Chapter 26 Acting Wisely: Counseling and Crises
Chapter 26
Acting Wisely: Counseling and Crises
Marv Penner
Jennifer’s voice sounded so matter-of-fact, it was impossible to imagine the life-changing significance of her phone call. What had been a routine Wednesday afternoon of preparation for the Senior High Bible Study that night, was about to turn into a terrifying race for a student’s life.
The church secretary had told me it was Jenn on the line, and I was glad to hear from her. It had only been a few months since she had started attending our youth group. She had come with a friend and seemed to plug into the life of the group easily. Because of her great sense of humor and cute pixie face, most of the guys in the group had welcomed her instantly. The girls had rallied around her, too, but for different reasons. Jenn’s family was a mess and the girls sensed she needed their support and friendship. Both her parents were alcoholics and there were whispers about abuse—certainly verbal, physical, and emotional, and probably sexual, too. One thing was true—she had experienced more pain in her life than most 15-year-olds I knew.
Lots of students would call at the office, but she never had. It didn’t seem at all unusual until we got past the “hi-how-are-ya’s” and she told me her reason for calling. “I’m calling to say goodbye,” she said, “and to tell you thanks for all you’ve done for me. You guys have been awesome.”
“What do you mean ‘Goodbye?’” I asked, dreading a confirmation of what I feared she was trying to tell me between the lines.
“I’m just saying goodbye and thanks,” she responded with an uncharacteristically emotionless voice.
“Jenn, are you trying to tell me that you’re planning to hurt yourself somehow?”
“So what if I am?”
“It’s a huge ‘so what’ if you are. You’re part of our group, and we need you to stay a part of us. What have you planned, Jenn? How are you hoping to do this…and when?” I tried to keep my voice calm as my gut was screaming with fear.
What do you do as a youth worker when you’re faced with the despair of a kid who has reached the end of her hope? What are the right questions to ask? You can’t exactly put her on hold for a few minutes and call a crisis hotline for advice in the middle of it all. What if you blow it and say the wrong thing at a critical moment like this? If the responsibility feels huge, that’s because it is.
To make a long and complex story much shorter, Jenn told me that afternoon that it was her plan to leave where she was calling from immediately to go to the nearest subway stop and jump in front of the first train that came into the station. It was one of the common suicide methods in our city, and after having spent a few years on the fire department before going into full-time youth ministry, I knew it was lethal. As I heard her begin to cry quietly, she hung up the phone. The last word I heard before the click was “sorry.”
She hadn’t told me she was calling from home but I had a hunch, and you know I was praying a lot harder than I had been when I began preparing my Bible study a half-hour earlier. I was right about the route she had chosen to walk and as I rounded the corner onto her street, she saw me coming. I was amazed when she got into my car as I stopped across the street from where she was walking. My mind was racing as she looked hopelessly at me.
Where do you start in a case like this? What’s the right thing to say? Do you lock the car doors and rush her to the nearest hospital? Do you let her talk or make her listen? Do you give her some helpful Scripture or ask her why? Where do you go with the confusion and intensity of these sorts of youth ministry moments?
Forewarned is forearmed?
Marv Penner mentions that he doesn’t have very good theological answers to suicide. What other issues are just as theologically complex, which you may not always have worked out before a crisis hits you? Marv waded into the suicide situation armed with theological certainty on at least one point: because Jesus was represented in Jennifer’s life, he felt committed to get involved.
Jennifer’s story is true and sadly not all that unusual. If you’re going to work with students, you will face overwhelming circumstances at some point in your ministry. I realized that Jennifer had called me on that day, not because of my expertise in suicide intervention (I had none). Neither was it because of my deep understanding of the theological issues that surround suicide (I still don’t have very good answers to some of those questions). Jenn also didn’t know that I could refer her to the kind of professional counseling she would need to help her out of her deep hole of despair (I had a few names and numbers.) She called me because somehow she knew I cared about her and her friends in the youth group, and for some mysterious reason she trusted me with her deepest moment of hopelessness.
Youth ministry, in the middle of complex counseling situations and crisis, is fundamentally no different than any other time in youth ministry. Certainly the stakes can be much higher and there is no room for carelessness. What we’re talking about is still simply a basic commitment to loving students with integrity and a willingness to share our lives with them for the sake of pointing them to Jesus. Loving Jennifer was a costly commitment. It turns out that she had just found out that she was pregnant, and with all the other junk going on in her life, the news had pushed her over the edge. The next seven months, and the first few years after the baby was born, could only be described as intensive care. But Jenn made it, and as I look back on it, I was honored to be part of the group that represented Jesus in her life.
The difference is…
Is this to say that our ministry to others will depend, not so much on our particular skills and training, but on the experience of God’s work in our own lives? The difference between experiences that give us empathetic insights or rapport and the historical reality of God’s grace in our own formation is critical to understand as we evaluate our own level of preparedness for crisis ministry.
This is what Paul is talking about in the opening thoughts of 2 Corinthians when he encourages us to comfort others out of the comfort that we have received from God. For reasons we can’t fully understand, God chooses to use us in the lives of kids to be his voice of encouragement and his touch of healing. According to Paul’s instructions, our point of connecting with hurting students does not come from the pain we have in common with them but from the confidence we have in our healing heavenly Father. You can’t minister to children of alcoholics simply because your dad drank to excess. That might give you some rapport, but ministry will come from how you’ve experienced God’s grace in the reality of that pain and your ability to communicate his grace. I’m not talking about simplistic platitudes that say, “Just trust Jesus and everything will be fine in the morning.” Acting wisely when we’re surrounded by pain and crisis requires careful thought, personal integrity, spiritual sensitivity, and a clear sense of our mission.
Basic presuppositions
Several important assumptions underlie everything else that follows in this chapter. These fundamental realities must be taken into account each time we get involved with a young person for the sake of bringing healing and hope.
Most adolescents are hurting much more deeply than they (or we) are willing to admit.
Things are generally worse than they appear. We don’t need a long list of statistical evidence to confirm that life is tough for kids growing up today. Very few adults would argue that contemporary adolescence is marked by pressure, stress, and pain unlike any known in recent history. Broken families, uncertain peer relationships, addictions, abuse, fear of the future, terror in the present, confusion about the past—these are the realities our young people live with.
Sadly, the issues are not dramatically different for church kids. Yet most of the students you know are experts at covering up what’s really going on inside. They are cautious about deciding whom they will allow to peek behind the carefully constructed masks they’ve perfected over the course of their childhood. We know from our own lives that a happy-go-lucky exterior often camouflages a deeply hurting heart, or that an angry outburst may be rooted in fear. That cocky senior, who seems to have everyone eating out of his hand, may be terrified that someone will get close enough to see how insecure he really feels. The life-of-the-party cheerleader who seems so comfortable with her sexuality, might very well be living with the shame of abuse that has left her feeling scarred and betrayed.
Why are adolescents so afraid to admit what’s really going on and to let adults know that they could use some help? In many cases the answer is simple. They’ve shown people how they’ve felt before, and no one has ever taken them seriously. The sense of rejection that came when they took the risk of being vulnerable and found themselves ignored was simply too painful. The logical response for most kids is to pretend that everything is all right and hide the reality from everyone else.
So what? The responsibility we have as youth workers to listen carefully and deeply to the heart of a hurting teen cannot be overstated.
In addition, some young people feel that if they admit a problem, they aren’t adequately handling their transition to adulthood. The notion that normal adulthood is a problem-free existence is a myth that has been perpetuated—especially in the church by adults unwilling to face the reality of their own lives. If being an adult means “having all your ducks in a row,” it follows that the shortest path to adulthood is to make sure everyone thinks that’s the case.
So what? We must learn to live honestly in front of our students so they can see that the relevance of the gospel is most profoundly felt in the midst of reality, even when that reality is painful. Seeing this kind of integrity will give them hope.
It should be noted that an often overlooked reason adolescents don’t share how they’re feeling is that they legitimately don’t have any idea. The confusion of raging hormones, cognitive transitions, and emotional upheaval may just feel too intense. They may not have a name to put on the intense feelings they’re experiencing, even though the effect is very real.
So what? Avoid the temptation to tell adolescents what they are feeling. Giving them permission to feel something deeply without having to put a name on it may be an important first step toward emotional honesty and healing.
Perhaps a more important question to ask is why we as spiritual leaders are so reluctant to acknowledge the seriousness of a kid’s pain. So often we find ourselves pretending that everything is fine, avoiding the students we know are hurting, and changing the subject when it feels like they want to take us to a deeper place in their lives. The spiritual leaders of Jeremiah’s day must have done the same thing: “From the least to the greatest, all are greedy for gain; prophets and priests alike, all practice deceit. They dress the wound of my people as though it were not serious. ‘Peace, peace,’ they say, when there is no peace” (Jeremiah 6:13-14) Dressing the wounds of people as though they aren’t serious is rooted in selfishness and dishonesty. Applying a Band-Aid when surgery is needed will cause far more damage in the long run. But it is costly and often terrifying to go to the painful places in a student’s heart. It often feels inadequate to provide only our presence when the situation seems to call for answers.
So what? Don’t underestimate the power of your presence when a young person has trusted you with a hidden corner of his life. You might need to refer him to someone who can provide answers, but your presence may be the basis for healing because he trusts you.
Resources for healing exist in the body of Christ that exist nowhere else.
Sadly these resources are often unacknowledged and underused. The power of community is something the early church understood and is something this millennial generation has embraced as no recent age group has. Perhaps it is the collective pain of contemporaries abandoned by family and misunderstood by the church that has driven them to the depth of interdependence they seem to experience so deeply. In the midst of crisis it seems that people are driven to deeper relationships with each other. It amazes me that we have failed to better harness the power of community. Like Larry Crabb, I have “strong reason to suspect that Christians sitting dutifully in church congregations for whom ‘going to church’ means doing a variety of spiritual activities have been given resources that if released could powerfully heal broken hearts, overcome the damage done by abusive backgrounds, encourage the depressed to courageously move forward, stimulate the lonely to reach out, revitalize discouraged teens and children with new and holy energy, and introduce hope into the lives of countless people who feel rejected, alone, and useless.”1 It seems as though youth groups have often grasped this concept better than others in the church. The reality of Paul’s body metaphor in 1 Corinthians 12 is something young people seem to understand intuitively. Perhaps if we celebrated the resources of community more consciously during adolescence when the concept seems natural, our young people could become Christian adults who know how to apply the “one another’s” of the New Testament more consistently.
First thing first
The depth of need adolescents have for counseling make one immediately conclude that youth ministry professionals need more and better skills and training. Marv doesn’t deny us that route, but as the first line of response, he calls our attention to the theological design of the body of Christ.
We have observed over and over in recent years that when crisis hits a community of adolescents, their strength as a group increases instantly. The consistent story coming out of Jonesboro, Arkansas; Littleton, Colorado; Fort Worth, Texas; and other communities where violent crisis has hit groups of young people is that their deepest comfort came from one another. The youth ministry implications are obvious.
So what? We must cultivate a climate of true Christian community in our youth groups where mutual ministry and spiritual interdependence are the norm so that when times of crisis occur, the relational framework for intervention is already in place.
Healing and change will always be a mystery and can’t easily be reduced to a formula or series of steps to victory.
Adolescence is, by definition, a time of developmental disequilibrium. With one foot reluctantly holding on to a place to stand in the familiar world of childhood, and the other searching for solid ground in the strange world of adulthood, it is no wonder teenagers often describe their lives as chaotic, confusing, and stressful. Perhaps this is why we often feel such a strong compulsion to provide simplistic solutions for the complex realities they live with.
Our natural attraction to formula solutions and steps to victory may be more tied to our lack of trust in God than our desire to see a young person experience deep healing. Formulas give us the illusion that we can control the outcomes. “If I follow the recipe carefully enough I can guarantee the results.” How many times have we realized in our own lives that these step-based approaches don’t always produce the outcome we desired?
Scripture often gets misused in counseling dilemmas because of our need for formulaic quick fixes. Passages taken out of context lose their intended power. Furthermore, verses meant to deliver healing and hope are impotent when quoted mindlessly without acknowledging the depth of pain they are meant to address. Romans 8:28 (“And we know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him”) is a powerful declaration of God’s sovereignty in the midst of confusing circumstances. However, all too often it’s given to young people without taking the time to understand what’s really going on in their lives. This is in no way meant to minimize the importance of allowing the Scripture to speak into the life of a hurting teenager but to remind us of the importance of providing a relationship in which the Scripture can take hold. The central hope of Christianity is the assurance of Christ’s presence in whatever circumstances we find ourselves. He is our example in the work we do with hurting kids.
Ponderable
Is it possible that even caring relationships can be reduced to a cookbook solution during crises? In other words, God’s whole plan for healing is not likely caught in either Bible Verses R Us or Relationships R Everything, but in some combination that guarantees a supportive person will be present to guide a teen into life-changing interaction with God’s Word.
So what? It is always more costly to provide our presence to a young person in crisis than to impose a cookbook solution and walk away. In most cases God chooses to work through relationships.
Wholeness and healing truly are available in relationship with Christ.
Contemporary psychology has become more and more adept at naming and classifying disorders and less effective in suggesting trustworthy solutions. With each release of a new edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, the American Psychiatric Association adds dozens of new diagnoses. There is a name for virtually every behavioral, relational, or emotional quirk people can dream up. In the meantime, the proliferation of apparently acceptable therapeutic strategies increases. A widening range of methodologies are being proposed with little consensus emerging about what really is effective. With all these conflicting voices, it is encouraging for the Christian youth worker to lean confidently on Christ’s words in John 10:10, “I have come that they may have life, and have it to the full.”
When we affirm that wholeness and healing are available in Christ, we do so realizing that it will still surely require work on the part of both the counselor and counselee. We recognize that healing may take time and could involve substantial pain along the journey. Pointing young people to Jesus is never a cop-out if we commit to staying engaged in the relationship while they experience his help. Our confidence comes in knowing that healing is his specialty.
So what? Christ’s life provides us with a model for dealing with crisis and counseling and the power to be the change agent in the lives of those with whom we work.
The Christ of crisis and counseling
When we read the stories of Jesus in the Gospels we see his healing touch expressed over and over. We imagine blind people tossing away their white canes, cripples using their crutches for kindling, and lepers auditioning for complexion commercials. It’s no wonder crowds chased him everywhere. It’s not a surprise that the religious leaders of his day felt more than just a little threatened by this healer who had chosen their neck of the woods to set up shop.
We can learn countless lessons from Christ’s interaction with hurting people. The gentleness of his touch is evident when he works with children. The boldness of his confidence in the power of his heavenly Father is seen when he confronts the insidious power of evil. The sensitivity of his spirit is obvious when he deals with those damaged and victimized by the actions of others. His acceptance is unconditional even when he knows that the mess the hookers and tax collectors are in is because of their own choices. The amazing thing is that in most of these cases he weaves spiritual solutions into the conversation and models what it means to deal with a whole person. Reading the stories gives us a picture of what it means to be like Jesus as we represent him in the lives of the students we care about.
There is an earlier biblical reference to the kind of healer Christ would become, and it, too, gives us some insights from which we can learn. The prophet Isaiah, speaking prophetically hundreds of years before Christ’s birth, describes Jesus’ mission in a series of names he uses in Isaiah 9:6. In this familiar Christmas passage, we get a look at the kind of people Christ was destined to touch by hearing the names he would go by: Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, and Prince of Peace. His incarnation appears to be a direct response to the nature of the brokenness of those he came to save. Since we are committed to an incarnational ministry in the world of adolescents, we would do well to pay attention.
Who needs a counselor? Is it not someone who is hurting, confused, unsure, wounded, and at the end of their own resources? What about a strong and Mighty God? People who feel weak, helpless, powerless, and alone long to know the strength Christ brings. The Everlasting Father Isaiah describes stands in sharp contrast to the deadbeat dads and detached workaholics a lot of kids today live with, and a Prince of Peace is what people who are stressed, fearful, and anxious need. The words hurting, confused, unsure, wounded, weak, helpless, powerless, alone, abandoned, stressed, fearful, and anxious could certainly be used to accurately describe the generation of young people God has called us to serve on his behalf. Our greatest privilege is to point them to that counselor, strong one, father, and prince.
Isaiah goes on at the beginning of chapter 61 to outline God’s call on his life. The parallel between Isaiah’s call and Christ’s character is clear. “The Lord has anointed me to preach good news to the poor. He has sent me to bind up the brokenhearted, to proclaim freedom for the captives and release from darkness for the prisoners” (Isaiah 61:1). The words broken and bound are so accurate in describing life apart from Christ, that to attempt to bring healing through any means that does not involve him is to overlook the reason he came.
So what? The healing ministry of Jesus is the template by which we model and evaluate our work with hurting students. To suggest that true wholeness is available in any way that eliminates Christ is to declare the cross irrelevant to the struggles of life in this broken world.
Acting wisely in counseling and crises
How, then, does this all look in the real world of working in youth ministry? How do we respond to the barrage of crises that seems to mark the lives of kids today?
The Chinese have an interesting insight into the nature of crisis. In their colorful language they have designated a compound word to portray the concept. The two words that make up the word for crisis are the words danger and opportunity. We must recognize that in the face of the danger that every crisis brings, there is also great opportunity. We have the opportunity to see God at work in difficult circumstances, the opportunity to use the comfort we have experienced from God to help someone, and the opportunity to grow in our own faith as we are stretched beyond the range of our personal skills and resources. The students we work with have great opportunity to grow in the midst of adversity as well. The nature of God is to meet us most personally in our darkest times, and for young people who want to know God deeply, there may be experiences of overwhelming pain to provide that opportunity.
Counseling adolescents is one of the biggest challenges of youth ministry. It seems that just when we think we’ve heard it all, a new story emerges that makes us shake our heads and wonder why we didn’t pursue a career in retail. What is it about counseling kids that makes it so challenging?
But in spite of all that’s just been said, the strategic potential of counseling teenagers must be appreciated. There is no better time in the human developmental process to come alongside someone than during their teen years. We can connect with them at a critical moment in their lives—when their childlikeness still leaves them open to the input of others who genuinely care, and their adultlikeness allows them to deal with the tough realities of choices in a way that can be mature and life-changing.
Getting started in counseling and crisis intervention
Some people seem to think that, without a Ph.D. and years of experience, they can’t do much to help a teenager in crisis. Remember Jenn? She wasn’t looking for academic qualifications. She was looking for someone she could trust. Certainly she needed some professional help along the way when she started dealing with the deeper issues, but before any of that could happen she needed someone in her life who cared about her and was willing to get involved. We can all be those kinds of people in the lives of hurting young kids if we are willing to start now. Here are some steps you can begin immediately to increase your effectiveness as a helper.
Cultivate the character of a healer
Certain characteristics of Christlikeness show up again and again when effective helpers are described. These character qualities are worth cultivating whether or not we see ourselves in the role of a helper. They include—
As these qualities increase, our trustworthiness with hurting students will increase as well—and the level at which they share will become deeper and more meaningful.
Define desired outcomes
What is the goal of your work with hurting teenagers? It’s easy to fall into the trap of measuring effectiveness purely on the basis of changed behaviors, more pleasant emotions, or altered circumstances. While each of these may be desirable in their own way, they do not necessarily represent spiritual growth in an individual. Movement toward health can be best understood in directional terms. Ask yourself, Is this young person trusting God more deeply today than last week? Is she willing to take risks based on obedience rather than creating a safe path through relationships? Is she able to define her feelings more accurately now than before? Does she have a clearer sense of who she is and how events of her life have shaped her to this point? Healing is always a journey. It may involve the participation of many different people all working together under the Wonderful Counselor’s ultimate supervision.
Practice interactive skills
Although who you are is probably more important to your work with kids than what you know, it is wise to develop the expertise necessary to work with people who are hurting. In fact, if you want to make counseling and crisis intervention a key part of your ministry, it will be critical that you receive training in the skills that will maximize your effectiveness. A good first step is to begin consciously practicing some of the components of good counseling. Learn to listen. This may be the most important skill of all to practice. Listen beneath the words for the feelings that are being expressed. Listen to the non-verbal language of the body, facial expressions, and tone of voice. Practice reflecting back to people what you are hearing them say. Learn ways to make it safe for them to say more. Develop your spiritual sensitivity so that you can more accurately determine what is going on for a person in that area. Use open-ended questions (those that require a thoughtful answer rather than just yes or no) in your conversations with friends to draw out their thoughts.
Don’t become an amateur psychologist in all of this. There’s nothing more obnoxious! Just work at being a better friend. As these skills become natural, you will be more effective in your counseling interactions and more confident in your ability to help people.
Recognize your own limitations
This chapter is not intended as training for professional therapists. It is aimed toward people who love kids and desire an opportunity to help them when they’re hurting. As a lay person, there are specific limitations to what you can and cannot do. Some of these limitations are legal and others are based in common sense. It is not your job to replace parents and family. It is wise to involve a young person’s parents wherever possible in recognition of their spiritual role of leadership in the lives of their children.
When you are dealing with issues of abuse, criminal activity, and other serious matters, you should be aware of the legal obligations in your area. They can be reviewed at the police department or at one of the child protection or social service agencies in your community. Even though you are not a professional counselor, you are bound by laws in these areas, and it is your obligation to understand and apply them as needed.
Also beware of your personal limitations. These will be different for every person, but it will be important for you to discover yours. There is a limit to the number of hurting students you can be involved with. There are certain topics you will feel less qualified to talk about than others. When you reach your limit in some of these areas, get help for yourself. A basic principle of lifeguarding is that there is no point in two people drowning. The rescuer must take responsibility for his own safety. The same principle applies in people-helping. It is easy to become overwhelmed with the needs of hurting kids all around us, but we are finite creatures with limits on how much we can offer.
Be ye faithful
Not only have most youth ministry vets realized they can’t do everything, but they’ve also realized that God never intended them to do it all. We can relax by accepting our limitations as a theological reality; faithfulness is doing what God expects us to do—no more or less.
Be careful not to tell kids that they can call you whenever they need you or that you’ll be there for them anytime. Reserve that privilege for rare and very extreme circumstances. Create a safe and healing place that you can retreat to so that your soul can be replenished.
Prepare for the unanticipated
Some people thrive on imagining worst-case scenarios. They seem to enjoy the possibility that a disaster is just around the corner waiting to crush them. We tend to look on folks like this with some suspicion. Rightly so! Without becoming chronically pessimistic about the future, it is important that we take a realistic position on the matter of crisis in our world of ministry. If we truly care about adolescents and surround ourselves with them for the sake of ministry, we will encounter crisis. The best way to prepare is to maintain a close relationship of dependence with the Wonderful Counselor we talked about earlier in the chapter. After all, our role is simply to be apprentices in his ministry plan. When we are familiar with his ways, sensitive to his voice, and responsive to his guidance, we can confidently embrace the most severe crisis knowing that we do not need to carry the burden alone. He is faithful. His grace is sufficient for any ministry circumstances we may face.
When I began my life in youth ministry over a quarter of a century ago, I imagined the thrill of having hurting kids pour out their souls to me. I envisioned myself as a hero to parents who couldn’t deal with the complications of raising an adolescent without my valuable insights. The novelty has long since worn off. I remember standing in the shower one evening after a long and sweaty day of working in the yard. As I watched the dirty water swirling down the drain at my feet I found myself wishing I could wash my soul as easily after a day of working with hurting kids and their families. The stories of abuse, anger, violence, and victimization I heard so often left me feeling contaminated and stained. And yet there was always a joy in seeing God’s healing at work in the lives of his children.
The experience of working with hurting teenagers is bittersweet. It is not for the faint of heart. If the novelty of seeing into the secret corners of someone’s life or a curiosity about the sordid details behind a story you’ve heard is what draws you to this ministry, I would suggest you look elsewhere. If the need to be needed energizes you in pursuit of kids to counsel, it will be a disappointing journey. But if God calls you to it and you understand what it means to be in partnership with him, there is no life like it. You’ll see miracles the likes of which you couldn’t have imagined.
