21. Teaching for Adoptive Ministry
I have known Dr. Jay Sedwick for more than a decade. He has served in a variety of contexts in both the church and community and is a full professor in educational ministries and leadership at Dallas Theological Seminary. Sedwick is a highly acclaimed consultant for the church and parachurch, and his students know him to be more than a professor; he is a friend and a leader. What adds credibility to Sedwick as a professor and author is his consistent commitment to youth ministry in the local church throughout his career. When many of us shift into teaching, writing, and speaking, we are forced to be less involved in direct ministry, but Sedwick has maintained his commitment to listen to and walk with ninth graders even while preparing to teach doctoral students.
One of our core commitments in this volume is to gather together a team of scholars and leaders to speak into what it means to create a church culture in which adolescents are welcomed as adopted siblings in diverse settings. Sedwick does not bring ethnic or gender diversity but rather theological and even geographic diversity. As a professor at Dallas Seminary, Sedwick views the Scriptures in ways that are different, perhaps vastly different, from some of the other authors in this book. For example, he interprets Deuteronomy 6 to mean that parents are the “primary disciplers” of their children, while I interpret it as a command to Israel as a community. Some included authors share his perspective, and some do not. This is exactly what we want to happen in this book. Our hope is that people and traditions who are typically seen as being somewhat isolated from one another will come together with a common commitment to God’s call to live as God’s family on earth. The theological issues that we may hold in tension are serious and worthy of dialogue, and yet the body of Christ seeks to be the people whom God has called us to be. Therefore, our unity is of utmost importance.
Sedwick brings a history and expertise in the teaching ministry of the church—a voice that in much of youth ministry literature is neglected. Yes, there is plenty of curriculum, books, and resources that we can use as we seek to help equip adolescents in their faith. But what we lack is a guide to thinking critically and theologically about faith education. This chapter offers an excellent correction in that regard.
As you read this chapter, consider these questions:
Mark is sixteen years old and, by most measures, has everything together. He is kind, compassionate, considerate, polite, friendly, and makes his spiritual development a priority. He has never been in trouble with the law, never used or abused any illegal substances, never been involved in an inappropriate relationship, and never demonstrated any rebellious tendencies or attitudes. He is a dream teenager so far. Most people don’t believe adolescents like Mark exist today. He is like bigfoot. Some believe he exists, but no one has any solid proof he’s really out there. Mark is real. I know Mark personally. How did Mark become the ideal teenager at sixteen years old? I’m convinced that adoptive relationships have played a huge part in his development.
Mark has two loving parents who are still married and lead his family to love and honor the Lord. He has grandparents who fear the Lord and spend intentional time encouraging him along the way. He has two close uncles he sees on a regular basis who are also walking with the Lord and leading their own families by example. They have both spoken into his life on many occasions. He has a football coach who leads the school team with integrity and spends time building Mark up in the Lord. He has a campus pastor at his Christian school who leads small group Bible studies and regularly mentors Mark, who is the chaplain of his sophomore class. He has a youth pastor he highly respects and who regularly challenges him to seek the Lord in all he does. These are the people who have “adopted” Mark and hold him accountable to the calling in his life to serve the Lord. Mark is blessed. I wish every teenager had this kind of support structure. Things would be very different.
Mark has been taught by all of these significant adults in different contexts, and they have all influenced him in remarkable ways. An adoptive teaching approach encompasses all of the adults in his life who continue to play a role in discipling him. So, what are the characteristics of adoptive teaching?
Adoptive Teaching
Why Do We Teach?
The disciples had just seen Jesus! He was alive! They touched him, spoke with him, and even ate a meal with him. How could this be? Every experience they had with him between his resurrection and ascension would be replayed in their minds again and again. All doubt and fear now gone, they followed whatever he said or told them to do without reservation. Acts 1:3 says that Jesus spent forty days interacting with his disciples and friends to further prepare them for what he had called them to do. The last words Jesus spoke to his disciples before ascending into heaven are critically important: “You will receive power when the Holy Spirit has come upon you; and you shall be My witnesses both in Jerusalem, and in all Judea and Samaria, and even to the remotest part of the earth” (Acts 1:8 NASB). He was sending them to lead and to serve what would become the church, his body and bride, for the rest of their lives. These were his marching orders, given to motivate and guide them as they spread the gospel throughout the known world. This was what they had spent over three years preparing to do; this was the goal. But how were they to accomplish this incredible task?
Jesus briefly outlined a simple strategy during his post-resurrection interaction with the disciples. Matthew’s Gospel records this strategy, which we commonly refer to as the Great Commission: “All authority has been given to Me in heaven and on earth. Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all that I commanded you” (Matt. 28:18–20 NASB). When discussing this passage with my students, I often ask them to identify the command in this statement. Many will say it is to “go” or “baptize” or “teach.” However, these verb forms are participles that support the imperative verb, which is translated “make disciples.” The simple strategy Jesus commands is to “make disciples.” The way disciples are made involves three steps—going, baptizing, and teaching. He assumed that his disciples would be going (Acts 1:8); after all, they were apostles, which means “sent” ones (John 17:18; 20:21). The action of obedience in taking the gospel to every part of the world is the first step. They took it seriously. Over two billion people alive today—and the countless others who have believed through the centuries—owe their knowledge and understanding of Jesus Christ to this handful of faithful followers.
The second step in the process of making disciples is baptizing through evangelism. I am relating the process of evangelism (presenting the gospel to an individual whom the Holy Spirit moves to belief) with baptism for those who have heard the gospel and believe that Jesus is Lord, that he died on the cross to pay the penalty for our sins, and that he was raised from the dead, resulting in salvation (Rom. 10:9). The word baptize means “to identify.” The new disciple identifies with Jesus as Savior in baptism after believing in him through faith. Throughout the New Testament, the rite of baptism was performed on those who had first believed. Jesus, in telling the disciples to baptize in the name of the Triune God (Matt. 28:19), infers that the gospel has already been presented and believed through evangelism.
The third step in making disciples is to teach all that Jesus commanded. The things that he taught his disciples were to be taught to subsequent disciples throughout the generations until his return to earth. Amazingly, Jesus prayed for you and me (John 17:20–21) and every future Christian who would come to believe in him because of the teaching handed down across the ages by the disciples through Scripture. The teaching ministry of the church is crucial for communicating the truth of God’s Word to every generation. The ongoing health of the church and the propagation of the gospel depend on how well that job is done. It has been said that “the church is one generation from extinction.” If at any point in the sequence the next generation is not taught the essential elements of the faith by the current generation, then the church will struggle to remain effective in its calling.
It is my contention that every aspect of the ministry of the church in all of its various forms should be viewed as part of making disciples. As Paul wrote in Colossians 1:28, “He is the one we proclaim, admonishing and teaching everyone with all wisdom, so that we may present everyone fully mature in Christ.” The disciple-making process is, therefore, a lifelong commitment to becoming like Christ. I want to focus more intently now on the vital role of teaching in the development of the young disciple of Jesus Christ.
Whose Responsibility Is It?
Scripture directly addresses the question of whose job it is to make sure children are taught the things of God: parents and the nation of Israel are primarily responsible. The Lord commanded the nation of Israel to make sure the children learned his commandments in order to obey and be blessed. Although written to the newly formed nation, the principles are applicable to us today. “These commandments that I give you today are to be on your hearts. Impress them on your children. Talk about them when you sit at home and when you walk along the road, when you lie down and when you get up. Tie them as symbols on your hands and bind them on your foreheads. Write them on the doorframes of your houses and on your gates” (Deut. 6:6–9).
The Lord gave the Hebrews a simple pattern to follow. As the psalmist writes:
He decreed statutes for Jacob
and established the law in Israel,
which he commanded our ancestors
to teach their children,
so the next generation would know them,
even the children yet to be born,
and they in turn would tell their children.
Then they would put their trust in God
and would not forget his deeds
but would keep his commands. (Ps. 78:5–7)
Paul, having been trained in the Old Testament as a Pharisee, knew the commandments well. He reiterated the primary responsibility of the parents to teach their children the things of God. Ephesians 6:4 states, “Fathers, do not exasperate your children; instead, bring them up in the training and instruction of the Lord,” which places the burden of “training” on the shoulders of the parents, and likely the fathers in particular. Extended families are to play a role too. Paul reminded Timothy of the influential teaching of his mother and grandmother,
For I am mindful of the sincere faith within you, which first dwelt in your grandmother Lois and your mother Eunice, and I am sure that it is in you as well. . . . You, however, continue in the things you have learned and become convinced of, knowing from whom you have learned them, and that from childhood you have known the sacred writings which are able to give you the wisdom that leads to salvation through faith which is in Christ Jesus. (2 Tim. 1:5; 3:14–15 NASB)
Although the evidence is slim, it appears that Timothy’s mother and family played a key role if not the key role in his development as a disciple of Jesus Christ.
When the Family Breaks Down
The ideal situation, and what I believe God intended, was for the family to be the “cradle of theology.” The influence that parents have over their children is more powerful than any other factor. Timothy was taught from birth in the home. The Israelites were commanded to do so as well. The problem with this approach today is the deteriorating health of the family. Can we realistically expect parents to do the job of teaching their children the things of God? The answer to that question is not straightforward. Parents who are still married and who take the responsibility to teach their children seriously can and should be expected to do so. However, their tribe continues to decrease in numbers. One parent often understands the responsibility and the other doesn’t, or doesn’t care. So many youth have experienced the pain and brokenness of their parents’ divorce. At best, they now split their time between two households. At worst, they have limited or no exposure to one of their parents for the rest of their adolescence. Although we cannot be certain of this, Timothy’s father was likely not a believer and perhaps had little to do with Timothy’s spiritual development (Acts 16:1). What we do know is that his mother and grandmother clearly provided significant spiritual modeling and nurture, which Timothy relied on throughout his life (2 Tim. 1:5). He was fortunate. Some youth don’t have either parent as a spiritual guide, nor do they have extended family to help fill the void.
Surrogate Family and Friends
In his groundbreaking research, presented in the books Hurt and Hurt 2.0, Chap Clark argues that the health and well-being of a teenager is directly proportional to the number of adult influencers in the teen’s life. In other words, the more adults who speak into the life of a teen the better off that teen is, particularly in terms of a number of factors deemed important for success in life. Clark found that those teenagers who have a relationship with an average of five significant adults navigate their way through adolescence with relative success. The problem, as Clark puts it, is that the adult population of our society has “abandoned” (his word) its youth. Whether intentional or not, many adults simply let teens fend for themselves during what many would say is the most difficult developmental stage of life. Just when adolescents need the influence of mature adults to help them navigate life’s many questions and challenges, they end up turning to the youth culture and their peers for answers. Unfortunately, the youth culture does not have their best interests in mind, and their friends are just as needy and confused as they are.
Research and Scripture affirm that the two most significant influencers in a teen’s life, for better or worse, are parents. When that doesn’t happen, and sometimes even when parents are actively in the picture, there are thankfully any number of places where other adults have influence on teenagers outside the home. A youth pastor could fill the role. A small group leader, a Sunday school teacher, a football coach, a dance instructor, an aunt or uncle, a neighbor, an employer, or a family friend might fill the role. These relationships are highly beneficial for healthy adolescent development. An adoptive teaching approach takes advantage of these meaningful adult relationships. The apostle Paul encourages this approach when he exhorts the older men and women to have influence over the younger (Titus 2:2–8). Peter also instructs the younger men to be subject to the shepherding of their elders (1 Pet. 5:5). Jesus, who brought a new level of connection, intimacy, and mutual responsibility, affirms that people in the church make up his “family” as God’s adopted children (Matt. 12:48; 25:40).
With all of the influence parents have, God gives us siblings in his earthly body to mutually care for and nurture one another, and this clearly includes the children. The church community is one of the best contexts where this can happen. Paul explains that every believer is spiritually gifted and an important part of the body (1 Cor. 12). Each part is valued and essential for the body’s overall health—that is, we are stronger together than when apart. The writer of Hebrews reminds believers to meet together regularly for the purpose of encouragement and accountability (Heb. 10:24–25). Adolescents benefit greatly by being around the influence of other, more mature, believers—their older brothers and sisters—in the church. An adoptive teaching approach takes advantage of these significant adult relationships.
What Should Be Taught?
All curriculum publishers use the guiding concepts of scope and sequence to help them determine the content of what to teach and the order in which to teach it. Their materials are organized in such a way that the essential Bible stories, doctrinal concepts, and theological views are presented in a systematic way. Some publishers strive to make their curriculum as comprehensive as possible, especially given that an age-graded and formally organized teaching format may last only six years for grades seven through twelve. The obvious downside of this strategy is that few if any children or adolescents will attend programs consistently enough to benefit from a cumulative curriculum. This strategy might be appropriate for a math class where attendance is mandatory, but it is untenable in the local church. Youth come and go throughout their adolescence, checking in and out through the years. Some are faithfully involved and do regularly attend, but most, for many reasons, are not as consistent. The other issue with sequential curricula that builds lessons on input from previous lessons concerns new or visiting students. How can a high school junior who has recently responded in faith but who has missed the last several years of teaching participate? We should be able to foster the discipleship process with every teenager no matter what his or her level of spiritual understanding and maturity is.
Should we give up and haphazardly teach whatever we feel is “relevant” at the moment? While that may sound exciting and immediately effective, I don’t believe it is the most beneficial in the long run. What I have found is that systematically teaching through books of the Bible provides the opportunity to address “relevant” topics as they are discussed in context—that is, as Scripture deals with those issues. If your leadership team made a list of all the “hot topics” they feel should be addressed in their teaching, many if not most of those “hot topics” will be covered when Scripture is properly interpreted and contemporarily applied, helping teenagers to discover the truth of God’s Word. The Bible is relevant for today and for tomorrow (2 Tim. 3:16–17).
Many quality curriculum series systematically cover the Bible; a few of them do so in a six-year cycle. Most publishers will send a free copy of their products for your review. David C. Cook offers a free downloadable curriculum evaluation guide that can be used to compare different curriculum. Select what best fits your purposes. Some churches choose to write their own curriculum—a task that takes more time than most people realize in order to produce appropriate material, but can be worth the effort in certain contexts. The advantage of writing your own curriculum is the immediate relevancy to the culture and context of your church and community. A publisher one thousand miles away does not know you, your teenagers, or your context and therefore must produce curriculum that is generic so that it can be used by various churches from different traditions.
Another approach is to anchor the scope and sequence of what to teach with what I call the Discipled Student Profile, or DSP. Ask yourself, “What are the essential qualities or characteristics a disciple of Jesus Christ should demonstrate or exemplify in life?” There are various lists like this available in print, with as many as thirty qualities enumerated, but no one outside your ministry knows your teenagers better than you do. Start by creating your own list of eight qualities that you believe every youth in your church should “own” by graduation, which will constitute your DSP. Your curriculum selection or writing can be guided by these qualities, supporting and teaching them on a recurring basis throughout the years. Basically, you are drawing a target that will help you to focus your aim in everything you teach.
Essential Bible stories, doctrinal concepts, and theological views can form still another organizing approach to scope and sequence. Teens are capable of studying the Bible for themselves and should regularly have the opportunity to dig into Scripture to discover truth. The word doctrine scares some people, but our Christian faith is constructed on doctrinal concepts such as the Trinity, the sinfulness of humanity, and the deity of Christ and his resurrection, to name but a few. Don’t shy away from tackling the important doctrines of the faith. In addition, theology is not a four-letter word, yet many people avoid it like it is. Youth are capable of understanding different theological views and should study them before they encounter other youth and young adults, especially in college, who will challenge their beliefs. There is nothing worse than having your faith challenged by someone who has developed answers to questions that haven’t even entered your mind. Many of our youth are unprepared and unarmed in the defense of their faith because we are no longer teaching them the essentials. A book like Truth Matters, which deals with many of the contemporary challenges to Christianity and is written for youth and young adults, could be used to build confidence in their faith.
Moreover, there has been a renewed interest in the catechetical process for youth. Catechesis, which is simply “oral religious instruction,” has been a mainstay of the church for centuries, especially since the Reformation. Historically speaking, catechesis was used to instruct the young convert in the essential Bible stories, doctrinal concepts, and theological views in preparation for confirmation or baptism. The Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Churches have a very defined content for their catechisms. The mainline Protestant church denominations have specific content in their catechisms as well, perhaps the best known being the Westminster Shorter Catechism. Tim Keller has more recently produced the New City Catechism, which is an update of the Heidelberg Catechism. These instructional materials can be used effectively by an adoptive teacher who deeply cares for those with whom he or she has influence.
Where Should We Teach?
Most of us associate teaching and learning (in a formal sense) with a location—a school, an office, a church. Is content discipleship limited to a church building and during a particular time period (Sunday morning or Wednesday night)? My answer is no, for where we teach is limitless. Following Jesus’s example, the where is less important than the who, the why, and the what. The New Testament presents a picture of the local gathering as the place where worship, instruction, fellowship, evangelism, and service either happen or are fostered, but it does not specify the place (other than “breaking bread” in homes; Acts 2:42–47). In Paul’s letters—written to the churches he planted over the years of his missionary journeys—he instructs the churches on doctrinal and theological issues, often correcting their misunderstanding of Scripture or their behavior toward one another. His letters were meant to be read in the gathering place for the benefit of the entire local body. Where they gathered was rarely mentioned.
Most churches have a formalized educational program for the purpose of teaching the things of God to their members. For youth, the most common program is an age-graded Sunday school. If your church has a Sunday school program, capitalize on it. An adoptive teaching strategy involves every Sunday school teacher and leader for the purpose of influence in teenagers’ lives. These well-trained adult leaders can have a tremendous amount of impact if they will take the time to do so. Youth desire relationships with adults who actually listen to what they have to say, spend time demonstrating the love of Jesus, and genuinely care about their needs and concerns. However, the relationships need to go beyond the forty-five minutes together on a Sunday morning. Often we do not ask enough of our leaders. The spiritual formation of our youth demands more of our time than we are typically willing to give. Therein lies a huge part of the problem.
Other formal settings in which teaching commonly happens are small groups or weekly large group celebrations. Small groups are often held in the homes of church members on a weeknight. This setting is more intimate and less threatening than the church, lending itself to a more relaxed atmosphere and the possibility of more transparency and authentic discussion. Adoptive discipleship relationships can grow strong through a small-group structure. The large-group celebration meetings are still a staple in many churches and, if used properly, can provide the catalyst for promoting the interaction necessary for relationships between adult leaders and youth.
Churches should also take advantage of casual, informal opportunities to teach the things of God and influence teenagers. Summer camps, weekend retreats, and simply being away from the regularity of daily life have been proved to provide the kind of environment in which God clearly works, especially for teenagers (but also for the rest of us). Being out in creation and experiencing the wonder and awe of God’s handiwork (Ps. 19) has the potential to get our attention in ways that buildings do not. There is something about getting away from the busyness of daily life to focus on God’s mercy and goodness for a few days or a week that moves teens to respond in powerful and often life-changing ways. Mission trips, both domestic and foreign, often break the hearts of youth for those who do not know Christ as Savior and for the needs of others in difficult life situations. Adult leaders with an adoptive teaching commitment should consistently seek opportunities to discuss the experiences the teens are having, giving them the chance to debrief and process as they construct their own biblical worldview.
The church is not the only place where discipleship instruction can happen. Since parents have a significant calling to help their children by teaching them how to worship and serve the Lord, they should take strategic advantage of the time available at home with their teens and their teens’ friends. Whether formally or—better yet—informally, they can use this time to focus on the Lord, discussing what it means to know and follow him together as a family. This may also mean opening our homes so that several young people or several families can share lives in the Lord with one another. Using the informal and comfortable settings of our homes in this way, as we learn not only about the Bible but also about how the Bible changes lives and how God is calling us to live as his children, is more in line with the early church than rows of chairs in a building.
The commandment in Deuteronomy 6 involves instructing children at all times of the day in various places and circumstances. We are a mobile society, and parents struggle to have any quality time together with their children. The concept of quality time is intriguing. I have found that scheduling quality time is impossible because it can’t be forced. It happens when people connect at a level that is infused by the Holy Spirit. What I have discovered is that quality time cannot happen unless a quantity of time together is scheduled. Quality time happens in the midst of quantity time. Those special moments we seek to have with our teenagers will happen only if we are willing to sacrifice our time in order to make time for them. Have a conversation with your son while driving to soccer practice about the opportunity to represent Christ with his teammates. Discuss the meaning of the play your daughter is in and the worldview it communicates. Process relevant and important news stories together in light of God’s Word. Make interaction like this a habit and a way of life, not a special occasion. Encourage the parents of youth in your church to change the way they view the time spent with their children. It must be more intentional.
Adoptive teaching can also involve those in the broader community. Many teens have the opportunity to attend a Christian school. There can be great opportunities to connect with godly teachers who desire to model and extend God’s love through the subject matter of the classroom. A number of public school teachers are faithful believers and can be a source of encouragement in a young person’s faith, although the opportunities may be harder to realize given the restrictions of that context. Campus fellowship opportunities and Bible studies can provide the setting for significant interaction with God’s Word, combined with the discipleship influence of the adult teacher/sponsor of the group. Young Life, K-Life, Student Venture, and other similar group meetings (all ministries that seek to reach and teach youth in high school) employ mostly young adults to build relationships with those who attend. These leaders can fill the role of one of the five adults who speak into the lives of the youth.
As King Solomon says, “As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another” (Prov. 27:17). To sharpen and refine a tool, another tool as strong or stronger is used to reshape it. The modeling and teaching of faithful living in Christ takes place in other relationships in the community as well. Any ongoing group function, like a sports team or musical group, can foster the life-on-life opportunities for influence between a Christian coach or band director and a teen. These are often cited as some of the most significant relationships that foster change and development toward following Christ.
When Do We Teach?
An adoptive teaching approach will change the way we think about when teaching takes place. If we don’t confine teaching to a particular location, parents and other adults can have influence on teens whenever they are together and even when they are apart. In Deuteronomy 6, Moses instructs the people of Israel as a group but uses singular pronouns to emphasize the individual responsibility that each family has to teach all the “statutes,” “judgments,” and “commandments” of the Lord. It is clear from the passage that this should be done at all times throughout the day, whenever there is an opportunity. Adoptive teaching means that parents spend lots of time with their children demonstrating a godly life, teaching godly principles, and consistently encouraging them to live “in Christ” (1 Pet. 5:14).
Teaching shouldn’t just happen during Sunday school, small group, or summer camp either. Adult leaders need to be much more intentional about the time that they spend with youth. The proliferation of smartphones for most youth means that connecting with them is easier than at any time in recent history. Social media tools like Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram provide the means to influence youth throughout the week in ways that were never dreamed of in the past. Of course, the technology can be overused and even abused, so appropriate safeguards must be in place to protect both adults and teens. Used effectively, social media can provide a level of accountability, interaction, and influence not seen before in the modern era.
The order in which you decide to teach certain content is the second part of scope and sequence. Rather than a haphazard “What do I want to teach this week?” approach, giving proper thought to sequencing can be useful in organizing your teaching calendar. We should not only be cognizant of the time of day or week when teaching takes place, but we should also think through the times of the year when certain Bible stories, doctrines, and theological views are best presented. The liturgical calendar used by many mainline denominations can serve as a guide for effectively teaching specific and critical aspects of the faith on an annual basis and when they coincide with religious holidays like Christmas and Easter. The Jewish calendar is full of festivals and feasts—holidays and celebrations that constantly reminded the Jewish people of who God is and what he has done for them. Christians should take a page from their practices and better instill a sense of awe and reverence toward our sovereign God by being reminded regularly of all he has done for us.
How Should We Teach?
The idea of teaching usually conjures up the image of a formal setting in which a teacher stands in front of a classroom of students and delivers a boring and lengthy lecture. Thankfully, most teaching situations aren’t as bad as that. There is a scene in the movie Dead Poet’s Society I ask my students to watch each semester that illustrates the difference between what I would call an adoptive teacher, who values mutual relationship and creativity in teaching, and the stereotypical authoritarian teacher, who values total control and rote memory. On the first day of school the film presents several teachers monotonously drilling students and threatening them with severe consequences if they don’t do exactly as instructed. Mr. Keating, played by Robin Williams, walks into his classroom whistling the “1812 Overture” and then walks out into the hallway, inviting the students to follow him. Once gathered around the trophy cases displaying pictures of Welton students from the past, the teacher uses the unorthodox location, a question-and-answer format coupled with the visuals of the pictures, and some conversational monologue to motivate the students to “seize the day.” The three “orthodox” teachers are depicted as engaging only the cognitive learning domain, that which is concerned with knowledge and understanding. Mr. Keating’s teaching methods are more experiential, engaging the affective domain—that which is concerned with attitudes, values, and feelings—in addition to the cognitive domain.
Adoptive teaching is more concerned with life transformation than with information transfer. To be sure, life transformation is predicated on information transfer, but we cannot stop with simply providing information. What the teenager does with the information is vitally important. Caution must be taken to make sure that the application of the Bible does not supplant the content; the two are inextricably connected and necessary to each other. Some published curriculum is so application heavy that very little of what the Bible actually says is taught. Be wise in evaluating and selecting your curriculum to make sure it is properly balanced between content and application.
Parents, as already mentioned, need to intentionally spend quantity time with their teens in order to be available for teachable moments—those quality times that can’t be planned—to happen. The key is being ready to take advantage of the opportunity when it arises (Col. 4:5). These informal teaching moments can happen at any time during the day as we live life together. Parents should also plan to use some formal contexts, like family devotions and family prayer time. Several Christian publishers produce useful materials that can help parents by providing them with guidance on what and how to teach. Lake Pointe Church in Rockwall, Texas, has developed HomePointe, a promising family-centric strategy complete with well-developed materials (many available for free) to help parents “become intentional about building a God-honoring home one step at a time.”
Adult leaders in the church also have responsibility to teach and will typically do so in a more formal setting. In their book Grounded in the Gospel, J. I. Packer and Gary Parrett argue that recent educational methods have failed to produce committed believers who know how to stand firm in their faith and defend their beliefs. They propose a return to a catechetical process in order to rectify this situation. A formal catechesis involves the teacher asking questions, which are followed by a specific answer. The Westminster Shorter Catechism’s well-known question, “What is the chief end of man?” is asked by the teacher, to which the student replies, “To glorify God and enjoy him forever.” This back-and-forth Socratic teaching method can still be very effective today. “At its core, catechesis is a way of helping people understand and internalize the core doctrinal teachings the church has held for hundreds of years, with the hope of transforming their hearts with the power of the gospel. It also serves as a way for people to renew their minds (Rom. 12:1–2) and be ready for every question that is asked about their faith (1 Pet. 3:15).” Will youth learn using this method? That’s a difficult question to answer directly because the teaching/learning process is complicated.
Researchers have developed dozens of niche learning theories, each with a particular emphasis. Not one of them is exclusively correct in terms of how learning best takes place, but each contributes something to our understanding. One field of study that can be helpful if applied in our adoptive teaching contexts is the recognition and use of learning styles to plan instruction. It is helpful to realize that teenagers bring different dominant learning styles, or preferred ways of learning, to the context. It can also be helpful for youth to be aware of their own dominant learning style. Teens perceive and process information best when their preferred style is used. However, they can still learn when the other styles are used and should be helped to grow in their ability to do so.
One of the more common classifications of learning styles is presented by Bernice McCarthy in her 4-Mat System, in which she identifies four learning styles: innovative, analytical, common sense, and dynamic. Innovative learners are primarily interested in personal meaning. They need to have reasons for learning—ideally reasons that connect new information with personal experience and establish that information’s usefulness in daily life. Some of the many learning methods effective with this type of learner are cooperative learning, brainstorming, and integration of content areas. Analytic learners are primarily interested in acquiring facts in order to deepen their understanding of concepts and processes. They are capable of learning effectively from lectures and enjoy independent research, analysis of data, and hearing what “the experts” have to say. Commonsense learners are primarily interested in how things work; they want to “get in and try it.” Concrete, experiential learning activities work best for them—using manipulatives, hands-on tasks, kinesthetic experience, and so on. Dynamic learners are primarily interested in self-directed discovery. They rely heavily on their own intuition and seek to teach both themselves and others. Any type of independent study is effective for these learners. They also enjoy simulations, role-play, and games.
According to this theory, my dominant learning style is analytic (the theory claims that everyone has tendencies in all four but typically has one dominant style). I prefer to learn with more information-based methods like lecture. I dislike interactive and creative methods like drama or artwork. Consequently, when I teach, I’m always tempted to teach the way I prefer to learn and have to remind myself that two-thirds to three-fourths of the youth in my group prefer to learn differently than I do. I have to get out of my comfort zone and use a variety of learning methods to make sure that the youth I teach have an opportunity to really enjoy learning. Dan Lambert has provided a great resource in his book Teaching That Makes a Difference called the “World’s Longest List of Teaching Methods.” He lists 217 ways to teach a concept, from acrostics to writing newspaper headlines. What is the best method to use? There is no clear answer to that question, but it should definitely be a method you haven’t used in the last several weeks. Providing variety in learning methods will greatly help you to stay creative as a teacher and will also help to keep the youth interested. Howard Hendricks, a greatly revered and longtime Dallas Seminary professor, used to regularly quote his friend Jim Rayburn, the founder of Young Life: “It is a sin to bore a kid with the gospel.”
Adult leaders may also need help organizing the teaching period. Total Period Teaching (TPT) is an old concept I learned in seminary years ago. TPT means that every moment, from the time the first teenager walks in the door until the last teenager leaves, is intentionally used for the purpose of teaching and learning. It doesn’t matter what the published start and end times are. There can be no unplanned dead time. The music that is playing, the lighting that’s used, the chair arrangements, those greeting youth as they arrive, food that is provided, games that early arrivers play—everything is done with purpose. Many curriculum publishers will provide suggestions in their lesson materials to help with this.
Curriculum publisher materials also have a suggested flow for each lesson that involves three sections: an introduction, a study of the Bible, and an application. I have found Larry Richard’s system of Hook, Book, Look, Took (HBLT) to be very helpful and easy to remember and teach others. The Hook section is the introduction, which is used to grab the teenagers’ attention. How will you motivate them to want to learn and listen to what you have to say? The best hooks involve every single student in the group. The Book section is when the students, guided by the teacher, actually study the Bible passage(s) that form the focus of the lesson. Every lesson should include reading, observing, and interpreting a portion of God’s Word. The Look section involves the teacher and students identifying together the timeless principle(s) derived from the text of Scripture just studied. What is the general application that applies to all people at all times in all places? The Took section is the conclusion; each teenager chooses a personal application to act on that moment, that day, that week, and so on. This personal application does not need to be, nor should it be, the same for every teenager. The Holy Spirit can and will work in the hearts of each of his children to practically apply the truth of his Word in a meaningful way.
Adoptive Teacher Training
Not many of you should become teachers, my fellow believers, because you know that we who teach will be judged more strictly. (James 3:1)
My church usually does it. Your church probably does it too. It’s August, and the new education year is about to start. That means it’s time for the obligatory teacher-training seminar to kick off the new year. Yea! Except the people who really need the training never come. The church heavily advertises, hires an outside expert speaker, feeds everyone, and even provides childcare—sometimes to great expense. The enthusiastic teachers, the ones who are already trying to be the best that they can be, are there taking notes, filling in blanks, and paying close attention. The expert speaker may actually say something they have never heard before and give them something they can use in their teaching right away. For all the time and effort, there is little return on investment. How much better at teaching are those who attend?
A better way to train teachers is Adoptive Teacher Training. Every church has a master teacher, the one who most people recognize as really good at teaching. Often it is the Christian educator hired by the church to supervise the discipleship programs of the church. That person “adopts” another teacher for six months of team teaching. These two meet together weekly to plan the lesson, brainstorming creative ideas and learning methods. They divide up the lesson section responsibilities and truly team-teach. Some weeks the master teacher teaches while the adopted teacher observes and critiques. Other weeks the adopted teacher teaches while the master teacher observes and critiques. After twenty-six weeks of teaching together the adopted teacher will be well trained in the philosophy of teaching that the master teacher espouses. You now have two great teachers. These two master teachers then adopt two new teachers and train them in the same way for six months. At the end of one year there will be four master teachers. They will then adopt four new teachers and train them for the next six months. At the end of eighteen months there will be eight master teachers. They will then adopt eight new teachers and train them for the next six months. At the end of two years there will be sixteen master teachers. The pattern is obvious. I would trade sixteen master teachers who have been very well trained for two annual teacher-training meetings in a heartbeat. For most youth ministries, sixteen master teachers will meet the teaching position needs. Adoptive Teacher Training takes a commitment of time to each other and to the Lord, but the return on investment is amazing.
The Role of the Holy Spirit
I’d like to offer one last thought, and it may be the most important one. If you are involved in teaching the Bible in any context, then the Holy Spirit is working in and through you. The apostle John writes, “I will ask the Father, and He will give you another Helper, that He may be with you forever. . . . But the Helper, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in My name, He will teach you all things and bring to your remembrance all that I said to you. . . . And He, when He comes, will convict the world concerning sin and righteousness and judgment” (John 14:16, 26; 16:8 NASB).
When you are engaged in making disciples by going, baptizing, and teaching, the Holy Spirit empowers you in a supernatural way, distinguishing what you are doing from any other endeavor. If you feel called and gifted to teach, then step out in faith, knowing that the Holy Spirit will help you every step of the way.
