observing and interpreting how these layers affect one another is crucial to understanding our context. Our context is the setting of our story. It includes the “unique place, people, history, and story” that surround us. Everything we do is done in context. We are caught up in its current, and without careful and deliberate investigation we are blissfully unaware of the ebb and flow it creates in our lives. As those who minister to students, our task needs to be to seek to understand how both God’s story and humanity’s story are at work in our ministry. This is where a framework of practical theology is essential.

    Why Is It Important to Have a Good Framework for Practical Theology?

    When I first was introduced to practical theology as a concept, my immediate thought was, “I am already doing that.” Student ministry is known for its ability to connect with students where they are and seeks to understand the world of adolescence. Being up to date with student culture, or the context and stories of students, is something on which most student ministers pride themselves. In the same way, I believed that I was pretty good at thinking theologically when it came to preparing my lessons and trying to help students grow in their faith. I worked hard to make God’s story applicable to the lives of my students in a way they could connect to. Yet as I began to learn about how to use practical theology in my ministry, I realized that being familiar with parts of the process is not the same as knowing how the process works. As I began to use practical theology to shape my ministry, I also realized that my end goals were being shaped more by unspoken expectations and traditions than by the kingdom of God.

    After my first ten or so years of working in student ministry in three different church settings, I came to a realization: being a church youth minister was fairly easy. Before you write me off, hear me out. Helping students to understand the love of our Creator and the need for the community of faith (that is the church) to join with God in the ongoing work of the kingdom in this world is not easy. Sharing your life and faith in an incarnational presence with others is not easy. Working to see the bride of Christ fall deeper in love with God and care for those God cares for is not easy. But keeping my job, as it turns out, was a relatively simple affair.

    Through numerous life/ministry lessons, I learned that there were really only a few unwritten expectations I needed to follow if I wanted to keep my youth parents, my church members, and my senior leadership happy (so that I could keep my job). For my senior leadership, the students needed to be seen (not necessarily heard) in the worship services, preferably sitting together in a nice big group. For our church members, it was important to know that there were lots of activities and discipleship opportunities going on for our students constantly. And for my youth parents, they needed to know I was working hard to keep their kids from making bad choices that could “ruin” the rest of their lives. While this is all very cynical and simplistic, at times it felt like as long as I followed these secret guidelines, everything else was good to go.

    It is easy to let cynicism creep into our ministry efforts. As ministers, when we become cynical about the church we tend to take on a hero complex, acting as if we have to do it all ourselves. Since student ministers often feel like they have little voice in the direction of the larger church, our efforts turn to making our ministries the bastions of all that is good and holy in the church. In essence, we stop focusing on the kingdom of God as our end goal and focus on what we are doing instead. This may sound like a harsh generalization, but if I’m honest it is more of a confession. Without good mentors, the care and wisdom of countless “senior adults,” youth and youth parents who were not afraid to examine our ministry practices and partner with me to make a difference, the encouragement of family, and an awakening to the destructive changes occurring in adolescence, my approach to ministry would be very different today.

    I say all of that to show why having a good framework of practical theology is important to us as student ministers. Ministry of any sort is messy. People will offend you; your schedule will push you. Interruptions will come at the worst possible time. It can be overwhelming, and even our best intentions can fall by the wayside. Over time, the comfort of routine can replace the work of ministry. Engaging the process of practical theology pushes us to move past our cynicism and routine. By forcing ourselves to “begin with the end in mind,” as Stephen Covey says, we must hold everything we do up to the inbreaking work of the kingdom. With this as our goal, we come to see humanity’s story and God’s story in a different light. Understanding the stories in this way helps us to see people, not problems. Our focus moves from assimilation into our student ministry or our congregation to acceptance into the family of God. For this reason, I think having a good framework of practical theology is essential to our goal of adoptive ministry for us and for our leaders.

    What Is Practical Theology?

    Prior to the 1960s practical theology was simply seen as “the fourth move in the four-fold encyclopedia behind biblical studies, church history, and dogmatics; the first three did the science, practical theology applied it.” In the past five decades, practical theologians have successfully argued that practical theology is more than simple application. Richard Osmer summarizes the reasoning for this change well.

    Practical theology as an academic field has its own distinctive research program. It makes its own constructive contribution to the theological enterprise as a whole and to the ongoing conversation of humankind in its quest for intelligibility. It carries out four mutually related intellectual operations: the descriptive-empirical, interpretive, normative, and pragmatic. This distinguishes practical theology from the social sciences, even as it overlaps these fields in certain ways.

    Don Browning is often credited with making the shift from pastoral (applied) theology to practical theology. “Browning proposed a new conception of practical theology based on an interdisciplinary correlation occurring between theology and the human sciences. He corrected the concept of practical theology as applied theology (theory-to-practice), and proposed a praxis-theory-praxis model using a comprehensive model of practical moral reasoning.” James Fowler also picked up on this shift, describing practical theology as “theological reflection and construction arising out of and giving guidance to a community of faith in the praxis of its mission. Practical theology is a critical and constructive reflection on the praxis of the Christian community’s life and work in its various dimensions.” Ray Anderson later defined practical theology as “critical and constructive reflection on ecclesial praxis . . . the process of ongoing critical reflection on the acts of the church in the light of the gospel and in critical dialogue with secular sources of knowledge with a view to the faithful transformation of the praxis of the church in the world.” Osmer would use his four intellectual operations (the descriptive-empirical, interpretive, normative, and pragmatic) to craft a definition and process of practical theology that would set the standard for discussion in this discipline.

    Practical theology is that branch of Christian theology that seeks to construct action-guiding theories of Christian praxis in particular social contexts. In part, it focuses on “how to”—how to teach, preach, raise children, influence society, and so forth. But this “how to” is informed by a strongly developed theory of “why to”—why we ought to practice the Christian way of life in certain ways in light of an interpretation of a particular social context and the normative claims of the Christian community.

    While all of these definitions shape the way we intellectually approach the work of practical theology, it is important to remember God’s role in the process. Mark Lau Branson recognizes that practical theology is “an ongoing transformational initiative of the Holy Spirit with a church.” As such, the Holy Spirit should be the guiding impetus throughout this process. When the Holy Spirit illumines God’s work in our midst, it raises questions about our current practices, revealing the opportunity for the work of the kingdom to break through. The work of practical theology gives Christians the tools to faithfully respond to the prompting of the Spirit in order to best join in what God is doing.

    What Has Shaped the Process of Practical Theology?

    Since the rebirth of practical theology in the 1960s, there have been many ideas, theories, methods, and approaches as to how practical theology should be done. While there are still a wide variety of opinions on how to arrive at faithful action, there does seem to be some consensus on what elements must be included in the process. Andy Root writes that “even in the midst of this diversity, practical theologians seem to be unified regarding a set of common tasks. Richard Osmer has done the most work in providing an account of these larger shared tasks.”

    Osmer uses four questions to guide his interpretation:

  • What is going on?
  • Why is this going on?
  • What ought to be going on?
  • How might we respond?
  • Answering each of these questions is the focus of one of the four core tasks of practical theological interpretation:

  • The descriptive-empirical task. Gathering information that helps us to discern patterns and dynamics in particular episodes, situations, or contexts.
  • The interpretive task. Drawing on theories of the arts and sciences to better understand and explain why these patterns and dynamics are occurring.
  • The normative task. Using theological concepts to interpret particular episodes, situations, or contexts, constructing ethical norms to guide our responses, and learning from “good practice.”
  • The pragmatic task. Determining strategies of action that will influence situations in ways that are desirable and entering into a reflective conversation with the “talk back” emerging when they are enacted.
  • Osmer’s tasks form the building blocks for the practical theology process. While various nuances and reworkings continue to add to the discussion of this discipline, these tasks continue to drive the process of practical theology forward. Along with these core tasks, practical theology is shaped by at least two other important characteristics.

    First, practical theology does not begin with theory, as other branches of theology do; “it is at least a praxis-theory-praxis process of constant dialogue and interpretation, communal reflection and challenge, and a never-ending quest to hear God’s voice and follow his call.” Thomas Groome states that “instead of theory leading to practice, theory becomes or is seen as the reflective moment in praxis, and articulated theory arises from that praxis to yield further praxis.” It is important to recognize that the Aristotelian term praxis is not the same as practice. The term practice is sometimes mistakenly used synonymously with praxis in practical theology literature. Hyun-Sook Kim explains:

    The Greek term praxis, frequently translated into English as “practice,” implies more than the typical English definition for “practice.” According to A Dictionary of Philosophy, practice was described as something pertaining to action, whereas praxis, itself, meant action or activity. Practical (Greek praktikos) referred to anything related to action, whereas the Greek theoretikos is classified as the theoretical or related to thought.

    Consider the game of golf, for example. You could seek to be a competent golfer and thereby practice your swing, putting, judging the distance to the green, and understanding what club to use when you hit the ball. All of these elements are clearly important to becoming a good golfer, but none of these elements is, in and of itself, the actual game of golf. Practicing golf is not playing golf; rather, playing golf would be our praxis.

    As noted in Kim’s definitions earlier, practical relates to action while theory focuses on thought. Thus practical theology begins by examining our current actions and practices and then bringing the weight of theological reflection to bear in order to create action that is faithful to a kingdom-oriented trajectory yet lived out effectively within our current context. That is why one will often hear practical theology described as “doing theology from below.”

    In his essay “Youth Ministry as Practical Theology,” Chap Clark argues that our praxis should be understood in light of our telos. He defines telos as “the culmination of God’s intended purpose for creation and redemption.” Clark notes that the conclusions of practical theology should always be mindful of God’s current action and God’s future intent for all of creation. This can also apply to understanding God’s story of the world. Clark believes that our praxis—the action/activity that drives us—should be the inbreaking of the kingdom of God. It is the “already and not yet” that seeks to permeate our existence and lead us toward the telos. Scott Cormode calls this “faithful action,” which must be “faithful, effective, contextual, and communal.” Our faith practices should help us to move toward faithful action, and therefore we must continually evaluate our practices in light of the trajectory, or inbreaking reality, of God’s kingdom in the world.

    Second, practical theology draws on an interdisciplinary conversation between the secular disciplines and theological reflection in order to faithfully evaluate and reorient our praxis. Root explains: “Using theories from fields as diverse as sociology, evolutionary biology, literary studies, existentialism, object relations psychology, and education, to name but a few, the practical theologian seeks to provide an interpretation, a particular theoretical lens that helps explain why such an occurrence is happening.” Ballard and Pritchard describe it this way:

    At a theoretical level [a hermeneutical dialogue] will be a critical correlation between theology and the social sciences, together illuminating the human condition. This method of “critical correlation” has become central to much recent practical theology, not least in North America, developing a theme found in Paul Tillich and elaborated in more recent hermeneutical theology such as that of David Tracy.

    The essay “Youth Ministry as Practical Theology” argues that

    practical theology is in its essence a correlative relationship between theology and any other data set that can inform and illuminate God’s call to his people. Whatever the source of these data sets, anything that speaks into the human condition such that believers can receive a deeper and more thorough understanding of the context in which the Gospel is to be lived out is an important part of a practical theology method.

    As you can see, this concept has the general support of the practical theology community.

    Osmer’s four tasks, the progression of praxis-theory-praxis, and the use of the interdisciplinary tools of both secular disciplines and theological reflection all contribute to the uniqueness of the work of practical theology. Understanding how these elements work together to lead our actions toward the inbreaking of God’s kingdom is our next step. While I find it helpful to describe this process in a more technical-rational nature, I recognize that the process of practical theology can and perhaps should, at least at times, be more organic than systematic. I appreciate David White’s reminder that “life in the Holy Spirit is more appropriately akin to dancing than engineering, more aesthetic than technical.” While the following guide is linear in nature, I affirm that any time the Holy Spirit introduces new revelations that call into question our previous assumptions, we must be willing go back and work the process again.

    Before We Continue

    An important question to answer before we tackle the “how” of practical theology is the “when” and “what.” When do we use practical theology and on what? Practical theology applies anytime we want to bring something more in line with what God is doing. That may seem vague, but it is true. The secret to success is working to refine your question or issue down to the core of the matter. What is the Holy Spirit prompting you to respond to? The process of practical theology will help you do this if you are faithful to the work. As with most things in life, the more effort you put into the process (making use of a wider array of secular disciplines, working to understand your faith traditions, looking for the connections between the stories, seeking the wisdom of others, praying through your implementation, etc.), the more you will get out of it. However, that does not mean that without volumes of research the process holds no value. The process of practical theology is ongoing. God is always creating, always redeeming. As such, God is always inviting us to join in the work of bringing the kingdom near. In some instances our work may result in a gigantic leap forward. At other times it may feel like a baby step. Remember, the distance isn’t as important as the direction; our goal is faithful action.

    Putting It All Together: The Process of Practical Theology

    Practical theology starts by recognizing that the Holy Spirit is constantly inviting us to join in God’s ongoing work of redemption and creation. In this discipline, when we realize a specific way in which God is inviting us to be involved, our proper response should be to first step back and try to observe what is going on. Try to determine what stories are involved. Think back to Bronfenbrenner’s Ecology of Human Development. By examining the interactions of the various layers, we hope to better understand our context and bring clarity to the praxis that the Holy Spirit is revealing.

    As the process begins, the urge to immediately jump in and respond must be resisted. We must develop the discipline to hover above any situation or setting and observe the context from a bird’s-eye view: What can we see? What do we notice? What is God drawing our attention to?

    When I took a CPR/first aid class the instructor taught us that when arriving on the scene of an accident, our first action should be to look around and survey the scene. Your instinct is to immediately address the problem, but doing so may jeopardize yourself and the person(s) you are trying to help. First, you need to assess and try to understand the factors involved and how they have affected the situation. The same is true with the process of practical theology.

    Root explains it this way: “Because the objective of practical theology is to attend to God’s action in the locations and practices of human individuals and communities, practical theologians must describe what is going on in concrete locales. In the descriptive task, therefore, the practical theologians will seek to answer the question ‘What is happening?’ in a rigorous manner that sets forth a thick description of location.” Osmer gives an important warning regarding this process: “It is worthwhile for students and leaders to learn the skill of attending to the words and actions of others without filtering them through interpretive and normative judgments. This is very important in the descriptive-empirical task of practical theological interpretation, which focuses on what is going on before reflecting on why it is going on or what ought to take place.” At this early stage of the process it is important to avoid assigning meaning and creating assumptive categories too quickly. To best assign meaning, we need to first take the time to hear the stories that are involved.

    Let’s return to the story of my meeting with my professor. While I do not believe my professor was intentionally working through the process of practical theology during our meeting, what transpired that day lends itself to parallels that can help us to understand the process better. When I went to my professor to ask about my grade, he did not immediately address my concerns. Instead, he seized the opportunity to learn more about the situation. He asked what I was studying. He asked about my undergrad work. He wanted to know about where I grew up. He asked about my family. When he found out that I had recently been married before coming to seminary, he asked how the transition was going. He wanted to know about the church I was serving in and how the student ministry was going. He asked all kinds of questions that had nothing to do with the B on my assignment. As we talked, I believe he made observations about what was important to understanding my story and what wasn’t. In the important areas, he would dig a little deeper. He would ask follow-up questions and allow more time for the story to unfold. When he was satisfied with the conversation, he redirected us back to the reason I had come to see him.

    Once we have thoroughly observed and described the context in which the Holy Spirit has prompted us to act, we can begin the next step of practical theology. Osmer refers to this as the interpretive task, in which we answer the question “Why is this going on?” I would recast the question of the interpretive task as “How does humanity’s story of the world contribute to what is happening?” Either way, the second step of the framework of practical theology is trying to better understand the context and stories that are involved in shaping God’s ongoing creation.

    To bring clarity to how our specific area of context is affecting our observations, we turn to practical theology’s interdisciplinary strength. As we have noted, practical theology draws from both the secular disciplines and theological reflection to help interpret our context and uncover the stories involved. Beginning with secular disciplines, we often use tools such as sociology, psychology, psychiatry, ecology, family systems, and the study of culture, race, ethnicity, and class to create a thick interpretation of our context. To again borrow from Hall’s imagery, these are all ways in which humanity tells its own stories. Learning to listen to these stories helps us to identify the root issue that God is inviting us to realign with the ongoing work of redemption and creation. The secular disciplines act as a lens to bring into focus how the context affects our story and influences our practices.

    Examining our context can be an exhaustive task. To help guide this process, I find Clark’s focus on internal and external factors to be helpful. Clark states, “There are two significant areas of influence that shape a context: relational (or internal) factors and environmental (or external) factors.” Internal factors are by and large “those that are primarily relational and are generally located within the familial systems, structures, and experiences that shape how a person or people group view themselves.” These would be the stories uncovered in the microsystems and mesosystems in Bronfenbrenner’s bioecological model. Clark goes on to say that external factors

    include anything outside of the individual and their familial history that influences how a community and even a collection of individuals will think about a given issue. These include the various messages that mold opinion and perspective (including media, advertising, etc.), the ecological dynamics and resultant push of the context (how the whole shapes the specific), the various expressions (both overt, such as film, music, and other forms of directed message, and just as potent but less institutional, like language, humor, and the like) that comprise the elements of a collective narrative and continually swirl in and throughout a community while providing meaning and a sense of belonging to those living within the context, and any other cultural force that has been forged over time that influences and guides a collective perspective.

    These would include the larger stories generated by the exosystem and macrosystem found in Bronfenbrenner’s model. By arranging our context into internal and external factors, we allow the “lens” of secular disciplines to better guide our process.

    Getting back to my original story, when my professor asked me why I had come to see him I asked him why I had received a B on my assignment. He asked me what grade I had wanted. I responded, “An A.” Without a word he picked up my paper, took a pen out of his desk, marked through the grade, wrote an A beside it, and slid it back across the desk to me. Then he asked me a question that was simple, yet profound: “Why is it important for you to get an A?” I responded without really thinking, “Because it’s the best.” Without hesitation he replied, “Why is it important for you to be the best?” In a moment our conversation shifted from a discussion about a few points on an assignment to a deep-seated truth about myself that I had never realized. This is what the tools of secular disciplines bring to the work of practical theology. They take our observations and peel back the layers of façades and defenses that cover the core of the issue that the Holy Spirit is revealing about our current praxis. With this newfound clarity we are able to move forward in the work of practical theology.

    Once our issue within its context has been uncovered, the issue and process is then brought into the work of theological reflection. Theological reflection brings to bear the fullness of the Christian faith understanding (the richness of God’s story revealed throughout history) to the issue at hand in an attempt to discern God’s call to faithful action. In practical theology, I would espouse that true theological reflection cannot occur without first doing the work of the descriptive-empirical and interpretative tasks. The reason? One relies on the other. As Hall observes, “Theology lives between the stories—God’s story of the world, and humanity’s ever-changing account of itself and all things. Theology is what happens when the two stories meet.” While these two movements are both necessary for the work of practical theology to happen, it does not mean that their contributions are equal influencers in determining our faithful action. Hall goes on to say, “It is of course the particular vocation of the disciple community to keep listening especially for God’s story.” Root lays out this idea more clearly:

    The heart of practical theology, the organ that pumps the blood through the organism, is theology itself. Therefore, the practical theologian’s work should not only possess deep reservoirs of reflection on experience, but also it must seek to reflect on God’s continued action in the world. Theology should never be used functionally as a kind of add-on. Rather it should provide direction for how the empirical task is done. Theology must remain the heart of the field, because its core objective is to discuss the association between divine and human action. While empirical work provides invaluable perspectives on human action, the divine can only be articulated theologically.

    When working with students, we must not neglect the work of theological reflection. It can be tempting at times to simply celebrate the breakthrough that uncovers the core issue and not press on. For example, say you have an active student who suddenly stops coming to church. Through observation and inquiry you discover that her parents are struggling with their marriage. In your conversations with her you discover that she blames herself and has even thought about taking her own life. Let’s say that somehow, by engaging the power of secular disciplines, you help this young lady realize that her parents’ struggles are not her fault, and as a result she no longer wishes to harm herself. Let’s go one step further and imagine that in the process of working with the family you all stumble across the core issue that has caused the marital turmoil and it is easily resolved. This is cause for celebration; the family has been restored. Given the situation, most people would be content not to press the issue. But what has the family learned about God’s plans for their life through this struggle? Has the young lady who was ready to take her life realized the value she holds in God’s eyes, or is she just content that Mom and Dad aren’t fighting anymore? How is God wanting to bring the work of the kingdom into this situation? As youth ministers, we must train ourselves to reflect theologically about the situations in which God invites us to take part. We cannot rely on observation and action alone.

    If my conversation with my professor had ended with the revelation that my need to be the best was not based on a healthy work ethic but on insecurity and a need for acceptance, it may have helped me be a better person, but it would not have changed my approach to ministry. The biggest God moment of that conversation was not the unpacking of my family issues or how I defined myself by my achievements. The psychosocial analysis was helpful in uncovering the deeper issue, but it was my professor’s theological inquiry that most shaped the work of the kingdom for me that day. In a profound moment of clarity my professor asked me, “How does your need to be the best affect how you see God?” That was when my story and God’s story collided and the work of theological reflection began.

    Theological reflection helps us to understand God’s story in the world, both presently and historically. The goal of theological reflection is to bring our issue into alignment with the work of the kingdom; or to put it another way, we work to align humanity’s story with God’s story in order for humanity to more clearly see the work of the kingdom of God. As the process unfolds, the desired outcome is a more deliberate alignment with God’s work and purpose than we had at the outset. This is referred to as the kingdom trajectory: “movement towards God’s ultimate trajectory for us as he brings his kingdom to fruition.” This is what Kenda Creasy Dean calls “the radical congruency between God’s action and our action.” Richard Osmer refers to theological reflection as the normative task necessary to answer the question “What ought to be going on?” It is appropriate to note that the revelation of new information may call into question our previous assumptions. Anytime this occurs, we must revisit each step of the process to make sure that our perceived kingdom trajectory is an appropriate expression of God’s revelation.

    Practical theologians use different descriptors and approaches to describe the actual process of theological reflection, but despite the various labels, I believe one can find common elements essential to the process. Synthesizing the current work regarding practical theology, I see four main standards by which, through the guidance of the Holy Spirit, we bring the weight of theological reflection to bear: theology, tradition, experience, and Scripture. To help establish my practical theological framework for theological reflection, I envision the first three standards as interlocking circles within a larger circle. The larger circle represents all that is bounded by the process of theological reflection while the smaller circles within represent theology, tradition, and experience.

    These three elements of theological reflection each bring a unique series of questions to bear on the contextual issue. Theology encompasses all of the ways in which we think about God. It draws from such rich disciplines as systematic, philosophical, historical, contextual, and ethical theology to reveal kingdom truth about our current issue. Tradition includes both historical and local church history. Through tradition we bring to bear the timeless wisdom and practices of the church as well as unique denominational views, doctrines, and congregational beliefs that influence our issue in light of specific context. Experience acknowledges the revelation of God in both our corporate and individual stories. It provides space for the beauty of “worship, discernment, and prayer” to permeate the issue at hand. All three elements are essential to the task of theological reflection. Each circle balances and tests the other in order to eventually lead to kingdom trajectory.

    Continuing with this imagery, in the center of the circle where theology, tradition, and experience overlap, is the revelation of Christ as revealed through Scripture. In the work of theological reflection all of these elements must be seen and interpreted in the light of Christ as revealed through Scripture by the Holy Spirit. Anderson uses the term biblical antecedent to address this idea: “As nearly as I can see, for every case in which eschatological preference (kingdom trajectory) was exercised by the Spirit in the New Testament church, there was a biblical antecedent for what appeared to be revolutionary and new.” While the biblical antecedent guides our course, it is the light of Christ that illuminates our path toward kingdom trajectory and ultimately faithful action. Once the process of theological reflection is satisfied, any action we choose to move forward with needs to be supported by a biblical antecedent and true to our kingdom trajectory. (This model of practical theology can be found on the website dedicated to this book: youthministry.fuller.edu.)

    As stated earlier, practical theology is a discipline of praxis-theory-praxis. When we recognize the Holy Spirit’s invitation to join the ongoing work of creation, we respond by observing the elements of our current praxis. We use secular disciplines to help us interpret what humanity’s story is telling us about the context in which the Spirit is moving. Having gained new insights, we turn to theological reflection (theory) to understand how God’s story is calling us to transform our actions to align more with the work (trajectory) of the kingdom. A new praxis emerges out of our theological reflection, but here we must be careful to continue on and complete the work of practical theology in order to ensure that our action is faithful action.

    Osmer’s fourth task of practical theology is the pragmatic task, and he uses the question “How might we respond?” to describe it. While Osmer’s intent is on target, I believe that we must dig deeper than Osmer’s question prompts. There is more to the end of the model than just our response. To simply respond to our theological reflection runs the risk of action that is less than faithful.

    As followers of Christ, we need to remember that our new praxis should promote the inbreaking of the kingdom of God, not just the ministry of the church. These goals are by no means mutually exclusive, but often our temptation can be to focus our outcome on what is best for our ministry or our members. For our actions to be as faithful as possible, we want to keep the focus of our praxis on our kingdom trajectory, not just on our congregation. Gerben Heitink, a leading international figure who was one of the first to attempt to formulate a complete theory of practical theology, states that “the exercise of practical theology does not have the church, but rather society, as its horizon.” Practical theology is constantly working toward the inbreaking of God’s kingdom “on earth as it is in heaven” (Matt. 6:10). By returning to humanity’s story of the world and reengaging the tools of secular disciplines, we can determine the best way to introduce our new praxis so that humanity’s story will move toward aligning with God’s story, allowing the work of God’s kingdom to be further established on earth as it is in heaven.

    When my professor asked me how my need to be the best affected how I saw God, the answer was clear, although I didn’t say a word. I had built my identity on achievement, and when I honestly examined my spiritual life the lines of works and grace had become very blurred. I was constantly doing ministry for God, but rarely did I seek to just be with God. Logically, I understood Paul’s rebuke in Philippians 3 about the confidence of the flesh and counting all of our own attempts at righteousness as garbage when compared to knowing Christ. But practically, I wanted others to see me as a “Hebrew of Hebrews” (Phil. 3:5). Being seen as zealous and faultless sounded pretty good. I guess my professor sensed my discomfort and brought our meeting to a close by saying, “Michael, there are more important things in this life than grades. What good is it if you get an A in this class but a D at being a husband? Who does it serve if you have a great GPA but are too busy for the students in your ministry? God will still love you if you make a B. If you want to be the best you can be, learn to be present with your family, your friends, and your ministry. If you want to be successful in this calling, you need to learn balance.”

    Not many professors would be advised to tell their students that grades are not that important. But I believe my professor understood what it meant to align our praxis with the work of the kingdom. He wanted my actions to be as faithful as possible and in that moment that was exactly the lesson I needed to learn. In our brief conversation, my professor (knowingly or not) used the tools of secular disciplines to uncover a deeper issue in my life, brought the power of theological reflection to bear on that issue, and reoriented my praxis to align more faithfully with what God was doing by helping me to understand what that meant in my context. It was pretty impressive. As my seminary career continued, I often had to remind myself that God would still love me if I made a B. It was an easy mantra that encapsulated the incredible experience I had with my professor and helped me to continually evaluate where my story was headed.

    Once our theological reflection leads to a kingdom trajectory that is informed by the tools of secular disciplines to best understand how to live out faithful action in light of our current context, we come to the end of Osmer’s four core tasks and our cycle of praxis-theory-praxis is complete. Yet one step still remains. In this process we have worked to make our praxis faithful to the work of the kingdom, but we must remember that this is a tale of two stories. As we come to the close of this process, I think it is important to pick up on the work of Ray Anderson. Whereas Osmer asks, “How might we respond?” Anderson asks, “What is Christ doing in this situation?” (emphasis added to both questions). He calls this Christopraxis. For Anderson, Christopraxis is a continuation of Christ’s own ministry of revelation and reconciliation. The process of practical theology invites us to journey with the Holy Spirit, offering our faithful action to Christ’s ministry of reconciliation (Christopraxis) to usher in the inbreaking of the kingdom of God (on earth as it is in heaven) in our particular context (or story). The inbreaking of the kingdom ultimately leads to further revelations of new praxis that need to be examined. Thus the work of practical theology is actually an ongoing process of revelation, reflection, reaction to the work of the Holy Spirit, and partnership in the reconciliation of Christ.

    How Practical Theology Can Lead to Adoptive Youth Ministry

    Understanding practical theology has changed the way I approach ministry. It has given me the focus to keep first things first (to borrow again from Stephen Covey). By keeping my attention on the inbreaking of the kingdom, I find it easier to resist cynicism and build the church, not just my ministry. Beyond equipping me with a good framework and tools by which to engage in ministry, understanding practical theology has shaped my philosophy of ministry and my understanding of my Creator. Because of these insights, I have come to embrace the ministry of adoption as the best narrative for my ministry practices with adolescents.

    Below is the revelation of what I believe the Holy Spirit has shaped in me over the past several years. You do not have to agree or disagree with me in order to appreciate the work of practical theology or the ministry of adoption. I offer it because it has proved to be important to my ongoing praxis of aligning with God’s kingdom work.

    One of the greatest strengths of practical theology is that it begins by respecting humanity’s story, our story. Hopefully God’s story can clearly be seen weaving in and out of the fabric of our own narrative; nevertheless, it is still our story—and one of God’s greatest gifts. By inviting us to join in the ongoing work of creation, to become co-laborers with Christ, God makes room for the beauty and tragedy of the stories we share. James Fowler writes, “God can and does call us to a partnership in the divine praxis.” By examining our story and God’s story, practical theology allows us to faithfully join in this work to move us toward the work of God’s kingdom.

    In this chapter I have referred often to the kingdom, God’s kingdom, the kingdom trajectory, the work of the kingdom, the inbreaking of the kingdom, and so forth. I realize that many of us will have preconceived notions of what those terms refer to, but nowhere in the chapter have I explicitly defined what I believe these terms incorporate. I want to argue that the work of the kingdom, and ultimately the work of practical theology, has two main overarching thrusts.

    The first thrust is the one we are probably more familiar with. Anderson focuses on this with his discussion of Christopraxis. We are called to join with Christ in the ministry of reconciliation, which is clearly seen in 2 Corinthians 5:17–21.

    Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, the new creation has come: The old has gone, the new is here! All this is from God, who reconciled us to himself through Christ and gave us the ministry of reconciliation: that God was reconciling the world to himself in Christ, not counting people’s sins against them. And he has committed to us the message of reconciliation. We are therefore Christ’s ambassadors, as though God were making his appeal through us. We implore you on Christ’s behalf: Be reconciled to God. God made him who had no sin to be sin for us, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God.

    When I talk about the work of the kingdom or the inbreaking of the kingdom, part of what I am referring to is the gospel news that because of Christ our relationship with God can be reconciled, redeemed, and restored. This is the joy that was set before Christ as described in Hebrews 12:2. Humanity can once again be in right relationship and community with its Creator.

    In the magnitude of this revelation it is easy to focus our ministry efforts on us (humanity) being in relationship with God. Songs like “Give Me Jesus” and “Turn Your Eyes upon Jesus” lift our focus toward God’s kingdom and the perfection of our community with our Creator that awaits us in heaven. We long for that day and echo that chorus, “You can have all this world / But give me Jesus.” However, relationships work two ways. Yes, we want to be reconciled in our relationship to God, but I believe God also wants to be reconciled in God’s relationship to us—and not just us (those who are in the church) but also the world. We may know John 3:16, “For God so loved the world . . .” When we place those words in the context of Jesus’s prayer in Matthew 6:10, “Your kingdom come, your will be done, on earth as it is in heaven,” we don’t need to be so quick to leave this world behind. God is not done creating yet. This is the second thrust of the kingdom work that I think we do not give enough attention to. Yes, the church should be drawing humanity closer to God, but in the process the church needs to be drawing closer to humanity because God so loved the world. If it is important to God it needs to be important to us.

    Practical theology begins with the Holy Spirit’s invitation to join in what God is creating. This profound statement does not need to be glossed over. Gilbert Bilezikian’s book Community 101 has been one of the most influential works in helping me understand the depth of this revelation. The Bible begins with God’s invitation for humanity to join in the creation process. Have you ever stopped to wonder why God created a garden that needed tending (Gen. 2:15)? Why not put everything on autopilot and give Adam and Eve a continual all-you-can-eat buffet? If you have ever eaten a tomato that you watched mature from a vine you planted, you know the answer. If you buy a tomato at the grocery store and it falls out of your shopping bag in the parking lot and busts, you are probably not going to worry that much about it. If you pick the first tomato of the season off a plant you have nurtured for months and accidently drop it on the way into the house, there is a twinge of pain and loss. (I know not everyone likes tomatoes, but you get the point.) Why is this? Because God invites us to connect with creation and to share in the beauty of cocreating. God does not simply place us in the midst of God’s creation as pawns; God also invites us to participate in the creation process.

    God didn’t stop with the garden either. In Genesis 1:28 God tells Adam and Eve to “Be fruitful and increase in number”; humanity is given the gift of giving birth. God allows us to participate in the creation of life. It is important to God that we are a part of the process. And it’s not just a little important; God chose for us to be involved even though humanity would reject God and inflict pain and suffering on its Creator and itself. In the Genesis story it is clear to me that God wanted us to be involved in what God was creating. So when we say that the work of the kingdom that God invites us into includes the ongoing work of creation, we need to ask: What is God creating?

    To understand that question we need to start at the beginning. Look back at the creation story in Genesis 1. In this story, our God is set apart as the creator of everything. As God’s creation progressively unfolds, God makes a judgment about each movement of creation. God says, “It is good.” What we often miss in this reading is that God created something that was deemed not good.

    Genesis 2:18 tells us that it was “not good for the man to be alone.” It is astounding to think that Adam was in God’s presence when this decree was made. At this point in the story, God had already filled Adam’s lungs with the breath of life, created a place for Adam to live, and provided food to eat, water to drink, and careful instructions by which to live. God had established a relationship with Adam, but it was not good for Adam to be alone? What could possibly be better than one-on-one time with our Creator?

    According to the story, God gets creative and forms all kinds of animals and birds from the dirt and brings them to Adam, but nothing cures Adam’s loneliness. Then God chooses a new medium. He takes from Adam and creates Eve. From the one God creates two. Human becomes humanity, and at the pinnacle of creation stands God’s crowning achievement: community. In God’s infinite wisdom, God chose to purposefully design humanity to be in relationship with God and one another. God calls this “very good.”

    To be clear, while I propose two main thrusts within the work of the kingdom, our relationship with God has to be primary. Yet if we pursue that relationship while ignoring our community, we are falling short of God’s invitation. Christ’s response to the expert in the law who asked, “Which is the greatest commandment in the Law?” (Matt. 22:36) demonstrates this idea. “Jesus replied: ‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind.’ This is the first and greatest commandment. And the second is like it: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’ All the Law and the Prophets hang on these two commandments” (Matt. 22:37–40).

    As Christians we have to recapture the beauty of community. We need to renew our efforts to love God and one another. As a church we need to draw people closer to Christ, and we (as a church) need to be drawn closer to the people. We need to move away from the “us” and “them” mentality of assimilating people into our membership and instead open ourselves to the transformative work of the ministry of adoption. As Galatians 4:4–5 (NRSV) says, “But when the fullness of time had come, God sent his Son, born of a woman, born under the law, in order to redeem those who were under the law, so that we might receive adoption as children.” Through Christ we become children of God and coheirs with Christ. This is the miraculous work of God’s kingdom, the revelation of Christ’s reconciliation for creation. In that revelation it is important for us to remember that this reconciliation is for our relationship with both God and one another. This is why practical theology is the best approach for student ministry today. A model of ministry that is built on a process that values humanity’s story as well as God’s story is the only way the church can grow in true community.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑