Chapter 8 Focusing Youth Ministry through the Family
Chapter 8
Focusing Youth Ministry through the Family
Mark DeVries
Several years back, I received a curious invitation. I was told that a new book was in the works, to be called, The 10 Hottest Youth Groups in the Country. I was honored to submit a chapter, but as I mailed it off, I realized that soon everyone would know what I had come to know so well: Our youth ministry was, in many ways, anything but hot. Nonetheless, I looked forward to receiving a copy of the book to discover the fascinating accounts of other ministries from which I was certain to learn a great deal.
That was over five years ago. And I’m still waiting.
I never heard another word from the would-be editor. The book, quite obviously, was never published. And it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to figure out why: the hottest youth groups in the country, were, on closer inspection, doing a lot of little things faithfully, but certainly nothing outrageous enough to make The 10 Hottest Youth Groups a decent read.
Youth ministry is a messy, typically unspectacular vocation regardless of how many years we have under our belts. No matter how clear our model, how tight our evaluation system, or how much we invest in the work, it’s messy—not something that can be domesticated into policies or models or procedures.
But despite my realism, I have, for more than 20 years, had one consuming passion in my work: to find the most effective ways of leading young people toward maturity in Christ (Colossians 1:28). Early in my ministry, I became aware that having a group of on fire teenagers was often not a reliable predictor of whether those students would grow to be men and women living with a passionate love for Christ as adults. And after years in this business, I have been disappointed again and again when some of our most committed youth group kids would head off to college and into adulthood without the sufficient spiritual infrastructure to make it as faithful disciples in the adult world.
It was in the context of these experiences that the whole notion offamily-based youth ministry1 began taking shape for me. And over the past five years, I have been fascinated by the broad-based groundswell of interest in this whole approach to youth ministry. In charismatic groups and to groups that are terrified of charismatics, in traditional groups and groups that despise tradition, in denominational groups and in groups that insist on calling their denomination “nondenominational,” in conservative groups, liberal groups, and even in groups that have trouble finding any theological common ground, I have found youth leaders embracing the principles of family-based youth ministry.
Ponderable
What comes to mind when you hear the phrase family-based youth ministry? How does it fit with your understanding of the basic task of youth ministry?
Though this vision of youth ministry has created a great deal of interest, it has also stirred up a good deal of confusion. Some see it as synonymous with abandoning all traditional youth programming. Others see it as a way to place the entire responsibility for the Christian nurture of teenagers on their own parents. And a few see it as just another good thing to add to their already overloaded job description.
This chapter will provide some clarity and perspective to those seeking to understand and hopefully engage in a family-based ministry. To simplify my explanation, I have organized my thoughts around four basic questions: Why? Who? What? How?
The why of focusing youth ministry through the family
“With all the kids I know who make it, there’s one thing they all have in common: individual contact with an adult who cared and kept hanging in there.”
—Barbara Staggers, counselor and physician at Children’s Hospital Teen Clinic in Oakland, California, quoted in Rolling Stone, December 9, 1993
For the past decade or so, I have maintained the somewhat controversial position that youth ministry today is in crisis. When I use the word crisis, many are quick to point out all the positive signs in youth ministry today. They point to the many churches reporting record numbers of young people active in their programs. They remind me of all the parachurch organizations and national church ministries that have found ways of attracting unprecedented numbers to their events. And they document the staggering number of youth ministry practitioners who are drawn to national youth worker training events.
But when I speak of the crisis in youth ministry, I am not suggesting that traditional youth ministry models have failed to get students and their leaders to attend meetings. I readily admit that we have become quite proficient at that process. But I still insist that there is a crisis.
Observe the following markers:
George Barna’s research indicates that in spite of the fact that more and more youth are participating in our programs, those teenagers are not growing up to be adults who participate in church any more than they did almost 30 years ago. In 1988, he wrote—
Since 1970, there has been no appreciable change in the proportion of adults who attend church services at any time during the week. This is true in spite of a growing number of churches, increased church spending for advertising and promotion, and the availability of more sophisticated techniques for informing people of a church’s existence.2
Additionally, by 1996, Barna was documenting a relatively steady decline in the levels of adult participation in church and in Christian education over the previous decade.3
A controversy
Some agree with Mark DeVries on this point, and others don’t. As one youth ministry vet put it, “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it—and youth ministry ain’t broke.” Do you agree with the severity of this perspective? Has youth ministry failed in its mission to train mature disciples?
The crisis in youth ministry is, simply put, that we have not been effective in leading our young people to mature Christian adulthood. Even with the massive increase in funding and training for youth ministry, even with the professionalization of youth pastors, even with the exponential increase in the number of resources available to those of us doing youth ministry, we are seeing no appreciable increase in the percentage of adults in our culture who are living out their faith for themselves.
“It’s one factor we haven’t mentioned: our woeful inability as mainline Protestants to retain our young.”
—Will Willimon, Christianity Today, August 17, 1997, 17-18.
By way of illustration, consider how would we evaluate an automotive production plant that brought only a small percentage of its cars off the assembly line, ready to be shipped to customers. The managers could point to the efficiency of the workers on the assembly line, the new developments in technology, or the increased morale of the staff. But if the company was not doing what it was created to do, namely, to produce cars, crisis would not be too strong a word to describe the situation.
If you look deep into the bowels of George Barna’s Index of Leading Spiritual Indicators, you’ll find that when thousands of believers were asked to rate what churches do best and what they do worst, “creating programs for teenagers” came in dead last.4 And we are nearing consensus that the frightening decrease in membership in mainline denominations is directly related the failure of those denominations to retain their own young people.
We could point to any number of secondary reasons for our inability to lead our young people to mature Christian adulthood: Most youth ministries today are funded for failure, setting aside just enough money to guarantee a frustrated staff.5 Most churches hire youth staff and recruit volunteers only for the short haul, making it sometimes impossible for youth in the church to develop friendships with durable, available adults.6
But I am convinced that reasons like those are only secondary causes for our failure to lead children to mature Christian adulthood. The primary cause of the current crisis in youth ministry lies in the ways that our culture (and too often our churches) has systematically isolated young people from the very relationships that are most likely to lead them to maturity. Granting our children the “privilege of being left alone,”7 has created, in part, a wholesale epidemic of adult neglect of the next generation. This audacious claim is precisely the thesis of Patricia Hersch in her groundbreaking study of adolescence in America, called A Tribe Apart. She writes—
A clear picture of adolescents, of even our own children, eludes us—not necessarily because they are rebelling, or avoiding or evading us. It is because we aren’t there. Not just parents, but any adults. American society has left its children behind as the cost of progress in the workplace. This isn’t about working parents, right or wrong, but an issue for society to set its priorities and to pay attention to its young in the same way it pays attention to its income.8
The television series “Dawson’s Creek” comes as close as anything to demonstrate how adults perceive the teenage experience. The producers of the show (I’m guessing not an adolescent in the bunch) leave viewers with the impression that the town of Capeside would change little if there were no parents or other adults present. In the makebelieve world of “Dawson’s Creek,” it is, in fact, the youth who are the purveyors of wisdom about their world. And those over 18 are either hopelessly out of touch or have little else to occupy their time than interfering with Dawson and his friends.
Back in the 1980s, Mihaly Csikzentmihalyi and Reed Larson, in their book, Being Adolescent, startled us with their report that teenagers spend less than 7 percent of their waking hours with any adults, while spending approximately half of their time with peers.9 And today, more and more children simply fend for themselves, often under the dispassionate care of television and other technology, sometimes under the thumb of shameful abuse and neglect. Emotionally available neighbors, grandparents, teachers, or coaches are quickly moving to the endangered species list, as the pace of life topples over itself and the number of children who need care vastly outpaces the number of adults who choose to be available to them. And even many youth-friendly churches block the doors of adult worship to their teenagers, sometimes in the name of age-appropriate worship somewhere else, but more often because of a lack of willingness to speak (or sing) in language and form that youth can understand.
Though the statistics and studies on this isolation are legion, they often don’t accurately depict the desperate aloneness that so many teenagers feel, an aloneness acted out in the self-destructive actions of millions each year. The following journal entry of a teenage girl writing several years ago for her high school English class portrays the pathos of this alone experience in all its intensity:
No one is there…
My wounds are green and throbbing.
I can’t scream any louder.
If they were here now
They would see
That the beauty that was out is now in
And the rottenness that was in is now out.
But no one will come.
“More often than not, children are learning major value systems in life from the horizontal peer culture. The vertical structure is not there in adequate increments of time or intensity to do the job.”
—Gordon MacDonald, The Effective Father (Wheaton, Illinois: Tyndale House, 1989), 102.
It is clear that young people grow to maturity in general and to maturity in Christ in particular by being around those people who have such maturity themselves. Margaret Mead, the renowned anthropologist, warned of the dangers of what she called a co-figurative culture—a culture in which all learning is horizontal, and little or no learning comes from an older and wiser generation.10 The obvious limitation of a co-figurative culture, or what Robert Bly calls a sibling society, is that each generation has to re-learn (and often incorrectly) a value system that can give them coherence and meaning. And Mary Pipher (of Reviving Ophelia fame) even goes so far as to pinpoint this phenomenon as the cause of much of our current social ills:
A great deal of America’s social sickness comes from age segregation. If 10- to 14-year-olds are grouped together, they will form a Lord of the Flies culture with its competitiveness and meanness. But if 10 people ages 2 to 80 are grouped together, they will fall into a natural age hierarchy that nurtures and teaches them all. For our own mental and societal health, we need to reconnect the age groups.11
Cold war
Is it possible that what Mark calls “the segregation of our teenagers into their own ghetto” has become a double-edged sword? Adults seem not to know what to do with kids, and are often too preoccupied with their own lives to invest significantly in the young. Sensing this, the young tend to respond, “Okay, then, just give me my own room, money, freedom, and space, and I’ll be fine. Who needs you, anyway?”
Youth workers (and committed teachers, compassionate coaches, concerned parents—those adults who truly care for kids) are often caught in the middle of this subtle relational cold war. And this is Mark’s plea in this chapter: the youth ministry task is to mobilize a systemically committed barrage of adults in love with adolescents devoted to caring for kids as they are, where they are. This is the best hope of reaching a lost, forgotten, and alienated generation.
Do you agree? Is it too late?
Increasingly, the message of adult culture to its youth has become “You’re on your own.” And this isolation (intentional or unintentional) has placed our culture squarely atop a demographic time bomb, and more and more voices are reporting that they can hear it ticking. I am convinced, therefore, that the most chronic problem our church’s youth ministries must address is the segregation of our teenagers into their own ghetto. We may assume that spending money on a youth house or a state-of-the-art youth room is exactly what our kids need. But nine times out of 10, such traditional “youth-serving” practices serve only as a quick fix, patronizing solution, resulting in even more isolation of youth from the very people they need to be around to develop a mature Christian faith. Any approach to youth ministry in the new millennium must move beyond a myopic focus on programming and “relational ministry” done by a few enthusiastic, inexperienced, short-term, early-20s youth leaders who stay around only long enough to “wow” our kids. Our modern fascination with the professionalization of youth ministry may have kept us blissfully ignorant of our growing proficiency at rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic. Unless our new models of ministry can help our culture restore the “generational threads that used to weave their way into the fabric of growing up,”12 our ministries will be severely limited in their long-term effectiveness.
The who of focusing youth ministry through the family
Give me a lever long enough and a prop strong enough. I can singlehanded move the world.
—Archimedes
For years we have known that the statistics are out there. Though social scientists have trouble agreeing about much of anything, most are clear in their recognition of the incomparable power (for better or for worse) of moms and dads in the faith and character formation of their children.
Take, for example, the results of a study done recently by the National Center on Addiction and Substance Abuse (CASA). The survey of 1,115 teenagers affirmed the crucial role that parents play in insuring that their children grow up drug-free. They found a clear link between certain types of parental behaviors and children who are likely to be free of chemical dependency. Here’s a sampling of those parental habits:
But those of us over 35 don’t need to see the studies. The reality of our own parents’ influence is all too obvious. I can still remember the day several years ago when I looked into the mirror in horror, realizing for the first time, that I looked less and less like the guy in my high school annual and more and more like my father. And I hadn’t been a parent for long before I found myself saying and doing the very things my parents had said and done, even those things I had promised myself as a child that I would never do.
When I ask adults in the church to consider the influence that their parents have had on their own faith formation, the vast majority of them have little difficulty describing the immensity of that influence. And it is staggering that whenever I ask a group of Christian youth leaders how many of them came from a home in which at least one Christian parent was present, an average of 90 percent of the folks in the class raise their hands. Even in families where neither parent was a Christian, the adult children confess that they bear some undeniable marks of the value system they grew up with.
Across the nation, churches are beginning to wake up to the fact that often the most faithful, long-term leaders of youth can actually be parents of youth themselves. Here’s why: No one has more long-term interest in students than their parents. In Nashville we have gone against conventional wisdom and filled our volunteer youth staff with parents. Of the more than 100 volunteers who work weekly with our teenagers, the vast majority are parents of one of the youths in the group.
But as powerful as the influence of a parent is on the faith development of child, there is another influence that can be even more powerful. The book, Faithful Parents/Faithful Kids, documents a study of Christian adults, a study that sought to determine the most effective faith-nurturing practices for parents. What they found was that there was no single, across-the-board practice that worked in even a slim majority of families. Some effective parents required their teenage children to attend church, but the majority did not (over 50 percent actually quit going to Sunday school in high school). Some families (25 percent) had devotions together; the majority did not. And surprisingly few of the adults (15 percent) surveyed reported praying fairly often with their parents during the teenage years. For the researchers looking for a barn-burning discovery, the results had to be somewhat frustrating.
What the study did discover, however, was a singlefaith-nurturing factor that was present in over 90 percent of those surveyed. The authors wrote, “While we didn’t come up with a sure-fire formula, one thing was obvious: Those who stuck with their faith…had a half-dozen ‘mentors’ present during their growing up years.”14 It is this influence that we must lean heavily on as our youth ministries become increasingly populated with teenagers who do not come from Christian homes.
Emmy E.Werner, from the University of California at Davis, has come to a similar, well-documented conclusion. Since 1955, she has been studying resiliency in a group of 500 Hawaiians who were born into difficult circumstances (poverty, addiction, etc.). Her work was one of small number of studies included in Radcliffe College’s Landmark Studies of the 20TH Century conference this year. Her “landmark” conclusion? The strongest predictor of resilience (of children who grow up in abusive situations and then go on to live happy and productive lives) was “an adult mentor outside the immediate family—grandmother, a minister [for example]—who gave them a sense of being loved and important.”15
As adolescents go through the acute changes of their developmental years, they are likely to go through any number of psychopathologies. But in the vast majority of cases, these imbalances do not last. During these years when the ability to offend and stumble clumsily along is so great, teenagers need adults who will know the wisdom of waiting and remaining connected as the process evolves in its own timetable.
It is only when the church and family abandon their role of helping young people navigate that passage to adulthood, that teenagers look to their friends, their music, and the media as surrogate (and often tyrannical) mentors. For too many kids, the media steps into the gap created by our cultural neglect and gives them a map of reality—telling them who they are and what they need to think about. And there they learn the frightening lie that the only ultimate arbiter of truth is oneself. Alone again. Unfortunately, it is often the students who desperately need mentors who have the most difficult time finding them. As Judith Wallerstein discovered in her highly acclaimed study of the children of divorce—
Children of divorce, who need help most of all, may find it even harder than other children to find mentors…There aren’t many mentors in the shopping mall. Where are modern youngsters going to find them? Of all the children in our study, only very few found and made use of mentors.16
But there are signs of hope—islands of light—where kids are making it out of circumstances in which all the odds are stacked against them. Consider the story of Gene Rivers.
What about…?
A family-focused youth ministry inherently brings at least one significant challenge, if not clear danger: what about those students whose families are not connected to the church, or who do not want to be? How can a youth ministry program resolve this in attempting to implement the issues raised in this chapter?
He grew up in a neighborhood where kids going to Harvard only happened in pipe dreams and miracle stories. So one might naturally assume that after getting his Ivy League ticket out of the gang-infested world of his childhood, Gene Rivers would never look back. But now, at 48 years old, after attending both Harvard andYale, he is beating the odds again.
He’s back in his old neighborhood giving hope to a generation of would-be disposable children, providing an alternative to kids growing up in the crime-ridden streets of Dorchester—one of the poorest areas in Boston. The work of this maverick minister has caused Newsweek, somewhat surprisingly, to suggest that it may just be the church that holds the secret that traditional secular strategies have missed:
Now both sides [of the political fence] are beginning to form an unlikely alliance founded on the idea that the only way to rescue kids from the seduction of the drug and gang culture is with another, more powerful set of values: A substitute family for young people who almost never have two parents, and maybe not even one at home. And the only institution with the spiritual message and the physical presence to offer those traditional values, these strange bedfellows have concluded, is the church (emphasis mine).17
The secret found in Gene Rivers’ story may just hold the key to providing a lasting ministry to teenagers in our churches—suburban, rural, and urban alike. It’s about churches doing the one thing they are best equipped to do: build supportive, nurturing relationships across the generations, in essence, an extended Christian family.
The “who” of family-based youth ministry, is quite simply, then, the parents and an extended Christian family of adults partnering together for the sake of the spiritual formation of the next generation. When a student makes it to mature Christian adulthood, she can almost always point either to the influence of godly parents or to the influence of at least one available, durable, non-exploitive Christian adult who modeled for them what being an adult Christian was all about. Sometimes 20-something youth directors can make this kind of long-term, ongoing investment in a handful of students, but by and large, their age-driven transience severely limits their long-term availability.
The what of focusing youth ministry through the family
If we are going to learn a life of holiness in the mess of history, we are going to have to prepare for something intergenerational and think in centuries.18
—Eugene Peterson, The Contemplative Pastor
Several years ago, scientists in Canada discovered that the population of rabbits in a particular area of their country had diminished to frighteningly low levels. And loving mysteries, as scientists are want to do, these curious scholars set out to discover the cause of this dramatic shift in the rabbit population.
Their first assumption was that there must have been an illness killing off all these rabbits. But they could find no evidence of any such epidemic. Several years later, while they were still scratching their heads over the cause of the decrease in the rabbit population, they noticed an unexplainable increase in those same numbers.
At the same time, other scientists began to notice dramatic fluctuations in the area’s fox population as well. Again, they investigated the possibility of an animal-specific disease, and again they came up with nothing. Finally, another scientist read of this quandary and offered this simple solution, one which ultimately proved to be astonishingly accurate. Having observed the relationship between the fluctuations in the rabbit and fox population, this scientist discovered an inverse relationship between these two groups. As the population of foxes increased, the number of rabbits decreased; and when the fox population decreased, the number of rabbits increased.
He postulated that as the population of rabbits multiplied, they provided an ample food supply for the foxes, resulting in an increase in the number of foxes. But as the fox population increased, they ate more of the rabbits, resulting in a decrease in the rabbit population. And the resulting lower number of available bunny meals caused a decrease in the fox population, which consequently again made it possible for the rabbits to multiply more rapidly. The cycle was self-perpetuating.19
When the scientists limited their focus to a single group, they were unable to discover a solution. When we attempt to “solve” the crisis in youth ministry with a myopic focus on adolescents and their problems, we will likely find ourselves coming up empty as well. When our perspective of a problem is limited to what happens within a specific group alone, we will of necessity ignore the problematic interactions between groups. If we become too narrowly focused “on teenagers and their problems,” the solutions we are searching for will remain a mystery.
For me, family-based youth ministry is grounded in at least two texts from Scripture. The first is a passage that directs the people of God to be specifically attentive to the next generation and confirms the priority and power of vertical relationships between generations. Though the nuclear family is central to this process, it is the entire extended family of God’s people who are commanded to take responsibility for naturally and repeatedly passing on the faith to the next generation:
Hear, O Israel: the Lord our God, the Lord is one. Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength. These commandments that I give you today are to be upon your hearts. Impress them on your children. Talk about them when you sit at home and when you walk along the road, when you lie down and when you get up. Tie them as symbols on your hands and bind them on your foreheads. Write them on the doorframes of your houses and on your gates.
—Deuteronomy 6:4-9 [italics added]
The second text, from the New Testament, contains a direct command to every believer to run the race of faith well. But it is not so much the command as the context that is instructive for the vision of Family-based youth ministry. According to the author of Hebrews, we are to run this race well because of the kinds of people by whom we are surrounded.
Therefore, since we are surrounded by such a great cloud of witnesses, let us throw off everything that hinders and the sin that so easily entangles, and let us run with perseverance the race marked out for us.
—Hebrews 12:1
In Hebrews 11, we are introduced to a “hall of fame of faith,” of sorts, as the author lists 20 or so men and women who, by faith, obeyed God. And chapter 12 begins by pulling those characters out of the history books and into our lives with a compelling image. By way of analogy, we are asked to imagine that these men and women of faith are in the arena surrounding us, perhaps even cheering for us as we run the race of faith. Family-based youth ministry is about stacking the stands, surrounding kids with an arena full of godly adults (both living and dead).
And so, rooted in these texts, I define my own approach to family-based youth ministry in this way: Using the position of the youth ministry to access, empower, and connect students to the most effective sources of faith formation, namely the nuclear family and the extended family of the church.
As I have attended family conferences and discussed and explored the different changes in family-based youth ministry, I have discovered two distinct approaches: the family ministry model and the youth ministry model. The major distinction between the two is found in the answer to a single question—What drives this ministry?
The family ministry model
If a family-based youth ministry is driven by a desire to empower families, it would likely fit into the family ministry model. No one describes (and more importantly, lives out) this model of family-based youth ministry better than my friend, Ben Freudenberg at Concordia Lutheran Church in St. Louis. Ben’s perspective (well documented in his book, The Family Friendly Church20 is that the church’s primary job in youth ministry is to support the ministry that rightly belongs to the family.
Programming for his ministry, therefore, is driven not by the church or the youth ministry as much as by individual families. Ben sometimes refers to this approach as family-centered, church-supported. In larger churches, this model of ministry would likely be run by a family pastor who focuses on empowering and equipping parents to fulfill the vows that many of them took for the Christian nurture of their children.
They might also spend a good deal of time on what some in family ministry refer to as ambulance programs (systems, like Stephen Ministry, that help people in crisis) and guardrail programs (including programs like Marriage Enrichment, that prevent later, larger problems in families). This approach is likely the most effective way to assist and support families, though it may be less effective in leading young people (particularly those from non-Christian or nominal Christian homes) to mature Christian adulthood.
The youth ministry model
If a family-based youth ministry is driven primarily by a desire to see young people grow to maturity in Christ, it would fit into the youth ministry model. Over the past few years, I have often straddled the fence of my ministerial identity, not quite sure if I was a youth pastor or a family pastor. Though many family ministers are dear friends of mine and I believe deeply in what they are doing, I have come to realize that I am, by calling and by passion, a youth pastor. And though I am committed to healthy families, it is my passion for seeing young people grow to maturity in Christ that has driven me to work with families.
In contrast to the family ministry model, the youth ministry model accesses parents and significant other adults, knowing that this approach will always be the most fruitful process for helping young people grow in Christ. The distinction is subtle yet significant. In the family ministry model, the focus is on supporting parents and families with classes, counseling, and support; while in the youth ministry model, the priority shifts to building an intergenerational faith-nurturing community for the teenagers. Both approaches can reasonably be called family-based youth ministry. But my particular emphasis is on the latter model.
The how of focusing youth ministry through the family
First the good news: Across the nation, youth leaders are coming to recognize that ignoring families is no longer a luxury that we can afford in youth ministry.
“I loved coming home to a place where the first three pews celebrated my coming back from college.”
—Mary Price Maddox, describing her experience growing up in an intentional family-based youth ministry.
Now the bad news: The vast majority of youth leaders feel ill-equipped to work with adults in general and with parents in particular. In a recent Link Institute study, “working with adults” was listed near the top of the list of the hardest things about youth ministry. And similarly, “lack of parental support” was ranked very near the top of the greatest challenges.21
It’s the same message I have heard from youth leaders all over the country: family-based youth ministry is a great idea, but show us how to do it.
When I talk about implementing a family-based youth ministry, it is important to understand that I am talking more about creating an ongoing ethos in the ministry (what might be called a new normal) than establishing any specific program or programs. Family-based youth ministry is not, strictly speaking, a model but rather a foundation that I believe every youth ministry needs to insure its long-term impact. Therefore, the specific model of youth ministry a church chooses is almost irrelevant.
Suppose, for example, that your church wants to adopt Doug Fields’ purpose-driven approach to youth ministry. You need not choose against family-based youth ministry in favor of purpose-driven youth ministry. Instead, you would use Doug’s principles as your model for your youth ministry but undergird that program with the kind of family-based connections that will offer the structures for the long-term faith formation of your youth. Another church might choose to use the Logos model or a Peer Ministry model. Family-based principles are an imperative foundation for any of them. Regardless of the model, every ministry must find ways to build on a foundation of parents providing intentional Christian nurture for their children and students connecting to an extended Christian family of faith-full adults.
The implementation process for family-based youth ministry is, therefore, very different from implementing a specific model for a youth ministry. When implementing a family-based youth ministry, it is not necessary to put weekly or even regular programs in place all at once. As a matter of fact, the most effective implementation process takes years (it took us almost a decade) to put in place. I teach a specific long-term implementation process for family-based youth ministry that borders on being absurdly simple. Here it is—
“Year One: Experiment with one family-based program.
Expect limited response.
If the program is well-received, repeat it the next year.
If the program flops, try something else the next year.
Year Two: Repeat what worked the year before (if anything).
Experiment with another family-based program.
Again, expect limited response.
Year Three: Repeat what worked the year before (if anything)
Experiment with another family-based program.
By this year, you can expect that something has been well-received.
I jokingly summarize this anybody-can-do-this, four-year process like this—
Try something. Fail.
Try something else. Fail again.
Try something else. Stumble on one thing that works.
Repeat what works. Try something else…
You get the idea.
Since my implementation process essentially involves the creation or experimentation with only one new family-based program a year, there is little need for hundreds of program ideas (though they are certainly out there). Instead, I have found it helpful to categorize family-based youth ministry programming into two distinct types: (1) completely new, family-based events and (2) what I call “exfamized” events.
In the final analysis, though, family-based programs provide only the context for healthy connections to be made. It is the caring attentiveness of the older generation to the younger that is likely to make the most significant difference in the lives of the teenagers we touch.
I recently heard the story of an altar boy in a small village, who, as he was carrying the chalice before the priest, dropped the goblet, spilling the consecrated wine all over the floor. The priest responded by backhanding the boy, striking him in the face and shouting, “Never come back here again!” The child obeyed.
In a very similar situation, another altar boy in a different church committed the very same mistake, serving before the bishop himself. But the bishop reacted very differently. He winked at the boy and whispered, “You’re going to be a priest someday.”
The first boy grew up to become Marshall Tito, the abusive, tyrannical head of the communist party in Yugoslavia, who reigned with an iron fist for decades. The second grew to become Archbishop Fulton J. Sheen, the Roman Catholic bishop who, in the 1950s received an Emmy for his work on television, a role in which he positively affected hundreds of thousands.
May we who form the face of youth ministry in the next century, lead and train others to lead in such a way that when our youth grow to be adults, we will know that we have invested well.
