Chapter 9 of 38

Chapter 6 The Myth of the Perfect Youth Ministry Model

Chapter 6 The Myth of the Perfect Youth Ministry Model

Chapter 6

The Myth of the Perfect Youth Ministry Model

Chap Clark

The exasperation of the executive pastor was driven by his inability to think beyond the “proven” models:

“Show me where this works!”

“If we are to keep young people involved in the church and if we are to renew our congregations, we first must acknowledge that many of our current forms of youth ministry are destructive.”

—Mark Yaconelli, “Youth Ministry: A Contemplative Approach,” The Christian Century (Web version), April 28, 1999, 2.

I was in the early stages of consulting the leadership of a large church on the need for a theology of community and family life as they made decisions regarding where the ministry should go (a term I now know means “how we programmatically create those ministries that we ‘do’ in church”). The frustration level gradually crescendoed when I offered a picture, or model, of what I thought would be an appropriate course of action for this particular church given this particular time in this particular place. It was clear from the ensuing discussion that neither this executive pastor nor most of the rest of the staff and lay leaders present were even slightly interested in having to create a ministry model that fit just for them. They wanted to take what someone else had done—and done successfully—and copy it.

The truth is, however, that a local church has little in common with a company that produces or sells products that can be franchised regardless of setting or environment. And there is more to church life than can be formulated through a careful analysis of demographic or socioeconomic factors. The church is the visible, tangible expression of God’s living community in the world. It is made up of ordinary, broken people who gather together in order to worship, love one another, connect, relationally share their lives, struggle with how to incarnate faith in a relatively hostile world, and be equipped and set free to serve Jesus Christ by loving those he loves. In every community and with every group of believers the expression of this family looks different, at least a little. To create an exact replica of “what works” in a different community, or family, is neither advisable nor even possible.

Ponderable

What convictions do you bring to a discussion on youth ministry models? The biases you carry will affect the way you hear others talk and write about ministry, and will ultimately impact your ability to grow beyond your personal journey.

This chapter constitutes a call to the church to be more theologically and sociologically committed to God’s unique movements in different places, with different people, and at different times than the staff and lay team described above. Models are helpful in that they enable us to see why and how others have expressed their corporate calling in their unique setting with their own unique people. But because the intent of this book is to push youth workers to think beyond the simple question of what works in order to learn how to think, act, and live theologically, it is important to let go of the need to copy and duplicate, and become men and women of prayerful thought and careful theological analysis and reflection. The goal of this entire section, then, is to enable readers to see how other youth ministry pioneers, influencers, and leaders have sought to bring the mandate of Christian mission to the adolescent community so that youth workers can use this history and these methods and tools to sculpt a unique ministry for the people to whom God has called them.

This chapter describes the power of youth ministry models (why it matters to know about, understand, and discuss other models), the history of models in youth ministry, the common threads of youth ministry models, a theological template for assessing the appropriateness of a given model in a given ministry context, and then closes with a plea to avoid the temptation to blindly apply carte blanche any model that may receive the most attention in any given year.

The power of a model

Every Christian leader must develop a balanced view of ministry models to create the kind of church community that has the flexibility to change with the environment and stay true to the biblical intent of the church. This means that our ecclesiology—our understanding of the theology of the church—must not always drive any programmatic expression of ministry but also be open to new forms of expressing our understanding of what it means to be the church. These models do and should come and go over time and place.

As we attempt to take the timeless truth of Scripture and contextualize it into our unique ministry setting, models are powerful in three ways: they are developed out of a response to a unique setting and need, they are organically shaped and evolve over time, and they give us hope that the gospel works in a wildly changing environment.



Models are developed out of a response to a unique setting and need.

Every model, whether involving sweeping changes or prescribing minor adjustments, began with someone asking important systemic, structural, programmatic, or strategic questions in the light of a given need or setting. There was always a first step in the development of a model. The pioneers of well-known ministry models seem to the rest of normal humanity as super-disciples who had an inside track on culture and ministry effectiveness. The assumption is that the inventor or initiator of a well-known model somehow came up with his “formula for success” in an error-free ministry laboratory. But in reality every single new idea for ministry that ultimately becomes packaged as a model began when a church or group decided that something needed to be a bit different. Almost no one sets out to develop a new, comprehensive model for everyone else to follow. Few start-up pioneers began with a vision designed to change the world—they simply set out to change their world. The seeds were planted in response to a unique need and setting, and the founding group moved on from there.

This is important because today most ministry leaders either do not trust themselves to create something from scratch in response to a given setting or need, or are not even willing to take the time to ask the hard questions. It is simply easier to trust the “experts.” But when the model was being formulated, the experts were not yet experts! They tended to simply ask some important questions and respond accordingly.



Models are organically shaped and evolve over time.

After a new idea emerges and begins to take root, it is almost never a full-blown model. What we end up reading or hearing about is actually the result of many starts and stops, several large and small decisions and programs, and a great deal of experimentation. It is important not to be intimidated by the successes and marketing of those who peddle universal models of ministry. A model is often more stumbled upon than strategically realized, and rarely do we get to see the dark side of the evolutionary process. A new youth ministry strategy, for example, may imply that the entire ministry is based on students being set free to use their gifts and relationships. But what looks like, at least on the outside, the definitive model for a new paradigm of youth ministry fails to recognize or even mention a 10-year history of healthy adult involvement and leadership in the lives of the student leaders. In this scenario, this one fact could be the linchpin of the entire model, and yet, because of the complexity of history and setting, it is underplayed by the model’s architects out of ignorance, focus, or streamlining of information.

Ponderable

What’s the best youth ministry model or program you have seen or heard about? What made it good? What about it caused you to be impressed, excited, or motivated to imitate it?

In developing the most appropriate ministry strategies, programs, and techniques, it is vital to recognize that even the most well-known and respected model pioneers went through evolutionary stages in developing their models. This is the same for all of us, for environmental, relational, historical, and other factors will always make tweaking, experimenting, and changing course a fact of life. To be wed to the “finished product” of the popularized, defined model is to deny the implicit nature of model development itself.



Models give us hope that the gospel works in a wildly changing environment.

The best thing about models is that they constantly provide us with hope that the gospel matters and is relevant regardless of the cultural or environmental setting. Throughout church history, leaders devoted to one another in community have produced incredibly creative and culturally relevant ways to express the truth to a world that Jesus Christ died to redeem. Models remind us, whether or not they work for everyone today or tomorrow, that God is faithful in moving his people to be creative, passionate, and involved in bringing God’s love, light, and salt to those he loves.

The history of models in youth ministry

In three major youth ministry publications, Trinity Christian educator Mark Senter III has described several different “models of youth ministry.”1 Senter lists a variety of models, most of which are technically currently employed. Nowhere does he provide the reader with the pros and cons of various models, but rather he has chosen to simply describe each as a viable alternative for the doing of youth ministry. Some examples of the models he describes are Christian school, competition, discipleship, and ministry. What Senter has done in the chronicling of the history of the youth ministry movement is to detail how wide and diverse the notion of youth ministry is—or at least has been. To even include the Christian school in the history of youth ministry models, for instance, is nonsensical to some and yet to others is absolutely essential.2 And in these chapters Senter has not discussed every model of youth ministry. When all is said and done, there are dozens if not hundreds of models of youth ministry actively functioning around the world.

As Senter describes these models, he does not advocate taking a singular model and ignoring all others. The lesson this youth ministry historian has for us is to learn from models and utilize their strengths as tools and resources as we develop our own unique ministry expressions. As Senter states, “Youth ministers most frequently take programs from a variety of possibilities and form them into a ministry package.”3

Perhaps the greatest youth ministry influencer of the 1980s and ‘90s is Duffy Robbins of Eastern College. In his book on foundational youth ministry, Youth Ministry That Works,4 Robbins advocates a funnel concept for organizing a youth ministry program. Borrowing from the work of Dennis Miller, he offers the following funnel,5 where programming is not so dependent on a model per se but rather on strategic categories of ministry focus:

Figure 6.1. Duffy Robbins’ funnel concept

In this template for youth ministry programming, Robbins states:

Ponderable

What is your experience with outreach programs? Do they really attract and win those students not at all into religion? Or is it possible that even the most creative and winsome church-based programs will have a hard time attracting those adolescents that see the church as irrelevant at best or offensive at worst?

Perhaps there needs to be another level—one that recognizes the reality of a huge population of youth who will not likely respond to traditional models of youth ministry.

For a youth program to be well-rounded, accomplishing the purpose for which it was designed, there must be some type of formal or informal programming that will meet the needs of kids at each of these levels of commitment. There needs to be Come Level programs, geared to the student who is ‘not into religion at all,’ and there needs to be programs that will motivate the forward progress and growth of those at the Grow, Disciple, and Develop Levels.6

These two contributors to the field of youth ministry have provided the most comprehensive thinking and programming strategy to date. Both Senter’s and Robbins’ contributions are invaluable to understanding the basic task of parish youth ministry.

The common threads of youth ministry models

I believe that Mark Senter’s contribution to the discussion on models is to see how others have viewed ministry focused on adolescents over the past 100 years. Even in his most recent chapter on models where he lists a section on the new models,7 however, there are obviously many ways to view the task of youth ministry. Senter’s work helps us to recognize that there are many viable alternatives to youth ministry other than the one that is most current with a given group, organization, church, or denomination.

Duffy Robbins, on the other hand, has most influenced the future development of healthy, creative, and workable youth ministry in offering a way of thinking about the youth ministry task (especially from the perspective of the local church). Robbins’ (and others’) notion of the funnel allows a youth ministry team to do exactly what Senter recommends—pick and choose the best of historical and current models in a comprehensive and holistic way. By applying a template from which to assess and deliver new programmatic, structural, or even philosophical ideas, a youth ministry can alter the forms of ministry without having to dismantle all history and structure.

In following up on Robbins’ work, over the last few decades of youth ministry there have emerged two foundational components of youth ministry programming. The first is a formula for making programmatic decisions in response to a defined mission statement and identified set of student needs. The second component is exemplified by the funnel of programming. Making use of the general idea of Robbins’ funnel, where students are programmatically and strategically encouraged to move downward (in the model), the Funnel of Programming offered herein provides a theological framework for deepening a student’s level of interest in—and therefore, hopefully, commitment to—a deeper walk with Christ.

There are three basic pieces to choosing programmatic and structural responses to the task of youth ministry—mission, needs, and resources.



Mission statement

The first and in some ways most important piece of the formula, spotlighted by Doug Fields in Purpose-Driven Youth Ministry, is the driving theological mandate of the ministry, or the purpose of the youth ministry task. Fields (and his senior pastor Rick Warren, Purpose-Driven Church) offers youth workers the “five purposes of the church” as the starting point for ministry to adolescents. This view has rightly received wide acclaim around the world in youth ministry circles. And yet, while wholeheartedly in agreement with the basic premises of the argument Fields brings, it is possible, and at times even advisable, to nuance and even more pointedly focus a mission statement than may be assumed from his strategy. Nonetheless, whatever the statement of mission you choose, it is imperative that this mission be all-encompassing enough to define and decide all youth ministry programs, strategies, and structures. A mission statement gives a reason for doing what you do.

Ponderable

What are some of the mission or purpose statements you have seen or heard about? Have you ever been around a youth ministry program where one actually made a difference?

For the purposes of the formula presented here, a mission statement is a compelling phrase that enables all decisions concerning structure and programming to be filtered. A mission statement, for example, that includes students’ assimilation into the larger body of Christ will push the ministry to structure itself and therefore program accordingly a strategy to make this happen. If a church already has a mission statement, it is imperative that the youth ministry either maintain the exact same statement or be so connected as to naturally flow from the general (church) to the specific (youth ministry).

Felt needs, real needs

Felt needs are those issues or areas that are described by adolescents as being important or significant. Example of statements that reflect felt needs:

  • I can talk about—
  • I worry about—
  • I think about—
  • I care about—
  • I often experience—
  • Real needs are those issues or areas that adolescents may or may not recognize as important or significant, but that supportive adults can recognize. Example of statements that reflect an outsider’s view of real needs:

  • Your life shows me—
  • Your world reflects—
  • The Bible describes (or dictates)—
  • Your future demands—
  • Your life needs—
  • Needs of constituency

    The next aspect or piece of the formula for making programmatic and structural decisions is assessing the needs of the people the ministry is designed to reach. When the issue of needs-based youth ministry is discussed, often there is little discussion beyond the surface of the kinds of needs adolescents experience. But it is important to delineate between the felt needs of adolescents and the real needs. Felt needs are those issues or areas that can be described by an adolescent community as being important or significant. Real needs, on the other hand, are those issues or areas that an adolescent community may or may not recognize as important or significant but an adult supportive community can recognize. Felt needs are comprised of issues like sexuality, dating, friendship, and choices. Real needs, conversely, could be related to such issues as studying and knowing the Bible, the intent of God related to authority, and the value of intergenerational connectedness. Both real and felt needs must be considered when designing a youth ministry structure, program, and strategy.

    In addition to delineating between real and felt needs, there are also three levels to both types of needs that must be considered. The first level to be discerned involves the general needs of students. This is where cultural analysis—movies, television, Internet, music, etc.—fits in. Books, statistics, lectures, and seminars often tend to describe young people in unequivocal homogeneous “blocks.” This is a helpful source of cultural and developmental analysis that must be considered, but it is not the only source of information that must be considered. It is just the first.

    Figure 6.2. General needs of adolescents

    The second area of consideration deals with the specific needs of the group of students you are attempting to reach. Often when youth ministry or culture leaders write a book or speak, they are offering general trends and attitudes among adolescent culture, usually confined to Caucasian, middle to upper-middle class adolescents, and even then in sweeping, generalized terms. But it is important to remember that because middle adolescents cluster in small groups more than ever, there are subtle yet determinative differences between groups of students. And this is especially true when one factors in economic, geographic, and ethnic differences, to name but a few.

    In determining the specific needs of students, it is important to keep in mind any area or issue that may influence a ministry’s ability to fulfill the mission to that particular group. For example, the majority of the students you are working with may come from relatively stable homes, and even 50 percent are home schooled. This information must come into play as you make programmatic and structural decisions. Conversely, if you have a group where 70 percent come from divorced homes, this will alter how you go about your work and planning. The general needs give you an overall picture and must be taken seriously, but an analysis of and commitment to discerning the specific needs of your students will allow you to be more focused and more personal as you attempt to design a program that truly impacts adolescents.

    Figure 6.3. Specific needs of adolescents

    There is one more area of needs to be addressed—one that is commonly overlooked in day-to-day youth ministry programming and strategic planning: the individual needs of each student impacted by the ministry. Even if a group is largely influenced by home schooled students, to use the above example, there will inevitably be a few who come from homes where parents are largely uninvolved. While it is difficult if not impossible to consistently program and structure a ministry to meet every student’s needs, any ministry team who seeks to touch adolescents’ lives in the name of Christ must be aware of and concerned about the individual issues involved. There must be an educated and strategic analysis of each students’ unique needs and issues, or they will be lost through the cracks.

    Figure 6.4. Individual needs of adolescents

    Resources of constituency

    The last aspect or piece of the formula for making programmatic and structural decisions is assessing the resources available that will affect the community’s ability to meet the students’ needs according to the mandate of the mission. This requires a broader redefinition of the term resources. In this formula for programmatic, structural, and strategic decision making, resources refers to “anything that will positively or negatively impact a community’s ability to fulfill the stated mission according to the needs of students.” In other words, a resource may not be something wholly tangible, or even measurable, but it is very real.

    For example, the amount of money a church or group has available will have an impact on the programmatic and strategic decisions that have to be made. If a group decided that a key mission mandate was to introduce students to Christ in a way that was relevant and attractive to them, and the conclusion was reached that according to the needs of students it is important to be taken out of the intensity of their cultural environment, then a possible programmatic solution could be to take kids to camps where they relationally encounter the gospel in a socially unencumbered setting. On the surface this is as clean and orderly a process as possible, thus offering a rationale for the status quo.

    The danger of this process, however, is that the final ingredient of the formula—assessing the resources of the community—is left out of the equation. In this scenario the programmatic decision to take kids to camp is decided before any strategic analysis of the resource appropriateness of the programmatic solution. Once decided, it would be in this case necessary to eventually go backward and most likely try to find the money to pull off the program, after the fact. The formula we are advocating—assessing the needs of the constituency, then determining any and every connected resource that will have an impact on the programmatic decision—enables the creative decision-making process to consider all of the factors before a decision has been reached. This is the process where effectiveness as well as creativity has the best chance to flourish, for decisions are not blindsided by lack of strategic consideration and appropriate data collection.

    Possible resources to consider are wide-ranging. Everything from money to facility, and numbers and maturity of staff to expectations of the power structures, needs to be considered at this stage. Sometimes this is very tangible, like money or facility. At other times this is more difficult but equally as important, like with institutional or programmatic history, maturity of staff, or expectations of parents and church or organizational leadership. But every resource stone must be turned over to determine the most appropriate course of action for any ministry program, strategy, or structure.

    After the resource analysis has been thoroughly accomplished, then programmatic decisions can be adopted and strategic concerns addressed. Thus the formula looks like this:

    Figure 6.5. Component one—formula for programmatic decisions

    There is one additional major aspect to making strategic and programmatic decisions. As mentioned above, it is vital to make choices according to the mission purpose, needs, and appropriate resources that will affect the ministry. But it is also important to recognize that students arrive at every program in very different places—developmentally, spiritually, and emotionally. For a variety of reasons, every individual student goes through unique stages of spiritual development and religious interest, and in some cases they change from week to week, especially at the upper levels of the Funnel. These initial attitudes, which are deeply personal and immensely powerful, are ultimately the most important direct factor in a youth ministry program’s ability to touch a student at any meaningful level. Every veteran youth worker knows this intuitively, yet few take the time to systematically address this fact of adolescent ministry.

    In synthesizing the wide variety of youth ministry programs and models of the last 40 years, there has emerged a general consensus that it is important to employ a diversity of programmatic options according to the interest level of the students who we are trying to reach. For example, if we genuinely want to strategically and programmatically care about the proverbial—

  • Joshua, a slightly hyperactive, disinterested freshman boy who is forced by his stepfather to attend the youth ministry program;
  • Samantha, an overly enthusiastic sophomore who knows more Bible than the senior pastor but has few friends; and
  • Jon, who has always enjoyed church but as a senior feels a bit out of it with no real place to be known and to serve,
  • we must program differently for different levels of student interest and commitment. In other words, we must scratch where they itch, instead of trying to place the round pegs of the students that God has called us to work with into the square hole of a prepackaged model of ministry. This is the assumption driving the Funnel of Programming.8

    The Funnel of Programming represents a synthesis of the most effective, historically viable, and biblically appropriate of contemporary youth ministry models. The Funnel identifies five levels of programming necessary to adequately cover the needs and desires of students in any sized youth ministry program. The five levels of student involvement and interest are Outreach Level, Entry Level, Community Building/Discipleship Level, Intimate Relationship Level, and Mentoring (or one-on-one) Level.



    Outreach level

    It is important to note that youth ministry Outreach Level attempts, programs, and events are distinct from Entry Level events in that an Entry Level adolescent is defined as one who would at least show up to a church or labeled “Christian” event or program. He or she may not be interested, connected, or involved—the student may in fact be

    Figure 6.6. Component two—the funnel of programming

    somewhat hostile—but at least that person is somewhat comfortable with the sociological environment of the church or “Christianized” setting. There are millions of adolescents in North America alone who would not, if they could help it, intentionally attend a church-sponsored event. These are Outreach students, and it is a rare Entry Level program or event that will attract or even entice them. The key words for Outreach Level programming are: going, relationships, time, investment, and adventure. These describe the essence of the task of reaching out to the severely disinterested student, the one who will not, for one reason or another, come to any kind of Christian meeting.

    “Do we know the poor in our own family? Maybe the members of our family are not hungry for a piece of bread, maybe they’re not naked or homeless, but do any of them feel unwanted or unloved?…

    The Missionaries of Charity care for the crippled and unwanted, the dying and the hungry, the lepers and the alcoholics. But the poor come to all of us in many forms. Let us be sure that we never turn our backs on them, wherever we may find them. For when we turn our backs on the poor, we turn them on Jesus Christ.”

    —Mother Teresa, “The Poor in Our Midst,” New Covenant Magazine (January 1977), 17.

    Entry level

    Entry Level programming is focused on caring for the student who comes but is disinterested, bored, or disengaged. The key words in this level are: Christ-centered, winsome, quality, relevant, and relational. These five words provide a template for creating Entry Level programs and events. Adults spending time pursuing these students on their own “turf” (called contact work) and going where they live and move to develop trusting relationships, is a crucial point of ministry to Entry Level students. Messages that lift up Jesus Christ in a way that engages the mind and heart of the less involved is also key. When an Entry Level student leaves a program targeted to her, the response sought is something like, “That was okay, even though it was church!”



    Community building/discipleship level

    The third level of programming in the Funnel is the Community Building/Discipleship Level, which is geared toward those students with a genuine and dynamic relationship with Jesus Christ and a desire for further growth in their faith. The greatest weakness of contemporary youth ministry programming is that there is rarely an effort to make a distinction in programs and events between Entry Level and Community Building/Discipleship Level students. Most programs, even those with multiple weekly meetings, will try the shotgun approach to discipleship—some prayer, but not too much; some Bible study, but watch for the kid who’s bored; some crazy fun, but keep the interest of the seniors—and youth ministry becomes a vain attempt at hitting every need and thereby meeting very few.

    Ponderable

    In your own experience have you seen a program or event that was able to connect equally well with Discipleship Level students and with severely disinterested Entry Level students?

    Do you agree or disagree that different meetings should have different goals for different interest levels of students? Is there a middle ground?

    If a church has two weekly programs, one should generally be more slanted to the Entry Level student, and the other to the Community Building/Discipleship Level studnet. Not that either will be ignored when they participate (Community Building/Discipleship students should also enjoy the focus and intent of the Entry Level programs), but there is clearly a time when those who love God are given the opportunity to function as a community. The key words in this level are: Christ-centered (but more in the spirit of “following the one we love,” rather than “check this God/man out” Entry Level focus), worship, prayer, intergenerational, church-wide, commitment, and Bible study. These seven concepts provide a template for creating Community Building/Discipleship Level programs and events. Contact work remains crucial, for teenagers and adults need to know they matter away from the program. But Community Building/Discipleship students are also expected to show almost as much relational initiative and investment to the community as the adult leadership.



    Intimate relationship level

    The fourth and fifth levels of programming in the funnel are the Intimate Relationship and Mentoring Levels. These levels of programming are geared toward those students with a genuine and dynamic relationship with Jesus Christ and a desire for further growth in their faith, as in the Community Building/Discipleship Level. These last levels take two more steps in helping the students attain a more intimate experience of faith while still under the focus of structured youth ministry.

    Intimate relationships, usually programmed in some form of small group ministry, can take on a variety of expressions, but the most important component is an adult directly related with a small number (from three to eight or so) of students. This is the level on the Funnel where student leadership fits—because every student leader should still have an adult who maintains a discipleship focus on the students involved. For example, from a student’s perspective, a program may have three student leadership teams (worship and music, welcoming, and activity) and three other small groups. From the adult leadership perspective, you actually have six small groups that all function a little differently, but still care for students in a more focused way than in Community Building/Discipleship Level programs where individuals can get lost.

    The key words in the Intimate Relationship Level are accountability, safety, warmth, friendship, and intimacy. These five words provide a template for creating Intimate Relationship Level programs and events. Again, contact work remains crucial, for the small group leader is now a key figure in the lives of those students.



    Mentoring level

    The Mentoring Level is most often an informal expression of the small groups. A leader of small groups can easily function, and probably in most cases should, as a mentor of sorts. In this case a mentor is simply an older friend who knows and loves the student. This leads to the ultimate goal of the funnel of programming—every student in the program develops an intimate, growing relationship with Jesus Christ and has at least one adult who has walked through this journey with her. This is after an adolescent’s segue into the larger church community. As a student is known and cared for by an adult, she is relationally drawn into the larger body via the adult. This is the ultimate goal of any youth ministry program—mature, healthy young adults who, once they have graduated from high school, are relationally and structurally assimilated into the fellowship of the body.

    One note: applying the funnel of programming as a strategic framework for other programmatic or structural templates allows for any model to be employed at a given time in a given environment or setting. The model chosen is not ultimately what is important. What does matter is that students are taken seriously where they are in their theological and sociological journey of individuation. The Outreach Level students need friends who will pursue them; Entry Level individuals need programming that is surprisingly relevant and friendly; and the Community Building/Discipleship Level students need to be taught the truth, led into deeper commitment to and community with the greater body of Christ, drawn in to intimate relationships, and ultimately mentored by an adult who is invested in them as an individual. This is what the Funnel of Programming is designed to facilitate.

    Remember, the funnel is not another model of youth ministry. It is a sociological, developmental, and foundationally theological template that enables youth workers to bring young people into the “fold of faith” in a way that honors, respects, and nurtures them while they go through this relatively wild adventure called adolescence. The following represents the theological foundation for not only the funnel of programming but for the task of youth ministry itself.

    Though far from exhaustive—the following chapters of this section will provide different angles on this same theme—this brief theological look at the five levels of student interest provides the youth worker with some biblical and theological categories that will keep the youth ministry focused.



    Outreach level (Colossians 4:5, 1 Peter 3:15, and 1 Thessalonians 2)

    The apostle Paul not only encouraged the followers of Christ to “be wise in the way you act toward outsiders; make the most of every opportunity” (Colossians 4:5), he lived it. In his letter to his friends in Thessalonica, he reminded them that he and his team loved them “so much that we were delighted to share with you not only the gospel of God but our lives as well, because you had become so dear to us” (1 Thessalonians 2:8). This was the method of Jesus and the resultant method of Paul. “You know brothers, our visit to you…” begins the first verse of this same chapter, and that is what God did for us. In the Incarnation, Jesus visited us, not allowing our disinterest or behavior to hold him back or cause him to question his love for us. In Paul’s ministry, he visited those who did not invite him in order to bring the visible, tangible reality of the gospel to those who were not seeking (for they did not yet know what their heart sought). In fact, seeking is the job of the church, not the job of the disinterested.

    And when we go to the world of disinterested adolescents, Peter reminds us to go with “gentleness and respect.” The gospel is to be presented as a peace offering, a beautiful fragrance, delivered to those who do not yet know or care about God’s love for them in a way that communicates God’s tender mercy and unfailing kindness. Any programmatic or strategic attempt to reach out to the least-of-these disinterested lost sheep that is not completely gentle, kind, peaceful, and respectful denies a biblical theology of evangelism and outreach.



    Entry level (Mark 10:13-16)

    Entry Level students are by definition disinterested to a point, but are still for some reason willing to show up. A career car salesperson knows the principle associated with this fact—showing up is 95 percent of the sale. Because these students are willing to at least walk through the door, they are thus communicating to the church, at some level, that they want to connect with it. Again, these are not Outreach students, for the true Outreach students would almost never show up, unless they were tricked or coerced.

    Theologically this is where the developmental passages of Scripture come into play. For adolescent ministry, an Entry Level student by showing up has taken the first—and biggest—step in the process of connecting to the community of faith. They have done their part, now (in their mind) it is time for us to do ours. They are developmentally as much children as adults (even high school students) and are often “hanging back” trying to determine if they fit, if they matter, and if anyone authentically cares about them. Contrary to popular opinion, the Entry Level student is far less concerned with programmatic quality and content as she is with relational safety and meaningful connectedness. More often than not, “Boring!” means “I’m not safe!”

    When the little children were brought to Jesus, and the disciples rebuked the people bringing them, the Incarnate Word became indignant. “Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them,” he told his disciples. So often our programming and strategies are more about the size of the event, the quality of the program, the content of the lesson, and the consistency of positive comments, that we lose sight of the reason for youth ministry—not to hinder the little ones from coming to Jesus! For the Entry Level kid to show up means that we have them right where God wants them, placing themselves in the vulnerable position of leaving their world and coming to ours. Every-thing we do, say, and offer must be carefully designed and orchestrated in a way that will whisper to that student, “You are safe here, you are welcome. The King has made you his special guest at the wedding feast!”



    Community building/discipleship level (John 15, Galatians 5)

    Students considered to be at this level of interest have displayed a willingness to be a part of communal Christian spirituality. This means that there is an expressed desire to know and connect to Jesus Christ (John 15:1-8) and to know and connect to others who share this common faith. This is what Paul means when he says that “the only thing that counts is faith expressing itself through love” (Galatians 5:6). Faith (pistis, also translated trust or belief) is the act of the will and the heart of putting our complete trust in Jesus Christ. This level student demonstrates a desire to connect to the vine, to trust Christ, and to authentically follow him (in developmentally appropriate ways) via his relationships. This is where spiritual disciplines, Bible study, and instruction are functionally inserted. This is the level where relatively deep and relevant contextual and interpretational discussions take place. It is in this setting where Christian community is developed, and where singing becomes a real expression of worship and praise.

    All too often Community Building/Discipleship Level students are left behind in a youth ministry program because there is simply too much energy devoted to trying to get, or keep, Entry Level students’ attention. The adolescent serious about Christ, however, deserves a focused ministry that will enable the interested, even committed, student to grow to new depths of faith. Every youth ministry program designed to bring young disciples into the “adult” faith community must find ways to develop the two central callings of the Christian faith—a meaningful, rich connection to Christ and committed relationships within the diversity of the family of God.



    Intimate relationship level (Colossians 3:13, Galatians 6:2)

    The biblical record consistently calls God’s people to intimate relationships. “Bear with each other” and “Carry each other’s burdens” imply a knowing and a significant involvement with one another. In this culture, this does not come naturally—or easily. Students, especially high school students, intuitively long for intimate relationships, but have very few resources to enable that to happen at any deep level.

    Generally small groups is the way we tend to address this need. But typically small group programs become essentially that—programs. Instead of being strategic and theological tools created to train young people how to connect at deep levels with others, they become one more ministry to manage. Regardless of the look of the youth ministry, God calls them (and therefore us as leaders) into long-term, authentic friendships with others in the body. This is a mandate of the family of God.



    Mentoring level (Titus 2:1-8; 2 Timothy 1)

    The final stage of the Funnel is to plan for each student to be personally known and loved by an adult. This most easily is a leader involved in the facilitation of the Intimate Relationships Level, but it can be anyone in a congregation or community, so long as the relationship is based on leading—by modeling and relationship—the adolescent to a deeper dependency on Christ. In Titus this is expressed as a direct admonition to older women to lead younger women, and also an implicit instruction for older men to model godly living, presumably to the younger members of the body. In Timothy we get a glimpse of the relationship that Paul had with his son in the faith. These are both examples of the Mentoring Level, and it fulfills the old adage, “Christianity is not taught, it is caught.”

    The myth of the perfect model—a plea

  • Pray, both individually and corporately. In every setting and with every decision, make Jesus Christ the Lord of your program, and not anyone else’s idea of what you should do. History, tradition, resources, expectations, and advice are all helpful and good in making large and small strategic and programmatic plans and decisions. But the Scripture is clear that God’s people called to leadership must devote a great deal of time and energy to prayer.
  • Be theologically grounded and committed. First and foremost, youth ministry must be a theological task (that is the basic purpose of this book). Avoid any program, strategy, or decision that you are not thoroughly convinced is the most theologically appropriate course of action you can determine for your unique situation. Whether it is in fundraising, camps and retreats, mid-week programming, student leadership, or special event planning, make sure that every person involved in your ministry can articulate the theological rationale for the strategy.
  • Stay open to change. The most dangerous youth worker is the one who thinks he has arrived at knowing how to do the task of youth ministry. Whether it is resilience in the way to do it or loyalty to a specific model or a subtle arrogance due to previous successes, it is the kiss of death to theologically and sociologically sensitive youth ministry. God is always moving—and always working—regardless of the cultural shifts and changes. We must be fresh in our openness to changing the way we bring the gospel to adolescents.
  • Trust in the Incarnate God, not proven models. Jesus Christ is the Lord and he is therefore Lord over methods, strategies, programs, and models. As long as he reigns on the throne of your ministry, his kingdom will come!
  • ↑ Back to top

    ↑