Chapter 8 of 38

Intro The Tasks of Practical Theology: Reflecting on Present Practice

Intro The Tasks of Practical Theology: Reflecting on Present Practice

Intro

The Tasks of Practical Theology: Reflecting on Present Practice

Kenda Creasy Dean

The youth rally that wasn’t

It seemed like such a good idea at the time. Charles Atkins, a.k.a. Christian hip-hop artist Manchild, came to seminary convinced that God had called him to a ministry of music with urban young people. So when one of his seminary professors urged him to perform at a Christian youth rally in a downtown Washington, D.C., city park, Charles cut short a stint in Latin America to do it.

The youth rally was the brainchild of the resident bishop of a large denomination, who estimated attendance would reach 5,000 people. He envisioned an event that would attract young people, especially unchurched teenagers in the neighborhood, and he turned the planning over to denominational youth staff in the area. Their job was to construct an event (in two months) that would appeal to teenagers in the city. Meanwhile, the bishop incorporated the youth rally into the schedule of a large church conference meeting at the same time in a nearby hotel, focusing on the church’s care of young people. The bishop arranged for a parade of teenagers and adults to march together from the conference hotel to the park, where the 90-minute rally—complete with music, food, and speakers to attract passersby—was in full swing.

That, at least, was the plan. When Charles arrived in Washington, D.C., the night before the event, he met the denominational youth director at the conference hotel. She seemed a little apprehensive. There had been a few additions to the schedule for tomorrow, she said. First came the parade, as planned, followed by some local church youth choirs, dancers, and a steel drum band. Then some local officials might be dropping by; the bishop’s office had invited several political leaders to speak, so they would need platform time, too. Then there was the motivational speaker, hired at the last minute to appeal to non-Christian youth with a non-sectarian “inspirational” message. Oh—and there were three or four local church rock bands that wanted to play at some point during the rally. The sermon would follow the bands, delivered by the seminary professor who had invited Charles, and then Charles would perform as the featured musician for the day.

Any questions?

“Yes,” said Charles. “How long is this rally supposed to last?”

“Well, it might take close to two hours—a little longer than planned, but then again, the political speakers had been a surprise.”

The next day, the rally unfolded as predicted. The sunny lunch hour parade of people streaming from a Washington, D.C., hotel to a park attracted lots of attention, including the press, and 30 minutes later the park was full of adults as well as youth.

The youth choirs, dancers, and steel drums were magnificent. The first political leader’s message for voters was a little too long; the press shot some footage and cleared out, as the crowd thinned a little. The next civic leader spoke to parents, a little longer than necessary; youths began to grow listless, and the sun ducked behind a cloud. The third politician addressed moral decay for much longer than seemed wise; teenagers began to fade visibly from the edges of the park and the dark clouds began to cloak the sky.

Two hours and 45 minutes into the rally, when the secular motivational speaker ended his energetic pitch with his a cappella solo of “The Impossible Dream,” thunder rumbled ominously. Most people started ducking for cover. Youth had vanished. The seminary professor was up to preach next. She called to the front platform any youths “still in the park”—there were about 20 of them—and prayed with them, then asked if they minded very much if she just cancelled the sermon. (They didn’t mind.) One of the local rock groups performed, to “warm up the crowd” for Charles. Charles couldn’t tell if the crowd looked sympathetic or just pathetic. The sky looked downright menacing.

Finally, Charles took the stage. The youth rally designed to attract 5,000 people had dwindled to about 20 teenagers and a handful of polite adults who (you could just tell) hated hip-hop music.

Now, if you were Charles, what would you do?

Reflecting on present practice

As a practical theologian, you would already be trying to make sense of the context of the youth rally. You would draw on the social sciences from the perspective of your theological convictions in order to describe the situation for ministry God had laid before you that Saturday afternoon. You might learn something from this description that modifies your theological rocks in some way, but for the most part you have simply been intent on understanding the context that calls for Christian action in this particular case.

But your theological perspective would also help you enter the second task of practical theology: reflection on present practice in youth ministry. You need to understand the youth rally both in light of the psychological, social, and historical climate of urban life, and in light of the way ministry is actually happening there (for better or worse). Some of this reflection happens outside the situation in which the action occurs; Charles had given careful thought to the basic purpose of the event, coordinating his music selection with the text of the sermon. But some amount of this reflection on Christian action also has to take place “in traffic,” as the concrete situation unfolds. In short, the second task of practical theology requires reflecting on current Christian practice in this particular case. In the second task we ask, What are we doing that faithfully represents the gospel in this concrete situation? While the first task of practical theology (Understand) wants to know What’s going on in this concrete situation? The second task (Reflect) asks, What is it that we’re doing in this concrete situation—and specifically, what is it that we’re doing as Christians? The reflective task explicitly seeks to identify the practices of Christian life and ministry in a given situation, and begins to consider some of the theological assumptions that guide those practices.

Putting reflection to work

Reflecting on the practice of youth ministry at the youth rally, for instance, reveals a number of things that bear watching. In the first place, despite the rhetoric of the occasion, the rally was really not intended as youth ministry. As it turned out, the real planning for the event resided in the bishop’s office, where the decisions to include political leaders and to invite the press were made. The bishop’s office envisioned an event about youth, while the denominational youth director envisioned an event for and with youth—two objectives that competed in planning the rally.

Theologically, the bishop’s office saw the event as a form of prophetic witness, and viewed its media-savvy spectacle as consistent with biblical norms of sensational prophetic practice. The denominational youth director, on the other hand, saw the rally as a pastoral event, designed to reach young people who don’t normally have an opportunity to hear the good news preached in their own backyard. To her, the presence of political speeches derailed the event’s significance for youth themselves.

The sequence of the rally also revealed theological assumptions behind the event. Scheduling the political leaders first might have highlighted the prophetic nature of the event, seizing an opportunity for the church to speak to public policy about youth. However, following the political speeches with a lengthy secular “inspirational” message made the event seem tailored for public consumption, not proclamation of the gospel. The conference planners assumed that straight-up Christian practice—namely preaching and praise music—would be too “churchy” (whether that meant radical or boring is unclear) to appeal to youth without church connections. Putting the secular aspects of the rally up front had the effect of preempting the sermon and the featured Christian music, the two parts of the rally that explicitly linked the event to Jesus Christ. When the seminary professor ditched the sermon—deferring to haggard attention spans as much as to the weather—the de facto preemption became official.

Now it’s your turn

In this section of the book, you will reflect on current practices of youth ministry that respond to the psychological, sociological, historical, and cultural contexts to which we have been called as youth ministers. After Chap Clark reminds us that there is no such thing as a perfect model for youth ministry (chapter 6), you can take a look at what it might be like to approach youth ministry through evangelism (chapter 7, Terry McGonigal); through families (chapter 8, Mark DeVries); through Christian practices (chapter 9, Mark Yaconelli); through student leadership (chapter 10, Dave Rahn);

through critical consciousness (chapter 11, David F. White); through community (chapter 12, Kara Eckmann Powell); and through innovation (chapter 13, Soren Oestergaard and Simon Hall). These approaches are suggestive, not exhaustive. Chances are, your own approach to youth ministry is an amalgam of many of these approaches, as well as others not featured here.

As always, bring your theological rocks to the discussion as you enter this second task of practical theological reflection. Your experience of youth ministry and your theological priorities will predispose you to favor some approaches over others. As you begin to locate your own practice of ministry in these pages, notice how your preferred approaches to youth ministry underscore theological rocks you find important. Some of the approaches outlined here may bother you, as well. Wrestle with why this is the case: do they omit or compromise theological convictions that matter greatly in your ministry with young people? These conversations are the first steps toward giving your own practices of youth ministry theological mooring. In other words, they will help you defend your pastoral choices along the lines of your convictions about who God is and how God works in the world, rather than as reactions to peer pressure, parent pressure, pastor pressure, or simply the pressure to stay relevant.

Dancing in the rain of God

Charles had come a long way to be at this rally. He placed a high priority on the doctrine of vocation; he wanted to model for youths needing a compass in their lives his own clear sense that God had called him to use his gifts for ministry. He wanted them to know that God has called each of them to use their gifts for ministry as well. Charles believed God wanted him to promote the gospel through music to teenagers in the cities. “This wasn’t exactly what I had in mind when I came here,” he thought as he took the stage, scanning the weary rally audience for the remaining 20 youths. But they were youths, and this was the city, and God had given him a gift for music they could identify with. So, Charles made a decision. He brought the 20 youths from the audience up on the stage beside him, and he taught them to dance. And as the downpour began, it found Manchild singing hip-hop onstage, surrounded by a group of relieved and happy teenagers, dancing for Jesus in the rain.

↑ Back to top

↑