Chapter 5 of 38

Chapter 3 Growing Up Postmodern: Theological Uses of Culture

Chapter 3 Growing Up Postmodern: Theological Uses of Culture

Chapter 3

Growing Up Postmodern: Theological Uses of Culture

Don C. Richter

Recently I was invited to present a guest lecture on Youth and Spirituality at a local college. One of the questions I posed for discussion was this: In what ways can the Internet be a spiritual resource for teens today? I assumed that the majority of these computer-savvy college students would regard the Internet as a useful means of communication and a constructive vehicle for teen spirituality. Instead, my question provoked controversy and lively debate. Several students expressed strong conviction that the Internet is an isolating and voyeuristic medium, steeped in consumerism and detrimental to the general well-being of teenagers. “Keep kids off the Web!” they pleaded. Other students countered that the Internet offers a wealth of information—if one browses responsibly—and provides valuable ways of connecting to others, making new friends and sustaining community over great distances. These students encouraged the development of faith-oriented Web resources for youth.

A key issue this discussion surfaced for the class was how to discern appropriate technologies and teaching strategies in our educational ministry with youth. Our class discussion also pointed to some larger questions, however, which are the subject of this chapter:

  • What perspectives help us understand the relationship between theology and culture in our ministry with youth?
  • What guidelines do we need to help us interpret contemporary culture—including youth culture—in light of the gospel?
  • We’ll begin by defining theology and culture, claiming that one term always points toward the other. Theology always implicates culture, and culture always lends itself to theological critique. We’ll examine the role language plays in shaping our worldview, our theological ideas, and spirituality. We’ll then examine two central themes of Christian theology that have implications for culture. Christian theology is grounded in the Incarnation—the scandalous claim that God became human and dwelt among us in the person of Jesus of Nazareth. Christian theology is given wings through our experience of redemption—the freedom and new life inaugurated by the death and resurrection of this same Jesus. For Christians, God’s incarnation and redemptive activity color every aspect of how we understand and relate to culture and how we understand and minister with youth—including how we evaluate cultural phenomena like the Internet as a spiritual resource for teens today.

    The interplay of theology and culture

    Tom Beaudoin, author of Virtual Faith, recalls that when he first studied theology, he thought he was going to be living with his “head in the clouds, floating in an airy, spiritual nothingness.” He imagined returning to earth at the end of each day to find himself back in his own culture. “I was completely wrong,” Beaudoin confesses.

    The grammar of faith

    Christian traditions all share a grammar, or structure, of faith in Jesus Christ. The Christian story has recognizable parts, arranged like a skeleton across which scores of faith traditions have been stretched over the centuries, each colored by its particular social and historical location. As a result, Christian traditions speak the language of faith with different theological accents, so to speak.

    If the only time you’ve ever studied language was in English Composition or Spanish 101, it may seem strange to hear Don Richter talk about language as a bridge between theology and culture. And yet language refers to historically established patterns of human behavior (spoken or otherwise) that carry meaning—but that only make sense within certain communities. Language defines a culture. Until we learn a culture’s language, it is alien to us. The same can be said for the language of faith. Until we learn the grammar of Christian faith, we cannot live fully as Christians. We learn that language best by immersion in the practices of a particular Christian community.

    Languages do not define God, but they do frame theologies, the ways people of faith have come to talk about God over the centuries. Theological languages—those concrete patterns of believing, behaving, and communicating that enact our basic convictions about who God is and how God acts in the world—make sense only in theological communities. And while Christians do share a common language of faith, Jesus also calls us to find ways to translate this theological language so we can speak to secular culture as well. Furthermore, we must do so without corrupting the basic grammar of the Christian story.

  • Think about your theological “accent.” Does God-talk come easily to you? Do you steer clear of churchy words? What practices of faith seem natural to you? What actions commonly give you away as a Christian? How do you account for your particular theological accent?
  • Is your theological accent so pronounced that non-Christians have trouble understanding you? Or is it so thin that no one can tell you apart from non-Christians?
  • Theology has to do with culture because theology has to do with living religiously, which always takes place within a culture. Theology, by its very name, makes the great assertion that we can express a logos (word or reason) about a theos (God). Theology means “talk about” God, because it is first possible to “talk with” God, or to encounter revelation about God.1

    We can see how theology and culture are deeply intertwined by considering how they are both dependent upon language. As Beaudoin notes:

    Whenever we use theological language, such as the phrase kingdom of God, our cultural concepts make it possible for us to understand what kingdom and God means. For us to understand even the word theology, a theology must take the form of terms and ideas that we can grasp, which means that it must be articulated in the language of our culture.2

    The term culture refers broadly to the way of life of a society—the shared learned behavior (thinking, feeling, and acting) and its products (art, laws, customs, etc.) that distinguish one community of people from another. We swim in our culture the way fish swim in water—it surrounds us so closely that we barely notice it affecting the ways we move through the world. By sharing our culture, though, we attempt to cultivate children into ways of life that are important to us. New generations do not have to reinvent the wheel because the wheel is an important artifact of culture that has been handed down for thousands of years.3

    Language is a defining feature of human culture, because every language conveys symbolic meanings and enables human knowledge to be transmitted to succeeding generations. Language marks the shift between biological and cultural existence. Individuals may utter nonsense sounds and make random motions, but when these become communication by means of sounds and gestures that signify shared social meanings, culture is born. How does this shift occur?

    All humans are born with linguistic capacity. Listen to the clicks, clucks, and cooing of an infant. Gradually, they begin to take on the sounds of the spoken language the child hears. A child’s linguistic capacity takes root and grows within the rich soil of a given language system. The child learns to interpret the world—to interpret reality itself—through the lens of a specific language with its vocabulary, grammar, syntax, and nuances of expression. We don’t learn to speak language in general; we learn to speak and comprehend a particular language.

    The language we use helps us see and know certain things but may prevent us from seeing and knowing other things. Persons raised within multilingual cultures (or bilingual families) become aware at an early age that different words can be used to identify the same object. A piece of furniture consisting of a smooth flat slab fixed on legs, is not only a table, but can also be der Tisch or la mesa. Persons who are conversant in several languages also recognize that each language is idiomatic—that it has its own peculiar logic and structure and way of viewing reality. “I’m cold,” I might say in English, though the equivalent German expression would translate, “It is to me cold”—two similar yet distinct ways of describing bodily experience.

    Sometimes the only way to appreciate how we have been shaped by our native culture is to step out of it and view it from the perspective of a different culture. Then we realize that what we have always taken for granted as “the way things are” suddenly seems strange and maybe even arbitrary to us. We realize that our native culture has formed us in powerful ways—in some ways that are healthy and in other ways that may not be. We don’t have to travel to foreign lands to have this experience, however. Leaving home and going away to college often prompts such reflection on our homes and families of origin.4 Learning a different language can also make us keenly aware of how deeply our worldview has been shaped by our mother tongue—the language system that has nurtured us since infancy in the ways of our culture.

    How does language link theology and culture?

    Theology is like a living language, a way of communicating meaning—even ultimate meaning—to ourselves and to others. Understanding how language functions in transmitting culture has six important implications for how we understand our practical theological task with youth.



    First, theological doctrines do not arrive prepackaged from on high, but are always constructed using the available tools of a particular culture.

    Tool time

    Because each culture brings different tools to the job, theological reflection arising in different cultural settings bring different theological truths to the surface. Can the same be said for youth and the culture they inhabit? What special tools do young people bring to the task of theological reflection? What truths might youth be able to discern in the Christian story that adults (with different tools) might overlook?

    Just as an artist uses available materials for an art project, a theologian draws upon the language, imagery, and cultural forms available in the immediate environment. Recall how Jesus told parables based in the common business and sociopolitical life of first-century Palestine. Fifteen centuries later Martin Luther led a church reformation movement by translating the Bible into German and describing the gospel in ways that were publicly accessible. And four centuries after that, Martin Luther King Jr. drew from African-American cultural resources to reinterpret biblical images and proclaim a theological message that addressed his country’s legacy of slavery and racial segregation. What we bring to the theological task depends upon the available tools in our cultural toolbox. If our toolbox doesn’t have a hammer, we might not notice how helpful nails can be until someone arrives with a hammer and shows us how to use it. We might spend all our time screwing in screws instead. In a similar vein, biblical scholars learn ancient Hebrew and Greek so they’ll have a wider range of tools to use in interpreting Scripture. They realize that the tools we bring to a task determine in large part what we can contribute to the task. And they know that learning to use different cultural tools gives us access to different theological understandings.

    A panoramic view

    Don Richter contends that if we understand the way language functions in culture, we can better grasp the way theology functions in culture as well. He outlines six ways theology operates as a kind of language for Christians:

  • Theologies are not universal, but are constructed with the tools available in a given cultural context.
  • Theologies both shape their host cultures and are shaped by them.
  • Theologies transcend contemporary cultures by pointing to realities beyond the culture.
  • Just as we are born with the innate capacity for language, we are born with an innate capacity for faith that comes into being through concrete religious practices in particular faith communities.
  • Theologies are partial and may not explain the fullness of God.
  • As in language, the broader our theological vocabulary, the larger our repertoire for perceiving God in the world.
  • Those who minister with youth need to draw upon every available tool in constructing theologies that speak to the cultural contexts of young people. The task before us is daunting: “In the first decade of the 21ST century, America can anticipate the largest generation of teenagers in its history, one even larger than the baby boomer generation that entered its teens four decades ago.”5 Good resources from the past will be available, but the theological reflection necessary to ministry in the 21ST century does not already exist on bookshelves or in seminary classrooms. Evangelizing the millennial generation will require the most talented, well-trained, energetic, and faithful group of adult leaders in the history of North American Christianity.6



    Second, just as theology is profoundly shaped by its host culture, theological claims and concepts powerfully shape culture.

    Even a casual observer of the North American scene would concede that the expression “religion and politics don’t mix” is, from a descriptive standpoint, both inaccurate and misleading. Consider the role religious values play in shaping school curriculum (for example, evolution versus creation), in framing ethical issues surrounding abortion, and in mustering support for or opposition to capital punishment. Our convictions about God and the nature of things—in light of God’s creative and redemptive activity—inevitably influence our positions regarding public policy and political decision-making.

    Ponderable

    Does the word Whatever! in young people’s vocabulary suggest that they have a “passion for tolerance”? Does a Christian passion for tolerance extend to those who are intolerant of others?

    Many teens consider their personal faith an important resource for participating in the wider culture. Fewer teens, though, consider theology a constructive resource for influencing culture. Theology gives faith a public face, a way to communicate our personal faith to others. Yet the face of theology that teens often witness is not pleasant to behold. At home and abroad, youth observe how theology is wielded as an ideological (and sometimes a literal) ax for chopping down all opposing positions. Youth ministry, then, must prepare teens to engage culture with a spirit—and a public face—that is generous and non-defensive. To become responsible agents in the public realm, young people must be nurtured by a passion for tolerance as well as a passion for truth. As a Quaker pacifist once put it: “Tolerance is the battlefield on which the struggle for truth is to be waged.”7

    Holding together a passion for truth and tolerance is not an easy task. It’s easier to have a passion for truth or tolerance rather than for both. We’ve already mentioned people who have such a zeal for truth that they would rather be right than reconciled. Other people show a basic level of respect for others but have no desire to discern or live in obedience to Truth. They have an indiscriminate tolerance, an anything goes attitude that refuses to take a stand or be guided by principles and convictions. And then there are people who exhibit a general apathy toward both truth and tolerance.

    Ponderable

    Some theologians believe that our language determines what we can know. In other words, we can only know those things that we can express.1 Is it possible to know God without having a language to describe God? Do we need a theological language before God becomes real for us?

    Fortunately, most teenagers have zeal for both truth and tolerance. Youth leaders can familiarize teenagers with theology as a resource for influencing their host culture. When teens learn to articulate and defend their faith perspectives in public settings, when they learn to use language that is broadly accessible rather than resorting to the use of in-house slogans and private code phrases, they discover their political agency and claim their voice as public theologians. (See related point six below.)



    Third, since theology is an activity of a living faith tradition, theology has the capacity to transcend or point beyond the limitations of its host culture.

    My host culture tells me that day begins at sunrise and that time is best measured by digital clocks that count seconds, minutes, and hours. A theological account of time, based on my Christian faith tradition, informs me that day begins at dusk rather than dawn (see Genesis 1) and that the kind of clocks I depend on were invented by Benedictine monks to call their community to prayer at set hours during the course of a day.8 God’s idea of time has little to do with mine. Theology helps me see a truth that is obscured by the temporal limitations of my native culture.

    Of course, it is possible for a theological agenda to be so thoroughly determined by the prevailing culture that precious little light can shine through its self-made prison walls. Lest we Christians be smug, we should remember that both Nazi Germany and apartheid South Africa were defended in the name of Christianity. And yet, because Christian theology is always accountable to the gospel of Jesus Christ, light will always break through even in situations of deep darkness.

    Archbishop Desmond Tutu has described the gospel’s illuminating power to expose and overturn the distorted, racist worldviews that were promulgated under the banner of Christianity in his homeland:

    There is a story, fairly well known, about when the missionaries came to Africa. They had the Bible as we, the natives, had the land. They said, “Let us pray,” and we dutifully shut our eyes. When we opened them, why, they now had the land and we had the Bible. It would, on the surface, appear as if we had struck a bad bargain, but the fact of the matter is that we came out of that transaction a great deal better off than when we started. The point is that we were given a priceless gift in the Word of God: the gospel of salvation, the good news of God’s love for us that is given so utterly unconditionally. But even more wonderful is the fact that we were given the most subversive, most revolutionary thing around. Those who may have wanted to exploit us and to subject us to injustice and oppression should really not have given us the Bible, because that placed dynamite under their nefarious schemes.9

    When democratic change finally did occur, South African religious leaders resisted efforts to dehumanize and persecute those who had held power. “To dehumanize someone is to commit blasphemy by dishonoring the image of God in that person,” Tutu proclaimed. Grounded in the power of the gospel rather than in the cultural script of revenge, South Africa established a Truth and Reconciliation Commission to undertake the painful but necessary task of beginning the healing process among all of its peoples.

    Ponderable

    Why do you think our culture casts teenagers in the roles of questers, consumers, tourists, and exotic pagans? Which of these scripts do teenagers seem to play out most often in your context for ministry? Can you think of other cultural scripts we hand to young people?

    We’ll return below to consider the gospel’s capacity to transcend and transform its host culture. For youth ministry, the implications of this culture-transcending dynamic are substantial indeed. Christian faith provides youth with critical leverage over the limited range of cultural scripts they are handed and expected to perform. These scripts are cultural expectations that ask teenagers to accept prevailing views of adolescence, casting teens in a variety of roles: questers on a psychological journey of self-discovery; consumers of culture rather than persons who help create and shape their culture; tourists wandering aimlessly through a period of life rather than pilgrims seeking a destination for their souls; or exotic pagans who have their own subculture that requires (adult) youth workers to be interpreters, field guides, and missionaries.10

    Ministry that encourages youth to discern their vocation—their life calling—can free youth to be the persons God calls them to be. Cultural scripts must still be negotiated, but Christian teens can be set free within the context of these scripts to fashion their own personhood as disciples of Jesus. Learning the language of Christian faith is essential to discerning God’s call, for this language invites us to step out of our socially-defined roles and pay attention to the way of abundant life God sets before us. This way of life will not be scripted or preordained, though, but will be more like improvisational theater with God onstage as a companion actor.



    Fourth, just as we are born with linguistic capacity that becomes activated through learning a particular language, we are also endowed with spiritual capacity that becomes activated through our participation in particular, concrete religious practices.

    It’s not uncommon, especially among postmodern people, to hear someone say, “I’m a spiritual but not a religious person.” Typically this means that the person appreciates religious ideas and perspectives, but chooses not to be affiliated with any specific religious tradition. What may feel like “spiritual liberation” to that individual, however, may simply be a repackaging of the values of the contemporary culture and the global marketplace. Taking cues from my surrounding culture, for instance, I might imagine “God” as my warm-and-fuzzy cosmic security blanket, and I might dismiss evil as “uncivilized behavior” or as a failed investment strategy. Without the anchor of specific religious practices that have endured over time, individual spirituality is cast about by winds blowing from every direction. Just as human utterance becomes unintelligible apart from its mooring in specific language, the activities of human spirit lose their mooring and larger significance apart from the logic and form of religious practices.

    While different faith traditions may emphasize a similar set of religious practices—worshiping, forgiving, caring for the downtrodden—the practices of each tradition point toward a distinct way of life. The Christian way of life is characterized by shared activities that address fundamental human needs in response to and in light of God’s redemptive activity in Jesus Christ for the life of the world.11 Christian practices address fundamental human needs and conditions, thereby involving practitioners in God’s activity and purposes in the world. People who are traveling or homeless are vulnerable and in need of food, shelter, and hospitality. People who are estranged need forgiveness and reconciliation. People who are ill need renewal and healing. By offering hospitality, forgiveness, and healing, and by doing so in light of the gospel, Christians confess that we participate in God’s providential care for all creation.

    The danger in talking about “Christian practices” is that we might delude ourselves into thinking that our salvation has more to do with human initiative and goodness than with God’s initiative and goodness toward us. As one wise preacher has put it: “By the goodness of God we have been born into this world; by the grace of God we have been sustained all the day long, even to this hour; and by the love of God, fully revealed to us in the face of Jesus Christ, we are being redeemed!”12 Christian practices are a means of grace by which God sustains us all the day long throughout our earthly pilgrimage. Indeed, when we participate in a Christian practice such as singing our lives to God, we join our voices with the communion of saints who have been singing praises and laments to God for thousands of years.

    Participating in Christian practices means becoming part of an ongoing, worldwide community—the church—that has been doing these things for 20 centuries, and that has wisdom to offer about doing them faithfully and well. Beliefs are very important, yet the primary form by which Christian faith has been transmitted—or institutionalized—from generation to generation has been through beliefs embodied as practices. In this broad sense, everyone who participates in Christian practices, in whatever setting and regardless of formal affiliation, is participating in the institutional church.13 A sports analogy: someone who plays golf participates in the ongoing institution of golf (with all of golf’s specific rules, customs, and lore) even if she doesn’t belong to a golf club or association, and even when she’s playing a round of golf by herself.

    To join or not to join?

    Don offers three reasons why a Christian should be a member of a particular, local congregation.

    What do you think of Richter’s reasons? Would any of these reasons be compelling for teenagers you know?

    So how important is it for a Christian to be a member of a local congregation? What if I can’t bring myself to join a local congregation because the members seem too hypocritical? Or what if I make an honest effort to go to church, but most of the time I feel like I’m just going through the motions? Here are guidelines to consider in response to these frequently asked questions:

  • Christians are called to life together in community. A Christian congregation is a face-to-face, intergenerational community that links people together in a network of care and accountability. A congregation initiates members into Christian practices—especially worship—and holds members accountable over the long haul for practicing their faith on a daily basis. Congregations also provide a place for corporate solidarity in the face of immense pressures urging cultural conformity. Youth ministry is called to build bridges between teens and local congregations, and to assist youth in finding a congregational home in which their faith can be shaped and nurtured.
  • Since the days of the early church, Christians from diverse congregations have been linked by a set of common practices. That’s why Paul’s letters to the congregations in Rome and Corinth were included in the Bible. The apostle Paul addressed local concerns in such a way that even today, almost 2,000 years later, congregations benefit from reflecting on their faith community in light of these letters. Paul knew that every congregation has its vices as well as virtues, and that some congregations are deeply conflicted by a spirit that seems more destructive than life-giving. Paul also trusted the Holy Spirit to blow cleansing winds of repentance and breezes of new life within Christian congregations. Youth ministry need not romanticize congregations, but can encourage teens to trust that the same purifying Spirit is at work among God’s people today.
  • The local congregation or parish is a vital form for Christian community. There are other settings, however, in which we can learn and participate in Christian practices. Study groups, soup kitchens, parachurch organizations, mission trips, and campus ministries are but a few of the contexts in which faith can be nurtured and enriched. Indeed, experiencing the vitality of Christian practices in a variety of settings helps us focus our spirituality and appreciate how Christian faith extends into every sphere of life. And Jesus did promise that wherever two or three are gathered in his name, he would be in the midst of them (Matthew 18:20). The task for youth ministry, then, is for youth leaders to become more deeply involved in soul-shaping practices of faith ourselves—within congregations and beyond—so that our own lives will have integrity and so that we can invite teens to join us in a work-in-progress.14
  • Fifth, thinking about how culture functions like a language provides a framework for living faithfully in our postmodern context.

    In the premodern view of the medieval world, the assumption was that everyone could best understand the world by looking at it the way the church did. If everyone chanted the same hymns (in Latin!) and peered together through the stained glass window of faith, everyone would understand the world in the same way. If folks didn’t happen to see the world the way the church did, well, they just needed their vision corrected—nothing a little Inquisition couldn’t fix!

    In reacting to this premodern worldview, the modern view insisted that people would best understand the world by speaking the common language of science and by observing reality objectively through the clear window pane of reason. The modern worldview of the Enlightenment did not believe coersion was necessary. Modernists were convinced that anyone gazing through a telescope or microscope would observe the same thing. Those who refused to see the world through the eyes of reason were simply choosing to live in ignorance, they surmised.

    In reacting to the hubris (overconfidence) of modernism, postmodernists reject the notion that there is any objective platform from which everyone can share the same view of reality. Instead of observing through clear glass, we find ourselves viewing reality through a kaleidoscope—the image changes when viewed from different angles by different persons. Instead of using the common language of science or Esperanto to describe the world, we recognize how different languages provide different yet valid ways of perceiving reality.15

    Today, some of us may choose to relate to the world primarily through stained glass and hymn singing—including an occasional Latin chant—but in a postmodern context we no longer assume that this is the only correct way to know reality and relate to the world. Even Christians have different ways of viewing the world, since every stained glass window is different. And though we believe that God has been revealed to us in Jesus Christ, human knowledge of divine truth is always partial and imperfect.

    Culturally, we respect that all knowledge—like language—is local, intersubjective, and community-specific. Theologically, as Christians we do not presume to know how persons of other faiths are experiencing God in their lives. If we are concerned about the spiritual well-being of friends, neighbors, and strangers who are not Christian, we must make the effort to understand how they perceive and relate to God. We must pay careful attention to their life stories—for stories convey our hopes and fears, our joys and sorrows, our faith convictions and deep yearnings. The stories we tell about ourselves, disclose the practices that give our lives meaning and purpose (see above).

    The challenge for youth ministry is to invite persons into communities that have been deeply formed by the stories (as well as practices) of Christian faith. This is not an easy task, for popular culture dismisses stories and proclaims “image is everything.” Images are impressionistic and appeal to us at the gut-level of feelings and impulses. That’s why the image is king in the advertising business. Advertisements suggest opportunities to individuals but rarely present and defend truth claims that are subject to communal accountability. From an early age, children are taught to consume advertising images so that by the time they are teenagers, they have learned to be consumers of culture rather than creators of culture. Even so-called youth culture is produced primarily by adults and sold to teenagers as a commodity. The power of advertising imagery persuades teens that they must purchase their way into youthhood rather than inheriting it by virtue of their chronological status.16

    The Christian faith story, on the other hand, teaches us that the image of God trumps any other images by which society may label us. Learning what it means to be created in the image of God requires more than reciting slogans and listening to sound bites. Youth yearn for deep familiarity with the biblical story that has been told and treasured for 2,000 years. Youth leaders need to resist moralizing and proof-texting and instead find creative ways for youth to encounter the Bible as Scripture (authoritative writings). We trust that the Bible will stake an authority claim on the lives of teenagers when we teach them to sing hymns of praise and psalms of lament; when we invite them to mime, paint, or sculpt a biblical scene; when we direct them in performing the role of biblical characters in plays and musicals. Simply by sharing the biblical story with teens, we provide them with a life-preserving, narrative anchor in a sea of cultural flotsam and jetsam.17

    Ponderable

    Christian ethicist Paul Lehmann defined koinonia as “the fellowship-creating reality of Christ’s presence in the world.”1 Would you say this is the same thing as Richter’s “communities of accountability and care”?

    Communities shaped by the Christian story are characterized by accountability and care. The postmodern market economy appeals to our capacity to choose (products), but is not equipped to hold us accountable for our choices and doesn’t care whether we choose wisely. Market interests actually benefit from the fragmentation of institutions such as families, schools, and congregations. The logic is simple: Weak institutional loyalties lead to fragile relationships and a lack of trust that one will be cared for by others. Therefore, one must become self-reliant and care for oneself. The market makes available—for a price—a variety of panaceas and strategies for self-care. Business leaders don’t necessarily conspire to undermine social institutions, but they do have a vested interest in sustaining their market share in a competitive economy.

    Youth ministry should strengthen and hold accountable those primary institutions that care for teens on a daily basis. We cannot afford an attitude of ironic detachment or casual disregard for the schools youth attend and the families with which they share a household. Theologically, we view these institutions as instruments of divine providence, as social structures God has provided for our nurture and well-being. Some youth ministries currently partner directly with area colleges, high schools, and middle schools. Other youth ministries advocate family-based youth ministry instead of age-segregated youth groups.18 Becoming a community of accountability and care for teenagers means helping them make wise and responsible choices within the various institutions that support them on a daily basis. In a postmodern era, we cannot expect society in general to teach teens how to live responsibly and faithfully.



    Sixth, just as familiarity with different languages makes us aware of the different ways people perceive and describe the world, familiarity with the vocabulary of other faith traditions can help us appreciate the diversity of God’s creation and the mystery of God’s gracious love for all people.

    Day by day, the religious landscape of North America is becoming more diverse. Most teens have friends, classmates, and e-mail correspondents of various religious backgrounds. Christian teens view persons of other faiths not with anthropological curiosity but with heartfelt concern for their salvation. “Sandra is my best friend at school and she is Hindu. My faith tells me that we can only be saved through faith in Jesus Christ. Does this mean that Sandra will not be saved and that she will go to hell? How can this be fair?! Sandra’s a much better person than I am.”

    More ways than one?

    Catholic theologian Hans Kung suggests that instead of insisting on the axiom, “There is no salvation outside the church,” Christians would do better to insist: “There is salvation inside the church!”1 Richter suggests that in a postmodern context, we can no longer assume that our way of knowing reality and relating to the world is the only way of doing so. “As Christians,” he writes, “we do not presume to know how persons of other faiths are experiencing God in their lives.”

    Do you agree? Are Kung and Richter compromising Jesus’ exclusive claims of salvation (cf. John 3:18; 14:6), or providing a viable alternative for sharing the Christian story in a postmodern culture? As a Christian youth minister, how do you see yourself relating to young people of other faiths?

    A youth leader could use this occasion to say a truthful word about how salvation is a matter of grace rather than good works, yet this would still not satisfy the more urgent concern being expressed about Sandra’s well-being as my friend. Youth leaders can help teens identify the ways we are interconnected with others, as well as the ways in which we are different from one another. We can then approach our neighbors with the attitude that together, we can both learn more about the life of faith and the world around us, without surrendering our deepest convictions or requiring others to conform to ours. The ground rule for interfaith dialogue is that all partners remain both committed to their respective faiths and open to the insights of others.19

    Christians believe that God was specifically revealed and embodied in the person of Jesus of Nazareth, whom we confess is Jesus the Christ (the Messiah). This is the good news we have received that we are eager to share with others, including persons of other faith traditions. Testimony means bearing witness to the truth as we have seen and heard and experienced it. Truthful speech is not coercive or manipulative but has a way of opening up space for others to add their own witness to the presence of God in the world.20 Youth ministry should nurture teens in this practice of telling the truth to one another and to God. This requires attentive listening to the testimony of others, especially to those who live on the margins of our culture. By remaining open to the testimony of the outsider and the other, we remain open to mystery and to the new word God may have for us this very day.

    We’ve examined the interplay between theology and culture, showing how one term always points toward the other. We’ve also explored the crucial role language plays in mediating both theology and culture. Many of these claims would hold for any religious tradition, but some point more directly toward Christianity. In the final section, we turn specifically to Christian theology by investigating what incarnation and redemption mean for our understanding of culture, and we identify implications for our ministry with youth.

    Incarnation and redemption

    Christians believe that God is not just an abstract principle or distant cosmic designer. At the heart of Christian faith is the scandalous claim that God assumed human flesh—actually became human—and dwelt among us in the person of Jesus of Nazareth. In the midst of a Greco-Roman culture that viewed spirit as sacred and matter as corrupt, Christianity was considered an abomination by many because of its blatant concern for the material world. Throughout the pages of the New Testament, we read that the early church’s concern for people’s spiritual well-being always required concern for their physical well-being, too. To be fair, the Jewish tradition had a significant “this-worldly” emphasis that Jesus magnified in his teaching and healing ministry. But the doctrine of the Incarnation thrust the Christian community into a radically new relationship to culture—a paradoxical relationship that continues to this day.

    The accomodation principle

    Accommodation means to oblige or adjust oneself to another. Augustine described the Incarnation as God’s accommodation to human limitations. Since human beings cannot adjust to God, God adjusted to human nature and became one of us. John Calvin viewed Scripture as God’s gentle way of approaching human beings in a way we could grasp, since we are far too weak to handle God’s undiluted revelation. Citing Augustine, Calvin noted: “We can safely follow Scripture, which walks softly, as with a mother’s step, in accommodation to our weakness.”1

    Don Richter advises youth ministers to be guided by an “accommodation principle.” What would ministry look like in a congregation that took accommodation to young people seriously?

    First, in Jesus of Nazareth, the Almighty God graciously accommodated our limited human capacities and understanding, becoming embodied in human form (a man) at a particular time and place.

    Likewise, Christian faith does not come to us out of the blue, but always comes to us embodied through the concrete material stuff of our culture such as word, water, bread, and cup.

    Jesus typically spoke to his followers in Aramaic, his native tongue. Likewise, we believe that the gospel can be mediated to us today in our native tongue. Jesus encountered folks in the midst of their daily lives and occupations. Likewise, we believe that Christ can encounter and accompany us in the midst of our concrete, individual circumstances. There’s no naked truth, because Christian faith—like all other faiths—always wears the clothing of a particular culture. And yet, instead of designating culturally specific objects, words, and places as sacred, Christianity evolved as a religion that can make sacred use of any available objects, words, and places.



    This points to a second feature of incarnational Christianity: Christian faith relativizes every culture it inhabits, viewing no particular culture as more special than any other.

    For Islam, Arabic is the sacred language of the Koran, and Mecca is the holy city for the hajj pilgrimage. For Christianity, sacred Scripture can readily be translated into any language, and any place can become a sanctuary for experiencing the presence of God. The first Christians were Jewish, yet the early church determined that Gentile converts need not become ritually Jewish on their way to becoming Christian (Acts 10). God revealed to the early church that the gospel—the Good News of Jesus Christ—can be embodied in and through every culture. Indeed, the gospel has a way of infiltrating and eventually transforming every culture it inhabits.

    A Gen-Xer’s open letter to the church: tell the story

    Responding to churches’ frustration with how to reach Gen-Xers who think truth is relative and suffering is inevitable, Xer Sarah Hinlicky writes:

    “So, you’re in quite a pickle: you can’t tell us that the church has ‘the Truth,’ and we know that the church won’t miraculously cure us of our misery. What do you have left to persuade us? One thing: the story. We are story people. We know narratives, not ideas. Our surrogate parents were the TV and the VCR…You wonder why we’re so self-destructive, but we’re looking for one story with staying power, the destruction and redemption of our own lives. That’s to your advantage: you have the best redemption story on the market.”1

    Youth ministry must be guided by this accommodation principle. We must not expect teenagers to bear the primary burden of accommodating themselves to our agenda, schedule, and program design. We begin by discerning how to accommodate our ministry to the capacities and life-worlds of teenagers. This does not mean simply throwing our hands up in despair because young people in our town are already over-programmed. Accommodation first means making room for youth in our hearts and minds, paying attention to where youth gather and how they spend their time, energy, and money. Youth leaders need to go where youth already are and address them within the context of their daily lives.

    Today going where youth already are involves forays into cyberspace as well as trips to the local mall. Responsible youth ministry will learn to make use of a wide range of cultural media for communicating gospel, including the Internet and the World Wide Web.21 But the accommodation principle does not mean that all forms of communication with youth must be explicit and direct. Sometimes the most powerful forms of communication are indirect. When the scribes and Pharisees grumbled about Jesus’ poor judgment in choosing dinner companions, Jesus did not launch into a lecture about the virtues of God’s come-as-you-are, open-table eating policy. That would have been direct communication. Instead, Jesus told three short stories—parables—about a shepherd searching for a lost sheep, a woman searching for a lost coin, and a father longing to be reunited with his two lost sons (Luke 15).These three stories communicate indirectly to Jesus’ accusers that God cares for everyone who is lost, including those who are lost due to stubborn self-righteousness. Jesus invites all who “overhear the gospel”—including his disciples today—to see themselves as characters in his stories of judgment and grace and to decide how they will now live in relation to the existence possibility these stories convey.

    Add to your glossary

  • Paradox: the holding together of two contradictory views without collapsing one into the other. A paradox from physics is how light behaves as both particle and wave. The Incarnation is the central paradox of Christian faith: Jesus Christ was both human and divine at the same time.
  • Redeem: to buy or win back, to free from captivity, to release from blame or debt, to repair or restore.
  • Storytelling is a powerful vehicle for indirect communication. So are other art forms such as drama, role-play, singing, sculpting, mime, mask-making, dance, film, poetry, and silent contemplation. The key to indirect communication is not the teacher’s technique, but rather the teacher’s focus and intention. For example, if I mime the story of blind Bartimaeus receiving sight from Jesus (Mark 10:46-52), I must perform the mime with passionate integrity and trust the Spirit to communicate through the mime. I can’t allow myself to become self-conscious about appearing foolish to my teenage audience. My direct focus is on the biblical story and on my own relationship to God whom I encounter in that story. Indirectly, my intent is to invite youth to decide for or against the new way of life—the new way of seeing—that this gospel proclamation reveals to them. As a teacher or youth leader, I must trust my subject matter implicitly and show radical respect for the freedom of learners to say yes or no to what is presented, resisting my impulse to interfere with their heartfelt responses, even when their responses are not what I had hoped for.22

    Unhelpful ways Christians relate to culture

    Here are four common attitudes Christians hold toward “the world.”

  • Christian yellow pages. “The world is evil and corrupt, so we must band together and develop an alternate culture to insulate our young people from contact with the nonredeemed world.” We are not called to insulate ourselves from others, but to go into all the world proclaiming the gospel of Jesus Christ.
  • Vaccination. “The world may be corrupt, but since I’ve been inoculated by Christian faith I’m immune to the seductions of culture.” Rather than being wary of the powers of darkness, we confidently assume that we are invulnerable to temptation. Our capacity for self-deception and self-justification is great; we need a faith community to hold us accountable, to help us detect, confess, and resist sin.
  • Sin’s a sham. “Persons who are enlightened by Christ come to see the world as good rather than as fallen, and come to understand sin and evil as illusions that have no power.” The cosmic struggle between good and evil continues, so we do not deny the very real consequences of evil’s potential to destroy and corrupt.
  • Pop culture preaches. “Since every human culture expresses religious impulses and longings—at least implicitly—we can simply immerse ourselves in popular culture to find God.” It’s one thing to claim that culture has religious significance and that we can reflect on culture (including popular culture) theologically. It’s another thing, however, to turn to contemporary pop culture for spiritual guidance and nourishment. Pop culture cannot “preach” unless we put it into dynamic interplay with the stories and imagery of the gospel.
  • But what if teens reject the invitation or misunderstand it? That’s precisely the risk God took in accommodating to humanity in Jesus Christ! God so greatly desires human freedom that God permits us to turn our backs and walk away from the fountain of new life and the table of grace. Yet even when we reject God, God still pursues us to offer us redemption. Of course, being Christian does not remove us from the world like some Invasion of the Body Snatchers movie. As described above, the Christian faith tradition has a complex and paradoxical relationship to culture.

    What does our experience of redemption mean for the way Christian youth relate to their surrounding culture? As Christians, we are called to be in the world but not of the world. Being in but not of the world means that Christians experience a profound sense of freedom in whatever cultural circumstances they find themselves. It’s helpful to think of Christian freedom as freedom from and freedom for. For example, Christians are called to be good citizens, to pay their taxes, and to support just laws and political leaders. Yet Christians are free from giving ultimate allegiance to anyone or anything but God. Knowing that God is our only true source of security frees us from anxiously trying to save and secure ourselves. This is important good news to share with teenagers who are (understandably) worried about their future prospects in a shifting global economy.

    Trusting God with our lives frees us from all cultural scripts that tempt us to be less than God is calling us to be. Teenagers live in a cultural era when public space that welcomes them is becoming more limited and when the range of socially permissible behaviors for them is becoming more restrictive. Christianity’s radical freedom provides youth with critical leverage over the limited range of cultural scripts they are handed and expected to perform. Teenagers—and all of us—need to hear the good news that we are more than the sum total of our SAT scores, our trophies, our résumés, and our net worth. The knowledge that sets us free is that we are created in the image of God; redeemed by God’s accommodation to us through the incarnation of Jesus Christ; and accompanied throughout our earthly pilgrimage (and beyond) by Christ’s Spirit who teaches us daily how to be in the world but not of the world. That’s real freedom, the kind of freedom that will give young people the theological wisdom to navigate their way through culture—including the Internet—for years to come.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑