Chapter 14 Theological Framework for Youth Ministry: Repentance1
Chapter 14
Theological Framework for Youth Ministry: Repentance1
Robin Maas
Christ and the adolescent: piper or prophet?
There is a legend, told now as a charming nursery tale, that must chill the heart of every parent who reads it. It is a story of seduction and enchantment; a story in which children disappear—-forever.
You know the tale I mean. It comes to us in the form of a long narrative poem by Robert Browning, “The Pied Piper of Hamelin.” Most children today probably encounter bowdlerized versions—retellings that may try to mitigate the horror. (One such retelling asserts that all the adults of Hamelin, and not just the city fathers, were greedy and ungrateful, implying that these parents deserved to lose their children.) What you may not know is that the legend is rooted in an actual historical event, recorded by some ancient, unknown hand on the city walls of Hamelin, Germany.
Something awful happened in Hamelin. We will probably never know precisely how it happened or why. But it did happen and that, I believe, is why this story is at the same time so strangely fascinating and repulsive. The writing is on the wall. It happened.
Just what does the writing say? That on July 22 of the year 1284, some 130 children were led out of town by a Pied Piper and were lost in (not on) Koppen Hill.2 Some believe the Piper was an agent of a Bishop Olrnutz who, in the late 13TH century, drew many of Hamelin’s youth to Moravia, where they were permanently resettled. Others claim that the children were kidnapped by landowners to replace serfs who had died in recent epidemics. A more elaborate theory proposes that the children of Hamelin suffered from the purple fungus ergot, which grows on rye grain during rainy seasons. Anyone who consumed the contaminated grain was likely to be afflicted with severe muscle spasms and hallucinations. The poison acted to constrict blood vessels, causing burning sensations in the victim’s hands and feet, could be relieved by strenuous physical activity, such as dancing; hence, the hiring of musicians, such as the Piper, to play for the afflicted so that they might dance. This explanation is a particularly poignant and intriguing one, since ergot is the source of the modem drug lysergic acid diethylamide, or LSD—the poison of choice for many of today’s youth.3
Another even more interesting hypothesis connects the legend to the bizarre and infamous children’s crusade, which occurred in the year 1212. Close to 100,000 youths—most of them boys around the age of 12—set off from both France and Germany to recapture Jerusalem from the Muslims by entirely peaceful means. Against all reason, rejecting all adult pleas to the contrary, these idealistic but deluded and ignorant children—led by other idealistic, ignorant, and deluded children and accompanied by a motley crew of both well- and ill-intentioned adults—set off to put right what the adult crusaders had gotten wrong.
While the majority of clergy and almost all other adults looked askance at the project and tried to dissuade the young idealists, there were some, including the father of the boy who led one of the German contingents, who found either personal or professional advantage in encouraging the unlikely project. The lad who led the French contingent claimed that Jesus himself appeared to him and handed him a letter commanding him to organize the crusade. One popular explanation of what really might have happened proposes that the boy was duped by an ambitious and unscrupulous priest, pretending to be the Lord.4
At any rate, there was no stopping them once the ball got rolling; and, in the end, many thousands of them perished or disappeared. Of the lost, those who did not die from cold, exhaustion, and starvation en route to the Mediterranean either perished at sea or were sold into slavery and prostitution in North Africa. The lucky ones straggled home, bitterly disillusioned.
Wanted: deliverer, money no object
Piper or prophet?
Look at a youth ministry job description. (If you don’t have ready access to these, you can find some online at www.youthspecialties.com/jobbank) Is the congregation or sponsoring organization looking for a piper or a prophet to fill this position?
Whatever happened in Hamelin, the fact remains that the young are always easy targets—especially when somebody comes along who will protest adult incompetence and injustice, make great music, and hold out the utopian promise of a perfect world—somebody like the Pied Piper.
A plague of vermin has a chokehold on the town of Hamelin. Destroyers of both public and private peace, these countless rats, harbingers of deadly plagues, fought the dogs and killed the cats,
And bit the babies in the cradles,
And ate the cheeses out of the vats
And licked the soup from the cook’s own ladles,
Split open the kegs of salted sprats,
Made nests inside men’s Sunday hats
And even spoiled the women’s chats
By drowning their speaking
With shrieking and squeaking
In 50 different sharps and flats.5
The beleaguered citizens of Hamelin are ready to throw their ineffective government out of office when an improbable savior suddenly appears. The poet Browning describes him as a tall, thin, ethereal character, swarthy but beardless, and quaintly garbed in a brightly colored, long robe—half yellow, half red—hence, the designation pied. He claims to be an expert terminator, a professional rescuer; and so the politicians, desperate for any kind of a solution, hire this strange-looking fellow. Besides, his résumé looks good:
“Please your honours,” said he, “I’m able,
By means of a secret charm, to draw
All creatures living beneath the sun,
That creep or swim or fly or run,
After me so as you never saw!
And I chiefly use my charm
On creatures that do people harm.”
Of course it will cost. They promise him 1,000 guilders to do the job, and then watch with astonishment as the Piper pipes thousands of rats out of town, leading them to their doom as they plunge, like lemmings, into the river Weser.
Ponderable
The Pied Piper exercises personality-based leadership, something to which all ministry—and not just youth ministry—is extremely vulnerable. Why is this? Is this necessarily a bad thing? Have you ever been part of a personality-based ministry? What are the advantages of this kind of leadership? What are the dangers? Some experts say that a particular youth ministry must be in place for six years or more if it is to outlive the personality of its leader. Does this ring true to you?
You remember the rest. Freed of the plague of rats, the mayor reneges his promise and offers the Piper only 50 guilders in place of the original 1,000. The Piper, a man not to be trifled with, gets his revenge. He changes his tune, and this time it is the youngest citizens of Hamelin who dance after him in droves, only to be swallowed up, not by a river, but by a magic mountain, wherein the Piper promised a veritable garden of delights. None are left to tell the tale except a single child, a little lame boy who could not keep up the pace and was left to his lonely fate in a town full of grown-ups:
“It’s dull in my town since my playmates left!
I can’t forget that I’m bereft
Of all the pleasant sights they see,
Which the Piper also promised me;
For he led us, he said, to a joyous land,
Joining the town and just at hand,
Where the waters gushed and the fruit trees grew,
And flowers put forth a fairer hue,
And everything was strange and new.
The sparrows were brighter than peacocks here,
And their dogs outran our fallow deer,
And honey-bees had lost their stings,
And horses were born with eagle’s wings;
And just as I became assured
My lame foot would be speedily cured,
The music stopped and I stood still,
And found myself outside the Hill,
Left alone against my will
To go now limping as before,
And never hear of that country more!”
Because of his physical imperfection, this boy misses out on the delicious paradise promised by the Piper, where everything would be strange and new—a place that sounds remarkably like that wonderful “holy mountain” envisioned by the prophet, where “the wolf will live with the lamb, and the leopard will lie down with the goat, and the calf and the lion and the yearling together…and the young child put his hand into the viper’s nest. They will neither harm nor destroy…” (Isaiah 11:6-9).This bereft and damaged child, who knows he is not perfect, is the only one of his generation fated to remain behind in the mundane and bourgeois little hamlet filled with anguished adults who, try as they might to find him, cannot pay the Piper what they owe and whose beautiful children, bound for an unearthly paradise, are lost to them forever.
Browning appends a word of advice at the conclusion to this cautionary tale:
So, Willy, let me and you be wipers
Of scores out with all men—especially pipers;
And whether they pipe us free from rats or from mice,
If we’ve promised them aught, let us keep our promise.6
There, but by the grace of God, go youth ministers
I suspect that those of you who are preparing to be full-time youth ministers may feel a profound empathy for the Piper. If you have served in youth ministry, perhaps you even envy him. You, too, may have felt manipulated by ungrateful adults who, for a pittance, wanted you to keep their children out of mischief and out of their hair, who expected you to work miracles by ridding the local environment of all its toxic elements, but who certainly did not wish you, in any sense of the word, to work miracles with their children.
You, too, may have fantasized about a showdown with the senior pastor or the parish council about craven compromises and fundamental injustices in the running of the youth program; and you have probably dreamed of having 130 teenagers hanging on your every word, taking what you have to offer with utmost seriousness, and showing up—without fail—for every meticulously planned meeting and event your program had to offer.
Perhaps you’d give anything for that secret charm and, like the Piper, you’d chiefly use it “on creatures that do people [especially young people] harm.” You, too, may be ready to pipe a different tune—because it’s easy to be seduced, even when you’re not so young. So be warned! The Piper remains a dangerous man, not just for the young but also for those who minister to them.
Repentance: time to pay the piper
Ponderable
Robin Maas frames her description of repentance around a passage from the gospel of Luke, that carries forward an Old Testament view of repentance as having both personal and public dimensions. How is repentance viewed by your religious community? Do you talk about it much? Is repentance considered a private matter, or does repentance carry public consequences as well? What does a ministry that takes repentance seriously imply for the way youth leaders conduct themselves? What does it mean for youth?
But take heart. There is another historical figure who, though he shares many of the Piper’s exotic and engaging qualities, offers a model of spiritual leadership that will lead neither you nor the young astray.
A voice of one calling:
“In the desert prepare
the way for the Lord;
make straight in the wilderness
a highway for our God.
Every valley shall be raised up,
every mountain and hill made low;
the rough ground shall become level,
the rugged places a plain.
And the glory of the Lord will be revealed,
and all mankind together will see it.
For the mouth of the Lord
has spoken.”
—Isaiah 40:3-5
Cause for repentance?
Would you ask for repentance in any of the following scenarios? What might that look like? Would you consider repentance entirely personal, between the party involved and God, or would it have public consequences as well?
This voice—urgent, piercing, insistent—penetrates hearts and either stirs or shakes them. The sound of this voice is not seductive, but compelling. We cannot ignore it, for it speaks words of both warning and promise. It is the voice, not of the Piper, who says, “I can deliver you—and the goods,” but of the prophet, whose role it is to prepare us for reality, and who says, “It’s time. Get ready. He’s coming.”
The young listen to this voice with excitement, the old perhaps with fresh hope, the powerful with suspicion, and the wicked with disdain or despair. But it is a sound, a message, that cannot be shut out: Wake up! Put your house in order! All your bills are falling due—it’s time to pay the Piper!Yes, something wonderful awaits those who are faithful to the God of Israel, but first there is something you must do. And it will not be fun. You will not go dancing to this task.
The people who first listened to this voice had some sense of what he was talking about. The prophet told them not only what to expect, but what to do about it: Clear a path, a straight, level path, a highway for your God. He is going to come barreling through in a way that cannot be mistaken for anything but what it is meant to be. The glory of the Lord carries with it beauty, terror, and power—the power to move mountains, to level them, if need be, and the will to lift up whatever has sunk into the depths. Is this the path to paradise? And if it is, do we want to be on it? Do we want our kids on it?
This is not a route that leads through the land of good grades, high SAT scores, careers, babies, and minivans. The prophet is talking about God. God is coming, and our little dreams—our modest hopes and plans—may all come to naught. The voice that makes this radical claim is a voice crying out about the transformation of a wasteland—the restructuring of an entire landscape. God is coming, and nothing will ever again be the same. Everything will be strange, and everything will be new.
Incarnational ministry
Because of the relational nature of our work, we like to say that youth ministry is incarnational ministry— ministry in which God enters the world through human beings, the way God entered the world in the person of Jesus Christ. On the one hand, incarnational ministry points to
youth ministry’s theological character, and helps to keep it from devolving into nothing more than good interpersonal relationships. After all, anybody can have a relationship, but only God can be Incarnate.
On the other hand, the term incarnational ministry has been abused by youth ministers who interpret it to mean that they are the incarnate ones. These leaders say to youth, in effect: “Follow me, because I follow Jesus Christ.”
True incarnational ministry, however, is never about “following me.” It is always about following Jesus Christ, the true Incarnation of God. We do better to say that we point to the true Christ, as witnesses (as Karl Barth suggested) or that we are windows or icons through which the true Christ may be glimpsed (as Martin Luther taught). But in no case are we the One youth should follow. While we want our lives to be faithful examples, faithfulness is not an educational strategy. We live faithfully in order to be more Christlike—not to be prototypes young people will imitate.
Incarnational ministry involves primary, not secondary, encounters between young people and the God of Jesus Christ. In incarnational ministry, youth follow their ministers only to the extent that we are transparent to Christ, allowing them to see Christ beyond us, and therefore follow him even if our footsteps stray from the path.
This voice, the one that urges us to hurry up, to get ready, to prepare a highway for our God, is always the voice of the prophet—the one through whom the Lord speaks. Although these words first appear in the book of Isaiah, Christians have learned to associate them with the voice of a prophet named John, who did indeed announce the coming of God.
The ministry of pointing and prodding
John was a young man who was all about getting ready for God. He embodies readiness for God in much the same way Mary does. Each one was bringing something to light. In the darkness of Mary’s womb, the light was taking flesh. Through this very young woman, “the true light that enlightens every [living soul] was coming into the world” (John 1:9). She neither piped nor prophesied. She was the instrument through which God blew; not the Piper, but the pipe.
John does not bear the light within, but points beyond himself toward the light. John’s words, his works, and his life all testify to the light that is coming into the world (John 1:7). The prophet is always herald, witness, and guide. His words, his works, and his person all bear witness to a reality that is beyond him, to something, someone, else. Any power he exercises is borrowed, derivative. His role, first and always, is to speak the truth and in this way to warn, console, and prepare. It is the prophet John the Baptizer—and not the mysterious Piper—who best serves as a model for youth ministers. Where the Piper enchants, the prophet prods and pokes. He is follower first, leading only where he is led. His testimony, because it is true, compels but cannot coerce.
What do we know about John? First, that he was kin to Jesus, son of a priest and a very pious but previously barren woman. Like so many great figures in biblical history, the circumstances of his birth mark him out as a special gift from God. The angel Gabriel tells John’s father, Zechariah, that his son will drink neither wine nor strong drink. He will not need these intoxicants because he will be filled, inebriated, with the Holy Spirit—even from his mother’s womb where the as-yet-unborn prophet recognizes the presence of the Messiah and leaps for joy (Luke 1:44). The Spirit has bestowed upon this child a special mission. John, says the angel, is coming to turn many of the people of Israel to the Lord their God, “and he will go on before the Lord in the spirit and power of Elijah, to turn the hearts of the fathers to their children and the disobedient to the wisdom of the righteous—to make ready a people prepared for the Lord” (Luke 1:16-17).
Can it possibly be that our own calling mirrors that of this new Elijah? Do we find in John’s commission any clues to an authentically prophetic ministry with the young?
Clue: prophetic ministry tells young people the truth
And he will go on before the Lord, in the spirit and power of Elijah…
—Luke 1:17a
The child’s name, chosen by Elizabeth in obedience to the angel Gabriel and in defiance of family tradition, means “Yahweh has shown favor.” The God of Israel loves his people. He takes pity on them and sends them prophets. John is the last of these remarkable gifts from God to God’s people. He comes when things are in a desperate state. He is Israel’s last chance—to change.
Those of us who read the Gospels centuries later would like to think that we would have heeded the preaching of this remarkable young man—that we would have recognized him as the true messenger of God. Maybe. Maybe not. Mark’s account suggests he was on the eccentric side. He camped out in that very same wilderness the prophet Isaiah had said would have to be transformed—leveled—for the highway of God. Like his spiritual predecessor Elijah, John wore a (camel’s) hair garment with a big leather belt. He ate bugs sweetened with honey (Mark 1:6). John, descended from a line of priests, was irritatingly noisy and odd—as odd in his own way as that other strange messenger of God, Elijah.
Sirach
Robin cites Scripture taken from the Book of Sirach, an intertestamental (“between the testaments”) book. Intertestamental books, sometimes called the Apocrypha, are not part of Protestant Bibles but are canonical (have Scriptural authority) for Catholics.
Sirach, an upper-class Jew with liturgical interests, probably wrote his book as poetry around 180 B.C. It is considered wisdom literature, and teaches that fulfilling the law of Moses means showing great wisdom. Like other intertestamental literature, Sirach is excluded from the Protestant Bible because it is unclear whether the book is “revealed” by God or serves primarily as an ethical book. Often criticized for its harsh treatment of women, the Book of Sirach shows similarities to Proverbs but has more of a historical tilt.1
I think of Elijah as the prototypical Hebraic prophet: a morose loner—cranky, eccentric, irascible, and meddling. A seasoned “smiter,” his word “burned like a torch” (Sirach 48:1). Using curses as his favorite weapon, he could call down fire and famine. He did indeed attack injustice; but his driving passion was combating idolatry—the vicious practices associated with the loathsome worship of Baal.
By John’s day, nearly nine centuries later, Elijah was an ancient memory—a symbol loaded with Messianic significance, and with hope. At the appointed time, it is written, Elijah will be the one “to calm the wrath of God before it breaks out in fury, to turn the heart of the father to the son, and to restore the tribes of Jacob” (Sirach 48:10).
In Malachi we see another instance of how the association of John with Elijah’s spirit comes to be made: “See, I will send you the prophet Elijah before the great and dreadful day of the Lord comes. He will turn the hearts of the fathers to their children, and the hearts of the children to their fathers; or else I will come and strike the land with a curse” (Malachi 4:5-6).
John, who like Elisha now wears the mantle of Elijah, is sent to tell Israel—and us—what to expect and what to do before that great and terrible day when we stand revealed for what we really are in the light that is Christ. John, as the new Elijah, is sent to turn hearts—to turn the hearts of fathers to their children and the hearts of children to their fathers. And there is, we should recognize, only one way to turn hearts—and that is through repentance.
That is why John comes preaching a baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins. Repentance is the hard, not-so-fun work of spiritual path—clearing or moral roadwork. It is a heart-turning, stomach-churning, mind-burning experience that actually changes people; and contrary to popular and current Christian opinion, forgiveness is not offered prior to repentance.
It is not enough, as you probably know, to be a show-stopping preacher. Strong words seize our attention—for as long as their sound lingers in the air. Real change requires a death; and that is what baptism is. Even the baptism of repentance is a slayer; and what we expect to find in the wake of dying is grief. And tears. These are the real change agents. The prophet always demands change; and this demand, though often experienced as harsh, is rooted in compassion; for the unpleasant dousing we receive in the baptism of repentance is a painful but effective way of staying out of hot water.
Ponderable
Since the earliest research on adolescence a century ago, adolescence has been considered a uniquely spiritual phase in the life cycle. Psychologists in the early 20TH century assumed conversion was
necessary for a healthy transition from childhood to adulthood (although not all agreed that it needed to be a religious conversion). For most of the 20TH century, churches assumed that most conversions took place during adolescence; a common statistic cited (though undocumented) is that 85 percent of commitments to Christ come before the age of 18.
Recently, George Barna’s research found that only 4 percent of those surveyed said they had had religious conversions as teenagers.1 This statistic has caused a stir among youth ministry professionals; it not only flies in the face of common assumptions, but it also contradicts generations of anecdotal evidence.
What’s going on here? Does Barna’s research ring true to you? Is conversion common during adolescence? Is it important that what Robin calls a “personal moral conversion” happen during adolescence?
It is always the prophet’s responsibility to tell people this, especially young people who today scarcely know what sin is and whose culpability is perhaps mitigated by adult unwillingness to reveal this truth to them. Better they be smitten by the torch of John’s word now than—sooner or later—to meet their Lord unprepared. How foolish we are when we think the young will reject outright a righteous rebuke when many of them are yearning for precisely this sign of love—for this prophetic witness to their worth.
Clue: prophetic ministry shows young people how to change
And he will…turn the hearts of the fathers to their children and the disobedient to the wisdom of the righteous…
—Luke 1:17b
The prophet John the Baptizer makes a dramatic appearance in the church lectionary during the season of Advent; and just as Advent signifies a special time of preparation in the church calendar, adolescence represents a special time of preparation in the life cycle of each individual. For the teenager, there is light just over the horizon. The teen calls this light freedom and equates it with adulthood. But while the light is in sight, the teen still needs a lot of adult guidance in preparing for adult responsibilities. High schools and colleges are places where youth prepare themselves for the adult responsibilities our society has identified as necessary for personal success.
The church has the responsibility for preparing youth for something much more momentous, however. Like John, the light to which we bear witness is Christ himself. We bear the heavy responsibility of announcing his coming to youth, of convincing them that he is indeed on the way, and that they can and must do something about it. We must do this, so that they have the chance to change.
The kind of change we most often expect from youth is the kind of change we call development. It is change that is bound to come, so to speak, and the issue is how well each individual will navigate the shoals of certain types of necessary change. But that’s not the only kind of change youth ministers need to be concerned about. The kind of change John the Baptist is asking for is personal moral conversion. It can happen when you’re 15, five, or 50. And while I imagine you think often about certain changes you would like to see affected in your youth, including moral change, you may not have thought much about your role in terms of bringing them to repentance—to tears—as a way of preparing them to meet Christ, the Lord of the Universe who is asking to be Lord of their hearts.
Bringing youth to repentance and tears
Anybody who has been part of a youth camp or conference knows the role tears play in the event. Typically, the momentum of the week builds to some kind of a commitment service on the last night, which is often an emotional—and significant—experience for youth. Youth returning year after year to the same event look forward to this night. On the last day of the event, young people cry at the thought of leaving each other to go back to their daily routines.
Developmental theorist Erik H. Erikson has pointed out that adolescents need to be moved, existentially as well as physically, and that this is important to their developing need for transcendence.1 Robin suggests that “bringing youth to repentance—to tears” is a way to prepare them to meet Christ. Some Christians who look back on their experiences at emotional worship services as youth remember them as life-changing events. Others remember them as shameless emotional manipulation of tired, hyped adolescents who want to fit in.
Pay attention to the link Robin draws between repentance and tears. To Robin, tears are not part of an emotional high; on the contrary, they suggest the depth of remorse that accompanies true repentance. Is repentance the reason for the tears you see at youth events? If not, what is their purpose? Are these tears indications of real change on the part of young people? How can youth ministry address the adolescent need to be emotionally moved, especially to be moved toward repentance, without resorting to manipulation?
A great deal of energy is expended by youth leaders and program developers in the interest of social justice. Certain aspects of American society, our culture, and “the establishment” are regularly excoriated for perpetrating injustices. This is fine as far as it goes. But we must be careful that we adults are not sending our kids off on fruitless and dangerous crusades for which they remain spiritually under-equipped. It is a form of adult exploitation to train our youth to sniff out these corporate moral failures from miles away while allowing them to remain blissfully ignorant of their personal moral failings because we have forgotten, or choose not to remember, that the prophets confronted individual sinners as well as nations.
We may all deeply regret the injuries suffered by those who occupy the lower social and economic rungs of the ladder; but the wounds that actually bring us to tears of repentance are those for which we recognize our own personal culpability—when the person we’ve hurt has a face and a name.
We know John the Baptist did not neglect the larger moral horizon in which he lived; it was one of his favorite sermon topics. But he baptized people one by one. To each one who came to him he said, “Own up to your sins, name them, repent, be cleansed in the waters of baptism—and change your ways. If you have been dishonest, hypocritical, selfish, a cheat, or indifferent to the poor, change your behavior.”
We religious professionals hear these words, and we think about the complacent and comfortable-but-faceless adults who, although they sit in the pews of our churches, remain indifferent to human suffering and go on consuming this world’s goods as if there were no tomorrow. Think again.
Remember, the new Elijah was to turn hearts—in particular the hearts of parents and children. The human family is the nursery of virtue and vice, and anyone who has spent more than 10 sessions with a therapist has been forced to recognize how many bruises on the heart first appear in disappointing and destructive struggles with family members. I remember—you remember—how anxious we were as youth to be rid of our tiresome siblings, our meddling mother, our embarrassingly inept or overbearing father. I said, you said, when I am grown up, when I am married, when I am a parent, I will not be like that…If I could just get away from this mess, I could be happy—I could even be good! You and I, because we expected our families and our world to be perfect, were easy bait for the Piper.
So what are we saying—that the youth minister’s job is simply to whip up a lot of adolescent guilt and remorse, to make the girls cry and the boys blush with shame? By no means! Back to John.
Although the prophet profoundly disturbs people, he also gives them hope, because he tells them the truth—not the false hope of a paradise without pain, but the real hope of conversion, of personal change. This is how the two-edged sword of truth works. It cuts to the bone; but truth is a surgeon, not a slayer. It is the ax laid to the root of the tree. It removes only that which is dying or already dead.
John gave his hearers hope because he told them there was something they could do to change themselves. He said: You can do something now that will make this future encounter with the Lord a “fruitful” one. And what he asked of those who wanted to prepare themselves was nothing heroic. It was doable. “Produce fruit in keeping with repentance.…The man with two tunics should share with him who has none, and one who has food should do the same” (Luke 3:8, 11). Nothing here about trouping off to liberate the Holy Land or being burned at the stake. Just the cheerful, unrelenting performance of duty, simple kindness to the neighbor, the generous impulse unhesitatingly indulged.
Fruits of repentance: go home and go to school
Robin suggests that youth ministers have a “golden opportunity” to turn disobedient youth “to the wisdom of the just” by helping them contribute to righteousness in their families and schools. This involves not only confronting youth on issues of personal morality, but sensitizing them to issues of social justice that impinge on their family or their school. The fruit that testifies to adolescent repentance should first be evident in these places, where teenagers are most invested.
To do this would require that youth themselves be in ministry to their families and classmates. In your experience, does youth ministry treat young people as agents of ministry or only as objects of ministry? How might young people learn to be ministers of righteousness (justice) at home and at school? What does that look like in families or schools that are engaged in patently unrighteous behavior?
Youth ministers are in a unique position to confront youth on immediate problems of personal morality, as well as trying to sensitize them to macro- and long-term issues of social justice. This is where we have a golden opportunity to “turn the disobedient to the wisdom of the just.” Turning the hearts of the young should begin with the place where their hearts are most vulnerable: the home, first, and then the school. These are places where personal accountability, courage, self-restraint and self-respect, honesty, and generosity are either nurtured or starved to death. These are the places where kids are not only vulnerable but where they are powerful as well—where they can hurt and destroy. These are the places where teenagers can most effectively begin to produce the kind of fruit that will testify to their repentance.
Youth ministers, insofar as they are prophets and not pipers, can say what a parent wants to say but is often afraid to say. We can offer warnings that will be heard where voiced parental forebodings are ignored. We can witness to the coming of Christ not simply as a consoling personal encounter, but as an acutely clarifying event, first in our own life and then in theirs. Don’t be surprised if this opportunity is not immediately embraced. Some kids would rather be swallowed up by a magic mountain than exposed to the light—especially if they are sinning and lack the courage or even the concepts and the language to acknowledge this.
The coming of God in the flesh to our flesh is a time when the light gets turned on. When the light gets turned on we can see everything, including the things we’d rather not see. When the light gets turned on, other people see things we’d rather not have them see. That’s the thing about light: It’s ruthless, because it reveals whatever is there, roadkill and all.
Clue: prophetic ministry knows when to let go
Many of the people of Israel will he bring back to the Lord their God…to make ready a people prepared for the Lord…
—Luke 1:16, 17c
When we have done what we can, when we have told youth the truth about what to expect and what they can do right now—right where they live—to prepare for the coming of God, when we have instructed the disobedient in the wisdom of the just, when we have exhorted them to turn their hearts—with tears of repentance—back to their families and schoolmates; then we will have done much to prepare them to confront what is wrong in our imperfect world, without their being tempted to give up on it in despair or disgust when the changes they want to see happen are slow in coming—or do not come at all.
When we have done all this, and if we have not tried to co-opt immature youth by enlisting them prematurely in our own pet adult crusades, we will have “made ready a [young] people prepared for the Lord.” They will be prepared for whatever grand and challenging new missions the real rescuer—the master piper—has destined for this particular generation. When we have done all this, we will have done as much as we can properly do.
Not here—there
This painting, Christ on the Cross with the Virgin, Saint John the Evangelist, Magdalen, and Saint John the Baptist, by Grünewald (1515), allegedly hung above Karl Barth’s desk throughout his career as a theologian. It shows John the Baptist pointing to the crucified Christ, drawing our attention away from the Baptizer and directing us to look toward the cross. Barth was intensely uncomfortable with anything that seemed to suggest that humans played a role in God’s saving work. For him, Christians are “witnesses” who point to the cross, where God’s salvation takes place.
That you will often pipe in your ministry to those who will not dance is to be expected. Jesus himself complains that he and John both have come to a generation who will not hear, no matter what kind of tune the piper plays (Matthew 11:16-18). That you will sometimes be plagued with faith-threatening doubts about the Lord and the claims you make for him is also to be expected. John himself did not escape these doubts (Matthew 11:2-6); and no doubt, the Lord will answer you as he answered John: “What changes have you seen? What evidence of the Spirit is at work in the lives of those you serve? Wisdom is justified by her deeds” (Matthew 11:4-6, 19). Neither of these problems need defeat you. But there is something else that could.
John the Baptist ministry: go to him, go to him
Several years ago, while on a trip to Peru, I met a Jesuit priest involved in youth work. He said something very interesting and very important about his work that I have never forgotten and that has provided the seed for what I am saying here. “Youth work,” he said, “is very appealing because young people are so responsive, so appreciative, and so easily idolize their leaders.” The great temptation of the youth leader, therefore, is to say: “Come to me, come to me”. What they should be saying, of course is, “Go to him, go to him.”
Because the kind of people who tend to be drawn to youth ministry are usually caring, compassionate, and idealistic, they can easily fall into the trap of trying to be pipers instead of prophets—they can be seduced into thinking that they have what these kids really need, and that they are personally responsible for saving them from themselves.
When this happens, what the trade calls burn out is not far behind. The distressingly rapid turnover of people in youth ministry has much to do with failing to be content simply with witnessing to the light. We are not the light. Youth ministers who cast themselves in the role of piper are not entirely unlike those well-intentioned but naive adults who accompanied the brave but deluded child crusaders on their impossible journey over the Alps. And what a burned-out youth minister often leaves in her wake are disappointed, sometimes disillusioned young crusaders.
So hear, all ye who are burned out, the words of the prophet to his disciples: “Look the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world!” (John 1:29). Behold, the one who can remove the impossible burden from your weary shoulders by relieving you of your illusions.
“Look!” says John the Baptizer, to those who are searching. “There is the one you should follow—not me.” John admits he didn’t know whom the great one coming after him would be. That he now recognizes Jesus as God’s own anointed is due to the visible manifestation of the Spirit. The same Spirit with which John is filled descended on the Lord like a dove when John baptized his cousin; and because he has seen this revelation with his own eyes, he can say with authority, “He is the one—follow him.” When Jesus inaugurates his own ministry and quickly gains a following, this news is communicated to John the Baptizer by his disciples: “Rabbi, the one who was with you across the Jordan, to whom you testified, here he is baptizing and everyone is coming to him.” Instead of feeling threatened by this development, John replies,
You yourselves can testify that I said, “I am not the Christ, but am sent ahead of him.” The bride belongs to the bridegroom. The friend who attends the bridegroom waits and listens for him, and is full of joy when he hears the bridegroom’s voice. That joy is mine, and it is now complete. He must become greater; I must become less.
—John 3:28-30
He must become greater; I must become less. He must increase, I must decrease, is the way another translation puts it. These words should be engraved on the heart of every youth minister. We must never forget that the children of God are meant to walk in the light. If we are not the light, then when the light appears the ones we love must be on their way—on his way.
This, of course, is the hard part of being a youth minister, but also the best part. It is closely related to the understanding that we are not the light but only witness to it. If we are in fact faithful and effective in witnessing to the light, then sooner or later, the young people we work with are going to go after it. And if we are like John, this is when we will feel most rewarded, when our joy will be full.
Repentance: holy road work
Here is the true measure of John’s greatness as a spiritual leader. He knows when to let go; he knows that if he is true to his calling, he will indeed diminish in importance to his disciples. They will be increasingly attracted, not by him and his radical witness, but by the radiant beauty—the light—to which his radical witness points. He cannot hang on to the wonderful young people who follow him for a while. To be true to his calling he must constantly point beyond himself to something more. Something better. Someone else.
How hard this is! It is so good to be needed, so good to be adored—or at least appreciated! But for this, John was born. For this, he leapt in his mother’s womb, foreswore strong drink, wore camel’s hair, and ate bugs—not to pipe his followers into an earthly paradise, but to help each person prepare a way, a broad and beckoning highway, over which the Lord may pass, into her life, into his heart.
The valleys that must be filled, the mountains that have to be leveled, the rough country that must be smoothed over, are apt metaphors for our own inner terrain. This is where the serious roadwork of repentance has to begin. It is an equally apt description of the unfinished state of adolescence—peaks of exhilaration, valleys of despair, rough and rugged ways of thinking, speaking, acting—a real wilderness of confusion and rebellion.
Into this rough and not-yet-ready place comes the prophet, the new Elijah, looking a little rough and ragged himself, but filled with unshakable faith in the truth of God’s promise to deliver—both us and the goods; filled with a healthy fear of God’s wrath and an immense hope in God’s mercy; filled with a hatred of sin and the injustices that are its inevitable fruits; and filled with boundless compassion for the sinner. Filled to the brim because he is inebriated with the Spirit, who blows his own tune, and who never fails to enchant. This new Elijah is not someone who will have to go looking for young listeners. They will come flocking—because they are looking for the light. And they are ready to do something about it.
