Chapter 11 Focusing Youth Ministry through Critical Consciousness
Chapter 11
Focusing Youth Ministry through Critical Consciousness
David F. White
For our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the authorities, against the powers of this dark world and against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly realms.
—Ephesians 6:12
The Powers…have long since been identified as an order of angelic beings in heaven , or as demons flapping about in the sky. Most people have simply consigned them to the dustbin of superstition. Others sensing the tremendous potential in the concept of the Powers for interpreting social reality, have identified them without remainder as institutions, structures, and systems…The Powers are the simultaneity of an outer, visible structure and an inner, spiritual reality. The Powers properly speaking, are not just the spirituality of institutions, but their outer manifestations as well. The New Testament uses the language of power to refer now to the outer aspect, now to the inner aspect, now to both together…It is the spiritual aspect, however, that is so hard for people inured to materialism to grasp.
—Walter Wink, Engaging the Powers
He removed the dangling pewter cross and tossed it to the dirt, taking another desperate swipe at the volleyball. I pondered the reason why Brian so easily discarded my confirmation gift of a few months earlier. I could not prevent the feeling that with it he had tossed aside the only tangible proof of his participation in the long, rigorous confirmation class of 13 junior and senior high youth. We had studied the Bible, church history, theology, and church polity together, and we had together made numerous retreats for prayer and reflection. Each youth had been assigned an adult mentor who met with them weekly to pray and discuss the journals they kept as reflections on their experiences. With other clergy staff, I had arranged significant liturgical events in which the entire faith community confirmed the progress of these youth toward full participation in the life of faith. But now, only six months beyond Easter, these newly confirmed youth rarely participated in liturgy, never achieved significant voice on church committees, sat at entirely different sides of the fellowship hall for church dinners, and were now playing volleyball outside as the adults debated the future of the church in this year’s charge conference.
Ponderable
David White implies that there are systems, structures, and powers that keep youths from getting and staying involved as “active agents of the faith.” Do you agree with his assessment? Is a main reason so many students drop out or lose interest in our programs due to the attitudes and structures of adult system? Or are there other more vital factors?
Twenty-two years of youth ministry, with all its problems and questions, led me to hold out much hope for this approach to educating youth in the stories, symbols, values, practices, and norms of this faith community. Instead, I found that even though we had succeeded in thoroughly enculturating youth in the symbols and stories of faith, both youth and adults had internalized the powerful and unconscious cultural assumption that youth were somehow not yet capable of being full participants in the life of the church. Although most adults of this church would happily affirm their theological conviction that youth are gifted and capable of great faith as disciples of Jesus Christ, these convictions remained in contradiction to their deeply held unconscious beliefs about youth and their capacities. It seems unfaithful to simply relegate youth to marginal congregational space in the basement or attic, to entertain them with games and parties until they someday become real adult members, or to teach them the Bible abstracted from real struggles and problems of their community. Perhaps there remains some dimension of youth ministry that could empower youth to critically engage their communities as active agents of faith.
What barriers and inhibitions prevent Brian, his friends, and their families from participating or allowing youth to participate fully in the life and mission of the church? And perhaps more importantly, is this a faithful question, relevant or central to ministry with youth, or any endeavor in Christian discipleship? These are perhaps the two most relevant questions facing youth ministry into the next century—an era in which the boundaries of adolescence are increasingly blurred, beginning earlier and extending later than any other time in history, within institutions where they have less than full power.
Clues for empowering youth
Many of the reasons youth are not empowered as full agents of faith and equipped to transform their churches and communities have to do with deep unconscious forces or powers that shape adolescent life and inform our understandings of them. Inhibitions to youth discipleship include the deep unconscious messages and cultural myths that can determine our relations with youth when we remain unreflective about them. Youth and adults who live in communities internalize the spirits or powers of those communities—the symbols, the myths, and tacit understandings, for example, about youth and their abilities. Teaching at a sheer cognitive or propositional level will not fully engage these spirits and powers that exist on an unconscious level. Often these inhibitions remain in unconscious contradiction to stated doctrines or theological assumptions. What are the sources of these spirits, forces, or powers? New Testament scholar Walter Wink argues that real spiritual force emanates from actual institutions—schools, cultures, churches, economies, families, nations, etc. He states:
There were, in the first century, both Jews and Christians who perceived in the Roman Empire a demonic spirituality that they called Sammael or Satan. But they encountered this spirit in the actual institutional forms of Roman life: legions, governors, crucifixions, payment of tribute, Roman sacred emblems and standards, and so forth. The spirit they perceived existed right at the heart of the empire, but their worldview equipped them to discern that spirit only by intuiting it and then projecting it out, in visionary form, as a spiritual being residing in heaven and representing Rome in the heavenly council.1
Wink observes that in New Testament times, people projected the felt or intuited spiritual qualities onto the screen of the universe, and perceived them as cosmic forces reigning from the sky. In the ancient worldview, a seer or prophet was able to sense the diseased spirituality of an institution or state, and then bring that spirituality to awareness by projecting it in visionary form onto the heavenly realm and depicting it as a demon on high. Our task today is to withdraw that projection from on high and locate it in the institution in which it actually resides. This requires the rigorous activity of discerning the spirits.
The spirit world
Central to David’s understanding of discernment is the belief that demonic powers are institutionally governed, instead of being personified creatures of evil from outside the visible realm. The author seems to have tacitly challenged those who fundamentally disagree with his interpretation of powers and forces.
But has he really? Regardless of what you believe about the spirit world in general and the demonic in particular, David’s point in this chapter is an important one for all Christians, wherever they land on the theological spectrum: adolescents need to be freed from institutional and systemic oppression and suppression. They also need to be encouraged and taught how to read and resist the spirit powers that would seek to destroy them and hold them back from the life God has created for them.
Discernment has a long history in the Christian church. In the early church discernment and expulsion of evil spirits was of primary importance for Christian discipleship. Records from around the third through fourth centuries from church fathers Cyril, Ambrose, Chrysostom, and Augustine reveal that candidates for Christian baptism underwent not only instruction in the Christian teachings, but rigorous examination and exorcism. Exorcism was viewed as intense work with a spiritual director for the purpose of exposing ways unwitting candidates participated in evil.2 The assumption of such examination is that what remains unconscious within us has the power to drive behavior and attitudes, but that raising the awareness of evil allows those seeking Christian discipleship to root it out, making room for the holy to abide. In later centuries St. Ignatius Loyola explored ways of refining the practice of discernment for understanding where God is at work in the world. And in modern times, various traditions as the Mennonites and Quakers have sought ways to engage entire communities, as well as individuals, in discerning good and evil.
The modern church in general and youth ministry in particular has undervalued the role of discernment in the Christian life. In some circles proof-texting biblical references, or merely seeking impressions in prayer, or superficial conversation has fallen under the rubric of discernment. What the early church seemed to practice was instead a deep critical engagement with shadow dimensions of society and one’s own internal distortions and false tendencies. Without such deep critical engagement with these shadow powers, Christian instruction can become nullified by our assimilation to dominant cultural attitudes and practices. For example, the southern United States in the 1940s and ‘50s deeply internalized Christian symbols, stories, doctrines, etc., yet amidst religious revival and church expansion somehow we remained oblivious to our oppressive attitudes and practices toward African-Americans. When we internalize racist structures so deeply, only ruthless critical reflection and introspection can expose these distorted powers. Without discernment, what is evil can appear natural and normal. While Christian instruction is an important part of discipleship, merely instructing youth and adults lacks the rigor of deep self and social critical investigation, and risks something analogous to the 19TH-century practice of teaching the Bible to African slaves while ignoring slavery itself as an evil structure.
Ponderable
David compares the social construct of slavery to that of adolescence, concluding that the essence of adolescence is something to be resisted. Elsewhere in this book, however, adolescence is perceived as a cultural invention that evolved into a “legitimate phase of the life span.” The author here obviously disagrees, stating that adolescence is a “somewhat oppressive construct.” Between these positions, where do you stand?
Youth ministry that does not engage youth in discerning and engaging the powers and principalities—the social forces that constitute their lives—risks working only in the cracks and crevasses of systems and structures that colonize more and more of life. The comparison of adolescence to slavery has more relevance than revealed at first glance. Both are ideas and practices constructed by societies and are seen by some as representing the natural state of existence, and both require critical awareness to resist their power. While many in mainline Christianity have become more aware, however incompletely, of the dangers of racism, few have become sensitized to the dangers of viewing the institution of adolescence as natural to the life cycle. Our churches and youth risk naturalizing the situation and institution of adolescence—a thoroughly social and somewhat oppressive construct.
The social construction of adolescence
While there has always been a liminal stage of life in all cultures, marking the movement from childhood to adulthood, the current prolonged stage of adolescence is relatively new, emerging with force only in this century. Once upon a time prior to the 19TH century, young children worked side by side with adults—watching, learning, playing, laughing, and talking. Young people became adults as they developed physical abilities for work to sustain themselves and contribute to their families. Young people also took on adult roles much earlier in life—marriage, work, and civic concerns for the common good of their communities. With the establishment of adolescence came the modern high school, which was initially designed as a means of keeping young street urchins out of trouble and socializing new immigrants into the American language, norms, and values—with academic aims being a somewhat distant consideration. In this context, the original Christian youth group movement began in 1884 as the Christian Endeavor Movement, with mainline Protestant versions following soon after—as an attempt to find a niche for youth, whose role in this new world was still in question. As the high school and youth group movements grew, and as more and more youth were assimilated, others saw a chance to exploit youth in this new protective institutional cocoon.
Quentin Schultze of Calvin College documents the exploitative and symbiotic relationship that soon developed between youth and the entertainment media. As early as the 1920s, youth became increasingly relegated to their own private subsociety, where peer conformity dictated style—clothes, cars, partners, social activities, etc.—with money making it all possible.3 Movies, cars, radios, and records all played a role in defining youth status. In fact, music has helped to define youth against their parents, family, and tradition. In each succeeding generation, music and media have driven youth and their families further and further apart. Creating markets means creating separate cultures, thus making the generations increasingly incomprehensible to each other. On this division, the entertainment industry depends. A special target of marketers is the disposable income of youth, now estimated at $2,500 per year per youth, on average.
Institutional cocoon—necessary precaution or restrictive exploitation?
David perceives postmodern culture, and especially Christian culture, as an exploitation of the young.
It is a serious indictment to include Christian support systems (youth ministry publishers and organizations that live off of the needs of youth ministry) in the same mix with the mainstream media, musicians, and advertisers. On the other hand, when you consider the cost of Christian-label CDs, for example, or ticket prices for outreach concerts, or the popularity of some youth speakers—when you consider factors like these, you wonder if David addresses forthrightly what most youth workers only whisper about. In any case, few on either side of this question deny that youth ministry is big business.
What do you think?
Additionally, mainstream media portrays life as a perpetual identity crisis, compelling youth to adapt to the latest trend. Youth report that they learn how to dress, make-up their faces, talk, and act from movies and television. Yet, they confess an abiding dissatisfaction with themselves, fed by the media that depends on it for the sale of products, driving the individual back for more products to salve the wound prescribed in a consumer economy. In fact, the success of the media depends on an ongoing crisis in social authority, and can be directly attributed to diminished authority of institutions of primary care—home, church, and school, etc. The void left by these institutions among youth has been filled by the media. For example, the founders of MTV reported that in their original market research they observed two gaps in American adolescent life—identity and intimacy. So in packaging their program for youth, they construct an informal set in which the VJs lounge on sofas and chat with the audience as they play music videos that provide norms, values, and beliefs for a generation of youth. Similarly, engaging in what was once considered the responsibility of trusted adults, teen magazines offer advice for dating, relationships, school, and career.
Another function of entertainment media is that of gender intensification. In their recent book, Generation On Hold: Coming of Age in the Late Twentieth Century, Cote and Allahar observe that the mass media sell goods and services based upon gender identity and they report, “gender is big business.”4 For example, young women spend enormous sums of money on feminine products—make-up, clothes, perfume—to shape them into the willowy, and often emaciated, creatures they view in teen magazines and movies. At the hands of teen-oriented media, young women experience a decline in self-esteem and academic performance as they attempt to become the pleasing, largely ornamental figures who will not threaten male egos, depicted in the media. Young men likewise are killing themselves in record numbers in attempts to drink beer, drive fast, smoke cigarettes, and have casual sex, promoted as norms of maleness. Yet, these cries are not often connected to these sources for adolescent identity—the powers of the media.
Youth ministry has in many communities become a new and somewhat pervasive social force impacting the lives of youth. But youth ministry, like other forms of social activity, can take many forms for good or ill. Youth ministry may unconsciously mirror popular culture or economic and political structures—e.g., exalting celebrity Christian musicians, overshadowing the gifts of youth themselves in creating music, forming youth as consumers. William Myers, for example, in his book Black and White Styles of Youth Ministry reveals the ways white suburban churches often internalize the root metaphors of their life context—e.g., the corporate metaphor, which shapes their understanding of church leadership as a hierarchically organized efficient machine.5 Alternately, youth ministry may also reach deep into ethnic traditions and find ways of resisting corporate powers, utilizing alternate root metaphors such as kinship. Many African-American churches, for example, have found in their ancient traditions, practices, and metaphors resources for survival and resistance in an otherwise hostile and racist world. These root metaphors and ways we organize our lives should be a source of reflection for the church and youth ministry that seeks to be faithful to Jesus and the church’s way of resisting the powers.
This glimpse of the social forces constituting contemporary adolescence, however incomplete, offers a hint of these external powers that confine the lives of historical and contemporary youth. But, the powers are not just “out there” but are also “in here.” Even as racism is not simply embodied outwardly as prohibitions from drinking fountains, restaurants, and restrooms—but also exists as inner feelings and attitudes inscribed as prejudices and fears onto our very hearts; so our attitudes toward youth are not simply manifested in school and media structures and practices, but are internalized—not just by adults, but by youth themselves. Powers exist as outward structures delineating a more domesticating role for youth, while at the same time shaping our unconscious responses and relationships with youth.
In the driver’s seat
Some claim the media mirrors culture, which means that the young actually drive the media. Still others believe that while the media has some influence, adolescents are extremely street smart and use the media even as the media seeks to exploit them—which produces a cycle that rapidly spirals out of control as the young both empower and feed off the media. What do you think?
The powers of the entertainment industry view youth not as a prophetic presence or gifts for the healing of the world, but as a source of bottom-line profit. And what is worse, the church has often unwittingly participated in this aggressive marketing to youth, by promoting contemporary Christian music celebrities, slick Christian youth magazines mirroring those proliferating in popular media, and acres of Christian youth products—T-shirts, CDs, tattoos, bumper stickers, key chains, Frisbees, video tapes, etc. And worse than participating in this marketing frenzy to youth, we have failed to engage them critically and equip them with the skills to see the dangers of the consumer market. Is it a matter of faith that youth buy or resist Nike shoes made with sweatshop labor in Southeast Asia? One wonders how Jesus might name the demons observed in a walk through the local shopping mall? What powers are analogous to the Roman powers of Jesus’ day? What are the symbols that elicit the feelings of dread, fear, hopelessness, anger, hunger, apathy among the social world of our youth—a Nike swoosh, a drive-by shooting, a television set, the image of an emaciated supermodel?
Movements of discernment
From a Christian youth magazine ad: “Jesus said, ‘Let your light shine before men.’ And [the Christian T-shirts are] a great way to shine your light.”
And they will know you are my disciples by your T-shirts and your fish ornaments.
Modern adolescent life is in many ways more complex than in earlier or more traditional cultures, requiring the church to engage and refine its practices of discernment. In particular, discernment in this era should include engaging the church in seeking to understand the sociocultural influence of life—the ethnic traditions, religious traditions, economic and political forces, etc. Discernment in this era should include a growing understanding of the social and cultural powers that constitute adolescent life and the ways God works in the redemption of them—and how youth might participate with God in resisting alienating cultural forces. While discernment may be shaped differently in different religious contexts and may include a wide variety of practices for raising awareness and judging, the barest understanding of discernment should include the following components: listening, understanding, dreaming, and acting.
Listening: loving God with our hearts
Learn to discern
It is clear where David stands on consumerism in the youth ministry culture. But his severest critique is against a youth ministry milieu that fails to help students discern the manipulative culture, both in and outside the church.
How can we help young disciples to be more discerning in how they spend their money and resist cultural pressures? What is a youth minister’s responsibility to shield students from the marketing efforts of Christian youth ministry companies?
The guiding questions for these listening activities are—
Listening is for the purpose of appreciating the energies that determine adolescents’ lives at a very deep level—reaching below the complexity of life to attend to emotions and passions surrounding concrete situations. Passions are the spring and source from which all ethical moral choices flow—what we love and yearn for is fundamental to our understandings of right and wrong. Human passion represents ways we are touched by God and moved toward God. Yet the human heart is also restless enough to form attachments in unhealthy ways, as neurosis, addictions, prejudices, patterns, sins, or complexes that close us off from life, God, and others.
G. Simon Harak in Virtuous Passions recounts a story of his visit to Kingston, Jamaica, where he escorted a group of 18- to 19-year-old boys from St. George’s College to meet their little brothers—a group of younger boys orphaned and from abused homes. He relates this story:
They had all been playing soccer when Fabian, the elected leader of the young men from St. George’s, came to me distraught and upset. His little brother, with whom he was trying so hard to get along, had scored a goal in the game. Everyone was excited. Fabian ran up to him and lifted his hand to clap him on the shoulder. But the boy flinched, and then cowered away from him. Fabian was stunned. “I was going to congratulate him,” he kept saying to me. “I wasn’t going to hurt him. What did he pull away for? I wasn’t going to hurt him.”…He (ultimately) discovered that every time (previously) a hand was raised to that little boy, he had been struck. Now, even when a hand was raised in congratulation, the boy had no choice.6
In Harak’s story the young orphan’s passions had been shaped in the abusive context of his early life, and was now closed to fuller life and relationship. As illustrated in the small boy’s once necessary, yet now unexamined flinching response, as long as our affective lives remain unconscious to us, our passions or our affective patterns of response have the power to determine our lives, thus closing us to God, fullness, love, and beauty.
For Christian theologians Augustine, Thomas Aquinas, and Ignatius Loyola, Christian discipleship is the process of attending to the shape of our passions and supporting or reshaping them in more completely life-giving ways. Thomas Aquinas acknowledges that God is love, and that the best way to know God is through the experience of love. According to Aquinas, God has created all of us out of the very fabric of God’s own self. God shares love and being with all in the form of their simple existing and in the uniqueness of their existence. To fulfill our nature is to satisfy fully the very purpose of our being—loving and being loved—as we are caught up in the love of God. All people are drawn close to God through all others in creation.
Movements of attraction and repulsion characterize all of creation—fire is drawn to air, rocks are drawn to the earth, etc. As human beings, we have a natural passion for God and also for each other. For Aquinas there are right and wrong appetites or passions—those that draw us to each other and God, and those that repel us from each other and God, and it is vital that we discern these deep forces within us. While the example used above illuminates the way a violent family can limit the life-giving responses of a child, the process of internalizing habits, addictions, myths, and prejudices can be initiated by not only families, but individuals in relation to communities, ethnic cultures, economic and political structures, and media sources.
By exploring practical ways to attend to our emotions and passions and their surrounding situations and relationships, we can get some distance from them and are not so immediately and unreflectively determined by them. Human life and experience is a complex mixture of social and cultural forces, community and family patterns, and individual psychic dynamics—all with addictions, distortions, gifts, and graces that remain unconscious to us. And what remains unconscious to us has the power to determine our behavior. For example, anger or frustration might thus be clues about injustice to us or to our community. By attending to this anger or frustration, we may sense, however vaguely at first, the possibility that life could be other than it is. Alternately, feelings of joy or vitality could signal directions for Christian vocation or giftedness. It is these energies that make us human and suggest the possibility of being fully who we were created to be in relation to each other and God. And it is here that we can sense the Spirit’s work among us—through yearnings deeper than words.
Ponderable
In considering your own experience, is youth ministry typically a good environment for adults to authentically listen to kids? What are some ways to help teenagers to tell their stories, to freely name their fears, and to feel safe enough to bare their souls with people they see once or twice a week in an institutional environment? Are we asking too much of teenagers? Of youth workers? Should we change how and where we do what we do?
Certainly one aim of listening to the stories and passions of youth is for the purpose of ultimately discerning where God is working—where there is life and where life is draining away—and participating in the transformation of all life for the reign of God. However, listening can in itself be understood as a healing practice, even in isolation from a full-blown discernment process with these ultimate aims. In a recent summer program at Emory University in which 60 youths from around the country were gathered to reflect on theology and engage in practical forms of Christian discipleship, the staff engineered an elaborate program of study, worship, recreation, music, service, and spiritual direction. But to the surprise of the staff, the one activity that consistently ranked highest on youth evaluations was a one-hour interview with a graduate student who was gathering research for a thesis. Rarely do youth experience the full and prolonged attention of a significant adult for the purpose of listening to them—for hearing what they love, what they hate, what their gifts are, what their families are like, what their hopes and dreams are for the future. Similarly, in a local California church when the adult staff spent months listening to the stories of youth—what makes them angry, sad, frustrated, loved, alive, joyful, connected—the youth and adults experienced a mutual conversion to each other, each feeling more understood, much less contemptuous and judgmental of each other. The mere practice of listening is healing for youth who are alienated from adults.
Some practical ways to engage youth in listening activities are the employment of small groups, drama, surveys that enable the group to go to deeper levels of discovery and discernment, using video and other popular media. There are many books and resources available to youth workers that can be invaluable in helping bring students to a more developed sense of wisdom and insight.
Understanding: loving God with our minds
The guiding questions for this movement include—
Thomas Aquinas offers an understanding of human life and intellect grounded in God. Briefly, Aquinas understands human beings as unique in that our intellect is united with a physical reality, our bodies. Like God, humans have an increased degree of freedom over rocks that must rely upon the physical nature of their being, and animals who are more free than rocks yet are largely bound by their senses and physical needs. Significantly, humans are able to think and move beyond our senses and physical being. We are capable of perceiving the Supreme Good, and able to order our particular goods in light of the Supreme Good. The vision of the Supreme Good and the power to act upon it is characteristic of human rationality. Rational beings do not blindly partake of the order of the universe but have the freedom and ability to participate in the ordering of ourselves and the universe toward God—our ultimate happiness and goal.
Aquinas’ conception of the organic unity of the soul and body must not be understood as the rational repression of the body and senses. The lifelong moral project of a human being would thus be to complete and fulfill the integration of the self, so that the whole self becomes fully rational, ordered in relation to God—an integrated body, heart, mind, soul. In fact, as noted earlier, it is not the intellect that is first drawn to God—instead we find ourselves desiring or wanting God. We are drawn more profoundly by love than by knowledge. By being created in the image of God, we have implanted in our very nature the seeds of a natural attraction to God’s own self. The human moral project is to be fully who we were created to be, fully alive and fully human, in love with God and rightly ordered in our loves in the world—with others, nature, etc. The ordering of the whole self to God is that of seeking the fullest delight—using our minds in attending to our bodies and senses and ordering our lives in ways that seek constant delight—the way to God. Our bodies and hearts are not sufficient in themselves for the task, but require the intellect for training and ordering the whole self returned to God. This ordering requires some concrete practices described below.
Observing and describing. Passions are evoked in relation to specific concrete historical circumstances. Understanding includes deliberately observing and describing the situations that evoke the emotions. It is important for those seeking God to understand the present action of their community—to name or express the present behaviors and circumstances evoking particular emotions. Until we can understand the dynamics of “what is going on” we cannot see beyond to further possibilities. Questions that are appropriate to this stage of discernment include, What is going on here? What is being done here?
Reflecting critically. Understanding a situation also means engaging questions about the social and personal dynamics that surround situations—understanding ways they are historically shaped by economic, political, and cultural forces. We live in a world so complex that cultures or traditions or social influences are rarely found in any pure state, but mingle in some form with multiple other traditions—ethnic, class, religious, pop cultural, etc. Emotions alone are not sufficient for discernment until the intellect is engaged in understanding the complexity of human situations. The appropriate questions for these understanding activities are, But why? What are the reasons why this situation has emerged in history? What are all of the aspects that determine this situation?
As we attend to our emotions, reflect upon them and the situations in which they are evoked, make judgments about them, and act faithfully in ways that honor them, we can participate in the transformation and healing of the world in God’s image. Understanding these situations includes perceiving individual ways we form attachments to ideas, relationships, images, possessions, or structures that may be less than ultimate—and the defenses we utilize to defend these attachments.
Dreaming: loving God with our souls
Some have noted that the imagination is the seat of the soul. We can become disembeded from the normal structures of our lives only if we can imagine other ways of being. Dreaming should reflect an attempt to order all of one’s passions and priorities in line with one’s ultimate passion for God, opening us out to fuller experiences of life, self, and God. Dreaming is the step of considering one’s emerging love of God in relation with the other affective attachments. Dreaming with God, through the resources of the Christian tradition, includes being reminded of our true self and being in God. The guiding questions for this movement include—
Dreaming includes developing a vision for how the world could be other than it is, and more reflective of the reign of God in the world. Dreaming includes bringing into view the historical expressions of the Christian community, particularly those that are moving for you and your community—as expressed in Scriptures, traditions, writings, practices, liturgies, and so on. The resources of the Christian tradition offer numerous opportunities for youth and adults to remember and nurture their passion for God—through remembering the historical people of Israel and their understandings of God’s work in the world, the winsome stories of Jesus Christ, the ecclesial practices of Eucharist, baptism, and confirmation, through the fellowship of the faith community, through prayer and meditation, and acts of solidarity and service with the poor and suffering of the world.
These resources of the Christian tradition should not be engaged only as an imposed framework of meaning—as rational understandings and doctrines—but as opportunities for and places where youth encounter God in fullness, glory, love, and compassion. Dreaming includes reflecting upon the promises and demands that arise from the Christian stories, relevant for conceptualizing new and more faithful ways of shaping and participating in the world. Authentic discipleship calls us beyond our present ways of acting and thinking into ways that are appropriate in light of our own lives and understandings of the Christian tradition—i.e., imagining more just ways of living that attend to the cultural and personal forces and impulses.
One practical approach for engaging youth in this stage of dreaming includes the following exercise:
Acting: loving God with our strength
The guiding questions for this movement include—
Reflection cannot neglect action, and neither can action neglect reflection. Discernment is an ongoing process in which actions are highlighted for reflection, and constantly refined in deliberate fashion. Human practices and processes must speak back to dreams and reflections, driving us to consider new and more adequate understandings and ways of ministry and life.
One persistent theme among youth is their yearning to do something. By this they are expressing a desire to engage beyond superficial social and recreational activities in order to participate in God’s redemptive kingdom work in the world. They sense the need to be actors in history and to not simply be acted upon. Indeed, their desire is consistent with the God of Jesus Christ who wrought redemption not simply in an eternal sphere but within the bounds of history, space, and time. As adolescents grow, they yearn to break free from the artificial protective institutions of adolescence to engage the world as agents of faith—not simply as passive consumers. In a day when youth workers languish in often tired rituals of youth group games and pizza parties, youth themselves relish significant roles in partnership with God’s Spirit in the redemption and healing of the world.
Conclusion
The church in general and youth ministry in particular has participated in the domestication of adolescents—bringing them into our institutions for our purposes. As a result, we have not only stifled them as gifted and creative children of God, but we have denied our own churches the energy, beauty, questioning, and the courageous challenge of youth—and thus a force for our own transformation. The shadow side of our cultural repression of youth has been that much of their creative energy has been channeled into exploitative, oppressive, dangerous, and unhealthy directions.
The practice of discernment engages youth and their churches in seeing the ways their understandings and behaviors need to be exposed to the light of Christ come into the world. Practices of discernment engage youth and their churches in staying attuned to God’s ever-present work in the world and discovering ways they can participate in it. Those of us who have risked ourselves in work with youth have found their gifts considerable and invaluable for the church and the world. Youth have vital gifts for the adult world, drained by alienating work of much of its life. Youth have gifts of questioning for adults who have been so enculturated by social and cultural forces and have forgotten their own questions. Youth have gifts of play for adults and congregations who have forgotten that God’s foundational work of creation was an act of play, and that Christ’s work in the world is a playful redemption of too-serious forces. Youth have gifts for courageous historic action and can once again, as in Civil Rights movements, labor movements, peace movements, and modern movements of diversity, be at the forefront of movements of justice and peace, in the name of God. The church can risk empowering youth through engaging them in rhythms of critical discernment of the powers, or it can relegate them to volleyball games and marginal spaces in the church attic or basement.
