Intro The Tasks of Practical Theology: Detecting Our Convictions and Evaluating Our Practices
Intro
The Tasks of Practical Theology: Detecting Our Convictions and Evaluating Our Practices
Kenda Creasy Dean
Greetings to the Faith Church congregation:
As I begin to write this, I’m overwhelmed by God’s goodness and faithfulness for the opportunity [to potentially serve as your youth pastor]. Please allow me to take a moment to introduce my wife Hannah and myself to you…I have volunteered and worked in various realms of youth ministry for over 10 years now. Though my philosophy and vision for ministry may have evolved over the years, my passion for youth ministry and Christ is still what makes me tick.
As I sit here, I’m wondering about each of you and what it will be like filtering through all this information about Hannah and me. In particular, my medical condition may have sparked lots of questions that I hope you will find satisfying and correct answers to in these next weeks. However, I would like to offer you some facts up front. Several years ago I was diagnosed HIV-positive. There was a short period during my late adolescence in which I made some poor choices that resulted in me contracting HIV. I’m now 31 years old, and those situations occurred many years ago.
Hannah and I realize that we didn’t have to disclose this information, but I wholeheartedly believe that living openly with my medical condition will allow me to be a completely authentic person, free to fully live for God and for others. My medical condition doesn’t define me, but it’s a part of me. My ministry is about the gospel of Jesus Christ, not about HIV/AIDS, but I do feel a responsibility to live openly so that God may be glorified in the fullness of what I might bring to Faith Church…
Friends, in closing, I’m fervently committed to the gospel of Jesus Christ and to the service of the church. The greatest gift in my life is my loving relationship with Hannah, for whom I would live and die. I wholeheartedly believe that the richest part of what I have to offer a congregation is grounded in the emotional, mental, and spiritual health I strive for in these primary relationships. I’m a man of my word who strives every day to reflect the integrity and truth of the Christian life. I look forward to the possibility of continuing the tradition of excellent youth ministry and being part of what God is doing at Faith Church.
Peace in Christ,
Josh McCormick1
This is an excerpt from a real letter submitted by a candidate for a youth ministry position at a wealthy, mid-sized congregation on the West Coast. After several interviews, the nominating committee concluded that Josh was the candidate God had prepared for Faith Church, and they moved his recommendation as associate pastor for student ministries.
Meanwhile, Josh and Hannah agonized over going public with a secret they had kept since before they were married: Josh is HIV-positive.
Josh’s diagnosis five years ago seemed like a death sentence, but he had responded well to drug therapy and in many ways had beaten the odds. Although Josh lived under careful medical scrutiny, he and Hannah were convinced, not only that he had a future in youth ministry, but that he had a future, period. They had told the other pastors at Faith Church about Josh’s illness midway through the interview process. The pastors’ reactions were overwhelmingly supportive. The senior pastor urged Josh to tell the nominating committee. Just before the committee made the recommendation to hire, Josh and Hannah flew to the coastal town where Faith Church is located to tell the committee personally.
It was gut-wrenching weekend both for Josh and Hannah and for members of the nominating committee, who had grown to love and admire them both. The nominating committee wanted some time to think it over. In the interim, the committee consulted countless medical and legal experts to assess the risk of having an HIV-positive pastor working directly with teenagers. A few weeks later, they voted unanimously to recommend Josh as their new youth minister.
Faith Church’s polity required a congregational vote to ratify the committee’s recommendation before they could actually hire Josh. Everyone knew that revealing Josh’s medical condition could jeopardize his nomination, especially in a position working with youth. Several lawyers frankly advised Josh and Hannah not to disclose Josh’s illness, fearing legal ramifications. In particular, the question “How did you get HIV?” seemed both invasive and inevitable. It had already come up in the nominating committee.
Josh considered skirting the question if it arose again; he had no legal obligation to share this information, and the senior pastor advised him to just tell people it was none of their business. He drafted a letter that essentially said this, but then destroyed it. Why didn’t it seem right to withhold this personal detail?
Finally, Josh concluded that everything he stood for as a Christian—not to mention as a youth pastor—grew out of a life lived in the freedom of God and in trusting God against the odds. All of his references spoke about Josh’s rare integrity, his deep self-knowledge, his ability to inspire trust. How could he be free for honest ministry or be trustworthy with other people’s pain, without full disclosure now? He and Hannah prayed feverishly over their decision. Just before they flew out for the final interview—where they would meet the entire congregation—he addressed an envelope to Faith Church, slipped in this letter, and dropped it in the mail.
Detecting our convictions and evaluating our practices
Practical theological reflection is the responsibility of faith communities as well as individuals. Brought up short by something that jars our accustomed practice of Christian life, we are forced to look for new ways to live out our faith that communicate the gospel more faithfully. The news that their top candidate for the youth ministry position was HIV-positive shocked Faith Church’s leadership. They immediately invested in better understanding the concrete situation calling for their Christian action. They reflected deeply on their Christian practice in calling a new youth pastor: had they left room for the Holy Spirit in this process? Had they prayed genuinely? Had they searched the Scriptures for guidance? Had they invoked their minds as well as their hearts in making this decision? Was calling Josh to serve at Faith Church God’s will or just their will? While nothing about the nomination process seemed to contradict Faith Church’s understanding of the gospel, the committee wondered how they might communicate this gospel more clearly—to both the congregation and the community—if they called a new youth pastor known to be living with HIV.
Thus they entered the third task of practical theology by setting out to detect their theological touchstones for calling a new pastor and to evaluate their practice of ministry according to those touchstones. This is different from evaluating a practice according to whether it works or not. There’s nothing inherently wrong with something that works—but in practical theology, we are primarily concerned with the radical congruency between God’s action and our action, which means we need to find out whether our normative practices of ministry are faithful. Does our standard way of doing business in youth ministry reflect who God is and how God works in the world—or does it subtly (or not so subtly) reflect something else? In this task of practical theology, our theological rocks become quite explicit, for we use them as plumb lines against which we evaluate our Christian actions, touchstones for defending—or dismissing—practices of ministry with young people.
Putting detection and evaluation to work
Evaluating Christian practice requires us to detect the theological standards by which we measure these practices. This is more straightforward than it sounds. Until recently, for example, much parachurch youth evangelism considered the magnet kid strategy normative for building youth clubs. The magnet kid strategy sought to attract to the club the most popular young person at school, on the premise that this student would draw other youth to the club as well. As a strategy for building Christian youth clubs, the magnet kid strategy worked exceptionally well.
However, when evaluated by standards of faithfulness rather than standards of effectiveness, the magnet kid strategy raised serious questions. For one thing, Jesus called “the least of these” as his first disciples. Whether Peter, James, John, or any of the rest of the Twelve would have qualified as magnet kids is highly questionable. Furthermore, the magnet kid strategy tended to suggest that young people should come to Christian youth clubs in order to follow the magnet kids, not Jesus Christ. As parachurch organizations matured and their leadership became more theologically selfa-ware, the magnet kid strategy began to receive less attention in leadership training manuals.2
In the case of Faith Church, the nominating committee first affirmed two theological convictions: God can overcome impossible odds, and God seemed to be calling Faith Church to stand as a witness to this kind of God in the midst of their affluent community. Hiring Josh seemed to underline both of these convictions. Even while Josh lived secretly with HIV for five years, God had used him in ministry despite incredible odds, and—ironically—God now seemed to be calling him to serve in a community where external beauty and economic comfort often forced hardship underground. Given those theological starting points, the nominating committee wondered: Should we hire Josh because we have faith in Josh? Or should we hire him because we have faith in God?
The committee decided that medical grounds were insufficient cause to withdraw their endorsement of Josh. And they could find no other reason not to hire him. He seemed a natural fit in both their church and their community. His youth ministry credentials and references were impeccable, surpassing the committee’s highest hopes. The person who asked, “How did you get it?”—as Josh immediately surmised—really wanted to know about his moral character, leading Josh to disclose in brief form the circumstances around his contracting HIV.
In short, when they held up their procedure for calling Josh alongside their practice and mission as a congregation, the nominating committee concluded that hiring Josh reaffirmed their belief in an awesome God, and renewed their sense that Faith Church was called to be a witness—to the community, to Josh, and now to the broader church that struggles with issues related to HIV. On these grounds, they defended Josh as their candidate of choice, and their procedure for arriving at this decision.
Now it’s your turn
The third task of practical theology (detecting our convictions and evaluating our practices) asks, Given our theological commitments, how can we defend the norms of youth ministry in this concrete situation?
The point here is not defensive—to counter charges against our practices of youth ministry against charges levied by complaining parents, queasy congregations, or hyper-critical higher-ups. The purpose of the third task of practical theology is evalua-tive: In which of our normative practices of youth ministry can God’s truth be heard most clearly? Which practices have the most static? Which practices are evidence of a radical congruency between God’s action and our action?
The next four chapters offer examples of theological starting points that make a difference in the way we defend what we do in youth ministry. Starting points are not ending points; theology is an interconnected discipline, and one doctrine leads to another and another and another. Emphasizing one theological theme as a foundation for youth ministry does not necessarily exclude others.
But we do have to start somewhere, and where we begin makes a difference in how we proceed. Each of the following authors has chosen a theological starting point for youth ministry—repentance (chapter 14, Robin Maas), grace (chapter 15, Rodger Nishioka), redemption (chapter 16, Darrell W. Johnson), and hope (chapter 17, Evelyn Parker). They demonstrate how to use such theological rocks as benchmarks, standards by which our practices of youth ministry may be defended because they are faithful, and not merely effective.
An avalanche of welcome
Prior to Josh’s final meeting with the Faith Church congregation, the nominating committee circulated a booklet introducing Josh to every member of the congregation. It included a letter from the nominating committee, theologically defending the committee’s procedures and why they viewed Josh as the person God had called to this position. The booklet included a summary of Josh’s résumé, a review of his credentials, and excerpts from Josh’s recommendations pertaining to his admirable moral character. A schedule of opportunities to meet Josh and Hannah on their visit to Faith Church was included.
The booklet also included Josh’s letter to the congregation, followed by a lengthy question-and-answer section on HIV and AIDS, tailored to the concerns of Faith Church. The nominating committee had developed the Q-and-A section in consultation with numerous experts in the medical, counseling, and pastoral fields (who were cited in the document). Furthermore, the booklet assured the congregation that their concerns would be taken seriously, listing many opportunities for members to raise questions, with obvious care taken to acknowledge anxiety and protect anonymity:
We encourage you to consult one of the following resources for answers to any questions you may have:
- Educational forums are being offered to provide information and answer questions.
- Answers to questions we anticipate congregation members may have are provided [in this booklet].
- The senior pastor and associate pastor will be happy to meet with any congregation members regarding questions or concerns [phone numbers and e-mail addresses listed].
- National HIV/AIDS Hotline, operated by the Centers for Disease Control and the American Social Health Association, that answers questions on a 24-hour, anonymous basis [phone number and email address listed].3
- A box will be available on the church office counter. You may deposit your questions in the box along with your name and phone number. You will receive a phone call with a response to your question.
Finally, the booklet contained enthusiastic letters of endorsement from both the senior and associate pastors.
Josh was overwhelmed by the document’s generosity. By the time Josh and Hannah arrived at Faith Church, an avalanche of welcome awaited them. So did a unanimous vote of approval and an invigorated congregation, convinced that with Josh as their new associate pastor, God would lead them into a new era of ministry.
