23. A Call to Adoption
23
A Call to Adoption
Integration of Youth Ministry to the Church
Imagine moving from suburban Chicago, a successful staff member of one of the most influential churches in the country, to a warehouse in Irvine, California. Imagine a highly energetic, widely gifted middle school leader who has never let gender or ethnicity hold her back, even while serving in a predominantly Asian American church. This is April Diaz.
Diaz’s experience and background are unparalleled; she was trained and entrusted by leaders at Willow Creek and Newsong in Irvine, California. Diaz is a mother of three children (two are adopted Ethiopians) and has been a pastor for seventeen years. She is also a writer, a speaker, and a leader committed to the health and equipping of youth workers. She is a sought-after speaker and coach, primarily because she continues to stay close to youth ministry in the local church. We have invited Diaz to offer her take on what it means and looks like for a youth worker to integrate adolescents into the faith family. She is an adoptive mom and has worked for years at a church that has been working hard at adoptive ministry.
As you read this chapter, consider these questions:
in·te·grate
verb
to bring together or incorporate (parts) into a whole
to give or cause to give equal opportunity and consideration to (a racial, religious, or ethnic group or a member of such a group)
to unite or combine
synonyms: merge, unify, fuse, mingle
When I was a young girl, I never imagined that I’d be an adoptive mom. I didn’t dream much of being a mom at all. I dreamed of changing the world, or at least becoming the first female president of the United States of America.
It’s funny how dreams change.
Years into marriage, my husband and I began dreaming of starting a family of our own. After a trip to Kenya, our “Plan A” became solidified: first have biological children and then adopt from Africa. Simple enough. We tried having a biological child the old-fashioned way, which led to an infertility diagnosis, which led to countless fertility treatment cycles. The entire three-year process led us to a broken heart and an empty crib.
As a result, God’s Plan A was revealed: adopt now. With battered hearts still glistening with hope, we began the adoption process.
Nearly five years after our original dream formed, we became parents to two of the most beautiful Ethiopian children the world has ever known. Judah came home forever when he was two-and-a-half years old; Addise was just shy of one year old. Though the four Diaz family members (at that time) shared no biological DNA, we were family. We were becoming integrated as close as flesh and blood can be.
It’s funny how dreams expand. Merely nine months after Judah and Addise became our own, we miraculously became pregnant with our son. (Note: though you may have heard of this phenomenon before, research confirms that less than 10 percent of infertile couples conceive after adoption. Fertility post-adoption is a rare occurrence—a miracle.) Terrified throughout most of my pregnancy of what adding a third child to our family would do to our barely adjusted multiracial and trauma-filled family, we increasingly allowed our fear to be transformed into trust in God’s Plan A for our family.
In just fifteen months Brian and I went from zero to three little ones in our home. Almost instantaneously we were parents to a three-and-a-half-year-old son, a barely two-year-old daughter, and a newborn son. Chaos became a way of life.
Vocationally, when I compare my dreams to God’s Plan A, things haven’t been all that different.
When I became a youth worker at the youthful age of eighteen, I never thought about the goal of youth ministry being “integration into the whole body of Christ.” I didn’t dream all that much about teenagers’ faith beyond high school. I dreamed about how they would receive the gift of salvation, impact their high school campus for Christ, discover their spiritual gifts, experience the power of community, and grow in their faith in Jesus Christ. I had lots of dreams for my students, but I honestly didn’t consider what would happen the day after they turned their tassels on graduation day.
It’s funny how dreams change.
Fast-forward nearly a decade. In my pastoral work with teenagers I started noticing a trend (I can be a slow learner). There weren’t nearly as many youth group graduates loving Jesus as there were when they were in the safety of their family and our youth ministry. A brutally painful trend emerged: there was an alarming percentage of youth ministry graduates who were no longer engaged in a local church or passionately following Jesus. These students (who were now emerging adults) whom I loved for years had left their faith somewhere after high school. They were too old for youth groups but hadn’t found their place within a church family; too many of them were no longer following Jesus like they had when they were in our youth ministry.
Sadly, our church’s statistics were not very different from the national statistics. It’s common knowledge these days that at least 50 percent of adolescents walk away from faith after high school. Six out of seven high school graduates say they’re not prepared for life after high school. For most college-bound students, if they don’t find a local church to be a part of within two weeks of entering college, it’s likely they’ll flail in faith for the rest of their college tenure (Fuller Youth Institutes’ Sticky Faith research captures these realities). The research was mirroring our church’s experience.
Something had to change.
First, the implicit, expressed goal needed to be revised. It was no longer enough for droves of students to be a part of our church’s program. Success could no longer be defined as x number of students participating in our youth ministry. The goal needed to be defined as students following Jesus for a lifetime.
So our church entered into a several-month-long honest, thorough, and discerning assessment and evaluation of our ministry, and the Holy Spirit graciously revealed a “new way” for our local community to raise, equip, and empower the adolescents in our midst. The Lord challenged us with Isaiah 43:18–19:
Forget the former things;
do not dwell on the past.
See, I am doing a new thing!
Now it springs up; do you not perceive it?
I am making a way in the wilderness
and streams in the wasteland.
He reminded us that all was not lost. The God of all time—and now!—is doing a new thing among us that requires a new carrier, a new wineskin to hold the valuable gift. “And no one puts new wine into old wineskins. For the old skins would burst from the pressure, spilling the wine and ruining the skins. New wine is stored in new wineskins so that both are preserved” (Matt. 9:17 NLT; see also Mark 2:22 and Luke 5:37–38).
God’s Plan A was illuminated for our community: the integration of teenagers into the whole body of Christ. With a grief-filled heart and bruised ego still full of hope, our local church began to dismantle the system that systematically abandoned our teenagers by isolating them from the whole body of Christ and began exploring a practical theology of adoption and integration.
If we were going to see more teenagers loving Jesus beyond graduation day, we needed to stop following old models and cease some of the practices that led teenagers to abandon and walk away from their faith. God was doing a new thing in our midst, and we needed to explore a new way of raising up the younger generation.
The New Way: Integration
After our evaluation and discernment process concluded, we determined a clear way for us to move forward. We would get about the business of integrating our students into the life of our whole church. No longer would our teenagers (or children or college students, for that matter) be isolated in their age-specific ministry programs. We would broaden the influence and exposure of our students, including them into the entire church community. “Far too often and for too long, the students’ immediate families and their spiritual family have been downplayed in our efforts to create safe youth ministry havens for teenagers. We believe it takes a village to raise a child, and that village needs to be much larger than a siloed youth ministry.”
In order to become a more integrated community, or a family of siblings, the people of God must align with a few core principles.
Adolescents are a part of the family of the church now. If adolescents are a part of the church today—which means siblings with other members—they need opportunities and environments to participate, explore, and experience relationships within the entire church. They need exposure to spaces outside the walls of the youth room. They need to interact with those who have earned their gray hairs, make decisions alongside middle-aged folks, and, of course, join in the changing of babies’ diapers. They need a vision and experience of what life and faith look like outside the confines of their high school boundaries.
Perhaps one of the reasons adolescents don’t find themselves a part of the church once they graduate is that they don’t really see themselves as a part of the church today. If they participate only in their designated service, in their assigned room, with predetermined leaders, why should it surprise us when they can’t find their way into service, worship, and community beyond their youth group years?
What if we expanded their vision—and ours!—and included them in the life of Christ, community, and cause no matter their age?
God is at work in our whole church. Scripture is clear that out of the mouths of babes come praise and wisdom and strength (Ps. 8; Matt. 21:16). When older followers of Jesus Christ have the humility and take the time to listen to a sixth-grade boy’s thoughts about creation or a tenth-grade girl’s questions about the Sermon on the Mount, God’s transformational activity materializes. When we open the space for a gifted middle school student to run the soundboard for our Sunday services, we affirm the gifting of the Holy Spirit in her life. When a worship pastor takes the time to invest in a younger musician, teaching him the techniques and heart of worship, the church is better. When an older person reveals their insecurity about a particular text to a high school student who engages with her, the body is built up.
The question needs to turn from “How do we tolerate ‘them’?” to “Where is God at work in our church, and how do we join him?” John 5:19 illuminates how Jesus engaged the kingdom: Jesus did only what he saw the Father doing. If our churches and communities are going to become more integrated by adopting teenagers into our lives, we have to recognize where God is at work in their lives and join God’s activity there. Knowing that God is at work with our youngest members of the body and that we have something to learn from them fosters humility. This mind-set results in far more than the recruitment of small group leaders for the youth ministry. It’s a paradigm shift that opens the church’s eyes to the transformation at work all around us.
Youth pastors and workers are not the sole experts of adolescents. The professionalization of youth ministry hasn’t been an entirely bad thing. We place a certain value on teenagers when we develop college degrees and church staffing positions for the purpose of caring for and developing teenagers. Undoubtedly, the rapid growth of youth ministry in the last generation is correlated to the professionalization of youth ministry.
However, one of the unintended consequences of this movement is that youth pastors and youth workers have become the academic authority on adolescents. Parents released their “I’m the expert on my child” card, and professional youth pastors willingly took it from them. The rest of the church abandoned their responsibility to spiritually form the younger generation.
The emphasis changed from “caring relationship” to “trained expert.” Perhaps we forgot that even without training or degrees “love covers a multitude of sins” (1 Pet. 4:8) and that there’s no substitute for parents—whether familial or spiritual.
I’m not suggesting a “throw the baby out with the bathwater” approach. Yes, we need adolescent experts among us who help us to understand youth culture and adolescent development, especially in a rapidly changing environment. But the rest of the church needs to increase their engagement with teenagers so that teenagers know their place in the larger body of Christ.
With these core beliefs in hand and heart, integration becomes more than possible. It becomes probable and essential. There is no argument that middle school and high school students have developmentally appropriate needs that are different from each other, not to mention different from a ten-year-old, a thirty-year-old, and a sixty-year-old. Those developmental needs must be considered, honored, and met in order for healthy development to continue into adulthood.
However, instead of looking for youth ministries to become the be-all and end-all for students, what if we focused on the developmentally specific actions that only a youth ministry can provide and looked to the whole church to meet other needs of the students? What if our faith community’s approach was to provide developmentally specific experiences within an intergenerational context? If our mind-set shifted only a few degrees, the long-term trajectory shift would be enormous. Adolescents would be seamlessly integrated into the whole body of Christ without being ignored, displaced, or isolated because of their specific developmental needs.
The Centrally Related Elements and Issues
As churches move toward becoming more integrated, consider the following ways, discussed in Redefining the Role of the Youth Worker, to focus on the developmental and holistic needs of adolescents without cutting off their connection to the whole community:
Some time ago I was at our church’s Sunday morning worship gathering, headed off to pick up my then-five-year-old son, Judah, from his classroom. As I walked through the door of his classroom, I quickly paused and instinctually took a step backward as I saw what was happening. Tears filled my eyes as I watched the scene unfold. Judah was sitting at a short, little table with his fellow adopted Ethiopian friend, Hallelujah (yes, that’s his birth name), a couple of other five-year-olds, and three high school students—Devin, Stephanie, and Abby. Together they were playing a made-up game around the table, laughing and joking with one another. A few other teachers were in the room: a Caucasian adoptive dad, who was leading alongside his Chinese middle school daughter, as well as Stephanie’s mom and elementary-age sister. The room was full of life, energy, and connection. The presence of love was palpable.
In that holy moment, the Lord affirmed a few truths to me. First, adoption is not easy. Whether you physically adopt a child or spiritually adopt another person into your faith journey, it will be messy. You won’t all look the same or carry the same bloodlines, but you might as well. You are family. You are family because that’s what the redemptive work of the Holy Spirit does for believers.
Second, it’s important to realize that discipleship matters. The investment you make in another person is always worth it. Before I was Judah’s mom, Devin, Stephanie, and Abby were students in my middle school spiritual leadership group. For two years I spent my time, energy, and prayers investing into their spiritual lives and leadership gifts because I believed in them—both in that moment and into the future.
As I stood in that doorway with tears spilling down my cheeks, I sensed the Father showing me that the pursuit of integration is worth it. Just as that adoptive dad and Stephanie’s mom had invested in their own kids, they were now doing the same with a room full of lively five-year-olds. Just as I had invested my life into Devin, Stephanie, and Abby, they were now investing in my son. Multiple generations were beautifully relating with one another. Faith was being integrated, woven into each person as they loved, served, and played together. I’m confident the kingdom came that Sunday morning, a little more on earth as it is heaven.
That scene in Judah’s classroom reminded me again of God’s word to the Israelites in Deuteronomy 6 when the Lord commands his chosen people to instruct their children at every opportunity, in any circumstance, with whatever truth is required. Yet we often misinterpret this passage as God’s word to parents. The Lord wasn’t exclusively instructing parents to do this for their children. He was calling forth the entire community—“all y’all”—to raise up the younger generation. It would require the entire village, all of the Israelites, to ensure that the next generation would know the great “I AM.”
That same directive was at work that Sunday in Judah’s classroom. “All y’all” was in action in that moment. But the village instructs my children at times and in ways I don’t even know. Only a few weeks ago I was with a dozen middle school students who serve in our children’s ministry. I had stepped in that day for our children’s pastor, who facilitates a monthly leadership meeting with these students. I hadn’t met several of the sixth, seventh, and eighth graders, and yet when I asked them whether they knew my kids—Judah, Addise, and Asher—they were quick to tell stories and squeal about them. I couldn’t conceal a silly grin as they exclaimed about what they had said or done in class with my kids. Joy exploded in my heart as I saw integration at work in our community.
Other Perspectives on Integration
Like Me, Not like Me
An often-voiced challenge to integration is that adolescents need a unique place to call their own. I couldn’t agree more. Needing to be with others “like me” is a basic human instinct. Affinity is a powerful force. I love to be with others who look like me, talk like me, are in similar seasons of life as me, and engage in similar passions and interests. This need is particularly strong in adolescence. One of the three primary tasks of adolescence is affinity. Teenagers are constantly asking the question (if not consciously, then subconsciously), “To whom and where do I belong?” Therefore, fostering places of connection and belonging is crucial for adolescent development.
Yet I also know from personal experience and studying the Scriptures that this doesn’t eliminate my need to be with others not like me. Many of the greatest transformations and times of growth in my lifetime have come from being with those not like me in age, race, socioeconomic status, season of life, religious beliefs, and family of origin. I also know that coming alongside teenagers to help them find affinity and a place of belonging with those who are not like them can be a powerful force. While the American church has done an incredible job of setting up small group ministries, age-specific ministry, and even entire churches around those who are “just like me,” Scripture gives us another picture.
The question we need to ask when we consider integrating teenagers into the life of our churches is, “Who is my neighbor?” The story Jesus told of the Good Samaritan illustrates this truth. (My lead pastor, Dave Gibbons, at Newsong Church in Orange County, California, does an incredible job of communicating this story in his book, The Monkey and the Fish.)
One day an expert in religious law stood up to test Jesus by asking him this question: “Teacher, what should I do to inherit eternal life?”
Jesus replied, “What does the law of Moses say? How do you read it?”
The man answered, “ ‘You must love the LORD your God with all your heart, all your soul, all your strength, and all your mind.’ And, ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’ ”
“Right!” Jesus told him. ”Do this and you will live!”
The man wanted to justify his actions, so he asked Jesus, “And who is my neighbor?”
Jesus replied with a story: “A Jewish man was traveling from Jerusalem down to Jericho, and he was attacked by bandits. They stripped him of his clothes, beat him up, and left him half dead beside the road.
“By chance a priest came along. But when he saw the man lying there, he crossed to the other side of the road and passed him by. A Temple assistant walked over and looked at him lying there, but he also passed by on the other side.
“Then a despised Samaritan came along, and when he saw the man, he felt compassion for him. Going over to him, the Samaritan soothed his wounds with olive oil and wine and bandaged them. Then he put the man on his own donkey and took him to an inn, where he took care of him. The next day he handed the innkeeper two silver coins, telling him, ‘Take care of this man. If his bill runs higher than this, I’ll pay you the next time I’m here.’
“Now which of these three would you say was a neighbor to the man who was attacked by bandits?” Jesus asked.
The man replied, “The one who showed him mercy.”
Then Jesus said, “Yes, now go and do the same.” (Luke 10:25–37 NLT)
The Western church has inaccurately identified our neighbor as someone who is “just like me.” We have built churches and designed ministries, including youth ministry, around descriptors and strategies that aim at a specific demographic. But this is not what we see in Jesus’s story.
The Jewish people were at the pinnacle of first-century Roman society. They were the revered ones, the religious and socioeconomic elite. Samaritans were the opposite. In this culture, Samaritans were half-breeds and misfits—half Jew and half gentile, which didn’t make them half as good as the Jews. It placed them at the bottom of the social hierarchy; it was more like they were half human. Samaritans were pushed to the margins of society because they weren’t really like anyone else. And yet this is the illustration Jesus chooses to bring to life the question, “Who is my neighbor?”
It is the Samaritan—a marginalized, isolated, and misunderstood member of society—who steps into relationship with the societal elite. Jesus makes a shocking and painstakingly clear point concerning how we are to interact with one another. Not only are we to walk toward someone who is not like us, but we are also to sacrifice our resources and pride for their personal benefit.
I can only imagine how our world would be different if the church were to walk toward and sacrifice our resources on behalf of teenagers, those who are not like us. The time has come for the church to once again respond to Jesus’s question, “Who is my neighbor?”
“It Takes a Whole Village to Raise a Child”
This popular African proverb advocates a powerful theological truth: my kids are your kids. My kids need you. I need you to help me grow my kids to be all God’s created them to be. My husband and I cannot do this alone. We were parents only for about five minutes before we realized we’d need an army of people to support us in the calling of parenting our children.
Visit a smaller American church or a community somewhere halfway across the world, and you’ll see integration at work. In many of these faith communities, they have recognized the truth of this proverb. Due to the perceived lack of resources in smaller American churches, our brothers and sisters have been “divinely forced” to use the whole community as they train up the younger generation. Church budgets haven’t allowed them to hire a youth pastor with the latest training or an expert, veteran youth worker. So they have “resorted” to the community to care for and love their teenagers. I have heard leaders from smaller churches or urban ministries lament that they can’t hire a youth pastor or additional paid staff to serve teenagers. But I want to commend our co-laborers for how they have intentionally—or even haphazardly—integrated teenagers into their faith communities. The ways in which they are investing in teenagers encapsulate what our larger churches or megachurches want more of—more care from the whole church, more parental involvement, and a long-term view of faith development. The silos that many churches must tear down in order to bridge the generational gap (by building relationships that cross the divide) simply aren’t a problem in those smaller contexts. Smaller ministries are resource-laden in this respect and are leading the way.
I was invited to speak on this vision of integrating teenagers into the life of the whole church at a conference a few years ago and after I’d finished speaking, a key influential leader in Latin America came up and immediately hugged me. I wondered what exactly the hug was for! And then he whispered in my ear, “This is what the church in Latin America has been doing for years. You’re right on. Thank you!” He quickly walked away, giving me a “thumbs up” and performing a little victory dance. I chuckled and thought, “We have so much to learn from the global church.”
To the smaller American churches and global church, thank you for your faithful service and leadership—especially when you were told you were doing something wrong, that you needed larger crowds, fancier technology, flashier gizmos, or more “fun events” on your calendar. Please forgive our large-church arrogance, and please continue to speak up so that we can learn from your heritage.
Don’t Throw the Baby Out with the Bathwater
I’m not sure I believe in balance. My friend Mark Oestreicher often says, “Balance is something you swing through on your way to the other extreme.” Integration is not swinging to the other extreme and eliminating youth ministry. Integration is not firing your youth pastor and mindlessly absorbing teenagers into the whole church. This is not about an “all-or-nothing” approach to working with teenagers.
It’s quite the opposite. Where traditional youth ministry (over the past couple decades) has hired out the care and spiritual development of teenagers to the youth department of the church, integration is about bringing people together for greater care and spiritual development. Integration is about increasing the engagement of the whole church because we deeply love the younger generation and desire relationship with them now and in the future. Integration is affirming that we are better together than we are apart.
I believe youth ministry is critical for the future, but it must be far more integrated and far less segregated if we are to see generations of students rise up to radically love God and his kingdom.
Building Blocks and Customized Development
So, if the church is to integrate students but not “throw the baby out with the bathwater,” what’s the best response? My suggestion is a both/and approach, which capsizes a one-size-fits-all model of youth ministry. We need to both integrate students into the life of the broader church whenever and wherever possible and provide the building blocks they need for their long-term spiritual formation. This requires customized spiritual formation that pays particular attention to adolescent brain development.
Most of the time, a baby needs to learn how to crawl before she learns how to walk, and she needs to walk before she runs. A baby needs to babble before words are uttered and sentences are formed. But not all babies learn to crawl, walk, and run at the same age, just as toddlers don’t all speak in sentences by their second birthday.
The same is true for spiritual formation. For example, people need to receive the gift of salvation before they can be baptized or receive spiritual gifts from God. Teenagers need to doubt and question their faith before it becomes their own. Therefore, as we look to the developmental changes in adolescents, we need to put the proper building blocks into place so that the next block can be laid solidly on that foundation. This demands that we be thoughtful and flexible concerning teenagers’ development. Families, churches, and young ministries need to be mindful that as we integrate students they are each in different places, requiring unique next steps for their holistic development.
Conclusion
It’s time for the church to go back to God’s Plan A for raising up the coming generations to fully know, passionately love, and radically follow Jesus for a lifetime. This is not a new idea. It’s an ancient way of life that desperately needs to be reclaimed “for such a time as this” (Esther 4:14).
In my immediate family and now in our church family we echo the belief of the Israelites’ way of life, repeating God’s commands “again and again to [our] children.” We “talk about them when [we] sit at home and when [we] walk along the road, when [we] lie down and when [we] get up” (Deut. 6:7). We desperately rely on our village to help us in this mighty calling because we are painfully aware of our inadequacies and limitations. Most of all, we pray. We pray our kids will experience a Romans 8 kind of love that will tether them to their Creator.
Isn’t this the prayer of us all? The more we can individually customize the spiritual formation of every young disciple while communally integrating and attaching them to the spiritual family of God, the more depth and breadth and length of faith we will see in the teenagers we love. As each disciple, young and old, considers not only the interests of themselves, but also the interest of others (Phil. 2:4), we will see the kingdom of God come on earth as it is in heaven because our teenagers will be introduced and integrated into a way of life that is greater than anything the world has to offer.
Just as we have been adopted into the family of God, so we have the privilege and calling of spiritually adopting adolescents to be fully engaged participants in our faith communities. May the miracle of spiritual adoption and this fullness of life become increasingly true in your immediate family, church community, spiritual family, and beyond. Yes and Amen.
