Chapter 2 The Changing Face of Adolescence: A Theological View of Human Development
Chapter 2
The Changing Face of Adolescence: A Theological View of Human Development
Chap Clark
[They] are passionate, irascible, and apt to be carried away by their impulses. They are slaves, too, of their passion…If the young commit a fault, it is always on the side of excess and exaggeration for they carry everything too far, whether it be their love or hatred or anything else. They regard themselves as omniscient and are positive in their assertions; this is, in fact, the reason for their carrying everything too far.1
—Aristotle
“The question for the new century is, How much longer will teenagers exist, at least in the form that James Dean made famous? Twenty years, tops, is my guess. Teenagers, as classically defined, are already dying out, or at least changing into something different. The buffer zone they once inhabited is being squeezed out of existence for two reasons: children are growing up faster than ever before, and adults are growing up more slowly.”
—Walter Kirn, “Will Teenagers Disappear?” Time (February 21, 2000), 60.
Citing the words of Aristotle and others, some people say that adolescents are the same as they have always been—free, unencumbered, wild, passionate, and disrespectful of those who have come before them (especially their parents). These people believe that adolescence has simply always been with us, and basically, when it comes to those in the midst of the transition from childhood to adulthood, things have not changed very much. But statements like these can just as easily be explained by recognizing that, out of context, remarks taken from history may not actually refer to what we postmoderns call adolescence at all. They may just as easily refer to young people who—then, as now—were simply upsetting the societal status quo. Notable perhaps, but not a description of the kind of adolescence that is the concern of churches and youth workers at the beginning of the 21ST century.
Other people claim that contemporary culture is changing so rapidly that our children and adolescents have been left behind by adults and have essentially been abandoned by the culture at large. These people argue that the result of this abandonment is a new generation of lost and broken young people who are struggling more than ever to find their way in the world. Still others see a bright future for the young because of the oft-reported optimistic character and values displayed by the generation known as the Millennials. This debate is currently being waged on several fronts, and the temptation for those who care about the young is to land in one camp over another.2
As with any generalized analysis of a complex phenomenon, all of these views have elements of truth and elements of oversimplification.3 Youth workers are rarely afraid to jump into the philosophical fray, and also report mixed reactions regarding the state and future of adolescence. But due to the dynamic nature of our task, youth workers frequently do more reflection—sociologically, psychologically, even theologically—on the fly than through careful deliberation.
Who are these people, anyway?
We tend to use words like adolescent, youth, teenager, student, and sometimes young adult interchangeably, although these terms have had fluid meanings over the past century.
Adolescent usually refers to anyone who has reached puberty but who has not yet made the vocational, ideological, or relational commitments of young adulthood.
Until the late 20TH century, youth simply meant anyone who was young or inexperienced, especially people in their late teens and early 20s. Today youth can mean anyone who is an adolescent.
Teenagers are those in the second decade of life. Recently, the media has dubbed younger teens tweens—a label that acknowledges a newly identified aspect of adolescence: the transition into teens.
The term student refers to persons in school—although it belies youth ministry’s historic middle class bias in favor of educated young people. Technically, of course, students may be old or young, and the church is called to minister to all young people in the name of Jesus Christ, not just to those who are in school.
The term young adult was coopted by church educators as a marketing device during the 1960s and 1970s when young people began to vanish from the pews like disappearing ink. Some denominational curricula informally adopted the term young adult during this period to refer to adolescents, in hopes that the term would flatter youth into increased church attendance (it didn’t work).
And then there are kids, the term young people often use to describe themselves but that sometimes offends on the lips of adults.
Should youth ministers describe their flocks as kids? What will you call the young people you serve in ministry?
For the past 40 years or so, youth ministry has been the normative title describing ministry efforts targeted toward adolescents. But it is rare when a youth minister stops to ask some fundamental of questions like, Just what is a youth? What kind of person am I trying to minister to? What are the distinctives between the students I work with in junior high and high school and the fifth graders who will soon be joining us? Most people who directly interact with adolescents believe that the culture has shifted in dramatic ways in the late 20TH century, and the pace of cultural change shows no signs of slowing down. These cultural changes have impacted the nature of adolescence itself, to the point that anyone who cares about children and adolescents has no choice but to take a new and careful look at how a postmodern, technological, and urbanized context affects the adolescent journey.
This is all the more important as we consider the theological mandate of the youth ministry task. We must care about what is happening in the adolescent world. The church is called to “declare [God’s] power to the next generation, [God’s] might to all who are to come” (Psalm 71:18). This is the ultimate reason for youth ministry. This passing on, however, becomes increasingly difficult in a changing world and community context. For those who are committed to “declaring the Lord” to adolescents, then, this chapter presents a theological response to what we know about the adolescent journey in a rapidly changing cultural situation. It is not only the cultural environment that is changing; social rules, norms, even the process of adolescence itself are changing. To those experiencing this critical and often difficult phase of life we are called to proclaim and model the hope of the gospel and the reality of a living God who cares. To care for those in transition we must take great care to make sure what we do in our ministry takes seriously the changing landscape.
The fertile soil of this ever-changing environment, however, does not nor should it ever change the core of the call. Jesus Christ is and will always be the only relevant and redeeming presence that a person could ever experience. When it comes to youth ministry, these constants remain:
Youth ministry, then, is the call of the church to relationally pass on the gospel to adolescents in any cultural or environmental setting. This means that we must know and understand, as much as possible, the population we are dealing with. Our message must never change, but in seeking to care for and reach the coming generations, our methods must change. This chapter focuses on understanding adolescents in a changing culture in order to best know how to change our ways of passing on the gospel to them.
At the outset it is important to note that this chapter is not primarily concerned with culture as a whole, but rather offers a focused understanding of adolescence in a changing cultural context.4 This chapter does take the view that a wildly adaptive cultural environment requires contemporary psychosocial developmental theories and assumptions about adolescence to be reexamined and contextualized. This is not to say that the basic elements of human developmental knowledge are “up for grabs,” but that how the framework of these and other related theories play out in a changing culture must be of concern to the theologically committed youth worker. These traditional theories have been and remain helpful general starting points for overview information regarding adolescent development. Youth ministry students would be well advised to learn all they can regarding different approaches to and views of human development. This chapter does not go into specific detail regarding any of the developmental theories. The point here is to understand the general issues that impact an adolescent so that theologically driven youth ministry can respond accordingly. Detailed human developmental theories are therefore outside the purview of this chapter.
What should be mentioned, however, is that many accepted developmental theories, developed primarily in the mid-20TH century, tend to view the adolescent journey as a relatively stable, predictable, and orderly—though sometimes difficult—process.5 For the past two or three decades, researchers and theorists attempting to more fully understand human development have been challenging many of these (and other) “tidy” themes and stages of development. But postmodern culture has tossed a proverbial wrench into the gears of developmental theory. In particular, such variables as shifts in cultural values and structure; changes in the family system; new research into peer relations; gender and ethnic differences; and new ways of thinking about morality, character, and ethics have become increasingly important in describing the nature of adolescence.6 As a result, this chapter will focus on these and other relevant cultural factors in looking at the changing face of adolescent development.
This chapter, then, is not:
Instead, this chapter will focus on the following two goals related to the latest trends in adolescent research that impact youth ministry:
Stages of faith?
As Chap Clark points out, “stage theories” still dominate discussions of human development. For example:
Stage theories’ relationship to faith poses special difficulties. While faith does mature over time, the question of how faith matures is unclear. Does God create us to be “hard wired” for faith to develop naturally under the right conditions, the way our intellects or our egos develop? Or does God bequeath faith by breaking through normative stages of human development, “messing up” developmental sequences by creating unexpected sacred sinews that hold us together in new ways?
Think about your own faith journey. Has it matured gradually and predictably over time? Has faith thrown a wrench into the welloiled gears of your personal growth? Have you ever known anyone whose faith makes them seem wise beyond their years, or childlike and open despite a lifetime of hardship?
What do the variety of faith stories suggest about the Holy Spirit’s relationship to human development?
Defining adolescence
The term adolescence is derived from the Latin root word adolescere, “to grow up,” and is most often considered to be the period from puberty to adulthood or maturity.7 Because the concept of adolescence as a life span phase is a relatively new idea, gaining currency in the social sciences only in the last 100 years, it is sometimes considered an “invention” of society.8 Some researchers credit the “pagan firebrand” Jean-Jacques Rousseau with introducing the new romantic ideal of free-spirited and passionate adolescence into Western society as early as the mid-18TH century.9 By using the term adolescere, the French philosopher Rousseau did play a part in the eventual acknowledgment that adolescence was a new social force to be reckoned with. But in calling for societal blessing for young adults’ behavior (encouraging them to delay the demands of contemporary adulthood), he was as concerned with describing sweeping cultural shifts while he observed them as he was arguing for a whole new social structure.
The earliest person to give developmental prominence to the notion of modern adolescence was G. Stanley Hall, a late 19TH century American psychologist. As Rousseau was seemingly elevating the appropriate exuberance of young adults, Hall pointed out that adolescence was actually a phase of late childhood. Hall, who has been labeled “the father of adolescent psychology,”10 has been credited with changing the social landscape by setting in motion new attitudes toward young people. Americans no longer thought of adolescents as “little adults,” but as older children in a prolonged stage of childhood.11 Whomever ultimately receives the credit for naming this newly emerging phase of life, by the turn of the 20TH century, adolescence had come to be accepted as sociological reality, and by the 1920s it was clear that the emerging youth subculture that was here to stay—although it was not until 1960 that there was common agreement among developmental psychologists that adolescence was a legitimate phase of the life span.12
It is clear from the history of adolescence that understanding and interpreting this phase of life has been developed primarily in the field of psychology. Hall was a psychologist who attempted to combine Darwinian theory with newly emergent developmental theories that correlated species evolution to species-specific development. His concept of adolescence was a key element in his developmental theory—that humans must go through a developmental process akin to the evolutionary history of the human species. To many Christians this may sound like a gross and heretical stretch of logic, and it soon ran aground among psychologists as well. But Hall’s theory opened the door for developmental theorists working more directly from a psychological framework to create developmental theories and systems no longer dependent upon Darwinian biology as a basis for understanding human growth. By the 1950s, Erik Erikson and others began to see human development as a psychosocial phenomenon, having to do with more than simply the mind and genetics but also mediated and affected by social realities and relationships. Currently adolescent research and discussion is interdisciplinary, for the complex nature of the adolescent process, especially as culture changes, must take into account not only psychological factors, but sociological and even interaction factors as well.
Theologians have only recently acknowledged the impact of adolescence on the church, missiological theory, or systematic theology. Although youth ministry has now become a staple of theological curriculum at all levels, there is almost no theological discussion—in print or otherwise—concerning adolescence. This trend may be waning, but as with many social realities, church leadership and thinking has a great deal of catching up to do.
Today, a generally accepted definition of adolescence has been summarized by developmental psychologist John Santrock, who calls adolescence “the period of life between childhood and adulthood…(the process) lasts from roughly 10 to 13 years of age and ends at 18 to 22 years of age, (however) defining when adolescence ends is not an easy task. It has been said that adolescence begins in biology and ends in culture.”13 Santrock offers as tight a definition as the phenomenon probably allows, for the entire adolescent experience fluctuates constantly and deviates greatly according to such variables as culture, locale, and familial health and makeup. But to understand adolescence, it is important to first define its parameters—where it begins and ends, and just what it involves.
Adolescence begins in biology
As noted above, the oft-cited beginning point of adolescence is puberty. There is debate, however, over when the exact physiological changes of puberty begin, and it is even harder to define for boys than it is for girls. It is relatively accepted, for example, that puberty for girls has been reported to be slowly dropping from as late as an average of 14.5 years old a century and more ago, to as early as 11 years old today. Whether or not the numbers are precise, there is strong consensus that a trend exists—puberty is beginning at an increasingly younger age. The American Medical Association, the United States Centers for Disease Control,14 and the majority of social scientists report this as demonstrable fact.15
Ponderable
How old were you when you started puberty? How old were your parents or grandparents when they started puberty? What ended your parents’ or your grandparents’ adolescence? (If you don’t know, this is a good time for a break. Give them a call!)
Because the beginning of the adolescent phase of development has been tied to the onset of puberty, it is therefore possible to assume that the psychological process of adolescence is beginning at a younger age as well. In other words, 30 years ago most people considered adolescence commencing around 13 years of age. Today it is seen as occurring at roughly the same period as the reported earlier onset of puberty, or around 11 years of age. It is interesting to note that these developmental shifts have taken place in both the physiology impacting adolescence and in the psychosocial factors that influence adolescence at the same time. Although most researchers are convinced that earlier menses (the final evidence of female puberty) is taking place,16 little attention has been given to the relationship between earlier menses and the psychosocial developmental process.17 The timing of and entrance into adolescence, then, is marked by a physiological (having to do with functioning of the body) event (puberty), but is generally described and discussed as a psychological (having to do with mind and behavior) as well as sociological (having to do with relationships and human interaction) event. This is why the developmental aspect of adolescence is often referred to a psychosocial phenomenon.
Vanishing markers
Adolescent psychologist David Elkind defines markers as external signs of where we stand “in the stages on life’s way.” Markers are signs that we are growing and changing. According to Elkind, “Markers protect teenagers by helping them attain a clear self-definition, and they reduce stress by supplying rules, limits, taboos, and prohibitions that liberate teenagers from the need to make age-inappropriate decisions and choices.”1
Elkind—like Chap—thinks that vanishing markers are reason for concern. Without markers, the distinction between adult and adolescent disappears, creating “adultified” youth (adolescents assumed to be fully competent to deal with complex adult issues) and “adolescent” adults (adults unable to individuate, and whose “self” is borrowed from whomever they are near at the moment).
What kind of markers do you notice among young people today? In the absence of socially sanctioned markers, do adolescents create their own? (If so, name some.) Or do they simply go without, and become “adultified youth,” as Elkind suggests?
Since most agree that the age of physiological development is declining, the question then becomes, Why is this important? For the purposes of youth ministry, if adolescence is beginning earlier than 30 years ago, then the ministry models designed during that era must be reexamined or outright rejected. The days have changed, and yet the majority of youth ministry models, philosophies, and programmatic expectations were created in the 1960s and ‘70s. Forty years ago a 12-year-old was a child needing the expertise of those in the field of children’s ministry. Today, a 12-year-old is an adolescent needing a different ministry focus. Clearly, to take seriously the call of the youth ministry task, we must be more committed to the continual contextualization of our theology than to the perpetuation of programs, models, and philosophies that no longer are appropriate for a changing adolescent culture.
Adolescence ends in culture
When developmental theorists attempt to define the endpoint of the adolescent journey, the most common reference is made to “culture.” However, across the centuries and cultures it has been far easier to demarcate the line between a child and an adult than between an adolescent and an adult. Unlike adolescence, the transition between childhood and adulthood has included clear markers distinguishing these two stages of life.18 Historically, these markers have included rites of passage and specific training for children preparing to take on adult roles in society. Once these rites and training are completed, the child is both equipped and expected to fulfill the role of an adult in his or her community.
What do we mean by maturity?
“When we talk about a mature person, we are talking in part about the healthy sense of identity and of self developed during the teen years. The kind of parenting a teenager receives and the social climate in which he or she grows up are critical in determining what sort of self-definition he or she will attain.
“Growth by integration is conflictual, time-consuming, and laborious…[But] once growth by integration has occurred, it is difficult if not impossible to break down…People who have a strong sense of self do not lose it even under the most trying circumstances…
“Substitution is the kind of growth suggested by the well-known adage, ‘When in Rome do as the Romans do.’…Such learning is not adaptive when it comes to constructing a sense of personal identity. A sense of self constructed by the simple addition of feelings, thoughts, and beliefs copied from others amounts to a patchwork self…Teenagers with a patchwork self have not developed an inner core of consistency and stability that allows them to deal with new situations in terms of past experiences.”
—David Elkind, All Grown Up and No Place to Go (Reading, Massachusetts: Addison-Wesley, 1984), 15-17.
Today the only real marker available to youth growing up in Western and urbanized societies is the process of adolescence itself. Some point to “turning 18 or 21” as chronological markers, due to the legal responsibilities and privileges associated with these ages. But few developmental theorists accept an arbitrary age standard set by a government as a cultural marker capable of ending the adolescent journey. In addition, the American judicial system, which is lowering the age of adult accountability into the early teens and lower, has essentially negated any credence this notion may have once had. If, as some historians claim, adolescence was invented “to prolong the years of childhood,”19 the invention has succeeded to the point where the process seems now to have no end. The “inventors” failed to prescribe when the child could (as in, be equipped) and finally should (as in, be expected to) become an adult!
If, as others suggest, adolescence itself has become the marker distinguishing youth from adulthood, an assumptive leap becomes necessary: “When the process of adolescence has been completed, the young person has reached adulthood.” The ambiguous endpoint of adolescence in our culture is a much larger question than this chapter can handle, but it is clearly cause for concern. When young people go through a process of “growing up into adulthood,” they must also be provided with some understanding of and appreciation for the end goal. With the media’s enticing encouragement, many contemporary adults are trying to live like adolescents. Adolescents, intuitively recognizing this, have little incentive to finish the process and become adults. Thus the adolescent journey continues to stretch into what centuries of human culture have considered the adult years.
Individuation: a key to understanding adolescent development
The primary and most basic goal of adolescence is known as individuation. Although there is some disagreement in social sciences regarding the exact definition, there is general consensus that individuation essentially means “becoming one’s own person.”20 When a young person begins the process of breaking away from the role of child in the ecology of the family system, she has embarked on a journey from which there is no turning back. This is the first step into adolescence, in which a young person intuitively recognizes that she yearns to leave the relative safety and comfort of the child’s role and become an interdependent, autonomous person.
Carl Jung made extensive use of this term throughout his writings. In Psychology Types, he states:
The concept of individuation plays a large role in our psychology. In general, it is the process by which individual beings are formed and differentiated; in particular, it is the development of the psychological individual as being distinct from the general, collective psychology. Individuation, therefore, is a process of differentiation, having for its goal the development of the individual personality.21
Ponderable
Why is it important for Christians to understand individuation as more that just “separation” from others? Humans are created in the image of God, who is Triune relationship, and we gather as one interconnected body of Christ. What implications does this have for a Christian understanding of self, in light of Chap’s discussion of individuation? How might Christians understand individualtion—“becoming one’s own person”—in light of a theology that defines us in relationship to God and others?
The concept of individuation has many uses in social science. In philosophy, for example, the term is used as “a means of uniquely distinguishing or identifying particular items or individuals.”22 Mostly, however, individuation describes a uniquely human developmental process. Margaret S. Mahler uses the term in describing what she calls the separation-individuation phase of early childhood (from roughly the fifth month following birth until the 36TH month). 23 In describing the process that occurs during this time, the separation-individuation process, she and her team coupled the concept of individuation with separation.24 Integrating Jung’s characterization alongside several others, individuation is essentially the process of becoming a unique person. This process actually occurs over the entire lifespan, but, as Jung refers to the process, is generally initiated and primarily developed during adolescence.
Mahler describes individuation as the process whereby a person achieves a level of independence from some external control and therefore becomes somewhat self-reliant (within the context of appropriate developmental expectations). But more recently developmental psychologists have used Mahler’s typology to define the adolescent process of separation and individuation. When a child begins to transition from the role of child to the role of adult, he goes through a similar process of separating from an external control figure (usually parents) in order to achieve a certain level of independence (although for an adolescent, the actual task of individuation is never fully complete, and is more about beginning the healthy journey of interdependence with others rather than actual independence).25 It is very important to remember that this “separating” is not about separating from the family, for the evidence is overwhelming that adolescents need and generally desire to have a close relationship with their family system, and parents in particular. But in adolescent individuation, the child goes through the process that has been described by Peter Blos as the second separation-individuation phase.26 In this second separation-individuation phase, the young person separates from the role and associated identity of child and moves toward becoming her own adult, differentiated person. In describing this second individuation, Santrock notes:
It is critical for adolescents to gain difference and distance from parents to transcend infantile ties to them. Individuation during adolescence is defined as a sharpened sense of one’s distinctness from others, a heightened awareness of one’s self-boundaries…individuation in adolescence means that individuals now take increasing responsibility for what they do and what they are, rather than depositing this responsibility on the shoulders under whose influence and tutelage they have grown up.27
It should be noted that empirical as well as anecdotal evidence suggests that there are differences between how girls and boys go through the process of individuation. There are arguments that suggest, for example, that girls individuate more according to relationship patterns and interactions and boys more through activities and competition.28 There is little doubt that there are differences, and this is an important area for future research in adolescent development. As distinctive areas become more clearly studied and demonstrated, youth workers must make themselves aware of the unique markers of male and female individuation. But it is equally important to recognize that, while some differences surely exist between how boys and girls grow up, human development across gender lines has far more similarities. For the youth worker, recognizing these similarities is perhaps a more crucial aspect of understanding adolescent development than trying to become an expert in the nuances of adolescent male and female development.
Primarily our task in youth ministry is to approach each adolescent as a uniquely designed and gifted masterpiece of the Creator. While it is important to understand the broad developmental differences between genders and across age groups, what every child, adolescent, and young adult needs far more is the personal touch of a loving community. In youth ministry we are seeking to theologically as well as developmentally understand the unique needs and desires of every adolescent God brings to us. The most foundational understanding we must carry with us as youth workers, then, is that both boys and girls are created in the image of God, “male and female he created them” (Genesis 1:27). This essentially means that the basic makeup of both men and women, and therefore boys and girls, is relational, for God as a three-person unit is relational (John 1:1-3). As relational creations, adolescent women and men are called to both care and to need care, instinctively long to connect to others, and yearn for a connection to the God who has created them. This theological understanding must guide us as we consider the implications of adolescent individuation.
Figure 2.1. Tightrope of adolescence
Figure 2.1, Tightrope of Adolescence, depicts the individuation process of adolescence. The left stanchion or pole in Figure 2.1 represents the childhood phase of development. A child climbs this pole holding fast to the relationships and context of the family, relying on the family system to provide protection, security, and a sense of place. Throughout the first 10 or 11 years of life, a child’s sense of self is grounded in familial relationships. As the child goes through the first separation-individuation phase (infancy through age three) until she prepares to take those first steps on the adolescent journey (represented by the tightrope model), there is an innate dependency upon the family system as a whole and the mother (or primary caretaker) in particular. 29
During this period, a child’s relationship with his or her family sets the stage for future development. This phase necessitates a child experiencing the comfort of a committed and nurturing presence, a supportive environment where a child is encouraged to explore and to experiment, and a relational setting where appropriate independence is encouraged. “For normal development to occur, the parent must walk the fine line of both encouraging independence while continuing to serve as a source of protection and nurturance. Overemphasis on either extreme can result in personality disturbances.”30 But if the phase is successfully navigated, the child will have developed the sense of security and self-concept needed to enter the second separation-individuation phase with relative confidence, which is known as adolescence. If the child does not successfully complete the first phase, then the adolescent phase will be affected as well.31
As a youth worker, occasionally we encounter an adolescent who is terribly insecure, well beyond shy. Or we may struggle with someone who is extremely aggressive or consistently inappropriate in social or program settings. Especially with early adolescents who are trying on the new clothes of individuation, these can be simple reactions to nervousness, slight social fear, or the amount of sugar they consumed before the meeting! But there are those whom we encounter who have deeper needs that youth ministry training and education has not equipped us to handle. The best route to take when confronted with someone who displays potentially significant personality or social issues is to get advice from a health professional. Every youth worker would do well to memorize the axiom, “When in doubt, refer!”
Once a child begins to pull away from the role of child in the family system, she begins to explore the next phase of life known as adolescence. This is represented on the model as a tightrope between the stanchion representing childhood (on the left side of the model) and that representing adulthood (on the right). The tightrope signifies the process of individuation, which adolescents must navigate as they pass through the second separation-individuation phase (from now on referred to simply as individuation). Today this commonly occurs somewhere between 10 and 12 years of age (although as previously mentioned, this may vary widely across regions, cultures, and even individual children).32
As noted, while the completion of individuation signals the entrance into societal adulthood,33 it is much harder to specify the end of adolescence than the beginning. As Raymore asserted, “Defining the point of transition from adolescence to young adulthood can pose problems for researchers.”34 Puberty is a far more discernible and objective marker than culture. In postmodern society, successful completion of individuation and becoming an adult is such a subjective experience that it varies from person to person. There is no societal or even intuitive moment when someone has “arrived” on the threshold of adulthood. There are no classes, rites, or rituals that definitively certify an adolescent is fully individuated. Individuation is a fluid, complex, and even internal process. One way to describe the end of the adolescent journey, then, is to analyze the tasks that comprise the individuation process. When young people have successfully completed these tasks, they are psychologically and sociologically equipped to take on the roles of adulthood. In most cases, this seems to occur as early as the mid-20s to as late as 30 years old.
Changes in the timing of the adolescence process
As has been mentioned, the timing and length associated with adolescence has changed over the past century (Figure 2.2, The Changing Face of Adolescence). The remarkable fact that this table makes clear is how the adolescent journey has significantly lengthened over the years. When psychology first identified adolescence as an actual phase of life (around the turn of the 20TH century), it generally lasted only three to four years. At the turn of the century, children were not quite children when they entered the high school (made mandatory by the 1930s but creating a societal foothold earlier), but they were clearly not adults. This created the cultural environment for Hall’s work that defined the life span phase.
Figure 2.2. The changing face of adolescence
Will teenagers disappear in the 21ST century?
This is the question columnist Walter Kirn asks in a recent Time special report on the millennium. Kirn suggests that adolescence is a “blip” on the historical radar screen, noting that “early 20TH-century adolescents were farmers, apprentices, students and soldiers—perhaps even wives and husbands—but not teenagers.”
Kirn describes teenagers as a modern luxury good. Those days, says Kirn, are rapidly coming to an end as teenagers become economically powerful, socially precocious, and legally responsible. He muses: “What will a world without teenagers look like? Like the adult world does now. Adolescents will feel the same pressures as their parents do: to succeed financially, to maintain their health, to stay on society’s good side. What’s more, adolescents will field these pressures using their elders’ traditional techniques: spending money, taking medication, contracting for professional advice. The carefree years will become the prudent years, and the prudent years will continue throughout life.”1
Is Kirn right? Why or why not?1
But neither Hall nor early adherents to his views saw adolescence as a lengthy period. The markers that described this new stage of life were more related to a “not quite child, not yet adult” set of loosely defined criteria than a long, drawn-out period of one’s life. Although Hall was a psychologist and attached his theory to biological factors, the majority of discussions in the 1920s and ‘30s were related to the high school community and subculture. “Primary school” was designed for children—six to 13 years of age, grades one through eight. The high school, designed during this period for the 14- to 19-year-old, marked the sociological beginning of adolescence. Adolescence ended there as well, for once young people finished high school they were expected to enter cultural adulthood, take up a trade, become economically responsible, and get married. Social historian Joseph Kett demonstrated that during this period, adolescence was understood as a phase experienced between 14 and 18 years of age.35
Then somewhere between 1950 and 1960, developmental theorists began to acknowledge adolescence as a legitimate part of the life span.36 In doing this, they assumed a universally accepted psychological clarity over when the process of adolescence started (the onset of puberty). When puberty began at roughly 13 years of age, psychosocial adolescence began at the same time. The sociological and familial dimensions of adolescence began to appear earlier, roughly seventh grade, dragging the institution of junior high school into the adolescent mix. During the ‘50s and ‘60s, students were considered adults soon after graduation from high school. At this stage, adolescence lasted on the average from five to seven years—from the age of approximately 12 or 13 to 18 or 19. Society had clear expectations that upon graduation from high school an adolescent was to live and function as an adult. Thus the process of individuation was (relatively) ordered, controlled, and directed by the external social systems.
Today adolescence begins earlier, both in the sociological world (the advent of the middle school, where students begin entering a traditional adolescent cultural environment as young as 11 years old) and in the psychological literature. Like adolescence, adulthood is at least partially culturally determined, and begins when a culture says it does. In our culture, however, a young person is on his own to determine the outcome of the adolescent journey. No longer does society solve the adolescent dilemma for its young. Indeed, no longer do the social structures and systems either equip the young for adulthood or expect the young to embrace adulthood at any prescribed point. So a contemporary adolescent does not necessarily need to remain an adolescent well into his or 20s. But as Lance Morrow wrote in a Time editorial, “No growing up occurs if there is nothing to grow up to, without the adult connection, adolescence becomes a Neverland, a Mall of Lost Children.”37 And in postmodern contemporary society, that “Neverland” can (and usually does) last as long as 15 years or more!38
As the length of adolescence has been increasing, the field of youth ministry has been forming its own methodological axioms that drive youth ministry philosophy and practice. An example of this is how the parent-adolescent relationship is now perceived by most youth workers. As youth ministry became more programmatically sophisticated, and books were written and seminars were presented, arguments supporting the idea of parental separation during early adolescence were developed during the ‘60s and ‘70s when adolescence comprised a shorter span of time than it does today. Youth ministry leaders during these decades promoted a subtle but important misunderstanding about what occurs at the outset of the adolescent process: that adolescents want and need to separate from their families and connect to friends as soon as they begin the task of individuation. One well-known resource, originally written during this period (and still widely respected) notes: “When children reach adolescence, they want to be their own person, separate from their parents. They want to make their own choices and commitments, to be set free.”39 While statements like this are true to a point, they have been greatly exaggerated, misunderstood, and misused in the name of youth ministry, and especially early adolescent ministry.
But adolescent individuation involves separating from the role of child, not separating from the love, support, and nurture of the family system. In our current cultural context, the adolescent journey is a 15-year process of separation from the role of child in the family system and individuating in terms of becoming one’s own person in a larger community context. Eventually adolescents do seek to and need to connect to peers as a key component of this phase, for the very process of individuation is about learning how to connect to others, including family members. But the perception that adolescent separation requires severing primary familial relationships is rarely true and never ultimately healthy for an adolescent. And even the desire to separate from the role of child for the adolescent is more a characteristic of middle adolescence (around 13 to 19 years of age) than of early adolescence (around ages 10 to 14). An early adolescent is still far more child than adult. As a newcomer to individuation, the early adolescent is more concerned with issues of safety, support, stability, and “feel” than about leaving parents behind in the search for meaningful peer friendships.
In youth ministry, the difference between an early and a middle adolescent is a very important distinction. Young adolescents need to be treated with tender care and diligent understanding, being careful not to think they are developing faster than they are. Typically middle adolescents are more interested in exploring life on their own, but even that is seeming to wane. An increasingly lengthy adolescent process makes the concept of familial separation for the postmodern early adolescent a far different, and more difficult, experience than it was for his counterpart a century or even a generation ago. Postmodern youth workers need to be aware that in a culture where few systems and relationships are trustworthy or stable, adolescents need to know that a Christian ministry designed to serve them will do all it can to ensure an experience of stability and health.
The three key tasks of individuation—identity, autonomy, and reconnection
There is much debate over the specific tasks of the adolescent journey. Almost every perspective on human development offers its own unique lexical description of these tasks. 40 One key figure in understanding the adolescent journey was Erik Erikson who, for example, stated that the single most crucial task for adolescents is identity formation. He used the label identity crisis to define the adolescent experience (although crisis for Erikson did not necessarily dictate some sort of catastrophe in the life of an adolescent, but rather defined a normative and crucial period in the adolescent life stage that would propel her toward adulthood). As Erikson formulated his theory, he recognized that there are other important issues that come into play during adolescent individuation. But like most theorists, he was convinced that the quest for identity lay at the heart of adolescence.41
The range of opinions, theories, and debates about the exact definitions of and processes concerning the tasks of adolescence is far beyond the scope of this chapter. The tack I have chosen is to present three of the most important and relatively agreed-upon characteristics of every adolescent’s journey. This synthesis is not intended to be a comprehensive summary of varied opinions but rather a framework for understanding some of the basic elements every young person must consider, experience, and face during the adolescent journey. Developmental psychologist John Santrock asserts: “Individuation has two main components—separateness and self-assertion.”42 He later acknowledges that there is a third component, but, as with several authors, practitioners, and theorists, he has also brought the need to reconnect with others under the umbrella of the other two components he mentions discussed here. So, to use Santrock’s template, another way to describe these terms is to view adolescent individuation as a process that accomplishes three basic tasks for the adolescent:
Thinking like a teenager
Adolescents think differently than adults because their intellectual development is in a different place than that of adults. The newfound ability to think abstractly implies that adolescents now possess traditionally “adult” structures of logic. They can engage in self-reflection for the first time (which is one reason adolescents are egocentric). Never before have they been able to be the object of their own thoughts. Because they can now project an “ideal” onto themselves and others, they worry more, and are ruthlessly critical of anything falling short of the ideal.
The presence of adult structures of logic doesn’t mean that adolescents and adults use these structures the same way. For example, adolescents lack the adult capacity to step outside a situation and reflect on it in light of long-term consequences. As a result, information that something might affect them in the future does little to change teenage behavior.
The evolving anti-smoking ads provide a great illustration. Ads in the 1970s urged teenagers to stop smoking because smoking causes cancer. The ad campaign had minimal impact on teen smoking. Later, the American Lung Association launched a campaign that stressed smoking makes you ugly and gives you bad breath. The threat of social rejection because of the way you look or smell seemed immediate and terrifying.
The most recent ads focus on the adolescent ability to think about thinking. These ads show youth how they have been manipulated by cigarette advertisers and rely heavily on irony and indignation.1
How effective do you think this group of ads will be among teenagers? Why?
One additional internal mechanism must be in place during this phase as a mediator of the three primary tasks. In asking the questions, Who am I? and Do I matter?, the adolescent must also continually ask a more fundamental question: How do I know these things? This self-reflection during the adolescent individuation process provides the internal structure for developing the confidence to trust the answers that emerge from the process. It is most often accomplished during the middle and late adolescent period where the individual tries on different selves with others in different relational settings. As the adolescent attempts to break away from reliance on his parents for self-awareness, and seeks to take a modicum of control over his life and his choices, he is also attempting to reform himself via relationships with others—primarily peers. As these converge there is a continual internal process gauging the progress the journey is making. This becomes the internalized governor to the process of adolescent individuation.43
Identity and autonomy for young, middle, and older adolescents
Discovering who we are and deciding to accept the person we have been created to be as we live in community, are the fundamental concerns of the human psyche.44 Who am I? is a question directly related to our understanding of self, or our identity. As mentioned earlier, there are more similarities between boys and girls in terms of identity formation than differences.45 Pastoral psychologist, author, and spirituality author Henri J. M. Nouwen observed that, in one way or another, we all ask, Who am I? every day.46 How we come to answer this question will impact every other area of our life. This is especially true for adolescents, who are by definition attempting to narrow in on the essence of the identity they will refine for the remainder of their lives. To Nouwen, identity is not imposed from the outside of one’s life, or even “tried on” as an internalized process of trial and error. It is, rather, discovered as we hear the voice of the God who calls us beloved.47 Our identity, then, is firmly rooted in the doctrines of creation and redemption. Every child is created by God with great care, and has been purchased by the death of the Son, Jesus Christ (Psalm 139 and Romans 8).
Identity: given, not found
Searching for identity is a theme as old as myths and fairy tales where young men are sent on a quest to parts unknown, in order to accomplish certain tasks necessary to receiving the reward. (In mythology young women are seldom sent to search for their true selves. Rather they find their true identities in the context of a relationship usually as a mother or a wife to the young man now home with an identity of his own).
While these stories inform our cultural consciousness in powerful ways and provide intriguing fodder for gender studies, Christians understand identity theologically. For Christians, identity—the true self—is a gift, ours by redemption, not human development. While that identity is distorted by sin, Jesus restored our relationship with God—and in so doing, he made visible once more the outline of our true identities as God’s beloved.
What difference does it make for youth ministry if identity is God’s gift to us and not something we must go out and find?
These fundamental facts, then, provide the ultimate answer to the question, Who am I?, and the key to our understanding and sense of personal identity—”I am the uniquely created, redeemed child of the living God.” As one of the key components of the individuation task, youth ministry must continually and consistently reinforce this theological truth in everything we do and to every student we encounter.
Young adolescents (usually around 10 to 14 years of age) have just begun to ask the question of identity. The identity of a young adolescent is still firmly fixed within the context of the family system, although the child will at times struggle to try on new identities, even at this early stage.48 This is expressed in the young adolescent who is happy-go-lucky one week, moody the next, an aggressive bully on Sunday morning, and a shy introvert on Wednesday night. All this is typical of the young adolescent. Early adolescence calls the youth worker to remain consistent in loving and caring for “tweens” for the unique persons they are, and not to be fooled by the roles and masks they wear. (This is especially true when we take into account the Mountain Dew factor, in which behavior bears a direct relationship upon the amount of Mountain Dew consumed immediately preceding the meeting!)
A middle adolescent (usually 13 to 19 years of age) has traversed the tightrope of adolescence to the point where family support is still present, but is seldom claimed by the adolescent as a significant point of security. There is a need for familial, and especially a father’s, blessing, affirmation, and attachment, but this is mostly sought out from a safe relational and sociological distance.49 A middle adolescent, for the most part, may not express a desire to spend time with her parents, but there is almost always the desire to know that parents are available if the adolescent wants to be with them. While conflict between parents and adolescents can be explosive throughout the entire developmental phase, usually the most difficult family conflicts occur during middle adolescence. Middle adolescents sense the need to be on their own, to discover who they are in relation to the world (i.e., peers), and to take responsibility for their own life. Problems arise when a middle adolescent longs to please, and wants to be acknowledged in the family as responsible—but due to the as-yet unformed self, he often stumbles. Many parents abdicate their responsibility to remain close to their children during this period, for it is easier to avoid this family tension than confront it. But a middle adolescent still needs parental influence, advice, nurture, and guidance. Middle adolescence calls caring youth workers to recognize and be available to assist the entire family as they navigate this period in the life cycle.
An area receiving more attention from social scientists in the last decade or so is the notion of parental attachment. Drawing on John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth’s work on infant attachment50 researchers have expanded Bowlby and Ainsworth’s basic premise to point out that our need for secure attachments is not limited to the first few years of life. Although it is too soon in the research process to assert these findings with significant confidence, healthy parental attachment appears to be related to the ability to complete both the first and the second separation-individuation phases of life, albeit in different ways. In infant attachment theory, which has seen significant consensus in recent years, the more secure and confident a child is in her relationship with her mother, the more positive the separation-individuation phase. Using this finding as a model for the second individuation phase, adolescent attachment to parents enables the adolescent to more quickly and confidently complete adolescence, as well as fosters a healthy self-concept and sense of confidence that accompanies the adolescent into adulthood. The notion of parental attachment, then, may play a significant role in the development of adolescents.
As has been mentioned, in early adolescence the family is still the foundation of loyalty and support. Youth ministry during this phase of the adolescent journey must see its role as a support to the family system. In middle adolescence, parents need to be viewed as partners. Although in many cases young adolescents may want their parents to stay far away from the youth ministry, youth workers must remember that nearly all high school students still desire a safe, connected relationship with their parents and families, no matter what they may say. When this is not the case, the youth worker should carefully seek to find out why. Perhaps this is an area where the family needs help.
Ponderable
Chap suggests that a number of factors impede older adolescents from making the final jump into adulthood: Do you agree that something is keeping older adolescents from joining the ranks of adulthood? If so, what? Is Chap too hard on parents, educators, and media?
In contemporary culture, late adolescence is an almost developmentally unnecessary but still dominant phase of the adolescent process. An older adolescent (usually late teens to middle 20s or later) is potentially ready to enter adulthood, but almost always still needs to be taught, led, and encouraged to make the final leap into an adult role as a capable, responsible, and interdependent person in the community. But, as noted earlier, we live in a culture that seems to deify youth and youthful irresponsibility and lack of commitment. Older adolescents stand on the threshold of making their mark on society and community but are often held back by systemic and environmental factors—parents who empower sloth and financial dependency, an educational system that treats the undergraduate curriculum as barely adequate preparation for graduate school, and media and advertising industries that make a far larger profit by appealing to the young to stay young (and the old to fight aging), to name but a few.
But late adolescents are culpable as well, for the opportunities abound for jumping into adulthood and influencing social change. For many if not most, it just seems too easy to stay a kid and float until one has no choice but to grow up. A basic rule of thumb, then, for those who serve the college-aged and young adults completing the individuation process (who have almost, but not quite, taken on the mantle of adulthood) is to treat them like adults but lead them like adolescents.
Role of parents in adolescent individuation
A relatively recent area of interest has been the role of parents in adolescent development. For Christians, this is hardly new territory; the apostle Paul provides a window into the cultural and perhaps universal role parents play in the life of a developing child (1 Thessalonians 2:7-11) in modeling human relationships. In describing how he dealt with the people in Thessalonica, Paul says, “we were gentle among you, like a mother caring for her little children” (v. 7). The statement here concerns the role of a mother, not biological packaging, and is clearly not intended to dictate rigid rules over households. Rather, Paul uses the image of a mother to describe the nurturing relationships that characterize Christian community.
Later, as the disciples matured and needed a different kind of nurturing, Paul writes, “For you know that we dealt with each of you as a father deals with his own children, encouraging, comforting and urging you to live lives worthy of God, who calls you into his kingdom and glory” (vv. 11-12). Although it would be inappropriate to understand these passages as models for human development, Paul’s description of Christian care and encouragement is clearly derived from his observations of the differing needs of children as they reach varying stages of maturity.
Despite a few popular writers in recent years who have claimed that peer influence far outweighs parental influence in the overall health and life of a child and adolescent, the sheer volume of data suggest this view is simply wrong.51 It is clear, at least from the data compiled thus far, that parents are more influential in young people’s healthy development than any other single external influence. Peer influence, though powerful in its own right, runs a distant second in influence to the impact of parents, for better and for worse.
Adolescence is the stage of life during which a father takes on a more decisive role in the life of a child. This is not to say that a mother’s influence decreases, per se, but that as an adolescent begins to shift into having to be more and more responsible for his own life, parents become much more background but just as developmentally important. Because mothers are most often experienced as primary attachment figures throughout childhood, fathers tend to have less impact on the day-to-day lives of their children. But a mother’s role is also connected to the child’s role as well, and so when a child moves through adolescence, there can develop a tension between a mother and her child. As Nancy Chodorow points out, during and following puberty, a girl “usually moves from preoccupation with her relationship to her mother to her concern with her father and males…She may feel guilty toward her mother for loving her father more.”52
Although generally true, this may be slightly overstated, for there is little evidence that a mother’s role significantly diminishes during this period. She often still represents the warmth, safety, and nurturance of the familial environment. Few doubt that mothers (and primary caretakers) are important in the lives of their children throughout the life span, but a father’s role takes on a new significance in that a father generally represents to an emerging adult the “real world” that he or she is approaching. Although far more understudied than the more generic distinction of parent, a father has shown to be a unique influence in the life of an adolescent. The following studies have demonstrated that the more strongly the adolescent perceives his attachment to his father, the more likely he is to experience the following outcomes, compared to adolescents who perceive weak father attachment:53
Again, this is not to say that mothers do not matter in the developmental life of an adolescent. But in a cultural environment where the role of the father is generally discounted at every turn, these are important studies.
Looking again at the Tightrope of Adolescence, but now adding the attachment component (figure 2.3), helps define the process of individuation more completely.
On the left side of the stanchion, mother (or primary caretaker) attachment represents the key relational figure in the life of the child. Underneath the tightrope itself, represented by a safety net, is father (or father figure) attachment. Underscoring all of this is the parental security factor of a stable home environment. Along with mother and father attachment, the security that comes from the perception of a secure parental couple adds one more layer of security for the child or adolescent to fall back on when needed.54
What about nontraditional families?
At this stage, however, it is crucial to recognize that even the most positive family situation is not a perfect familial situation. Single parents, grandparents, foster, and adoptive parents all have the ability to offer a child and an adolescent the kind of environment where there is love, safety, and nurture. There is no question that many households where no father is present are far more conducive to healthy growth and development than many homes where a father lives. And theologically, God knows that we are fallen creatures who have allowed selfishness, stupidity, and the raw realities and circumstances of life to wreak havoc with the familial needs of children and adolescents. Therefore God has given us other people so that, no matter how good or bad our families are, we have others to rely on. This is an area where a theologically grounded youth ministry can make an impact on postmodern families. In an ideal, all-things-considered world, mothers and fathers are very important in the developmental life of an adolescent. At the same time, youth ministers must constantly seek to care for students and families who need the support that the church is called to provide. As Paul writes, “Carry each other’s burdens, and in this way you will fulfill the law of Christ” (Galatians 6:2).
Figure 2.3. The tightrope of adolecence with attachment
Adolescence through the lens of practical theology
Because adolescence is an invention of modernity in an urbanized culture, it is very difficult to extrapolate from the Scriptures specific guidelines for understanding and then dealing with adolescents.55 But that certainly does not mean the church should sit back and allow theories of development to create a de facto theology of adolescent development. In fact the opposite is true, especially for those of us engaged in youth ministry. If you are involved in ministry, you are called to be a practical theologian, for you are making divine revelation relevant and coherent to a specific cultural setting. The task of practical theology, then, is to connect God’s story to the stories of those we serve in youth ministry.
A method for theological thinking
Chap claims that just because the Scriptures don’t offer specific guidelines on how to deal with adolescents, “the church cannot sit back and allow theories of development to create a de facto theology of adolescent development. ” Why not? Should the church take its guidance from the social sciences, from theology, or both? Can the social sciences inform youth ministry or only youth work? What disciplines have been the most helpful to you for youth ministry: social sciences—like psychology, education, anthropology, sociology—or theology? Why?
Adolescence is changing—and quickly. Puberty is starting earlier and resolving the questions of identity and autonomy later and later. This means that the concept of youth can no longer be limited to the two programmatic foci of North American youth ministry, junior and senior high. From fifth grade to the mid-20s, young men and women are finding themselves in a state of flux, continually on the lookout for anyone who would bless, affirm, and help them to finally land as a unique, responsible person. This is where youth ministry is at its best—recognizing the unique needs and dreams of the emerging generation—and taking it seriously enough to reach out. Because adolescents are in such an emotionally and relationally transitional state, the calling to care for them is an exciting and necessary opportunity and adventure. The transitional nature of adolescence implies, however, that youth workers must be especially diligent in making sure that youth ministry appropriately nurtures the young.
Addressing the uniqueness of adolescence cannot be limited to the sole responsibility of a youth ministry leader, team, or program. The church, as a family of “families, ” is called as a community to be the prime agent of nurturing this and any future generation. The church is not intended to be a large organization with several smaller, more specific congregations who happen to gather on a Sunday morning. The local church is instead called to be a living, connected, caring community of people who love Jesus Christ and are committed to loving and serving God in their fellowship and in the world (John 15).56
Youth ministry, then, is not an appendage of the body, it is rather an expression of the whole body caring for a specific group. Adolescents need an adult community who will love them appropriately and with great care. This is the call of the church. Young adolescents need several second families, and middle adolescents need a safe place to explore peer relationships while knowing that there are many others in the wings committed and available to them. Older adolescents need to know that they matter to the other adults in the community. Youth ministry is everybody’s job!
