Chapter 27 Assessing Honestly: Continuous Improvement
Chapter 27
Assessing Honestly: Continuous Improvement
Dave Rahn
At the end of each week, we must find ways to make peace with the worth of our work. If we don’t, we can get chased out of youth ministry by our insecurities and bewilderment. And so we routinely figure out ways to assess our ministries. Some of our efforts are formal; others are private mental exercises. These patterns suggest that the most pressing question is not typically whether we will do ministry assessment, but rather what kind of ministry assessment we will do. This question, and numerous derivatives, is profoundly connected to our theological commitments.
Some of us find it hard to not evaluate our ministries; we seem to be constantly working out our nearly involuntary judgments about how well a particular program, lesson, or even conversation went. Youth pastors cut from this cloth mentally replay their ministry encounters over and over, looking for the slightest indicators of health or sickness, strength or weakness, success or failure. Even subtle nuances of activity are scrutinized with microscopic diligence. Too many yawns during the evening’s talk are instantly interpreted as a testimony to our ineffective communication. A first-time smile becomes the magnificent relational breakthrough we’ve been working toward—holding promise to usher in the next Great Awakening. Those of us in this camp assess our ministries through observable outcomes. Sure, we make too much meaning of too little information, but we can’t help it. Like some sort of result-driven junkies, we feel the need for more and more reliable data, believing that such information can offer us certainty and peace about how we’re really doing.
Others of us have achieved a remarkable, transcendental bliss about the whole notion of ministry assessment. We can immerse ourselves fully in ministry moments, concentrate on giving our best, and not be bothered by concerns about outcomes. Since our effectiveness indicators come from within, we are liberated from the need to be ever vigilant about what’s happening out there. We gauge a ministry’s worth by checking the pulse of our own efforts. Rather than monitoring results, these assessment strategies pay close attention to the processes of ministry. The worth of our efforts is judged on the merits of our efforts themselves. Many times these judgments can be made on the spot, in the “here and now” of ministry.
Even our reasons for doing ministry evaluation vary. Sometimes we’re driven by external obligations. A board, senior pastor, supervisor, or accountability partner is waiting to hear our assessment of how things are going. The year-end report is due, or a presentation needs to be made in order to secure funding. For someone—or something—outside of ourselves, we need to give an accurate report of our ministry.
At other times we may be interested in evaluation for the noblest of reasons. We feel the need to learn all we can about what works and doesn’t work in our ministries. Years ago I learned that, for me to be fulfilled in my work, I need conditions that allow me the chance to do the best and be the best I can be. It’s really important for me to have feedback loops that help me constantly assess and improve whatever it is I’m doing. Those of you who are put together like me would agree we “owe it to ourselves” to get accurate feedback about our ministry. Such an internal obligation represents a powerful motivation in our lives.
Assessment
We can certainly turn an assessment eye on other things. For example, many persons do a needs analysis before formulating ministry strategies—a type of assessment that focuses neither on an outcome nor a process, but on helping youth workers get an accurate picture of what ministry needs they should address.
Let’s reflect on our personal ministry assessment preferences. By meta-thinking our way through this, we may benefit from considering which of the preceding descriptions most accurately describe us. Are we primarily concerned with our ministry’s outcomes, or does the process of ministry get our closest attention? Is our sense of obligation for assessment primarily a response to others’ requests or are we addressing our personal need for integrity? If we locate the quadrant (see figure 27.1) that combines our chief orientation with our number one assessment motivation, we can concentrate on exploring the theological reflection questions that will yield the greatest personal benefit.
Figure 27.1. Assessment: personal motivation and targeted focus
Try this on. Jan is a youth minister in quadrant I who cares about ministry assessment largely because of the biweekly meeting she has with the senior pastor. It may also follow that this senior pastor is a bottom-line type of person, and so wants to hear exclusively about ministry results. The questions bomb away at Jan: How many kids have been attending? Have there been any significant spiritual decisions lately? Who has completed the discipleship program? How are camp sign-ups coming? A youth minister working in this setting very quickly learns what is important to her supervisor, and can be tempted to pay exclusive attention to those outcomes that are most measurable. That’s where our “nickels and noses” bias come from with regard to ministry assessment. As Larry Richards has pointed out, it’s not as easy to record clear observations about life change as it is to see how many showed up for Wednesday’s meeting.1 When we’ve got to point to immediate outcomes to keep the boss happy, it’s not hard to sympathize with the tendency to grab our data from the most accessible shelf in the store.
Rich’s “results orientation” is a little different from Jan’s. He sometimes wishes he were held accountable by a senior pastor—or anyone who knew anything about youth ministry. He’s a quadrant III person, driven to figure out what outcome measures will signal to him that he’s on the right track in all of his efforts. Sometimes his difficulty sleeping traces back to the fact that he can’t yet see the fruit that he wants so desperately in his ministry.
There are cautions we must attend to if we’re going to use ministry assessment to weigh outcomes—regardless of our motivation. The Bible makes it clear that the outcomes that ultimately matter the most are those that are attributed to God’s efforts, not ours. The psalmist writes, “Unless the Lord builds the house, its builders labor in vain” (Psalm 127:1a). Jesus indicated that each of us depend on God’s initiating activity to be drawn to him (John 6:44, 65). When we believe that we bring about uniquely God-based results through our ministry routines, we have fallen for the mechanical/technocratic myth of ministry.2 Paul rebuked the Corinthians for giving undue (and divisive) credit to the ministers of their formative past when it is clear that only God is responsible for growth (1 Corinthians 3).
Ponderable
This is the lie? Which of us doesn’t honestly have a vision of God-glorifying results in mind as we struggle to persevere in ministry? Isn’t the exercise of writing one’s vision statement, in fact, an exercise in painting a picture of desirable, measurable outcomes?
Some of our approaches to ministry evaluation belie our cause and effect misconceptions. Kenda Creasy Dean and Ron Foster illustrate this in a short case: “Eric’s relationship with youth will ‘cause’ them to develop an interest in Christ; the youth’s involvement in Sunday school will ‘cause’ them to know the Bible; their experience in youth group will ‘cause’ them to mature in their faith, and so on.”3 Here’s the lie in a nutshell: If we can count on the fact that our right efforts will bring about desired results, it should be fair to target outcomes as the focus of our ministry assessment.
So we shouldn’t pay any attention to results when we evaluate our youth ministries, right? Hold that thought. Luke reported on the early church in ways that have caused many of us to aspire to greater dedication, richer fellowship, a common life, reputations of integrity, and explosive numerical growth (Acts 2:42-47). These were observable outcomes, and the early church understood that they had received God’s blessing as a result of them. When the Holy Spirit interrupted Peter just as he was getting into the meat of his message to Cornelius’ and company, Peter drew upon this experience in a way that helped to untether the early church from its restrictive moorings (Acts 10:24-11:18). Paying proper attention to the right results can actually guide us to greater faithfulness!
What if you’re not necessarily inclined to look at results in ministry assessment? For example, Joey works at South Northville Community Church and thinks of himself as a quadrant II type. He also has a biweekly accounting with his supervisor, but the kind of questions he has to answer have very little to do with outcomes. His senior pastor wants to see weekly goals, asks how the youth pastor’s time was spent, and even explores how he (the head honcho) might assist the youth pastor with his current urgent projects.
Joni, on the other hand, doesn’t let ministry assessment keep her awake at all. She’s also highly motivated, but she has the overall sense that she can’t control the outcomes that will really matter 200 years from now, so she concentrates on trying to be the right person doing the right things by the kids she serves. Daily disciplines of journaling and reflection help her explore her own degree of faithfulness in ministry. Joni’s a quadrant IV person—self-motivated to evaluate and focused on improving herself.
There is a lot to commend process assessment to us as we minister. For one thing, as we’ve already observed, our partnership with God in ministry means that we do as we are told and leave the results up to him. This frees us to really pay attention to the details of our obedience. If you need a reminder of how important the little things are in our faithfulness to God, try arranging for an interview with Moses about why he didn’t get to go into the Promised Land. At the end of Israel’s desert training experience, God told him to speak to the rock for water. This must have been a little déja vu for Moses. “Wasn’t this the same place where thirsty grumblings resulted in a rock faucet appearing 40 years ago?” he might have thought. Of course, then he was instructed to strike the rock with the big stick God had given him (Exodus 17:1-7). Seems reasonable that he could do an encore this time. But God had asked Moses to speak to the rock this time, not strike it. Moses’ actions constituted a disrespect for God insofar as he wasn’t attentive to doing precisely as God wished. Details, details. Apparently, they were important enough to God that he benched Moses, keeping him from leading the Promised Land Victory Parade even after his distinguished run of faithful service (Numbers 20:1-13; 27:14; Deuteronomy 32:51). If ministry assessment helps us honor God by correcting our “good enough” ministry tendencies to conform to more exacting standards of holiness, it has served us well.
There’s a further consideration that suggests the way we approach ministry is an important ingredient in ministry evaluation. God is not simply sovereign over the outcomes of ministry; he also rules in matters of timing. As followers of the crucified Christ, we are aware that doing the right things in the right way doesn’t always result in immediately positive results. An evaluation of Jesus’ ministry effectiveness conducted on Good Friday would have yielded disastrously wrong conclusions. Similarly, if you were scouting Jesus’ team for future promise on the evening of their Last Supper, I’m not sure you would have concluded that Peter was the kind of person on which the new church could be built. Timing is a theological issue that must be accounted for in our assessment strategies.
God graciously personalized this lesson for me in my first few months of full-time ministry with Youth for Christ. While backpacking in the Smokies with me and a dozen others, a charismatic high schooler named Dave made an unusually strong commitment to follow Jesus Christ. His growth curve after that trip was almost as remarkable as the impact he seemed to be having upon his friends. The day we returned from the trip he convinced a friend to join him in his newfound faith. Troi and Dave forged an inseparable bond in Jesus, and I saw them at least once a day. We shared Scripture, prayed, laughed, and dreamed together about how God was going to rock their school through them.
Three and a half weeks after returning from the Smokies, everything changed. Dave and Troi were involved in a tragic accident at our office where they were both electrocuted. Dave was killed instantly; Troi was burned severely and would take months to recuperate.
Student body president and vice-president, co-captains on the football team, white and black best buddies…what a waste! The senselessness of this tragedy overwhelmed me. I remember asking—accusing—God if he really knew what he was doing. The Lord allowed me to vent—to pour out my pain. He then reminded me that he had never let me down and it wasn’t in his nature to do so now. I had to be patient. In the meantime I stumbled through the first funeral of my ministry. I met parents and tried to offer comfort when I was desperate for healing myself. The first time I met Dave’s father we cried in one another’s arms. In a remarkable show of personal grace, he thanked me for my investment in Dave over the past month! He had noticed the change in Dave since our trip together.
Here’s the real kicker. For the next four years I ministered through Campus Life in that school community. Each year I met someone I had not previously known who testified that his life was profoundly changed by the personal impact Dave made on them during the three-plus weeks that he walked with Jesus on planet Earth. Assess that.
So which is it? Should we evaluate processes or outcomes? It’s possible to infer that I believe one’s approach to ministry assessment is simply a matter of personal preference and style. I certainly do believe that our natural and circumstantial orientations become the default assessment strategies that we employ. But if our evaluation efforts aren’t rooted in biblical ministry values, then what values are we serving?
Look again at the matrix constructed for earlier reflection, but this time concentrate on the consideration of motives for assessment. Are there biblical ministry values that transcend the practical worth of doing assessment in order to meet someone else’s accountability demands? Connecting our ministry evaluations to external obligations testifies to the reality of interdependence of which the Scripture speaks. It suggests that we appreciate the call of Scripture to submit ourselves to one another, particularly to those who have authority over us (Ephesians 5:21; Hebrews 13:17; 1 Peter 2:17). We recognize the kingdom value of having our work scrutinized today, because we know it will be judged in the future (1 Corinthians 3:12-14).
The practical reasons we assess our youth ministry may include the need to meet external obligations, but submission is healthiest when it reflects an internalized value. We must be convinced that interdependence is a two-step reality. Unlike independent and self-reliant structures, the metaphor of the body suggests that we truly do need one another. Unlike dependent and other-reliant structures, it suggests that we have been uniquely designed to make original and meaningful contributions, without which others will genuinely be impoverished.
Ponderable
It’s worth pausing over the suggestion that ministry assessment, properly motivated, can be a spiritually meaningful exercise. Those who now do ministry assessment primarily because someone else is asking for a form of accountability—such persons may need to figure out how to turn this religious obligation into willing and free submission, if they’re going to realize a benefit to their own soul.
The highest forms of assessment can take place only when honesty and humility blaze a trail that honors truth above all else. This isn’t always easy; it’s the same sort of posture that earned Socrates the label as the gadfly of Athens:4 In the service of the truth, any question was fair game for this ancient philosopher. Douglas Hyde reported that this kind of attitude provided the climate for critical evaluation among Communist Party members as they critiqued their various campaigns.5 Knowing the truth was more important than protecting someone’s ego from being bruised. The nice thing is that caring for others and loving the truth are not incompatible in the economy of the Christian faith. Paul insisted that the Ephesians should contribute to one another’s growth by “speaking the truth in love” (Ephesians 4:15).
Honest evaluation can help us understand the true state of health in our youth ministries. It can also reveal something about our own biases and ill preparedness to make important judgments about ministry effectiveness. We can always see what needs cleaning up better when the lights are on. Assessment helps us make sure we’ve got enough candlepower pointed in the right direction to really improve our ministry effectiveness. Continuous improvement is a worthy, even holy, goal. As John Wesley wrote, “It is a great thing to seize and improve the very now.”6
Escaping limitations
Assessment conclusions based on our past experience are difficult to question. (Pride is a pervasive infection, isn’t it?) Yet it is exactly those experience-based assumptions that most often need to be scrutinized if we want our judgments to be accurate. Using an alternative way of knowing, such as the inductive method, may help us escape the limitations of elevating our own experience beyond its true value.
So what does good assessment look like? For one thing, it probably appreciates the multiple ways of knowing that are available to us. Rick Yount points out that there are at least six different lenses through which we understand the world around us.7 When applied to youth ministry assessment, these various approaches describe familiar practices. For instance, we use common sense to determine that the retreat we planned around winter sports had trouble attracting kids because the unseasonably warm weather didn’t produce any snow. At another time, we deferred to professional authority to help us understand something beyond our own expertise—that a kid’s psychiatric disorder was the major influence in his bizarre behavior. Many times we’ll draw assessment conclusions informally, while we’re in the middle of the action, listening to our Holy Spirit aided intuition as to whether a particular time might be right for a particular confrontation with a young person. Of course, most of us lean on our past experience to help us evaluate current situations. Youth ministry veterans may have difficulty getting beyond this “been there, done that” version of ministry assessment. When logic or deductive reasoning are used to help us evaluate our ministries, we have reasoned our way from a true principle to an understanding of specific situations. For example, if we know that crowding has a positive effect on persuasion,8 and that a particular meeting was in a cavernous hall, we may conclude that the impact of the message was not as great as it could have been. Finally, the scientific or inductive method may be used in assessment. This approach requires us to make a number of different observations (perhaps using a survey) and come to our ministry judgments based upon what we’ve discovered through various samples.
None of these approaches are entirely sanctified, just as none of them need to be godless. The following 10 questions may help us drag our ministry assessment practices into compatibility with our theological convictions. There’s no reason that we can’t honor God by continuously improving our ministries through assessment.
